Named25 Jun 2026Planning Committee
Appointment of Members to Strategic Applications Sub-Committee
(3) Councillor Foulkes, Councillor Luxon-Kewley, Councillor Kenny, Councillor Gardner, Councillor Walsh-McDonald, and Councillor Kelly be appointed to the Strategic Applications Sub-Committee.
Moved25 Jun 2026Planning Committee
APP/26/00261 - The Links, 100 - 102 Meols Drive, West Kirby, Wirral, CH48 5DB
Councillor Andrew Gardner moved and the Chair, Councillor Stuart Kelly seconded a motion to refuse the application for the reasons set out below:
Declared16 Jun 2026Economy Regeneration & Housing Committee
Members' code of conduct - declarations of interest
Councillor Andrew Gardner declared a personal, non-pecuniary interest in Item 6 by virtue of having an offer on land which may be submitted in the Call for Sites process.
Declared16 Mar 2026Council
Declarations of interest
Councillor Andrew Gardner declared a personal non prejudicial interest by virtue of having a family member who is a veteran of the Armed Forces.
Named16 Mar 2026Council
Declarations of interest
Councillor Andrew Gardner, Helen Raymond and Ed Lamb declared personal non prejudicial interests in agenda item 5 by virtue of owing rental property in Wirral.
Declared5 Feb 2026Planning Committee
Members' code of conduct - declarations of interest
Councillor Andrew Gardner declared a personal interest in relation to item six, (APP/21/02199, Caldy Sports Club, Telegraph Road, Caldy) as his brother was a member of Caldy Rugby Club and had previously coached players there and confirmed that he had not pre-determined the application.
Seconded5 Feb 2026Planning Committee
APP/22/01830 Suncroft, Cross Lane, Bebington, Wirral, CH63 3AL
On a motion proposed by the Chair, Councillor Stuart Kelly, seconded by Councillor Andrew Gardner, it was:
Seconded19 Jan 2026Economy Regeneration & Housing Committee
Egerton village
On a motion proposed by Councillor Pat Cleary, Seconded by Councillor Andrew Gardner, it was therefore:
Seconded1 Dec 2025Council
Motion 3 - SUPPORTING LOCAL BUSINESSES, SHOPS AND JOBS THROUGH PARKING POLICY
Councillor Jeff Green moved and Councillor Andrew Gardner seconded a motion submitted in accordance with standing order 13.
Seconded21 Oct 2025Economy Regeneration & Housing Committee
Outcome of the Review of the Joint Waste Local Plan for Merseyside and Halton
On a motion proposed by Councillor Mike Sullivan, seconded by Councillor Andrew Gardner, it was:
Seconded11 Sep 2025Planning Committee
APP/25/00209 - Oxton Cricket Club, Townfield Lane, Oxton, CH43 2LH
On a motion by the Vice-Chair, Councillor Steve Foulkes, and seconded by Councillor Andrew Gardner, it was:
Named13 Mar 2025Planning Committee
Changes to the scheme of delegation to officers for the determination of planning related matters
Councillor A Gardner arrived part way through this item and took no part in the debate or vote.
Seconded6 Feb 2025Planning Committee
APP/24/01535 - Park House, 17 Nelson Street, New Brighton, Wallasey, Wirral, CH45 1NG - Change of use to large House in Multiple Occupation
On a motion proposed by the Chair, seconded by Councillor Andrew Gardner, it was:
Declared16 Jan 2025Strategic Applications Sub Committee
Apologies
Councillor Andrew Gardner declared a personal interest in item 3 as he was a member of the Economy, Regeneration and Housing Committee where this development had been discussed but he retained an open mind on the subject.
Named9 Dec 2024Pensions Committee
Apologies
Councillor Jeff Green (Councillor Andrew Gardner deputising) Councillor Ruth Molyneux (Councillor Jo Bird deputising) Ruth Bennett, Liverpool Council Martin Bond, St Helen’s Council Christine Howard, Sefton Jon Rae, Non-District representative
Named7 Nov 2024Planning Committee
APP-24-00816 - WEST KIRBY GRAMMAR SCHOOL FOR GIRLS, GRAHAM ROAD, WEST KIRBY, WIRRAL, CH48 5DP - Proposed (isolated) demolition to enable the erection of a Sports Hall, 6th Form Centre with dining facilities and associated re-modelling works to facade, means of access, parking and landscaping
On a motion by Councillor Andrew Gardner, seconded by the Chair, Councillor Stuart Kelly, it was:
Seconded7 Nov 2024Planning Committee
APP-23-00334 - LAND AT POOL LANE BROMBOROUGH POOL - Refurbishment of existing building for use as a Sports Club including changing rooms, removal of a recent extension and alterations to windows and doors.
On a motion by the Chair, Councillor Stuart Kelly, seconded by Councillor Andrew Gardner that the public and community benefits arising from the development clearly outweigh the harm resulting from the partial loss of sports pitches caused by the car park and also outweigh the less than substantial harm to the conservation area arising from the car park, the benefits being noted as:
Seconded16 Sep 2024Economy Regeneration & Housing Committee
Egerton Village
Therefore, on a motion by the Chair, seconded by Councillor Andrew Gardner, it was – Resolved – That, under section 100 (A) (4) of the Local Government Act 1972, the public be excluded from the meeting during consideration of the following item of business on the grounds it involves the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined by paragraph 3 of Part I of Schedule 12A (as amended) to that Act. The Public Interest test has been applied and favours exclusion.
Seconded18 Jul 2024Planning Committee
App/23/01821 poulton victoria football ground, clayton lane, poulton, wallasey, wirral, ch44 5tb erection of a new function room at south-eastern edge of site (retrospective)
On a motion by the Chair, Seconded by Councillor Andrew Gardner, it was Resolved (unanimously) - That the application be approved subject to the following conditions:
Named14 Mar 2024Planning Committee
RVC/23/01413: 100 & 102 Meols Drive, CH48 5DB Section 73 application for the variation of condition 2 of consented scheme ref APP/20/01716 to remove basement and provide parking at ground level, together with internal layout alterations and to pick up an error in the approved South Elevation Plan
The Lead Principal Lawyer addressed the Committee and advised that Ward Councillor Andrew Gardner had sent apologies that he was unable to attend the meeting an read a representation that he had sent to the Committee.
Said8 Feb 2024Planning Committee
APP/22/00573; Farm, PARK ROAD, MEOLS, CH47 7BE, Conversion of an existing single storey hay barn into a 2 bedroom dwelling (resubmission of Application Number 21/01378 refused dated 15th October 2021)
Ward Councillor Andrew Gardner addressed the committee.
Moved9 Oct 2023Council
Clean air for a healthier wirral
This included a very successful workshop with interested stakeholders and experts from across the region held in Wirral earlier this year.’ As moved by Councillor Andrew Gardner and seconded by Councillor Jenny Johnson, to insert an additional paragraph at the end as follows:
Named11 Jul 2023Pensions Committee
Apologies
Roger Bannister, UNISON retired members representative Martin Bond, St Helens Council Councillor Chris Carubia , Wirral Council Councillor Tony Cox, Wirral Council Councillor Andrew Gardner , Wirral Council
Named7 Jun 2023Regulatory and General Purposes Committee
Apologies
The Vice-Chair confirmed apologies had been received from Councillors A Hodson (Chair) with Councillor I Lewis deputising, M Jordan with Councillor A Gardner deputising and R Pitt with Councillor D Kenny deputising.
Seconded7 Jun 2023Regulatory and General Purposes Committee
Conferment of the title of honorary alderman
On a motion by Councillor Mike Sullivan and seconded by Councillor Andrew Gardner it was – Resolved – That the conferment of the title of Honorary Alderman on former Councillors Tony Smith and Dave Mitchell be recommended to Council in accordance with Section 249(1) of the Local Government Act 1972.
Named24 May 2023Council
Civic mayor's announcements
It was further announced that Councillor Andrew Gardner was due to arrive once the meeting had commenced.
Named14 Mar 2023Environment, Climate Emergency and Transport Committee
West Kirby Flood Alleviation - Variation of Construction Phase Contract and Acceptance of Flood Defence Grant Funding
Councillor Andrew Gardner indicated that he was supportive of the motion and proposed a friendly amendment that the report be referred to the Audit & Risk Management Committee so that consideration can be given to reviewing concerns relating to the procurement of the construction contract and the increase in cost of the project. The Chair accepted this as a friendly amendment.
Seconded14 Mar 2023Environment, Climate Emergency and Transport Committee
Liverpool City Region's Zero Waste Strategic Framework 2040
Councillor Tony Cox moved an amendment, that the following sentence be added, ‘further and more comprehensive data to be provided and the strategic framework as set out in the appendix needs to have firm actions appended to points which were currently no more than high level aims.’ This was seconded by Councillor Andrew Gardner.
Seconded12 Jan 2023Planning Committee
LDP/22/01313; 52 Penkett Road, Liscard, Wallasey, Wirral, CH45 7QW, Proposed change of use from 7 bed residential dwelling to an Ofsted Registered Residential Children's Home, providing accommodation for up to four Looked After Children aged between 10-18.
On a motion by the Chair and seconded by Councillor Andrew Gardner it was – Resolved (9:0:1 abstention) – that the application be approved.
Moved30 Nov 2022Environment, Climate Emergency and Transport Committee
Pollinator Strategy
Councillor Andrew Gardner proposed a motion, seconded by Councillor Tony Cox that – Committee resolves that recognised official and affiliated park groups to the Council can be impacted in their work by “No Mow May” and such groups can apply for exemption from “No Mow May” providing that they produce a pollinator policy that will describe how they will otherwise prosper pollinators in lieu of “No Mow May”.
Named30 Nov 2022Environment, Climate Emergency and Transport Committee
Pollinator Strategy
The Committee moved to a vote on the motion from Councillor Andrew Gardner, it was put and lost (4:7).
Declared4 Aug 2022Planning Committee
Members' code of conduct - declarations of interest
Councillor Andrew Gardner declared a personal interest in item 6 and stated that he would leave the chamber during the discussion of this item.
Moved4 Aug 2022Planning Committee
APP/20/01716 100 and 102 Meols Drive, West Kirby CH48 5DB, Demolition of the existing dwellings on site and erection of a residential apartment building (Use Class C3) with associated parking, landscaping and access (Amended Scheme)
It was moved by Councillor Andrew Gardner and seconded by Councillor David Burgess-Joyce that the proposal be rejected on the grounds that it did not comply with Policy CH2 of Wirral’s Unitary Development Plan. The motion was put and lost (2:9).
Named4 Aug 2022Planning Committee
Failure to Comply with the Requirements of an Enforcement Notice at Thornton Manor, Manor Road, Thornton Hough Wirral
Councillor Andrew Gardner left the Chamber.
Seconded11 Jul 2022Council
Wirral Plan Update
Councillor Tom Anderson moved an amendment, which was seconded by Councillor Andrew Gardner, as follows:
Asked11 Jul 2022Council
Decisions taken since the last council meeting
Councillor Andrew Gardner asked a question of Councillor Liz Grey, in respect of minute item 67 of the Environment, Climate Emergency and Transport Committee, asking the Chair to confirm whether the Parking Strategy fell within the Terms of Reference of the Committee, whether the Strategy was in place and if not when it would be.
Seconded20 Jun 2022Environment, Climate Emergency and Transport Committee
Consultation on Proposed Car Parking Charges - Update Report
In light of the advice from Legal Services to defer consideration of the item as detailed in Minute Item 5, it was moved by the Chair, seconded by Councillor Andrew Gardner, that the item be deferred until the next meeting. The motion was put and agreed by assent. It was therefore – Resolved – That consideration of the item be deferred until the next meeting.
Named26 Jan 2022Economy Regeneration & Housing Committee
Apologies
Councillor Andrew Gardner gave apologies and was deputised by Councillor Max Booth.
Named16 Dec 2021Planning Committee
APP/21/01371; 11 CALDY ROAD, WEST KIRBY, CH48 2HE Proposal: Demolition of the existing dwelling and outbuildings and the erection of a detached building containing 6 apartments with associated access, parking and landscaping.
On motion by Councillor Andrew Gardner, seconded by Councillor Kathy Hodson it was – Resolved (7:3) – that the application be refused on the following grounds.
Asked22 Nov 2021Economy Regeneration & Housing Committee
Acquisition of former Co-op building - 100 New Chester Road, New Ferry
Councillor Andrew Gardner queried the valuation of £700k and asked why the Council were looking to pay this, when the premises had failed to sell in the open market. The Assistant Director advised that the original asking price was £1.5 Million and if acquired with the adjacent site there would in valuation terms be a ‘marriage value.’ .
Seconded18 Oct 2021Council
Motion - Spartina Anglica Risks to the North Wirral Foreshore
Councillor Tony Cox moved and Councillor Andrew Gardner seconded the following motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 13.1.
Asked6 Sep 2021Council
Decisions taken since the last council meeting
Councillor Andrew Gardner asked a question of Councillor Julie McManus in respect of minute 6 of the Housing Committee,10 March 2021 referencing government plans for affordable housing and whether the housing needs of the most deprived people in the Borough were being met.
Declared10 Jun 2021Planning Committee
Members' code of conduct - declarations of interest
Councillor A Gardner declared a prejudicial interest in respect of item 5 by virtue of having previously carried out a building survey on the property for the applicant and would withdraw from the Chamber during the discussion and debate on that item.
Named10 Jun 2021Planning Committee
APP/21/00016: 20 BEACON DRIVE, NEWTON, CH48 7ED - Erection of two storey extensions (to the front, rear and side); Extensions to existing dormers alongside the introduction of x1 new front dormer; erection of x2 balconies to the rear elevation
Having previously declared a prejudicial interest in connection to this item, Councillor A Gardner left the room during consideration.
Declared18 Mar 2021Planning Committee
Members' code of conduct - declarations of interest
Councillor A Gardner declared a personal interest in respect of Item 3 – APP/20/00891: Land at Chicken Corner Farm, Raby Mere Road, Raby – by virtue of being acquainted with the applicant’s agent (minute 36 refers).
Declared18 Mar 2021Planning Committee
App/20/00891: land at chicken corner farm, raby mere road, raby, ch63 4jq - demolition and removal of existing commercial buildings and structures (use classes b1, b2, b8, d2 and sui generis) and the erection of six dwellings (use class c3)
Councillor A Gardner declared a personal interest in this matter (minute 33 refers).
Declared4 Mar 2021Economy Regeneration & Housing Committee
Members' code of conduct - declarations of interest
Councillor Andrew Gardner declared a Disclosable Pecuniary Interest in item 12 (Minute 39) (Wirral Ways to Work) as Involve Northwest were a professional client of his.
Named4 Mar 2021Economy Regeneration & Housing Committee
Wirral Ways to Work
Councillor Andrew Gardner, having declared a Disclosable Pecuniary Interest, left the meeting for the debate and vote.
Seconded11 Feb 2021Planning Committee
APP/20/01065 - Land to the rear of 9 & 10 COPSE GROVE, IRBY, CH61 4YP
It was moved by the Chair and seconded by Councillor A Gardner that the application be refused.
Named14 Jan 2021Planning Committee
APP/20/00720: Teviot Bank, 6 COTTAGE LANE, GAYTON, CH60 8PB - Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of building containing 8 No. apartments, with associated landscaping, parking, bike store and bin store
Councillor A Gardner lost connection during consideration of this matter and therefore (having regard to the LLG Remote Meetings Protocol and Procedure Rules) took no part in the decision and was unable to vote on this matter as he had not heard all the facts.
Seconded14 Jan 2021Planning Committee
APP/20/01435: Mill House, BLAKELEY ROAD, RABY MERE, CH63 0LZ - Alterations to existing boundary fencing and entrance gates.
It was moved by Councillor M Jordan and seconded by Councillor A Gardner that the application be refused for the following reason:
Seconded7 Dec 2020Council
Motion - Supporting Car Clubs in Wirral
· A survey of the current provision of car clubs in the Liverpool City Region · An analysis of council support for car clubs elsewhere in the country and the potential application of similar support in Wirral · Recommendations as to the specific policies and measures required to help facilitate future car club provision in Wirral” Councillor David Burgess-Joyce moved and Councillor Andrew Gardner seconded the following amendment, submitted in accordance with Standing Order 13.3:
Named21 Aug 2020Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Call-in Hoylake Beach Management
Explanation of Call-In by the Lead Signatory The delegated decision made on 13 th March 2020 had been called in, with Councillor Andrew Gardner as the lead signatory setting out the reasons for bringing this matter before the Environment Overview & Scrutiny Committee.
Said21 Aug 2020Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Call-in Hoylake Beach Management
• the decision is ill conceived and ideologically motivated rather than being based on Wirral residents’ wishes • no consultation has taken place with residents • it breaks a current agreement (The 2010 Hoylake Beach Management Agreement) with a national body who have not consented to such and • the decision becomes an irreversible, predetermined outcome due to the nature of the beach itself Councillor Andrew Gardner, as lead signatory, added that Natural England guidance did not prohibit raking of the beach and that the Council should continue to adhere to the aforementioned existing beach management plan until 2021.
Said21 Aug 2020Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Call-in Hoylake Beach Management
Councillor Gardner stated that the beach is a dynamic, natural area which has historically been impacted by cycles of sand accretion and, although it is impossible to know what the future will hold, there were immediate issues with drainage and an uncertainty about how stopping current management techniques will impact the area.
Said21 Aug 2020Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Call-in Hoylake Beach Management
Councillor Gardner responded to Members’ questions, particularly noting that he did not believe that there was any indication from Natural England that the Council would be prohibited from raking the beach and that he believed that management should continue as before and reassessed in 2021.
Said21 Aug 2020Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Call-in Hoylake Beach Management
In response to a Member question, Councillor Gardner advised the Committee that local ward councillors had received a large volume of contact from local residents regarding the management of the beach and, according to a questionnaire sent to residents as part of political campaigning in 2018, the majority of local people were in favour of retaining a sandy beach – a point opposed by a number of Members who questioned the validity and impartiality of the questionnaire.
Named21 Aug 2020Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Call-in Hoylake Beach Management
In response to Member questioning, Councillor Gardner clarified his position that the currently managed beach area was the only amenity space for Hoylake residents and that allowing this part of the beach to become overgrown with saltmarsh and vegetation had a tangible impact on the wellbeing of the local community.
Named21 Aug 2020Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Call-in Hoylake Beach Management
In addition, Councillor Gardner reaffirmed that Natural England guidance regarding conservation related only to the ‘intertidal’ area and that there was no reason why a small proportion of ... view the full minutes text for item 53.
Declared4 Mar 2020Business Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Members' Code of Conduct - Declarations of Interest / Party Whip
Councillor Andrew Gardner declared a personal interest in respect of agenda item 5, ‘NNDR and Business Rates Retention’ by virtue of his business.
Said13 Jan 2020Council
Declarations of interest
Councillor Andrew Gardner expressed a prejudicial interest in item 3a (Wirral Local Plan) because of elements of his professional work and would leave the chamber whilst the item was debated.
Declared4 Nov 2019Pensions Committee
Members' Code of Conduct - Declarations of Interest
Councillor Andrew Gardner declared a pecuniary interest by virtue of being a member of Merseyside Pension Fund.
Named14 Oct 2019Council
Petitions
Councillor Andrew Gardener 844 Petition to maintain grass free beaches at Hoylake Councillor Andrew Gardner 1546 Petition to allow 2 hours free parking for the council carparks in West Kirby.
Named18 Jul 2019Planning Committee
ANY OTHER URGENT BUSINESS ACCEPTED BY THE CHAIR - Wirral's Local Plan - Review and Development of Development Management Policies
Labour; Councillor S Foulkes, Councillor G Davies, Councillor S Whittingham, Councillor S Frost Conservative; Councillor G Watt, Councillor A Gardner, Councillor I Lewis Green Party; Councillor S Hayes Liberal Democrats; Councillor S Kelly On a motion by the Chair and seconded by the Vice Chair it was – Resolved (13:0) – That a sub-committee comprising 9 members of the Planning Committee be established to make appropriate recommendations to the Cabinet in the formulation of the Local Development Framework for the Borough.
Declared16 Jul 2019Pensions Committee
Members' Code of Conduct - Declarations of Interest
Councillor Andrew Gardner declared a pecuniary interest by virtue of being a member of Merseyside Pension Fund.
Seconded4 Jul 2019Business Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Appointment of Vice-Chair
It was moved by Councillor George Davies and seconded by Councillor Steve Foulkes, that – “Councillor Jo Bird be appointed Vice-Chair of this Committee.” It was then moved by Councillor Tony Cox and seconded by Councillor Andrew Gardner, that – “Councillor Steve Williams be appointed Vice-Chair of this Committee.” The first motion was put and carried (6:5) (One abstention).
Moved20 Jun 2019Planning Committee
App/19/00431: westways, 16 lingdale road, west kirby ch48 5dq
It was moved by Councillor A Gardner and seconded by Councillor K Hodson that the application be refused.
Declared25 Mar 2019Pensions Committee
Members' Code of Conduct - Declarations of Interest
Councillor Andrew Gardner declared a pecuniary interest by virtue of being a member of Merseyside Pension Fund.
Asked10 Dec 2018Council
Leader's, executive members' and chairs reports
Councillor Andrew Gardner asked a question of Councillor George Davies, Cabinet Member Housing and Planning regarding Government guidance on housing numbers did not represent a mandatory target, and was simply a starting point for local authorities to work within its boundaries and other constraints such as green belt.
Seconded10 Dec 2018Council
Motion - Climate Emergency
· writes to inform the Prime Minister that Wirral has declared a climate emergency.” First Amendment Councillor Adam Sykes moved and Councillor Andrew Gardner seconded the following amendment submitted in accordance with Standing Order 12(9) such that the Motion be approved subject to – Delete “establish an Overview and Scrutiny Committee working group, with a remit to (i). Seek advice from experts to develop a robust carbon budget and set a challenging target date for carbon neutrality in Wirral;
Moved10 Dec 2018Council
Motion - Time to end the Hoylake Golf Course Development
Councillor Andrew Gardner moved and Councillor Gerry Ellis seconded the following amendment submitted in accordance with Standing Order 12(9) such that the Motion be approved subject to – Delete from paragraph 4 ‘ looks increasingly unviable.’ a nd insert ‘is best left to private sector financiers.’ Alter the final paragraph after ‘Leader and Cabinet’ to:
Seconded10 Dec 2018Council
Motion - Police Crime Commissioners to rethink Policing priorities in the interests of Wirral residents
Councillor Tony Cox moved and Councillor Andrew Gardner seconded the following Motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 7 – “As the person with sole responsibility for policing priority in Merseyside, Council recognises that the position of PCC is an onerous role.
Declared29 Oct 2018Pensions Committee
Members' Code of Conduct - Declarations of Interest
Councillor Andrew Gardner declared a pecuniary interest by virtue of being a member of Merseyside Pension Fund.
Moved15 Oct 2018Council
Motion - uts foundation, hoylake
Councillor Andrew Gardner moved and Councillor Tony Cox seconded the following Motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 7 – (1) Council acknowledges the efforts of the UTS Foundation in Hoylake in its work in helping improve the lives of Wirral residents.
Said4 Oct 2018Constituency Committee - Wirral West
Road Safety Update
Councillor Andrew Gardner stated that Heron Road is the biggest issue in his area. He stated that the ongoing issue was the high number of accidents that would be considered of ‘low seriousness’ by the police. He continued that there is so much likelihood of a low-level accident that it is only a matter of time before someone is seriously hurt or killed.
Declared16 Jul 2018Pensions Committee
Members' Code of Conduct - Declarations of Interest
Councillor Andrew Gardner declared a pecuniary interest by virtue of being a member of Merseyside Pension Fund.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.