Named14 Jul 2025Scrutiny Committee
Leaders priorities 2025/26
Councillor Coggins touched on the Leader’s desire to improve transport network connectivity across the Borough and suggested this as a possible topic for Scrutiny. The Member also suggested that Local Nature Recovery Strategy as possible.
Named14 Jul 2025Scrutiny Committee
Access to council services - progress update
Councillor Coggins echoed the thoughts of Councillor Hartley, noting that parking permit applications were now all online. As such, the Member asked whether there needed to be a fall-back option, to combat concerns of digital exclusion. The Head of Customer Service, Libraries and Culture noted that the parking services team would first try and help residents apply online but will revert to a paper option if needed.
Named14 Jul 2025Scrutiny Committee
Council budget update
Councillor Coggins observed the concerns around the fair funding review and the numbers in temporary accommodation in the Borough.
Asked14 Jul 2025Scrutiny Committee
Council budget update
Also, Councillor Coggins asked whether the capitalisation direction that the Council aimed to use as little as possible of, could be kept by the Council if it went unused.
Said19 Jun 2025Standards Committee
Member development
Councillor Coggins added that parties selecting Chairs could implement this within their own organisations.
Named19 Jun 2025Standards Committee
Member development
The omission of carbon literacy training was highlighted, with Councillor Coggins suggesting that if tackling the climate crisis was a priority, it should be better implemented. The Manager was to feed this back.
Said12 Mar 2025Scrutiny Committee
Prioritisation of highway work
Councillor Coggins noted that residents’ complaints were not on the matrices, despite having been told that complaints were considered for highways issues. The Member asked what role complaints had. The Principal Engineer (Traffic and Transportation), Amey, noted the pros and cons of considering complaints during the process.
Named12 Mar 2025Scrutiny Committee
Safety of roads and pavements in the borough
Councillor Coggins, referencing page 50 in the document (targeted delivery and programme for safety of roads and footways in the Borough), felt they were aimed at the victims of road violence, such as pedestrians and cyclists. The Member asked whether more could be done to tackle driver behaviour. The Technical Director, Amey, referred to work on the Greater Manchester level to improve driver behaviour called the safer roads partnership.
Named12 Mar 2025Scrutiny Committee
Safety of roads and pavements in the borough
Councillor Coggins was interested in a breakdown of where crashes happened and which type of roads were most common for incidents. The Director of Highways, Transport and Environment responded that this could be provided on a map and would share this with Members. He added that there would be no surprises, with majority of incidents clustered around A and B roads.
Asked12 Mar 2025Scrutiny Committee
Safety of roads and pavements in the borough
Referring to page 44 of the slides, Councillor Coggins asked if there was any analysis done on the statistics of road collisions each year. The Director of Highways, Transport and Environment felt it showed a downward trend since the high in 2017. The Principal Engineer (Traffic and Transportation), Amey, noted that different influences and scenarios were monitored in a general sense by the service.
Asked12 Mar 2025Scrutiny Committee
Safety of roads and pavements in the borough
Councillor Coggins asked if the item could be considered again in the next Municipal Year to look at it in more detail. The Director of Highways, Transport and Environment agreed, and felt the Committee had provided the granular level of detail they would have appreciated.
Named22 Jan 2025Scrutiny Committee
Damp and mould, housing repairs, and maintenance within trafford housing stock
Councillor Coggins referred to the meeting in September 2023, where L&Q had suggested they were taking on new staff, increasing their workforce. The Member asked whether all providers felt sufficiently staffed.
Asked22 Jan 2025Scrutiny Committee
Maximising existing social housing in trafford
Councillor Coggins asked about reducing and increasing stock. The Member enquired as to whether poor quality properties were ever divested, and whether the associations ever bought ran down properties. It was added, whether there was the opportunity to buy and expand stock.
Named22 Jan 2025Scrutiny Committee
Executive response to scrutiny committee task & finish group - reducing car dependency
Councillor Coggins, who had been part of the group, found the report frustrating reading. The Member felt the responses within the report included a mixture of the Council saying: they were either already looking into it without being clear how; saying the Council could not afford to implement it; or were rejecting the suggestions. The Member concluded by suggesting a lack of political leadership and pushed for more work on car clubs.
Asked6 Nov 2024Scrutiny Committee
Draft budget proposals
Councillor Coggins asked about the reserves of the Council. A recent Manchester Evening News article had suggested Trafford had healthy reserves available (£53m), however, the Councillor had previously understood that Trafford had relatively low reserves.
Asked6 Nov 2024Scrutiny Committee
Draft budget proposals
Councillor Coggins asked whether the Director could provide more detail on this. The Director of Finance highlighted the difficulty in comparing different districts positions, as different treasurers announce their accounts differently. Referring to the article, Salford stood out to the Director as when they had considered Salford’s statement of accounts, there equivalent to Trafford’s £53m was around a quarter of a billion.
Asked6 Nov 2024Scrutiny Committee
Culture, sport and heritage strategy
Councillor Coggins asked about a possible Year of Culture bid and asked whether that could support the other aims of the Council, especially in relation to the environmental impacts of any events.
Asked6 Nov 2024Scrutiny Committee
Travellers update
Councillor Coggins asked whether temporary stopping zones would continue, with 2024 being a quieter year for visit. The Member also enquired as to how the Council communicates the use of Boyer Street. The Member raised concern over some of the language used on the report such as gypsy and encampment and asked that this be considered in the future.
Asked16 Oct 2024Council
Questions By Members
(c) Question from Councillor Coggins concerning the Carbon Budget As a supplementary question Councillor Coggins asked what pressure the Council would be putting on the new government to ensure that the inevitable breach of the Council’s carbon budget would be as small as possible.
Named16 Oct 2024Council
Questions By Members
Councillor Williams, Executive Member for Climate Change sympathised with the sentiments expressed and assured Councillor Coggins that he was doing everything in his capacity to challenge Labour colleagues in Westminster and welcomed the support of all groups on the Council in so doing.
Said18 Sep 2024Scrutiny Committee
Electric vehicle charging provision
Councillor Coggins raised observations from the report.
Asked18 Sep 2024Scrutiny Committee
Electric vehicle charging provision
On the Amey proposal, Councillor Coggins asked about the procurement associated with this, raising a company which did this work.
Asked18 Sep 2024Scrutiny Committee
Electric vehicle charging provision
Furthermore, Councillor Coggins asked about the funding of the proposal.
Named18 Sep 2024Scrutiny Committee
Transport for greater manchester bee network - metrolink operation and active travel
Councillor Coggins referred to a study done by the GM Cycle campaign which had looked at the ... view the full minutes text for item 48.
Said10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Constitutional review 2024
Councillor Coggins noted that the report was not circulated to the CWG before it was published.
Said10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Constitutional review 2024
Councillor Coggins also noted that the moving of petitions and limiting of questions was to give more time for speeches.
Said10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Constitutional review 2024
However, Councillor Coggins added that there was discussion that questions were being limited due to the number of questions related to casework and felt this had not come through in the report and asked if it could be added. The Director of Legal and Governance confirmed the report had not gone back to the CWG, however, the final recommendations had been shared. The Director recognised that the issue of casework questions had been acknowledged, with a discussion had about looking at the question and using a criterion to determine whether the question was suitable.
Named20 Mar 2024Council
Adoption of Places for Everyone Plan
Councillor Coggins began by thanking those officers and Councillors in Trafford and across Greater Manchester for the work done over the years.
Named20 Mar 2024Council
Adoption of Places for Everyone Plan
Councillor Coggins also accepted that working together as a group of Councils across Greater Manchester was the best way to preserve and protect green spaces, and mentioned some of the elements of the plan they felt were positive.
Said20 Mar 2024Council
Adoption of Places for Everyone Plan
However, Councillor Coggins emphasised how the Green group could not support a plan which doubled airport use or intended to build a road over Carrington Moss.
Said20 Mar 2024Council
Adoption of Places for Everyone Plan
Furthermore, Councillor Coggins felt the plan prioritised economic growth, coming at the expense of the green belt, biodiversity, and the stability of the climate.
Named20 Mar 2024Council
Adoption of Places for Everyone Plan
Councillor Coggins finished by restating the Green group’s intention to vote against the plan.
Asked20 Sep 2023Scrutiny Committee
Partnership between trafford council and l&q following merger with trafford housing trust
Councillor Coggins asked whether any of the membership of the Board was also a local councillor at another Council, asked if Trafford was one of the largest Council’s that L&Q operate in, and if so, would Trafford have more of a case to be on the Board. The Partnerships Director NW at L&Q responded that as far as she was aware, there was no one on the L&Q Board who was on it due to ... view the full minutes text for item 17.
