Apologies for absence
Councillor Sarah James attended as a substitute member for the vacancy on the committee.
Every time Vale of White Horse's minutes name Councillor James, as the council published it.
Councillor Sarah James attended as a substitute member for the vacancy on the committee.
Councillor Sarah James attended as a substitute member for the vacancy on the committee.
Councillor Whiteman moved and Councillor James seconded the motion as set out on the agenda at item 19 A - South East Strategic Reservoir Option (SESRO) now known as the White Horse Reservoir (WHR) – Regulatory Compliance and Customer Protection - RAPID OFWAT PROCESS SCRUTINY Following debate and being put to the vote the motion was declared carried.
Councillor Sarah James registered to speak and sent a statement which was read out detailing plans for an amendment to be put to Council requesting an additional £22,500 be made available to administer the allocation of the historic underspend of the Disabled Facilities Grants.
It was agreed that Councillor Crawford and Councillor Coleman would carry out relevant discussions with officers and Councillor James.
The Leader expressed her thanks to Councillor James for raising this matter ahead of the Council meeting on 11 February 2026.
Councillor Sarah James attended as a substitute member for the vacancy on the committee.
Councillor Sarah James addressed Cabinet in relation to the Purchase of Waste Vehicles item and raised two main concerns.
Councillor James stated that the timing of the decision had not been made in line with the process outlined in the Waste Vehicle Procurement Strategy and requested that reviewing vehicle options and the capital budget available be considered further in advance of the next purchase decision.
Councillor James also commented on the climate impacts of the decision with specific regard to how they had been assessed and presented in the report and asked the Climate Impact Assessment Tool be assessed to ensure it accurately highlights climate impacts of council decisions.
The Chair thanked Councillor James for her comments, which the Cabinet would consider under the Purchase of Waste Vehicle Item.
Councillor Sarah James addressed the committee. She considered that there was a failure to uphold the aims of the council plans on climate action, including reducing operational carbon emissions.
Although the targets were confirmed as not on track, Councillor James felt this purchase pushed the target further away. She questioned whether alternative fleet options were considered fully and as per the procurement strategy of the councils. She considered that the steps within this strategy were not followed.
Councillor James considered that no evidence was provided to back up the statement that EV range was unsuitable for rural waste collection rounds. She considered that the committee should refer the decision back to the decision maker.
Councillor James moved, and Councillor Foxhall seconded, the following amendment:
Councillor Stevens moved and Councillor James seconded the motion as set out on the agenda at item 16:
Councillor Sarah James addressed the committee and urged members to further push to improve carbon reduction, making a case for influencing where possible (noting that transport was an Oxfordshire County Council (OCC) responsibility, but we could have influence), and referenced the potential option to charge more for carparking or charging more for heavier vehicles.
Councillor James also discussed signposting the public and making sure they know what resources are available to them, mentioning issues of fuel poverty and building efficiency, and grants available to help residents.
The chair thanked Councillor James for her points, which the Cabinet members would consider as part of the discussions for agenda items 12 and 13. No further questions were asked by the Cabinet.
Councillor James was thanked for her views given under public participation. The council had supported other measures, such as the OCC home upgrade grants, the Climate Action Fund and installation of electric car charging points. The Cabinet member noted the importance of the Council’s ongoing involvement in Local Energy Area Planning (LAEP), exploring options for Local Carbon Heat Networks and influencing the planning process.
Councillor Sarah James and Paul Barrow attended as substitute members respectively.
Councillor James declared her membership of the Westmill Solar Co-operative (motion 2 of agenda item 15).
(1) Councillor James moved and Councillor Foxhall seconded the motion as set out on the agenda at item 15(1).
Councillor Sarah James attended as substitute for Councillor Cheryl Briggs.
Councillor Sarah James (Leader of the Green Group) addressed the Cabinet. She asked for consideration to be given to scrutiny in this process.
Green Group amendment Councillor James moved and Councillor Patel seconded the following amendment:
In moving the amendment Councillor James stated that the amendment proposed making an additional £50,000 available for the Climate Action Fund grants in the 2025/26 financial year. The budget currently provided for £100,000 in Climate Action Fund grants each year, so this would bring it to £150,000.
