P24/V2434/HH - 4 Raleigh Park Road, North Hinksey, Oxford, OX2 9AZ
Ward member Councillor Emily Smith spoke on the application.
Every time Vale of White Horse's minutes name Councillor Smith, as the council published it.
Ward member Councillor Emily Smith spoke on the application.
Question from Councillor Smith to Councillor Clegg, Cabinet Member for Environmental Services, Climate Action and Nature Recovery in relation to responsibility for litter clearance on the A34.
Councillor Smith suggested that the Council engage with other stakeholders and sought clarification on potential financial implications.
The Planning Enforcement update report was introduced by the Cabinet member, Councillor Emily Smith. The Development Manager was present to support questions.
Councillor Emily Smith declared that as ward member for the item on Botley Pavilion (item 12), she intended to speak as ward member in the public speaking agenda item and would not participate as a Cabinet member for that item.
Councillor Smith left the table for this item, as she spoke as a ward member.
Councillor Smith received a certificate on behalf of former member Debby Hallett.
Question from Councillor Clegg to Councillor Smith, Cabinet member for Cabinet Member for Planning Development (Major/Minor Applications, Building Control and Enforcement) “South and Vale's Planning Enforcement contains a Triage Harm Assessment Form, which helps focus the councils' resources on alleged breaches where the potential planning harm is considered significant enough to warrant further investigation. One of the criteria within this form is for "Irreversible harm" to environmental aspects such as "Biodiversity", "Protected Species", or "Trees". While this is entirely appropriate, I question whether prevention of harm is still sufficient: since the Environment Act (2024) came into effect, developers must leave relevant habitats for wildlife in a measurably better state than they were before the development.
Councillor Smith responded that she would ask officers to review the webpages but reiterated that other options were available. She advised that the Scrutiny Committee meeting on 3 November would receive a planning enforcement update report. B.
Ward member Councillor Emily Smith spoke on the application.
Councillor Smith, Co-Chair of the Joint Audit and Governance Committee presented the annual report. She noted that this was the first time that the Joint Audit and Governance Committee had produced an annual report which addressed the recommendations of the external advisor engaged to provide training to the committee last year, and also that of the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA).
Councillor Emily Smith, a district councillor and ward member for Botley spoke to committee. She explained that in the consultation, Botley skatepark and Pavilion was now mentioned but not complete in accuracy, mentioning that Botley was referred to as South Oxfordshire. Construction was underway for the pavilion and we don’t want existing improvements, we have planning permission for a replacement pavilion.
Councillor Smith felt that the wording was confusing at best and request the wording to be updated and made factually correct. Why was the pool closure not addressed? How will provision loss be addressed?
In questions of clarification, it was explained by Councillor Smith that the strategy mentioned accessibility to be able to drive to places within 20 minutes. Some people needed to take the bus, so it will take longer than 20 minutes. As a district, we were encouraging active travel so why were we basing the strategy on how easy it ... view the full minutes text for item Sc75
Chair gave thanks to Councillor Emily Smith for the joint work on scoping a housing delivery strategy item (in her role at Joint Audit and Governance Committee). This would come to a future scrutiny committee and had been sent to officers.
Councillor Emily Smith suggested that in terms of agenda management and the most effective use of the limited meeting time available, reports where there was an opportunity for the Panel to respond to specific recommendations to the FOP and make its own comments and recommendations should be prioritised over items to note or items presented for update only.
Councillor Smith also asked why the current agenda had not included an item on a proposed Memorandum of Understanding, (MoU) between Oxfordshire County Council and the districts concerning the transition of the Oxfordshire Local Enterprise Partnership, (OxLEP) functions to the County Council given an item had been listed in previous iterations of the forward work programme. Andrew Down, Future Oxfordshire Partnership Director responded that the draft memorandum had been withdrawn by the County Council as not all district partners had been ready to agree it. Work on the transition arrangements up to September 2024 would continue and it was considered that a further report would be submitted to the Future Oxfordshire Partnership, (FOP) in the future, but ultimately this would be a question for Oxfordshire County Council to determine.
With the agreement of Council, Councillor Smith moved, and Councillor Foxhall seconded amended wording to the motion set out in the agenda at item 19 to accommodate an amendment with additional words shown in bold below:
Question from Councillor Smith to Councillor Coleman, Cabinet member for environmental services and waste There is growing concern in my ward about the number of single use disposable vapes that are littering our streets and public spaces. People who want to ensure their used vapes are disposed of safely are not ... view the full minutes text for item 36.
Councillor Emily Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in agenda item 5, Refreshing the Strategic Economic Plan June 2023 update on the basis that she had attended a number of public engagement workshops held about the Plan in a professional capacity related to her employment. She remained in the meeting for the course of the discussion.
Councillor Smith commented that she felt that the focus of the Panel’s time on specific agenda items had worked quite well, but suggested that when speakers attended, they were asked to provide a brief summary report which could help prompt questions and support the Panel’s discussion.
Question from Councillor Emily Smith to Councillor Sue Caul, Cabinet member for affordable housing, development and infrastructure Oxfordshire Community Land Trust (CLT) have worked with our council for around 15 years to bring forward Oxfordshire’s first CLT housing scheme in Dean Court, Cumnor.
Councillor Emily Smith proposed and Councillor Andy Cooke seconded Councillor Katherine Miles as Chair of the Panel. There being no other nominations, the nomination was agreed after being put to a vote.
Councillor Smith suggested the addition of an update on the Oxfordshire Food Strategy to the Panel’s work programme.
Question from Councillor Emily Smith to Councillor Bethia Thomas - Council Leader and Cabinet Member for Community Engagement Our district is home to so many inspirational individuals, charities and community groups. Over the past three years as we have lived through COVID-19 and now a national cost of living crisis, it's been incredible how Vale residents have stepped up to help each other.
Written answer I agree wholeheartedly with Councillor Smith that we are truly blessed in our district with so many individuals and organisations who show real community spirit.
The planning officer introduced the report and highlighted that the application was brought to the committee as the applicant was a member of the council, Councillor Emily Smith.
Councillor Smith, Leader of the council, provided an update on a number of matters. The text of her address is available on the council’s website .
As part of her address Councillor Smith confirmed her resignation as Leader of the council and that she would continue to serve as councillor for Botley and Sunningwell Ward.
On Behalf of Council, Councillor Crick, Chair of council, thanked Councillor Smith for her time as Leader of the council and wished her well in her career.
Councillor Smith proposed and Councillor Thompson seconded the appointment of Councillor Thomas as Leader of the council.
Question from Councillor Bob Johnston to Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the Council Given that consultation is now underway on the proposed Botley West Solar Farm spanning ours and two other districts, would the Leader agree with me that to deprive local councils of the power to determine the outcome would be an egregious example of centralised decision making? Written answer In 2008 the Government introduced a process to streamline decision making for major infrastructure projects, a Development Consent Order (DCO). They say this is fairer and faster for communities and applicants.
(1) Councillor Emily Smith moved and Councillor Bethia Thomas seconded the motion as set out in the agenda at agenda item 14.
Councillor Emily Smith declared interests in items 11 and 12 on the agenda. Her interest in item 11, Oxfordshire Food Strategy, related to accepting an offer of employment in a food charity that might be involved in the strategy’s action planning. Her interest in item 12, Didcot Growth Accelerator Enterprise Zone Memorandum of Understanding, related to her being a non-executive director of the Oxfordshire Local Enterprise Zone, with which the council was negotiating a revised memorandum of understanding.
Councillor Emily Smith announced that this would be her last meeting as both the chair of Cabinet and a Cabinet member as she was stepping down from her position as leader of the council on 7 December 2022. She thanked officers and fellow Cabinet members for their support.
The chair, Councillor Emily Smith, declared an interest in this item and left the meeting during its consideration.
The chair, Councillor Emily Smith, had declared an interest in this item and left the meeting during its consideration.
Councillor Emily Smith stated that it was reassuring to see that the Vision was aligned to the individual corporate plans. She also agreed with the Chair that its further socialisation was very important. It would, nevertheless, be necessary to prioritise and filter the areas in which the Partnership could and would operate so as to avoid duplicating existing activity.
The Chair commented that it was his understanding that Councillor Emily Smith had announced her intention to resign as Leader of Vale of White Horse District Council and that this was her last meeting of the Future Oxfordshire Partnership.
Consequently, the Chair paid tribute to Councillor Smith for all her hard work and valuable contributions not only in support of the Partnership but also as the Chair of the Oxfordshire Plan 2050 Advisory Group.
It was noted that Councillor Emily Smith (Council Leader) was present to introduce both papers this evening, as Cabinet Member for Finance and Corporate Assets, Councillor Andy Crawford, sent apologies.
The planning officer introduced the report and highlighted that this was called into the committee by a local ward member, Councillor Emily Smith. The application itself was part retrospective and falls withing the Oxford Green Belt. Work original commenced on the site under the assumption that it was allowed via permitted development rights.
Councillor Emily Smith and Debby Hallett, local ward councillors, spoke objecting to the application.
Councillor Maggie Filipova-Rivers, Cabinet Member for Community Wellbeing (South) introduced the report, supported by Councillor Emily Smith, Vale Council Leader, who was standing in for Councillor Pighills, Cabinet Member for Healthy Communities (Vale), who was unable to attend. Chair reminded that Covid support packages were already scrutinised, and further questions would need to be sent to officers or dealt with in confidential session if necessary.
Councillor Emily Smith, a local ward member, made a statement in support of the proposed name change. Officers recommended changing the parish name in line with the parish council’s request. The majority of consultation responses supported this.
