CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
People/Welwyn Hatfield/Councillor James Broach
JB

Councillor James Broach

Vice-Chairman, Development Management Committee
Follow Councillor Broach's committeesAn email when their committees meet and decide
82%meetings attended155 of 189 since 2016, apologies 19
47times in the minutesAsked 1, said 12, moved 2, seconded 5
27recorded votes at their meetingsTheir own vote is named only where the minutes list it
1declarations at meetingsInterests declared on agenda items
5committees in the last year1 as Chair or Vice-Chair

On the record

Every time Welwyn Hatfield's minutes name Councillor Broach, as the council published it.

Named6 Feb 2026Council

Appoint to Leader of the Council

Councillor Broach nominated, and Councillor Moore seconded, Councillor Grewal as Leader of the Council.
From the council's minutes: Council, 6 Feb 2026, item 81Open the meeting
Named19 May 2025Council

Confirmation of the Cabinet and Appointment to Committees 2025/26

He thanked the panellists for their time and made special mention to Councillor Broach and applauded his recovery and presence back in the Chamber and also thanked him for all the work that he had put into the Cabinet before. He thanked the Cabinet for agreeing to another year.
From the council's minutes: Council, 19 May 2025, item 28Open the meeting
Named19 May 2025Council

Confirmation of the Cabinet and Appointment to Committees 2025/26

Councillor Kingsbury echoed the welcome of Councillor Broach back to the Chamber. He stated he was pleased to put forward his nominations to the committees. He said achieving the right balance took time and was sure the other group leaders would agree.
From the council's minutes: Council, 19 May 2025, item 28Open the meeting
Named25 Feb 2025Council

Council Tax Setting 2025/26

·            Councillor Broach was thanked for his work on the budget.
From the council's minutes: Council, 25 Feb 2025, item 3Open the meeting
Named4 Feb 2025Cabinet

Appointments of cabinet panels and outside body

Councillor Kieran Thorpe to replace Councillor Broach on the Hatfield Community Sports Fund Board.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 4 Feb 2025, item 362Open the meeting
Named4 Feb 2025Cabinet

Appointments of cabinet panels and outside body

Due to the health condition of Councillor James Broach, it is proposed that a new representative is nominated on the Hatfield Community Sports Fund Board.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 4 Feb 2025, item 362Open the meeting
Named3 Feb 2025Council

Announcements

We wish her well at this difficult time I would like to wish Councillor Broach a speedy recovery on behalf of the Council.” The Chief Executive made the following announcement:
From the council's minutes: Council, 3 Feb 2025, item 140Open the meeting
Named3 Feb 2025Council

Review of political proportionality & cabinet portfolio update

Members took the opportunity to thank Councillor Broach for his work and welcomed Councillor Scott to the Cabinet.
From the council's minutes: Council, 3 Feb 2025, item 145Open the meeting
Named21 Jan 2025Cabinet

Announcement from the Leader of the Council

The Leader of the Council thanked Councillor Broach for his work as the Executive Member (Resources), and announced Councillor Scott would take on the portfolio for Executive Member (Finance).
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 21 Jan 2025, item 350Open the meeting
Named21 Jan 2025Cabinet

FP2093 Budget Proposals and Medium Term Forecasts 2025/26

·          Councillor Broach was thanked for his efforts to produce the budget.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 21 Jan 2025, item 353aOpen the meeting
Named3 Dec 2024Cabinet

FP2104 University of Hertfordshire Campus Masterplan

At this point in the meeting Councillor Broach and Thorpe left the room.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 3 Dec 2024, item 331bOpen the meeting
Said20 May 2024Council

Member Development Annual Report

Councillor Broach thanked members of the Member Development Steering Group for their work over the year and officers for their work.
From the council's minutes: Council, 20 May 2024, item 93Open the meeting
Seconded13 Mar 2024Council

FP2005 Street Trading Policy

It was moved and seconded by Councillor Broach and Panter.
From the council's minutes: Council, 13 Mar 2024, item 81Open the meeting
Seconded13 Mar 2024Council

Constitution Updates

It was moved and seconded by Councillor Broach and Zukowskyj.
From the council's minutes: Council, 13 Mar 2024, item 82Open the meeting
Seconded13 Mar 2024Council

2024/2025 Pay Statement

Section 38(1) of the Localism Act 2011 requires English local authorities to produce a Pay Policy Statement for each financial year It was moved and seconded by Councillor Broach and Jones.
From the council's minutes: Council, 13 Mar 2024, item 83Open the meeting
Seconded5 Feb 2024Council

