CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
People/Winchester/Councillor Malcolm Wallace
MW

Councillor Malcolm Wallace

Chairperson, The Scrutiny Committee
Follow Councillor Wallace's committeesAn email when their committees meet and decide
80%meetings attended20 of 25 since 2022, apologies 1
25times in the minutesAsked 0, said 10, moved 1, seconded 0
3recorded votes at their meetingsTheir own vote is named only where the minutes list it
7declarations at meetingsInterests declared on agenda items
6committees in the last year1 as Chair or Vice-Chair

On the record

Every time Winchester's minutes name Councillor Wallace, as the council published it.

Said8 Jul 2026Health and Environment Policy Committee

Public Participation

In addition, Councillors Wallace and Adams spoke in respect of Item 9 and Councillor Wallace also spoke on Item 11. A summary of their comments are set out under the relevant minutes below.
From the council's minutes: Health and Environment Policy Committee, 8 Jul 2026, item 7Open the meeting
Named8 Jul 2026Health and Environment Policy Committee

Integrated Update from Special Maintenance and the Natural Environment and Recreation Team - River Management and Pollution

Councillor Wallace ·          He welcomed the briefing note and the opportunity to discuss water management, which he regarded as one of the most important environmental issues facing the district.
From the council's minutes: Health and Environment Policy Committee, 8 Jul 2026, item 9Open the meeting
Named8 Jul 2026Health and Environment Policy Committee

Integrated Update from Special Maintenance and the Natural Environment and Recreation Team - River Management and Pollution

·          Councillor Wallace encouraged the council to incorporate a small suite of outcome measures in future reports, suggesting indicators such as nutrient levels, pollution incidents, ecological status, and river flood monitoring results to help members and residents understand if river conditions were moving in the right direction.
From the council's minutes: Health and Environment Policy Committee, 8 Jul 2026, item 9Open the meeting
Said8 Jul 2026Health and Environment Policy Committee

Integrated Update from Special Maintenance and the Natural Environment and Recreation Team - River Management and Pollution

·          In conclusion, Councillor Wallace noted that whilst fluvial flooding in Winchester was discussed, many rural communities were particularly vulnerable to groundwater flooding, highlighting that Hambledon ranked first and Upper Meon Valley ranked third in Hampshire for groundwater flood risk. He requested stronger future focus on outcomes and a broader reflection of water management challenges across the entire district.
From the council's minutes: Health and Environment Policy Committee, 8 Jul 2026, item 9Open the meeting
Said8 Jul 2026Health and Environment Policy Committee

Investing in Communities: Making CIL Work Harder and Faster (Presentation)

Councillor Wallace addressed the Forum on this item. His comments are summarised below:
From the council's minutes: Health and Environment Policy Committee, 8 Jul 2026, item 11Open the meeting
Said8 Jul 2026Health and Environment Policy Committee

Investing in Communities: Making CIL Work Harder and Faster (Presentation)

·          In conclusion, Councillor Wallace urged the committee to encourage the administration to place fairness, transparency, and accessibility alongside speed of delivery as key objectives for the future management of CIL, noting that providing this information would build confidence in evidence- and need-based future allocations and help identify communities requiring additional support to bring projects forward.
From the council's minutes: Health and Environment Policy Committee, 8 Jul 2026, item 11Open the meeting
Said17 Jun 2026Cabinet

Winchester Sport and Leisure Park improvements

Councillor Wallace As chair of Scrutiny Committee, Councillor Wallace expressed concerns that the accelerated timetable bypassed proper scrutiny and the spirit of the council's constitution provisions relating to decision-making. He questioned the justification for allocating £740,000 of Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) funding to a successful leisure facility, noting the lack of a clear link to mitigating development impacts. Furthermore, he highlighted the inequity of using funds generated district-wide for city-based projects, particularly when rural areas contribute significantly to the total CIL pot.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 17 Jun 2026, item 8Open the meeting
Named2 Jun 2026Council

Second Home Council Tax Premium (CL180)

Councillor Malcolm Wallace 33.
From the council's minutes: Council, 2 Jun 2026, item 5Open the meeting
Moved2 Jun 2026Council

To consider and determine the following Recommended Minutes of the Scrutiny Committee held 26 May 2026 - Annual Scrutiny Report 2025/26 (SC102) - draft Recommended Minute to follow.

Councillor Wallace (Chair of the Scrutiny Committee) moved that the recommended minute of the Scrutiny Committee be approved and adopted (seconded by Councillor Batho).
From the council's minutes: Council, 2 Jun 2026, item 8Open the meeting
Named2 Jun 2026Council

To consider and determine the following Recommended Minutes of the Scrutiny Committee held 26 May 2026 - Annual Scrutiny Report 2025/26 (SC102) - draft Recommended Minute to follow.