Councillor Emily Smith, a local ward member, made a statement in support of the proposed boundary change at The Copse and of no change to the boundary at the Westwood Hotel site. South Hinksey Parish Council had submitted the proposal for the boundary changes. Kennington Parish Council had objected to the transfer of the Westwood Hotel site into South Hinksey parish but had not responded before the committee meeting in relation to the proposed boundary change at The Copse .
Councillor Emily Smith, a local ward member, made a statement in support of no change to the parish boundaries.
Councillor Emily Smith and Councillor Val Shaw, local ward councillors, both made statements objecting to a parish name change. Officers recommended that the committee made no change to the name of the parish. At its meeting on 26 May 2022, the committee had agreed to consult on a name change.
Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, provided an update on a number of issues. The text of her address is available on the council’s website .
Councillor Smith commented that as the Chair of the Oxfordshire Plan 2050 Advisory Group she echoed [name removed] remarks. She also welcomed the Scrutiny Panel’s support of the report’s recommendations.
While Councillor Smith had been disappointed that it had not been possible to agree on a process to determine housing need, she emphasised that a lot of good work had been achieved through the Plan process which they should be proud of including in the Oxfordshire Strategic Vision.
If the Partnership agreed to the recommendation to continue with a reamed and refocused advisory group, Councillor Smith commented that the county would still be able to work together and undertake strategic planning discussions on cross-boundary issues. It was also felt that this would contribute to mitigating some of the concerns expressed by the public speakers at the meeting.
Councillor Smith referred to the notes of the Oxfordshire Plan 2050 Advisory Group meeting held on 16 June 2022.
Councillor Smith suggested the addition of an item relating to the proposals for a new reservoir south of Abingdon – if the project went ahead, it would have implications far wider than that of the Vale of White Horse. Given the expectation that the public consultation on the project would start in November, officers were asked to reflect on how best the Partnership could consider the issue.
Giles Hughes, Senior Responsible Officer for the Oxfordshire Plan 2050, introduced the paper and, alongside Councillor Emily Smith, Chair of the Oxfordshire Plan 2050 Advisory Group, answered the Panel’s questions.
Councillor Emily Smith (Chair) had sent her apologies for absence.
Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, provided an update on a number of issues. The text of her address is available on the council’s website .
d) Future Oxfordshire Partnership Oxfordshire Plan 2050 Advisory Group Chair – Councillor Emily Smith and;
Councillor Smith referred to the notes of the meetings of the Oxfordshire Plan 2050 Advisory Group held on 17 February, 17 March and 29 April 2022. It was highlighted that a second joint workshop between council leaders and members of the advisory group was expected to take place in July. Communication around the Plan remained an area of focus.
Councillor Smith commented that it was an open question whether solar farm policy best sat at Oxfordshire Plan or Local Plan level, but there was a need as an Oxfordshire system to give the issues raised due consideration.
Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, provided an update on a number of issues. The text of her address is available on the council’s website .
Councillor Emily Smith updated the FOP.
There had been two meetings held since the minutes provided in the meeting pack, so Councillor Smith provided an update.
Councillor Smith felt it was useful way to guide discussion on spatial options, and work will be continued.
Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, provided an update on a number of matters. The text of her address is available on the council’s website.
Councillor Smith can take this point back to the sub-group (as Chair) and see what scrutiny could do to influence.
Recommendations 1 and 2 related to the Panel’s discussions with Councillor Emily Smith about the emerging Oxfordshire Plan 2050. It was their view that the Plan needed to make provision for contingency planning in respects of severe weather events.
The Chair informed the Panel that he had invited Councillor Emily Smith, Chair of the Future Oxfordshire Partnership’s Oxfordshire Plan 2050 Advisory Group, to attend the meeting as they were considering several items linked to the Plan.
At the Chair’s invitation, Councillor Smith responded that the Oxfordshire Plan 2050 Advisory Group was not currently considering this issue. She, nevertheless, stated that future food security was a matter that would have to be considered at both a county and national level – especially in terms of the balance of land use. Consideration of this issue could also feed into the spatial and local plan process.
In light of this, Councillor Smith moved and Councillor Boyd seconded a motion to ensure Vale of White Horse District Council secured the same representation as that to be agreed by South Oxfordshire District Council. On being put the motion was declared carried.
Councillor Smith, Leader of the council, provided an update report on a number of matters. The text of her address is available on the council’s website .
Councillor Smith commented that she also understood and appreciated the concerns of the Bicester community regarding the removal of the Howes Lane scheme, but that given the pressures around the Lodge Hill interchange she supported the re-allocation of the funds to that scheme. The issue did though highlight the strict conditionality around of use of funds within the Housing and Growth Deal.
Councillor Smith referred to the notes of the Oxfordshire Plan 2050 Advisory Group held on 14 October 2021 and also referred to the most recent meeting of the advisory group held on 18 November 2021.
Councillor Smith highlighted that the advisory group had felt it was very important to maintain a good level of engagement with the Planning Inspectorate and the new ministerial team at the Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities as the Oxfordshire Plan 2050 process moved towards the Regulation 19 stage so as to ensure the plan was developing in an acceptable technical manner. At its most recent meeting the advisory group had considered an initial and interim high-level summary of themes starting to emerge from the analysis of the Regulation 18 consultation responses. The advisory group had discussed how the output from the consideration of the consultation responses might be made available publicly and it was expected that a report setting out further information would be available in the New Year with the intention that it be considered by the district and city council overview and scrutiny committees.
Councillor Smith moved, and Councillor Boyd seconded, the following motion.
Councillor Smith, Leader of the council, provided an update on a number of matters. The text of her address is available on the council’s website .
Councillor Emily Smith declared a personal interest in item 12 – revision of the Science Vale Enterprise Zone accountable body memorandum of understanding – in so far as she was a director of the Oxfordshire Local Enterprise Partnership.
Councillor Emily Smith declared a personal interest in this item as she was a director of the Oxfordshire Local Enterprise Partnership.
Councillor Smith took no part in the debate on this item.
Councillor Emily Smith returned to the meeting room and took the chair for the remainder of the meeting. Cabinet considered the head of finance’s report, which proposed a new procurement strategy. This set out guidance on how the council should procure goods and services, whilst at the same time supported the council’s priorities and strategic themes.
Councillor Smith, Leader of the council, thanked the public speakers for taking ... view the full minutes text for item 31.
She referred to the communication activity set out in appendix 1 to the report and concluded by referring to the interim arrangements and the extension of subscriptions advised by Councillor Smith (see minute 31).
Councillor Catherine Webber moved, and Councillor Smith seconded the recommendation to note the report and the current position with the garden waste service as set out in the report.
Councillor Smith referred to the notes of the meetings of the Oxfordshire Plan 2050 Advisory Group held on 15 July 2021 and 12 August 2021. She also commented verbally on their most recent gathering on 16 September 2021.
In her update, Councillor Smith highlighted that the Regulation 18 Part 2 public consultation period would run until 8 October 2021. Several different stakeholder events had been held including a series of webinars and the contributions made had been very positive. She thanked everyone that had engaged with the process so far.
Councillor Smith asked for an item updating members on the implementation of the name change from the Oxfordshire Growth Board to the Future Oxfordshire Partnership to be added to the work programme.
Councillor Smith, Chair of the Oxfordshire Plan 2050 Advisory Group, also gave thanks to officers and members for their work to date. She said that it was an innovative document which had the issues of the environment and climate change at its heart. Furthermore, this was a genuine consultation presenting a series of options and it was, therefore, important that a wide range of people provided a response.
Councillor Smith said that she advocated for changing the name as it did not accurately reflect the Board’s role. As a body it made very few decisions and, therefore, the word Board was inaccurate. She argued that Partnership would be a much more suitable title.
Councillor Smith explained that at the previous meeting discussion had focussed on how to reach the maximum number of people through the consultation process. She also noted that the Advisory Group would be meeting as the consultation was ongoing to consider progress and to undertake more detailed post-consultation work planning.
Councillor Smith, Leader of the council, noted that this meeting was Margaret Reed’s final Council meeting prior to her retirement.
On behalf of councillors, Councillor Smith thanked her for her many years of service to the council and Vale residents. Although due to retire in 2020, Margaret had agreed to stay on for a further year to assist the council with its response to the Covid pandemic. She thanked Margaret for her support, advice and approachable manner and wished her a well-earned retirement.
Councillor Smith, Leader of the council, provided an update on a number of matters. The text of her address is available on the council’s website .
Councillor Emily Smith, Chair of the Oxfordshire Plan 2050 Advisory Group, paid tribute to officers for their work in progressing the Plan to the point of Regulation 18 consultation. She stressed that its publication would mark the start of a genuine consultation around the options facing the county. It was, therefore, important that as many people as possible took part in the consultation.
Councillor Emily Smith welcomed all present to the meeting. As outgoing Chair, she made a statement in which she thanked the members of the Board and officers for their support in what had been a challenging year and for how they had worked together to deliver a truly Oxfordshire wide agenda including the advancement of climate changes issues. The Growth Board had continued towards a more open approach to engagement with the public and improved its transparency, but its name was misunderstood and implied decision making and a focus on housing growth when its remit extended far wider.
Councillor Smith suggest reconsideration of one of the alternative names suggested during the Growth Board review.
Councillor Smith proposed Councillor Michele Mead as Chair of the Oxfordshire Growth Board for the year 2021/2022 and this was seconded by Councillor Susan Brown. There being no other nominations this was confirmed by the voting members present.