Schedule of Meetings 2024/25

It was moved and seconded by Councillor Broach and Councillor Panter that the recommendations in the report be approved.
From the council's minutes: Council, 5 Feb 2024, item 67Open the meeting
Declared4 Dec 2023Development Management Committee

Declarations of interest by members

Councillor Broach declared an interest in agenda item 7 as the Councillor that called in the application, and noted he would leave the Chamber during the discussions and vote.
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 4 Dec 2023, item 105Open the meeting
Seconded4 Dec 2023Development Management Committee

6/2022/1355/maj former beales hotel, comet way, hatfield, al10 9ng

In the circumstances, it is recommended by officers that the item is deferred to the next meeting of the Development Management Committee to allow an opportunity for comments to be made.” Councillor Hellyer proposed, and Councillor Broach seconded, that the item be deferred. RESOLVED (unanimous) The Committee agreed to defer the item to a future meeting of the Committee.
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 4 Dec 2023, item 106Open the meeting
Named4 Dec 2023Development Management Committee

6/2023/0775/full long arm and short arm, 18 lemsford village, lemsford, welwyn garden city, al8 7tn6

The application was presented to the Development Management Committee because Councillor Broach had called-in the application. The reasons for the call-in were set out in the report.
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 4 Dec 2023, item 107Open the meeting
Named15 Nov 2023Council

Notices of motions under procedure rule 16

Report Back to Council: Present the findings, community feedback, transition plan, and any recommendations to the council for further deliberation, modifications if necessary, and final approval within 6 months.” The following amendment to the motion was submitted by Councillor Broach and was seconded by Councillor Bonfante “We are all aware of the pressures on council finances. As we strive to optimise our resources, it has become evident that there is a significant opportunity to enhance efficiency, reduce costs, and streamline our operations through a transition from elections by thirds to all-out elections.
From the council's minutes: Council, 15 Nov 2023, item 47Open the meeting
Moved15 Nov 2023Council

Cabinet Panels

It was moved by Councillor Broach and seconded by Councillor Zukowskyj.
From the council's minutes: Council, 15 Nov 2023, item 48Open the meeting
Moved15 Nov 2023Council

Faith Covenant

It was moved by Councillor Broach, and seconded by Councillor Siewniak. During the discussions, Councillor J.Boulton declared an interest in the item due to his employer and left the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Council, 15 Nov 2023, item 49Open the meeting
Said11 Jul 2023Cabinet

Capital Outturn 2022/23 (Forward Plan Reference FP1173)

During this item Councillor Broach requested that progress be made on the £1m re-phasing of Angerland Football and Rugby Schemes.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 11 Jul 2023, item 113cOpen the meeting
Named15 Jun 2023Development Management Committee

Substitutions

·        Cllr Lucy Musk for Cllr James Broach ·        Cllr Adrienne Nix for Cllr Frank Marsh ·        Cllr Julie Cragg for Cllr Samuel Kasumu ·        Cllr Alastair Hellyer for Cllr Rebecca Lass
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 15 Jun 2023, item 68Open the meeting
Named5 Dec 2019Development Management Committee

20 roe green close, hatfield, al10 9pe - 6/2019/2002/house - erection of part single, part two storey rear extension following demolition of existing conservatory and erection of single storey side porch

This application was presented to the Development Management Committee because Hatfield Town Council had submitted a Major Objection and Councillor James Broach had called-in the application.
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 5 Dec 2019, item 78Open the meeting
Named5 Dec 2019Development Management Committee

20 roe green close, hatfield, al10 9pe - 6/2019/2002/house - erection of part single, part two storey rear extension following demolition of existing conservatory and erection of single storey side porch

The reason Councillor James Broach had called-in this application was as follows:
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 5 Dec 2019, item 78Open the meeting
Named26 Sep 2019Council

Question to the Leader from Councillor James Broach

As the uncertainties around Brexit become clearer we hope we are of course ready to use the money which has been allocated by central government as required.” Councillor Broach in a supplementary question said that as the Government had already allocated £4bn to Brexit does Councillor Kingsbury agree with him that it is madness to see local government spending being slashed whilst at the same time watching the same government finding huge wads of cash to use on making a pig’s ear of Brexit?
From the council's minutes: Council, 26 Sep 2019, item 26bOpen the meeting
Named5 Sep 2019Development Management Committee

55 bishops rise, hatfield, al10 9bx - 6/2019/0814/full - erection of 1 x two bedroom dwelling

This application was presented to the Committee because Councillor Broach had called it in:- ‘I would like to call this application in to DMC, however I am happy for this to be refused under delegated powers if applicable. My reasons for the call in are as follows:
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 5 Sep 2019, item 44Open the meeting
Named28 Feb 2019Development Management Committee

11 and 11a holly close, hatfield, al10 9jb - 6/2018/2968/full - conversion of existing 6-bedroom dwelling at 11 holly close into two self-contained 2-bedroom flats

The application had been presented to Development Management Committee because Councillor James Broach had called-in the application and Hatfield Town Council had responded with a major objection.
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 28 Feb 2019, item 109Open the meeting
Named6 Dec 2018Development Management Committee

1 roe green close, hatfield, al10 9pd - 6/2018/1933/full - erection of 8 flats and creation of car parking and amenity space following demolition of existing dwellinghouse

The application had been presented to the Development Management Committee because Councillor Broach had called-in the application:
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 6 Dec 2018, item 77Open the meeting
Named19 Nov 2018Council

Question to the Leader from Councillor James Broach

this means that we will not only be in a position to effectively administer the increase in licences but also undertake targeted proactive investigations into Landlords who fail to licence their properties and take formal action where appropriate.”   Councillor Broach in a supplementary question said it was good to hear so many landlords were signing up and noting that there were not lots of applications coming through for HMOs on the planning weekly list, asked if the call-in rules for Members had changed?
From the council's minutes: Council, 19 Nov 2018, item 44bOpen the meeting
Said19 Jul 2018Development Management Committee

11 elm drive, hatfield, al10 8nr - 6/2018/1061/house - erection of first floor extension above existing ground floor extension

I have been contacted by local residents with concerns over this, and considering similar previous applications have been refused, if this intended to be approved it should be determined by the DMC committee.” Hatfield Town Councillor James Broach spoke against the application reiterating Hatfield Town Council’s objections:
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 19 Jul 2018, item 29Open the meeting
Said1 Mar 2018Development Management Committee

36 salisbury square, hatfield, al9 5af - 6/2017/1902/full - change of use of ground floor from sui-generis to residential (c3) to include the creation of 2no 1-bedroom and 3no 2-bedroom flats with external alterations including new fenestra

Hatfield Town Councillor James Broach spoke against the application, raising concerns about the loss of vital services, such as the Job Centre, and the resulting impact on the economic needs of the area. In addition, he also raised concerns about the noise of the main road and railway.
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 1 Mar 2018, item 120Open the meeting
Said1 Mar 2018Development Management Committee

36 salisbury square, hatfield, al9 5af - 6/2017/1903/full - erection of 4no front, 4no rear and 2no side dormer windows, 5no front and 5no rear roof-lights to facilitate conversion of roof, to include the creation of 2no 1-bedroom and 2no 2

Hatfield Town Councillor James Broach spoke against the application, stating that it was overdevelopment of the site and would set a precedent for converting commercial space to residential. He raised additional concerns about the noise, lack of green space and parking for residents. A discussion followed which in the main acknowledged that a roof conversion would have minimal impact on the economic vitality of the town.
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 1 Mar 2018, item 121Open the meeting
Said1 Feb 2018Development Management Committee

111 the ryde, hatfield, al9 5dp - 6/2016/0900/full - change of use to sui-generis large house in multiple occupation (hmo) for up to 9 occupants

[name removed], objector spoke against the application Hatfield Town Councillor James Broach spoke against the application and objected to the change of use of a family home to a large HMO, which was out of keeping in the area and would have a detrimental impact on the amenity of the residents of the neighbouring properties and the occupiers of the house itself.
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 1 Feb 2018, item 112Open the meeting
Said7 Dec 2017Development Management Committee

98-102 great north road, hatfield al9 5db - 6/2017/1194/maj - erection of 24 retirement living units (category ii sheltered housing) with associated communal facilities, car parking and landscaping following the demolition of existing buildings

Hatfield Town Councillor James Broach spoke against the application.
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 7 Dec 2017, item 82Open the meeting
Named7 Dec 2017Development Management Committee

11 and 11a holly close hatfield al10 9jb - 6/2017/2064/full - conversion of existing 6-bedroom dwelling at 11 holly close into two self-contained 2-bedroom flats

The reason that the application had been presented to the Development Management Committee was because Councillor James Broach has called it in for the following reason:
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 7 Dec 2017, item 83Open the meeting
Said9 Nov 2017Development Management Committee

Plot 6000 land adjacent to porsche garage hatfield avenue hatfield business park hatfield al10 9ua - 6/2017/0550/maj - erection of a 75 bed elderly care home development (c2) with 24 parking bays and associated landscaping

Hatfield Town Councillor James Broach spoke against the application.
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 9 Nov 2017, item 73Open the meeting
Asked11 Sep 2017Council

