Motion 1 - Addressing the funding crisis in Local Government
The following motion was proposed by Councillor Rodrigues, seconded by Councillor Watkin:
Every time Watford's minutes name Councillor Watkin, as the council published it.
The following motion was proposed by Councillor Rodrigues, seconded by Councillor Watkin:
There was a change of membership for this meeting with Councillor Duduta replacing Councillor Watkin.
Councillor Watkin commented that the report showed how the council was getting to grips with key information and managing it. He had spoken with the Intelligence, Performance and Improvement Lead about the data and how it would be possible to review the figures month by month to check if services were meeting the targets with explanations if not met. It provided an opportunity to be able to react more rapidly as issues arose.
The Mayor invited Councillor Watkin to introduce the report, as he chaired the Property Investment Board.
Councillor Watkin explained that due to changes introduced by the government it was necessary to review the terms of reference for the Property Investment Board. He informed members about some of the changes being introduced and affecting how and when councils could borrow money. The proposed changes ensured the Board’s terms of reference reflected the government’s guidance.
Councillor Watkin commented on the breadth of applications and the range of subjects from the arts to a playground. There was a wide range of opportunities.
The Mayor invited Councillor Watkin to introduce the report.
Councillor Watkin provided the background to Croxley Park and the council’s acquisition of the lease over the site. The business plan provided a comprehensive review of the local economic context. The rent levels were slightly lower than the predicted levels when the site was acquired.
Councillor Watkin added that he also needed to declare an interest in minute number 64. He was a member of Hertfordshire County Council and, in addition, was a member of the panel who agreed the process under discussion; he therefore also had a disclosable pecuniary interest in the matter. He confirmed he would leave the meeting for the duration of that item.
Councillor Watkin said that he wished to thank Carol Chen in her role as Group Head of Democracy and Governance and particularly as Monitoring Officer. He felt it was hard to think of Watford Borough Council without Carol. Carol had steered the council through difficult decisions and provided wise counsel.
He invited Councillor Watkin to introduce the report.
Councillor Watkin explained that the report set out the details of a long discussion with the Sikh community about the site. He congratulated the community on raising the funds needed to acquire the long lease. He explained the background to the site and the short-term tenancies to the Gurdwara.
Councillor Dychton wished to thank Councillor Watkin and officers for their work. She was aware of the importance of the Sikh community in Watford and the support they gave to all communities.
He then moved the budget and council tax to be approved, which was seconded by Councillor Watkin.
Councillor Watkin remarked that the report referred to the council having strong controls over its finances but had identified that there were a few things that could be changed. He referred to the appointment of an Independent Person to the Audit Committee, which was in progress. Another recommendation had been the inclusion of the Finance Monitoring report at Cabinet, which was on the agenda for this meeting.
The Mayor invited Councillor Watkin to introduce the report.
Councillor Watkin explained that the report provided details of the original budget that had been agreed at Council on 31 January 2023 and the changes agreed by Council on 17 October 2023. It included information on the pressures on the council, which were clearly explained in the report by the Chief Finance Office. He highlighted the main variation due to the cost of temporary accommodation due to an increase in demand.
Councillor Watkin explained the report provided a huge amount of detail, including breakdown of expenditure for each department. He would provide a snapshot, but it would be explained in much more detail at Council.
Councillor Watkin said it had been a tough year for local authorities, with a predicted four out of 10 councils potentially facing bankruptcy. He stressed this was not the situation for Watford. Referring to the revenue budget gap he advised that there had been an increase in the Medium Term Financial Strategy.
Councillor Watkin stated that the overall capital expenditure for 2024/25 would be £33 million. A further £6 million would be taken from the reserves. However, this would still leave adequate reserves of £25 million.
Councillor Watkin informed members that due to the pressures on the council’s finances the maximum permitted Council Tax increase of 2.99% would be recommended to Council. He acknowledged that the council was facing great financial pressures and that there would be loyal members of staff leaving.
The Mayor invited Councillor Watkin to introduce the report.
Councillor Watkin introduced the report. He referred to recent policies that had been introduced and the establishment of the Customer Experience Project board. He commented that real time information was available about the number of complaints and response times.