Named12 Jul 2023Scrutiny Committee
Committee work programme 2023/24
Following the introduction Councillor Coggins put forward the LNQ and THT merger as an area for the Committee consider along with the Damp and Mould and Retrofitting as they all involved the Housing Association.
Said12 Jul 2023Scrutiny Committee
Committee work programme 2023/24
Councillor Coggins also suggested that the Committee look at wildflower expansion, allotments, and food growing.
Said12 Jul 2023Scrutiny Committee
Committee work programme 2023/24
The Chair agreed to take the action to refer the item to the Health Scrutiny Committee Councillor Coggins suggested that The Items suggested by the Executive Member for Finance and Governance and the Director of Finance and System could be taken up by the Accounts and Audit Committee rather than the Scrutiny Committee.
Said12 Jul 2023Scrutiny Committee
Committee work programme 2023/24
Councillor Coggins noted that there appeared to be a number of key themes within the items and suggested that Retrofitting and Damp and Mould could be covered together and the merger of THT and LNQ.
Named12 Jul 2023Scrutiny Committee
Committee work programme 2023/24
The Chair agreed with Councillor Coggins suggestion and stated that those items would form the basis of the next agenda.
Asked23 Jan 2023Executive
Altrincham town centre
After the introduction, Councillor Coggins asked that ward Councillors be kept updated on progress.
Asked23 Jan 2023Executive
Altrincham town centre
Councillor Coggins also asked about the Council’s process and the timelines for completion and the Executive Member for Economy and Regeneration provided a detailed response.
Said11 Jan 2023Scrutiny Committee
Committee work programme
Councillor Coggins expressed her interest in taking part in the group. The Committee agreed that an email be sent to all Councillors to ask if they wish to take part in the Task and Finish group.
Said9 Nov 2022Scrutiny Committee
Placing green spaces into fields in trust
Councillor Coggins noted the resources required and the response provided by the Executive Member for Environmental Services but felt that the sites selected for Fields in Trust were not always the best one. Spoke about the Cow fields that the council were building on as an example of a site that would have been protected.
Asked21 Sep 2022Scrutiny Committee
Carrington relief road
Councillor Coggins asked about the implications section of the report and how it spoke about the benefits of active transport rather than looking at the impact from the increase in traffic that new road would bring to the area. The Executive Member for Climate Change and Transport Strategy took the point on board and sated that it was a new item added to reports and it would take a while to fine tune the reporting.
Said21 Sep 2022Scrutiny Committee
Carrington relief road
Councillor Coggins spoke about how people did not respond to consultations as they were often long, technical, and time consuming to complete and people would not take the time if they felt it would not ... view the full minutes text for item 12.
Said21 Sep 2022Scrutiny Committee
Feasibility and cost of placing all parks into a field of trusts
Councillor Coggins noted that the areas which had been placed into trusts were all areas where a large public outcry had been received and asked whether that was a factor in which sites were chosen rather than the environmental benefit. The Executive Member for Environmental Services responded that many reasons were put forward when considering the applications to place a space into Fields in Trust and that an analysis of the decisions made would need to look at each application rather than identifying patterns retrospectively. The Director of Growth and Regulatory Services stated that he would reply in writhing about the selection of the sites in question.
Said27 Jul 2022Council
Greater Manchester's Clean Air Plan - July 2022 Update
Councillor Coggins spoke about how the government had faced a number of legal cases around the high levels of emissions.
Said27 Jul 2022Council
Greater Manchester's Clean Air Plan - July 2022 Update
Councillor Coggins noted that while the plan made some positive steps it did not go far enough to bring about the change required as it did not go beyond the legal minimum requirements.
Said27 Jul 2022Council
Greater Manchester's Clean Air Plan - July 2022 Update
Councillor Coggins felt that the government suggested that they could either support people through the cost-of-living crisis or have clean air, but the Green party believed that both could be done and asked that the Council looked to strengthen what was proposed within the plan.
Said29 Jun 2022Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny committee work programme 2022/23
Councillor Coggins informed the Committee that a review by the Trafford Climate Commission had shown Trafford was falling far behind the action plan the Council had agreed.
Said29 Jun 2022Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny committee work programme 2022/23
Councillor Coggins suggested that it be an item on the work programme as it aligned with the Council’s priorities and there were several actions the Council could take to improve performance.
Named29 Jun 2022Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny committee work programme 2022/23
The Governance Officer asked Councillor Coggins to share the information from the Trafford Climate with the Committee. The Committee agreed to add the topic to the work programme.
Named13 Oct 2021Council
Green Party Group Leadership and Membership of Committees
Councillor Jerrome placed on record his thanks to Councillor Coggins for leading the Green Party as a new Group on the Council and for her accomplishments in that time, making a positive difference for the residents of the Borough.
Named28 Sep 2021Accounts and Audit Committee
Accounts and audit committee work programme 2021/22
Following up on a previous request by Councillor Coggins the Audit and Assurance Manager informed the Committee that an update on climate change was to be provided to full Council and it would be up to the Committee they wanted a further update after that.
Said25 Mar 2021Standards Committee
Member development
Councillor Coggins noted that Carbon Literacy Training for Members was not listed as part of the training programme and asked when this was to be provided. The Monitoring Officer informed the Committee that the Carbon Literacy Training had been discussed by the Corporate Leadership team for staff and members.
Named25 Mar 2021Standards Committee
Member development
The Monitoring Officer said that an update would be provided to Councillor Coggins.
Named17 Feb 2021Council
Budget 2021/22
Councillor Newgrosh, on behalf of the Liberal Democrats Group and then Councillor Coggins, on behalf of the Green Party Group also responded to the Motion.
Asked30 Sep 2020Council
Questions By Members
(b) Councillor Coggins asked the following question for which she had given notice:
Said22 Sep 2020Trafford Pandemic Scrutiny Committee - work of this committee has concluded
Active transport
Councillor Coggins welcomed the progress that had been made across the borough in the last few months and noted that keeping active and reducing weight were two ways people could combat COVID and active transport was a way that the Council could look to encourage that.
Asked22 Sep 2020Trafford Pandemic Scrutiny Committee - work of this committee has concluded
Active transport
Councillor Coggins asked whether the Communications around active transport could be changed to express what they added to the Community rather than what they took away.
Asked22 Sep 2020Trafford Pandemic Scrutiny Committee - work of this committee has concluded
Active transport
These means of transport had been successful in areas where extensive engagement exercises had been conducted and Councillor Coggins asked if there were any plans to do this in Trafford. The Executive Member responded that the timeline for the work was out of the Council’s control which had reduced the opportunity for consultation with residents and was something that the Council was working on improving.
Asked22 Sep 2020Trafford Pandemic Scrutiny Committee - work of this committee has concluded
Active transport
Councillor Coggins then asked a range of further questions relating to the report.
Said22 Sep 2020Trafford Pandemic Scrutiny Committee - work of this committee has concluded
Active transport
The Chair stated that rather than receiving answers for each of the questions during the meeting the points raised by Councillor Coggins and other Members of the Committee would form a report to go to the Executive to receive a full response. The Vice Chair welcomed the Chairs suggestion and hoped that the Committee would capture the wider picture within the report and that engagement with businesses and residents within the community would play a large part in any recommendations made to the Executive.
Asked19 Aug 2020Trafford Pandemic Scrutiny Committee - work of this committee has concluded
Treasury management annual performance report
Councillor Coggins asked for clarification around a number of points raised within the update including the spreading of the deficit across years, what the £4M reduction in the deficit related to, and whether the worst case scenario regarding Manchester Airport had been updated. The Executive Member for Finance responded that around £2M of the current year’s deficit was being spread to next year and that the main increase in the 2021/22 deficit was due to expected recurring COVID 19 pressures. The £4M was an estimate of the support that Trafford would receive from the Government in relation to the loss of income.
Asked29 Jul 2020Trafford Pandemic Scrutiny Committee - work of this committee has concluded
Health and adult social care
Councillor Coggins asked about the exceedance report being in the red zone and what this meant. The director of Public Health responded that the monitoring was based on models on the number of new cases projected. Trafford had been doing well and had gone into red in the last two weeks as they were exceeding the number of cases projected.
Asked29 Jul 2020Trafford Pandemic Scrutiny Committee - work of this committee has concluded
Health and adult social care
Councillor Coggins asked whether there was a breakdown of tests by age. ER responded that Trafford did not have that data at the moment but they were asking for that information to be provided.
Said29 Jul 2020Trafford Pandemic Scrutiny Committee - work of this committee has concluded
Items for future meetings
Councillor Coggins requested that active transport be considered by the Committee at their meeting in September. The Chair confirmed that the Committee meeting on the 19 th August would be going ahead and that finance would be the main item on the agenda for that meeting.
Said15 Jun 2020Trafford Pandemic Scrutiny Committee - work of this committee has concluded
Items for future meetings
Councillor Coggins noted that there had been a lot of changes to the active transport network and asked that considered as a topic for a future meeting. The Committee agreed to add active transport as a topic for consideration.
Named4 Mar 2020Standards Committee
Civility in public life
Councillor Coggins had attended events at the LGA conference and was amazed at the amount of stress and the issues that Councillors faced across the country.
Named19 Feb 2020Council
Budget 2020/21
Councillor Newgrosh, on behalf of the Liberal Democrats Group and then Councillor Coggins, on behalf of the Green Party Group also responded to the Motion.
Named20 Feb 2019Executive
Executive's response to scrutiny committee's recommendations to the budget proposals for 2019/20
and the Leader indicated that he would liaise with Councillor Coggins in respect of the request for funding to support the Scrutiny task and finish group review of climate change. RESOLVED - That the Executive’s response to Scrutiny be approved.
Named20 Feb 2019Council
Budget 2019/20
Councillor Bowker, on behalf of the Liberal Democrat Group and then Councillor Coggins, on behalf of the Green Party Group also responded to the Motion.
Declared13 Dec 2018Planning and Development Management Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Coggins declared a Personal and Prejudicial Interest in Application 95660/FUL/18 (Former Rileys Snooker Club, 1D Bridgewater Road, Altrincham) due to her involvement.
Declared13 Dec 2018Planning and Development Management Committee
Application for planning permission 95660/ful/18 - former rileys snooker club, 1d bridgewater road, altrincham
[Note: Councillor Coggins declared a Personal and Prejudicial Interest in Application 95660/FUL/18, due to her involvement and removed herself from the Committee. After making representations to the Committee she left the room during consideration of the item.] The Head of Planning and Development submitted a report concerning an application for planning permission for the demolition of the existing snooker hall (Class D2) and erection of a 3 to 6 storey residential development consisting of 38 residential units (Class C3) with ancillary amenity space, car parking, cycle parking, bin store, landscaping, new boundary treatment and alterations to the access fronting Bridgewater Road and other associated works.
Named25 Jul 2018Council
Motion Submitted by the Green Party Group with the support of a Liberal Democrat Member - Reducing Single Use Plastic in Trafford
(Note: With the consent of the meeting, Councillor Coggins altered the Motion of which she had given notice with the deletion of “, in the UK,” from the first sentence. It was moved and seconded that :
Said12 Jul 2018Planning and Development Management Committee
Applications for permission to develop etc
In respect of Application 94320/FUL/18 Councillor Coggins stated that although she had had discussions with residents, she was approaching the application with an open mind and with no preconceptions and that she would listen fully to the debate and carefully weigh up all the relevant planning considerations before making a decision on the matter.]
Declared12 Jul 2018Planning and Development Management Committee
Application for planning permission 93143/ful/17 - former rileys snooker club, 1d bridgewater road, altrincham
[Note: Councillor Coggins declared a Personal and Prejudicial Interest in Application 93143/FUL/17, due to her involvement and removed herself from the Committee. After making representations to the Committee she left the room during consideration of the item.] The Head of Planning and Development submitted a report concerning an application for planning permission for the demolition of the existing snooker hall (Class D2) and erection of a 3 to 7 storey residential development consisting of 42 residential units (Class C3) with ancillary amenity space, car parking, cycle parking, bin store, landscaping, new boundary treatment and alterations to the access fronting Bridgewater Road and other associated works.
Declared12 Jul 2018Planning and Development Management Committee
Application for planning permission 93153/ful/17 - land on wharf road, altrincham
Also, Councillor Coggins declared a Personal and Prejudicial Interest in Application 93153/FUL/17, due to her involvement and removed herself from the Committee. After making representations to the Committee she left the room during consideration of the item.] The Head of Planning and Development submitted a report concerning an application for planning permission for the demolition of all structures on site, followed by the erection of a part 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 storey building to form 99 dwellings, with associated access, car parking and associated works.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.