Assets of community value panel
Councillor Acton felt the decision to not allow ward Members to sit on the ACV panel for an application within their ward should remain.
Every time Trafford's minutes name Councillor Acton, as the council published it.
Councillor Acton felt the decision to not allow ward Members to sit on the ACV panel for an application within their ward should remain.
Councillor Acton asked why there were no Members on the Board. The Director of Legal and Governance responded that it was due to it being a technical board, which would feedback to the Executive and Members.
Councillor Acton criticised the current process in the Council Chamber and applauded the work done by the CWG to produce the report.
Councillor Acton, Chair of Scrutiny, informed Members that Scrutiny held its last meeting of the Municipal Year recently. An update of the new Corporate Plan was presented and was well received. The progress report on the Carrington Relief Road was also presented and discussed.
Councillor Acton provided an overview of what work had been completed across the year, and referenced the Reducing Car Dependency task and finish group report which would come in the next Municipal Year.
Councillor Acton also informed Members of the Committee that responses to the Scrutiny reports looking at Access to Council Services and Events and Old Trafford would come to the Committee in 2024/25.
Councillor Acton also reminded Members of the Budget reports which come every year, firstly in November, outlining the draft proposals, and the Scrutiny response that goes to the meeting in January, with Budget Scrutiny set to take place in late November again.
Councillor Acton informed the Committee that the budget Scrutiny Committee had agreed two dates of the 28 th and 30 th November 2023 to look at the budget proposals as part of the budget scrutiny process and welcomed all Councillors to attend the meetings and feed into the process.
Councillor Acton informed the Committee that the Scrutiny Committee had recently had a briefing on Access to Council Services which had raised some concerns with Members and he informed the Committee that an short interim report with recommendations would be submitted to the Executive in December.
Councillor Acton informed the Committee that the Scrutiny Committee had held a meeting with five of the largest housing associations in Trafford on how they were dealing with damp and mould following the coroner’s report from the previous year.
Councillor Acton felt that the providers had been open in their responses and in their commitment to tackling damp and mould within the housing stock in Trafford.
Councillor Acton thanked the Executive Member for Housing and Advice and Adrian Fisher for attending the meeting and providing information with regards to the Councils approach.
Councillor Acton felt that the Council needed to look at increasing the capacity of Council Officers in order to hold housing providers to account.
Following the introduction, The Chair and Councillor Acton both welcomed the report and voiced their support of the continuation of the market supplement.
Councillor Acton informed the Committee that the Scrutiny Committee had met for the first time and had agreed a work programme for the year.
Councillor Acton highlighted a number of key items the Committee were going to look at including Access to Council Services and Damp and Mould within social Housing.
Councillor Acton concluded his update by stating that the task and finish group on Events at Old Trafford and Reducing Car Dependency would be continuing within the new municipal year.
The Leader thanked Councillor Acton for his update and welcomed the Committee’s input on access to Council services and Damp and Mould in Social Housing. The Leader stated that he and the rest of the Executive looked forward to working closely with the Committee over the Course of the year.
(a) Scrutiny Committee Councillor Acton, Chair of the Committee reported that an Extraordinary Meeting of Scrutiny Committee was held on 10 July 2023 to discuss the Greater Manchester Fire Service’s plans regarding cover at Sale Fire Station with the Greater Manchester Fire Chief and Fire Union representatives. Members then met to formulate their views and decided as a Committee, unanimously across party lines, to reject the proposals as it was strongly felt that the plans presented to them would increase the risk to the people of Sale and the surrounding area.
Councillor Acton informed the Committee that the Scrutiny Committee were holding an extraordinary meeting on the 10 th of July 2023 to discuss the Fire Cover Review which proposed the replacement of night shift full-time firefighters with on-call firefighters at the Sale fire station. The GM Fire Chief and trade unions had been invited to discuss the proposals and all Councillors were invited to attend.
Councillor Acton added that the first ordinary scrutiny meeting of the Municipal year was to be held on the 12 th of July where the Committee would discuss and agree their work programme for the municipal. The Leader had confirmed that he would attend to inform the Committee of the executive’s priorities for the municipal year.
The Leader thanked Councillor Acton and noted the importance of the Fire Cover Review and stated that he looked forward to working with Scrutiny.
(a) Scrutiny Committee Councillor Acton, Chair of Scrutiny Committee announced that the Committee had established Task and Finish Group for the reduction of car dependency in the Trafford area with Councillor Axford as its Chair.