Councillor Watkin informed members that the overall number of complaints had decreased by 20% compared to the previous year. With regards to Stage 2 complaints, these had also decreased by 20%; a total of 12 had been received. The statistics were the lowest of any Hertfordshire authority.
• Sustainability – new EV charging points with installation progressing • Tree planting • Rediscovering the River Colne project • Cassiobury Park Wetlands • Watford Business Park redevelopment completion • 120 new social rented homes on target • Opening of new crematorium at Hemel Hempstead • Good progress on the Watford business charter The Mayor invited Councillor Watkin to further introduce the report.
Councillor Watkin explained that the Council Plan provided the strategic framework for the council over four years. The Delivery Plan covered a two-year period. The overall results had been positive.
Councillor Watkin added his thanks to the Intelligence, Performance and Improvement Lead for her work.
He invited Councillor Watkin to introduce the report.
Councillor Watkin thanked the Associate Director of Property and Asset Management who had overseen the development of the strategy and policy and the Interim Lead Asset Manager for his hard work in getting it to this stage. He provided members with the background to the development of the two documents, which would provide a more considered and managed way forward for the council’s community assets and in return the council would get the best financial and commercial benefit.
Councillor Watkin explained that these assets were separate from the council’s commercial portfolio. He advised that the 47 sites that formed part of the council’s community assets were there for the benefit of the community rather than the council’s own operations. However, he stressed there was currently very little vacant space available.
Councillor Watkin said that this reflected the council’s commitment to work with all community organisations, whether it was about the right facilities, financial support or environment for them to work successfully. It provided clarity about how the council engaged with the organisation and why.
Councillor Watkin was invited to add further details, as it related to his portfolio covering Human Resources.
The Mayor invited Councillor Watkin to introduce the report.
Councillor Watkin stated that during his time as a councillor he had seen the council transformed. The council was more reactive and higher performing than previously. However, it was facing some of the greatest challenges than it had on the past.
Councillor Watkin added that everyone lived in a fast-changing world and it was important to be able to react. Portfolio Holders needed to be able to see live information rather than historical data. It would enable officers to react quicker.
Councillor Watkin reiterated the Mayor’s comments on the difficulties many councils were facing, including Watford, which, like other councils, was facing a shortfall in its funding, rising inflation and increasing demand on services. During his time on the council, he had never witnessed the challenges the council was currently facing. For the current financial year, the council was facing an increase of £3 million in budget expenditure.
Councillor Watkin advised members that the charging policy included different categories that could be applied to fees and charges. The main three were:
Councillor Watkin noted that the council was sympathetic to anyone struggling to pay the charges and within the report an explanation of concessions was provided and who would be eligible.
Councillor Watkin commended the recommendations to Cabinet for approval at Council.
The Mayor thanked Councillor Watkin and the officers for their work in preparing the information for the meeting.
Councillor Watkin asked whether the lack of an adopted Local Plan would have an impact on progressing the Joint Strategic Plan.
Councillor Watkin added that it was difficult at times to work together, but it was better to work together ... view the full minutes text for item 30.
The Mayor invited Councillor Watkin to provide additional information about the key performance indicators.
Councillor Watkin stated that the key performance indicators were critical to the management and oversight of the council. The community was able to see quickly and clearly the council’s commitments. They provided an overall impression that the council understood where it was and how it was progressing.
Councillor Watkin, who was also the county councillor covering the park, added that the project would not cover the whole park but would concentrate on the recognised routes crossing, it would enhance the installations already in place.
He invited Councillor Watkin to explain the report in more detail.
Councillor Watkin added his thanks to the Associate Director of Customer and Corporate Services and Intelligence, Performance and Improvement Lead. The strategy was a fundamental building block for the council to ensure it continued to progress and react to the changing environment. The council would become information rich, enabling it to capture data correctly and efficiently.
Councillor Watkin stated that he had a conservation area within his ward. He was also working with another councillor on the reducing traffic speeds on Grove Mill Lane. He would welcome support in getting the bridge repaired.
The Mayor invited Councillor Watkin to provide further details.
Councillor Watkin stated that the results shown in the report and appendices underpinned the work set out in the Mayor’s manifesto. He said it was important to recognise the staff for all the work they had done. He advised that the council had just received an award which recognised the staff went above and beyond the requirements of a committed team.
