Planning Application DC/26/0283/FUL -Development Site, Stoke Road, Clare (Report No: DEV/WS/26/022)
This was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Every time West Suffolk's minutes name Councillor Bull, as the council published it.
This was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Outline planning application - (means of main vehicular access from Hopton Road to be considered) for up to 60 dwellings This application was referred to the Development Control Committee as the local Ward Member Councillor Carol Bull (Barningham) formally called the application in. As the application was for major development, the Scheme of Delegation therefore required the application to be presented to the Development Control Committee.
Speakers: Councillor Jan Chalmers (Chair of Barningham Parish Council) spoke against the application Councillor Carol Bull (Ward Member: Barningham) spoke on the application Peter Hilldrup (agent) spoke in support of the application During the debate of this application a number of Members voiced their displeasure at the proposal being for ‘up to 60 dwellings’ when the allocation in the Local Plan was for ‘around 37 homes’.
Councillor Jim Thorndyke proposed that the planning application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation, and this was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
(Councillor Carol Bull declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that she had sat on the Licensing and Regulatory Sub-Committee who had determined the premises licence application for the site in question.) Planning application - change of use from funeral directors (Class E use) to bar and shop (sui generis use) This application was referred to the Development Control Committee following consideration by the Delegation Panel.
This was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Speaker: Andrea Mayley (applicant – West Suffolk Council) spoke in support of the application Councillor Carol Bull posed a question with regard to the temporary storage of soil and asked if there was a fixed timescale in connection with its export from the site. The Principal Planning Officer confirmed that there was no defined timescale and the applicant would need to manage the matter alongside the development of the site.
Planning application - construction of a. four poultry breeder sheds, b. administration block and, c. gatehouse with associated landscaping and infrastructure (following demolition of existing pig housing buildings) as amended by plans received 28 February 2025 This application was referred to the Development Control Committee at the request of the Ward Member for Barningham, Councillor Carol Bull, noting the significant number of local objections and interest in the application.
Speakers: Maya Pardo (on behalf of Communities Against Factory Farming) spoke against the application Councillor David Mills (Chair, Blo’ Norton Parish Council) spoke against the application Neil Gillis (speaking jointly as a Thelnetham resident and on behalf of Thelnetham Parish Council) spoke against the application Councillor Carol Bull (Ward Member: Barningham) spoke on the application Jonny Rankin (agent) spoke in support of the application (On conclusion of the registered speakers the Chair permitted a short comfort break before reconvening and commencing the debate on the application.
Councillor Carol Bull proposed that the application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation.
Councillor Carol Bull proposed that the application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation.
Councillor Carol Bull spoke in support of the application and explained that as the original cottage was a tall property she did not consider the extension to be dominant, in her view it respected the original dwelling and was furthermore largely screened by landscaping.
Accordingly, Councillor Bull proposed that the application be approved, contrary to the Officer recommendation of refusal.
Councillor Carol Bull (Ward Member for Barningham) Councillor Bull made her statement and referred to the proposed changes to the Locality Budget and wished to make the following observations, which centred around:
Councillor Carol Bull raised specific questions in relation to the requirements around the habitation of a self-build property.
The Service Manager Planning explained that she would consult the necessary legislation and respond directly to Councillor Bull outside of the meeting.
Speakers: Councillor Garry Bloomfield (Chair of Hepworth Parish Council) spoke against the application Councillor Carol Bull (Ward Member: Barningham ) spoke on the application Adam Cornish (agent) spoke in support of the application Considerable discussion took place on the application during the debate, with a number of Members posing questions on various elements.
Speaker: Phil Cobbold (agent) spoke in support of the application The Chair invited Councillor Carol Bull to open the debate in her capacity as Ward Member for the application.
Councillor Bull advised Members that the Parish Council still supported the application and she proposed that the application be approved, contrary to the Officer recommendation, for the reasons outlined at the August Committee meeting.
The Senior Planning Officer explained that condition No 11 could be expanded to capture this, if Members were minded, and the Chair confirmed with the proposer (Councillor Carol Bull) that she was content to include this within her motion.
Councillor Mike Chester substituting for Councillor Carol Bull; and Councillor Janne Jarvis substituting for Councillor Liz Smith.
Councillor Patrick Chung substituting for Councillor Carol Bull; and Councillor Charlie Lynch substituting for Councillor Rachel Hood.