Councillor Acton acknowledged that it would be a difficult task to convince people to use alternative means and looked forward to the Group reporting back and its submission to Council in due course.
Following the overview Councillor Acton asked whether the Council was falling foul of the legislation due to the level of the gender pay gap. The Director of Human Resources informed the Committee that the Council was not in breach of any legislation.
Councillor Acton asked about the work of the agency staff focus groups and the make-up of those groups. The Resourcing Consultant responded that any agency staff employed for over 13 weeks could come across to work for the Council without penalty. The groups were made up of agency staff who had worked with the Council for a prolonged period but had not decided to switch to work for the Council.
Councillor Acton asked that the information from those groups on why they did not want to switch to work for the Council be shared with the Committee.
Councillor Acton asked whether Members would be engaged with.
Councillor Acton asked about the improved visitor arrangements at Council buildings and whether those arrangements could be shared. The Director of HR responded that the Health and Safety Lead would provide the information in the next Health and Safety report. The Committee were informed that the review of the safety arrangements had identified the need for investment to deliver some enhancements within the Council buildings.
Councillor Acton welcomed the response from the Executive and noted the amount of monitoring required by all three Scrutiny Committee’s to ensure the budget was delivered as agreed.
(b) Manchester United Stadium Scrutiny Task and Finish Group Councillor Acton, Chair of Scrutiny Committee was pleased to inform Members that a task and finish group had been established specifically to consider the experiences of residents living in the shadow of Manchester United’s Stadium which was being chaired by local Councillor Walsh. It was the first exercise of this type and an initial survey was to date approaching 500 responses, the highest return since the Council had started to use Citizens Space surveys. The task and finish group would be considering the responses at its next meeting.
Following the introduction questions were raised by Councillor Ennis and Councillor Acton. Detailed responses were provided and the Councillors were satisfied with the answers received.
(a) Scrutiny Committee Councillor Acton, Chair of Scrutiny Committee reported that further to the Council Motion regarding Fields in Trust protection for all of Trafford’s parks and open spaces (Minute No. 64 of the Council meeting held on 26 January 2022 refers), Scrutiny had received a report and having discussed the issues concluded that it would be an expense for the Council as it would need to employ more staff in the existing team to implement all the 156 sites in the Borough. There were already various protections across the Borough with sites already having Fields in Trust protection or were due to gain the protection.
Following the presentation Councillor Acton asked how the family hubs would develop going forward. The Director Education Standards, Quality and Performance responded that Trafford had two family hubs so far and that an appointment would be made for an officer to drive the work forward, especially with regards to the digital offer.
Councillor Acton noted that family hubs were similar to children’s centres but with a greater amount of collaboration and expressed his interest in seeing how the hubs developed.
In response to Councillor Acton the Corporate Director of Children’s Services spoke of the unique approach Trafford was taking to delivering the work. The support received from schools and third sector providers had helped the service to move forward with family hubs in the area, but the complexity of delivering the work collaboratively presented a large challenge.
Councillor Acton introduced the Budget Scrutiny report.
As part of his introduction Councillor Acton recognised the difficult situation the Council was working in with the post pandemic recovery and the cost-of-living crisis being particularly challenging.
Councillor Acton drew the Committee’s attention to recommendation 2 of the report which asked that a report detailing the impact of the cost-of-living crisis upon residents and the actions the Council were taking to mitigate that impact be submitted to the Scrutiny Committee at their first meeting of the 2023/24 municipal year.
Councillor Acton informed the Executive of the outcome of the Scrutiny review of the feasibility of putting all the Council’s Green Spaces and parks into Fields in Trust.
Councillor Acton informed the Committee that due to the costs associated it was the Scrutiny Committee’s Recommendation that the Council continued to utilise a range of approaches to protect the areas green spaces and parks including Fields in Trust.
The Executive Member for Climate Change and Transport Strategy stated that it was some of the best work he had seen Scrutiny do during his time as a Councillor and asked Councillor Acton to pass hid feedback onto the Committee at their next meeting.
Councillor Acton welcomed the feedback from the Executive Member for Climate Change and Transport Strategy, the Executive’s response to the work of scrutiny, and the recommendations within the report to establish a temporary stopping site within the borough.
(b) Scrutiny Committees Councillor Acton, Chair of Scrutiny advised that Budget Scrutiny Sessions were to be held on 29 November and 1 December 2023 and that all non-Executive Members were welcome to attend.
Councillor Acton as Chair of the Scrutiny Committee informed the Committee that the Budget Scrutiny sessions would be held on Tuesday the 29 th of November and Thursday the 1 st December and invited all none executive members to attend the sessions.
Councillor Acton agreed with Councillor Freeman about the importance of building control, especially following on from the Grenfell tower tragedy and asked whether the funding the Director of Growth and Regulatory Services spoke of was likely to come through. The Director of Growth and Regulatory Services responded that it would be a reliable stream of income for the Council.
Councillor Acton, as Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, advised the Executive that the substantive item for consideration was the Executive’s response on the Review of Disability Access. (The following Minute refers.)
As Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, Councillor Acton made some preliminary remarks in connection with the report of the Executive Member for Economy and Regeneration which set out the Executive’s response to the Scrutiny Task and Finish Group’s interim review report on Disability Access within Trafford . He noted that, whilst the progress of the review had been slower than envisaged, he welcomed the Executive‘s response, agreeing that implementation of the recommendations would constitute a significant step forwards. He expressed his thanks to the review group, and in particular to its Chair.
Councillor Acton welcomed the improvements recognised in the Ofsted report. He then noted that children in care were not always able to attend review meetings so not always able to contribute.
Councillor Acton then asked whether this was an area for development and, if so, what the development process would be. The Corporate Director of Children’s Services replied that there had been a review of review meetings and they were ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Councillor Acton noted it was very difficult to deal with address recruitment issues when the wages and responsibility for agency workers were much better than an authority was able to offer.
Councillor Acton recognised that the Council were looking to do as much as they could, but the picture did not look good.
The Chair Agreed that the outlook did not look good for all the reasons highlighted by Councillor Acton.
Councillor Acton welcomed the report and especially the training available to help people identify the signs.
Councillor Acton asked whether the Council would signpost people to safe havens or providers. In response the Strategic HR Lead Policy for Reward and Intelligence informed the Panel of the support services available for staff.
Councillor Acton, as Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, advised that the principal item for consideration related to the executive’s response to the task and Finish Group’s report on Gypsy, Roma and Traveller visits. (The following Minute refers.)
Councillor Acton welcomed the response of the Executive, acknowledging, as emphasised by the Leader of the Council, that the issues were complex and that further work would be required to explore the recommendations of the Task and Finish group. He hoped that a further update would be made to the Scrutiny Committee once this work had been progressed.
Councillor Acton welcome the change in reasons for leaving and what the service had done to bring about the change. The Strategic Lead Practice Improvement and Learning detailed the changes in approach around supervision and support provided by managers, which included the introduction of the supervision framework. The Corporate Director for Children’s services added that Ofsted had noted the improvements in supervision and support for staff during their recent visit.
Councillor Acton noted foster caring represented a reduced cost compared to other forms of provision.
Councillor Acton expressed his disappointment that Trafford was one of the lowest performing authorities when it came to recruitment and urged the need to find out why. The Corporate Director for Children’s Services responded that the recruitment rate was below where they wanted to be. Trafford had aimed to recruit 15 during the year but had only recruited 4 so far with 4 more being trained.
Councillor Acton asked whether putting additional resources into the foster carer service to provide the support they needed would lead to overall savings. The Corporate Director of Children’s Services agreed that it was an area where the Council could invest to save. The Corporate Director then informed the Committee of the support offered to foster carers and the plans to enhance the offer.
Councillor Acton, as Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, advised Members that in consequence of issues arising from the movement of members of the Traveller community into the borough in the summer of 2021, the Scrutiny Committee had established a Task and Finish group to review the Council’s approach and seek to identify steps to improve relationships. In his context an awareness training session had been held for Members, involving members of the Traveller community; this had been well attended by Members, and would inform the ongoing project.
Councillor Acton, as Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, welcomed the response, noting that Scrutiny would continue monitor key issues throughout the forthcoming year, and to work with the Executive on issues of shared concern in relation to budgetary matters.
Councillor Acton emphasised that, in considering the proposals, Scrutiny Members had been mindful of the particular and significant challenges to budget setting, arising notably from a lengthy period of financial constraints and the COVID-19 pandemic. Members had highlighted a number of ongoing risks, which Scrutiny would continue to monitor. In concluding, he wished to record his thanks to all who had been involved in supporting Trafford’s communities in the face of the recent challenges; and to all officers and Members for their support and co-operation in producing the current report.
(b) Scrutiny Committee Councillor Acton, the Chair of Scrutiny Committee reminded the Council that the Budget Scrutiny Sessions would be held on 30 November and 2 December 2021.All Scrutiny Members had been invited and all non-Executive Members would also be welcome to attend the sessions which were being held online.
As Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, Councillor Acton provided an update on the ongoing review of the Scrutiny function, expressing his thanks to all who had responded to the associated survey. The Executive would be advised of the outcome in due course. The Leader added his thanks, acknowledging the significance of the review for an important aspect of the Council’s work.
Councillor Acton, as Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, advised Members that a Panel overseeing a review of the Council’s Scrutiny function had met and agreed terms of reference.
A survey had been issued to Members and to senior officers, seeking to identify where arrangements currently worked well and where there might be room for improvement; and both Councillor Acton and the Deputy Leader encouraged the completion of this survey.
Councillor Acton asked whether the Council had signed up to the domestic abuse charter or whether they were in the process of doing it. The Strategic HR Lead Policy, Reward and Intelligence responded that the Council had liaised with GMB, had identified the strands required to sign up to the charter, and were working to complete them. The Council had approached a training provider to deliver domestic abuse training for mental health first aiders, managers, and staff.
Councillor Acton asked how the birthday Leave scheme and two additional flexi days would be managed. The Interim Director of HR responded that the Council had taken this decision considering the high number of hours that staff had worked over the past year and the additional days leave was a reward for staff in recognition of their efforts. The Committee were informed that the Council were using a flexi recording system which allowed staff to carry forward more than the 16-hour limit between flexi periods.
As Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, Councillor Acton reported that Members of the three Scrutiny Committees had met over the course of the past month in order to develop those committees’ work programmes for the forthcoming year.
Following the overview Councillor Acton asked how many staff were in the town hall and whether the levels varied. The Interim Director of Human Resources responded that Council buildings were operating at 20% occupancy with a view of increasing to 40% as restrictions lifted. The Council were looking to change the way employees worked with a programme called Trafford Smart Working.
Councillor Acton asked how the re-opening of Council buildings was progressing and the Interim Director of Human Resources responded that each department was managing their own occupancy levels. While this had led to occasional fluctuations in occupancy it was always within safe manageable levels.
Councillor Acton asked whether HR were confident that the Council would meet their target of having 104 apprenticeships. The Interim Director of Human Resources responded that the Council was doing what they could to meet the target but it had been impacted by the pandemic. The target was on the priority list and the Council were confident it would be met.
Councillor Acton asked whether the work to support managers with supporting staff impacted by domestic abuse was having the desired impact. The Interim Director of Human Resources responded that a lot of work had been going on around the check in sessions and to encourage managers to have wellbeing discussions with staff ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Following the overview Councillor Acton asked about recruiting Social workers and whether the recruitment campaign was underway.
Councillor Acton asked whether workforce plans had been developed for when the lockdown came to an end. The Corporate Director of Strategy and Resources responded that the Council had been working on the workforce integration plans throughout the pandemic. The Council were taking a cautious approach in allowing people to move back into office working.
(d) Scrutiny Update Councillor Acton, Chair of Scrutiny Committee informed the Council that following the two budget scrutiny meetings held in December 2020, a report had now been submitted to the Executive and it was hoped that it would assist finalisation of the Council’s budget proposals.
Councillor Acton, as Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, introduced the key features and recommendations arising from the Scrutiny review of the Executive’s draft budget proposals for 2021/2; and thanked Members of the Executive and Corporate Leadership Team for their engagement with the process.
The challenges arising from the pandemic were acknowledged, and Councillor Acton advised that Scrutiny would welcome any opportunity to assist with the development of the Council’s recovery plan. In response, the Leader of the Council thanked the Committee for its input, noting that the Executive would in the normal way make a formal response to the recommendations set out in the report.
Councillor Acton, as chair of the Pandemic Scrutiny Committee, advised that the Committee had recently held its Budget Scrutiny sessions, and that the resulting report would be referred to the Executive in January 2021. In discussion it was noted that, as agreed by Council at its recent meeting, Scrutiny would revert to its standard structure and pattern of meetings in the New Year.
Councillor Acton, as Chair of the Pandemic Scrutiny Committee, introduced the report, noting that it represented a summary of the work undertaken during the Committee, following its establishment in response to the Covid-19 pandemic. In response, the Leader of the Council thanked the Committee’s Chair and Members for all the work they had undertaken, and advised that the Executive would consider the report and its recommendations and respond formally to Scrutiny in due course.
(c) Pandemic Scrutiny Committee Councillor Acton, the Chair of the Pandemic Scrutiny Committee wished to place on record his thanks to all the members and officers of the Committee for their commitment and work over the past eight months during a particular difficult period and believed it was appropriate to recommence with the traditional Scrutiny Committees in the New Year.
Councillor Acton also thanked Members of the Executive, officers and other organisations that had contributed, provided information and researched the issues raised. He reflected on a very meaningful period for scrutiny, one where it was necessary to hold Members and officers to account and whilst there was still a way to go with the pandemic, the Chair was optimistic that there were signs of an improvement.
Following the update Councillor Acton asked whether there had been a target number of severances and whether that level had been met. The Corporate Director of Strategy and Resources responded that there was a forecasted figure of around 100 employees so the 43 that were currently going through the approvals process was below the figure expected. However, following the announcement of the new regulations the Council would create a new offer in line with the changes and reopen the scheme to employees along with the other schemes.
Following the overview Councillor Acton asked how the Council were going to manage staff taking built up leave to ensure the smooth running of the organisation. The Strategic HR Lead Policy, Reward and Intelligence responded that staff were encouraged to discuss plans for taking large amounts of leave with their manager as far in advance as possible to ensure it was taken at a time when the service would be able to cope.
Councillor Acton responded that there needed to be central control of the taking of how managers were administering the scheme. The Strategic HR Lead Policy, Reward and Intelligence responded that the Council had been looking to empower managers in order to run their respective teams and make those decisions but HR could pull data from the system to evaluate the taking of leave across the organisation, identify any patterns, and provide an overview to Corporate Directors. The Corporate Director of Strategy and Resources agreed that this was something that the service would look into.
Councillor Acton, as Chair of the Pandemic Scrutiny Committee, reported that the Committee had received a number of updates on the Council’s financial position, and reminded Members of the two Budget Scrutiny sessions to be held on 1 st and 3 rd December 2020. It was further noted that an interim report on the subject of Homelessness was being referred to the Executive (as discussed in the following Minute).
Councillor Acton, as Chair of the Pandemic Scrutiny Committee, introduced a report which, further to the Committee’s meeting on 19 th August 2020, laid out a number of recommendations to the Executive relating to the issue of homelessness.
As Chair of the Pandemic Scrutiny Committee, Councillor Acton reported that, with a single Scrutiny committee currently operating, it had been a busy period for its Members. The Committee had been receiving updates on current health and social care issues, and continuing its work on homelessness, active travel and the Council’s response to the OFSTEd inspection of Children’s Services, on which reports would be prepared in due course. Members were reminded that the two Budget Scrutiny sessions were scheduled for 1 st and 3rd December respectively.
Councillor Acton expressed his thanks to the Committee’s members for their work during the period, and these were endorsed by the Deputy Leader of the Council.
(c) Budget Scrutiny Councillor Acton, the Chair of the Pandemic Scrutiny Committee informed the Council that two budget scrutiny meetings were to be held to consider the Executive’s budget proposals and that all Members were welcome to participate in due course.
Councillor Acton asked many staff had been affected by the guidance on traveling abroad. The Corporate Director of People responded that there had been a number of staff affected by the guidance, in particular when the restrictions on travel from Spain were introduced as some ... view the full minutes text for item 11.
Councillor Acton asked whether the new policy would be cost neutral. The Strategic HR Lead Policy, Reward and Intelligence confirmed that the policy would be cost neutral as the staff members were receiving an annual payment which had been calculated using a similar level of compensation as the new policy.
As the Committee’s Chair, Councillor Acton provided a brief update on the work undertaken by the Pandemic Scrutiny Committee in relation to the Covid-19 health emergency, and expressed his thanks to those who had contributed to the Committee’s work.
Councillor Acton thanked the Corporate Director of People for the comprehensive report and stated that he felt that the Council was taking every precaution and voiced his support for the recommendations within the report. The Chair asked the Committee if they supported the approach within the report and the Committee unanimously agreed.
Councillor Acton welcomed the work and the lessons that had been learnt from going through this crisis around working patterns. When looking at remote working and remote meetings there had been some excellent work within the Council and the Councillor stated that they would like to see Member involvement in this work. The Councillor asked that Members be considered in terms of how the Council’s business would continue and that they could be involved in talking to the community.
Councillor Acton asked if there was anything that the Council could do to get rid of the gender pay gap. The Corporate Director of People responded that the councils traded services were mainly female and those staff have lower wages due to the Council needing to stay competitive within the market.
Councillor Acton noted the continued shortage of qualified social workers and how a national solution to the problem was needed.
On behalf of the Scrutiny Committee, its Chair, Councillor Acton, introduced the key features of the report and action plan arising from the Committee’s review of the Executive’s draft Budget Proposals for 2020/21, thanking Members and officers for their participation in the process. The Deputy Leader thanked the Committee for its input, noting that a formal response would be made to the Action Plan in due course. In response to a question, it was agreed that clarification would be sought outside the meeting of the proposed timing for the Scrutiny Committee’s review of the capital Budget.
As Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, Councillor Acton advised of the holding of two forthcoming Budget Scrutiny sessions, one on Tuesday 3 rd December, dealing with resources, investments and the Place directorate; and the second on Thursday 5 th December, dealing with Children’s Services and social care.
(a) Scrutiny Committee Councillor Acton, the Chair of Scrutiny Committee reported that the Climate Emergency Task and Finish Group had concluded its work and submitted recommendations to the Executive which, as could be expected, were challenging.
With climate change being the most important issue the world faced in the coming years, Councillor Acton hoped Trafford would play a full part, meaning a commitment from every Member, if the Council was to deliver zero carbon by its target and that of Greater Manchester, of 2038.
Councillor Acton wished to place on record his thanks to the members of the task and finish group for embarking on this vital work.
Councillor Acton was in attendance to present to the Executive the key recommendations of the Scrutiny Committee’s Task & Finish Group report on the Climate Emergency.
Councillor Acton expressed his thanks to the Members of the Group who had worked on the report, noting that it was intended to be referred both to the Executive and Council. On behalf of the Executive, the Executive Member for Environment, Air Quality and Climate Change welcomed the report, and undertook that, following further consideration, a formal response would be made to Council.
In addition, Councillor Acton, as Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, noted that the Committee’s working group on Climate Change had already held one meeting; and that a further meeting was to be held on 11 th April, 2019.
Councillor Acton, as Chair of Scrutiny Committee, introduced the report of the Task and Finish Group’s review of the One Trafford Partnership, drawing the Executive’s attentions to the recommendations set out in the report. On behalf of the Executive, the Executive Member for Environment, Air Quality and Climate Change advised that the report would be considered and a formal response made to the Scrutiny Committee in due course.
Councillor Acton, as Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, reported that the Committee had met on 12 th February, and agreed a report and recommendations, developed under the auspices of the One Trafford Partnership review group, which would now be formally referred to the Executive. Members were also advised that a working group had been established, further to the Council resolution in relation to climate change; and that the first meeting of the group would be held on 11 th March.
Councillor Acton, as Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, advised that a draft had been finalised of the Scrutiny report into the One Trafford Partnership; and that the Committee would meet on 12 th February formally to agree the report and refer it to the Executive. It was noted that a Task and Finish Group was being established in respect of carbon reduction; and in response to a question the Chair of Scrutiny and Leader of the Council confirmed their intention to undertake and respond to this exercise as expeditiously as possible.
Councillor Acton, as Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, formally presented to the Executive the Budget Scrutiny report and associated recommendations which had been developed following two budget scrutiny sessions held in December 2018. The Leader of the Council expressed his thanks to all Scrutiny Members involved for their efforts in producing the report, and undertook to respond formally in due course.
Councillor Acton, as Chairman of the Scrutiny Committee, reported briefly on the two recent Budget Scrutiny sessions which had been held under the Committee’s auspices, thanking Executive Members for their contributions to the process. The Committee’s report was in preparation, and would be formally referred to the Executive in due course.
(c) Scrutiny Committee Councillor Acton, the Chair of Scrutiny Committee reminded the Council that the Budget Scrutiny Sessions would be held on 4 and 6 December 2018 and that all Scrutiny Members were welcome to attend.
Councillor Acton, as Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, reminded Members that the two forthcoming Budget Scrutiny sessions were scheduled for 4 th December (Health and Social Care issues) and 6 th December (all other issues).
In discussion, Councillor Acton, as Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, advised that the committee had recently established a task and finish group to look into issues of housing availability, and that it would incorporate allocations within the scope of its review. The Executive Member noted and welcomed this information.
(c) Scrutiny Committee Update Councillor Acton reported that, in response to residents’ overwhelming concerns, one of his first acts in his new role as Chair of Scrutiny Committee was to set up a task and finish group to scrutinise the Council’s contract with Amey. He wished to make it clear that he attached no blame to the frontline workforce and that it was clear the contract needed an in depth review to determine what improvements could be made, in order to deliver services in a manner that everyone would expect.
