P25/V2679/FUL - 28 Eynsham Road, Botley, Oxford, OX2 9BP
Councillor Judy Roberts spoke as representative of Cumnor Parish ... view the full minutes text for item 277.
Every time Vale of White Horse's minutes name Councillor Roberts, as the council published it.
Councillor Judy Roberts spoke as representative of Cumnor Parish ... view the full minutes text for item 277.
[Councillor Roberts joined the meeting at 19:21 mid item] It was noted that the report was a snapshot in time and specific answers might be needed from the relevant portfolio holder.
Councillor Judy Roberts spoke on behalf of Cumnor Parish Council Prof. Nicholas Perkins spoke in objection to the application Scott Houghton spoke as ward councillor Members queried why the application was Outline only and were advised that it was in order to establish whether the site was suitable for the proposed flats and that all matters aside ... view the full minutes text for item 240.
Councillor Judy Roberts, spoke on behalf of Cumnor Parish Council in objection to the application.
Councillor Judy Roberts declared that she was a member of Oxfordshire County Council, as Cabinet Member for Infrastructure & Development Strategy.
The reason for urgency being that the one of the current appointees, Councillor Roberts, was no longer permitted to be a member of the Scrutiny Panel following her appointment to Oxfordshire County Council’s Cabinet. The next scheduled meeting of the panel was scheduled for November prior to the next scheduled Council meeting.
The call-in request was made by Councillor Katherine Foxhall as chair of Scrutiny Committee, vice-chair Councillor Judy Roberts, and scrutiny committee members Councillors Hayleigh Gascoigne, Robert Maddison and Sally Povolotsky, for the following reasons:
Councillor Roberts, who worked for many years to push this scheme forward, and I were at the groundbreaking and in June at the opening. It is incredibly exciting to see the building almost finished and people from the Vale's housing register able to move into this truly affordable and low carbon housing. But it took such a long time to get to this point.
The planning officer introduced the report and highlighted that the application was called into the committee by the local ward member, Councillor Judy Roberts. The application was within the Oxford Green Belt and was a retrospective application for a detached outbuilding.
Councillor Judy Roberts, a local ward councillor, spoke objecting to the application. The committee inquired about what type of land the outbuilding sat on, and the planning officer confirmed that it was considered to be within the domestic curtilage. In addition, members asked why the application was considered acceptable, but the originally proposed application was not.
Councillor Judy Roberts, Cabinet member for development and infrastructure, acknowledged the points raised. She stated that the council proposal in its budget for consideration at the meeting was to limit the increase to 5%, well below the current inflation figure of approximately 10%, recognising the cost-of-living pressures on residents.
Question from Councillor Hayleigh Gascoigne to Councillor Judy Roberts, Cabinet member for development and infrastructure Great Western Park has been almost complete for a few years now, and community assets, such as community centres, parks and green space have over this time been gradually transferred from the developer, Taylor Wimpey to the Council.
Councillor Judy Roberts, ward member, was unable to attend but the Democratic Services Officer read out her statement, which was previously circulated to the committee.
Councillor Roberts spoke against the application. Both speakers raised concerns over overlooking.
If not how will any changes in the spending of the S106 contributions be decided?” Councillor Roberts, Cabinet member for development and infrastructure, responded as follows:
Question from Councillor Hayleigh Gascoigne to Councillor Judy Roberts, Cabinet member for development and infrastructure “The house building in Great Western Park, which sits on the boundary of Didcot and Harwell, appears to be almost complete, if not already completed.
Councillor Judy Roberts, a local ward member, made a statement objecting to the application. The committee noted that the live 2016 permission could be fully implemented on site. The changes proposed to the scheme were considered to not materially alter the impact of the development on the visual amenity of the area, when compared to the 2016 permission.
Speaking to item 9 was Ward Councillor Judy Roberts, who joined virtually to express her concerns.
RE11 – Restrict Garage Accommodation (Full) Ward Councillor Judy Roberts spoke to the committee to express concerns about the view from the street and setting a precedent on this street for this kind of application, which would be of detriment to the area. She was concerned that the property’s hedge needed protecting and wanted clarification that it would remain even if owners changed.
Question from Councillor Alison Jenner to Councillor Judy Roberts, Cabinet Member for Development and Infrastructure What affordable housing provision has this council achieved in recent years and how does this compare with our Oxfordshire neighbours?
Supplementary question and answer In response to a supplementary question asking for details of the amount of affordable housing commuted sum and growth deal money the council had spent, Councillor Roberts responded that £735,400 of the affordable housing commuted sum funds had been allocated, from the growth deal funds £2.4 million had been provided for extra care housing within the Didcot Housing 21 Project and £2,481,400 had been allocated for the Heylo Scheme and the Oxfordshire Community Land Trust Scheme.
Councillor Judy Roberts had sent her apologies for absence.
Councillor Roberts declared that she had assisted the Cumnor Neighbourhood Plan Steering Group with the development of the Cumnor Neighbourhood Development Plan and would not take part in the discussion or voting on agenda item 9.
Councillor Roberts did not take part in the discussion or vote on this item – see minute 5.
Councillor Roberts declared a personal interest in agenda item 15 on funding the Oxfordshire Community Land Trust (minute 169 refers).
Councillor Judy Roberts declared a personal interest in this item, as she had been involved with it since 2007, and left the meeting during its consideration. Council considered Cabinet’s recommendation, made at its meeting on 17 March 2021, on a proposal for funding through the Oxfordshire Growth Deal and S106 affordable housing commuted sums to support the development of an affordable housing scheme of eight units at Eynsham Road, Dean Court, Cumnor.
[name removed], Oxfordshire Clinical Commissioning Group; Councillor Ian Hudspeth, Oxfordshire County Council (who was substituted by Councillor Yvonne Constance); and Councillor Emily Smith, Vale of White Horse District Council (who was substituted by Councillor Judy Roberts).
Councillor Judy Roberts declared a personal interest in the item on funding the Oxfordshire Community Land Trust (minute Ca.95 refers).
Cabinet member for Development and Infrastructure, Councillor Judy Roberts, introduced the report on .
Councillor Roberts ran through the main changes as follows:
The “establishing a delivery vehicle” report was introduced by Cabinet member for development and infrastructure, Councillor Judy Roberts.
Councillor Judy Roberts, a local ward councillor, spoke in support of the application.
Motion proposed by Councillor Judy Roberts and seconded by Councillor Neil Fawcett Council notes that a hierarchy of organisations has grown up which influence regional development, some more accountable than others. These are collectively making increasing incursions into the decision-making abilities of elected local councils and placing significant growth demands on our districts.
Councillor Judy Roberts, one of the local ward councillors, spoke in objection to the application .
Councillor Judy Roberts, one of the local ward councillors, spoke in support of the application.
Councillor Judy Roberts spoke, objecting to the application on behalf of Cumnor Parish Council .
Councillor Judy Roberts to Councillor Roger Cox, Cabinet member for Partnership and Insight What will be the mechanism by which the Vale representatives on the Growth Deal’s three working sub-groups (Infrastructure, Joint Statutory Spatial Plan, and Housing) periodically and regularly feed back to full Council to let members know how the Growth Deal is progressing, the impact on our communities and how we can contribute to the plans?
Councillor Judy Roberts to Councillor Roger Cox, Leader of the council The chairman of the Local Government Association's Brexit Taskforce has said "the UKs exit from the European Union will have a significant impact on local government. Brexit will ultimately be judged on the success of failure by local areas; real people in real communities.
Councillor Judy Roberts asked Cabinet how the joint spatial plan could be valid if the route of the proposed Oxford to Cambridge Expressway was unknown. In response, it was reported that councillors and officers working on the joint spatial plan had recognised this issue and had raised the question with the Ministry for Housing, Communities and Local Government. The Oxfordshire Growth Board had also discussed the matter on 25 September and had requested its chairman to write to the Government to raise this concern.
Councillor Roberts asked if the Vale could seek special stakeholder status in the Oxford to Cambridge Expressway discussions with Government. In response, it was reported that the Vale would be a stakeholder and would attend such events as the council needed to be involved as closely as possible.
Councillor Judy Roberts attended as Councillr Johnston’s substitute.
Councillor Judy Roberts stepped down from the committee and took no part in the debate or voting for this item.
Question from Councillor Judy Roberts to Councillor Mike Murray, Cabinet member for Development and Regeneration “What funding is allocated in the 2018-19 Vale budget specifically to the Housing Enabler role as outlined in the Joint Housing Delivery Strategy?” Answer Councillor Ware responded to the question in the absence of Councillor Murray. She stated that the 2018/19 funding for the housing enabler role will be found from the existing housing team strength.
Councillor Judy Roberts had submitted the following question:
Councillor Judy Roberts, one of the local ward members, spoke objecting to the application. The committee noted that:
Councillor Judy Roberts, the ward councillor, spoke in objection to the application. Her concerns included the following:
Councillor Roberts moved and Councillor Smith seconded an amendment to the above budget to provide for a grant fund of £100,000 for Children’s Centres and £3,000 to pay for officer time to administer the grants.
Question from Councillor Judy Roberts to Councillor Matthew Barber, Leader of the council.
(1) Motion moved by Councillor Debby Hallett and seconded by Councillor Judy Roberts:
· The size, bulk, scale and mass of the proposed development were unacceptable · The square would not provide an attractive place to meet · The local facilities would not be improved and there would be much less choice · The proposed development did not satisfy the policies, objectives and requirements of the Local Plan and the Botley Centre Supplementary Planning Document Councillor Judy Roberts, a local member for the neighbouring Cumnor ward, spoke objecting to the application. Her concerns included the following:
Question from Councillor Judy Roberts to Councillor Charlotte Dickson, Cabinet member for leisure.
(1) Councillor Judy Roberts moved and Councillor Councillor Ed Blagrove seconded the following motion:
Councillor Judy Roberts, the local ward councillor, spoke objecting to the application and stated that Cumnor Parish Council had not been offered a presentation by the applicant. Her concerns included the following:
Councillor Judy Roberts declared an interest in application VNBH\25 Dean Court Community Association ( Cumnor ) as chair of the trustees. She stood down from the committee to speak in support of the application then left the meeting taking no part in any discussions or voting on this item.
Councillor Judy Roberts declared an interest in this application as the chair of the trustees. She stood down from the committee to speak in support of the application then left the meeting taking no part in any discussions or voting on this item.
Question from Councillor Judy Roberts to Councillor Matthew Barber, Cabinet Member for Legal and Democratic Services Would the leader be in agreement that a written response to all petitions is provided by the officer/committee to all councillors and the petition presenter?
In response to a supplementary question he offered to discuss sensible improvements to the process with Councillor Judy Roberts.
The application would increase harm as it was overdevelopment of the site, it would overdominate neighbouring properties, and an additional window to the rear would increase overlooking It would be out of keeping with the character and appearance of the area There was no visitor parking The parish council had concerns about water run-off from the site affecting other properties The proposed bin store location was inappropriate Councillor Judy Roberts, one of the ward councillors, spoke against the application, making the following points:
Vale of White Horse District Councillor Judy Roberts spoke, in accordance with standing order 17 of the constitution. She objected to the development and her concerns included the following:
Councillor Judy Roberts declared an interest in the grant application from Dean Court Community Association ( Botley ) as she holds the position of Chairman of the trustees. She would speak on this item but would not take part in the discussion or vote.
(1) Dean Court Community Association- Ref CCGNE\11 Film club and other equipment and additional storage Grant sought: £3,903 Councillor Judy Roberts spoke in support of the application but took no part in the discussion or voting as she was chairman of the trustees of Dean Court Community Association.
Councillor Judy Roberts was her substitute.
Councillor Judy Roberts, one of the ward councillors, spoke against the application. The points she raised included an objection to the skyline being out of character with the rest of the street as all the other properties have pitched roofs.
Councillor Judy Roberts left the meeting.
· Councillor Debby Hallett : her substitute was Councillor Judy Roberts;
A written statement from Councillor Judy Roberts, one of the ward councillors, was read out. This raised concerns about the design.
Councillor Judy Roberts, one of the ward councillors, spoke in support of the application.
Councillor Judy Roberts, one of the ward councillors, spoke objecting to the application, she made the following points:
Councillor Judy Roberts asked questions of the Scrutiny Committee and the committee discussed this item.
Question from Councillor Judy Roberts to the Cabinet member for economic development, Councillor Elaine Ware:
Councillor Judy Roberts, one of the ward councillors, spoke objecting to the application.
Councillor Judy Roberts had sent her apologies for absence;
Councillor Judy Roberts, one of the ward councillors, spoke objecting to the application. As well as raising the above concerns, she requested a full hydro-geological survey of the entire area as she was concerned about surface water flooding.
Councillor Judy Roberts, one of the ward councillors, spoke objecting to the application.
Councillor Judy Roberts was in attendance as Council lor Bob Johnston ’s substitute.
The committee noted the comments of Councillor Judy Roberts which were read out by the planning officer. She raised concerns regarding the impact on sewerage and noted that the proposal would amount to a substantial change to the property. She had commented that there would be an impact on the neighbours.
(2) Councillor Judy Roberts spoke in support of the application for Cumnor Parish Council reminding the Committee of her personal and prejudicial interest in the item. She explained that Cumnor Parish Council was seeking a grant towards the cost of installing safety surfacing as a part of a project to provide new and challenging play equipment for an area in the centre of what was formerly the Pinnocks Way council estate. She explained that the local area had suffered from many incidents of vandalism and anti-social behaviour and some families in the area fell into the ‘socially deprived’ classification.
Councillor Judy Roberts had declared a personal and prejudicial interest in this application and they left the meeting room during its consideration.
Councillor Judy Roberts declared a personal interest in item 7 Community Grants in that her son was a pupil at Matthew Arnold School .
(5) Councillor Judy Roberts also supported the application from Botley Boys and Girls Football Club and reported that the floodlights scheme had the support of local residents.
Planning and Community Strategy It was reported that Councillor Judy Roberts had expressed concern at the current performance of Local Performance Indicator’s TP3 and 4 – Enforcement and enquired whether such poor performance had been as a direct result of insufficient staffing resources. It was noted that the recent Planning Delivery Grant award would be partly used to increase staffing resources.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Roberts attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13 Mar 2018 | Abingdon and North East Area Committee | Community Grants | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Jan 2016 | Abingdon and North East Area Committee | New homes bonus and capital grants 2015/16 | Carried | 15 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 19 Jan 2016 | Abingdon and North East Area Committee | New homes bonus and capital grants 2015/16 | Carried | 14 for, 0 against, 2 abstained | |
| 19 Jan 2016 | Abingdon and North East Area Committee | New homes bonus and capital grants 2015/16 | Carried | 9 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 19 Jan 2016 | Abingdon and North East Area Committee | New homes bonus and capital grants 2015/16 | Carried | 16 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 11 Nov 2014 | North East Area Committee | Capital Community Grants (CCG) 2014/15 (round two) | Carried | 7 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 1 Oct 2014 | Planning Committee | 93 Eynsham Road, Botley, Oxford - P14/V1440/FUL | Carried | 12 for, 1 against, 1 abstained | |
| 1 Oct 2014 | Planning Committee | Land adjacent to 1 New Cottages, Ardington, Wantage - P14/V1218/FUL | Carried | 12 for, 0 against, 2 abstained | |
| 1 Oct 2014 | Planning Committee | Land at Witney Road, Kingston Bagpuize - P14/V1540/FUL - P14/V1541/A | Carried | 6 for, 5 against, 2 abstained | |
| 1 Oct 2014 | Planning Committee | Land at Witney Road, Kingston Bagpuize - P14/V1540/FUL - P14/V1541/A | Carried | 14 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 1 Oct 2014 | Planning Committee | 48 Cullerne Close Abingdon - P14/V1783/FUL | Carried | 14 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 20 Feb 2013 | Council | Notices of motion under standing order 11 | Lost | 14 for, 24 against | |
| 28 Oct 2009 | Council | Notices of Motion Under Standing Order No.11 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 May 2009 | Council | Questions Under Standing Order No.12 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2009 | Council | Recommendations from the Executive and Committees | Lost | 14 for, 22 against, 3 abstained | |
| 25 Feb 2009 | Council | Recommendations from the Executive and Committees | Carried | 22 for, 14 against, 3 abstained | |
| 25 Feb 2009 | Council | Council Tax 2009/10 for Parish and District Council Purposes | Carried | 23 for, 0 against, 16 abstained | |
| 1 Sep 2008 | Council | Amendments to the Constitution | Carried | 23 for, 12 against, 1 abstained | |
| 13 Aug 2008 | Council | Standing Order 31(1) - Requirement to Stand | Carried | 28 for, 10 against, 4 abstained | |
| 21 May 2008 | Council | Standing Order 31(1) - Requirement to stand whilst addressing the meeting | Carried | 28 for, 10 against, 4 abstained | |
| 10 Mar 2008 | Planning Committee | ABG/1781/4 – Demolition of existing house. Construction of a two storey building containing 7 flats (revision to permitted scheme). 116 Oxford Road, Abingdon, OX14 2AG. | Carried | 13 for, 2 against | |
| 27 Feb 2008 | Council | Council Tax 2008/09 for District and Parish Purposes | Carried | 30 for, 16 against, 2 abstained | |
| 4 Dec 2007 | Council | Minutes of Executive and Committees | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Roberts was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 18 of 30 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Roberts declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11 Jun 2024 | Scrutiny Committee, item Sc43 | Councillor Judy Roberts declared that she was a member of Oxfordshire County Council, as Cabinet Member for Infrastructure & Development Strategy. | |
| 18 May 2021 | Council, item 5 | Councillor Roberts declared that she had assisted the Cumnor Neighbourhood Plan Steering Group with the development of the Cumnor Neighbourhood Development Plan and would not take part in the discussion or voting on agenda item 9. | Took no part |
| 24 Mar 2021 | Council, item 157 | Councillor Roberts declared a personal interest in agenda item 15 on funding the Oxfordshire Community Land Trust (minute 169 refers). | |
| 24 Mar 2021 | Council, item 169 | Councillor Judy Roberts declared a personal interest in this item, as she had been involved with it since 2007, and left the meeting during its consideration. Council considered Cabinet’s recommendation, made at its meeting on 17 March 2021, on a proposal for funding through the Oxfordshire Growth Deal and S106 affordable housing commuted sums to support the development of an affordable housing scheme of eight units at Eynsham Road, Dean Court, Cumnor. | Left the room |
| 17 Mar 2021 | Cabinet, item 87 | Councillor Judy Roberts declared a personal interest in the item on funding the Oxfordshire Community Land Trust (minute Ca.95 refers). | |
| 19 Jan 2016 | Abingdon and North East Area Committee, item 3 | Councillor Judy Roberts declared an interest in application VNBH\25 Dean Court Community Association ( Cumnor ) as chair of the trustees. She stood down from the committee to speak in support of the application then left the meeting taking no part in any discussions or voting on this item. | Left the room |
| 19 Jan 2016 | Abingdon and North East Area Committee, item 7 | Councillor Judy Roberts declared an interest in this application as the chair of the trustees. She stood down from the committee to speak in support of the application then left the meeting taking no part in any discussions or voting on this item. | Left the room |
| 11 Nov 2014 | North East Area Committee, item NE18 | Councillor Judy Roberts declared an interest in the grant application from Dean Court Community Association ( Botley ) as she holds the position of Chairman of the trustees. She would speak on this item but would not take part in the discussion or vote. | Took no part |
| 20 Oct 2008 | North East Area Committee, item 7 | Councillor Judy Roberts declared a personal interest in item 7 Community Grants in that her son was a pupil at Matthew Arnold School . |
Where Councillor Roberts sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2007 | 124 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Scrutiny Committee | Vice-Chair | Jun 2007 | 65 | 30 Nov 2026 |
| Joint Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2015 | 28 | |
| Joint Audit and Governance Committee | Co-Chair | Oct 2018 | 21 | 12 Jan 2027 |
| Cabinet | Guest | Apr 2013 | 39 | |
| Audit and Governance Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2008 | 30 | |
| Planning Committee | Guest | Jan 2008 | 15 | |
| North East Area Committee | Vice-Chair | Mar 2008 | 11 | |
| Abingdon and North East Area Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2016 | 10 | |
| The Future Oxfordshire Partnership Scrutiny Panel | Committee Member | Jun 2023 | 3 | |
| Strategic Review Committee | Substitute | Sep 2007 | 2 | |
| Oxfordshire Growth Board (now the Future Oxfordshire Parnership) | Committee Member | Mar 2021 | 1 | |
| Licensing Acts Committee | Committee Member | May 2023 | 1 | |
| General Licensing Committee | Committee Member | May 2023 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.