There were no questions or debate, before Councillor Wallace was invited to sum up before the Council voted on the Recommendations before it.
From the council's minutes: Council, 2 Jun 2026, item 8Open the meeting
Said28 May 2026Cabinet

Central Winchester Regeneration (CWR) proposed land acquisition (less exempt appendix)

Councillor Wallace (Chair of Scrutiny Committee) Councillor Wallace reported that the Scrutiny Committee recognised the strategic opportunity to enhance the CWR scheme’s design flexibility and coherence by acquiring the former St Clement’s Surgery site. He noted that while the acquisition was not essential for delivery, it would prevent a poor-quality building from remaining at the heart of the development. However, he raised serious concerns regarding the council’s potential financial exposure, specifically the risk of holding a non-performing asset and the impact of borrowing on the wider capital programme.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 28 May 2026, item 9Open the meeting
Said28 May 2026Cabinet

Bar End depot disposal (less exempt appendices)

Councillor Wallace (Chair of Scrutiny Committee) Councillor Wallace reported that the Scrutiny Committee had been supportive of the project’s focus on affordable housing, acknowledging the council's decision to accept a reduced financial return to secure 82 homes and a community facility. Members had sought reassurances regarding the preferred bidder’s track record, site contamination, and the availability of Homes England funding.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 28 May 2026, item 10Open the meeting
Said28 May 2026Cabinet

Q4 Performance Monitoring 25/26

Councillor Wallace (Chair of Scrutiny Committee) Councillor Wallace agreed that further consideration would be given to the best methods for scrutinising performance reports. He expressed significant concern regarding climate delivery, noting that both corporate and district carbon reduction measures had been rated amber for an extended period. He questioned at what point these ratings would trigger a formal recovery approach and raised further queries regarding the clarity of reporting for the local area energy plan.
From the council's minutes: Cabinet, 28 May 2026, item 11Open the meeting
Said26 May 2026Planning Committee

Dene Cottage New Road Swanmore Southampton (Case Ref: 25/01431/OUT) Ward: Central Meon Valley

Councillor Malcolm Wallace spoke as a ward member and expressed several points on behalf of residents which could be summarised as follows:
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 26 May 2026, item 9Open the meeting
Declared17 Mar 2026The Scrutiny Committee

Declarations of Interests

Councillor Wallace declared a disclosable pecuniary interest due to his role as a Hampshire County Councillor. However, as there was no material conflict of interest, he remained in the room and spoke under the dispensation granted by the Audit and Governance committee.
From the council's minutes: The Scrutiny Committee, 17 Mar 2026, item 2Open the meeting
Declared17 Mar 2026Licensing & Regulation Committee

Disclosures of Interests

Councillor Wallace declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in respect of various items on the agenda due to his role as a Hampshire County Councillor.
From the council's minutes: Licensing & Regulation Committee, 17 Mar 2026, item 2Open the meeting
Declared4 Mar 2026The Scrutiny Committee

Declarations of Interests

Councillor Wallace declared a disclosable pecuniary interest due to his role as a Hampshire County Councillor.
From the council's minutes: The Scrutiny Committee, 4 Mar 2026, item 2Open the meeting
Said4 Mar 2026The Scrutiny Committee

Planning Enforcement - Task and Finish Group - Feedback to Scrutiny Committee.

Councillor Malcolm Wallace, Chair of the Planning Enforcement Task and Finish Group, introduced the report which set out the findings and recommendations of the group ( available here ). The introduction included the following points.
From the council's minutes: The Scrutiny Committee, 4 Mar 2026, item 7Open the meeting
Named4 Mar 2026The Scrutiny Committee

Planning Enforcement - Task and Finish Group - Feedback to Scrutiny Committee.

These points were responded to by Councillor Malcolm Wallace, Julie Pinnock, Corporate Head of Planning and Regulatory Services, Sarah Armstrong, Service Lead: Built Environment and Councillor Jackie Porter, Cabinet Member for Place and Local Plan accordingly.
From the council's minutes: The Scrutiny Committee, 4 Mar 2026, item 7Open the meeting
Declared10 Feb 2026The Scrutiny Committee

Declarations of Interests

Councillor Wallace declared a disclosable pecuniary interest due to his role as a Hampshire County Councillor. However, as there was no material conflict of interest, he remained in the room and spoke under the dispensation granted by the Audit and Governance committee.
From the council's minutes: The Scrutiny Committee, 10 Feb 2026, item 2Open the meeting
Named10 Feb 2026The Scrutiny Committee

Planning Enforcement - Task and Finish Group - Feedback to Scrutiny Committee.

Councillor Wallace, as Chair of the Task and Finish Group asked that a review of the recommendations be undertaken and a further virtual meeting was agreed. The Chief Executive proposed that the recommendations through the report be brought together once agreed and an update included on the agenda of a future meeting of this committee.
From the council's minutes: The Scrutiny Committee, 10 Feb 2026, item 7Open the meeting
Declared13 Nov 2025The Scrutiny Committee

Declarations of Interests

Councillor Wallace declared a disclosable pecuniary interest due to his role as a Hampshire County Councillor. However, as there was no material conflict of interest, he remained in the room and spoke under the dispensation granted by the Audit and Governance committee. 2.
From the council's minutes: The Scrutiny Committee, 13 Nov 2025, item 2Open the meeting
Declared29 Sep 2025Licensing & Regulation Committee

Disclosures of Interests

Councillor Wallace declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in respect of various items on the agenda due to his role as a Hampshire County Councillor.
From the council's minutes: Licensing & Regulation Committee, 29 Sep 2025, item 2Open the meeting
Declared8 Sep 2025The Scrutiny Committee

Declarations of Interests

The following declarations were made: a)     Councillor Wallace declared a disclosable pecuniary interest due to his role as a Hampshire County Councillor.
From the council's minutes: The Scrutiny Committee, 8 Sep 2025, item 2Open the meeting
Named8 Sep 2025The Scrutiny Committee

Chairperson's Announcements

Following consultation with Councillor Wallace and a review of the circulated communications, both were satisfied that the matter had been appropriately addressed and concluded.
From the council's minutes: The Scrutiny Committee, 8 Sep 2025, item 3Open the meeting

Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.

Votes at their meetings

Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Wallace attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.

DateMeetingItemTheir voteResultCount
20 May 2026CouncilTo elect from amongst the Members of the Council a person to be Mayor of the City of Winchester for the ensuing year.CarriedUnanimous
20 May 2026CouncilTo move a vote of thanks to the Retiring Mayor.CarriedUnanimous
20 May 2026CouncilTo elect from amongst the Members of the Council a person to be Deputy Mayor of the City of Winchester for the ensuing year.CarriedUnanimous
Hover an item for the minutes' own words. Most councils record the count, not each councillor's vote.

Attendance

Meetings Councillor Wallace was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.

Council
5 of 6
The Scrutiny Committee
5 of 6
Licensing & Regulation Committee
2 of 4
Cabinet
3 of 3
Licensing Sub-Committee
3 of 3
Planning Committee
2 of 2
Audit and Governance Committee
0 of 1
Last 12 monthsPresent Apologies Absent
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov

Present at 20 of 23 meetings in the last 12 months.

Declarations of interest

What Councillor Wallace declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.

DateWhereWhat the minutes sayWhat happened
17 Mar 2026The Scrutiny Committee, item 2Councillor Wallace declared a disclosable pecuniary interest due to his role as a Hampshire County Councillor. However, as there was no material conflict of interest, he remained in the room and spoke under the dispensation granted by the Audit and Governance committee.Stayed and took part
17 Mar 2026Licensing & Regulation Committee, item 2Councillor Wallace declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in respect of various items on the agenda due to his role as a Hampshire County Councillor.
4 Mar 2026The Scrutiny Committee, item 2Councillor Wallace declared a disclosable pecuniary interest due to his role as a Hampshire County Councillor.
10 Feb 2026The Scrutiny Committee, item 2Councillor Wallace declared a disclosable pecuniary interest due to his role as a Hampshire County Councillor. However, as there was no material conflict of interest, he remained in the room and spoke under the dispensation granted by the Audit and Governance committee.Stayed and took part
13 Nov 2025The Scrutiny Committee, item 2Councillor Wallace declared a disclosable pecuniary interest due to his role as a Hampshire County Councillor. However, as there was no material conflict of interest, he remained in the room and spoke under the dispensation granted by the Audit and Governance committee. 2.Stayed and took part
29 Sep 2025Licensing & Regulation Committee, item 2Councillor Wallace declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in respect of various items on the agenda due to his role as a Hampshire County Councillor.
8 Sep 2025The Scrutiny Committee, item 2The following declarations were made: a)     Councillor Wallace declared a disclosable pecuniary interest due to his role as a Hampshire County Councillor.
Hover a line for the full wording.

Committees and roles

Where Councillor Wallace sits, from the attendance records.

CommitteeRoleSinceMeetingsNext meeting
CouncilCommittee MemberNov 2025625 Nov 2026
The Scrutiny CommitteeChairpersonMar 20266
Licensing & Regulation CommitteeCommittee MemberDec 202542 Dec 2026
CabinetGuestMay 2026318 Nov 2026
Licensing Sub-CommitteeCommittee MemberJul 20263
Planning CommitteeObserverMay 2026210 Dec 2026
Audit and Governance CommitteeDeputySep 20251
Committees with no meeting in the last year are shown faded.

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies