Election of Vice Chair of the Council for 2026 to 2027
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, Deputy Leader of the Council, nominated Councillor Jools Savage.
Every time West Suffolk's minutes name Councillor Lukaniuk, as the council published it.
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, Deputy Leader of the Council, nominated Councillor Jools Savage.
On the motion of Councillor Waterman, duly seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 42 for, none against, 13 abstentions and two votes not cast, it was
On the motion of Councillor Waterman, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
On the motion of Councillor Hind, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, Deputy Leader of the Council and Ward Member for Brandon West, commended the work of the Independent Commission and that it would be valuable steer for the Council on the future direction of travel for Brandon.
On the motion of Councillor Hind, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
On the motion of Councillor Waterman, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
On the motion of Councillor Taylor, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 43 for the motion, none against and one abstention, it was
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk expressed his particular concerns and that, in his view, the revised business case being presented was precarious and was gambling with public money and that the agreement with Xtreme 360 was still in the final stages of being signed.
Councillor Lukaniuk stated, therefore, that he could not support the motion being presented this evening and ... view the full minutes text for item 724.
The motion, as set out in paper number: COU/WS/25/018, was duly proposed by Councillor Waterman and seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, Deputy Leader of the Council, who reserved his right to speak until later in the debate.
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, Deputy Leader of the Council, nominated Councillor Peter Armitage.
On the motion of Councillor Waterman, duly seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
On the motion of Councillor Hind, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
On the motion of Councillor Hind, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was ... view the full minutes text for item 408.
In the absence of Councillor Jim Thorndyke, Portfolio Holder for Planning, Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, Deputy Leader of the Council drew relevant issues to the attention of Council. These included setting out the process that had been followed by Hargrave Parish Council and Hargrave residents to review the Hargrave Neighbourhood Plan, as set out in the report.
Councillor Lukaniuk proposed the motion to accept the recommendations detailed in the report, subject to a slight amendment to the second recommendation so that delegated authority would be given to the Director (Planning and Growth) and not to the Service Manager (Planning Policy) to carry out the functions stated in the recommendation.
On the motion of Councillor Lukaniuk, seconded by Councillor Hind, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
As previously advised, the Chair called upon Councillor Victor Lukaniuk to introduce and move the motion.
Councillor Lukaniuk drew attention to a number of issues, which included highlighting that being an elected member of West Suffolk Council was both a privilege and a responsibility. Sadly, this came with an increase in abuse and intimidation directed at members and officers, which caused a significant impact on the health and wellbeing of members, officers, and their families, therefore steps should be taken to ensure, in particular, that elected representatives felt safe and secure in their own communities.
Councillor Lukaniuk urged members to commit to challenge the normalisation of abuse against elected politicians and uphold exemplary standards of public and political debate in all it did.
On the motion of Councillor Lukaniuk, seconded by Councillor Hopfensperger, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
Speakers: Councillor Victor Lukaniuk (Brandon Town Councillor and adjacent District Council Ward Member) spoke in support of the application Councillor Jools Savage (Ward Member: Brandon Central) spoke in support of the application Trevor Cronin (applicant) spoke in support of the application A number of Members argued that, contrary to the Officer’s reason for refusal, the area of Brandon in question did not have any ‘local distinctiveness’ and that the dwellings surrounding the application site largely varied in size and style.
Councillor Mick Bradshaw substituting for Councillor Victor Lukaniuk
Speakers: Councillor Victor Lukaniuk (objector) spoke against the application Councillor Gerald Kelly (Ward Member: Lakenheath) spoke against the application by way of a written statement read out by the Democratic Services Officer in their absence David Huckstep (applicant) spoke in support of the application Councillor Donna Higgins addressed the meeting and explained that as she was acting as a substitute and had not attended the Member site visit in April, she felt unable to determine the application and would abstain from the vote. However, she drew attention to the concerns raised by the local Members.
The Case Officer advised that since publication of the agenda a formal objection had been submitted by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, Ward Member for Brandon West.
Speakers: Councillor Victor Lukaniuk (Ward Member: Brandon West) spoke against the application Matt Sawyer (architect) spoke in support of the application During the debate there was some discussion by Members over the terminology the architect used when he referred to ‘ customers’ . The Chair invited him to clarify and the Committee was advised that the lorry wash and driver facilities building would only be used by the owners of the site and would not operate for commercial use.
The Deputy Leader of the Council, Councillor Victor Lukaniuk thanked the Committee for the opportunity to present Report No: OAS/WS/24/009, which outlined the draft West Suffolk Councils’ Annual Report (2023 to 2024) and was before the Overview and Scrutiny Committee for their comments.