Question from Councillor James to Councillor Crawford, Cabinet Member for Finance and Property Vale of White Horse District Council has had a plan in place for some time to move our offices to a new headquarters, Didcot Gateway, which was to be built and owned by South Oxfordshire District Council. This long-term plan is upended by the Government’s move to require wholescale reorganisation of Local Government in much of England, including Oxfordshire.
Councillor James moved, and Councillor Patel seconded, the motion as set out in the agenda at item 19.
Councillor Sarah James spoke to agenda item 15, Revenue Budget 2025/26 and Capital Programme 2025/26 - 2029/30.
Councillor James considered that action on climate change and nature recovery were clear priorities and were supported by the public (as reflected in the Council Plan consultation), and the target, even if hard to achieve, was considered appropriate by Councillor James, who asked where was the action on climate change in the Budget and Capital Programme?
It was noted that some projects had funding and were proceeding, but Councillor James considered that additional budgeting was needed to meet targets.
Councillor James was thanked for her contribution. The Chair noted that we were legally required to balance the budget and forecast for the medium-term financial plan.
A written response would be provided to Councillor James.
Ward Councillor Sarah James spoke on the ... view the full minutes text for item 174.
The planning officer confirmed that the application was called in for decision by committee at the request of ward Councillor Sarah James. The application is for a new dwelling on land formerly used as a Bowling Green in East Hanney , located behind the former Plough public house. The site, within a conservation area and surrounded by listed buildings, was previously intended to retain the Bowling Green and build a new club house, as part of the development proposals for the Plough The proposed dwelling is centrally located on the site, with access from Orchard Lane, parking at the front, and a garden at the rear.
Ward member Councillor Sarah James spoke on the application.
Councillor James declared that she works for National Energy Foundation, in relation to item 21 on the draft Nature and Climate Action Plan (NCAP).
This was noted but would not impact Councillor James participating at this stage.
The committee was advised of a missing representation from Councillor Sarah James, Hendreds ward member.
Councillor James reported that she was in full support of the proposal to designate Milton Hill Bowls Club as the polling place for polling district SJD – Milton (Heights).
Question from Councillor James to Councillor Thomas, Leader of the council and Cabinet member for Climate Action, Nature Recovery, and Strategic Partnerships In December 2023 this Council voted unanimously on a motion that noted the importance of Nature Recovery and made 12 resolutions towards delivering nature recovery in our district.
Motion moved by Councillor Clegg and seconded by Councillor James as set out on the agenda at agenda item 14 (1) Following debate, the motion was declared carried.
Councillor Sarah James, as leader of the Green Group at Vale of White Horse District Council, addressed Cabinet on items 9 and 10 of the agenda, Operational Net Zero Target and District Net Zero Target. She highlighted that achieving net zero was a priority of Green councillors and congratulated Cabinet on the progress made to date. Despite this progress it was clear that the current interim target would not be achieved.
Councillor James noted the severe regional rainfall event that the district had experienced that week which was a predictable impact of climate change that had disrupted residents and the local economy. She went on to highlight that Council had voted for SMART targets in July and in light of this asked that Cabinet strengthen the recommendations before them in respect of items 9 and 10 and require the targets set to be SMART.
Cabinet were satisfied with the report but wished to ensure, in line with comments made by Councillor James and Patel and the approved Council motion from July, that any future interim targets set were SMART.
Councillor Sarah James, as leader of the Green Group at Vale of White Horse District Council, addressed Cabinet on item 6 on the agenda, Regulation 19 draft Joint Local Plan. She recognised that the draft Joint Local Plan Cabinet was making recommendations to Council on was important to the delivery of council priorities to shape a district where people and nature could thrive. She confirmed these were priorities shared by the Green Group who were looking for reassurance that the Joint Local Plan could do this when full Council debates putting the JLP forward to the next stage.
Councillor James highlighted some key changes since the Regulation 18 Preferred Options consultation, namely a reduction in the requirement for affordable housing in Vale of White Horse to 40% of dwellings (from 50%), though this remains 50% in South Oxfordshire, removal of the requirement for residential developments of 50 homes or more in Vale to limit embodied carbon, though this remains a requirement in South Oxfordshire. Her understanding was that these changes arose from the viability assessment, but that assessment hadn’t been seen by members yet.
Councillor James asked Cabinet, in their debate, to fully explore these changes to requirements in Vale compared to South. It would be helpful to members to hear and understand the basis for these changes and the expected impacts and risks to making or not making these changes.
In response, Councillor Foulsham, the Cabinet Member for Policy and Programmes, confirmed that the changes Councillor James highlighted were as a result of the viability assessments. Whilst it was regrettable that the affordable housing requirement had been dropped from 50 per cent it was still a marked improvement on the 35 per cent required under the current Local Plan. He went on to advise that care had to be taken to ensure the soundness of the plan on deliverability grounds, the small adjustments which had been made went towards ensuring the viability and soundness of the plan.
2) Councillor Sarah James made a statement on item 10, the Corporate Performance Report and Climate Action Plan Performance Report – Quarter four 2023/24, and item 12, the Review of the Future Oxfordshire Partnership. On item 10, she sought Cabinet’s support for there to be more data presented in the climate action plans as she believed the additional quantitative data would make the reports clearer to residents. The Leader responded by saying that the next report would be taking a new format and would account for these recommendations.
On item 12, Councillor James agreed that the current form of the FOP was difficult to follow from the outside due to its lack of transparency and welcomed the recommendations to seek engagement with all members on the partnership. In response, the Leader agreed with the desire to see more members comment on the FOP report and that she encouraged members to address the Scrutiny and Joint Audit and Governance Committees when they discuss the item. She was also keen to see the FOP reports become public, rather than taken to the private advisory groups.
The Cabinet member for policy and programmes, Councillor Andy Foulsham, presented the two documents and highlighted that the reporting on these documents would change for the new plans, reflecting the information that needed to be known and also accounting for the comments from Councillor James.
Councillor James, a neighbouring ward councillor, made a statement in agreement with the Chair’s words and thanking Richard Webber for his support when she was first elected as a district councillor.
Councillor Sarah James, as ward member, spoke to the S106 request for a new community hall with sporting facilities at Milton. She supported this request for a new community hall with sporting facilities, acknowledging the work of those involved to bring this together, noting the growing number of homes and residents in need of this facility. She was pleased to see this item and explained the vital need to bring communities together.
It was noted that Councillor James, as ward member, spoke to this item under public participation and was in full support, along with confirmed support from the parish council.
Councillor Sarah James had submitted a statement in relation to item 7 on the agenda, White Horse Leisure & Tennis Centre and Wantage Leisure Centre Salix Phase 3b Decarbonisation Projects. The Democratic Services Team Leader read out her statement. Whilst she was pleased to note the commitment to decarbonising the districts leisure centres and the funding which had been secured for this project, she was concerned about the risk of losing some of the secured funding for the project, and therefore the delivery of the project as planned, due to delays in the procurement process.
Councillor James asked the Cabinet member for finance and property for an explanation as to what had happened.
The Cabinet member for finance and property presented the report and began by responding to the question raised by Cllr James. He advised that had there been no challenge to the procurement or had funding been rolled over from year one to year two, as it has been in the past, the council would be in a very different position but provided assurance that a lessons learnt exercise would be carried out. He continued by stating the importance that officers focused on contract delivery and mitigating the risks which had been identified.
The Cabinet member for finance and property committed to providing a written response to Councillor James.
“Oxford Friends of the Earth welcomes and endorses the Motion proposed by Councillor James on nature and climate change issues. We are a long-established environmental group with over 1700 supporters across the county. We are not linked or affiliated to any political party or grouping.
(2) Councillor James moved and Councillor Foxhall seconded the motion set out on the agenda at item 16(2) Following debate and being put to the vote the motion was declared carried. RESOLVED :
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor James attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor James's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor James was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 13 of 19 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor James declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 16 Jul 2025 | Council, item 107 | Councillor James declared her membership of the Westmill Solar Co-operative (motion 2 of agenda item 15). | |
| 9 Dec 2024 | Climate Emergency Advisory Committee, item 82 | Councillor James declared that she works for National Energy Foundation, in relation to item 21 on the draft Nature and Climate Action Plan (NCAP). |
Where Councillor James sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2023 | 27 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2023 | 10 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Climate Emergency Advisory Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2023 | 5 | |
| Community Governance and Electoral Issues Committee | Substitute | Mar 2024 | 5 | |
| Joint Climate and Nature Advisory Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2026 | 2 | 7 Dec 2026 |
| Cabinet | Committee Member | Jun 2024 | 2 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.