Councillor Patrick Chung substituting for Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Carol Bull proposed that the application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation, and this was duly seconded by Councillor Sara Mildmay-White.
Speakers: Councillor Carol Bull (Ward Member:
Councillor Carol Bull asked for clarification on what the specific benefits of the application were considered to be in reaching the recommendation for approval. Mindful that the application considered by the Committee prior to this item had similar policy conflicts and was recommended for refusal.
This was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Carol Bull voiced support for the application which she viewed as an improvement to the existing property and with the inclusion of obscure glazed windows on the southeast fenestration she consid ered there to be no loss of neighbouring amenity.
Accordingly, Councillor Bull proposed that the application be approved, contrary to the Officer recommendation, and this was duly seconded by Councillor Lora-Jane Miller-Jones.
The Chair advised the meeting that Councillor Bull had asked that the Committee was informed that she had been unable to attend as a result of personal circumstances and offered her apologies for not being present to the residents of her Ward.
This was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Carol Bull further highlighted the impact the proposed scheme would have on the amenity of the future residents of Plot 1 due to the proximity of that dwelling to the road/access into the development.
Furthermore, the proposer and seconder of the motion were asked if they also wished to include the impact on the amenity of the future residents of Plot 1 (due to the proximity of that dwelling to the road/access) as a further reason for refusal, as referenced by Councillor Bull. Councillors Smith and Miller-Jones confirmed that they supported this additional inclusion and the removal of the reference to highway safety.
This was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Carol Bull asked if these elements could be conditioned, however, the Service Manager (Planning – Development) explained that the outstanding matters related to the suitability of the scheme and Officers therefore considered it necessary to have this information prior to determination.
On the motion of Councillor Kelly, seconded by Councillor Carol Bull, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
Councillor Carol Bull made reference to an omission from the report, in that she as Ward Member for the application attended the Delegation Panel in question and had requested that it be determined by the Development Control Committee.
Speakers: Councillor Carol Bull (Ward Member:
Councillor Carol Bull proposed that the application be approved, contrary to the Officer recommendation, as she did not consider it to have an adverse impact on the character of the area.
Councillor Carol Bull (Ward Member for Barningham ) Councillor Carol Bull addressed the Cabinet and wished to expressed her personal disappointment and sadness on the lack of diversity of the new Cabinet, in that there were only two women who had been appointed.
The Leader of the Council responded and thanked Councillor Bull for her very important question. The Leader also agreed that he would have liked to have had a more diverse make-up of the Cabinet. However, some of the members who had been asked to join the Cabinet, had considered that they did not have the time or resources to be able to participate in this role.
Councillor Sara Mildmay-White substituting for Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Carol Bull (who had been unable to be present at the meeting today) had raised a question in relation to page 3 of the Guidance, second paragraph, where it stated ‘Where appropriate, reasonable additional measures will be taken by the council to protect the safety of those experiencing domestic violence and abuse while travelling between home and work …’ .
Councillor Bull asked as to how this might be accomplished.
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council.
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor Sara Mildmay-White, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 44 for the motion, none against and four abstentions, it was
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council. This included, as proposer of the substantive motion, proposing an additional change to one of the suggested amendments to the Scrutiny Committees Procedure Rules, as follows:
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor Jim Thorndyke, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 46 for the motion, none against and two abstentions, it was
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council, including that in 2022/2023, the frequency of some meeting dates had been adjusted to help avoid cancellations that had been evident in the previous year. Some additional reserve dates for Council and Cabinet had been included in the calendar and these were used where required. This saw less meetings being cancelled where there were no items requiring a decision.
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor John Burns, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
Councillor Carol Bull, Chair of the Grant Working Party, also addressed the Cabinet. Overall, the Working Party had supported ten applications to the value of £315,303 to assist with cost-of-living challenges. Projects ranged from supporting mobile foodbanks, providing debt and councillor services, delivering support for vulnerable individuals/families through arts workshops and opening a community café for elderly residents.
Councillor Bull also commended the Grant Working Party for their hard work and thanked Officers that had supported the process. She also commended Officers for the depth of knowledge for enabling organisations that were turned down or had a reduction in Community Chest funding to be signposted to alternative grant schemes and sources of funding. This had provided some reassurance that projects may still be able to come to fruition.
Councillor Birgitte Mager substituting for Councillor Carol Bull.
The Chair called upon Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance to speak on the item. She duly thanked Richard Cooper and the IRP for the work undertaken on this matter. However, whilst the IRP’s rationale for its recommendation was understood, she and members of the Conservative Group, felt this could not be accepted, particularly in the current economic climate.
Councillor Bull subsequently proposed an alternative motion as follows:
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council.
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor Sara Mildmay-White, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 45 for the motion, none against and one abstention, it was
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council, which included responding to the following questions raised:
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor John Burns, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 45 for the motion, none against and no abstentions, it was
This was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, also wished to again explain that the current situation was as a result of historic working practices adopted by all three tiers of local government in the respective areas. She also referred to the recommendations agreed by Cabinet on 8 November 2022, which included the timescales and the processes for taking this matter forward, which would involve both the Town/Parish Councils and Suffolk County Council.
In conclusion, Councillor Bull wished to reassure the Members present, that the Council had acknowledged their concerns and was working with its partners to explore this.
Councillor Sara Mildmay-White substituting for Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Cabinet, including that she and other Cabinet members had listened to the views of the local ward members that had made statements on this matter during Agenda item 4, Open Forum (see minute 406. above) and was mindful of the depth of feeling regarding the perceived disparity between the former Forest Heath and St Edmundsbury street light ownership.
Councillor Bull added that the situation was complex with regards to street light ownership and further work needed to be done to ensure a fair and consistent approach was in place across the entire district.
Councillor Carol Bull proposed that the application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation and inclusive of the amendments as outlined to the relevant conditions and S106, this was duly seconded by Councillor Mike Chester.
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council. She thanked the Community Governance Review Task and Finish Group and the Business Partner (Governance) for their work on the review, and extended her thanks to members, town and parish councils and other groups that had engaged with the process.
In response, Councillor Bull informed Council that the feedback from the consultation had been carefully considered and with the evidence presented to the Task and Finish Group, the final recommendation had been made on that basis.
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor Robert Nobbs, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 51 for the motion, none against and one abstention, it was
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council, including that a recruitment process had been undertaken over summer 2022 with a view to appointing five individuals to form the aforementioned pool . Short profiles for each were attached as Appendix A to the report.
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor David Roach, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 50 for the motion, none against and two abstentions, it was
This was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Mike Chester substituting for Councillor Carol Bull.
This was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, also responded and also urged the Councillors to read the content of this report, which had been produced as a result of their previously raised concerns regarding the anomalies around the provision of street lighting across the district.
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, also drew relevant issues to the attention of the Cabinet and specifically outlined the next steps to be taken in the review, ahead of it feeding into the wider Town and Parish Council review in 2023 to 2024:
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, also drew relevant issues to the attention of the Cabinet and explained that the Strategy (as set out in Appendix A to Report number CAB/WS/22/029) outlined how the Council would continue to deliver services in a changing and challenging environment focusing on how to attract, reward, nurture and develop its staff, through five key workstreams:
Also, Councillor Carol Bull, Cabinet Member for Governance suggested a reward could be presented as part of the staff awards, handed out at the end of the year.
On the motion of Councillor Griffiths, duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 43 for the motion, none against and one abstention, it was
Councillor Trevor Beckwith substituting for Councillor Roger Dicker; and Councillor Sara Mildmay-White substituting for Councillor Carol Bull.
On the motion of Councillor Griffiths, duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
It was proposed by Councillor Andy Drummond that the application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation, and this was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
It was then proposed by Councillor Carol Bull that the application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation, and this was duly seconded by Councillor Ian Houlder.
On behalf of Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, who was unfortunately unable to attend the meeting, Councillor Sara Mildmay-White, Deputy Leader, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council. She thanked the Community Governance Review Task and Finish Group for their work on the review so far and extended her thanks to members, town and parish councils and other groups that had engaged with the process to date.
In the absence of Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, Councillor Sarah Broughton, Portfolio Holder for Resources and Property, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council.
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council, including that as a result of requests for change, the following issues had been considered and accepted by the Constitution Review Group. These would require amendments to the Constitution, further details of which were set out in section two of the report:
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council, including that there had been an increasing number of meetings cancelled over the past few years due to no items requiring decision. This had been particularly noticeable for full Council meetings. To try to avoid this situation this year, before producing next year’s calendar the Democratic Services Team had completed some analysis of meetings held and cancelled over recent years and adjusted the meeting dates and frequency to reflect forthcoming expected agenda items.
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor Mike Chester, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
Councillor Carol Bull commended the Staff Achievement Awards, in which she had previously attended in her role as Portfolio Holder for Governance. She stated as to whether it would be an option in the future for all Members to be invited to attend the Awards, so that they could also see the achievements of the staff.
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council, which included making reference to the proposed Terms of Reference for the CGR that were attached to the report as Appendix A. These set out the purpose and objectives of the review and how it would be undertaken and also included proposing the creation of a Task and Finish Group, which would be appointed by Council and Chaired by the Portfolio Holder for Governance. The Group would oversee the review process and make recommendations to Council for approval at various stages of the review.
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor Julia Wakelam, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
Councillor Roger Dicker proposed that the application be refused, as per the Officer recommendation, and this was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Carol Bull nominated Councillor Andrew Smith as Chair and this was seconded by Councillor Mike Chester.
· Proposed changes to officer appointments procedures · Amendments to the Code of Conduct for employees · Budget and policy framework procedure rules Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council.
On the motion of Councillor Carol Bull, seconded by Councillor Joanna Rayner, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council.
Councillor David Smith asked the following questions of Councillor Bull to which she provided responses but would follow up with a written reply that would be circulated to all members.
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor David Roach, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 51 for the motion, none against and one abstention, it was
On the motion of Councillor Griffiths, duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull and upon being put to a ‘minded to’ vote, it was Recommended to Council (19 May 2021):
Speaker: Russell Grant (applicant) spoke in support of the application Councillor Peter Stevens proposed that the application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation, and this was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Speakers: Nigel French (neighbouring objector) spoke against the application Councillor Miranda Martin (Market Weston Parish Council) spoke against the application Councillor Carol Bull (Ward Member: Barningham) spoke on the application Juliet Hargrave (applicant) spoke in support of the application (Nigel French and Councillor Martin did not connect to the meeting to personally address the Committee and instead the Democratic Services Officer read out pre-prepared submitted statements on their behalf.) A number of Members made comment/posed questions on the application which the Case Officer responded to as follows:
Councillor Carol Bull substituting for Councillor David Roach The Democratic Services Officer then verbally outlined all Members of the Committee who were present, together with any attending Councillors and the names of the Officers supporting the meeting.
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council, including responding to the following questions:
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor Andrew Smith, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 57 for the motion, none against and one abstention, it was
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council, including that largely due to the uncertainties around the Covid-19 situation which had impacted on the ability to convene meetings in person, no venues had been stipulated on the calendar at present.
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor Sara Mildmay-White, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
In response to the update on joint pain, Councillor Carol Bull, Cabinet Member for Governance was pleased to hear the joint pain initiative had been worthwhile.
Councillor Carol Bull substituting for Councillor Ann Williamson The Democratic Services Officer then verbally outlined all Members of the Committee who were present, together with any attending Councillors and the names of the Officers supporting the meeting.
During this part of the meeting Councillor Carol Bull briefly lost connection during the Ward Member’s statement, accordingly the Chair asked the Democratic Services Officer to re-read this statement once Councillor Bull had regained connection.) During the debate the Committee posed a number of questions which the Planning Officer responded to as follows:
Speakers: Councillor Carol Bull (Ward Member:
Councillor Andy Neal substituting for Councillor David Palmer; and Councillor Carol Bull substituting for Councillor David Roach Following which the Democratic Services Officer verbally outlined all Members of the Committee who were present, together with any attending Councillors and the names of the Officers supporting the meeting.
In response Councillor Carol Bull, Cabinet member for Governance informed the Sub-Committee that she sat on the East of England Local Government Association for member training, and was interest in what the course covered.
Councillor Karen Richardson agreed to forward the course link to Councillor Bull and the Service Manager (Health and Safety) to look into further.
3) Councillor Carol Bull had provided a link to a webinar regarding joint pain by Health Innovation Network, with the idea that it might be useful to staff. Having looked into it further, the council would be getting 10 wellbeing champions signed up to undertake the training. The idea was to tray advisors so they could have a 1 to 1 conversation about supporting people to understand, manage and support the condition.
Councillor Carol Bull substituting for Councillor Ann Williamson.
Councillor Griffiths explained both he and Councillor Carol Bull presently represented West Suffolk Council on the Trust and that Councillor John Augustine had expressed an interest in filling the vacancy.
On the motion of Councillor Griffiths, seconded by Councillor Carol Bull, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 51 for the motion, 1 against and 3 abstentions, it was
Dwelling and detached garage This application was referred to the Development Control Committee following consideration by the Delegation Panel at the request of the Ward Member (Barningham) Councillor Carol Bull.
Speakers: Councillor Carol Bull (Ward Member:
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council.
In response to questions, Councillor Bull stated that the Council was significantly below the national average pay ratio and in Suffolk, of the data sourced, West Suffolk’s ratio compared extremely well with only Ipswich Borough Council faring better. She added that in respect of whether the same differential increase between the national living wage and the Council’s minimum pay of £9.00 per hour that was awarded last year would be added this year and if this would also be applicable to the under 25’s was subject to review.
In the context of the provision of figures within the Pay Policy Statement 2020/2021 relating to whether a gender pay gap was evident within the Council, Councillor Karen Soons asked Councillor Bull whether any figures were available in respect of a potential diversity/ethnicity pay gap.
A written response would be provided by Councillor Bull and this would be shared with all Members in due course.
On the motion of Councillor Carol Bull, seconded by Councillor Patrick Chung, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 56 for the motion, 1 against and 2 abstentions, it was
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council, including that the Constitution Review Group was satisfied that the Constitution was generally operating as intended. However, the Group was suggesting changes should be made in the following areas:
On the motion of Councillor Carol Bull, seconded by Councillor Diane Hind, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council, including placing her thanks on record to the IRP for their work on the interim review. She added that it was proposed for this Scheme to be adopted until February 2024, at which stage a further review would be required. The IRP had also suggested criteria, as set out in section 9 of their report, for when an interim review should be undertaken and it was proposed the Council should adopt these criteria.
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of the Council, including that other bodies not listed in the Council’s Constitution and those arranged on an ‘as required’ basis would be scheduled throughout 2020/2021 and Members would be advised of these separately.
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor Simon Cole, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
Councillor Carol Bull substituting for Councillor David Roach.
(Prior to commencing this item the Business Partner (Litigation/Licensing) sought consent from the licence holder to allow Councillor Carol Bull to remain in the meeting to observe proceedings for training purposes.) The Business Partner (Litigation/Licensing) welcomed all present to the Hearing, reported that no declarations of interest had been received and introductions to all parties were made.
Councillor Carol Bull substituting for Councillor Susan Glossop Councillor Dawn Dicker substituting for Councillor David Gathercole
Councillor Carol Bull substituting for Councillor Ann Williamson Councillor Terry Clements substituting for Councillor David Roach
This was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council, including that as with the recent parliamentary boundary review (and the approach taken by the former St Edmundsbury Borough and Forest Heath District Councils to that review), it was proposed that West Suffolk Council would not submit any formal ‘corporate’ response to the LGBCE consultation, other than the Electoral Registration Officer highlighting any technical errors in the proposals under their statutory role.
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor John Griffiths, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 46 for the motion, two against and two abstentions, it was
Speakers: Councillor Carol Bull (Ward Member:
Barningham ) spoke on the application on behalf of the applicants Paul Nunn (applicant) spoke in support of the application During the debate Councillor Bull spoke in support of the application and highlighted that granting approval would protect and enhance the countryside and rural economy; and a number of other Members equally shared this view.
Speakers: Nigel French (neighbour objector) spoke against the application Robert Snelling (neighbour objector) spoke against the application Councillor Miranda Martin (Vice Chairman, Market Weston Parish Council) spoke against the application Councillor Carol Bull (Ward Member: Barningham ) spoke on the application on behalf of village residents Juliet Hargrave (applicant) spoke in support of the application Considerable debate took place by Members with a number commenting on the lack of amenity that village residents received directly from the premises (when operating as a holiday let) together with the limited control the Local Authority had on businesses of this nature.
Speakers: Councillor Carol Bull (Ward Member:
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Governance, explained that in order to facilitate review of the Constitution, a small review group, the Constitution Review Group, should be formed with similar terms of reference to the former Joint Constitution Review Group. These were attached to the report as Appendix A. Membership of the Review Group would be based on the proposals set out in paragraph 2.3.
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor John Griffiths, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
As the next item on the agenda was exempt, on the motion of Councillor John Griffiths, seconded by Councillor Carol Bull, and duly carried, it was
Councillor Sara Mildmay-White was substituting for Councillor Carol Bull (Employer’s Side).
Councillor Carol Bull nominated Councillor Clive Springett and this was duly seconded by Councillor Margaret Marks.
[Councillor Carol Bull, Cabinet Member for Governance arrived at 4.10pm during the consideration of this item].
Councillor Carol Bull nominated Councillor Andrew Smith as Chair and this was seconded by Councillor Andy Drummond.
This was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull and upon being put to the vote, and with the vote being unanimous, it was
Councillor Carol Bull attended the meeting as substitute for Councillor Ann Williamson.
Councillor Carol Bull (Ward Member:
On the motion of Councillor Susan Glossop, seconded by Councillor Carol Bull, and duly carried, it was
Councillor Ruth Bowman moved the recommendations, as set out in Report No: COU/SA/19/006, and the motion was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Carol Bull, one of the Shadow Executive (Cabinet) Members with the responsibility for Future Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of the Shadow Council, including the proposed changes to the Scheme of Delegation, arrangements for the operation of the Development Control Committee, and the definition of a ‘key decision’, as summarised in Section 2 of the report.
On the motion of Councillor Bull, seconded by Councillor Ruth Bowman, and duly carried, it was
On the motion of Councillor Ruth Bowman, seconded by Councillor Carol Bull, and duly carried it was
Councillor Bowman moved that the schedules of Polling Districts and Polling Places, attached as Appendices 3 and 4 of Report No COU/SA/19/002, be approved and this was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Carol Bull, one of the Cabinet Members for Future Governance, explained that the proposal to transfer the existing West Suffolk Coat of Arms was because it closely related to the West Suffolk District and had links to the current Forest Heath and St Edmundsbury Coat of Arms. The Future Governance Steering Group had considered the matter and had made this recommendation to Council.
Councillor Carol Bull moved that the College of Arms be requested to transfer the West Suffolk County Council Arms to West Suffolk Council and this was duly seconded by Councillor Ruth Bowman.
This was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Carol Bull, one of the Shadow Executive Members with the responsibility for Future Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of the Shadow Council, including providing further detail on the proposed ambassadorial role of the new civic leader for West Suffolk Council and the key considerations required for the new role. This included working more closely with town and parish councils across West Suffolk to develop and support civic leadership at a local level, which may involve the possibility of town councils such as Bury St Edmunds, should they so wish, to create new town mayors.
Councillor Bull also explained the significant amount of work that had been undertaken to form the review and how it was carried out; and that:
Councillor Bull proceeded to move the recommendations contained within report, but with the following amendment to Recommendation (3) to remove reference to suspend Council Procedure Rules for enabling a two-thirds majority vote to be required on whether to proceed with convening a special meeting for the purpose of deciding whether to ... view the full minutes text for item 46.
Councillor David Nettleton proposed that the application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation, and this was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
On the motion of Councillor Ruth Bowman, seconded by Councillor Carol Bull, and duly carried, it was:
On the motion of Councillor Carol Bull, seconded by Councillor Ruth Bowman and with the vote being unanimous, it was
Councillor Carol Bull pointed out that future owners of the properties would have been able to have constructed garages as part of the Permitted Development rights associated with the properties. As such, she considered it an advantage for the garages to be constructed en bloc by the developer as this would ensure a uniform of design.
Councillor Carol Bull concurred with the reason for refusal and seconded the motion.
Councillor Carol Bull, SEBC’s Portfolio Holder for Future Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of the Joint Committee, including that in October 2017, both FHDC and SEBC’s Cabinets had agreed a programme of work to support implementation of GDPR. Subsequently, work had been undertaken across all services (including the Anglia Revenues and Benefits Partnership) to develop processes and procedures to support the Councils’ compliance with the new requirements.
On the motion of Councillor Ruth Bowman, seconded by Councillor Carol Bull, and duly carried it was
Councillor Carol Bull proposed approval of the recommendation contained in the report.
Councillor Carol Bull, in her capacity as Chairman of the Future Governance Working Group, presented this item which sought adoption of the Shadow West Suffolk Council constitution.
Councillor Bull also gave thanks to the Joint Constitution Working Group for their valued work and input, under the chairmanship of Councillor David Nettleton, and moved the recommendation to adopt the constitution.
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Future Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council, including that whilst residents would still be able to identify separate Forest Heath and St Edmundsbury issues listed on the agenda, the collective decision making of a Joint Executive (Cabinet) Committee would assist with the transition towards creating a single council for West Suffolk.
On the motion of Councillor Carol Bull, seconded by Councillor David Nettleton, and duly carried, it was
Ward No: 17 Risby Ward No. of electorate: 1938 2237 %Away from Average: minus 5.74% + 8.80% Councillor Carol Bull, Chairman of the Future Governance Steering Group introduced this item and provided some background. As there were several issues and Options to consider, the Mayor then invited the Service Manager (Democratic Services) to set out how the debate would be handled, which included inviting the Director and Electoral Services Manager to speak during the item to provide background to the particular Option under consideration and assist with any questions Members may have.
The Chairman of the Mayoral Advisory Committee, Councillor Carol Bull, reported that the Committee had recommended that:
Councillor Andrew Smith moved that the recommendation be approved and this was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Future Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council, including the policy requirements summarised in Section 4 of the report, namely the requirements the Secretary of State would place to ensure the process was robust and transparent, which included the establishment of the Shadow Authority until the new council came into being on 1 April 2019.
On the motion of Councillor Carol Bull, seconded by Councillor David Nettleton, and duly carried, it was
In the absence of the Leader of the Council, Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Future Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council, including that Appendix 1 provided details of the committees required to be politically balanced and their respective place entitlement and proposed seat allocations. Proposals for the allocation of seats to non-grouped Members were also set out in this Appendix, as provisionally agreed by Group Leaders.
On the motion of Councillor Carol Bull, seconded by Councillor John Burns, and duly carried, it was
On the motion of Councillor Carol Bull, seconded by Councillor Peter Stevens, and duly carried, it was
Councillor Carol Bull, Portfolio Holder for Future Governance, drew relevant issues to the attention of Council, including that other meetings not listed in the Council’s Constitution and those arranged on an ad-hoc basis would be scheduled throughout 2018/2019 and Members would be advised of these separately.
On the motion of Councillor Carol Bull, seconded by Councillor Clive Pollington, and duly carried it was
Councillor Carol Bull echoed this satisfaction and seconded the motion.
Upon opening the meeting, Councillor John Griffiths, Leader of the Council and Chairman, formally welcomed Councillor Carol Bull to her first meeting of Cabinet since her recent appointment as Portfolio Holder for Future Governance.
Speakers: Councillor Carol Bull spoke on the application as Ward Member for Barningham .
Councillor Carol Bull attended the meeting as substitute for Councillor Clive Springett (St Edmundsbury Borough Council – Employers’ Side).
Councillor Carol Bull then proposed that the application be approved, contrary to the Officer recommendation, and this was duly seconded by Councillor ... view the full minutes text for item 347.
Councillor David Roach spoke in support of the screening suggestion and questioned the degree of harm that would be caused by the panel’s re-orientation, he moved that the application be approved, contrary to the Officer recommendation, and this was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor David Nettleton moved the that application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation, and this was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Peter Stevens nominated Councillor Jim Thorndyke as Chairman and this was seconded by Councillor Carol Bull.
Councillor Peter Stevens nominated Councillor Carol Bull as Vice Chairman and this was seconded by Councillor Julia Wakelam.
Councillor Carol Bull moved that the application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation (and inclusive of the delegation made reference to), and this was duly seconded by Councillor John Burns.
Councillor Houlder then moved the following alternative motion to that proposed in the report, which was duly seconded by Councillor Carol Bull:
Councillor Carol Bull arrived at the meeting immediately prior to the Officer’s presentation of the report on this item) The Committee had visited the application site on 28 July 2016 but the item had been withdrawn from the agenda for the meeting on 4 August 2016 to enable matters relating to car parking and refuse bin storage to be clarified.
(a) Parish Council - Councillor June Plackett , Chairman (b) Ward Member - Councillor Carol Bull (c) Applicant - Simon Butler- Finbow , agent During the presentation by Officers reference had been made that it had not been possible to achieve the extent of landscaping along the southern boundary as had been envisaged by the Development Brief adopted by the Council in respect of the site. In response to a Member’s question as to the reasons why this had not been possible Officers advised that whilst full details of the landscaping proposed were not yet available it had been recognised that because of constraints which would be imposed by drainage and other works associated with the development of the site it would not be possible to accommodate the same extent of landscaping outlined in the Development Brief.
Councillor Carol Bull attended the meeting as substitute for Councillor Clive Springett (St Edmundsbury Borough Council – Employers’ Side).
Councillor Angela Rushen 11 votes Councillor Carol Bull 9 votes Councillor David Roach 7 votes RESOLVED – That Councillors Carol Bull and Angela Rushen be appointed Vice-Chairmen of the Committee.
Councillor Carole Bull attended the meeting as substitute for Councillor Clive Springett (St Edmundsbury Borough Council – Employers’ Side).
Councillor Bull substituting for Councillor Stamp.
Councillor Carol Bull, Ward Member for Barningham spoke in support of the Hopton Village Hall Site and Sarson’s Field Development Brief, which she considered satisfactorily met the future needs of the village. She commended the consultants acting on behalf of the landowner, on the level of community engagement and how the Development Brief had been suitably amended following the feedback from the consultation.
Councillor Carol Bull attended the meeting as substitute for Councillor Clive Springett (St Edmundsbury Borough Council – Employers’ Side).
Councillor Carol Bull for Councillor Patricia Warby.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Bull attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 May 2022 | Development Control Committee | Planning Application DC/22/0090/HH - 18 Aspal Hall Road, Beck Row (Report No: DEV/WS/22/012) | Carried | 13 for, 3 against | |
| 4 May 2022 | Development Control Committee | Planning Application DC/21/2220/HH - 29 Springfield Avenue, Bury St Edmunds (Report No: DEV/WS/22/014) | Carried | 12 for, 4 against | |
| 21 Jul 2020 | Cabinet | Report of the West Suffolk Environment and Climate Change Taskforce: Environment and Biodiversity Emergency in West Suffolk (Report No: CAB/WS/20/046) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Mar 2019 | St Edmundsbury Council | Presentation of Long Service Awards (Report No: COU/SE/19/006) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Mar 2019 | St Edmundsbury Council | Retiring Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Mar 2019 | St Edmundsbury Council | Deputy Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 28 Jun 2016 | St Edmundsbury Council | Referral of Recommendations from Cabinet: 14 June 2016 West Suffolk Operational Hub | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Oct 2015 | St Edmundsbury Cabinet | Business Case to Establish a Housing Development Company | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Bull was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 22 of 29 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Bull declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 Mar 2026 | Development Control Committee, item 614 | (Councillor Carol Bull declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that she had sat on the Licensing and Regulatory Sub-Committee who had determined the premises licence application for the site in question.) Planning application - change of use from funeral directors (Class E use) to bar and shop (sui generis use) This application was referred to the Development Control Committee following consideration by the Delegation Panel. |
Where Councillor Bull sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Development Control Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2019 | 79 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | May 2019 | 52 | 15 Dec 2026 |
| Licensing and Regulatory Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2019 | 29 | |
| Licensing and Regulatory Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2019 | 16 | 11 Jan 2027 |
| St Edmundsbury Development Control Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2015 | 49 | |
| Cabinet | Guest | May 2019 | 43 | |
| St Edmundsbury Council | Committee Member | May 2015 | 31 | |
| St Edmundsbury Cabinet | Committee Member | Jun 2015 | 16 | |
| Health and Safety Sub-Committee | Guest | Jun 2019 | 12 | |
| Joint Executive (Cabinet) Committee | Committee Member (St Edmundsbury) | Jun 2018 | 11 | |
| Shadow Council | Committee Member | May 2018 | 9 | |
| Staff Consultative Panel | Committee Member | Jul 2019 | 9 | |
| St Edmundsbury Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2015 | 7 | |
| Shadow Executive (Cabinet) | Committee Member | Jun 2018 | 7 | |
| West Suffolk Standards Committee | Associate Member | Jul 2019 | 6 | |
| West Suffolk Joint Staff Consultative Panel | Substitute Member (St Edmundsbury) | Jul 2015 | 4 | |
| St Edmundsbury Sustainable Development Working Party | Committee Member | Sep 2015 | 4 | |
| St Edmundsbury Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Guest | Mar 2016 | 2 | |
| St Edmundsbury Mayoral Advisory Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2017 | 2 | |
| St Edmundsbury Treasury Management Sub-Committee | Substitute | Jul 2015 | 1 | |
| St Edmundsbury Democratic Renewal Working Party | Substitute | Dec 2015 | 1 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Ward Member | Dec 2024 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.