Councillor Watkin commented that the Mayor had mentioned some of the key successes. However, he did want to mention that there was one red indicator in the Delivery Plan. This was related to the completion of a new crematorium, which the council was working in partnership with other local councils.
The Mayor invited Councillor Watkin to explain the report in more detail.
Councillor Watkin explained that the council had been part of a buying consortium for its energy. It was important to prepare for the period after the current contract expired. He thanked the council’s Corporate Procurement Manager for his work on reviewing the options available.
The Mayor invited Councillor Watkin to present the report.
Councillor Watkin thanked Sean Brew and the team from LSHIM for their work in overseeing and managing the Park. The Annual Business Plan had already been reviewed at Property Investment Board and had recommended it to Cabinet for approval. He outlined some of the key elements of the report.
The Mayor informed Cabinet that he and Councillor Watkin had been involved in the discussions about the new shared services. He referred to the success of the existing shared services with Three Rivers District Council which had provided resilience and a cost effective way of delivering services. He stated that Three Rivers District Council could join the new shared services at a later date if they wished.
· Budget setting report · Income charging policy · Schedule of fees and charges · Capital Strategy (Including the Treasury Management Policy, Minimum Revenue Provision Policy and Prudential Indicators) · Budget and Council Tax Resolution 2022 to 2023 · Medium Term Financial Strategy 2022-23 to 2024-25 · Report of Licensing Committee 13 January 2022 · Report of Cabinet 17 January 2022 The Mayor moved the budget report which was seconded by Councillor Watkin. The Mayor presented the budget which would help the town to continue to respond to the pandemic, support those most in need, enable businesses to grow and succeed, provide the best local services and ensure value for money for residents.
He invited Councillor Watkin to expand further.
Councillor Watkin noted that the proposed policy had attracted national interest and had appeared in a national newspaper. The policy set out the procedures to ensure everyone understood how the council selected names for new roads or buildings. A database of acceptable names would be compiled and provided to developers for reference.
Councillor Bell noted the process outlined by Councillor Watkin, but was concerned that if residents did want a street name changed that obstacles would be put in their way. He also asked whether the council could provide financial support or fund any change.
Councillor Watkin emphasised that it was unlikely that the Mayor or councillors would ignore residents’ or businesses’ views if the request met the criteria set out in the policy.
Councillor Watkin introduced the report. He explained the background and the decision to award the contract to Morgan Sindall / Overbury for a period of three months. There were no further comments or questions about the report.
Councillor Watkin, Portfolio Holder responsible for Finance was invited to introduce the report.
Councillor Watkin commented that at last year’s budget setting meeting he had said there was uncertainty about the impact of coronavirus on the council; it had proven those concerns were correct. He highlighted key points within the budget report. Coronavirus was still having an impact on some of the services provided by the council and these would continue to be monitored throughout the coming year.
Councillor Watkin advised that the budget, as set put, proposed an increase of approximately 1.5%, equivalent to approximately £2 per month. It was likely to be one of the lowest increases in Hertfordshire.
Councillor Watkin commented that in line with his portfolio he was responsible for shared services. He noted that officers reflected the Watford position in their work for the council even if directly employed by another authority. He looked forward to working with the other councils on these mutual areas.
In response to a question from Councillor Watkin about signage, Councillor Williams replied that the county council allowed temporary signs to be put up, but he was looking to have larger and bolder signs installed.
The Mayor invited Councillor Watkin, Portfolio for Resources including Finance to present the report.
Councillor Watkin outlined the details contained in the officer’s report. He noted that a small balance had been transferred to the Economic Impact Reserve. The property portfolio had held up well considering the pandemic.
Councillor Watkin explained that Appendix 6 in the annex to the report set out the various reserve accounts. Some of these had been closed and transferred to the Recovery Fund. It had been the most challenging of years financially.
Councillor Watkin thanked the task group for their report. The review of internal policies would build on the council’s strengths and it was appropriate for them to be reviewed.
Councillor Watkin, the Portfolio Holder for Resources and Customer Services, introduced the report.
Councillor Watkin, Portfolio Holder for Resources, introduced the report. He advised that he was confident that following a review of the service’s procedures the same problem would not re-occur.
Councillor Watkin, Portfolio Holder for Resources, explained that officers were seeking permission for the council to underwrite one-fifth of the loan to Dacorum Borough Council. The funding would be used towards a new crematorium in Hemel Hempstead.
Councillor Watkin, Portfolio Holder for Resources, introduced the report. The council had decided to seek professional management advice following the receipt of £92 million in connection with Croxley Park, as detailed in the report. The Interim Director of Finance commented that she had delegated authority to make the appointment, but was seeking an endorsement from Cabinet.
In response to a question from Councillor Watkin, the Development Team Leader explained that most telecommunications masts were now shared amongst providers. Whilst this reduced the number of masts required, the new 5G antennas had a shorter range than older iterations, so generally more masts were needed to deal with the range and the increased usage of phones and data. There was a short discussion around 2G, 3G, 4G and 5G.
Councillor Watkin thanked the Group Head of Service for his work on this strategy. He welcomed that the health and wellbeing of staff had been the top theme. He had been pleased to see the Customer Service Academy.
Councillor Watkin introduced the report. He said that the version before Cabinet was slightly different to the one presented to Finance Scrutiny Committee. He explained the projected loss of income and increase in costs.
Councillor Watkin introduced the report. He highlighted some of the key elements of the report, including the overall underspend, further sum added to the economic reserve and the carry forward for the capital budget which would be rephrased in 2020/21.
Councillor Watkin introduced the report. The scheme allowed the council to review requests from council taxpayers for an amount of their council tax to be reduced or written off.
Councillor Watkin, an ex-allotment holder, commented that it was a very rewarding activity. He cautioned against self-management for allotments, as it could become divisive amongst plotholders .
Councillor Watkin, at the invitation of the Mayor, provided Cabinet with the headlines contained in the report. He advised that the budget was prudent, cautious but still allowed for innovative schemes, for example the new transport schemes. He explained about the expected budget gap and its prospective growth to £2 million.
Councillor Watkin advised the committee of the process for selecting the new managing director and of the progress that had been made to date. He went on to discuss decisions made by Cabinet in relation to the Croxley Business Park and the Bike Share Project. He ended by explaining that the Revenue and Benefits service would remain ... view the full minutes text for item 10.
Councillor Watkin thanked finance officers and commented that there was short term income as well as greater security for the future.
The Portfolio Holder, Councillor Watkin, thanked the programme team for the presentation. He suggested it may be useful to give councillors a demonstration at the next meeting. He suggested the process of transformation looked impersonal.
Councillor Bell and Mayor Thornhill paid tribute to Robert Gordon and Councillor Watkin spoke about Robert Caton.
There was a change of membership for this committee; Councillor Bolton replaced Councillor Kent and Councillor Watkin replaced Councillor Laird.
Councillor Watkin explained that the budget was fairly neutral as it was not making radical changes but instead was announcing a change to how the council would have to run its finances in the future as the government removed the Revenue Settlement Grant (RSG). The council had to raise income or reduce costs in order to find £1m. This budget was about launching the council to be ready to do this; it would be a year for planning and preparation.
Councillor Watkin continued that for council tax there was a proposed increase of £5 or 2% which equated to 10p per week for a band D property. Since the last council tax increase the Retail Price Index had increased by 19%. There would continue to be council tax support for those disadvantaged members of the community.
Councillor Watkin introduced the report and explained it was the final report on last year’s financial performance. There had been an overspend on the temporary accommodation budget. However, the council had managed to achieve significant improvements to commercial rent income and income from kerbside recycling.
Councillor Watkin continued that with regards to capital expenditure there would be £9.125m re-phased into 2016/17. There was major investment into the borough which was seen as a key priority. However, there was also uncertainty about the future particularly the relationship with Europe following the recent referendum result.
Councillor Watkin commented that at that day’s Hertfordshire County Council Cabinet meeting they had looked at future transport plans, including making Watford Junction into a significant transport hub.
There was a change to the Committee for this meeting: Councillor Watkin replaced Councillor Sharpe. Apologies had been received from the Community Services Section Head.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Watkin attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Watkin's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Watkin was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Watford has not published attendance for Councillor Watkin's meetings yet.
What Councillor Watkin declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Watkin in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Watkin sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Watkin yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.