Named21 Jul 2026West Surrey Shadow Authority Executive
Members' Questions.
If so, what contingency plans are being considered if key systems are not fully integrated by vesting day?” Response from Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder “Yes, we are managing risks relating to IT system migration through a minimum viable change approach for Vesting Day, with existing systems retained wherever possible and priority given to those needed for safe, legal and operational service delivery.
Named15 Jul 2026Shareholder Executive Committee
LAC 2021 Ltd - Wind Down Process and Governance Confirmation SEC26-044
In response to a question from Councillor Roberts regarding the closure process, officers advised they anticipated that Elmbridge and Surrey Heath would agree to the winding-up of the company.
Asked15 Jul 2026Shareholder Executive Committee
Victoria Square Woking Ltd Performance Report SEC26-041
Councillor Roberts asked for an update on the remediation issue at the Marches. Alex Short explained that the required work had been identified in a report undertaken by Sir Robert McAlpine and that work was taking place with construction lawyers. It was expected that the remediation work would be undertaken in parallel with the marketing process.
Said9 Jul 2026Executive
Treasury Management Annual Report 2025-26 EXE26-035
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance and Economy, advised that the report provided assurance to Members that treasury activities had been carried out in accordance with the Treasury Management Strategy and the relevant statutory framework. It was noted that the year-end position was stronger than budgeted, reflecting lower borrowing costs, higher investment income, and continued progress with the Council’s wider recovery programme.
Said9 Jul 2026Executive
Asset Disposal - Morris House, Commercial Way, Woking EXE26-086
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Asset Management, explained that the disposal was in the context of the Strategic Asset Disposal Programme approved in March 2025 as part of the Improvement and Recovery Plan debt reduction and asset rationalisation strategy.
Named11 Jun 2026Executive
ThamesWey Energy Limited (TEL) EXE26-078
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance and Economy, provided context to the company-related reports before the Executive and acknowledged the extensive work undertaken to develop a clear strategy for recovery and divestment. It was explained that the reports formed part of a coordinated programme designed to simplify company structures, reduce commercial risk, support debt reduction, facilitate asset disposal, and underpin the wider recovery programme agreed with Government.
Said11 Jun 2026Executive
Asset Disposal - Provincial House, Commercial Way, Woking EXE26-012
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Asset Management, explained that the disposal was in the context of the Strategic Asset Disposal Programme approved in March 2025 as part of the Improvement and Recovery Plan debt reduction and asset rationalisation strategy.
Said10 Jun 2026Shareholder Executive Committee
Update on Cemetery Companies SEC26-033
Councillor Roberts added that as a heritage asset it was important that it was correctly maintained now and in the future.
Named10 Jun 2026Shareholder Executive Committee
Victoria Square Woking Ltd Performance Report SEC26-035
Following a question by Councillor Roberts, Alex Short provided an update on a maintenance issue at the Marches and the remedy plans. It was envisaged that the building would still be marketed while any remedial works were being completed. A maintenance issue affecting Boots was close to being completed.
Said10 Jun 2026Shareholder Executive Committee
Victoria Square Woking Ltd Performance Report SEC26-035
Councillor Roberts stated that it would be helpful for a single page matrix to be worked up which would articulate the work that had taken place in terms of assessing expected asset value and legal ownership, transaction risk, execution risk and TEL ... view the full minutes text for item 11.
Named10 Jun 2026Shareholder Executive Committee
ThamesWey Ltd Performance Report SEC26-034
Councillor Roberts referred to the financial position of ThamesWey Energy Ltd. Antony Collins stated that Interpath had assessed the options and had produced a five year plan, which could include the restructuring of debt held. The scenarios had shown that there would be options to drive efficiencies and work towards profitability.
Named19 May 2026Council
Announcements by the Leader of the Council, Committee Chairs and the Chief Executive.
The Leader outlined Executive appointments and responsibilities, confirming Councillor Roberts as the Deputy Leader with oversight of finance and service delivery, alongside Councillor Hughes as Deputy Leader with responsibility to support delivery through to March 2027. Portfolio holders were confirmed with ongoing priorities including delivery of the new waste contract, housing improvements and development, progression of the Sheerwater scheme, advancement of the Local Plan, and continuation of community asset transfers and essential services. Community safety, voluntary sector engagement, and the continued role of scrutiny were also highlighted.
Named16 Apr 2026Council
ThamesWey Central Milton Keynes Limited (TCMK) Disposal EXE26-052
The Portfolio Holder, Councillor Roberts, noted that the proposed disposal represented a significant step in progressing from stabilising historic arrangements to resolving them in a controlled and transparent manner. The disposal was a core element of the Council’s company divestment strategy and supported both the debt reduction programme and the improvement and recovery plan. Members further noted that TCMK was balance?sheet insolvent and that the debt owed to the Council was not recoverable in practical terms.
Named18 Mar 2026Executive
ThamesWey Central Milton Keynes Limited (TCMK) Disposal EXE26-052
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance and Economy, provided context to the three company-related reports before the Executive. The Portfolio Holder drew attention to the complex commercial structures and investments which the Administration had inherited. The work to strengthen governance arrangements, professionalise company boards, introduce commercial protocols, establish regular reporting frameworks, and ensure proper Member oversight was noted.
Said18 Mar 2026Executive
Asset Disposal - Joint Sale of VSWL and WBC Assets EXE25-064
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Asset Management, introduced the report which sought approval for the principle of the proposed sale of several combined assets namely Wolsey Place (incorporating Alexander House and Export House), ThamesWey residential units and Victoria Square retail and ancillary leisure as a package in accordance with the advice and considerations set out in the report. The Shareholder Executive Committee, at its meeting earlier in the evening, had discussed matters relating to the detailed transaction structure. The Portfolio Holder thanked both VSWL and Council Officers for their role in developing the complex packaging of assets.
Named18 Mar 2026Shareholder Executive Committee
ThamesWey Ltd Performance Report SEC26-016
Following a question by Councillor Roberts, Andy Pinto reported that the Middle East conflict had caused a rise in gilt rates which could contribute towards a reduction in property prices and affect assets owned by ThamesWey Ltd. The situation therefore would therefore warrant divestments to be made sooner rather than later.
Named18 Mar 2026Shareholder Executive Committee
ThamesWey Ltd Performance Report SEC26-016
Councillor Roberts observed that due to the historic inadequacies of the arrangements in Woking, it had not been possible to undertake a complete Shareholder cycle of review of the companies, from business plan approval to reporting against the plan which consider any exceptions and areas of over or under performance. It was not the fault of the SEC or the company boards and all involved had dealt with the situation as best they could, however dealing with company performance without having a baseline had felt uncomfortable.
Named18 Mar 2026Shareholder Executive Committee
Victoria Square Woking Ltd Performance Report SEC26-017
Following questions by Councillor Roberts, it was noted that the previously discussed impact of gilt rises would also apply to Victoria Square Woking Ltd assets. Alex Short provided an update on building surveys, any issues identified and further investigations required.
Named18 Mar 2026Shareholder Executive Committee
Victoria Square Woking Ltd Performance Report SEC26-017
Councillor Roberts referred to the marketing of the set of assets and asked whether there was confidence that remaining issues such as freehold title could be worked through in time for the assets to be taken to market. It was stated that the Executive later in the evening was being asked to consent to the ... view the full minutes text for item 10.
Said12 Mar 2026Executive
Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy EXE26-058
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Digital Services and ICT, introduced the report which recommended to Council adoption of the Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy. The Resource and Finance Scrutiny Committee had considered the report at its meeting on 11 March 2026 under its remit for pre-decision scrutiny. A copy of the recommendations of the Committee was before the Executive.
Said12 Mar 2026Executive
Write off of Sundry Debts EXE26-008
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, confirmed that debts were only recommended for write off when there was no possibility that the income could be recovered.
Named2 Mar 2026Council
Questions from Members of Public. WBC26-010
And is any failure to support such reviews indicative of an intention by Central Government to reduce local democracy?” Reply from Councillor Dale Roberts “A Community Governance Review is a significant undertaking for any Council. The statutory nature of the process would require consultation, legal advice, evidence gathering and professional support. The cost of a Community Governance Review falls on the local Council itself, as Central Government does not make funding available specifically for this workstream.
Said2 Mar 2026Council
General Fund Budget 2026-27 EXE26-001
Councillor Dale Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the budget reports together with the report proposing the Council Tax level for the coming year. The Portfolio Holder recognised the extraordinary journey the Council had taken over recent years and reported that the Council was now in a position to present a legal, balanced, “business-as-usual” budget for the coming year.
Named12 Feb 2026Council
Investment Debt Repayment and Standstill for the ThamesWey Group 2025-26 and 2026-27. EXE26-019
Councillor Roberts, portfolio holder for finance, was invited to introduce the recommendations and explained that the report proposed the extension of the debt repayment standstill for the Thamesway Group of companies. This was to allow an orderly and value-protecting exit from commercial activity rather than forcing insolvency or distressed sales. It was noted that the Council had already agreed a comparable standstill for Victoria Square Woking Limited.
Said12 Feb 2026Council
Investment Debt Repayment and Standstill for the ThamesWey Group 2025-26 and 2026-27. EXE26-019
Councillor Roberts emphasised that the standstill would not write off debt or remove liabilities. It would, however, pause the scheduled repayments for a defined period, whilst assets were prepared for disposal and business plans were executed. In addition, a ‘cash sweep’ mechanism would remain in place to ensure that any surplus funds not required for solvency were returned to the Council and applied directly to reducing outstanding debt.
Named12 Feb 2026Council
Statement of Accounts 2023-24 and 2024-25. AUD26-001
The Portfolio Holder for Finance, Councillor Dale Roberts, took the opportunity to thank the Members of the Audit and Governance Committee, past and present, for their significant work in reviewing the accounts before their presentation at Council.
Named12 Feb 2026Council
Appointment of Senior Information Risk Officer (SIRO). WBC26-004
The Portfolio Holder, Councillor Roberts, stated that, in short, the decision was a practical step that strengthened the Council’s ongoing, forward -looking governance and better visibility of risk The appointment, which had taken effect from 5 January 2026, had been made under authority available to the Chief Executive to take decisions that were so urgent that they could not wait for the next meeting of Council or the relevant Committee.
Said5 Feb 2026Executive
General Fund Budget 2026-27 EXE26-001
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the budget papers at Items 7 to 11 on the agenda together. It was noted that the Resource and Finance Scrutiny Committee had considered the budget reports under its remit for pre-decision scrutiny, and the budget reports had also been considered by the Finance Working Group. Members were thanked for their engagement, and Officers were thanked for their professionalism in the preparation of papers.
Said5 Feb 2026Executive
2026-27 Fees and Charges EXE26-018
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, explained that the review of fees and charges had been shaped by the principles of fairness, equitability, affordability, and social responsibility in order to ensure a balance between service users and taxpayers, whilst sustaining services at a time when fundamental redesign could not happen in the lead up to LGR.
Named3 Feb 2026Resource and Finance Scrutiny Committee
Resolution
Members later agreed to extend this to Cllr Roberts, who was also present but did not sit on either of the two committees named.
Named22 Jan 2026Executive
Questions
The Commissioners’ Fifth Report (December 2025) notes that “progress is not being made on the substantive strategic focus of the divestment plan” (paragraph 25).” Reply from Councillor Dale Roberts “Welcome back to [name removed], good to see you again. The future of ThamesWey Central Milton Keynes Limited is being considered jointly by the Council and the Central Government Commissioners in line with the Local Authority’s best value obligations.
Said22 Jan 2026Executive
Investment Debt Repayment and Standstill for the ThamesWey Group 2025-26 and 2026-27 EXE26-019
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which provided an update on the Council’s existing debt repayment standstill agreement with ThamesWey for 2025-26, and which recommended to Council a further agreement for 2026-27. The proposals formed part of the Council’s overall Improvement and Recovery Plan (IRP). Members were reminded that the same approach had been approved by Council in December 2025 for Victoria Square Woking Limited.
Said22 Jan 2026Executive
Asset Disposal - Albion House EXE26-010
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Asset Management, explained that the disposal was part of the broader strategy to reduce the Council's unsustainable debt burden, refocus resources on core services and enable new private investment into the town. T he recommendation to sell the property was aligned to the Woking For All Strategy, the guiding principles of the Commercial Protocol, and a business case proforma including NPV (net present value) had been prepared. The Executive supported the proposal to dispose of the site, noting the commercial and financial benefits which would be achieved.
Named21 Jan 2026Shareholder Executive Committee
Victoria Square Woking Ltd Performance Report SEC25-011
Following a question by Councillor Roberts, Alex Short stated that as the divestment process was being pursued there were some areas identified that required external specialists, for example ongoing work taking place within TEL; the structure of building ownership;
Seconded11 Dec 2025Council
Minutes.
The motion was seconded by Councillor Roberts. It was noted that the Chief Executive’s decision not to accept the motion had been discussed both at the start of meeting under Urgent Business and towards the end of the meeting under Notices of Motion.
Seconded11 Dec 2025Council
Calendar of Meetings 2026-27 EXE25-058.
Councillor Roberts seconded the proposal.
Said11 Dec 2025Council
Investment Debt Repayment and Standstill 2025-26 and 2026-27 EXE25-077.
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the recommendations of the Executive , advising that the report set out the proposed approach to the Council's lending arrangements with Victoria Square Woking Limited for the year ahead. Since the intervention in 2023 and the Section 114 notice, the Council had been implementing the improvement and recovery plan, a key part of which was the orderly and responsible exit from commercial activity.
Said4 Dec 2025Executive
Investment Debt Repayment and Standstill 2025-26 and 2026-27 EXE25-077
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which provided an update on the Council’s existing debt repayment standstill agreement with VSWL for 2025-26, and which recommended to Council a further agreement for 2026-27. The proposals formed part of the Council’s overall Improvement and Recovery Plan (IRP). The Portfolio Holder explained that extending the debt standstill would provide the Council with the necessary time to prepare the VSWL assets for sale in 2026-27, supporting both financial solvency and the achievement of optimal sale value and better value for money.
Said4 Dec 2025Executive
Fees and Charges 2026-27 EXE25-057
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which presented the initial review of the Council’s Fees and Charges for 2026-27. It was noted that proposals had been prepared earlier than the previous year in order to allow time for feedback ahead of final proposals being brought back to Executive in February 2026. A constructive discussion on the report had been held at the Finance Working Group at its meeting on 3 December 2025, and fees and charges proposals were also due to be considered by the Resource and Finance Scrutiny Committee.
Said4 Dec 2025Executive
Draft Capital Programme 2026-27 to 2029-30 EXE25-061
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, explained that since the Section 114 Notice issued in June 2023, the Capital Programme had been substantially moderated with provisions only for items which met the Council’s agreed, strict Capital Principles. It was confirmed that no new General Fund borrowing was proposed. The Portfolio Holder explained that the Capital Programme reflected the financial constraints the Council continued to operate within and the Capital Principles agreed by the Council.
Said13 Nov 2025Executive
Update on Draft Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) and General Fund Budget 2026-27 EXE25-059
The interest was such that speaking and voting were permissible.] Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which provided an updated position on the Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) and which presented the Executive with savings options and growth pressures to be considered for inclusion in the 2026-27 General Fund Budget. The Portfolio Holder drew attention to the Government’s unprecedented provision of £500m debt support for the Council in 2026-27, which confirmed that the scale of the Council’s historic borrowing was unsustainable, and reflected the confidence the Government now had in the Council’s seriousness towards its approach to recovery and recognition of the work undertaken to rebuild financial discipline.
Asked12 Nov 2025Shareholder Executive Committee
Good Economy Baseline Impact Report - Thameswey Ltd SEC25-003
Councillor Roberts asked whether implementing the recommendations would optimise value for the divestment process in light of the additional costs for ThamesWey Ltd and Antony Collins undertook to provide an answer outside of the meeting.
Named12 Nov 2025Shareholder Executive Committee
Good Economy Baseline Impact Report - Thameswey Ltd SEC25-003
Councillor Roberts referred to Amy Ingham’s experience with other local authorities and asked whether there were common themes among local authority housing companies ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Named16 Oct 2025Executive
Sheerwater Land Transfer EXE25-098
The Portfolio Holder for Asset Management, Councillor Roberts, explained that the report also provided an update on progress regarding the sale of the remaining three development land parcels to the preferred private developer and sought the agreement of the Executive to proceed with the disposal. The Executive was advised that the proposed sale of the remaining development land would deliver significant capital receipts to the HRA and allow private investment to complete the Sheerwater Regeneration scheme.
Said15 Oct 2025Shareholder Executive Committee
Good Economy report - Victoria Square Woking Limited
Councillor Roberts highlighted the strong impacts of the scheme whilst noting it had exceeded the limit of affordability for the Council; and that it was necessary to ensure the asset was managed responsibly and that the lessons learnt about financial discipline, decision-making and Member oversight were embedded.
Named15 Oct 2025Shareholder Executive Committee
ThamesWey Ltd Performance Report and Business Plans
Following a question by Councillor Roberts, it was agreed to provide further information on the components for the increase in sales.
Named25 Sep 2025Council
Housing Revenue Account Forensic Review EXE25-096
The Portfolio Holder for Finance, Councillor Roberts, introduced a report which outlined the findings of a forensic review of the Housing Revenue Account (HRA) which had been undertaken by Forvis Mazars. The review related principally to historic transactions associated with the Sheerwater Estate Regeneration Project which had been charged to the Housing Revenue Account. The report also sought approval for the proposed next steps to address the conclusions of the review.
Said25 Sep 2025Council
Housing Revenue Account Forensic Review EXE25-096
Councillor Roberts advised that the report had been considered by the Audit and Governance Committee on 18 September. The Committee had noted the report subject to two points – (1) the amendment to the wording around the total reimbursement figure for the New Vision Homes Underwrite Agreement;
Said25 Sep 2025Council
Housing Revenue Account Forensic Review EXE25-096
Councillor Roberts responded to the points raised, noting that the proposals would ensure that the HRA would be more robust going forward and adding that a comprehensive capital budget for housing improvements had been agreed and that the Council had recently adopted its first 30 year HRA Business Plan.
Seconded25 Sep 2025Council
Updates to the Constitution WBC25-032.
The Leader moved and Councillor Roberts seconded a motion that the Chairs of the three Scrutiny Committees should also be formally consulted on such decisions.
Named17 Sep 2025Shareholder Executive Committee
Victoria Square Woking Ltd Performance Report
Following a question by Councillor Roberts it was noted that the main issues were ensuring the key data was up to date in light of the quality of past record keeping being variable. The Leader added that it would be helpful for the Asset Management Director, Alex Short, to attend future meetings to deal with any queries on the retail side of the business.
Said11 Sep 2025Executive
Housing Revenue Account Forensic Review EXE25-096
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which presented the findings of the independent forensic review of the Housing Revenue Account (HRA) undertaken by Forvis Mazars. The Executive was informed that the review related principally to historic transactions in the Sheerwater Estate Regeneration Project which were charged to the HRA. The Portfolio Holder explained that Executive approval was sought to recommend to Council the proposed next steps to address project costs incorrectly allocated to the HRA.
Said11 Sep 2025Executive
Asset Disposal - Dukes Court and Albion House EXE25-053
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Asset Management, explained that the disposals were part of the broader strategy to reduce the Council's unsustainable debt burden, refocus resources on core services and enable new private investment into the town. It was noted that the assets were included in the Council’s Strategic Asset Disposal Plan.
Named3 Sep 2025Executive
Questions
The revised Sheerwater regeneration plans will deliver a large net shortfall of social housing and see some properties built by Thameswey sold on the open market.” Reply from Councillor Dale Roberts “Thank you to [name removed] for another great question.
Said24 Jul 2025Council
Treasury Management Annual Report 2024-25 EXE25-051
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the recommendation from the Executive in respect of the report on Treasury Management performance, which provided an update on the economy, the Treasury strategy and details of borrowing taken in 2024-25.
Named21 Jul 2025Executive
Questions
Any period between 6pm and 5.59am is charged at £2, but at the moment the machines appear to be adding a £2 surcharge to the £15 if you come back to the car after 6.00pm, which therefore makes it impossible to only pay £15 for up to 24 hours?” Reply from Councillor Dale Roberts “I completely understand the confusion, the reason for the question. For clarity, there isn't really a single 24-hour car parking charge. There is a charge for 24 hours and it is made up of two parts.
Said21 Jul 2025Executive
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) and 2026-27 Budget Planning EXE25-044
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which refreshed the Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) projections previously agreed by the Executive in July 2024, and which provided updated General Fund budget projections to 2028-29. The report also set out a proposed strategy for managing the Council’s finances and budget gap from 2026-27. The Portfolio Holder explained that the report included a review of the business as usual (BAU) budget; a useful planning tool which presented the cost of delivering Council services excluding transformation and financing costs associated with the legacy debt.
Said21 Jul 2025Executive
Investment Debt Repayment and Standstill 2024-25 and 2025-26 EXE25-073
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which provided an update on the Council's investment debt management arrangement with its two major companies, ThamesWey and Victoria Square Woking Limited (VSWL). In December 2024, the Council had approved a debt repayment standstill for the 2025-26 financial year. The Portfolio Holder advised that, under the debt standstill, the companies were still required on a quarterly basis to transfer any surplus cash back to the Council as lender (known as a ‘debt sweep’).
Named21 Jul 2025Executive
Greenfield School Update EXE25-090
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, drew attention to the clear and appropriate conditions which had been set by the Executive in November 2024, including professional independent assessment of the borrower's solvency and legal advice to ensure compliance with subsidy control rules. The Executive was informed that Interpath , financial restructuring experts, had been appointed to provide advice on the rescheduling options and the long-term viability of the School. Interpath’s report was provided in Part II of the agenda.
Named16 Jul 2025Shareholder Executive Committee
Victoria Square Woking Ltd Performance Report
Following a question by Cllr Roberts, it was stated that the companies were seeking to mitigate issues which could affect the divestment process, which included the areas of energy security, residential operating costs, car parking and land titles. Tax advisers were looking into the issue of accumulated tax losses.
Said12 Jun 2025Executive
Asset Disposal - Triangle Site, Woking Centre EXE25-080
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Asset Management, explained that the Triangle Site had been assembled by the Council to regenerate the area, facilitate additional town centre housing and to allow for the potential widening of the Victoria Arch Bridge. The Portfolio Holder commented that the Council had no business in leading the ambitious project, and had adopted responsibility and risk rather than partnering appropriately with Surrey County Council (SCC) and Network Rail. The project had been terminated as a result of the Council’s serious financial situation.
Named11 Jun 2025Shareholder Executive Committee
Apologies for absence
As the Leader was therefore not present the meeting was chaired by the Vice-Chairman, Councillor Roberts.
Moved19 May 2025Employment Committee
Election of Chair.
Councillor Roberts moved and Councillor Graves seconded the election of Councillor Barker as Chair of the Committee.
Named19 May 2025Employment Committee
Election of Vice-Chair.
Councillor Barker moved and Councillor Howes seconded the election of Councillor Roberts as Vice-Chair of the Committee.
Named19 May 2025Employment Committee
Election of Vice-Chair.
Resolved That Councillor Roberts be elected Vice-Chair of the Employment Committee for the ensuing year.
Named19 May 2025Shareholder Executive Committee
Election of Vice-Chair.
Councillor Barker moved and Councillor Nicholson seconded the election of the Councillor Roberts as Vice-Chair of the Shareholder Executive Committee.
Named19 May 2025Shareholder Executive Committee
Election of Vice-Chair.
Resolved That Councillor Roberts be elected Vice-Chair of the Shareholder Executive Committee for the ensuing year.
Moved19 May 2025Council
Election of Deputy Mayor 2025/26.
Councillor Roberts moved and the Mayor seconded that Councillor Leach be appointed Deputy Mayor.
Named19 May 2025Council
Leader of the Council's Statement.
The Leader was proud to advise that the Executive for the coming year would comprise Councillor Roberts and Councillor Nicholson as Deputy Leaders, and Councillors Greentree, Johnson, Lyons and Morales.
Named19 Mar 2025Executive
Questions
Before answering the questions, Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance and Economy, reminded the Executive of the background to the loan arrangements totalling £13.3 million which the previous administration had entered into with Greenfield School. The Executive, at its meeting on 14 November 2024, was advised that the School had indicated it could only partially meet a loan obligation of £2.4 million. At its November meeting, the Executive was of the view that the former administration had no business in entering into the arrangement with the School and had made it clear that the strong preference of the Council was that the School meet its existing commitment.
Named19 Mar 2025Executive
Questions
Other than the risk of financial loss on the loans the council is breaking competition laws i.e. by subsidising the school against its competition through cheap capital.” Reply from Councillor Dale Roberts “The Council is in ongoing discussions with the School in respect of the outstanding payments. The School is fully aware that the preference of this Executive is that they repay their existing obligations. They are also aware that they are required to provide independent and professional advice on the viability of their plans to repay the remainder of the loans and that the advice must represent the best interests of the lender, not just the borrower.
Said13 Mar 2025Executive
Asset Disposal Strategy EXE25-033
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Asset Management, explained that the Improvement and Recovery Programme published in August 2023 had highlighted the Council’s challenging financial position as a result of historic commercial property investment projects which had resulted in unsustainable levels of borrowing. As a result, one of the aims of the Recovery Programme was to rationalise the Council’s asset base to reduce the debt.
Said13 Mar 2025Executive
Asset Management Report EXE25-035
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Asset Management, advised that in line with the Asset Disposal Strategy considered earlier in the meeting, the Property Services Team been implementing a programme of asset management activities including reviewing lease events, revising the letting programme , and implementing better general asset management practices. As well as the SAMP, Officers had identified a portfolio of assets and each of those assets had undergone an individual asset review to create a bespoke proforma setting out the relevant property data and the Council’s approach to the future of the asset.
