Members' Questions
Councillor Cleary asked the Chair of the Planning Committee about the use of lawful development certificates for smaller HMOs and whether this represented a loophole in planning policy.
Every time Wirral's minutes name Councillor Cleary, as the council published it.
Councillor Cleary asked the Chair of the Planning Committee about the use of lawful development certificates for smaller HMOs and whether this represented a loophole in planning policy.
Councillor Cleary asked the Chair of the Planning Committee how much Biodiversity Net Gain funding arising from two recent planning approvals would be spent within Wirral.
Councillor Ewan Tomeny moved a further amendment, seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary, in accordance with Standing Order 13.3 as follows:
Following a discussion regarding the public statement made earlier in the meeting, with Members seeking assurance that they had considered all relevant information before reaching a final decision, Councillor Pat Cleary, seconded by Gail Jenkinson, moved an amendment requesting that the Make Hamilton funding request also be reviewed in light of the additional information provided to the Committee. The amendment was accepted by the proposer and seconder of the original motion.
Councillor Gail Jenkinson, seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary, proposed a further amendment to Recommendation 6 to require that any delegated decisions relating to future allocations be undertaken by the Chief Executive in consultation with the Chair and Group Spokespersons of the Committee. The amendment was accepted by the proposer and seconder of the original motion.
It was then moved by Councillor Ruth Molyneux and seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary that, Council is recommended to authorise the Monitoring Officer as proper officer to carry out the wishes of the Political Groups in allocating appoint the following Members as Chairs and Vice Chairs of all other Committees, listed below, other than those which the Council has decided should be appointed by the committee itself, in accordance with the following group allocations:
Councillor Pat Cleary, referring to the LCR’s announcement on 10 March 2026 of a £2 billion investment fund aimed at unlocking development, job creation and housing delivery.
Councillor Pat Cleary moved and Councillor Judith Greer seconded a motion submitted in accordance with standing order 13.
Councillor Ed Lamb moved an amendment, seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary that, Delete the recommendation and replace with the following:
Councillor Pat Cleary proposed a motion based upon the officer recommendations which included additional wording to the effect that the Director of Law and Corporate Services be authorised to approve the novation of the grant funding agreement in consultation with the Chair and Party Spokespersons of the Committee.
On a motion proposed by Councillor Pat Cleary, Seconded by Councillor Andrew Gardner, it was therefore:
Cllr R Molyneux was deputising for Cllr P Cleary.
The proposal was seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary.
The Civic Mayor advised Members there were amendments to the appointment of Committees by the Green Group which had been circulated to Members prior to the meeting It was then moved by Councillor Pat Cleary, Seconded by Councillor Jo Bird that, Council is recommended to authorise the Monitoring Officer to allocate seats as identified in appendix one of the council summons as detailed below:
It was then moved by Councillor Jo Bird and seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary that, Council is recommended to authorise the Monitoring Officer as proper Officer to allocate the Chairs and Vice Chairs of all other Council committees, listed below, other than those which the Council has decided should be appointed by the committee itself, in accordance with the following group allocations COMMITTEE CHAIR VICE -CHAIR Policy and Resources Labour Labour Adult Social Care and Public Health Green Lib Dem Children Young People and Education Labour Gre en Economy, Regen and Housing Labour C onservative Environment, Climate Emergency and Transport Labour Conservative Tourism, Communities, Culture and Leisure Conservative Labour Audit and Risk Management Green Labour Pensions Labour Green Planning Lib Dem Labour Regulatory and General Purposes Conservative Labour Total 5:2:2:1 5:2:2:1 Following a number of members speaking to the amendment, it was put to the vote and lost (20:42) 1 Abstention.
Further to a debate, with officers responding to the comments raised, a motion was made by Councillor Jo Bird, Seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary that, That be referred to the next meeting of the Tourism, Communities, Culture and Leisure Committee for consideration and to allow for further consultation with the Council for Voluntary Service (CVF) and other third sector organisations .
A discussion was held by Members regarding the report and recommendations further to which a motion was proposed by Councillor Jo Bird, Seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary that the following text be added to recommendation iii, iii. implement any necessary change control process in consultation with Economy, Regeneration & Housing Committee’s Chair and group spokespersons and in line with the council’s scheme of delegation thresholds.
Councillors Bird formally moved the Green Group Amendment which was seconded by Councillor Cleary.
It was then moved by Councillor Pat Cleary, seconded by Councillor Jo Bird, that, Inset additional recommendation (1):
Councillor Judith Grier moved and Councillor Pat Cleary seconded a motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 13.
On a motion proposed by Councillor Pat Cleary, seconded by Councillor Chris Carubia, it was:
Councillor Cleary moved and Councillor Jenkinson seconded their motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 13.
Cllr Ann Ainsworth - Cllr Mike Sullivan deputising Cllr Pat Cleary – Jo Bird subbing Roger Bannister, retired members Ruth Bennett, Liverpool Council Christine Howard, Sefton Council
The Civic Mayor then advised that an amendment had been received by the Green Group and it was then moved by Councillor Jo Bird, Seconded by Councillor Gail Jenkinson that, Cllr Stephen Bennett be appointed as Chair of Children, Young People and Education Committee Cllr Pat Cleary be appointed as Chair of Pensions in place of Cllr Stephen Bennett The Monitoring Officer be authorised as proper officer to carry out the wishes of the Group Leaders in allocating Members to membership and substitute membership of any affected committees as a result of the change in Committee Chairs with effect from the date at which the proper officer is advised of the names of such Members.