Question to the Leader from Councillor James Broach

I would strongly dispute any claim that Hatfield Town Centre is falling apart.”   Councillor Broach asked about the panel of glass which fell out of the arcade and in response the Leader advised that repairs had been carried out under the manufacturer’s warranty and to ensure that it did not happen again. This was safety glass which was dealt with quickly and the arcade re-opened in twenty-four hours.
From the council's minutes: Council, 11 Sep 2017, item 27aOpen the meeting
Said17 Aug 2017Development Management Committee

23 PARK STREET, HATFIELD, AL9 5AT - 6/2016/2339/FULL - CHANGE OF USE FROM RESTAURANT (A3) TO RESIDENTIAL (C3) AND THE ERECTION OF SINGLE STOREY AND FIRST FLOOR REAR EXTENSION AND SUBDIVISION INTO FOUR FLATS (2 x 1 BEDROOM FLATS AND 2 X 2 BEDROOM FLATS)

Hatfield Town Councillor James Broach spoke against the application.
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 17 Aug 2017, item 39Open the meeting
Named25 May 2017Development Management Committee

11 and 11a holly close hatfield al10 9jb - 6/2017/0090/full - conversion of existing dwelling at 11 holly close into two self contained 2-bed flats and extension of front porch

Reason for Committee Consideration The application is presented to Development Management Committee because Councillor James Broach has called it in for the following reason:
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 25 May 2017, item 10Open the meeting
Named27 Apr 2017Development Management Committee

23 PARK STREET, HATFIELD, AL9 5AT - 6/2016/2339/FULL - CHANGE OF USE FROM RESTAURANT (A3) TO RESIDENTIAL (C3) AND THE ERECTION OF SINGLE STOREY AND FIRST FLOOR REAR EXTENSION AND SUBDIVISION INTO FOUR FLATS (2 x 1 BEDROOM FLATS AND 2 X 2 BEDROOM FLATS)

Reason for Committee Consideration The application was presented to the Development Management Committee because Councillor Broach has called it in for the following reasons:
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 27 Apr 2017, item 161Open the meeting
Said27 Apr 2017Development Management Committee

13 deerswood avenue hatfield al10 8rx - 6/2016/2123/full - erection of porch, single storey rear extension, conversion of dwelling house into 1 x 1bedroom flat and 1 x 2 bedroom flat involving demolition of exisitng garden shed and relocation of shared garden shed

Hatfield Town Councillor James Broach spoke against the application.
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 27 Apr 2017, item 162Open the meeting
Said13 Oct 2016Development Management Committee

Comet hatfield, st albans road west, hatfield, al10 9rh - 6/2016/1740/lb - extension and refurbishment of the grade ii listed building (use class c1) following demolition of existing rear and side extensions

Hatfield Town Councillor James Broach spoke against the application.
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 13 Oct 2016, item 76Open the meeting
Named12 Sep 2016Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Actions update

Councillor Broach and the Head of Public Health and Protection undertook to work together on the problem at the Energy Centre.
From the council's minutes: Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 12 Sep 2016, item 18Open the meeting
Named12 Sep 2016Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Actions update

That Councillor Broach and the Head of Public Health and Protection work together on the smells being emitted from the Energy Centre at the University of Hertfordshire.
From the council's minutes: Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 12 Sep 2016, item 18Open the meeting
Said21 Jul 2016Development Management Committee

1 mulberry mead, hatfield, al10 9eh - 6/2016/0878 - first floor side extension, loft conversion including roof lights, conversion of garage and erection of a garden shed

Councillor J Broach (Hatfield Town Council) spoke against the application.
From the council's minutes: Development Management Committee, 21 Jul 2016, item 35Open the meeting

Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.

Votes at their meetings

Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Broach attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.