Said13 Mar 2025Executive
Write off of Sundry Debts EXE25-008
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, confirmed that debts were only recommended for write off when there was no possibility that the income could be recovered. Attention was drawn to the proposal to write-off a loan principle of £100,176 owed to the Council by A&B Menswear. It was noted that the company had failed during lockdown and the outstanding debt was considered irrecoverable.
Said12 Mar 2025Shareholder Executive Committee
ThamesWey Ltd Performance Report
Councillor Roberts added that it would be beneficial to include a group snapshot at the start for housing and energy setting the expected and actual revenue and cost levels, and requested an update on how the operation and charges levied by ThamesWey Energy Limited affected VSWL and any other parts of the Council group of companies.
Named3 Mar 2025Council
General Fund Budget and Council Tax Setting 2025/26 WBC25-006.
The Portfolio Holder for Finance, Councillor Dale Roberts, introduced the report on the General Fund Budget. The report provided Members with final 2025/26 General Fund budget proposals, following the receipt of confirmation from MHCLG that Exceptional Financial Support (EFS) would continue to be provided by Government to Woking Borough Council into 2025/26. The report also set the level of Council Tax for 2025/26.
Named3 Mar 2025Council
General Fund Budget and Council Tax Setting 2025/26 WBC25-006.
Following the debate, Councillor Roberts summarised the proposals and responded to points raised during the debate, highlighting the achievements made over the past year. The support of the Government continued to be essential and the Authority had to continue to focus on achieving savings.
Said3 Mar 2025Council
Capital, Investment and Treasury Management Strategies and Minimum Revenue Provision (MRP) Statement 2025-26 EXE25-004.
Councillor Dale Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report on the capital investment treasury strategies and the Minimum Revenue Provision (MRP) statement for the coming year. The strategies were key to the Council’s financial recovery, ensuring the Authority could manage its assets, investments and borrowing responsibilities . The Council would continue to focus on reducing risk, prioritising statutory services and aligning capital spending with the recovery strategy.
Named27 Feb 2025Council
Final Accounts Report 2023/24 WBC25-009.
The Portfolio Holder for Finance, Councillor Dale Roberts, introduced a report on the accounts for 2023/24, noting that the Audit and Governance Committee has received the accounts at its meeting on 20 February 2025. The Government had adopted a ‘backstop’ position and had announced that the outstanding accounts for 2023/24 had to be published by 28 February 2025.
Named27 Feb 2025Council
General Fund Budget 2025-26 EXE25-001
The recommendations of the Executive in respect of the General Fund Budget were introduced by the Portfolio Holder for Finance, Councillor Dale Roberts. The report outlined the provisional budget proposals for the coming year together with proposals for the three years up to 2027/28.
Said27 Feb 2025Council
General Fund Budget 2025-26 EXE25-001
Councillor Roberts thanked the Councillors for their comments before referring them to the recommendations set out in the report before them.
Said27 Feb 2025Council
Fees and Charges 2025-26 EXE24-060
Councillor Dale Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, presented the recommendations of the Executive in respect of the proposed fees and charges for the coming financial year. The Council was advised that the proposals would ensure that discretionary services were sustainable going forward. Benchmarking had been undertaken and adjustments had been made for inflation, to ensure that service costs were appropriately allocated.
Said27 Feb 2025Council
Fees and Charges 2025-26 EXE24-060
Councillor Roberts responded to the comments made during the debate, emphasising that the Council was committed to reducing costs through efficiencies. In accordance with Standing Orders, the names of Members voting for and against the recommendations were recorded as follows:
Named27 Feb 2025Council
Housing Revenue Account Budgets 2025-26 EXE25-002
The proposals were introduced by Councillor Dale Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, and Councillor Ian Johnson, Housing Portfolio Holder, who highlighted the intention to spend £16m on fire risk and decent homes over the coming year, leading to a big impact for tenants. The proposals included an element of borrowing, though it was emphasised that this had been budgeted for.
Said27 Feb 2025Council
Capital Programme 2024-25 to 2028-29 EXE25-003
Councillor Dale Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, presented the recommendations of the Executive in respect of the Capital Programme which outlined the investments over the period 2024/25 to 2028/29 to deliver the Council’s strategies and objectives. The proposals focussed on essential investments in infrastructure and housing. Of the proposed spending of £30.5m, a total of £23.5m would be spent on housing services.
Named27 Feb 2025Council
Pay Award 2025/26
Councillor Roberts took the opportunity to recognise the impact the decision not to make a pay award in 2024/25 had had on staff, expressing his gratitude that they had stayed with the Council.
Named13 Feb 2025Executive
Questions
As the council is a key stakeholder in Woking Shopping are they disappointed in the lack of visible improvement and investment in the centre and paucity of (quality) lettings that will drive up footfall and dwell time which will benefit council finances through increased car parking revenue?” Reply from Councillor Dale Roberts “Thank you to [name removed] for the question and his obvious interest in an important subject for us, the economic wellbeing of our town centre. The Council has had a number of meetings with the Arora Group acting in its capacity as the Freeholder and local statutory body over the past 12 months. As the questioner correctly notes the authority, as a key stakeholder in the town centre, has every interest in encouraging improvements and investment within the retail core.
Named13 Feb 2025Executive
Questions
Likewise the failure to find any comparative retail to grow in the area of Lark and Gail’s to improve the quality of the town centre retail experience?” Reply from Councillor Dale Roberts “Thank you again to [name removed]. The authority has worked closely with both ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Said13 Feb 2025Executive
General Fund Budget 2025-26 EXE25-001
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which recommended to Council the provisional budget proposals for 2025-26 and for the three-year period leading to 2027-28. The Portfolio Holder highlighted that all discretionary services would be maintained, housing and homelessness had been made a clear priority, and Council Tax was proposed to increase by 2.99% on the previous year.
Said13 Feb 2025Executive
Review of Fees and Charges 2025-26 EXE24-060
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, explained that the review of fees and charges had been shaped by the principles of transparency, fairness, equitability, affordability, and social responsibility with a particular focus on ensuring that discretionary services moved further towards cost neutrality. It was noted that the review had included benchmarking with comparable local authorities, addressing historic under-pricing, and work to understand the true cost of services as part of the ‘hidden subsidy’ workstream of the Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS).
Said13 Feb 2025Executive
Capital, Investment and Treasury Management Strategies and Minimum Revenue Provision (MRP) Statement 2025-26 EXE25-004
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, stated that the approach of the Administration was to prioritise prudence and financial responsibility in contrast to the strategy of the previous Administration which had resulted in the Council having the highest debt per head of any authority in England. It was confirmed that the Executive would continue to take a prudent low risk approach. The Debt Reduction Plan was also highlighted.
Named12 Feb 2025Shareholder Executive Committee
Recommendation from Environment and Place Scrutiny Committee
Following questions by Councillor Roberts over the communication with the contractor and the disruption over the closure of Victoria Way, Jane Wynne stated that the response from Sir Robert McAlpine after the storm had been very good and informative. Jonathan Ellis, Consultant Chief Operating Officer, added that the contractor representatives were well aware of the disruption caused and were doing everything that could be done. Alex Short stated that as the section of Victoria Way had been closed due to public safety, and a range of measures were being considered to enable Victoria Way to re-open.
Said16 Jan 2025Executive
2025-26 Budget Update EXE25-019
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance and Economy, introduced the report which provided an update on the General Fund budget position following December’s Local Government Provisional Finance Settlement, the impact of the review of the Council’s overheads apportionment, and the submission of an initial request to MHCLG for the continuation of Exceptional Financial Support (EFS) into 2025/26. Since the budget update received at the December Executive, the Portfolio Holder reported that the ‘business as usual’ budget gap for 2025/26 had increased from £2.7m to £3.4m and would continue to increase for the following two years. The Executive was advised that the budget gap increase was largely due to the Government’s unfavourable Provisional Finance Settlement and the outcome of the review of recharges following a review of the Council’s overheads.
Said16 Jan 2025Executive
Asset Disposal - Egley Road Barn Site EXE25-010
Following correspondence received from Woking Gymnastics Club, Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Asset Management, advised that the Council wrote a letter of assurance to the Club, a tenant on the site, in November 2023 outlining what the Council could do to balance all parties interests in both the management of the Egley Road site and the Kingfield site which the Club wished to develop. The Portfolio Holder provided assurance that the decision before the Executive regarding Egley Road Barn Site did not change the position with the Club. The Council continued to do all it could to facilitate the extension of the Club’s new site at Kingfield.
Named12 Dec 2024Council
Questions from Members of Public WBC24-044.
The site is designated as being suitable for residential development under Policy UA8.” Question 2 – Bhushan Sharma “What is the latest plan going forward concerning the development of the triangle section of Guildford Rd (next to railway bridge) which has been mostly bulldozed and fenced off?” Reply from Councillor Dale Roberts “This legacy project was fundamentally flawed not least because it required Woking Borough Council to carry the risk for works to both the replacement bridge and highways. A number of scaled-down, and lower-risk alternatives were considered with our partners but were ultimately considered unviable at that time. Instead, the site has recently been subject to an initial marketing exercise undertaken on behalf of the authority by two local agents.
Named12 Dec 2024Council
Questions from Members of Public WBC24-044.
For future reference, please email [email protected] in respect of any planning consultations.” Question 4 – Bhushan Sharma “What is the plan going forward regarding the future of the derelict shopping zone previously occupied by Debenhams in Town centre?” Reply from Councillor Dale Roberts “The Debenhams Department store is part of the Peacocks Shopping Centre which is owned by a third party, The Arora Group, and is not in the control of the Council. The Council therefore is not able to determine the plans for this site.
Named12 Dec 2024Council
Final Accounts Report 2019-20, 2020-21 and 2021-22 WBC24-053.
The report itself was introduced by Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance. Whilst the Council was required to approve the historic accounts for audit purposes, the Portfolio Holder recognised that Members were reluctant to do so given the concerns over the reliability of the accounts. As such, the recommendations had been drafted in such a way that the caveats around the proposed decisions were clear.
Said12 Dec 2024Council
Investment Debt Repayment and Standstill 2024-25 and 2025-26 EXE24-087
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, presented the recommendations, noting that the debt standstill previously agreed by the Council was currently in place. The proposals by the Executive sought to ensure a similar arrangement was put in place for 2025/26 financial year. The proposal would enable a temporary pause on payments to debtors.
Named12 Dec 2024Council
Investment Debt Repayment and Standstill 2024-25 and 2025-26 EXE24-088
The Portfolio Holder for Finance, Councillor Roberts, introduced the documents and the Council was invited to raise any questions or concerns they had.
Said5 Dec 2024Executive
Investment Debt Repayment and Standstill 2024-25 and 2025-26 EXE24-087
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which provided an update on the Council’s existing debt repayment standstill agreement with ThamesWey and Victoria Square Woking Limited for 2024-25, a debt sweep against the agreement, and which recommended to Council a further agreement for 2025-26. The Executive was informed that a debt standstill was a temporary arrangement between a borrower and its creditor to pause repayments for a period of time. The conditions which the debt standstill would be subject to were set out by the Portfolio Holder, which included an agreement on the Council being provided with overarching loan security against the assets for the ThamesWey group of companies which was currently not the case.
Said5 Dec 2024Executive
Update on Draft Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) and General Fund Budget 2025-26 EXE24-062
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio for Finance, advised that MTFS reports received by the Executive in July and October 2024 had indicated a £5m underlying budget gap for 2025/26 rising to £10m by 2027/28. Regarding the debt overhang, it was confirmed that exceptional financial support would be needed from Government for 2025/26. The Portfolio Holder highlighted that such support would be contingent on the Council taking reasonable steps to live within its means.
Said27 Nov 2024Shareholder Executive Committee
Victoria Square Woking Ltd Performance Report and Outline Business Case
Councillor Roberts stated that year on year footfall in retail would be useful to consider. Jane Wynne added that it was important to compare the performance of Woking with other similar locations.
Said14 Nov 2024Executive
Greenfield School - Loans EXE24-093
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance and Economy, introduced the report which provided an update on the Greenfield School loan arrangements. It was noted that the total outstanding loan principal was £13.3m, of which £2.4m of those loans were due for repayment by the School on 25 November 2024. It was noted that the School had been meeting its obligations and had repaid £851,098 of the £2.4m loan.
Said14 Nov 2024Executive
Budget Monitoring Q2 2024-25 EXE24-043
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, advised that the report showed an improved position over Q1 with the £3.2m overspend reported in Q1 reducing to £0.1m in Q2. The Portfolio Holder advised that the Council was approaching a balanced budget position in-year for 2024/25. Budget savings of £10.8m had been successfully delivered to-date against a target of £12.5m for 2024-25 and remained a critical focus for the Council to demonstrate its ability to live within its means.
Named31 Oct 2024Shareholder Executive Committee
ThamesWey Ltd Performance Report
Following questions by the Leader and Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, it was agreed that the Shareholder Liaison Service would submit a formal question as part of the Shareholder Instruction as to the current financial situation for the completion of the yellow phase of the Sheerwater development in light of the loan funds provided by Government for this purpose. It was noted that any project overspend against budget over the past couple of years had not been reported to the Leader or Finance Portfolio Holder and had not been raised in recent monitoring reports to the SEC. Councillors expressed grave concern that, if the formal reply to the above question raised the possibility of a potential overspend, it had not been highlighted by ThamesWey either in the report or in the verbal highlight requested at the outset of the meeting.
Named17 Oct 2024Executive
Update on General Fund and Housing Revenue Account Budgets 2025-26 EXE24-090
The Leader, on behalf of the Portfolio Holder, Councillor Roberts, introduced the report which provided an update on the work being undertaken to prepare the 2025/26 Budget and Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS). Following the previous budget update report to the Executive before the summer, it was explained that the report before the Executive outlined the next steps towards delivering a balanced budget for 2025/26 and to securing a sustainable position in the Council’s financial strategy to 2027/28.
Named26 Sep 2024Council
Announcements by the Leader of the Council, Committee Chairmen and the Chief Executive.
Councillor Ellen Nicholson and Councillor Dale Roberts would be taking on a new joint role as deputy leaders and Councillor Stephen Greentree would be joining the Executive.
Named26 Sep 2024Council
Annual Accounts 2019/20, 2020/21 and 2021/22 WBC24-038.
The Portfolio Holder for finance and economy, Councillor Dale Roberts, introduced the report on the Authority’s draft accounts for the years 2019/20, 2020/21 and 2021/22. It was noted that nationally, the number of local authorities with outstanding audits and failing to publish accounts within prescribed deadlines had been growing. At the same time, the complexity of the Borough Council’s accounts and a lack of sufficient resources had added to the delays on the accounts.
Named26 Sep 2024Council
Appointments to Committees 2024/25 WBC24-036.
The Leader has appointed both Councillor Roberts and Councillor Nicholson to serve as Deputy Leaders and Councillor Greentree has been appointed to the vacancy on the Executive.
Said12 Sep 2024Executive
Legacy Adjustments to the Housing Revenue Account (HRA) EXE24-083
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which provided an update on the review of recharges between the General Fund (GF) and Housing Revenue Account (HRA), the details of discrepancies on the historic recharges made, and an outline of the adjustments required to correct the recharges. In addition to £2.1m of incorrect recharges from the GF to the HRA from 2019/20 to 2024/25 being restored to the HRA as part of the 2024/25 budget work, further work had identified an additional £782k of fuel cell recharges which had been wrongly charged to the HRA dating back to 2013/14. Further, the interest on balances calculation identified an HRA entitlement from the GF of approximately £460k.
Said12 Sep 2024Executive
Budget Monitoring Q1 2024-25 EXE24-042
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, advised that an overspend of £3.296m was projected for the General Fund and explained the material forecast variances for the period. It was noted that the majority of variances related to the Council’s commercial activity, which had been identified as a workstream in the Medium Term Financial Strategy. The financial impact of homelessness was highlighted in the report; an overspend of £0.596m due to increased demand.
Named12 Sep 2024Executive
Vote of Thanks
The Leader advised that the Liberal Democrat Group had supported Councillor Nicholson and Councillor Roberts to become the joint Deputy Leaders of the Council in the future.
Named12 Sep 2024Executive
Vote of Thanks
Councillor Forster wished Councillor Nicholson and Councillor Roberts good luck as joint Deputy Leaders.
Named10 Sep 2024Resource and Finance Scrutiny Committee
Legacy Adjustments to the Housing Revenue Account (HRA) RFSC24-008
The Portfolio Holder for Economic Development, Resources, and Finance, Councillor Roberts, advised that it would take many years for the issues faced by the Council to be fixed through a variety of objectives including;
Named10 Sep 2024Resource and Finance Scrutiny Committee
Improvement and Recovery Programme Update RFSC24-007
The Portfolio Holder for Economic Development, Resources, and Finance, Councillor Roberts, suggested the Committee should seek to identify the level of information it wished to receive to be able to contribute towards the work being undertaken through the Improvement and Recovery Plan. The Vice-Chair considered that the report to the Executive was bland and confusing and that a presentation would have been of more value. The Officers took onboard the comments and added that a full ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
Said11 Jul 2024Executive
General Fund Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE24-031
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which established a Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) for the years 2024-25 to 2028-29 covering General Revenue budget, the Housing Revenue Account (HRA) and capital budget. The Portfolio Holder advised that the report was important for developing the financial strategy for the next four years and provided the framework for the work required to prepare for the 2025-26 budget setting.
Named13 Jun 2024Executive
Strategic Parking Objectives EXE24-069
The intention of the proposals, introduced by Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Parking Services, was to rationalise the daily tariff options into a simplified, user -friendly structure which would focus on encouraging longer stays. The number of parking permit options would also be rationalised to better incorporate Woking’s overall corporate policies. In drawing up the changes, Officers had taken into account guidance from the British Parking Association.
Said13 Jun 2024Executive
Performance Management Report
Councillor Roberts expressed his appreciation for the work undertaken by Officers to draw together the information.
Named20 May 2024Employment Committee
Election of Vice-Chair.
Councillor Graves moved and Councillor Barker seconded the election of Councillor Roberts as Vice-Chair of the Committee.
Named20 May 2024Employment Committee
Election of Vice-Chair.
RESOLVED That Councillor Roberts be elected Vice-Chair of the Employment Committee for the ensuing year.
Named28 Mar 2024Council
Questions from Members of the Council.
What is the total Council Tax bill for the previous four quarters regarding Council managed properties that are subject to KPI IM3?” Reply from Councillor Dale Roberts “The Council has spent £80,748.89 in the 2023/24 financial year to date on Council Tax related to its housing assets. Whilst the largest element of this will relate to void properties, there will be an element that is an ongoing liability – for example, shared accommodation used for temporary accommodation which cannot be split and properties used as guest flats or for other housing management purposes.” Supplementary Question No.
Said21 Mar 2024Executive
Write off of Sundry Debts EXE24-008
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, confirmed that debts were only recommended for write off when there was no possibility that the income could be recovered. The Portfolio Holder advised that the largest business rates item related to Twisted Stone, a company dissolved in 2022, that operated a golf course in Pyrford. The Executive heard that it was understood that a new business was operating on the same site and had become liable for business rates from August 2022.
Said21 Mar 2024Executive
Resident Services Programme EXE24-022
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder, advised that the Programme would deliver an improved experience to residents and reduce operational costs. The report set out proposals regarding web publishing, telephony, and customer facing platform.
Named4 Mar 2024Council
General Fund Budget and Council Tax Setting 2024-25 WBC24-002.
Councillor Forster, Deputy Leader of the Council, introduced the report on the General Fund Budget and Council Tax for the coming years, noting that the Portfolio for Finance, Councillor Roberts, who had led on the work, had unfortunately been unable to attend. The exceptional support recently confirmed by the Government, without which the Authority would not have been able to achieve a balanced budget, was highlighted. The support represented a package of up to £785million for the following year.
Said8 Feb 2024Council
General Fund Budget 2024-25 and Proposed Savings EXE24-001.
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the recommendations of the Executive in respect of the General Fund Budget for the coming year which identified service savings of £8.4m.
Said8 Feb 2024Council
Housing Revenue Account Budgets 2024-25 EXE24-002.
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the recommendations of the Executive in respect of the Housing Revenue Account (HRA) Budgets 2024-25. Under the proposals, the rent levels would increase from 1 April 2024 by 7.7% based on September CPI of 6.7% and in line with the advice of the Government. Total rental income was forecast to increase by circa £1.79 million to circa £20 million, excluding void losses.
Named8 Feb 2024Council
Capital Programme 2023-24 to 2027-28 EXE24-003.
The recommendations of the Executive in respect of the Capital Programme 2023-24 to 2027-28 were introduced by the Portfolio Holder for Finance, Councillor Roberts. The programme set out the investments required to deliver the Council’s key strategies and objectives over the period, with focus shifting to housing and putting in place a plan of work to address fire safety remedial work in the Council’s housing stock.
Said1 Feb 2024Executive
General Fund Budget 2024-25 and Proposed Savings EXE24-001
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which recommended to Council service savings of £8.4m and provided updates on the processes for Equality Impact Assessments (EIAs) and public consultation which had been part of the decision-making process. It was noted that the Overview and Scrutiny Committee had considered the report at its meeting on 29 January 2024. The Portfolio Holder explained that an Extraordinary meeting of Council on 4 March 2024 would receive a report finalising the treatment of the Council’s debt in 2024-25 and the level of Council Tax.
Said18 Jan 2024Executive
UK Shared Prosperity Fund (UKSPF) EXE23-084
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Economic Development, explained that the Council had received £1m of UKSPF funding with the aim of helping local places to build pride in place and increase life chances. Due to the Digital Centre of Excellence not proceeding, it was necessary to consider how those uncommitted funds of £601,000 could be used in 2024/25. The Portfolio Holder confirmed that the proposed projects in the report were in alignment with the overriding purpose of the UKSPF and related to transformation.
Said14 Dec 2023Executive
Draft Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) and General Fund Budget 2024-25 EXE23-059
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which set out the strategic financial approach that the Council needed to take to deliver the Improvement and Recovery Plan (IRP) and respond to the Council’s serious financial position whilst continuing to meet its statutory duties. The Portfolio Holder explained that the approach included the development of a debt reduction plan and asset disposal strategy, and the commitment to a £12m savings target. The Executive was informed that progress continued to be slowed by poor data, inadequate systems and insufficient capacity, and the Executive welcomed that Commissioners had supported additional resources in the finance team.
Said14 Dec 2023Executive
Draft Housing Revenue Account Budget Update 2024-25 EXE23-060
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, reported that the HRA would likely be in balance next year with an estimated surplus of circa £1m which could be invested back into much needed capital improvements to HRA stock. Uncertainties remained regarding future capital financing requirements and the Government’s rent setting approach. It was noted that the 30-year HRA Business Plan would be updated as part of the budget setting process.
Said30 Nov 2023Council
Review of Fees and Charges 2024-25 EXE23-057
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report on the annual review of Fees and Charges, setting out the context in which the proposals had been drawn up. As a result of over reliance on income from commercial investments, the Council faced a budget shortfall in the region of £12m. Whilst the Council had identified significant savings, it was clear that it was no longer in a position to fund its discretionary services and faced three options; such services could be placed with an organisation better placed to meet community needs; or, if a priority, the services would have to become self-funding; or the Council had to withdraw from the service.
Said30 Nov 2023Council
Review of Fees and Charges 2024-25 EXE23-057
Councillor Roberts highlighted two points: in respect of the car park charges, a Parking Study was currently taking place and proposals would be put forward for Member consideration in February 2024. Secondly, a supplementary paper had been published earlier in the day, setting out an additional recommendation (v) for the Council to consider in respect of introducing fees for the electric vehicle charging points in Council owned car parks. As an officer report and proposal, it was not necessary for the recommendation to be formally moved and seconded.
Said30 Nov 2023Council
Review of Fees and Charges 2024-25 EXE23-057
Councillor Roberts responded to the points raised during the debate, emphasising that it would take time for the Council to achieve its ambitions around the annual review of fees and charges. The concerns and frustrations of Members over the position the Council found itself in were acknowledged.
Said20 Nov 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Urgent Business
Councillor Roberts noted that the Council had historically not prioritised management accounting which had caused insufficient reporting and those reports that were generated not including all information that would be beneficial to Members. This was an area that Officers were actively addressing.
Said16 Nov 2023Executive
Review of Fees and Charges 2024-25 EXE23-057
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, highlighted that the review of fees and charges needed to be considered in the context of, and was constrained by, the Council’s current financial position following the issue of a Section 114 Notice in June 2023. The Executive noted that the Council faced a deficit of £1.2bn and was experiencing a budget shortfall of £12m due to an over reliance on commercial income. The Portfolio Holder advised that the Council had identified £8.5m savings to address the budget shortfall.
Said16 Nov 2023Executive
Update on General Fund and Housing Revenue Account Budgets 2024-25 EXE23-079
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which provided an interim update on the General Fund and Housing Revenue Account Budgets 2024-25. The Executive noted that a more detailed report would be received by the Executive at its meeting on 14 December 2023, and an all Member Briefing would be held on 11 December 2023. The Portfolio Holder highlighted that the budget gap had widened to £19.3m in 2024-25 due to increased capital financing costs and ongoing pressures on commercial income.
Named16 Oct 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Task & Finish Group: HS2 Funding for Brookwood Cemetery OSC23-051
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, offered his assistance to Councillor Davis and Councillor Rice should they require it during the review.
Named12 Oct 2023Council
Questions from Members of the Council WBC23-040.
Now that this Council gave the CEO permission on 28 September to proceed with cuts to staffing budgets in discretionary roles, to what extent had the business community been consulted on regarding the closure of the Business Liaison function and what impact will closing this vital function have on the economic landscape?” Reply from Councillor Dale Roberts “As described in the response to the previous question, there is the opportunity for staff, residents and stakeholders (including businesses) to give their views on all proposed budget cuts through the Medium-Term Financial Strategy survey and through internal consultation with staff teams.
Named28 Sep 2023Council
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE23-064
The Portfolio Holder for Finance, Councillor Roberts, set out a historical timeline of events since July 2022 through to the proposals being presented at the current meeting for the purpose of the public consultation. The Council had agreed a savings target of £12m of which £8.5m had been identified, against a total service spend of £45m. Despite additional cost pressures of £8.3m arising in September 2023, the savings target had been maintained at the same level of £12m as further reductions at this stage could not be reasonably identified, following consultation with the Commissioners.
Said28 Sep 2023Council
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE23-064
Councillor Roberts emphasised the importance of restoring the confidence in the Council with Commissioners, the Department of Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, and the Treasury as it had been unable in hindsight to set a balanced budget since at least 2018; the reserves held had therefore been illusory; past claims of financial strength in light of high borrowing levels had been incorrect; past borrowing for revenue purposes was not permitted; and the Council had borrowed funds from the Public Works Loan Board to fund loss making Council owned companies, taking a margin and ... view the full minutes text for item 9a
Said14 Sep 2023Executive
Financial Monitoring Report EXE23-051
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, explained that the paper reported on budget forecast and variance within the Council’s Directorates and would be received by the Executive quarterly. The Executive welcomed the report which would improve governance, control and accountability. The implementation of a new financial forecasting process was considered vital and would enable monitoring and course correction during the financial year.
Said22 Aug 2023Council
Improvement and Recovery Plan WBC23-32.
Councillor Roberts outlined the financial recovery theme and the intention to put in place better controls and governance and agreeing a financial support package with the Government.
Named20 Jul 2023Council
Notice of Motion - Cllr K Davis - Digital Spine Connection EXE23-047
The Portfolio Holder for Economic Development, Councillor Roberts, introduced the recommendation of the Executive to support the motion, and fully supported the objective to provide gigabit capable broadband to local businesses and residents.
Said20 Jul 2023Council
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE23-041
The Portfolio Holder for Finance, Councillor Roberts advised that a timetable with clear milestones had been drawn up as part of the Strategy which included a further update in September 2023.
Said13 Jul 2023Executive
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE23-041
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which provided an updated Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) for the period 2024/25 to 2028/29 and which also set out a timetable with clear milestones for a further update of the MTFS in September 2023. An updated Budget Timetable (Annex 4 to the report) was tabled at the meeting. It was noted that the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, at its meeting on 10 July 2023, had considered the MTFS report under its remit for pre-decision scrutiny.
Said10 Jul 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Pre-Decision Scrutiny: Medium Term Financial Strategy Update OSC23-034
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, noted that the February 2023 budget was presented with two caveats; the budget could be balanced with use of reserves, and that it was only possible if there was no change to the MRP.
Named10 Jul 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Pre-Decision Scrutiny: Medium Term Financial Strategy Update OSC23-034
The sentiment was agreed by Councillor Roberts and the Chair.
Said15 Jun 2023Executive
Notice of Motion - Cllr K Davis - Digital Spine Connection EXE23-047
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Economic Development, advised that sufficient provision was most likely to be provided within the next three years by private sector network providers. However, the Portfolio Holder was supportive of investigating other opportunities to accelerate access to gigabit capable broadband should the Council not be achieving the proper balance of access for residents and businesses, and affordability in terms of resources available to the Council.
Named22 May 2023Council
Appointments to Ad Hoc Bodies and Ex Officio Positions 2023/24 WBC23-025.
Cllr Morley (Cllr Sullivan) Farnborough Airport Consultative Cttee (1 rep, 1 year plus 1 sub, 1 year) Cllr Barker (Cllr Sullivan) Friends of Woking Palace (1 rep, 1 year) Cllr Barker Maybury Centre (2 reps, four years to 2026 and 2023 respectively) Cllr Graves (2026) Cllr Aziz (2027) National Parking Adjudications Service Joint Cttee (1 rep, 2 years, plus 1 sub, 2 years to 2023) Cllr Barker (2025) (Cllr Roberts) (2025) Police and Crime Panel (1 rep, 1 year) Cllr Nicholson ShopMobility (1 rep, 1 year plus 1 sub, 1 year) Cllr Barker (Cllr Jordan) South East Employers (1 rep, 1 year plus 1 sub, 1 year) Cllr Barker (Cllr Davis) Sport Woking (formerly Woking Sports Council) (2 reps, 1 year) Cllr Aziz Cllr Martin Surrey County Playing Fields Association (1 rep, 1 year) Cllr Nicholson Sutton Green Village Hall Management Cttee (2 reps, 1 year, 1 to be local Ward Cllr, 1 to be a Member of WBC) Cllr Davis Cllr Rice Woking Access Group (2 reps, 1 year) Cllr Barker Cllr Javaid Woking Community Transport (2 observers, 1 year) Cllr Rice Cllr Aziz Woking People of Faith (1 rep, 5 years to 2026) Cllr Morales (2026) Woking Youth Council (2 reps, 1 year plus 1 substitute, 1 year) Cllr Brown Cllr Leach (Cllr Akberali)
Named30 Mar 2023Council
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE23-016.
The recommendations of the Executive in respect of the updated Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) for the period 2023/24 to 2025/26 were presented by Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance. The report submitted to the Executive had outlined the position of the initiatives which the Council had agreed to commit to in order to pursue financial resilience and to constrain expenditure. It was noted that a further, more significant update of the MTFS would be brought to the Executive in July 2023.
Named30 Mar 2023Council
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE23-016.
Councillor Roberts referred to the ongoing work on restrictions on expenditure and the detailed technical work required for minimal revenue provision, both of which related to the risk issuing a Section 114 Notice.
Named30 Mar 2023Council
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE23-016.
Following the debate, Councillor Roberts was provided with the opportunity to respond to the points raised before the Mayor referred the Members to the recommendations set out in the report before the Council. In accordance with Standing Order 10.8 the recommendations were put to a vote.
Said23 Mar 2023Executive
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE23-016
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which provided an updated Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) for the period 2023/24 to 2025/26.
Said23 Mar 2023Executive
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE23-016
Following the Budget report to Council on 23 February 2023, Councillor Roberts explained that the report provided an update on initiatives which the Council had agreed to commit to in order to pursue financial resilience and to constrain expenditure. The report set out a timetable with clear milestones for a further update of the MTFS in July 2023. The Executive noted that the report included a recommendation that the Council’s future loans to Thameswey Central Milton Keynes Limited (TCMK) were supplied without margin in order to relieve the financial burden on the company.
Named23 Feb 2023Council
Council Tax WBC23-011.
Following the responses, the Mayor advised the Council that the Portfolio Holder for Finance, Councillor Roberts, would introduce the reports for Agenda Items 6A to 6D together; an opportunity to debate each of the items would be given following the introduction. The Leader of the Council would introduce agenda item 6e, ThamesWey Business Plans 2023.
Named23 Feb 2023Council
Council Tax WBC23-011.
Councillor Roberts set out the basis on which the proposals for Council Tax for the coming year had been drawn up, outlining the financial position faced by the Authority and the objectives going forward. A 3% increase in Council Tax was proposed for Woking Borough Council, from £255.46 in 2022/23 to £263.12 in 2023/24; it was noted that Surrey County Council had agreed an increase of 2.99% in their precept and that the precept set by the Surrey Police and Crime Commissioner had increased by £15, the maximum allowed for 2023/24.
Said19 Jan 2023Executive
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE23-021
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which provided an update on the Medium Term Financial Strategy and approach to financial resilience work required to set the 2023/24 budget.
Said19 Jan 2023Executive
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE23-021
Following updates received by the Executive in November and December 2022, Councillor Roberts reported that work on stabilising reserves and identifying cost savings was progressing. The Executive was informed that the analysis undertaken to date should enable a budget to be set for 2023/24.
Said19 Jan 2023Executive
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE23-021
Councillor Roberts stressed that this would involve a significant spending reduction. In addition, if the Council’s assessment of a more prudent provision for its borrowing was necessary then it would likely be unsustainable within the General Fund budget.
Said8 Dec 2022Executive
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE22-077
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, outlined the serious financial position of the Council and informed the Executive that a fundamental review of the Council’s budget was required to rebalance service costs within the resources now available post Covid. The report also recommended actions targeted at delivering greater financial resilience, namely actions to identify funds to increase the level of reserves in order to give the Council more time to deliver savings that were sustainable.
Said8 Dec 2022Executive
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE22-077
Councillor Roberts advised that without further action, the Council’s expenditure could exceed the resources the Council had at its disposal.
Said1 Dec 2022Council
Review of Fees and Charges 2023-24 EXE22-062
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the recommendations of the Executive in respect to the 2023/34 fees and charges. The financial position of the Council was such that charges could not continue to be kept low and that increases would have to go above the level of inflation, recognising the disproportionate increases in costs such as energy. The approach adopted would seek to be fair and equitable, and affordable for the residents of the Borough whilst maintaining the Council’s social responsibility.
Named17 Nov 2022Executive
Victoria Place Update EXE22-054
The Portfolio Holder for Finance, Councillor Roberts, advised the Executive that additional equity investment would be sought in the long-term. New governance arrangements approved by Council in July 2022 were highlighted which would scrutinise the Council’s investment.
Said17 Nov 2022Executive
Review of Fees and Charges 2023-24 EXE22-062
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, highlighted that the report needed to be considered in the context of the Council’s overall position set out in the Medium Term Financial Strategy later in the agenda, and the national picture. The effect of high inflation and energy costs on Council services was also highlighted. Given the Council’s financial situation, the Executive was faced with a difficult choice between delivering services at an additional cost to services users or not delivering those services at all.
Said17 Nov 2022Executive
Draft Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) and General Fund Budget 2023-24 EXE22-064
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report which provided an update to the Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS).
Named17 Nov 2022Executive
Draft Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) and General Fund Budget 2023-24 EXE22-064
Councillor Roberts set out the scale of the challenge facing the Council drawing attention to further pressures since the MTFS update in July which included interest rate rises. It was noted that commercial and parking income had continued at levels substantially below 2019 levels. Despite work to identify savings, the Executive was informed that reserves were likely to fall beneath the minimum acceptable level by the end of 2023/24 and be fully used during 2024/25.
Said6 Sep 2022Planning Committee
2021/1168 17 Brackenwood Road, St Johns
Councillor D Roberts, Ward Councillor, spoke in support of the application and commented that no public concerns had been raised regarding this application. He commented that it was a thoughtful design that cleverly lessened the impact to the street scene. The new footprint of the property was set to be 89.7sqm, from a previous footprint of 43.5sqm, which was not dissimilar to other extensions in the area; the amenity space would still be 285sqm.
Said6 Sep 2022Planning Committee
2021/1168 17 Brackenwood Road, St Johns
Councillor D Roberts said that he thought a subservience would be achieved by the setting back of the property and the use of specific materials. It was of a modern design, but the SPD suggested that modern design could sit next to traditional properties successfully.
Named6 Sep 2022Planning Committee
2021/1168 17 Brackenwood Road, St Johns
Councillor D Roberts thought that the application met the requirements of national and local policies, and the careful choice of materials achieved a subservience which minimised the impact on the street scene. He thought it was an imaginative and intelligent design and hoped the Committee would consider approval.
Named21 Jul 2022Council
Notice of Motion - Cllr D Roberts - Benefits Management EXE22-042
At its meeting on 31 March 2022, the Council had referred the following Notice of Motion from Councillor Roberts to the Executive.
Named21 Jul 2022Council
Notice of Motion - Cllr D Roberts - Benefits Management EXE22-042
This council will therefore investigate how it will implement benefits management on all major projects as part of existing standard project controls such as risk and issues management.” Before it had been considered by the Executive, Councillor Roberts had suggested an amendment to the wording following discussion with Officers as follows:
Named21 Jul 2022Council
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE22-043
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Corporate Financial Planning and Policy, introduced the recommendation of the Executive to approve the Medium-Term Financial Strategy as updated. Included within the Strategy was a pilot to reduce the off-street parking charges on Saturdays as a measure to encourage visitors to the town centre. Several questions were raised over the proposals, including on the readiness of the car parks for a new charging scheme and what the intention was at the end of the pilot, which was scheduled to occur just before Christmas 2022.
Named14 Jul 2022Executive
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) EXE22-043
Councillor Roberts, Portfolio Holder for Corporate Financial Planning and Policy, introduced a report which provided an update to the Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) for 2022-23 to 2025-26. The report also outlined the approach to aligning Council budgets with the priority outcomes defined within the Woking for All strategy, as well as the supplementary and amended priorities from the new administration agreed at the last meeting of the Executive. The Portfolio Holder explained that the financial forecasts within the report set out the level of challenge faced by the Council due to increased inflationary pressures and risk to the level of the Council’s forecast income.
Named16 Jun 2022Executive
Notice of Motion - Cllr D Roberts - Benefits Management EXE22-042
Councillor D Roberts “The council undertakes programmes of work to deliver benefits to the borough and controls are put in place to ensure the work is delivered on time, on budget and to scope. Whilst delivering to scope should result in the delivery of benefits, it may not always be the case. Complex projects spanning many years can require interim decisions to balance budgets, timescales, and scope because of issues arising throughout the life of the project.
Said16 Jun 2022Executive
Notice of Motion - Cllr D Roberts - Benefits Management EXE22-042
This council will therefore investigate how it will implement benefits management on all major projects as part of existing standard project controls such as risk and issues management.” Councillor Roberts spoke in support of the Motion and drew attention to a suggested amendment to the wording of his Motion which recognised the Council’s current benefits management practices and which proposed improvement to the practice to ensure that any changes to benefits were reported back to Members. The Executive was invited to recommend the revised wording to the Council. The revised wording of the Motion reads as follows:
Seconded31 Mar 2022Council
Recommendations of the Executive and Committees. WBC22-010.
Councillor D Hughes moved and Councillor D Roberts seconded the reception and adoption of the report and recommendations from the meeting of the Standards and Audit Committee held on 3 March 2022.
Moved31 Mar 2022Council
Notice of Motion - Cllr D Roberts - Benefits Management.
Councillor Roberts The following motion was moved by Councillor Roberts and seconded by Councillor Nicholson and referred to the Executive on 16 June 2022 in accordance with Standing Order 5.7.
Said22 Mar 2022Planning Committee
Planning Peer Review
Councillor D Roberts commented that this was a complex point as there were some things that could be changed at this point and some that could not; he was unsure we should be asking for community ownership of the masterplan at this point. The Chairman commented that more detail from recommendation 7 should be included in this action point, particularly reference to the residents panel and community engagement. Giorgio Framalicco commented that Members could choose to add further wording, but ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Seconded3 Mar 2022Audit and Governance Committee
Review of Code of Conduct Arrangements STA22-001
In considering the details of the proposals, Councillor Hughes moved and Councillor Roberts seconded an amendment to the Summing Up process to allow complainants to have the opportunity to rebut any matters raised within the Panel to which they disagreed as a right, rather than at the discretion of the Chairman of the Standards Panel. On being put to a vote, all Members present supported the amendment which therefore formed part of the substantive recommendations before the Committee.
Named29 Sep 2021Standards Panel
Election of Vice-Chairman
Councillor Roberts was elected Vice-Chairman of the Sub-Committee for the meeting.
Moved16 Sep 2021Audit and Governance Committee
External Audit Plan 2021
In view of the fact that the Plan before the Committee was draft and yet to be completed, Councillor Roberts moved and Councillor Hughes seconded that the recommendation before the Committee be amended to receive, rather than agree, the draft External Audit Plan. The amendment was supported by the Committee and it was RESOLVED That the draft External Audit Plan for 2020/21 be received.
Asked16 Sep 2021Audit and Governance Committee
Review of Code of Conduct Arrangements
Councillor Roberts asked whether coaching or external mediation were offered as part of the arrangements and was advised that, whilst options were limited in the formal arrangements, the proposals included the offer of support to the complainant by another member of the Legal Team, an arrangement which could be extended to include members of the HR Team.
Named13 Sep 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Economic Development Task Group Update OSC21-024.
The Chairman of the Economic Development Task Group, Councillor Roberts, had prepared a report on the discussions at the meeting of the Task Group held on 25 August 2021.
Said7 Sep 2021Planning Committee
2020/0940 75 St Johns Road, Woking
Councillor D Roberts commented that he had concerns around car parking and that this did not provide any visitor spaces.
Named7 Sep 2021Planning Committee
2020/0940 75 St Johns Road, Woking
Councillor D Roberts thought that there were elements to commend about the application but that the bulk and mass was too large for the site.
Moved7 Sep 2021Planning Committee
2020/0940 75 St Johns Road, Woking
Councillor D Roberts proposed, and it was duly seconded by Councillor A Boote, that the application should be refused on the grounds of bulk and mass.
Named24 May 2021Audit and Governance Committee
Constitution of Sub-Committee.
RESOLVED That the following Members be appointed to the Standards Hearings Sub-Committee: [name removed], Independent Co-Opted Member Cllr Hughes (Cllr Johnson s ubstitute) Cllr Martin ( Cllr Mohammed substitute) Cllr Rana (Cllr Whitehand s ubstitute) Cllr Roberts ( Cllr Howard s ubstitute)
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.