Planning Application DC/26/0708/VAR - Land opposite Kingshall Farmhouse, Kingshall Street, Rougham (Report No: DEV/WS/26/020)
Councillor David Smith proposed that the application be approved, ... view the full minutes text for item 644.
Every time West Suffolk's minutes name Councillor Smith, as the council published it.
Councillor David Smith proposed that the application be approved, ... view the full minutes text for item 644.
On the motion of Councillor Kelly, seconded by Councillor David Smith, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
Councillor David Smith asked if the use of a music noise limiter could be conditioned for use at the premises.
Councillor David Smith proposed that the application be approved as per the Officer recommendation and inclusive of the amendments outlined to the five identified conditions.
Councillor David Smith proposed that the application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation.
Councillor David Smith nominated Councillor Roger Dicker and Councillor Dicker accepted the nomination.
Councillor David Smith substituting for Councillor Pat Hanlon.
Councillor David Smith, one of the Council’s appointed representatives on the Police and Crime Panel, was invited to present this report.
Attached at Appendix 1 to the report was a copy of the report of the meeting held on 10 October 2025, which Councillor David Smith had attended.
During his presentation of this item to the Committee, Councillor David Smith as West Suffolk Council’s appointed representative of the Suffolk Police and Crime Panel, drew attention to the Suffolk Police and Crime Commissioner’s annual survey, which sought to gauge public views on their draft proposal for the policing element for the council tax precept for the next financial year.
Councillor David Smith agreed to source this information so that it could be circulated to Members of the Committee by way of a written response.
On the motion of Councillor Hind, seconded by Councillor David Smith, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
This was duly seconded by Councillor David Smith.
Other Members did not share this concern and Councillor David Smith highlighted the proximity of a 24-hour garage very close by. The Senior Planning Officer also informed the Committee that Public Health and Housing had proposed the hours of operation and therefore did not consider them intrusive.
This was duly seconded by Councillor David Smith.
On the motion of Councillor Kelly, seconded by Councillor David Smith, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
The Chair explained that unfortunately neither West Suffolk Council’s appointed full or substitute representative were able to attend the March meeting of the Health Scrutiny Committee and Councillor David Smith attended in their place.
The Chair therefore invited Councillor Andrew Martin to present the report compiled by Councillor David Smith following the meeting on 5 March 2025 and attached as Appendix A, with a supporting presentation document at Appendix B.
Councillor Marion Rushbrook made reference to the report that had been compiled by Councillor David Smith (Appendix A) and the sentence in relation to online consultations ‘ This may be done by a GP, care practitioner, nurse, or someone else…’.
(Councillor David Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he was a Member of Haverhill Town Council, who had considered the application. However, he stressed that he would keep an open mind and listen to the debate prior to voting on the item.) Planning application - single storey side extension to existing community building This application was referred to the Development Control Committee because the application site was owned by West Suffolk Council. The site was rented to Haverhill Community Sports Association which operated the New Croft site.
Councillor David Smith opened the debate and referenced the informal arrangement with the neighbouring Samuel Ward Academy, whereby users of New Croft were allowed to use the Samuel Ward car park outside of school hours.
Councillor David Smith therefore went on to propose that the application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation.
Councillor David Smith spoke in support of the scheme and proposed that the application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation and inclusive of the amended and additional conditions. This was duly seconded by ... view the full minutes text for item 557.
Councillor Phil Wittam proposed that the application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation, and this was duly seconded by Councillor David Smith.
Therefore, it was nominated that Councillor David Smith be the Vice-Chair.
The Democratic Services Advisor advised the Panel that Councillor David Smith had confirmed, if nominated as Vice-Chair he would accept the nomination.
The Committee received report number OAS/WS/25/002, presented by Councillor David Smith. Attached at Appendix 1 to the report was a summary of topics discussed at the Police and Crime Panel meetings held on 2 December 2024 and 31 January 2025, being:
Councillor David Smith informed the Committee that detailed discussions were held on the proposal to increase the policing precept by 5.1 per cent, which was approved, but not unanimous.
In response Councillor David Smith agreed to provide a written response.
The Committee also discussed the Town Pastors charity (who were funded by the PCC) and asked what their remit was, and in particular requested a breakdown of the different types of workers doing outreach / support in our town centres, with their remits and funding from the police and council to which Councillor David Smith agreed to provide a written response.
Councillor Donna Higgins substituting for Councillor David Smith
(Councillor David Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he was a Member of Haverhill Town Council, who had considered the application.
Councillor David Smith highlighted the climate emergency declaration and gave considerable weight to the low carbon energy associated with the scheme. He also stated that he considered the visual impact to be subjective.
These concerns were acknowledged by Councillor David Smith, Chair of the Constitution Review Group (CRG), and Councillor Kelly, as proposer of the motion. These particular changes had been proposed in response to addressing a specific matter and it was fully expected that any future amendments to the Constitution as a result of national changes to the standards regime as referenced in the White Paper, would be considered by the CRG and recommended to Council at the appropriate time.
Councillor David Smith substituting for Councillor Andrew Martin.
[Councillor David Smith arrived at 5.33pm during the discussions and prior to the vote taking place].
The Committee received report number OAS/WS/24/016, presented by Councillor David Smith. Attached at Appendix 1 to the report was a summary of topics discussed at the Police and Crime Panel meeting held on 12 July 2024, being:
Councillor David Smith informed the Committee that an online Public Meeting was being held on the 6 November 2024 to provide the public with an opportunity to ask questions of the Police and Crime Commissioner and the Constabulary, and to find out more about policing in the county. To attend the meeting, residents needed to register with the PCC.
In response to a specific question raised on how many staff worked for the PCC, Councillor David Smith advised that there were three members of staff. There being no decision required the Committee noted the contents of the report.
Councillor Charlie Lynch substituting for Councillor Rachel Hood; and Councillor Donna Higgins substituting for Councillor David Smith
On the motion of Councillor Kelly, seconded by Councillor David Smith, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
(Councillor David Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he was a Member of Haverhill Town Council, who had considered the application.
Councillor Mike Chester substituting for Councillor Rachel Hood; and Councillor David Smith substituting for Councillor Marilyn Sayer
(Councillor David Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he had attended Haverhill Town Council’s meeting when the Town Council considered the application. However, he stressed that he would keep an open mind and listen to the debate prior to voting on the item.) Planning application - change of use from Class E (c)( i ) (professional services) to Class F.1(a) for the provision of education to part of the ground floor and part of the second floor This application was originally referred to the Development Control Committee on 6 March 2024 because it was on land owned by West Suffolk Council.
On the motion of Councillor Kelly, seconded by Councillor David Smith, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 51 for the motion, none against and one abstention, it was
Councillor David Smith acting as temporary substitute for Councillor Rowena Lindberg.
Councillor David Smith substituting for Councillor Sue Perry.
It was then proposed by Councillor David Smith, seconded by Councillor Ian Holder, and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
It was then proposed by Councillor David Smith, seconded by Councillor Ian Houlder and with the vote being unanimous, it was RECOMMENDED That:
Speakers: Denis Elavia (neighbouring objector, speaking on behalf of himself and other neighbouring objectors) spoke against the application Councillor Frank Eve (Vice Chair of Withersfield Parish Council) spoke against the application Councillor Indy Wijenayaka (Ward Member: Withersfield) spoke against the application David Barker (agent) spoke in support of the application Councillor David Smith made reference to Plots 1 and 5 and stated that the Member site visit had reaffirmed his concerns in relation to the proximity of these plots, in particular, to the existing neighbouring premises. He considered the proposal to be overdevelopment and also referenced highway safety concerns.
Speakers: Denis Elavia (neighbouring objector, speaking on behalf of himself and other neighbouring objectors) spoke against the application Councillor Frank Eve (Vice Chair of Withersfield Parish Council) spoke against the application Councillor Indy Wijenayaka (Ward Member: Withersfield) spoke against the application David Barker (agent) spoke in support of the application Councillor David Smith made reference to Paragraphs 45 and 48 of the report which outlined the changes that had been made to Plots 1 and 5. He raised concerns that the amendments were marginal, with the siting of the Plot 1 dwelling not having been changed at all.
Councillor David Smith referenced the importance and the benefits of inter-generational contact.
(Councillor David Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he had attended Haverhill Town Council’s meeting when the Town Council considered the application. However, he stressed that he would keep an open mind and listen to the debate prior to voting on the item.) Planning application - Change of use from residential dwelling (class C3) to a residential children's home (class C2) This application was considered by the Delegation Panel on 1 August 2023 at the request of the Ward Member, where it was decided that the application should be determined at the Development Control Committee. A Member site visit was held prior to the meeting and as part of her presentation to the Committee the Planning Officer also showed videos of the site.
(Councillor David Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he had attended Haverhill Town Council’s meeting when the Town Council considered the application. However, he stressed that he would keep an open mind and listen to the debate prior to voting on the item.) Planning application - change of use from residential (C3) to residential children's home (C2) This application was considered by the Delegation Panel on 1 August 2023 at the request of the Ward Councillor, where it was decided that the application should be determined at the Development Control Committee. A Member site visit was held prior to the meeting and as part of her presentation to the Committee the Planning Officer also showed videos of the site.
Councillor Peter Armitage substituting for Councillor Lora-Jane Miller-Jones; and Councillor Donna Higgins substituting for Councillor David Smith.
Councillor Janne Jarvis substituting for Councillor Marilyn Sayer; and Councillor David Smith substituting for Councillor Rowena Lindberg.
Accordingly it was proposed by Councillor John Burns that the application be approved, as per the Officer recommendation, and this was duly seconded by Councillor David Smith.
(Councillor David Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he had attended Haverhill Town Council’s meeting when the Town Council considered the application. However, he stressed he would keep an open mind and listen to the debate prior to voting on the item.) Planning application - a. replacement of entrance door off High Street and associated glazing b. external bin collection point c. external platform lift d. goods lift to service yard This application was referred to the Development Control Committee as the applicant is West Suffolk Council.
During the debate Councillor David Smith raised some reservations with the location of the disabled parking bays, however, he noted that the Haverhill Disability Action Group had been consulted and they had not raised concerns.
It was proposed by Councillor David Smith, seconded by Councillor Brian Harvey and with the vote being unanimous, it was resolved that
i(Councillor David Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item in light of the fact that he had attended Haverhill Town Council’s meeting when the Town Council considered the application. However, he stressed that he would keep an open mind and listen to the debate prior to voting on the item.
Councillor David Smith substituting for Councillor Diane Hind.
Councillor John Griffiths, Leader of the Council; together with Councillor Ian Shipp, Leader of the Independent Group; and on behalf of Councillor Diane Hind, Leader of the Labour Group, Councillor David Smith, each paid their own tribute to Councillor Marks.
Councillor David Nettleton substituting for Councillor Andy Drummond; and Councillor Diane Hind substituting for Councillor David Smith
(Councillor David Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item in light of the fact that he had taken part in Haverhill Town Council’s consideration of the application. However, he stressed that he would keep an open mind and listen to the debate prior to voting on the item.
Speaker: Richard Sykes-Popham (agent) spoke in support of the application Councillor David Smith addressed the meeting and raised concern at the site in question in view of it being outside the settlement boundary and in the countryside. He also highlighted the significant impact the facility could have on ... view the full minutes text for item 191.
Councillor James Lay substituting for Councillor Andy Drummond; and Councillor Diane Hind substituting for Councillor David Smith.
(Councillor David Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item in light of the fact that he had taken part in Haverhill Town Council’s consideration of the application.
Councillor David Smith asked the following questions of Councillor Bull to which she provided responses but would follow up with a written reply that would be circulated to all members.
(Councillor David Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item in light of the fact that he had taken part in Haverhill Town Council’s consideration of the application.
Speaker: Oliver Ingwall-King (West Suffolk Council Energy Advisor, applicant) spoke in support of the application Councillor John Burns proposed that the application be approved as per the Officer recommendation, this was duly seconded by Councillor David Smith.
(Councillor David Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item in light of the fact that he had taken part in Haverhill Town Council’s consideration of the application when they resolved to oppose the scheme.
Speakers: Susie Cooper (resident objector & on behalf of fellow neighbouring objectors) spoke against the application (via a pre-recorded audio file submission) Lionel Thurlow (architect) spoke in support of the application Councillor David Smith asked if it would be possible to condition the use of the courtyard. In response, the Principal Planning Officer explained that this would not be considered reasonable due to the communal use of the area by residents. Members were also reminded of the two additional conditions in respect of the glazing and alarmed fire doors.
Councillor David Smith (Employer’s Side) was also unable to attend the meeting.
Speaker: Councillor David Smith (Ward Member: Haverhill South) spoke on the application Ben Wallace (applicant) spoke in support of the application Councillor David Smith advised the meeting that he had taken part in Haverhill Town Council’s consideration of the application when they resolved to oppose the scheme. Furthermore, he had also been quoted in the report before the Committee, as Ward Member, objecting to the application. He advised the Committee that he had sought the Monitoring Officer’s advice prior to the meeting.
Councillor David Smith expressed his disappointment that the motion on notice presented to Council on 16 July 2019, was not debated at the meeting. He quoted from the Council Procedures Rules contained in the Constitution that ‘ Any motion on notice under paragraph 9.1 above of these Rules, on being moved and seconded, will usually, without discussion, be referred to the appropriate forum for consideration. If the Chair considers it appropriate, allow the motion to be dealt with at the meeting at which it is moved and seconded ….’ .
Councillor David Smith asked if it would be possible to include some form of ‘spur’ off the foot/cycle path in order to provide a more direct link to the school site.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Smith attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 May 2022 | Development Control Committee | Planning Application DC/22/0090/HH - 18 Aspal Hall Road, Beck Row (Report No: DEV/WS/22/012) | Carried | 13 for, 3 against | |
| 4 May 2022 | Development Control Committee | Planning Application DC/21/2220/HH - 29 Springfield Avenue, Bury St Edmunds (Report No: DEV/WS/22/014) | Carried | 12 for, 4 against |
Meetings Councillor Smith was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 21 of 26 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Smith declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9 Jul 2025 | Development Control Committee, item 556 | (Councillor David Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he was a Member of Haverhill Town Council, who had considered the application. However, he stressed that he would keep an open mind and listen to the debate prior to voting on the item.) Planning application - single storey side extension to existing community building This application was referred to the Development Control Committee because the application site was owned by West Suffolk Council. The site was rented to Haverhill Community Sports Association which operated the New Croft site. | |
| 5 Feb 2025 | Development Control Committee, item 516 | (Councillor David Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he was a Member of Haverhill Town Council, who had considered the application. | |
| 10 Jul 2024 | Development Control Committee, item 457 | (Councillor David Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he was a Member of Haverhill Town Council, who had considered the application. | |
| 3 Apr 2024 | Development Control Committee, item 436 | (Councillor David Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he had attended Haverhill Town Council’s meeting when the Town Council considered the application. However, he stressed that he would keep an open mind and listen to the debate prior to voting on the item.) Planning application - change of use from Class E (c)( i ) (professional services) to Class F.1(a) for the provision of education to part of the ground floor and part of the second floor This application was originally referred to the Development Control Committee on 6 March 2024 because it was on land owned by West Suffolk Council. | |
| 6 Sep 2023 | Development Control Committee, item 374 | (Councillor David Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he had attended Haverhill Town Council’s meeting when the Town Council considered the application. However, he stressed that he would keep an open mind and listen to the debate prior to voting on the item.) Planning application - Change of use from residential dwelling (class C3) to a residential children's home (class C2) This application was considered by the Delegation Panel on 1 August 2023 at the request of the Ward Member, where it was decided that the application should be determined at the Development Control Committee. A Member site visit was held prior to the meeting and as part of her presentation to the Committee the Planning Officer also showed videos of the site. | |
| 6 Sep 2023 | Development Control Committee, item 375 | (Councillor David Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he had attended Haverhill Town Council’s meeting when the Town Council considered the application. However, he stressed that he would keep an open mind and listen to the debate prior to voting on the item.) Planning application - change of use from residential (C3) to residential children's home (C2) This application was considered by the Delegation Panel on 1 August 2023 at the request of the Ward Councillor, where it was decided that the application should be determined at the Development Control Committee. A Member site visit was held prior to the meeting and as part of her presentation to the Committee the Planning Officer also showed videos of the site. | |
| 4 Jan 2023 | Development Control Committee, item 319 | (Councillor David Smith declared, in the interests of openness and transparency, that he had attended Haverhill Town Council’s meeting when the Town Council considered the application. However, he stressed he would keep an open mind and listen to the debate prior to voting on the item.) Planning application - a. replacement of entrance door off High Street and associated glazing b. external bin collection point c. external platform lift d. goods lift to service yard This application was referred to the Development Control Committee as the applicant is West Suffolk Council. | |
| 3 Aug 2022 | Development Control Committee, item 266 | i(Councillor David Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item in light of the fact that he had attended Haverhill Town Council’s meeting when the Town Council considered the application. However, he stressed that he would keep an open mind and listen to the debate prior to voting on the item. | |
| 3 Nov 2021 | Development Control Committee, item 191 | (Councillor David Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item in light of the fact that he had taken part in Haverhill Town Council’s consideration of the application. However, he stressed that he would keep an open mind and listen to the debate prior to voting on the item. | |
| 23 Jun 2021 | Development Control Committee, item 146 | (Councillor David Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item in light of the fact that he had taken part in Haverhill Town Council’s consideration of the application. | |
| 28 Apr 2021 | Development Control Committee, item 127 | (Councillor David Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item in light of the fact that he had taken part in Haverhill Town Council’s consideration of the application. | |
| 7 Apr 2021 | Development Control Committee, item 119 | (Councillor David Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item in light of the fact that he had taken part in Haverhill Town Council’s consideration of the application when they resolved to oppose the scheme. |
Where Councillor Smith sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Development Control Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2019 | 91 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | May 2019 | 52 | 15 Dec 2026 |
| Staff Consultative Panel | Vice-Chair | Jul 2019 | 17 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Associate Member | Jul 2022 | 7 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| Licensing and Regulatory Committee | Substitute | Jul 2023 | 4 | 11 Jan 2027 |
| Cabinet | Guest | Jul 2019 | 2 | |
| Financial Resilience Sub-Committee | Substitute | Jan 2024 | 1 | |
| Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee | Associate Member | Jul 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.