This was seconded by Councillor Emily Smith:
e) Growth Board Oxfordshire Plan 2050 Advisory Group Chair – Councillor Emily Smith and;
Councillor Smith declared that she had helped start and write the North Hinksey Neighbourhood Development Plan and would not take part in the discussion or voting on agenda item 10.
Councillor Smith, Leader of the council, provided an update on a number of matters. The text of her address is available on the council’s website.
Council noted the details of an urgent decision taken by Councillor Smith, Leader of the council, to approve arrangements for the council to administer Contain Outbreak Management Fund (COMF) grant funding to implement measures to support proactive containment and intervention to reduce Covid-19 outbreaks and the spread of infection.
Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, provided an update on a number of matters. The text of her address is available on the council’s website.
[name removed], Oxfordshire Clinical Commissioning Group; Councillor Ian Hudspeth, Oxfordshire County Council (who was substituted by Councillor Yvonne Constance); and Councillor Emily Smith, Vale of White Horse District Council (who was substituted by Councillor Judy Roberts).
Councillor Emily Smith was in attendance to present the item on a Joint Local Plan.
Councillor Emily Smith introduced the report on a joint local plan.
He moved and Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, seconded a motion to approve Cabinet’s recommendations as follows:
Councillor Smith moved and Councillor Thompson seconded the following motion:
Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, provided an update on a number of matters. The text of her address is available on the council’s website.
Question from Councillor Nathan Boyd to Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council We note with interest the flurry of letter writing to government and various local bodies to try and influence policies and represent our residents. With the push for transparency and the Corporate Plan focus on this matter, could the Leader please check and confirm by listing out these letters over the last three months to ensure that we have been made aware of all letters of influence and requests that have been sent by this administration either as Leader, Deputy Leader of by our Chief Executive on behalf of the Council that we should be aware of, and any responses received?
Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, provided an update on a number of matters. The text of her address is available on the council’s website.
It was proposed by Councillor Emily Smith and seconded by Councillor Barry Wood that Councillor Michele Mead be elected as Vice-Chair of the Growth Board for the remainder of the 2020/2021 Growth Board year. Upon being put to the meeting it was:
Councillor Smith and Councillor Wood summarised the key points of the Arc Leaders Group meeting held on 17 November 2020 and highlighted the holding of webinar on the Oxford to Cambridge Arc which had been attended by over 300 delegates. This was available to watch on the OxLEP YouTube Channel . Jeremy Long, Chair of OxLEP updated the Board on developments relating to productivity across the Arc.
[name removed], Church Warden of the parish of Abingdon, asked the following question “Why would you think of selling Old Abbey House when as you have said on many occasions it could play such an important community role?” Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, provided the following response “Thank you for your question and for your comments about the importance of Old Abbey House. Both in terms of its position at the centre of the town and the affection local people have for the building. It is incredibly sad to walk past the building all boarded up, and with maintenance costs mounting up as a result of it being empty for far too long, I am anxious to see it back in use.
In responding to the petition Councillor Smith, Leader of the council, thanked Julie Kelly for starting the petition and presenting it to Council. She acknowledged that the petition showed the strength of feeling and affection local people have for Old Abbey House and its place at the heart the town.
Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, provided an update on a number of matters. The text of her address is available on the council’s website .
Following recent changes to Cabinet member portfolios made by Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, Council considered a recommendation to appoint Councillor Catherine Webber, Cabinet member for climate emergency and environment, to the steering group.
The was introduced by Leader of the Council, Councillor Emily Smith.
Councillor Emily Smith, Chair of the Oxfordshire Growth Board, attended the meeting and gave an update on Growth Board activity with a particular focus upon the Oxford to Cambridge Arc and the Arc Leadership Group Executive. This included:
· As Chair of the Oxfordshire Growth Board, Councillor Smith had raised the need within the arc to achieve negative carbon emissions. This would mean going further than any current zero carbon ambitions and would involve the prioritisation of rail over road infrastructure · There was a need for more effective communication in relation to the Oxford to Cambridge Arc. A greater focus, for example, should be placed on the fact that the Arc was a much wider than simply physical transport links.
Councillor Emily Smith, in her capacity as an Oxfordshire County Councillor, spoke to the application, expressing concerns about traffic generation with the southern Lodge Hill slip roads not in place, no account being given to future A34 widening, and the apparent lack of funding from the developer to the clinical commissioning group for health services.
Councillor Smith also highlighted the problem of parking on verges and asked about the possibility of installing bollards at some locations. The planning officer confirmed that this was possible through an additional planning condition.
Councillor Smith also expressed concern over enforcing proposed condition 10 which related to preventing garage conversions without the need for planning permission.
In relation to the Growth Board, Councillor Smith responded that it was a collaboration of local council and system leaders with the purpose of coordinating efforts to maximise economic, housing and infrastructure developments in an inclusive and beneficial way.
It was agreed that the letter should be signed by Councillor Smith as Chair of the Growth Board. Several minor alterations were made to the draft text of the letter as follows:
Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, provided an update on a number of matters. The text of her address is available on the council’s website .
Supplementary question Councillor Smith undertook to provide a written response to a supplementary question regarding the possible widening of the Covid-19 Grant Scheme to help communities with innovative and creative ways to recover from the economic shock of the pandemic. B.
Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, referred to the flooding situation in the district and the ongoing updates provided by the Environment Agency and communities under high risk. She stated that the council’s website contained useful information to assist those likely to be impacted by flooding including links to relevant websites.
Councillor Crawford moved and Councillor Smith seconded a motion to approve Cabinet’s recommendations as follows:
Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, provided an update on a number of matters. The text of her address is available on the council’s website .
Instead, the Leader of the Council, Councillor Emily Smith, proposed Council approve the Cabinet recommendations noting that the plan safeguarded the character of the two parishes and provided for a new development at Dalton Barracks, together with a green buffer. The plan was compatible with the European Union obligations and complied with the Habitats Regulations Assessment. The independent planning inspector has supported the plan and agreed that it should proceed to referendum.
Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, addressed Council. The text of her report is available on the council’s website .
Councillor Emily Smith, a local ward councillor, was unable to attend the committee but provided a statement, objecting to the application. This was read out to the meeting and had been emailed to the committee prior to the meeting.
The Leader of the Council, Councillor Emily Smith, attended the meeting on behalf of the Cabinet member for planning. The leader asked the committee for its comments on the report and for any suggestions on how the team should prioritise its work in the future. The committee noted that ability to improve performance was restricted by resourcing difficulties.
Councillor Emily Smith, one of the local ward councillors spoke in objection to the application.
Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, addressed Council. The text of her report is available on the council’s website .
She advised that Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, and Councillor Simon Howell, Leader of the Conservative Group, had agreed to trial a process for councillor questions whereby written responses are circulated to all councillors in advance of the Council meeting. These were circulated to all councillors on Tuesday 16 July with copies made available for members of the public. In light of this she sought, and received, Council’s agreement to suspend Council Procedure Rule 36, which specifies how questions may be answered.
Councillor Emily Smith responded as follows:
Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, addressed Council. The text of her report is available on the council’s website .
Question 1: Councillor Simon Howell to Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council Officers put in place an excellent and detailed induction programme for new and returning councillors . Could the leader of the council summarise the level of attendance?
Supplementary question and answer In response to a supplementary question Councillor Smith confirmed that she will provide updates on the progress on the training programme and details of any refresher training.
Councillor Emily Smith paid tribute to Monica Lovatt in recognition of her work as chairman of the council during the past year.
Councillor Emily Smith, Leader of the council, addressed Council. The text of her report is available on the council’s website .
At its meeting on 13 February 2019 Council considered a motion submitted by Councillor Smith and seconded by Councillor Johnston.
Councillor Emily Smith moved, and Councillor Bob Johnston seconded the withdrawal of the motion.
Councillor Emily Smith spoke to the application as a local ward member. A motion, moved and seconded, to approve the application was declared carried on being put to the vote. RESOLVED : to grant planning permission for application P18/V2930/HH, subject to the following conditions:
Councillor Smith moved and Councillor Hoddinott moved an amendment in the following terms:
Councillor Emily Smith addressed Cabinet, suggesting that the plan should contain more aspirations and that the Scrutiny Committee’s recommendations should be taken into account before the consultation commenced.
Councillor Smith also questioned which organisation was accountable for the Oxfordshire Plan and asked that this was clearly set out for the public. Cabinet welcomed the draft plan and considered that it should be a high level strategic document setting out the vision for Oxfordshire in 2050. Cabinet asked that the suggestions made by the Joint Scrutiny Committee were considered by the head of planning in agreement with the other councils’ equivalents, and to make any necessary minor amendments and presentational changes to the documents prior to publishing the plan for consultation.
Councillor Emily Smith addressed the committee and made the following points:
Councillor Emily Smith addressed the committee.
The committee considered the views expressed by Councillor Smith and Sarah Medley. In respect of polling districts SSB1 and SSB2, the committee agreed that officers should investigate the possible use of either King Alfred’s School (west site) or Stockham Primary School. The committee noted the suggestion made by Sarah Medley in respect of Harwell East and requested officers investigate the suitability of the Boundary Park Pavilion as a polling place.
In response to the issue raised by Councillor Smith (see minute 52), officers confirmed that, due to the above, electors will now vote in the relevant Abingdon district and Abingdon parish ward.
Councillor Emily Smith attended as substitute for Councillor Jenny Hannaby .
Councillor Emily Smith stepped down from the committee and took no part in the debate or voting for this item.
Councillor Emily Smith, Vale of White Horse District Councillor for the Botley and Sunningwell ward, spoke in relation to this review. Her points included the following:
Councillor Emily Smith to Councillor Mike Murray, Cabinet member for Development and Regeneration I was shocked to learn that this council has £10million in developer contributions to pay for affordable housing sitting in the bank unspent. With these funds needing to be spent by various dates before having to be returned to developers, where can I find the council’s strategy for delivering these desperately needed affordable homes?
He stated that whilst Councillor Smith is correct that there is a time limit for investment of this money, none of the money received so far has an expenditure deadline of before 2022.
Motion proposed by Councillor Emily Smith, seconded by Councillor Jenny Hannaby:
Councillor Emily Smith asked who should be held accountable for the outsourcing of services and who was now responsible for trying ... view the full minutes text for item Sc13
Written representations regarding this review had been received from Councillor Roger Cox, a local ward councillor, and Councillor Emily Smith since the publication of the agenda and were circulated at the meeting.
In contrast Councillor Smith urged the committee not to proceed with a community governance review prior to the May 2019 elections, until further information becomes available on the review of Oxfordshire County Council Divisions, due to commence in 2019/20, and clarity is received on the timing of any unitary proposals for Oxfordshire, both of which could impact on the review. She also expressed the view that any consultation should not be undertaken before the new homes are built and occupied to allow residents to have their say in a consultation.
Written representations regarding this agenda item were received form Councillor Reg Waite, a local ward councillor, and Councillor Emily Smith since the publication of the agenda and circulated at the meeting.
Councillor Smith urged the committee not to create the new parish, or undertake a community governance review prior to the May 2019 elections, until further information becomes available on the review of Oxfordshire County Council Divisions, due to commence in 2019/20, and clarity is received on the timing of any unitary proposals for Oxfordshire, both of which could impact on the review.
She congratulated Councillor Emily Smith on her election as leader of the Liberal Democrat Group and therefore leader of the opposition.
He expressed best wishes to Councillor Matthew Barber in his new role as full time deputy police and crime commissioner, Councillor Emily Smith as new leader of the opposition and Councillor Jane Murphy as the new leader of South Oxfordshire District Council. He highlighted a number forthcoming events/issues:
Cabinet also received a statement from Councillor Emily Smith in support of the petition for a changing places toilet at the Abbey Meadows, Abingdon. A changing places toilet being provided at the Guildhall should be in addition to, not be instead of, providing one at the Abbey Meadows.
Councillor Smith asked how much budget was available to pay for this and had Cabinet sought funding from alternative sources to assist?
Councillor Emily Smith had registered to speak at the meeting.
Councillor Emily Smith had submitted the following question:
Question from Councillor Emily Smith to Cabinet Member for environmental health, Councillor Elaine Ware In the 2015 Air Quality Management Action Plan the 11 district wide actions were:
Councillor Emily Smith, Vale of White Horse District Council ward member for Botley and Sunningwell, spoke in support of the recommendations, referencing the recent proposals to amend the boundary of Sunningwell parish, which was discussed at the previous meeting, as an example of how the current system is unsatisfactory. Her points included the following:
Councillor Hallett moved and Councillor Smith seconded an amendment to refer the issue back to Cabinet as follows:
(3) Councillor Emily Smith expressed concern that the county council’s officers had not been consulted on the map submitted to the Scrutiny Committee. The map showed the area of safeguarded land for a cycle route from Dalton Barracks to the proposed park and ride site at Lodge Hill.
Councillor Smith reported that the county council wanted to reduce the number of car journeys and instead encourage cycling. The council should not encourage the use of a park and ride so close to homes. She urged Cabinet to delay the local plan to allow more time for the county council to respond before the council proceeded with the Regulation 19 consultation.
Councillor Emily Smith addressed the committee. Her points included:
Councillor Emily Smith made a statement that she was employed by Oxfordshire County Council. However, as the subject of the motion (agenda item 17) would not directly impact on her employment she would take part in the discussion and voting on the item.
Councillor Roberts moved and Councillor Smith seconded an amendment to the above budget to provide for a grant fund of £100,000 for Children’s Centres and £3,000 to pay for officer time to administer the grants.
Question from Councillor Emily Smith to Councillor Charlotte Dickson, Cabinet member for waste.
Councillor Emily Smith was proposed as Vice Chair by Councillor Debbie Hallett and seconded by Councillor Margaret Crick. RESOLVED .
Question from Councillor Emily Smith to Councillor Matthew Barber, Leader of the Council.
They were joined by Councillor Emily Smith, who had stepped down in order to be able to speak as an advocate.
Councillor Mike Badcock moved and Councillor Emily Smith seconded the following motion:
Councillor Emily Smith, one of the local ward councillors, provided a statement to be read out objecting to the application, covering the following points:
Question from Councillor Emily Smith to Councillor Roger Cox, Cabinet member for planning development management and housing “Of all the homes granted full and outline planning permission since 2011, how many have been completed, how many are not yet started, and what actions have Vale taken to speed up construction and make sure homes are delivered as soon as possible?” Councillor Roger Cox responded as follows:
Councillor Emily Smith, one of the ward councillors, spoke about her concerns relating to the height and scale of the SPD for Botley Centre and also raised her concerns about the consultation process .
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Smith attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13 Apr 2016 | Planning Committee | P15/V2933/O - Land North of Appleford Road, Sutton Courtenay | Carried | 6 for, 1 against, 3 abstained | |
| 19 Jan 2016 | Abingdon and North East Area Committee | New homes bonus and capital grants 2015/16 | Carried | 15 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 19 Jan 2016 | Abingdon and North East Area Committee | New homes bonus and capital grants 2015/16 | Carried | 14 for, 0 against, 2 abstained | |
| 19 Jan 2016 | Abingdon and North East Area Committee | New homes bonus and capital grants 2015/16 | Carried | 9 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 19 Jan 2016 | Abingdon and North East Area Committee | New homes bonus and capital grants 2015/16 | Carried | 16 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 7 Oct 2015 | Planning Committee | P15/V1795/FUL - Land off Field Close, Kingston Bagpuize with Southmoor | Carried | 9 for, 1 against | |
| 7 Oct 2015 | Planning Committee | P15/V0770/FUL - The Manor Court Road running North East From Manor Court, Chilton, Didcot | Carried | 10 for, 0 against | |
| 7 Oct 2015 | Planning Committee | P15/V0698/FUL - 197 - 199 Cumnor Hill, Oxford | Carried | 11 for, 0 against | |
| 7 Oct 2015 | Planning Committee | P15/V1101/FUL - The Old Pump Station and Kennels, Winaway, Harwell | Carried | 11 for, 0 against | |
| 7 Oct 2015 | Planning Committee | P15/V1876/HH - 12 Welford Gardens, Abingdon | Carried | 11 for, 0 against |
Meetings Councillor Smith was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 12 of 20 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Smith declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 24 Oct 2025 | Cabinet, item 190 | Councillor Emily Smith declared that as ward member for the item on Botley Pavilion (item 12), she intended to speak as ward member in the public speaking agenda item and would not participate as a Cabinet member for that item. | |
| 18 Jul 2023 | The Future Oxfordshire Partnership Scrutiny Panel, item 14 | Councillor Emily Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in agenda item 5, Refreshing the Strategic Economic Plan June 2023 update on the basis that she had attended a number of public engagement workshops held about the Plan in a professional capacity related to her employment. She remained in the meeting for the course of the discussion. | Stayed and took part |
| 2 Dec 2022 | Cabinet, item 45 | Councillor Emily Smith declared interests in items 11 and 12 on the agenda. Her interest in item 11, Oxfordshire Food Strategy, related to accepting an offer of employment in a food charity that might be involved in the strategy’s action planning. Her interest in item 12, Didcot Growth Accelerator Enterprise Zone Memorandum of Understanding, related to her being a non-executive director of the Oxfordshire Local Enterprise Zone, with which the council was negotiating a revised memorandum of understanding. | |
| 1 Oct 2021 | Cabinet, item 27 | Councillor Emily Smith declared a personal interest in item 12 – revision of the Science Vale Enterprise Zone accountable body memorandum of understanding – in so far as she was a director of the Oxfordshire Local Enterprise Partnership. | |
| 1 Oct 2021 | Cabinet, item 36 | Councillor Emily Smith declared a personal interest in this item as she was a director of the Oxfordshire Local Enterprise Partnership. | |
| 18 May 2021 | Council, item 5 | Councillor Smith declared that she had helped start and write the North Hinksey Neighbourhood Development Plan and would not take part in the discussion or voting on agenda item 10. | Took no part |
Where Councillor Smith sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2015 | 76 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Cabinet | Committee Member | Sep 2017 | 52 | 27 Nov 2026 |
| Joint Audit and Governance Committee | Co-Chair | Mar 2022 | 13 | |
| Planning Committee | Substitute | Oct 2015 | 12 | |
| Abingdon and North East Area Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2016 | 10 | |
| The Future Oxfordshire Partnership Scrutiny Panel | Committee Member | Jan 2022 | 10 | |
| Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Nov 2017 | 9 | |
| Joint Staff Committee | Vice-Chair | Jun 2018 | 9 | |
| Oxfordshire Growth Board (now the Future Oxfordshire Parnership) | Chair | Jul 2020 | 9 | |
| The Future Oxfordshire Partnership | Committee Member | Sep 2021 | 8 | |
| Community Governance and Electoral Issues Committee | Guest | Oct 2018 | 2 | |
| Joint Scrutiny Committee | Guest | Jan 2019 | 2 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.