Councillor Acton welcomed the new Members of the Committee and in particular, Councillors New and Thomas who had recently been elected on the Council.
Councillor Acton enquired as to where the expertise around online safeguarding was within the structure. The Director of Safeguarding answered that online safeguarding was covered under complex safeguarding. This was because online safeguarding involved complex external factors which used to select and affect individuals.
(Note: As Council representatives on the Greater Manchester Fire and Rescue Service, Councillor Acton who was also its Chair and Councillor Whetton, each declared a personal interest in this item and remained in the meeting during consideration of the matter.) It was moved and seconded that :
(Note: As a Council representative on the Greater Manchester Fire and Rescue Service and its appointed Chair, Councillor Acton, declared a personal interest in this matter insofar as it relates to the Service’s funding settlement and its ability to protect businesses in the Borough.) It was moved and seconded that :
(d) Councillor Acton The Leader of the Council was aware of some news concerning the Leader of the main Opposition and invited Councillor Acton to address the Council, whereby he announced that he was standing down as Leader of the Labour Group.
Councillor Acton indicated that after 17 years as Leader of the Group, including 7 years as Leader of the Council and 5 years as Deputy Group Leader beforehand, it was becoming difficult to manage his other roles as Chair of the Greater Manchester Fire and Rescue Service and most recently the Labour lead ... view the full minutes text for item 47.
The Mayor reported that the Leader of the Council, Councillor Anstee had completed his “Ice Bucket Challenge” the week previously, suitably aided by Councillor Acton who was on hand with the bucket to ensure that he got a soaking. £127 was raised on the day for charity with direct text donations made afterwards still to be calculated.
Evans Councillor Acton
Councillor Acton and Councillor Walsh were also given an opportunity to raise their concerns and ask questions on behalf of the local residents within the Gorse Hill Ward. The Managing Director circulated a number of leaflets including information on crowd management and plans for event safety and offered an invitation to anyone present to come and visit the premises. The Chairman thanked the Managing Director for his worthwhile presentation and everyone at the meeting for their attendance and contribution to the discussions.
(b) Motion submitted by the Labour Group – Fire Service [Note: As Chairman of the Greater Manchester Fire and Rescue Service, Councillor Acton declared a personal interest in this item and remained in the meeting during consideration of the matter.] It was moved and seconded that:
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Acton attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 Mar 2025 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - Violence Against Women and Girls (VAWG) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Nov 2024 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Green Party Group - Greater Manchester Pension Fund and Trafford's involvement: Arms, Human Rights and International Law | Carried | 43 for, 6 against, 6 abstained | |
| 20 Nov 2024 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - Affordable Housing | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Nov 2024 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - Local Nature Recovery Strategy | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Nov 2024 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Conservative Group - Transparency, Accountability, and Community Engagement in Asylum Seeker Housing Decisions | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Nov 2024 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Liberal Democrat Group - Timperley Local Place Plan | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Oct 2024 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Conservative Group - Winter Fuel | Carried | 37 for, 19 against, 0 abstained | |
| 16 Oct 2024 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Conservative Group - Winter Fuel | Lost | 19 for, 37 against, 0 abstained | |
| 16 Oct 2024 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Conservative Group - Winter Fuel | Carried | 43 for, 7 against, 6 abstained | |
| 16 Oct 2024 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - Bike Library | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Oct 2024 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - The Protection and Support of Children by Trafford Council | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Jul 2024 | Council | Conferment of the Title of Honorary Alderman | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Jul 2024 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Liberal Democrats Group - Upgrading Trafford's Belisha Beacons | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Jul 2024 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Green Party Group - Cost of Living: Reduce Bills and Tackle Poverty | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 May 2024 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - Happy 50th Birthday Trafford Council | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Mar 2024 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - My Vote, My Voice Charter | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Mar 2024 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Green Group - Pavement obstruction: towards the Vision Zero target | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Nov 2023 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - Vaping | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Nov 2023 | Council | Cross-Party Motion Submitted by the Liberal Democrats Group and Conservative Group - Support for a Greater Manchester-wide Trial of the Baby-box | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Jul 2023 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - The Problems With Leasehold and Rejuvenating Commonhold | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Mar 2023 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - Trafford Poverty Truth Commission | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Feb 2023 | Council | Budget 2023/24 | Carried | 34 for, 18 against, 0 abstained | |
| 25 Jan 2023 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Liberal Democrats Group - Improving Public Safety with later-running Trams | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Nov 2021 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - Future Trafford Park and Just Transition to a Greener Economy | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Nov 2021 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Green Party Group - Bikeability Training for Children Who Missed Out During the COVID-19 Pandemic | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 28 Jul 2021 | Council | Places for Everyone Plan (2021): Approval of Places for Everyone 2021 for submission to the Secretary of State | Carried | 40 for, 15 against | |
| 28 Jun 2021 | Employment Committee | Interim leadership arrangements | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 30 Sep 2020 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - Financial Impact of Covid on Local Authority Budgets | Carried | 39 for, 15 against | |
| 29 Jun 2020 | Employment Committee | Workforce update covid-19 related absence | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2020 | Council | Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel | Carried | 31 for, 16 against, 2 abstained | |
| 9 Oct 2019 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - Abolition of Section 21 Evictions | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 28 Nov 2018 | Council | Conferment of the Title of Honorary Alderman | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 28 Nov 2018 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Conservative Group - Altrincham Health and Wellbeing Hub | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 28 Nov 2018 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Conservative Group - Car Parking Charges | Carried | 33 for, 26 against, 0 abstained | |
| 26 Sep 2018 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - Education Results | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Sep 2018 | Employment Committee | Recruitment of chief executive officer | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Jul 2018 | Council | Motion Without Notice - Procedure Rule 12 (c) | Lost | 26 for, 31 against, 0 abstained | |
| 25 Jul 2018 | Council | Motion Without Notice - Procedure Rule 12 (d) | Lost | 26 for, 32 against, 0 abstained | |
| 25 Jul 2018 | Council | Appointment of Interim Chief Executive and Appointments to Corporate Leadership Structure | Carried | 32 for, 26 against, 0 abstained | |
| 29 Nov 2017 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Conservative Group - Broadheath Community Hub | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Oct 2017 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - Business Rates Retention | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Oct 2017 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Conservative Group - Free After Three | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Feb 2017 | Council | Budget 2017/18 | Carried | 31 for, 23 against | |
| 17 Feb 2016 | Council | Budget 2016/17 | Carried | 36 for, 21 against, 0 abstained | |
| 20 Jan 2016 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - Political Education in Schools | Lost | 25 for, 32 against, 0 abstained | |
| 16 Sep 2015 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Conservative Group - Fairer Funding for Schools | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Sep 2015 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - Refugee Crisis | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Sep 2015 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - Police Allocation Formula and Impact on Greater Manchester Police | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Jul 2015 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Conservative Group - Children's Services | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Jul 2015 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group - Bus Franchising | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Feb 2015 | Council | Budget 2015/16 | Carried | 33 for, 26 against, 1 abstained | |
| 13 Nov 2013 | Council | Motion submitted by the Labour Group - Legal Aid | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Nov 2013 | Council | Motion submitted by the Conservative Group - Domestic Abuse | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Oct 2013 | Council | Local Government Act 1972 Section 249(5) - Honorary Freedom of the Borough | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Sep 2013 | Council | Motion submitted by the Conservative Group | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Jul 2013 | Council | Motion submitted by the Conservative Group | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Jul 2013 | Council | Motion submitted by the Conservative Group | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Jun 2013 | Council | Motion Submitted by the Labour Group | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Acton was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 17 of 20 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Acton declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 13 Mar 2013 | Council, item 80 | (b) Motion submitted by the Labour Group – Fire Service [Note: As Chairman of the Greater Manchester Fire and Rescue Service, Councillor Acton declared a personal interest in this item and remained in the meeting during consideration of the matter.] It was moved and seconded that: | Stayed and took part |
Where Councillor Acton sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Jan 2013 | 112 | 18 Nov 2026 |
| Planning and Development Management Committee | Reserve | Jan 2021 | 26 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Standards Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2024 | 8 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Accounts and Audit Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2025 | 4 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| Public Protection Sub-Committee | Reserve | Jun 2026 | 2 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Executive | Guest | Mar 2013 | 54 | |
| Employment Committee | Vice-Chair | Jul 2018 | 29 | |
| Scrutiny Committee | Chair | Jul 2018 | 28 | |
| Health Scrutiny Committee | ex-Officio | Jun 2018 | 27 | |
| Children and Young People's Scrutiny Committee | ex-Officio | Jul 2018 | 23 | |
| Trafford Pandemic Scrutiny Committee - work of this committee has concluded | Chair | May 2020 | 9 | |
| Council ( | Committee Member | Jun 2013 | 1 | |
| Public Meeting prior to Council Meeting | Committee Member | Jul 2013 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.