Said22 Jul 2025Children and Young People's Scrutiny Committee
Food-related ill health and children and young people
Councillor Axford praised the language of the title of the item and asked for more information on the work being done with school meals. The Public Health Programme Manager advised that there was an opportunity to work on school meals due to Trafford’s in-house catering service, which covered 90% of primary schools and five secondary schools within the borough. The challenges for the catering team were assessed, and the standout difficulties were the cost of food labour and energy prices.
Named22 Jul 2025Children and Young People's Scrutiny Committee
Send board update
Councillor Axford was interested in hearing more about the Local Inclusion Support Offer which had been detailed in the report. The Director advised that this was about ensuring there was training, advice, and support for children, as well as early intervention and support which was critical. This offer also aimed to help schools embrace a culture shift of meeting SEND needs within a mainstream school.
Said22 Jan 2025Scrutiny Committee
Maximising existing social housing in trafford
Councillor Axford raised a piece of casework in their ward, where the resident was told to apply through the Council for a chair lift and wet room, however, were told of a significant delay. The residents had then been asked to fund the work themselves if urgent.
Said22 Jan 2025Scrutiny Committee
Executive response to scrutiny committee task & finish group - reducing car dependency
Councillor Axford, Chair of the task and finish group, thanked the Officer for the response. The Member highlighted the ask for an overarching strategy, linking up active travel and public health initiatives, providing a visionary approach for Trafford. The Director of Growth and Regulatory Services responded that in framing the report, the Trafford Local Plan, which was currently being prepared, would be where the overarching approach would come through.
Asked22 Jan 2025Scrutiny Committee
Executive response to scrutiny committee task & finish group - reducing car dependency
Councillor Axford also asked whether the walking, wheeling and cycling strategy could be updated. The Director of Growth and Regulatory Services confirmed that there would be an opportunity for this, however, it would not happen immediately. The Director did speak positively on how the thinking behind active travel had changed in recent years.
Asked6 Nov 2024Scrutiny Committee
Draft budget proposals
Councillor Axford, on National Insurance, asked what the extent of the impact would be on employees. The Member also asked about the savings identified by CIPFA from work done by other authorities, and what this referred to. A further question on a possible Council tax referendum was also asked.
Asked6 Nov 2024Scrutiny Committee
Draft budget proposals
Councillor Axford asked further whether there were any predictions the Council had on the level of Council tax. The Leader of the Council recognised that it could go up or down, but they felt it would stay at 4.99%, with national government being mindful of the cost of living. The Leader asked Members to be mindful of the positive financial impact for the Council, every percentage point Council tax goes up, so if it does stay the same, savings ... view the full minutes text for item 54.
Named6 Nov 2024Scrutiny Committee
Culture, sport and heritage strategy
Councillor Axford referred to the strategic aims included within the report and, noting the work ongoing with mental health in the borough, asked how high-profile health was in the culture strategy, recognising that it had been in discussions. The Director of Cultural Transformation informed Members that the Cultural Transformation Hub in December would be focussing on health and wellbeing, referencing work ongoing with colleagues in Public Health, as well as knowledge sitting within Trafford and at the Combined Authority level more widely.
Asked6 Nov 2024Scrutiny Committee
Travellers update
Councillor Axford asked if the Council understood the reason behind the reduction in numbers, asking whether the Police Crime Act might have had an ... view the full minutes text for item 56.
Asked18 Sep 2024Scrutiny Committee
Electric vehicle charging provision
Councillor Axford asked what the Council’s position was on encouraging employers to offer free chargers at work. The Director responded that all employers were being encouraged but highlighted the Council focus to fill gaps itself.
Said18 Sep 2024Scrutiny Committee
Transport for greater manchester bee network - bus franchising implementation in trafford
Councillor Axford felt a stigma remained regarding travelling on bus compared to Metrolink, asking how this could be changed. The Network Director for Buses agreed that the image needed improving through resetting how the bus system looked and felt, with a need to talk up bus usage and the additional safety measures coming to the network.
Named18 Sep 2024Scrutiny Committee
Transport for greater manchester bee network - metrolink operation and active travel
Councillor Axford echoed Councillor Hartley on walking and crossing, feeling as though pedestrian prioritisation at traffic light could be a straightforward change in the future to increase usage. The Network Director for Active highlighted timings being modified on 160 crossings so far, with further changes ongoing.
Named18 Sep 2024Scrutiny Committee
Committee work programme
Councillor Axford on the permit parking for November currently, asked whether this could look more widely at the parking review. The Member also raised possibility for a Task and Finish group. This was to be discussed after the meeting.
Named22 Jul 2024Executive
Matters from council or overview and scrutiny committees (if any)
Councillor Axford was in attendance to present a task and finish group report on Reducing Car Dependency. The Member outlined the key justifications for reducing car dependency in the Borough, provided data from surveys supporting this, and highlighted the several meetings the group had with other Local Authorities, Transport for Greater Manchester (TfGM), and Dame Sarah Storey (Greater Manchester’s Active Travel Commissioner). These meetings had informed the recommendations made by the group.
Named22 Jul 2024Executive
Matters from council or overview and scrutiny committees (if any)
Councillor Axford concluded that the group felt that Trafford would benefit from a strategic overarching approach to join up ongoing good work, suggested the strategy title, Healthy Living Streets for All, and hoped that this would encourage a modal shift within the population, help the Council play a leading role in tackling climate change, make greater use of public transport, and enable more children to walk and cycle to school.
Named22 Jul 2024Executive
Matters from council or overview and scrutiny committees (if any)
Councillor Williams, Executive Member for Climate Change, thanked Councillor Axford for the report and commended the work undertaken by the group. The Chair echoed this. The Executive Member was to bring a response to the report and its appendices to a future Executive meeting.
Said10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Executive response to access to council services scrutiny report
Councillor Axford raised concern about phone numbers not being available on the website, and felt it was important that as part of this work, phone numbers for different services were made available.
Said10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Leader of the council's priorities and corporate plan 2024/27
Councillor Axford felt the plan was good and very clear.
Named10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Leader of the council's priorities and corporate plan 2024/27
Councillor Axford was unsure how the Council could measure whether residents were happy, and asked how it would be.
Named10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Leader of the council's priorities and corporate plan 2024/27
Councillor Axford was glad to see the culture, sport, and heritage priority.
Said10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Leader of the council's priorities and corporate plan 2024/27
Finally, on climate change, Councillor Axford felt there was too much focus on ‘greening’ Trafford Park, suggesting that housing and transport emissions too, need to be looked at.
Said10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Leader of the council's priorities and corporate plan 2024/27
Councillor Axford also felt there was too much focus on adaptation in the climate crisis priority, and felt the Council needed to be proactive rather than reactive.
Asked10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Constitutional review 2024
Councillor Axford questioned why questions from Councillors even came to Council meeting and was more concerned that the meeting did not included questions from the Public.
Asked10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Constitutional review 2024
Regarding petitions, Councillor Axford asked whether residents could be assured that these would be publicised the same as if they were going to full Council.
Asked10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Constitutional review 2024
Finally, Councillor Axford asked whether it was discussed to limit the number of speeches during Motions.
Asked10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Executive response to the events at old trafford task and finish group
Councillor Axford asked whether use of the metrolink had been looked at and felt the news on trains and greater tram provision was positive.
Said10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Reducing car dependency task and finish group draft report
Councillor Axford presented the report as the Chair and, on behalf of, the Task and Finish group looking at Reducing Car Dependency.
Said10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Reducing car dependency task and finish group draft report
Councillor Axford outlined the key justifications around reducing car dependency, provided data from surveys of Members of the Public, and highlighted the meetings with Local Authorities, Transport for Greater Manchester, and Dame Sarah Storey (Active Travel Commissioner), which had informed the report as set out in the agenda.
Named10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Reducing car dependency task and finish group draft report
Councillor Axford concluded that the group felt Trafford would benefit from a strategic overarching approach to join up the good work already taking place and suggested the strategy, Healthy Living Streets for All, which would encourage a modal shift, play a leading role in tackling the climate crisis, make greater use of public transport, enable more children to walk, wheel or cycle to school, as well as further suggestions made by the group and laid out in the report.
Named10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Reducing car dependency task and finish group draft report
The Chair thanked Councillor Axford and praised the report. The Chair liked the idea of a campaign to raise awareness for drivers who must park on pavements to allow space for pedestrians, as well as the suggestion of planting wildflowers along road verges.
Said10 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee
Reducing car dependency task and finish group draft report
Councillor Axford responded that there was not, but it would need to be part of the next stage with any of the recommendations that the Executive take forward.
Named13 Mar 2024Scrutiny Committee
Carrington relief road
Councillor Axford understood the rationale behind the road, however, remained concerned about the implications of increased car usage on the road.
Asked13 Mar 2024Scrutiny Committee
Carrington relief road
Councillor Axford enquired as to why there was no bus lane on the road.
Asked13 Mar 2024Scrutiny Committee
Carrington relief road
Councillor Axford asked how confident the Director was of receiving the funding from the Greater Manchester Combined Authority (GMCA) which was included in the report.
Asked13 Mar 2024Scrutiny Committee
Carrington relief road
Councillor Axford also asked how the public engagement in January had gone.
Asked13 Mar 2024Scrutiny Committee
Items for consideration for the municipal year 2024/25
Councillor Axford asked whether the topic of Travellers in the Borough be brought back in the new year, with persistent issues remaining.
Said13 Mar 2024Scrutiny Committee
Items for consideration for the municipal year 2024/25
Councillor Axford added further that there would be opportunity later in the year to look at the Bee Network as it comes to Trafford through Tranche three by the end of 2024.
Said13 Mar 2024Scrutiny Committee
Items for consideration for the municipal year 2024/25
Councillor Axford raised the opportunity to get colleagues from the Greater Manchester Combined Authority (GMCA) to attend and discuss.
Said13 Mar 2024Scrutiny Committee
Items for consideration for the municipal year 2024/25
Councillor Axford also raised concerns on affordable housing in the Borough, as well as looking at remaining issues with housing providers such as L&Q.
Said13 Mar 2024Scrutiny Committee
Items for consideration for the municipal year 2024/25
Councillor Axford felt that the financial risk of the project should be considered.
Said13 Mar 2024Scrutiny Committee
Items for consideration for the municipal year 2024/25
Councillor Axford agreed that this would be interesting to look at.
Named16 Jan 2024Scrutiny Committee
Weeding programme, re-wilding and green spaces review
Councillor Axford ... view the full minutes text for item 21.
Asked16 Jan 2024Scrutiny Committee
Work programme
Councillor Axford asked whether the outcomes of the trial and consultation of temporary stopping areas for Travellers could come to a future meeting.
Asked16 Jan 2024Scrutiny Committee
Work programme
Councillor Axford asked further about reported mould in L&Q properties and whether there had been any feedback to an email sent in December.
Said20 Sep 2023Scrutiny Committee
Damp and mould within the trafford housing stock
Councillor Axford noted that the issue with damp and mould was linked to the cost-of-living crisis and the cost of energy and asked if the number of complaints of damp and mould has increased over the past year. The Team Leader for Housing Standards responded that only since last year was there ... view the full minutes text for item 15.
Named15 Mar 2023Council
Announcements
(a) Scrutiny Committee Councillor Acton, Chair of Scrutiny Committee announced that the Committee had established Task and Finish Group for the reduction of car dependency in the Trafford area with Councillor Axford as its Chair.
Said8 Mar 2023Scrutiny Committee
Corporate plan delivery
Following the introduction Councillor Axford noted that the level of depression which had increased which was a worrying trend.
Said8 Mar 2023Scrutiny Committee
Corporate plan delivery
Councillor Axford commented that when looking at smoking cessation cannabis use needed to be included as she was aware of many instances of it being smoked in public spaces. The Leader agreed that cannabis should be included and he had also noticed a number of instances of cannabis smoking across the borough.
Asked8 Mar 2023Scrutiny Committee
Corporate plan delivery
Councillor Axford asked for information about uptake of the Your Home Better programme. The Leader responded that he would have to take that away and provide the figures outside of the meeting.
Asked8 Mar 2023Scrutiny Committee
Corporate plan delivery
Councillor Axford asked a final question of what was being done to support people in libraries.
Named8 Mar 2023Scrutiny Committee
Corporate plan delivery
The Head of Customer Service, Libraries and Culture responded to Councillor Axford that the library support was around the digital offer and helping people to access digital services safely.
Said8 Mar 2023Scrutiny Committee
Gypsy, roma, and traveller visits
Councillor Axford noted that Gypsy, Roma, and Travellers usually went to rural areas and asked how they would be informed of the site.
Named8 Mar 2023Scrutiny Committee
Gypsy, roma, and traveller visits
The Director of Growth and Regulatory Services responded to Councillor Axford that if the site was deemed to be acceptable then the Council would look at how to approach informing Gypsy, Roma, and Traveller groups of the site. Part of that would be when Gypsy, Roma, and Traveller visitors would be directed to the site when moved on from other areas of the borough.
Asked8 Mar 2023Scrutiny Committee
Gypsy, roma, and traveller visits
Councillor Axford asked about suitability of the site around safety and access to water. The Director of Growth and Regulatory Services answered that the Council was aware of the issues with the site and were considering possible solutions.
Asked8 Mar 2023Scrutiny Committee
Gypsy, roma, and traveller visits
Councillor Axford asked what the maximum level of stay would be and whether it was 28 days. The Director of Growth and Regulatory Services responded that the maximum length of stay was 28 days and that the council would look at what would happen after that following feedback from the consultation.
Asked8 Mar 2023Scrutiny Committee
Gypsy, roma, and traveller visits
Councillor Axford asked whether the charity Friends, Families, and Travellers were being consulted with and the Director of Growth and Regulatory Services confirmed that they were.
Asked8 Mar 2023Scrutiny Committee
Items for consideration 2023/24
Councillor Axford asked about what housing providers including THT were doing around retrofitting.
Said11 Jan 2023Scrutiny Committee
MINUTES
Councillor Axford noted that the Climate Change action plan had not been circulated to the Committee. The Governance Officer confirmed that he would chase the action after the meeting.
Asked11 Jan 2023Scrutiny Committee
Electric vehicle charging strategy
Councillor Axford asked why people would use the Council supply rather than private and whether each house needed an access point rather than having shared access points for the street. The Director of Highways, Transport, and Environment spoke about how the switch to electric vehicles and charging presented an opportunity for Councils to generate income and if the Council provided charging in the correct way that was accessible for residents they would use it. One aspect of this was ensuring that as many people as possible were able to use the charging solutions the Council put in place.
Said11 Jan 2023Scrutiny Committee
Committee work programme
Councillor Axford suggested that a task and finish group be formed to look at how to reduce car usage within the borough. The Governance Officer informed the Committee that there was not adequate officer capacity to support an additional task and finish group.
Named11 Jan 2023Scrutiny Committee
Committee work programme
The Committee agreed the that the task and finish group to be formed and would be conducted by Members with Councillor Axford as the Chair of the group.
Said9 Nov 2022Scrutiny Committee
MINUTES
Councillor Axford noted that costing had not been received for Gypsy, Roma, and Traveller visits and that the finance update requested at the last meeting had also not been provided.
Said9 Nov 2022Scrutiny Committee
Draft budget proposals 2022/23
Following the presentation Councillor Axford thanked Officers and Executive Member for the work they had done in preparing the draft budget and for the presentation.
Asked9 Nov 2022Scrutiny Committee
Draft budget proposals 2022/23
Councillor Axford then asked whether car parking fees were due to increase and whether consideration had been given car to fees being means tested as a way of increasing revenue.
Asked9 Nov 2022Scrutiny Committee
Draft budget proposals 2022/23
Councillor Axford also asked about the Council’s position regarding discretionary services, for example the music service, and whether any of them would cease to be delivered by the Council.
Named9 Nov 2022Scrutiny Committee
Draft budget proposals 2022/23
The Executive Member responded to Councillor Axford that some answers would be provided at the meeting and others at the budget scrutiny sessions. The Executive Member then answered that consideration had not yet been given to means testing parking fines but that he would ask officers to investigate whether it could generate funds for the Council. With regards to street lighting the executive Member for Finance and Governance assured the Committee that officers would monitor the areas where lighting was to be reduced to ensure that the proposals did not impact public safety.
Said9 Nov 2022Scrutiny Committee
Climate change action plan performance
Following the introduction Councillor Axford stated that she was disappointed the public panel was no longer going ahead and she felt the Council needed to look into harnessing the energy of the public including Trafford youth cabinet.
Said9 Nov 2022Scrutiny Committee
Climate change action plan performance
Councillor Axford noted that planning permission had been given to some large developments across the area which would have a high level of emission and asked how the Council could ensure future developments did not have large levels of emissions.
Asked9 Nov 2022Scrutiny Committee
Committee work programme
Councillor Axford asked that it be added to the agenda for the Committee meeting in March.
Said21 Sep 2022Scrutiny Committee
Finance change programme
Councillor Axford noted that the programme was looking at innovating and bringing change to meet the pressures and asked what that meant and whether community wealth building was part of it.
Named21 Sep 2022Scrutiny Committee
Finance change programme
The Executive Member for Finance and Governance invited Councillor Axford and all Scrutiny Members to provide suggestions for how the Council could look to save money.
Asked21 Sep 2022Scrutiny Committee
Carrington relief road
Councillor Axford asked whether the consultation would be delivered by the same company as the previous consultation and why they had been selected.
Asked21 Sep 2022Scrutiny Committee
Carrington relief road
Councillor Axford also enquired about the environmental impact of the road and how the Council would align that work with their goals for carbon reduction. The Executive Member for Climate Change and Transport Strategy shared the concerns Committee Members had regarding the company who had done the previous consultation. The last consultation had included 10,000 leaflets being dropped in Bucklow St Martins ward and had a particularly poor response rate.
Said21 Sep 2022Scrutiny Committee
Executive response to the gypsy, roma, and traveller visit task and finish group interim report
Councillor Axford welcomed the response but felt that there was not enough information available to decide the current cost of clean-up made providing toilets and bins cost effective. Councillor asked questions relating to negotiated stopping and having a transit site and about the use of section 177 and section 61 by the police.
Said21 Sep 2022Scrutiny Committee
Executive response to the gypsy, roma, and traveller visit task and finish group interim report
Councillor Axford also commented that she felt all Councillors should be informed of Traveller visits within the borough and not just the relevant Ward Councillors. The Director of Growth and Regulatory Services responded that there would be a further report looking specifically at the associated costs.
Named29 Jun 2022Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny review implementation 2022/23
Councillor Axford was disappointed that the meeting with the Leader had not been held prior to the meeting.
Asked16 Mar 2022Scrutiny Committee
Carrington relief road
Councillor Axford asked how secure the funding listed within the report was. The Director of Growth and Regulatory Services responded that the planning obligation funds were secured. The other areas of funding were subject to funding agreements with conditions, except for £2M of advanced funding from Homes England which had lesser conditions attached.
Said16 Mar 2022Scrutiny Committee
Carrington relief road
Councillor Axford noted the figures of other transport developments in 3.7 of the report and how the funding for a road compared to developing the Metrolink. The Director of Growth and Regulatory Services responded that the examples given were to demonstrate that relatively small transport developments were still expensive and gave an example of the Poynton Relief Road, ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Asked7 Feb 2022Scrutiny Committee
Councillor code of conduct
Councillor Axford asked where the amendments within the code had come from. The Head of Governance responded that the amendment had come from the Standards Committee, who had discussed the code at length.
Asked12 Jan 2022Scrutiny Committee
Homelessness in trafford
Councillor Axford asked what the reason was for the item coming to Scrutiny. The Chair responded that the item had come up due to concerns raised about the possible rise in homelessness due to the pandemic and the resulting difficulties for the service.
Asked10 Nov 2021Scrutiny Committee
High rise cladding update
Councillor Axford asked for details about the high-rise panels.
Asked10 Nov 2021Scrutiny Committee
Draft budget proposals 2021/22
Councillor Axford asked how much government funding Trafford received compared with other authorities. The Executive Member for Finance and Governance responded that Trafford was a very lean Council and had come together with other low funded Councils to lobby to receive 90% of the average funding received by Councils per capita. If the lobbying was successful Trafford receive an additional £5M.
Asked23 Sep 2021Scrutiny Committee
Trafford economic and recovery plan
Councillor Axford asked for the work around having a low carbon Trafford Park to be included within the update.
Said30 Jun 2021Scrutiny Committee
Committee work programme 2021/22
Councillor Axford noted that an update was scheduled for the next meeting on Climate Change and requested that the Committee cover the Council’s response to climate change regularly.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.