It was moved by Councillor Tony Cox, seconded by Councillor Phil Gilchrist, that the recommendations as detailed in the report be agreed It was then moved by Councillor Pat Cleary, seconded by Councillor Jo Bird, that, ‘In addition to the recommendations detailed in the report, that a further recommendation 3 be included, (3) That in respect to Part 3(B) Responsibility for Functions – (B) Committees, an additional paragraph be included as follows - All committees adhere to the requirements of Section 15 (as amended) of the Local Government and Housing Act 1989 in their composition for political proportionality. In the appointment of Chairs and Vice Chairs, the Council chooses to apply the principle of proportionality so that the number of Chairs and Vice Chairs appointed represents the same proportionality as its council membership.’ Following a number of members talking to the amendment, a number of Members rose to request a recorded vote on the amendment in accordance with Standing Order 17.4 as follows, For (14) Councillors Jo Bird, Pat Cleary, Chris Cooke, Harry Gorman, Naomi Graham, Judith Grier, Gail Jenkinson, Ed Lamb, Craig McDonald, Ruth Molyneux, Kieran Murphy, Amanda Onwuemene, Ewan Tomeny and Jason Walsh Against (46) Councillors Ann Ainsworth, Colin Baldwin, Paula Basnett, Gary Bennett, Stephen Bennett, Max Booth, Allan Brame, Helen Cameron, Chris Carubia, Tony Cox, Angie Davies, George Davies, Steve Foulkes, Gardener Phil Gilchrist, Jeff Green, Liz Grey, Brenda H
An amendment was then moved by Councillor Jo Bird and Seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary that allocation of committee places be amended as set out in the Council Summons Supplement (pt 2) Following a number of members speaking to the amendment, the amendment was put to the vote and lost (14:46) (1 abstention). The original motion was then put to the vote and was carried (46:14) (1 abstention). It was therefore – Resolved, that – (1) the formation of those Committees set out in Part 3(B) of the revised Constitution be agreed and seats on the Committees be allocated as set out in Appendix 1.
Group Leaders, Councillor Jeff Green, Councillor Pat Cleary and Councillor Phil Gilchrist echoed this
Councillor Jo Bird moved and Councillor Pat Cleary seconded a motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 13.
Councillor Pat Cleary, as Leader of the Green Group, then addressed the Council on the budget proposals.
Councillor Pat Cleary moved and Councillor Gail Jenkinson seconded the following amendment, submitted in accordance with Standing Order 14.g (1) Agree that the overall number of seats be reduced from 114 to 113 as set out in paragraph 3.1.7.
Councillor Pat Cleary then proposed an amendment, seconded by Councillor Jo Bird, in respect to recommendation 4 (d) which was to delete the words “finance sub-committee” and replace them with “the relevant Policy and Service Committee”.
Councillor Cleary moved, seconded by Councillor Molyneux; that the Responsible Investment Working Party be established as discussed and that it consider the issue of Merseyside pension fund investments in arms companies and bring a report to the committee within the next six months.
Councillor Pat Cleary asked a question to Councillor Jenny Johnson as Chair of Audit and Risk Management Committee regarding the exercise being undertaken to evaluate the effectiveness and efficiency of programme governance within the regeneration progress, and sought an update on when it would be reported back to the Audit and Risk Management Committee.
Councillor Tony Jones and Councillor Pat Cleary declared a non-prejudicial interest by virtue of their membership on the Town Team Board.
Members were informed that Councillor Pat Cleary wished to move an amendment.
Councillor Cleary spoke to his amendment and discussed the value of the previously established Town Deal Board, noting that it was an effective forum for scrutinising and improving proposals and that the expansion due to the pathfinder pilot was a positive step.
Councillor Cleary commented that there was a good template in the Town Deal Board but felt it should be extended to include new areas now included within the levelling up funds.
To consider the motion, the meeting adjourned at 6:52pm The meeting reconvened at 7:00pm A motion was then formally put by Councillor Pat Cleary, seconded by Councillor Jo Bird ‘Committee recognises the positive work of the Towns Deal Board to date. Taking account of the clear guidance from DHLUC in establishing a successor Pathfinder Board this committee agrees;
Councillor Pat Cleary in hs capacity as a member of public asked when a report on Mass Transit would be received by councillors and when work was likely to start on any solutions.
Councillor Cleary asked a supplementary question seeking assurance that a report on Mass Transit would be delivered to Members no later than February 2024.
Council requests the Leader of the Council and Party leaders to write to Israel’s Ambassador to the UK, Tzipi Hotovely, expressing our deepest sympathy for all those who were murdered and confirms Council’s continuing support for Israel’s right to exist and defend itself.’ Councillor Pat Cleary moved and Councillor Jo Bird seconded the following amendment:
An amendment was then moved by Councillor Pat Cleary, seconded by Councillor Jo Bird, that the officer recommendations be agreed with the following two further resolutions:
Following a discussion, the proposal was formally moved by Councillor Jo Bird and seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary. The motion was put the vote and lost (4:11). The Chair then sought the Committee’s agreement to note the work programme.
On a motion by the Chair, seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary, it was – Resolved – That (2) Holborn Square be referred to the relevant Policy and Services Committee to consider the potential for a Community Asset Transfer.
Following a discussion, it was moved by Councillor Jo Bird, seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary, that the officer recommendations in the report be agreed, with the inclusion of an addition resolution ‘that the Council, in consultation with the other shareholder, request Edsential to prioritise the payment of the Real Living Wage within the overall benefits package for employees, and to present options to the shareholders to this effect in the future.’ The Chair sought the input of the Director of Finance on the implications of the motion, where he advised if both shareholders insisted that the Real Living Wage was paid, Edsential would likely have to change their pricing structure accordingly. To ensure the business remained in a solvent position, the costs would need to be passed onto schools who could potentially look elsewhere for those services, potentially leading to the decline of the business.
Councillor Pat Cleary asked a question to the Chair of the Economy, Regeneration and Housing Committee in relation to minute item 63 of the meeting held on 8 March 2023 outlining concerns over the delivery of the regeneration programme and seeking an update on planned meetings of the Regeneration Working Group to ensure member oversight.
Councillor Pat Cleary moved and Councillor Judith Grier seconded a motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 13.
Following a debate, and Councillor Pat Cleary having replied as mover of the motion, it was – Resolved (unanimously) – That Council notes the harmful effects of the use of gill nets upon fishing populations and other marine life, especially Porpoises and fish-eating birds such as Grebes and Divers.
It was then moved by Councillor Jo Bird, seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary, that ‘In addition to the amendments identified in the report, that the Constitution be further amended in the following way:
It was moved by Councillor Pat Cleary, seconded by Councillor Harry Gorman, that Councillor Pat Cleary be elected.
Councillor Pat Cleary suggested an addition to the officer recommendations, so that the second recommendation included an additional sentence: ‘This report to include a list of and details around the options available to the council regarding the future provision of services provided by .’ Councillor Jenny Johnson suggested an alteration to the officer recommendation, to delete reference to Shareholder Board as she felt the matter warranted further consideration by Policy and Resources Committee.
Councillor Pat Cleary presented a petition with 84 signatures against planning application APP/22/02189.
Councillor Pat Cleary presented a second petition with 154 signatures requesting additional measure to deal with anti-social behaviour taking place outside St Werburgh’s Church in Birkenhead.
Councillor Pat Cleary asked the Chair of Environment, Climate Emergency and Transport Committee, Councillor Liz Grey, a question regarding a new capital grants scheme from Natural England to enhance habitats that protect endangered species and asked whether Councillor Grey would request that officers submit a bid for this funding.
Councillor Pat Cleary asked a supplementary question seeking clarification from Cllr Liz Grey that she expected a bid to be submitted.
Councillor Pat Cleary, as Leader of the Green Group , then addressed the Council on the budget proposals.
It was moved by Councillor Pat Cleary, seconded by Councillor Jo Bird, that the officer recommendations be agreed, with the inclusion of an additional resolution – ‘The composition of the Policy & Resources budget working group should be Leaders and Deputy Leaders of each of the Political Groups represented on the Policy & Resources Committee, or in their absence their deputies, as appointed by their Group Leader.’ Following a discussion in which Councillor Cleary spoke to the additional resolution, the motion was put and agreed (unanimously). It was therefore – Resolved (unanimously) – That 1. the outcome of the Provisional Local Government Financial Settlement for 2023/24 be noted, in advance of the Final Settlement which is expected in late January/early February 2023.
The Civic Mayor informed the Council that one petition had been received from Councillor Pat Cleary in relation to speed and weight restrictions for Price Street, Birkenhead.
Councillor Cleary presented the petition with over 200 signatures, seeking the Council to acknowledge the regular excess speed of vehicles on Price Street, the high volume of large vehicles, the danger to residents and their calls for action.
The following amendment was then moved by Councillor Jo Bird, seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary – At paragraph 2.
It was moved by Councillor Jo Bird, seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary, that the matter be referred to Policy and Resources Committee.
In the absence of the Leader of the Council, Councillor Pat Cleary asked a question of Councillor Jean Robinson, in respect of minute item 21 of Policy & Resources Committee, raising concerns in relation to delays to the implementation of active travel schemes and seeking views as to how Councillors from all parties could unblock the logjam and progress the schemes.
Insert new paragraph after paragraph 2 : ‘Council notes the work of various officers and their continued co-operation with elected members during this time.’ Councillor Rennie also confirmed that she was happy to accept the Green Group amendment, which was moved by Councillor Naomi Graham, and seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary as follows:
It was moved by Councillor Jo Bird, seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary, that the recommendations within the report be agreed, subject to the inclusion of the following – “A further report be submitted to Policy & Resources Committee, by its first meeting in September, regarding the Real Living Wage being paid to all workers delivering Council services.” Further information was sought from the Director of Resources, who informed the Committee that the feasibility of the proposal had been undertaken with an estimated cost to the Council of £600k to £1.2m, which was considered to be unaffordable, therefore any report that would be submitted to the Policy & Resources Committee as a consequence of the motion would advise the Committee that the proposal was not affordable.
Councillor Jo Bird asked a question of Councillor Pat Cleary in respect of minute 47 of the Pensions Committee of 23 February, 2022 regarding responsible investment and human rights.
Councillor Pat Cleary responded that Merseyside Pension Fund (MPF) was actively working to address its exposure to investment linked to Russia and to fully comply with UK sanctions. However with the Russian stock market closed and additionally foreign investors had been banned from selling by the Russian authorities, one of just several complicating factors. The implications of sanctions which the MPF needed to understand as they precluded most financial transactions with Russian entities.
Insert new paragraph after "(h) ....Greenbelt where those sites are within it." (i) That the savings proposal listed at Appendix 2 headed “Temporary Closure and Remodelling of Bidston Tennis Centre” be amended to reduce the savings proposals so as to make sufficient monies available to enable Bidston Tennis Centre to continue to operate until 31 March 2023 whilst public consultation and further discussions take place with the Lawn Tennis Association; which will provide a reduction of in-year savings of £114k.” GREEN GROUP AMENDMENTS The Green Group amendments were then formally moved by Councillor Pat Cleary and seconded by Councillor Jason Walsh, as follows:
The recommendations were moved by Councillor Pat Cleary and seconded by Councillor Brian Kenny.
Minutes of the previous Northern LGPS Joint Committee meeting were appended for noting It was moved by Councillor Pat Cleary and seconded by Councillor Joe Walsh.
It was moved by Councillor Pat Cleary and seconded by Councillor Jo Bird.
It was moved by Councillor Pat Cleary and seconded by Councillor Joe Walsh.
Councillor Pat Cleary presented a petition of some 72 signatories regarding pedestrian access to Mersey Park, Tranmere.
Councillor Pat Cleary asked a question on behalf of Councillor Emily Gleaves (who had given her apologies) of Councillor Tony Jones regarding the internal layout of Birkenhead Market and Market Traders’ proposals for a reorganisation.
It was moved by Councillor Janette Williamson and seconded by Councillor Yvonne Nolan, that Council – “(a) agree the revised proportionality in the political composition of membership of ordinary committees of the Council as set out at Appendix A of the Director of Law and Governance’s report; and (b) appoint Councillor Jo Bird to sit on the Council’s Regulatory and General Purposes Committee and Licensing Act Committee and the Pensions Committee.” It was moved as an amendment by Councillor Jo Bird, and seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary, that – “Replace: ‘ (b) appoint Councillor Jo Bird to sit on the Council’s Regulatory and General Purposes Committee and Licensing Act Committee and the Pensions Committee’ with: ‘ (b) appoint Councillor Jo Bird to sit on the Housing Committee and Pensions Committee.’” Following a short debate and Councillor Williamson having replied, the Civic Mayor then allowed Councillor Bird to make a short personal statement to the Council.
The Chair welcomed Members of the Local Pension Board, Councillor Pat Cleary, Chair of the Pensions Committee and viewing members of the public to the meeting. It was noted that this meeting was being held remotely in consultation with the legal advisor and the Director of Pensions due to current restrictions and it was hoped that the Local Pensions Board would be able to resume face to face meetings as soon as possible.
Councillor P Cleary, Chair of Pensions Committee addressed the Board and thanked the Director of Pensions for his work in engaging with the Committee and the Board by way of organising a workshop for Members of the Committee and Board to attend.
On a motion by Councillor P Cleary and seconded by Councillor J Green it was:
It was moved by Councillor P Cleary and seconded by Councillor J Green and Resolved – That the Pensions Committee note the minutes of the Local Pensions Board.
It was moved by Councillor Cleary and seconded by Councillor Jones and
It was moved by Councillor P Cleary and seconded by Councillor J Green and Resolved – That the Pensions Committee approve the minutes of the working party meetings.
On a motion by the Chair, seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary, it was - Resolved - That the Budget Workshop feedback and outcomes, as detailed in appendix 1, be agreed and be reported to Policy and Resources Committee for consideration.
Councillor Pat Cleary requested an amendment to minute 39, ‘Motion – Creating Low Traffic Streets and Neighbourhoods Across Wirral’, as it was he, not Councillor Harry Gorman who had moved the motion.
Councillor Harry Gorman moved and Councillor Pat Cleary seconded a motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 13.
On a motion moved by Councillor Jannette Williamson, seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary it was – Resolved (3:2):
The motion was formally moved by Councillor Janette Williamson and seconded by Councillor Yvonne Nolan Before moving to debate the Civic Mayor made Council aware of an amendment moved by Councillor Cleary and seconded by Councillor Grey, ‘ Delivering a robust Active Travel strategy and Road Safety plan at pace for all of Wirral is fundamental to achieving our policy objectives on climate, air quality and health. These issues cut across various aspects of council activities. Successful outcomes will rely on active engagement across several committees.
Remove section 2 from Safe and Pleasant Communities and place the items clearly within the Sustainable Environment part of the Delivery Plan.’ After a debate Councillor Janette Williamson spoke to the amendment to confirm she had no particular issue with it, however was concerned around some of the language used by Councillor Cleary when speaking to the amendment about it being outdated.
Councillor Pat Cleary moved and Councillor Chris Cooke seconded a motion submitted in accordance with standing order 13:
This was seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary and was put to the vote but lost (2 for, 12 against and 1 abstention) The meeting adjourned for 10 minutes.
This was unsupported by Councillor Pat Cleary as there was no evidence available of this.
Councillor Pat Cleary had sent his apologies and Councillor Chris Cooke was deputising for him.
It was moved by Councillor Pat Cleary and seconded by the Chair, that an addition to the recommendations contained in the report, be made as follows:
Councillor Pat Cleary, Chair of the Pensions Committee, attended the meeting and addressed members. He offered his thanks to all members of the Board for their diligence and attention to detail and noted that the meeting had been very interesting.
Councillor Cleary referenced the areas of Climate Risk, Training and IMWP meetings commenting that it was pleasing to note that members of the Board had been attending Working Party meetings as observers. He hoped that if the limit on the numbers of observers could be relaxed that more members could be encouraged to attend.
Councillor Cleary further commented that the Pensions Committee was impressed by the work done by officers such as the introduction of CEM Benchmarking and noted that the Pensions Committee was grateful for the positive work that Board members do. He concluded by thanking all Board Members for their input in the meeting.
Councillor Chris Cooke moved and Councillor Pat Cleary seconded a motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 13.
Councillor Cleary referred to a specific condition (No.9) made by the Planning Committee in its approval of the development, which was not referred to in the report, and the need to ensure this along with the other conditions was implemented, this condition stated that:
After a lengthy debate and the Director having responded to questions from Members, it was moved by the Vice-Chair, seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary and then - Resolved (12:5) – That, (1) the Director of Law and Governance be authorised to acquire, on behalf of the Council, the site identified in the report for the sum as referred to in the report;
Councillor Pat Cleary asked a question of the Chair of the Environment, Climate Emergency and Transport Committee on the rollout of Carbon Literacy Training across the Council.
Councillor Elizabeth Grey responded accordingly and informed Councillor Cleary that up to 10 December, five courses had been held with 16 Members attending and with Wirral working towards a silver rating.
Councillor Pat Cleary moved and Councillor Chris Cooke seconded the following motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 13:
Councillor Elizabeth Grey moved and Councillor Pat Cleary seconded a Motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 13.
Following a short debate it was moved by Councillor Anita Leech, seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary and then - A. RECOMMENDED (unanimously) – That Council is requested to remove from political balance requirements in accordance with the requirements of the Local Government Housing Act 1989, the Local Plan Steering Sub Committee, at section 1.7 of Part 3(B) of the constitution , so that it be constituted in a manner that reflects the membership of the Local Plan Advisory Group, being one member from each political group on the Council. It is noted that the Chair of the Sub-Committee has been appointed at the Annual Meeting of Council.
In respect of the appointment to the Liverpool City Region Transport Committee, it was moved by Councillor Phil Gilchrist and seconded by Councillor Chris Carubia, that, “Councillor Dave Mitchell be appointed to the fourth position on the LCR Transport Committee.” It was moved by Councillor Chris Cooke and seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary, that, “Councillor Pat Cleary be appointed to the fourth position on the LCR Transport Committee.” The Director of Law and Governance, in response to a Member’s question, advised the Council that he had sought advice from the Combined Authority’s Monitoring Officer in respect of this appointment, and that it had been confirmed that it was entirely a matter for each Local Authority who was appointed with there being no requirement for political balance for the four places allocated to Wirral Council.
Resolved (33:28) (One abstention) – That Councillor Pat Cleary be appointed to the final position on the Transport Committee of the Liverpool City Region Combined Authority.
The Civic Mayor moved and it was seconded by Councillor George Davies, that, “The recommendations in the report be approved.” An amendment was moved by Councillor Pat Cleary, seconded by Councillor Chris Cooke, as follows:
Representations had also been received from Ward Councillors, Councillor Pat Cleary and Councillor Steve Hayes who supported the representations submitted by local residents. Copies of all representations were available.
Representations had also been received from Ward Councillors, Councillor Pat Cleary and Councillor Steve Hayes who both supported the representations submitted by local residents. Copies of all representations were available.
A local resident also attended the meeting by way of video conference together with Councillor Cleary, Ward Councillor.
The Licensing Manager confirmed that all documentation had been sent and received and that a local resident had requested that Councillor Cleary also speak on his behalf.
An amendment to the motion to approve the application was put by Councillor S Kelly and seconded by Councillor P Cleary as follows:
“The premises shall not be open for business outside the following hours:- 08:00 and 17:00 Monday to Friday” The amendment was put and carried (13:0) It was then moved by Councillor S Kelly and seconded by Councillor P Cleary and:
On a motion by Councillor Pat Hackett, seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary, it was - Resolved (36:0) - That the Council adopts the draft Remote Meetings Procedural Rules as appended to the Director of Law and Governance’s report, for use until 6 May 2021, if it continues to be necessary because of Coronavirus.
A local resident also attended the meeting together with Councillor P Cleary, Ward Councillor by way of video conference.
Councillor Pat Cleary asked a question of Councillor Pat Hackett regarding the planned children’s museum Eureka at Seacombe Ferry and what action had been taken to assess how visitors would travel and what viable public transport options there would be.
On a motion by Councillor Pat Cleary, seconded by Councillor Geoffrey Watt, it was - Resolved (57:0) (Two abstentions) - That the recommendation contained within minute 41 of the Pensions Committee, 4 November, 2019, be approved, as follows, that the revisions to the Pension Board’s terms of reference be adopted into the Council’s Constitution.
Councillor Pat Cleary voiced the views of the residents of Circular Road.
Councillor Cleary requested that it be raised at Business Overview and Scrutiny Committee; that members should have more training before putting forward proposals such as this, which may cause a divide between residents, specifically requesting they seek further involvement and opinions from outside bodies such as Merseyside Police before going forward with proposals.
Councillor Pat Cleary asked Councillor Tony Jones, Cabinet Member for Regeneration, if he felt there was a shortage of grade A office space locally as he had noticed such space available in Liverpool.
Councillor Pat Cleary moved and Councillor Chris Cooke seconded the following Motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 7(1):
Councillor Pat Cleary moved and Councillor Steve Hayes seconded an amendment in accordance with Standing Order 12(9).
Councillor Pat Cleary moved and Councillor Chris Cooke seconded an amendment in accordance with Standing Order 12(9).
An extract from the Council papers in relation to the motion ‘Future Pensions Fit for Purpose’ Proposed by Councillor Pat Cleary and Seconded by Councillor Paul Doughty was provided for members information.
Councillor Kelly as mover of the motion, and duly supported Councillor Blakeley as seconder, indicated acceptance of the amendment moved by Cllr Cleary. The substantive motion was therefore put and carried.
Councillor Kelly as mover of the motion, and duly supported by Councillor Brame as seconder, indicated acceptance of the amendment moved by Cllr Cleary. The substantive motion was therefore put and carried.
It was moved by Councillor P Cleary and seconded by Councillor I Lewis that the application be refused,.
Having been seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary, it was – Resolved (65:0) (One abstention) – That the method of election be undertaken as set out in Standing Order 18(6).
Pensions (4:3:1:1(G)) - chaired by Cllr Pat Cleary;
It was moved by Councillor Pat Cleary, seconded by Councillor Chris Carubia and – Resolved (64:0) (Two abstentions) - That the numbers be agreed for each appointment of Members (and/or other individuals) to all Outside Bodies for the 2019/2020 municipal year, including the proportional split, where appropriate, and the nominations be submitted by the respective Political Group Leaders (and Chief Executive in respect of Council Officer nominations) to the Director of Governance and Assurance and be as set out in Appendix C to the minutes of this meeting.
Councillor Pat Cleary moved and Councillor Paul Doughty seconded the following Motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 7 - “Council welcomes the success of the Merseyside Pension Fund (MPF) in expanding its membership to over 137,000 and raising its fund value to £8.6 billion.
(i) Councillor Pat Cleary on behalf of 36 signatories regarding a request for traffic calming measures on Park Road, Eastham; and (ii) Councillor Anita Leech on behalf of over 800 signatories regarding ‘saving the 106 bus service’, together with a second petition of over 400 signatories regarding retention of the same service.
The Chair informed the Committee that representatives of MPF including the Director of Pensions, Councillor Pat Cleary, Owen Thorne, Portfolio Manager and himself had recently attended a launch opening at the Stock Exchange and had been presented with a glass memento of the occasion. He commented that Members could be very proud of MPF taking the lead at his event.
3 a reply to the motion from Sefton Council be prepared by the Director of Pensions in conjunction with Cllr Cleary and agreed by the Chair of Pensions.
An amendment was moved by Councillor Gilchrist and seconded by Councillor Pat Cleary that the guillotine come into effect at 9:30pm.
Councillor Pat Cleary moved and Councillor Stuart Kelly seconded the following Motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 7 – “Council notes the findings of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) report ‘Global warming of 1.5°’ published on 8 October 2018, in particular:
Councillor Alan Brame moved and Councillor Pat Cleary seconded the following Motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 7 – “Council notes that a recent report to Cabinet on the ‘Future Provision of Golf Courses’ included these comments:
Councillor Pat Cleary commented that he trusted that the event would feature climate change and that the presentation would address this at a high level.
Councillor Pat Cleary asked a question of the Cabinet Member for Jobs and Growth in relation to the proposed golf resort scheme in Hoylake.
Councillor Pat Cleary moved and Councillor Allan Brame seconded the following Motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 7 – (1) Council notes that existing Government policy, following on from the Paris Summit held in December 2017, includes steps to tackle climate change and emissions. This has been followed by the Zero Emission Vehicle Summit held in Birmingham in September 2018 and the signing of a declaration which set out the aim of...
On a motion proposed by Councillor S Kelly and seconded by Councillor P Cleary it was proposed that the application be refused for the following reasons:
Furthermore, Council considers that there is no requirement for any release of land for development from the Green Belt and calls on Cabinet to work to that end.” Councillor Pat Cleary accepted that in light of the revised Conservative motion, his amendment was now redundant and in accordance with Standing Order 12(12), with the agreement of the seconder, Councillor Allan Brame and the Council, the amendment was withdrawn. ... view the full minutes text for item 38.
On a motion by Councillor Abbey and seconded by Councillor Cleary it was:
Councillor Pat Cleary on behalf of 63 residents requesting effective calming measures be put in place to address the speed of traffic travelling along Elmswood, Tranmere.
Councillor Pat Cleary welcomed the report and the proposals put forward and noted his thanks and congratulations to the report author Owen Thorne, Portfolio Manager (Monitoring & Responsible Investment). He also raised a number of issues concerning the percentage of transfer to low carbon investments, the timescales involved and how this was going to be measured.
On a motion for refusal moved by Councillor S Kelly and seconded by Councillor P Cleary it was:
Councillor Pat Cleary on behalf of 189 residents requesting effective traffic calming measures along the Oxton stretch of Woodchurch Road.
Councillor Pat Cleary asked a question of the Cabinet Member - Highways and Transport, Councillor Stuart Whittingham.
Following a debate and Councillor Pat Cleary having waived his right of reply, the amendment was put and carried (55:0) (One abstention).
On a motion moved by Councillor D Elderton and seconded by Councillor P Cleary it was:
On a motion to refuse moved by Councillor D Realey and seconded by Councillor P Cleary it was:
Councillor Patrick Cleary on behalf of 98 residents r equesting effective traffic calming measures and the introduction of safe crossing facilities on Derby Road, Tranmere .
The Chair reported that at the meeting of the Council held on 10 July 2017 (minute 34 refers) the following Notice of Motion proposed by Councillor Pat Cleary and seconded by Councillor Stuart Kelly was referred by the Civic Mayor to this Committee for consideration - FAIR VOTES “Council believes that a Parliament that more accurately reflects the views of the nation, enabling people to feel that their votes count, is more likely to develop an economic, social and environmental agenda that benefits Wirral’s residents.
In accordance with Standing Order 7(6) Councillor Pat Cleary had been invited to attend the meeting in order for him to explain the Motion.
Councillor Cleary elaborated on the Motion and highlighted the need for a fairer voting system and increased representation from women and those from an ethnic minority background into politics.
Councillor Pat Cleary then addressed the Council, speaking in support of the motion and it was then – Resolved (unanimously) – That in pursuance of the provisions of Section 249 (5) of the Local Government Act 1972 and in recognition of the tragic loss of life and continued fight for justice on their behalf, the 96 named below, be posthumously admitted as Honorary Freemen / Freewomen of this Borough:
The Managing Director for Delivery submitted the above application taken out of delegated powers as requested by Councillor P Cleary for consideration.
Councillor Pat Cleary on behalf of 75 residents concerned regarding the state of the open land bordered by Conway Street, Simpson Street and Parkfield Avenue, Birkenhead.
On a motion by Councillor P Cleary and seconded by Councillor S Foulkes it was:
On a motion by Councillor P Cleary and Seconded by Councillor T Johnson it was:
In relation to paragraph 2.2 e) of the report “e) the authority’s policy on how social, environmental or corporate governance considerations are taken into account in the selection, non-selection, retention and realisation of investments” Councillor Pat Cleary asked when the Committee would receive an update and Peter Wallach advised that he was hopeful that a report could be brought to the April meeting of the IMWP.
Councillor Pat Cleary indicated that Members had not had sight of the letter and response relating to fossil fuels and Peter Wallach agreed to make this available to Members. The Chair commented that the Fund was proactive in investing in areas such as windfarms and anaerobic digestion and indicated that it would be appropriate for Members to receive a brief presentation on what the Fund did invest in at a future meeting.
(ix) Councillor P Cleary on behalf of 49 residents calling upon the Council to contact owners of the Victoria Lodge Hotel, Tranmere to respond to calls to adequately secure and maintain the building.
Councillor P Cleary declared a prejudicial interest in respect of item 5 by virtue of him residing on the road in question.
On a motion by Councillor Kelly and seconded by Councillor Cleary it was moved that the application be refused on the following grounds:
Having previously declared a prejudicial interest in connection with this item, Councillor Cleary left the room during consideration of this application.
Councillor Pat Cleary asked a question of the Cabinet Member Children and Family Services.
Councillor Cleary declared a prejudicial interest in respect of item 5 by virtue of him residing on the road in question.
Councillor P Cleary identified that his apologies had not been recorded on the previous meeting.
On a motion by Councillor P Cleary and seconded by Councillor I Lewis it was – Resolved (9:4) – That the application be refused for the following reason:
It was moved by Councillor P Cleary and seconded by Councillor S Kelly that – “The application be refused.” The motion was put and lost (2:11).
The Head of Legal and Member Services reported that at the meeting of the Council held on 14 March 2016 (minute 119 refers), the following Notice of Motion proposed by Councillor Pat Cleary and seconded by Councillor Phil Gilchrist was referred by the Mayor to this Committee for consideration – REDUCING PEDESTRIAN CASUALTIES IN WIRRAL “Council notes that the Wirral Plan 'A 2020 Vision' Phase 1 states 'we will continue to invest in our highways, keeping Wirral moving and making sure our road network Is safe and well maintained; always remembering our duty to residents in regard to road safety'.
Accordingly the Cabinet Member be requested to a. report on the production of the new road safety strategy b . explain how the concerns of the Pedestrians Association can be properly taken into account to the Regeneration and Environment Policy and Performance Committee.” In accordance with Standing Order 7 (6), Councillor Cleary had been invited to attend the meeting in order for him to be given an opportunity to explain the Motion.
The Committee was informed that Councillor Cleary could not attend the meeting and the Chair suggested that the item could be deferred until the September meeting.
Councillor P Cleary declared a prejudicial interest in respect of item 9 by virtue of him being acquainted with the applicant.
Councillor P Cleary, having previously declared a prejudicial interest, left the room during consideration of this application.
Councillor P Cleary, Ward Councillor was also in attendance on behalf of local residents.
[name removed] and [name removed] responded to questions from Members of the Sub-Committee, the responsible authorities, Councillor Cleary and [name removed], Legal Advisor to the Sub-Committee.
Councillor P Cleary identified an inaccuracy in minute 77 and suggested that the vote should have been recorded as 11:1 and not 12:0.
The Chair advised that at the meeting of the Council held on 12 October 2015 (minute 51 refers), the following Notice of Motion proposed by Councillor P Cleary and seconded by Councillor P Gilchrist was referred by the Mayor to this Committee for consideration.
Councillor Cleary and Gilchrist were invited to address the Committee to explain the Motion.
Councillor Cleary asked the Council to support the development of facilities for cycling in the interests of improved health, reduced air pollution, less congestion, and more economical travel. In particular, he called upon the Committee to recognise that secure cycle parking/storage facilities are fundamental in facilitating the bicycle as a practical mode of transport for Wirral residents.
Officers responded to questions by Members regarding cycling provision in planning applications It was moved by Councillor Cleary and seconded by Councillor Mitchell and Resolved (12:0) That the Council be advised that the Planning Committee supports the Notice of Motion ‘Better Planning to Facilitate Cycling.’
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Cleary attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13 Oct 2025 | Council | Motion 3 - delivering wirral’s ‘borough of sanctuary’ commitment | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 6 Nov 2024 | Policy and Resources Committee | Edsential CIC Director Appointment | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 7 Oct 2024 | Council | Six month attendance rule s85 (1) of the local government act 1972 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 May 2024 | Council | Adoption of a revised council constitution | Lost | 14 for, 46 against | |
| 11 Dec 2023 | Pensions Committee | Establishment of working party | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 4 Dec 2023 | Council | Six Month Attendance Rule S85 (1) of the Local Government Act 1972 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 4 Dec 2023 | Council | Joint arrangements and external organisations | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 9 Oct 2023 | Council | Urgent Item - Terrorist Attacks in Israel | Carried | 47 for, 11 against | |
| 24 May 2023 | Council | Appointment of Chairs and Vice-Chairs of Committees | Carried | 49 for, 13 against | |
| 10 Oct 2022 | Council | Decisions taken since the last council meeting | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Jun 2022 | Policy and Resources Committee | 2021-22 Budget Monitoring for Quarter 4 (1 Jan-31 Mar), 2021-22 Outturn | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 1 Sep 2021 | Policy and Resources Committee | Referral from Economy, Regeneration and Development Committee - Wirral Growth Company - Governance Arrangements | Lost | 2 for, 12 against, 1 abstained | |
| 10 Aug 2021 | Decision Review Committee | Decision reviewed item - car parking charging options | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 9 Jun 2021 | Policy and Resources Committee | Appointment of Sub-Committee Members | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Nov 2020 | Policy and Resources Committee | Establishment of a Local Plan Working Group | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Oct 2019 | Council | Civic mayor's announcements | Carried | 39 for, 21 against, 1 abstained | |
| 14 Oct 2019 | Council | Governance Review | Lost | 27 for, 33 against, 1 abstained | |
| 14 Oct 2019 | Council | Civic Mayor's announcements | Lost | 18 for, 29 against, 2 abstained | |
| 14 Oct 2019 | Council | Civic Mayor's announcements | Carried | 32 for, 16 against, 1 abstained | |
| 14 Oct 2019 | Council | Motion (5) WIRRAL COUNCIL TO COMMIT TO KEEP IT LOCAL CAMPAIGN | Lost | 24 for, 25 against | |
| 14 Oct 2019 | Council | Motion (6) BETTER PROVISION FOR STRAY, ABANDONED AND NEGLECTED DOGS | Carried | 30 for, 19 against | |
| 14 Oct 2019 | Council | Motion (7) APPRAISAL OF PARKING RESTRICTIONS IN WIRRAL | Carried | 42 for, 6 against | |
| 14 Oct 2019 | Council | Motion (9) EVERY CHILD MATTERS | Carried | 31 for, 18 against | |
| 14 Oct 2019 | Council | Motion (10) DELIVERING A NEW DEAL FOR TRANSPORT | Lost | 21 for, 23 against | |
| 14 Oct 2019 | Council | Motion (13) SAFER ROADS | Carried | 44 for, 5 against | |
| 21 Mar 2019 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Jan 2019 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Nov 2018 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Oct 2018 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Sep 2018 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Aug 2018 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 9 Jul 2018 | Council | Motion - BETTER ACCESS TO HOSPITAL | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 31 May 2018 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Mar 2018 | Council | Motion - Securing Safe Energy Supplies | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Feb 2018 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Jan 2018 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Dec 2017 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Nov 2017 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Oct 2017 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Oct 2017 | Council | Motion - tyred campaign | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Sep 2017 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Aug 2017 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Jul 2017 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Jul 2017 | Council | Civic mayor's announcements | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jun 2017 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 1 Jun 2017 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 Apr 2017 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Feb 2017 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Jan 2017 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Dec 2016 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Nov 2016 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Oct 2016 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Sep 2016 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Jul 2016 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jun 2016 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Jun 2016 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Apr 2016 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Mar 2016 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Feb 2016 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Jan 2016 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Dec 2015 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Dec 2015 | Council | Proposal for a fire station on green belt land in saughall massie - committee referral | Carried | 8 for, 5 against | |
| 26 Nov 2015 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Oct 2015 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 Oct 2015 | Council | Notices of motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Jul 2015 | Planning Committee | Requests for site visits | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Cleary was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 17 of 21 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Cleary declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 21 Nov 2023 | Policy and Resources Committee, item 69 | Councillor Tony Jones and Councillor Pat Cleary declared a non-prejudicial interest by virtue of their membership on the Town Team Board. | |
| 18 Jan 2017 | Planning Committee, item 113 | Councillor P Cleary declared a prejudicial interest in respect of item 5 by virtue of him residing on the road in question. | |
| 15 Dec 2016 | Planning Committee, item 100 | Councillor Cleary declared a prejudicial interest in respect of item 5 by virtue of him residing on the road in question. | |
| 18 Feb 2016 | Planning Committee, item 158 | Councillor P Cleary declared a prejudicial interest in respect of item 9 by virtue of him being acquainted with the applicant. |
Where Councillor Cleary sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Jun 2014 | 136 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Policy and Resources Committee | Deputy | Oct 2020 | 53 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Pensions Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2015 | 48 | 7 Dec 2026 |
| Economy Regeneration & Housing Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2022 | 14 | 1 Dec 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Spokesperson | Jun 2014 | 74 | |
| Senior Officer Appointments and Staffing Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2020 | 19 | |
| Constituency Committee - Birkenhead | Committee Member | Jul 2014 | 17 | |
| Tourism, Communities, Culture & Leisure Committee | Spokesperson | Jun 2021 | 8 | |
| Policy and Performance - Families and Wellbeing Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2014 | 7 | |
| Health and Wellbeing Board | ex-Officio | Jul 2019 | 4 | |
| Decision Review Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2021 | 2 | |
| Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Independent Persons | Jul 2018 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.