On the motion of Councillor Hind, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, it was put to the vote and with the vote being 31 for the motion, 7 against and 15 abstentions, it was
· Advanced Manufacturing and Engineering (AME) Centre Project · Housing Related Support · Bury St Edmunds Leisure Centre · Olding Road, Bury St Edmunds: Options Appraisal In the absence of the Leader, Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, Deputy Leader drew relevant issues to the attention of Cabinet. He stated that although listed in the report, the AME Centre Project item would not now be considered by Council as it had been deferred to allow further work with partners to take place.
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, Deputy Leader of the Council, nominated Councillor Pat Hanlon.
On the motion of Councillor Waterman, duly seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
Councillor Mick Bradshaw substituting for Councillor Victor Lukaniuk
The motion was duly seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk.
Councillor Kelly then moved the motion, which was duly seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk.
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, Deputy Leader of the Council and one of the ward members for Brandon, was pleased that despite the environmental constraints which limited growth in the town, provision had been made in the Plan whereby the Council would use its best endeavours to achieve a solution to successfully deliver sustainable growth in Brandon whilst working within the current constraints.
Councillor Jools Savage substituting for Councillor Victor Lukaniuk (Employer’s Side).
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk nominated Councillor Roger Dicker and Councillor Dicker accepted the nomination.
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, Leader of the Independents, nominated Councillor Cliff Waterman for the election of Leader of the Council.
On the motion of Councillor Waterman, duly seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, it was put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was
It was then proposed by Councillor John Auguste, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
It was then proposed by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, seconded by Councillor Robert Nobbs, and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
It was then proposed by Councillor Robert Nobbs, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk and with the vote being unanimous, it was RECOMMENDED That:
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, Ward Member for Brandon Central Concerns continued to be raised by these particular Members with regards to the arrangements for street lighting costs within the district. They again stated their view that some of the towns/villages, within the former Forest Heath area, were being treated unfairly because the Town/Parish Councils paid for some of the street lighting, which was not the case in the former St Edmundsbury area. The Members stated that provision needed to be made within the forthcoming West Suffolk Council budgets for 2023/2024 to address this disparity.
It was then proposed by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, seconded by Councillor Robert Nobbs, and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, ward member for Brandon Central Concern was expressed that Report number:
It was then proposed by Councillor Robert Nobbs, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
Rural England Prosperity Fund (‘Rural Fund’): Councillor Victor Lukaniuk wished to place his thanks on record to the Operations team, and in particular the work of those in the Parks and Landscapes for their efforts in Brandon.
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk nominated Councillor Ian Houlder as Chair.
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk moved the recommendation, this was duly seconded by Councillor Robert Nobbs, and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
It was then proposed by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, seconded by Councillor Ian Houlder and with the vote being unanimous, it was RECOMMENDED That:
It was then proposed by Councillor Robert Nobbs, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, and with the vote being unanimous it was:
Councillor Ian Houlder (Conservative Group) Councillor Elaine McManus (Conservative Group) Councillor Victor Lukaniuk (The Independent Group) Councillor Robert Nobbs (Conservative Group – Substitute) b. Health and Safety Sub-Committee:
This was duly seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, and with the vote being unanimous, it was
- Councillor Victor Lukaniuk (The Independent Group) wished to continue to serve as a full member on the Sub-Committee - Councillor Robert Nobbs (Conservative Group) wished to continue to serve as the substitute on the Sub-Committee.
Councillor Robert Nobbs then moved the recommendation this was duly seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, and with the vote being unanimous, it was RECOMMENDED:
This was duly seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, and with the vote being unanimous, it was
It was then proposed by Councillor Elaine McManus, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, and with the vote being unanimous it was:
It was then proposed by Councillor Elaine McManus, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk and with the vote being unanimous, it was RECOMMENDED That:
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk then moved the recommendation, this was duly seconded by Councillor Phil Wittam, and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
Councillor Phil Wittam then moved the recommendation, this was duly seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
It was the proposed by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, seconded by Councillor Ian Houlder, and with the vote being unanimous, it was RECOMMENDED:
It was proposed by Councillor Elaine McManus, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, and with the vote being unanimous, it was RECOMMENDED:
It was then proposed by Councillor Ian Houlder, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, and with the vote being unanimous, it was RECOMMENDED:
Members were also advised that since publication of the agenda an email had been received from Brandon Central Ward Member Councillor Victor Lukaniuk who stated that he supported the view of Brandon Town Council; in that the plot was sizeable and he did not think the proposal would be overbearing. He also highlighted that there had been no representations made by neighbours.
The Planning Officer further advised that an email had also been received from fellow Brandon Central Ward Member Councillor Phil Wittam who concurred with all comments made by Councillor Lukaniuk.
Additional comments on the Leader’s Statement included recognition from Councillor Victor Lukaniuk on the proposed investment in Brandon Leisure Centre and thanking those that had been instrumental in helping to bring the Havebury Housing development in Brandon forward.
When considering Appendix G (Capital Programme) Councillor Lukaniuk suggested that more consideration should be given to property investments in Brandon. In response, officers explained that when making investments the council was not just looking at achieving a financial return, it also considered the wider social and economic return. Each proposed investment was considered on its own merits, and officers had looked at potential property investments in Brandon.
It was then proposed by Councillor Cliff Waterman, and duly seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, and with the vote being 5 for, 1 against and 3 abstentions, it was RECOMMENDED:
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk then moved the recommendation, this was duly seconded by Councillor Ian Houlder, and with the vote being unanimous, it was RECOMMENDED:
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk then moved the recommendation, this was duly seconded by Councillor Elaine McManus, and with the vote being unanimous it was:
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk substituting for Councillor Lisa Ingwall-King.
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk referred to the summary of capital borrowing table and suggested the word “investments” be replaced with “borrowing”, so the row at the bottom of the tables reads “total value of borrowing ”, as he felt how it was currently worded was misleading. In response to a question raised regarding the PWLB loan increase, members were informed that even with the 1%, the councils business cases were still valid as contingencies had been built-in, just in case there was a change in interest rates.
It was then proposed by Councillor Ian Houlder, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
It was then proposed by Councillor Karen Richardson, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk nominated Councillor Ian Houlder as Chair.
It was then proposed by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, seconded by Councillor Richard Alecock and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
It was then proposed by Councillor Richard Alecock, seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
Councillor Ian Houlder moved the recommendation, this was duly seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, and with the vote being unanimous, it was:
(a) Appointment of Chair of Overview and Scrutiny Committee Councillor Victor Lukaniuk nominated Councillor David Nettleton and this was seconded by Councillor Sara Mildmay -White.
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk drew attention to the reference within the Leader’s statement to the homes needed for future generations. He stressed the importance of including residential developments within Brandon, mindful of the restrictions currently imposed by Stone Curlew habitats.
[Councillors Christine Mason and David Palmer declared non-pecuniary interests as they lived in Brandon and remained in the meeting and the subsequent vote] Prior to the Committee considering this late urgent item, the Chairman o utlined the procedure for the conduct of the call-in, which was set out in Appendix 4 of the report, and sought the name of the member who would be the main spokesperson for the call-in, being Councillor Victor Lukaniuk.
In line with the Overview and Scrutiny Committee Procedure Rules, as contained within Part 4 of the Forest Heath District Council Constitution, Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, with the support of Councillors Andrew Appleby, Christine Mason, David Palmer and Peter Ridgwell called-in the Portfolio Holders decision notice published on 28 February 2019. The call-in had been actioned under items 1 and 8 of the principles for decision making, as follows:
In line with the guidance note, the Chairman invited the lead call-in member, Councillor Victor Lukaniuk to outline to the Committee the reasons/concerns in actioning the call-in, making reference to items 1 and 8 of the principles of decision making (below):
Councillor Lukaniuk informed the Committee that he considered it was a poor decision, and the first he had heard about the Future High Street Fund Bid was on 19 February 2019, then on 28 February 2019 when the actual Portfolio Holder decision was published. As a result, he felt Brandon councillors we were not able to put forward a case for the Town to be the subject of the bid. He believed the Portfolio Houlder should have made efforts to contact local members as otherwise they were excluded from the debate.
The Chairman invited the Forest Heath District Council Portfolio Holder for Planning and Growth, Councillor Lance Stanbury to respond to the points raised by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk, making reference ... view the full minutes text for item 289.
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk posed a question with regard to the ‘Social Prescribing Initiative’ as made reference to in the statement.
Councillor Lukaniuk was advised that it was yet to have commenced in Brandon or Mildenhall and further information would be circulated to Members prior to it launching.
Councillor Lukaniuk also asked that his thanks be recorded to Councillor David Bowman, Cabinet Member for Operations, for the resurfacing of Brandon Country Park’s car park.
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk thanked the Leader for the congratulations he included in his statement to Brandon for their recent achievement in being awarded Best Newcomer in the Anglia in Bloom awards.
Councillor Lukaniuk then went on to make reference to Toggam Solar Farm and he questioned the level of return that the project was achieving.
Councillor Stephen Edwards responded, in his capacity as Cabinet Member for Resources and Performance, and robustly challenged the figures stated by Councillor Lukaniuk. He outlined in detail the income that had been generated from the project to date and what was forecast to be achieved.
Councillor Lance Stanbury also spoke in response to the comments made by Councillor Lukaniuk and expressed disappointment that the points raised seemingly did not appreciate the real success of the solar farm and were, instead, appearing to portray it to the public (inaccurately) as a ‘failed project’.
Both Councillor Lukaniuk and Silvester considered this data to be flawed.
Councillor Lukaniuk explained that he had requested an additional site to be included by Suffolk County Council as part of the monitoring study but it appeared from the data that this had not been done.
Furthermore, Councillor Lukaniuk strongly disputed the statement within the County Council’s report that “the majority of HGV traffic coming into Brandon does so for business uses and is not through traffic”.
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk raised a question with regard to the Council’s purchase of a property in Newmarket, as made reference to within the statement. The Leader duly responded, whilst highlighting that the matter in question was the subject of a separate report later on the agenda (Item 13).
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk raised concerns with the process and queried as to why alternative buildings, such as The Flowerpot in Brandon, were not considered for the scheme.
In response, the Leader advised Councillor Lukaniuk that a potential project for The Flowerpot was due to considered by Cabinet in May and he would ensure that Councillor Lukaniuk was briefed accordingly.
(Councillor Victor Lukaniuk left the meeting at 6.31pm during the discussion of this item.)
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk raised a question with regard to the Toggam Solar Farm as made reference to within the statement. He asked the Leader at what point would the solar farm generate the predicted £700,000 per annum income.
(a) Brandon Country Park (Report No: CAB/FH/18/012) Councillor Victor Lukaniuk referred to this item which was due for consideration by the Cabinet and expressed his support for Forest Heath District Council acquiring the freehold of Brandon Country Park.
Councillor Lukaniuk did also request for consideration to be given for the involvement of the Brandon West Ward Members on any Management Committee which may be established for the operation of Park.
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk (as one of the Brandon Ward Members) raised the following points:
Councillor Lukaniuk explained that he found these two statements to be contradictory;
Officers would liaise with Councillor Lukaniuk on their proposed locations.
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk made reference to Appendix 1 attached to the report. He was disappointed that Brandon, as one of Forest Heath’s largest towns, was not mentioned by name in the entire document despite Omar Homes (which was located in the town) being referenced. Officers noted this comment and agreed to take it on board.
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk made reference to his concerns with regard to air quality within Brandon, which he had previously raised with Officers, and stressed that he would be willing to sit on a Working Party for air quality, should one be formed.
Councillor Victor Lukaniuk attended the meeting as substitute for Councillor Andrew Appleby.
This was duly seconded by Councillor Victor Lukaniuk and with 4 voting for the motion, 6 against and with 1 abstention the Chairman declared the motion lost.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Lukaniuk attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30 Jan 2020 | Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee | 2019-2020 Performance Report (Quarter 3) | Carried | 5 for, 1 against, 3 abstained | |
| 28 Nov 2019 | Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee | Treasury Management - September 2019 | Carried | 9 for, 1 against, 1 abstained |
Meetings Councillor Lukaniuk was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 19 of 25 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Lukaniuk declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Lukaniuk in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Lukaniuk sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2019 | 52 | 15 Dec 2026 |
| Cabinet | Deputy Leader | Nov 2022 | 35 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| West Suffolk Standards Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2023 | 11 | |
| Staff Consultative Panel | Committee Member | Jul 2023 | 8 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2020 | 5 | |
| Licensing and Regulatory Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2026 | 1 | 11 Jan 2027 |
| Forest Heath Council | Committee Member | May 2016 | 22 | |
| Performance and Audit Scrutiny Committee | Observer | May 2019 | 22 | |
| Financial Resilience Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2019 | 11 | |
| Forest Heath Licensing and Regulatory Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2016 | 10 | |
| Shadow Council | Committee Member | May 2018 | 9 | |
| Forest Heath Cabinet | Guest | Jul 2016 | 3 | |
| Development Control Committee | Associate Member | Apr 2024 | 3 | |
| Forest Heath Development Control Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2016 | 2 | |
| Forest Heath Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Guest | Mar 2019 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.