DateMeetingItemTheir voteResultCount
16 Sep 2026CouncilPlanning committees and the national scheme of delegation: constitutional updatesCarried29 for, 0 against, 15 abstained
6 Feb 2026CouncilFP2191 Budget Proposals and Medium-Term Forecasts 2026/27Lost8 for, 27 against, 0 abstained
6 Feb 2026CouncilFP2191 Budget Proposals and Medium-Term Forecasts 2026/27Carried35 for, 0 against, 0 abstained
6 Feb 2026CouncilFP2191 Budget Proposals and Medium-Term Forecasts 2026/27Carried6 for, 0 against, 29 abstained
18 Sep 2024CouncilConstitution ReviewCarriedUnanimous
12 Sep 2024Development Management CommitteeApologies & substitutionsCarriedUnanimous
13 Mar 2024CouncilConstitution UpdatesCarriedUnanimous
5 Feb 2024CouncilFP2014 2024/25 Budget and Council Tax SettingLost17 for, 25 against
5 Feb 2024CouncilFP2014 2024/25 Budget and Council Tax SettingLost17 for, 25 against
5 Feb 2024CouncilFP2014 2024/25 Budget and Council Tax SettingCarried24 for, 17 against
5 Feb 2024CouncilSpecial Responsibility AllowanceCarried36 for, 0 against
23 May 2022CouncilAppointment of section 151 chief finance officerCarriedUnanimous
17 Mar 2021CouncilThe following motion has been submitted by Councillor M.Cowan and was seconded by Councillor S.Elam:-CarriedUnanimous
17 Mar 2021CouncilThe following motion has been submitted by Councillor M.Cowan and was seconded by Councillor S.Elam:-CarriedUnanimous
23 Nov 2020CouncilThe following motion has been submitted by Councillor G.Hayes and was seconded by Councillor K.Thorpe:-CarriedUnanimous
20 Jul 2020CouncilThe following motion has been submitted by Councillor M.Cowan and was seconded by Councillor P.Zukowskyj:-CarriedUnanimous
12 Nov 2019Environment Overview and Scrutiny CommitteeFlats recyclingCarriedUnanimous
26 Sep 2019CouncilHousing, Homelessness and Rough Steeping Strategy 2019-2024CarriedUnanimous
4 Feb 2019CouncilThe following motion had been submitted by Councillor S.Elam and was seconded by Councillor M.Cowan:-CarriedUnanimous
9 Jul 2018CouncilQuestion to the Leader from Councillor K.ThorpeCarriedUnanimous
9 Jul 2018CouncilThe following motion had been submitted by Councillor P.Zukowskyj and seconded by Councillor S.Elam:-CarriedUnanimous
26 Mar 2018Environment Overview and Scrutiny CommitteeEnvironment services (quarter 2 & 3) 2017/18CarriedUnanimous
26 Mar 2018Environment Overview and Scrutiny CommitteeEnvironment services (quarter 2 & 3) 2017/18CarriedUnanimous
5 Feb 2018CouncilThe following motion was submitted by Councillor M.Cowan and seconded by Councillor H.QuenetCarriedUnanimous
21 Nov 2016CouncilThe following motion was submitted by Councillor M.Cowan and seconded by Councillor H.Quenet:-Lost20 for, 25 against
3 Oct 2016CouncilNotices of motions under procedure rule 49CarriedUnanimous
11 Jul 2016CouncilNotices of motions under procedure rule 49CarriedUnanimous
Hover an item for the minutes' own words. Most councils record the count, not each councillor's vote.

Attendance

Meetings Councillor Broach was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.

Council
63 of 75
Development Management Committee
38 of 47
Cabinet
17 of 22
Audit Committee
5 of 6
Cabinet Planning and Parking Panel
3 of 4
Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee
21 of 21
Welwyn Hatfield Highways Liaison Meeting
0 of 5
Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee
5 of 5
Standards Committee
2 of 2
Development Consultation Forum
0 of 1
Overview and Scrutiny Committee
1 of 1
Last 12 monthsPresent Apologies Absent
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov

Present at 17 of 21 meetings in the last 12 months.

Declarations of interest

What Councillor Broach declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.

DateWhereWhat the minutes sayWhat happened
4 Dec 2023Development Management Committee, item 105Councillor Broach declared an interest in agenda item 7 as the Councillor that called in the application, and noted he would leave the Chamber during the discussions and vote.
Hover a line for the full wording.

Committees and roles

Where Councillor Broach sits, from the attendance records.

CommitteeRoleSinceMeetingsNext meeting
CouncilCommittee MemberMar 20167523 Nov 2026
Development Management CommitteeVice-ChairmanJul 20164726 Nov 2026
CabinetCommittee MemberJan 2017221 Dec 2026
Audit CommitteeCommittee MemberJun 2018615 Dec 2026
Cabinet Planning and Parking PanelCommittee MemberJun 2026424 Nov 2026
Environment Overview and Scrutiny CommitteeCommittee MemberApr 201621
Welwyn Hatfield Highways Liaison MeetingCommittee MemberOct 20185
Resources Overview and Scrutiny CommitteeCommittee MemberJun 20195
Standards CommitteeCommittee MemberJun 20222
Development Consultation ForumCommittee MemberOct 20171
Overview and Scrutiny CommitteeGuestJan 20231
Committees with no meeting in the last year are shown faded.

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies