CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
People/West Suffolk/Councillor Andrew Smith
AS

Councillor Andrew Smith

West Suffolk CouncilBardwell wardConservativeCouncillor since 2016
Chair of Development Control Committee / Conservative Group Chair and Deputy LeaderChair, Development Control Committee
Follow Councillor Smith's committeesAn email when their committees meet and decide
93%meetings attended230 of 247 since 2016, apologies 5
92times in the minutesAsked 2, said 19, moved 10, seconded 15
5recorded votes at their meetingsTheir own vote is named only where the minutes list it
8declarations at meetingsLeft the room for 1 item
3committees in the last year1 as Chair or Vice-Chair

On the record

Every time West Suffolk's minutes name Councillor Smith, as the council published it.

Declared5 Aug 2026Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/25/0980/FUL - Land South of Knox Lane, Bardwell (Report No: DEV/WS/26/024)

(Councillor Andrew Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he was a Member of Bardwell Parish Council, who had previously considered the application. However, he stressed that he had not taken part in the Parish Council's vote on the item.
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 5 Aug 2026, item 14Open the meeting
Named5 Aug 2026Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/25/0980/FUL - Land South of Knox Lane, Bardwell (Report No: DEV/WS/26/024)

He would therefore consider the matter with an open mind.) Planning application - installation and operation of a 42MW ground mounted Solar Farm with substation, CCTV, boundary fence, equipment, landscaping and necessary grid connection infrastructure This application was referred to the Development Control Committee due to the Ward Member Councillor Andrew Smith (Bardwell) formally calling the application in due to the level of public interest.
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 5 Aug 2026, item 14Open the meeting
Said5 Aug 2026Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/25/0980/FUL - Land South of Knox Lane, Bardwell (Report No: DEV/WS/26/024)

Speakers:     Tony Cooke (Bardwell resident objector on behalf of himself and a group of fellow resident objectors) spoke against the application Councillor Karen Witton (Vice Chair, Bardwell Parish Council) spoke against the application Councillor Andrew Smith (Ward Member: Bardwell) spoke on the application Simon Betts (agent for applicant) spoke in support of the application (On conclusion of the public speaking the Chair permitted a short comfort break.) Councillor Rachel Hood opened the debate and queried the temporary (40 years) nature of the application and the subsequent decommissioning of the site, particularly if the ownership of the  ...  view the full minutes text for item 14.
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 5 Aug 2026, item 14Open the meeting
Named16 Jul 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Transport and Infrastructure Task and Finish Group Recommendations (Report No: OAS/WS/26/010)

The Chair gave thanks to the Members who had sat on the Task and Finish Group, in particular Councillor Andrew Smith who had chaired the group and who addressed the meeting in that capacity alongside the Cabinet Member for Planning.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 16 Jul 2026, item 82Open the meeting
Moved16 Jul 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Transport and Infrastructure Task and Finish Group Recommendations (Report No: OAS/WS/26/010)

It was proposed by Councillor Andrew Smith, duly seconded by Councillor Phil Wittam and with the vote being unanimous, it was
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 16 Jul 2026, item 82Open the meeting
Asked16 Jul 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Suffolk County Council Suffolk Police and Crime Panel: Meeting of 20 March 2026 (Report No: OAS/WS/26/014)

During the discussion of this item, Councillor Andrew Smith asked for advice in reaching out to the Police and Crime Commissioner in relation to the ongoing situation at RAF Barnham.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 16 Jul 2026, item 86Open the meeting
Named3 Jun 2026Development Control Committee

Election of Chair 2026/2027

Councillor Jon London nominated Councillor Andrew Smith as Chair and Councillor Smith accepted the nomination.
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 3 Jun 2026, item 634Open the meeting
Declared29 Apr 2026Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/23/0600/FUL - Former St James Ceva Middle School, The Vinefields, Bury St Edmunds (Report No DEV/WS/26/016)

(Councillor Andrew Smith declared a, non-pecuniary, Other Registerable Interest (ORI) in this item in light of the fact that he was Treasurer of Friends of Bardwell Church and a full member of the Bardwell Parochial Church Council, the parish of which came under the St Edmundsbury and Ipswich Diocese who are the applicant, he therefore asked that this be noted in the interests of transparency.) Planning application a. Partial demolition of existing school buildings b. Conversion of three buildings to 14 residential dwellings c.
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 29 Apr 2026, item 633Open the meeting
Declared1 Apr 2026Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/25/2035/FUL & Listed Building Consent DC/25/2036/LB - St Marys Church, Crown Street, Bury St Edmunds (Report No DEV/WS/26/014)

(Councillor Andrew Smith declared a, non-pecuniary, Other Registerable Interest (ORI) in this item in light of the fact that he was Treasurer of Friends of Bardwell Church, the parish of which came under the St Edmundsbury and Ipswich Diocese as did the application site, he therefore asked that this be noted in the interests of transparency.) Planning application - resurfacing works to the pathway along St Marys Church Application for Listed Building Consent - resurfacing works to pathway These applications had been referred to the Development Control Committee because West Suffolk Council was the applicant.
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 1 Apr 2026, item 626Open the meeting
Said24 Mar 2026Council

Community Governance Review

Councillor Andrew Smith, ward member for Bardwell, informed Council that Honington cum Sapiston and Fakenham Magna were both located within his ward. He paid tribute to the commitment and efforts of local parish councillors in seeking to improve their communities and expressed his support for the draft recommendations set out in Appendix A relating to these two particular parishes.
From the council's minutes: Council, 24 Mar 2026, item 523Open the meeting
Said6 Nov 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Appointments to Outside Scrutiny Bodies - Suffolk Health Scrutiny Committee (Report No: OAS/WS/25/019)

Prior to the discussion on this item Councillor Andrew Smith advised the Committee that he was formally advising them of his resignation as the substitute Member appointed to the Health Scrutiny Committee. Meaning West Suffolk Council therefore had no appointed representative on the body and the Committee would need to appoint both a full and substitute Member.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 6 Nov 2025, item 47Open the meeting
Named6 Nov 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Cabinet Decisions Plan: 1 November 2025 to 31 May 2026 (Report No: OAS/WS/25/022)

The Chair thanked Councillor Andrew Smith for all his efforts on the topic and invited him to brief the Committee on Cabinet’s recent consideration of the Rural Buses review.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 6 Nov 2025, item 50Open the meeting
Said6 Nov 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Scrutiny Work Programme Update (Report No: OAS/WS/25/023)

Councillor Andrew Smith advised the meeting that new local plan guidance was due to be issued to the Council, in connection with the new plan to be produced, by the end of the calendar year. He therefore asked if the Cabinet Member for Planning could be invited to March’s meeting of the Committee to enable Members to be briefed on the guidance. It was agreed that an invitation would be extended to the Cabinet Member for the meeting on 5 March 2026.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 6 Nov 2025, item 51Open the meeting
Named4 Nov 2025Cabinet

Open forum

Councillor Andrew Smith (Ward Member for Bardwell) Councillor Smith addressed the Cabinet and outlined the work which had been undertaken by “The Save Our Buses Task Force”, which had been established by 13 local parish communities to the north-east of Bury St Edmunds, following notification that their bus services would be severely curtailed and, in some places, stopped altogether. This had resulted in a successful bid for two bus services (73 and 73A) being funded for two years. The Task Force continued to explore innovative solutions to ensure the long term sustainable and commercial viability of bus services for local communities.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 4 Nov 2025, item 747Open the meeting
Named4 Nov 2025Cabinet

Rural Bus Review

He also thanked Councillor Andrew Smith and the Bardwell Taskforce for their support around rural bus provision.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 4 Nov 2025, item 751Open the meeting
Named14 Oct 2025Council

Motions on notice

Councillor Andrew Smith duly seconded the motion and reserved his right to speak later in the debate.
From the council's minutes: Council, 14 Oct 2025, item 478Open the meeting
Named11 Sep 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee

West Suffolk House - Audio Visual System (Report No: OAS/WS/25/014)

Members were reminded that Councillor Andrew Smith had raised this topic at the meeting of the Committee on 6 March 2025 and had subsequently completed a scrutiny work programme suggestion form which generated the production of this report to the Committee.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 11 Sep 2025, item 34Open the meeting
Said11 Sep 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee

West Suffolk House - Audio Visual System (Report No: OAS/WS/25/014)

Councillor Andrew Smith addressed the meeting and stated that he had completed the work programme suggestion form as a result of difficulties experienced with the system at meetings such as full Council and Development Control Committee. However, he was pleased to report that a number of issues had now been resolved and the operation at meetings was much better.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 11 Sep 2025, item 34Open the meeting
Named4 Jun 2025Development Control Committee

Election of Chair 2025/2026

Councillor Jon London nominated Councillor Andrew Smith as Chair and Councillor Smith accepted the nomination.
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 4 Jun 2025, item 541Open the meeting
Named20 May 2025Cabinet

Open forum

Councillor Andrew Smith ( Ward Member for Bardwell) Councillor Smith made his statement and referred to the proposed changes to the Locality Budget. He explained that the report recognised that many rural communities had their own community assets, most of which were managed by Parish Council or local community groups and that some of these assets were in need of significant capital investment.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 20 May 2025, item 690Open the meeting
Named20 May 2025Cabinet

Report of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee: 6 March 2025

(paragraph 2.4.3) The request from Councillor Andrew Smith to scrutinise the Council’s newly installed audio visual (AV) equipment was due to be considered by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee on 11 September 2025.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 20 May 2025, item 692Open the meeting
Seconded6 Mar 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Suffolk County Council: Health Scrutiny Committee - 22 January 2025

Detailed discussions were held on Suffolk’s Primary Care Estate, in particular the health facilities in Haverhill and questioned how health monies were allocated and spent and what the difference was between Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) and s106 funding At the conclusion of the discussions it was proposed by Councillor Tony Brown, seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith, and with the vote being unanimous, it was RESOLVED :
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 6 Mar 2025, item 7Open the meeting
Named6 Mar 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Work programme update 2025

Councillor Andrew Smith wished to raise concerns he was experiencing as the Chair of the Development Control Committee with the Council’s newly installed audio visual (AV) equipment and the livestreaming of meetings, for example with microphones cutting out, and felt that there should be some form of scrutiny on what had been purchased; the cost; and the Service Level Agreement with the supplier. Discussions then took place on the suggested topic.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 6 Mar 2025, item 10Open the meeting
Named6 Mar 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Work programme update 2025

At the conclusion of the discussion, it was agreed that Councillor Andrew Smith would complete a suggestion form inviting the relevant Portfolio Holder to its next meeting setting out the spend, the contract with the supplier and the Service Level Agreement.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 6 Mar 2025, item 10Open the meeting
Named6 Mar 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Work programme update 2025

There being no decision required, the Committee noted the update, and that Councillor Andrew Smith would complete the suggestion for inviting the relevant Portfolio Holder to its next meeting to discuss the Council’s AV equipment.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 6 Mar 2025, item 10Open the meeting
Named4 Feb 2025Cabinet

Open forum

Councillor Andrew Smith (Ward Member for Bardwell) Councillor Smith made a statement in support of the recommendations put forward by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee following its review of rural bus service provision in West Suffolk.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 4 Feb 2025, item 660Open the meeting
Named4 Feb 2025Cabinet

Report of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee: 16 December 2024

This review, which was held at Stanton Community Village Hall, was well attended and comprised several witnesses that provided evidence and added value to the review (see minute 664. below for further detail.) Councillor Broughton thanked Councillor Andrew Smith for submitting the ‘suggestion for scrutiny’ which had led to the extensive and thorough review.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 4 Feb 2025, item 663Open the meeting
Named4 Feb 2025Cabinet

Recommendations of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee: 16 December 2024 - Review of rural buses in West Suffolk

Following acceptance by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee to include a ‘suggestion for scrutiny’ put forward by Councillor Andrew Smith to look at ‘rural bus service provision’ and the impacts that a reduction in service would have on rural communities, the review was held on 16 December 2024 at Stanton Community Village Hall.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 4 Feb 2025, item 664Open the meeting
Named16 Dec 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Review of Rural Buses in West Suffolk

-       West Suffolk Council Ward Members, Councillor Mike Chester, Councillor Carol Bull The Chair explained that the Committee on 7 November 2024 agreed to include a suggestion put forward by Councillor Andrew Smith to look at “rural bus service provision” and the impacts that a reduction in services had on rural communities. The Committee also agreed the scoping document and key lines of enquiry for the review.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 16 Dec 2024, item 321Open the meeting
Said16 Dec 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Review of Rural Buses in West Suffolk

Councillor Andrew Smith then addressed the Committee as follows. He explained that in July 2024, multiple parish communities to the northeast of Bury St Edmunds were informed that bus services would be significantly reduced or, in some cases, stopped altogether.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 16 Dec 2024, item 321Open the meeting
Moved7 Nov 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Planning Enforcement and Planning Appeals Update

At the conclusion of the discussions, Councillor Andrew Smith proposed the recommendations, these were duly seconded by Councillor Birgitte Mager, and with  ...  view the full minutes text for item 311.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 7 Nov 2024, item 311Open the meeting
Named7 Nov 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Work programme update and suggestion for scrutiny

Attached at Appendix 2 was the completed suggestion form submitted by Councillor Andrew Smith on rural bus services and attached at Appendix 3 the scoping document and key lines of enquiry.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 7 Nov 2024, item 314Open the meeting
Said7 Nov 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Work programme update and suggestion for scrutiny

Councillor Andrew Smith presented the suggestion form, which was supported by a number of councillors. The Committee considered the scoping document and key lines of enquiry form and asked questions.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 7 Nov 2024, item 314Open the meeting
Moved7 Nov 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Work programme update and suggestion for scrutiny

At the conclusion of the discussions, Councillor Andrew Smith proposed the recommendations, which were duly seconded by Councillor Kevin Yarrow, and with the vote being unanimous, it was RESOLVED , that the Committee 1)    Noted the update on topics currently scheduled for 2025.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 7 Nov 2024, item 314Open the meeting
Named5 Nov 2024Cabinet

Report of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee: 12 September 2024

In addition, the Committee would be considering a ‘suggestion for scrutiny’ submitted by Councillor Andrew Smith, who wished the Committee to investigate ‘rural bus service provision’ and the impacts a reduction in service would have on rural communities. If supported by the Committee, it was anticipated that the Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting already scheduled for 16 January 2025 be moved to 16 December 2024 so that the Committee may consider the issue prior to the upcoming change to the Simmonds bus schedule. It was being proposed that this meeting be held in Stanton, which was one of the communities affected by the changes to the Simmonds 73 and 73A bus routes.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 5 Nov 2024, item 628Open the meeting
Named17 Sep 2024Cabinet

Open forum

Councillor Andrew Smith (Ward Member for Bardwell) Councillor Andrew Smith made a statement in connection with Agenda Item 11 (Simpler Recycling and Refuse Collections) which was to be considered by the Cabinet later on the agenda.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 17 Sep 2024, item 606Open the meeting
Said12 Sep 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Work programme update

Councillor Andrew Smith suggested the Committee looks at Rural Public Transport as a bus services/routes were being cancelled across West Suffolk and provided examples of villages affected, such as Bardwell and Stanton.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 12 Sep 2024, item 304Open the meeting
Named12 Sep 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Work programme update

The Democratic Services Officer would work with Councillor Andrew Smith in completing the work programme suggestion form.
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 12 Sep 2024, item 304Open the meeting
Named5 Jun 2024Development Control Committee

Election of Chair 2024/2025

Councillor Jon London nominated Councillor Andrew Smith as Chair and Councillor Smith accepted the nomination.
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 5 Jun 2024, item 443Open the meeting
Declared3 Apr 2024Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/22/2190/HYB - Land at Shepherds Grove, Bury Road, Stanton (Report No: DEV/WS/24/014)

(Councillor Andrew Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he had attended Bardwell Parish Council's meeting when the Parish Council considered the application. However, he stressed that he did not take part in the discussion or voting on the item at the Parish Council and therefore had an open mind.
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 3 Apr 2024, item 433Open the meeting
Declared6 Mar 2024Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/22/2190/HYB - Land at Shepherds Grove, Bury Road, Stanton (Report No: DEV/WS/24/008)

(Councillor Andrew Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he had attended Bardwell Parish Council's meeting when the Parish Council considered the application. However, he stressed that he did not take part in the discussion or voting on the item at the Parish Council and therefore had an open mind.
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 6 Mar 2024, item 422Open the meeting
Named22 Jan 2024West Suffolk Standards Committee

Substitutes

Councillor Andrew Smith substituting for Councillor Sara Mildmay-White
From the council's minutes: West Suffolk Standards Committee, 22 Jan 2024, item 47Open the meeting
Seconded9 Nov 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Abbeycroft Leisure Strategic Partnership Task and Finish Group- Findings and Recommendations

At the conclusion of the discussions, it was recommended by Councillor Tony Brown, duly seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith and with the vote being unanimous it was:
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 9 Nov 2023, item 254Open the meeting
Said19 Sep 2023Cabinet

Open forum

Councillor Andrew Smith (Ward Member for Bardwell) Councillor Andrew Smith addressed the Cabinet in relation to Agenda Item 11 (De-carbonisation Initiatives Fund; Report number CAB/WS/23/040).
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 19 Sep 2023, item 495Open the meeting
Moved20 Jul 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Work programme update and Suggestions for Scrutiny

It was then proposed by Councillor Andrew Smith, duly seconded by Councillor Julia Wakelam, and with the vote being unanimous:
From the council's minutes: Overview and Scrutiny Committee, 20 Jul 2023, item 233Open the meeting
Said5 Jul 2023Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/22/2078/FUL & Listed Building Consent DC/22/2079/LB - Land at Malting Row, Honington (Report No: DEV/WS/23/016)

Speakers:     Councillor Robert Williams (Chair, Honington cum Sapiston Parish Council) spoke against the application Councillor Andrew Smith (Ward Member: Bardwell) spoke on the application Mark Cleveland (agent) spoke in support of the application The Planning Officer responded to questions/comments in connection with the following topics:
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 5 Jul 2023, item 358Open the meeting
Named22 Jun 2023Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee

Substitutes

Councillor Andrew Smith substituting for Councillor Nick Clarke.
From the council's minutes: Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee, 22 Jun 2023, item 177Open the meeting
Seconded22 Jun 2023Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee

Outline Internal Audit Plan (2023 to 2024)

Councillor Karen Richardson moved the recommendation, this was duly seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith, and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
From the council's minutes: Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee, 22 Jun 2023, item 187Open the meeting
Named7 Jun 2023Development Control Committee

Election of Chair 2023/2024 and Correction to Agenda Front

Councillor Roger Dicker nominated Councillor Andrew Smith as Chair and Councillor Smith accepted the nomination.
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 7 Jun 2023, item 345Open the meeting
Named23 May 2023Council

Election of the Leader of the Council

Councillor Andrew Smith, Deputy Leader of the Conservative Group, nominated Councillor Nick Clarke. No other nominations were received.
From the council's minutes: Council, 23 May 2023, item 289Open the meeting
Named1 Jun 2022Development Control Committee

Election of Chair 2022/2023

Councillor Peter Stevens nominated Councillor Andrew Smith as Chair and this was seconded by Councillor Brian Harvey.
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 1 Jun 2022, item 237Open the meeting
Named22 Mar 2022Council

Apologies for absence

(Councillor Andrew Smith joined the meeting during the consideration of this item.)
From the council's minutes: Council, 22 Mar 2022, item 194Open the meeting
Seconded22 Feb 2022Council

Amendments to the Constitution (Report number: COU/WS/22/004)

On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
From the council's minutes: Council, 22 Feb 2022, item 188Open the meeting
Said1 Sep 2021Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/19/2155/FUL - Storage Tank, Station Yard, Station Road, Barnham (Report No: DEV/WS/21/032)

Speakers:     John Bauer (neighbouring resident) spoke against the application Councillor John Bauer (Barnham Parish Council) read out a statement on behalf of the Parish Council against the application Councillor Andrew Smith (Ward Member: Barnham) spoke on the application Jonny Rankin (agent) spoke in support of the application ([name removed] did not attend the meeting to personally address the Committee and instead the Democratic Services Officer read out a pre-prepared submitted statement on his behalf.) Considerable discussion took place on the application, with Members posing a number of questions to the Senior Planning Officer who responded in respect of; the history of operation on the site, surface water drainage, the other businesses operating at the Gorse Industrial Estate and the Traffic Regulation Order in place on the adjacent highway.
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 1 Sep 2021, item 171Open the meeting
Named23 Jun 2021Development Control Committee

Election of Chair 2021/2022

Councillor Carol Bull nominated Councillor Andrew Smith as Chair and this was seconded by Councillor Mike Chester.
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 23 Jun 2021, item 132Open the meeting
Seconded23 Feb 2021Council

West Suffolk Planning Code of Practice (Report number: COU/WS/21/004)

On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 57 for the motion, none against and one abstention, it was
From the council's minutes: Council, 23 Feb 2021, item 117Open the meeting
Named4 Dec 2019Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/18/0544/HYB - Land North of Green Acre, Thetford Road, Ixworth Thorpe (Report No: DEV/WS/19/047)

Speakers:     Councillor Ben Lord (Chairman, Ixworth & Ixworth Thorpe Parish Council) spoke in support of the application Councillor Andrew Smith (neighbouring Ward Member of Bardwell) read out a statement in support of the application on behalf of Ward Member ( Ixworth ) Councillor John Griffiths Phil Cobbold (agent) spoke in support of the application In response to comments made by the Committee during the debate, the Service Manager (Planning – Development) made reference to Policy DM27 and asked Members to give particular consideration to those recent appeal decisions made in connection with this policy.
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 4 Dec 2019, item 71Open the meeting
Named5 Jun 2019Development Control Committee

Election of Chair 2019/2020

Councillor Carol Bull nominated Councillor Andrew Smith as Chair and this was seconded by Councillor Andy Drummond.
From the council's minutes: Development Control Committee, 5 Jun 2019, item 1Open the meeting
Declared3 Jan 2019St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/18/1925/HH - Briar Cottage, Bury Lane, Stanton (Report No: DEV/SE/19/009)

(Councillor Andrew Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item, being familiar with the applicant having contracted him to carry out work to his own property over a year ago. He would remain within the meeting and would take part in the discussion and voting thereon.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 3 Jan 2019, item 82Open the meeting
Said18 Dec 2018Shadow Council

Referrals Report of Recommendations from the Shadow Executive (Cabinet) (Report No: COU/SA/18/015)

Councillor Andrew Smith raised a query in that the figures set out in Paragraph 1.5 of Report No: COU/SA/18/015 did not match those listed within Recommendation 1.
From the council's minutes: Shadow Council, 18 Dec 2018, item 56Open the meeting
Seconded6 Dec 2018St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/18/1507/FUL - Paltry Farm, Brand Road, Great Barton (Report No: DEV/SE/18/048)

This was duly seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 6 Dec 2018, item 69Open the meeting
Seconded6 Dec 2018St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/18/1862/FUL - Prospect House, 57 Hollands Road, Haverhill (Report No: DEV/SE/18/049)

Councillor Frank Warby moved that the application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation, and this was duly seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 6 Dec 2018, item 70Open the meeting
Moved28 Nov 2018St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee

Mid-Year Treasury Management Report and Investment Activity (April - September 2018)

Councillor Andrew Smith then moved the recommendation, this was duly seconded by Councillor Patricia Warby and with the vote being unanimous, it was RECOMMENDED:
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee, 28 Nov 2018, item 27Open the meeting
Seconded1 Nov 2018St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/18/1220/FUL - 2 & 4 Mill Road, Haverhill (Report No: DEV/SE/18/041)

This was duly seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 1 Nov 2018, item 59Open the meeting
Said4 Oct 2018St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/18/1010/FUL - Land Adjacent To Forge Cottage, Blacksmith Lane, Barnham (Report No: DEV/SE/18/038)

Speakers:     Councillor Charles Merrifield (Barnham Parish Council) spoke in support of the application Councillor Andrew Smith (Ward Member: Bardwell) spoke in support of the application [name removed] (applicant) spoke in support of the application A considerable debate took place by the Committee with Members voicing both support and opposition to the proposal.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 4 Oct 2018, item 53Open the meeting
Moved25 Jul 2018St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee

Annual Treasury Management Report 2017-2018 and Investment Activity (April - June 2018)

It was then proposed by Councillor Andrew Smith, seconded by Councillor Clive Pollington, and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee, 25 Jul 2018, item 223Open the meeting
Seconded31 May 2018St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee

Internal Audit Report (2017-2018)

Councillor Patricia Warby moved the recommendation, this was duly seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith, and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee, 31 May 2018, item 208Open the meeting
Seconded31 May 2018St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee

Outline Internal Audit Plan (2018-2019)

Members had considered report then Councillor Patricia Warby moved the recommendation, this was duly seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith, and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee, 31 May 2018, item 209Open the meeting
Asked5 Apr 2018St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/17/0688/FUL - 46 to 47, St Andrews Street South, Bury St Edmunds (Report No: DEV/SE/18/015)

Councillor Burns and Councillor Andrew Smith asked Officers as part of the deferment to consider the points raised by Suffolk County Council as Highways Authority in connection with the application; specifically in relation to their comments in their correspondence dated 2 March 2018 and their request for £15,000 to alleviate parking provision concerns.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 5 Apr 2018, item 12Open the meeting
Declared5 Apr 2018St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/17/2389/FUL - EMG Used Cars, Tayfen Road, Bury St Edmunds (Report No: DEV/SE/18/016)

(Councillor Andrew Smith declared a local non pecuniary interest in this item as he had been party to the appointment of the architect for this application for an unrelated scheme, in a capacity unrelated to the Borough Council. He would therefore remain in the meeting and take part in consideration of the application.) Planning Application - 46 no. apartments and 1 no. commercial unit (Class A1/A2/A3/B1(a) use) (Re-submission of DC/16/0730/FUL) This application was referred to the Development Control Committee because the Town Council objected to the proposal which was contrary to the Officer recommendation of approval.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 5 Apr 2018, item 13Open the meeting
Moved12 Mar 2018St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Tree Preservation Order TPO/028 (2017) - The Foundry, Old Bury Road, Stanton (Report No: DEV/SE/18/013)

Councillor Andrew Smith moved that the recommendation be approved and this was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 12 Mar 2018, item 6Open the meeting
Said1 Feb 2018St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/17/1487/FUL - Station Yard, Station Road, Barnham (Report No: DEV/SE/18/003)

Speakers:     Councillor Ed Wyer (Chairman, Barnham Parish Council) spoke against the application Councillor Andrew Smith (Ward Member: Bardwell) spoke against the application [name removed] (agent) spoke in support of the application Prior to the Chairman opening the item up for debate by the Committee, the Lawyer advising the meeting reminded Councillor Smith of the importance of not having a closed mind in respect of the proposal before Members that was seeking determination.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 1 Feb 2018, item 364Open the meeting
Said1 Feb 2018St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/17/1487/FUL - Station Yard, Station Road, Barnham (Report No: DEV/SE/18/003)

Councillor Smith acknowledged this.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 1 Feb 2018, item 364Open the meeting
Seconded31 Jan 2018St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee

Delivering a Sustainable Medium Term Financial Strategy 2018-2021

Councillor Patricia Warby moved the recommendation, this was duly seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee, 31 Jan 2018, item 197Open the meeting
Moved31 Jan 2018St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee

Treasury Management Policy Statement and Investment Strategy 2018-2019 and Treasury Management Code of Practice

It was proposed by Councillor Andrew Smith, seconded by Councillor Karen Richardson and with the vote being unanimous, it was RECOMMENDED That:
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee, 31 Jan 2018, item 202Open the meeting
Named22 Jan 2018St Edmundsbury Treasury Management Sub-Committee

Substitutes

Councillor Andrew Smith for Councillor Sarah Broughton.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Treasury Management Sub-Committee, 22 Jan 2018, item 66Open the meeting
Seconded22 Jan 2018St Edmundsbury Treasury Management Sub-Committee

Election of Chairman for the Meeting

This was duly seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith, and with the vote being unanimous, it was
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Treasury Management Sub-Committee, 22 Jan 2018, item 67Open the meeting
Seconded22 Jan 2018St Edmundsbury Treasury Management Sub-Committee

Treasury Management Report 2017-2018 and Investment Activity (1 April to 31 December 2017)

It was proposed by Councillor David Roach, seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith and with the vote being unanimous, it was RECOMMENDED That the Treasury Management Report 2017-2018, for the   period 1 April to 31 December 2017, attached as Appendix 1 to Report No: TMS/SE/18/001, be approved.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Treasury Management Sub-Committee, 22 Jan 2018, item 71Open the meeting
Seconded22 Jan 2018St Edmundsbury Treasury Management Sub-Committee

Treasury Management Policy Statement and Investment Strategy 2018-2019 and Treasury Management Code of Practice

It was proposed by Councillor David Roach, seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith and with the vote being unanimous, it was RECOMMENDED That:
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Treasury Management Sub-Committee, 22 Jan 2018, item 72Open the meeting
Moved29 Nov 2017St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee

Mid-Year Treasury Management Report and Investment Activity (April - September 2017)

Councillor Andrew Smith moved the recommendation, this was duly seconded by Councillor Betty Mclatchy and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee, 29 Nov 2017, item 186Open the meeting
Named20 Nov 2017St Edmundsbury Treasury Management Sub-Committee

Substitutes

Councillor Andrew Smith for Councillor Patricia Warby.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Treasury Management Sub-Committee, 20 Nov 2017, item 60Open the meeting
Seconded20 Nov 2017St Edmundsbury Treasury Management Sub-Committee

Mid-Year Treasury Management Report 2017-2018 and Investment Activity (1 April to 30 September 2017)

It was proposed by Councillor David Roach, seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith and with the vote being unanimous, it was RECOMMENDED:
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Treasury Management Sub-Committee, 20 Nov 2017, item 64Open the meeting
Moved20 Sep 2017St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee

West Suffolk Local Code of Corporate Governance

Councillor Andrew Smith moved the recommendation, this was duly seconded by Councillor Betty Mclatchy and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee, 20 Sep 2017, item 168Open the meeting
Said7 Sep 2017St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/17/0995/VAR - Forge Cottage, Bowbeck, Bardwell (Report No: DEV/SE/17/038)

Speakers:     Ian Wilkinson (neighbour) spoke against the application Councillor Andrew Smith (Bardwell Parish Council) spoke in support of the application* David Tomlinson (applicant) spoke in support of the application (*Whilst speaking as a member of and on behalf of the Parish Council, Councillor Smith clarified that when the Parish Council considered the application in question he personally abstained from the vote and stressed that he would maintain an open mind when considering the item.) During his address to the meeting Councillor Smith had requested, on behalf of the Parish Council, that screening options be explored with the applicant to help mitigate the impact of the solar panel’s re-siting.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 7 Sep 2017, item 348Open the meeting
Said1 Jun 2017St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/16/0788/FUL - Street Farm Barns, Low Street, Bardwell, Bury St Edmunds (Report No: DEV/SE/17/025)

Speaker:       [name removed] (agent) spoke in support of the application Councillor Andrew Smith advised the meeting that he had considered the planning application previously when it was brought before Ousden Parish Council, prior to him being elected to St Edmundsbury Borough Council.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 1 Jun 2017, item 323Open the meeting
Said1 Jun 2017St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/16/0788/FUL - Street Farm Barns, Low Street, Bardwell, Bury St Edmunds (Report No: DEV/SE/17/025)

Councillor Smith stressed that he would maintain an open mind when considering the item.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 1 Jun 2017, item 323Open the meeting
Named1 Jun 2017St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/16/0788/FUL - Street Farm Barns, Low Street, Bardwell, Bury St Edmunds (Report No: DEV/SE/17/025)

Councillor Smith also remarked upon the proactive way in which the agent had engaged with the Parish Council and gave thanks for this.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 1 Jun 2017, item 323Open the meeting
Said1 Jun 2017St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/16/0788/FUL - Street Farm Barns, Low Street, Bardwell, Bury St Edmunds (Report No: DEV/SE/17/025)

Councillor Smith raised a question with regard to boundary treatments as this was an element of the application that the Parish Council had made reference to. The Senior Planning Officer explained that conditions had been included to cover this and the Parish Council could be consulted in connection with these.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 1 Jun 2017, item 323Open the meeting
Declared3 May 2017St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Planning Application DC/17/0665/LB - Lavender Barn, Bowbeck, Bardwell (Report No: DEV/SE/17/022)

Prior to the consideration of this report Councillor Andrew Smith declared a pecuniary interest in the item, being the applicant and owner of the property in question, and left the meeting.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 3 May 2017, item 314Open the meeting
Named2 Feb 2017St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Substitutes

Councillor Andrew Smith for Councillor Paula Fox and Councillor Frank Warby for Councillor Patsy Warby.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 2 Feb 2017, item 288Open the meeting
Named5 Jan 2017St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee

Substitutes

Councillor Sara Mildmay-White for Councillor Patsy Warby and Councillor Andrew Smith for Councillor Angela Rushen.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, 5 Jan 2017, item 276Open the meeting
Named21 Nov 2016St Edmundsbury Council

Introduction

The Mayor then welcomed Councillor Andrew Smith to his first meeting of Council following his recent uncontested election to the Bardwell Ward.
From the council's minutes: St Edmundsbury Council, 21 Nov 2016, item 197Open the meeting

Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.

Votes at their meetings

Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Smith attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.

DateMeetingItemTheir voteResultCount
4 May 2022Development Control CommitteePlanning Application DC/22/0090/HH - 18 Aspal Hall Road, Beck Row (Report No: DEV/WS/22/012)Carried13 for, 3 against
4 May 2022Development Control CommitteePlanning Application DC/21/2220/HH - 29 Springfield Avenue, Bury St Edmunds (Report No: DEV/WS/22/014)Carried12 for, 4 against
19 Mar 2019St Edmundsbury CouncilPresentation of Long Service Awards (Report No: COU/SE/19/006)CarriedUnanimous
19 Mar 2019St Edmundsbury CouncilRetiring MayorCarriedUnanimous
19 Mar 2019St Edmundsbury CouncilDeputy MayorCarriedUnanimous
Hover an item for the minutes' own words. Most councils record the count, not each councillor's vote.

Attendance

Meetings Councillor Smith was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.

Development Control Committee
89 of 91
Council
43 of 52
Overview and Scrutiny Committee
18 of 20
St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee
28 of 29
St Edmundsbury Council
19 of 20
St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee
10 of 11
Shadow Council
8 of 9
Cabinet
7 of 7
St Edmundsbury Overview and Scrutiny Committee
2 of 2
St Edmundsbury Treasury Management Sub-Committee
2 of 2
West Suffolk Standards Committee
2 of 2
West Suffolk Joint Growth Steering Group
1 of 1
Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee
1 of 1
Last 12 monthsPresent Apologies Absent
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov

Present at 20 of 25 meetings in the last 12 months.

Declarations of interest

What Councillor Smith declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.

DateWhereWhat the minutes sayWhat happened
5 Aug 2026Development Control Committee, item 14(Councillor Andrew Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he was a Member of Bardwell Parish Council, who had previously considered the application. However, he stressed that he had not taken part in the Parish Council's vote on the item.
29 Apr 2026Development Control Committee, item 633(Councillor Andrew Smith declared a, non-pecuniary, Other Registerable Interest (ORI) in this item in light of the fact that he was Treasurer of Friends of Bardwell Church and a full member of the Bardwell Parochial Church Council, the parish of which came under the St Edmundsbury and Ipswich Diocese who are the applicant, he therefore asked that this be noted in the interests of transparency.) Planning application a. Partial demolition of existing school buildings b. Conversion of three buildings to 14 residential dwellings c.
1 Apr 2026Development Control Committee, item 626(Councillor Andrew Smith declared a, non-pecuniary, Other Registerable Interest (ORI) in this item in light of the fact that he was Treasurer of Friends of Bardwell Church, the parish of which came under the St Edmundsbury and Ipswich Diocese as did the application site, he therefore asked that this be noted in the interests of transparency.) Planning application - resurfacing works to the pathway along St Marys Church Application for Listed Building Consent - resurfacing works to pathway These applications had been referred to the Development Control Committee because West Suffolk Council was the applicant.
3 Apr 2024Development Control Committee, item 433(Councillor Andrew Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he had attended Bardwell Parish Council's meeting when the Parish Council considered the application. However, he stressed that he did not take part in the discussion or voting on the item at the Parish Council and therefore had an open mind.Took no part
6 Mar 2024Development Control Committee, item 422(Councillor Andrew Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he had attended Bardwell Parish Council's meeting when the Parish Council considered the application. However, he stressed that he did not take part in the discussion or voting on the item at the Parish Council and therefore had an open mind.Took no part
3 Jan 2019St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, item 82(Councillor Andrew Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item, being familiar with the applicant having contracted him to carry out work to his own property over a year ago. He would remain within the meeting and would take part in the discussion and voting thereon.
5 Apr 2018St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, item 13(Councillor Andrew Smith declared a local non pecuniary interest in this item as he had been party to the appointment of the architect for this application for an unrelated scheme, in a capacity unrelated to the Borough Council. He would therefore remain in the meeting and take part in consideration of the application.) Planning Application - 46 no. apartments and 1 no. commercial unit (Class A1/A2/A3/B1(a) use) (Re-submission of DC/16/0730/FUL) This application was referred to the Development Control Committee because the Town Council objected to the proposal which was contrary to the Officer recommendation of approval.
3 May 2017St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee, item 314Prior to the consideration of this report Councillor Andrew Smith declared a pecuniary interest in the item, being the applicant and owner of the property in question, and left the meeting.Left the room
Hover a line for the full wording.

Committees and roles

Where Councillor Smith sits, from the attendance records.

CommitteeRoleSinceMeetingsNext meeting
Development Control CommitteeChairJun 2019912 Dec 2026
CouncilCommittee MemberMay 20195215 Dec 2026
Overview and Scrutiny CommitteeCommittee MemberJun 20232019 Nov 2026
St Edmundsbury Development Control CommitteeWard MemberJan 201729
St Edmundsbury CouncilCommittee MemberOct 201620
St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny CommitteeCommittee MemberMay 201711
Shadow CouncilCommittee MemberMay 20189
CabinetGuestJun 20237
St Edmundsbury Overview and Scrutiny CommitteeGuestJan 20172
St Edmundsbury Treasury Management Sub-CommitteeSubstituteNov 20172
West Suffolk Standards CommitteeSubstituteJun 20232
West Suffolk Joint Growth Steering GroupGuestMar 20171
Performance and Audit Scrutiny CommitteeSubstituteJun 20231
Committees with no meeting in the last year are shown faded.

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies