Urgent Business
Councillor Oades queried whether the requirement for Members to complete the mandatory Audit and Governance Committee training before attending meetings was being enforced consistently.
Every time Woking's minutes name Councillor Oades, as the council published it.
Councillor Oades queried whether the requirement for Members to complete the mandatory Audit and Governance Committee training before attending meetings was being enforced consistently.
Councillor Oades raised a concern regarding the escalation route for Councillors dissatisfied with Council officer decisions, relating to the notice of motion from Councillor Akberali not being received by Full Council. He stated that the officer advice had been to contact the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman which had subsequently advised him that only complaints from members of the public would be accepted. It was stated that a written response would be provided to Committee Members, including consideration of whether the escalation route should be included in the Constitution.
Councillor Cosnahan noted that Grant Thornton was unable to provide an opinion on the last two years’ accounts, and Councillor Oades stated that the position was unacceptable given the length of time involved. Stephen Fitzgerald confirmed that the matter continued to be raised with BDO and Public Sector Audit Appointments. Sir Tony Redmond advised that he had escalated concerns to the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government and to the Financial Reporting Council.
Councillor Oades identified a couple of typographical errors and queried the explanation of risk scoring. Toby Nash agreed to correct the errors before the report went to Executive and to clarify that risk scores were derived from probability and impact. Sir Tony Redmond advised that Commissioners had taken a close role in strengthening the framework due to the historic weaknesses in the Council’s risk management and stressed that risk awareness needed to be embedded at all levels.
Councillor Oades referred to the positive messages regarding the Housing Capital Programme. Graeme Clarke responded that internal audit was one source of assurance focused on specific higher-risk areas. Stephen Fitzgerald added that wider strategic improvements, such as the Housing Revenue Account business plan, were distinct from individual audit findings.
Councillor Oades raised concerns that some long-running housing cases may have been omitted from KPI reporting, potentially affecting reported performance. Stephen Fitzgerald undertook to provide a written response clarifying the Council’s KPI reporting approach including omission of any long-running cases, and Graeme Clarke confirmed that KPI accuracy and reporting would be considered in future housing-related audits where appropriate.
Councillor Oades questioned whether two received quotes were sufficient for Threshold 3 procurements and queried wording on financial transactions not being subject to competition; officers explained the distinction between procurement and treasury transactions and agreed that wording and typographical errors, including clause 28.1, would be corrected.
In the absence of the Chair, Councillor Pearce noted, and Councillor Spenser seconded, that Councillor Oades sit as acting Vice-Chair for the duration of this meeting, to support the Vice-Chair in the Chair.
Councillor Lyons moved and Councillor Oades seconded that Councillor Leach be elected Mayor.
The Mayor expressed his thanks to the Members for their support of his nomination and appointment, including appreciation for Councillor Lyons who proposed and Councillor Oades who seconded his appointment. The Mayor invited the Reverend [name removed] to continue to serve as Mayoral Chaplain for the forthcoming year.
During the debate, a specific case was referred to by Councillor Oades concerning a block of eight Council-owned flats which had been without heating or hot water for 15 months. Even so, the residents had been paying for the services whilst also meeting the costs of additional heaters and the use of immersion heaters. Further details of the case were shared, including the presence of mould and an incident of sewage flooding in a property, and it was noted that compensation had only been paid in the past month.
Councillor Oades asked whether BDO had indicated when its response letter to the objector would be shared with the Council. Stephen Fitzgerald confirmed that BDO had undertaken to copy their response to him for circulation to Committee Members although had not yet committed to a date.
Councillor Oades referred to the implementation of recommendations, highlighting that 23 medium priority actions were stated to be overdue, with 22 of them being more than 150 days beyond their target dates. Sam Lowe stated that there had been improvements on overdue numbers, with repeated reminders and a new escalation process assisting to reduce the backlog. Stephen Fitzgerald added that clearing legacy audit recommendations was a priority strongly emphasised by the Chief Executive.
Following a question by Councillor Oades, it was stated that the financial corrections (transfers from the General Fund to the HRA) had been agreed in full for implementation in 2025/26.
Councillor Oades asked why the issue of the relationship between ThamesWey Energy Ltd and Victoria Square Woking Ltd, particularly regarding energy dependence had not been included in the lessons learned document, and it was noted that the original review had focused on the HRA?specific issues.
Following a proposal by Councillor Pearce, which was seconded by Councillor Oades, and consideration of a written question from Puneet Jasuja, it was agreed to recommend to Council that under Planning Committee – Speaking by the Public and Ward Councillors (set out in point 2 of the amended Appendix 1) be amended by replacing ‘up to three minutes’ speaking time for Members with the principle that whilst brevity and a maximum of three minutes would be aimed for speaking times would be at the discretion of the Chairman. It was further agreed to be recommended to Council that if a Councillor could not attend the meeting to speak regarding a called-in application in their Ward, another Councillor on the Committee (rather than the committee clerk as currently proposed) could read a statement on their behalf. Additionally, paragraph 11.7 of the Notices of Motion proposal (point 8 of the updated Appendix 1) should be amended to include gender neutral language for reference to the Chief Executive.
Following questions by Councillor Oades, it was noted that the Housing Revenue Account (HRA) figures were presented prior to adjustments following the Mazars forensic report; and that the Council expected to recoup the full loan for Greenfield School, noting the impaired value of £7.8m shown in the accounts reflected the prevailing conditions at 31 March 2025.
Councillor Oades expressed concern that there had been adjustments to the group accounts since the September meeting for both 2023/24 and 2024/25 and it was stated that after publishing the draft accounts, amendments had been made following an internal quality assurance review on group inter-company transactions and that this was not unusual during the course of an audit. Joanne Brown and Paul Jacklin of Grant Thornton confirmed that a high-level disclosure review had been undertaken on the group accounts, with substantive testing on the 2024–25 Council (single entity) accounts, for example investigating in?year transactions and closing balances, to provide a level of assurance prior to the backstop deadline. Following a question by the Chairman, Joanne Brown stated that a positive trajectory in the control environment was being observed, with a greater number of recommendations being classed as ‘key’ rather than ‘statutory’ in the Auditor’s Annual Report.
Councillor Stephen Oades referred to SR01 and asked whether it remained appropriate for the General Fund and HRA to remain together as a single risk in light of the two major corrections recently made to the HRA. Regarding SR03, it was noted that whilst the risk remained red, the score had reduced since quarter one following the appointment of a Corporate Restructuring Officer.
Councillor Oades suggested that such information could be added as explanatory footnotes. In relation to SR06, Kevin Foster advised that the current red rating reflected the nature of cyber risk nationally rather than any specific issue within the Council. Councillor also Oades referred to SR10 and Kevin Foster explained that when new developments were proposed, sufficient natural green space must be available to offset associated environmental impacts.
Councillor Oades advised the Council of a concern he had which would have the potential of requiring an urgent update to the Constitution.
Councillor Oades stated that the resident had been advised that it was not for the Scrutiny Committee to call in the decision of the Chief Executive to refuse the motion submitted by Councillor Akberali.
Councillor Oades considered that the implication of this statement was that decisions made by any officer could not be called in by a Councillor to scrutiny.
If this was the case, Councillor Oades stated that an amendment was needed to the Constitution.
Councillor Oades referred to his previous request for Councillor Rice to attend the Housing Revenue Account (HRA) briefing on 14 July 2025 for Committee members only, along with the reasons for the request. He stated that following a meeting he had not been aware of between two statutory officers and the Chair, following which the request had been declined, his level of trust had been damaged and that, as a result, he intended to resign as Vice-Chair of the Committee, following the meeting. He added that the Leader had advised him that any Member could attend Council meetings.
Councillor Oades stated that item (iv) of the resolution referred to a total impact of £4.49 million, while section 5.20 of the report listed the total reimbursement as £4.453 million. Brendan Bradley clarified that the difference of approximately £36,000 was due to interest added to the Birch & Pines Pub transaction.
Councillor Oades requested that the wording be revised to avoid confusion. In addition, it was confirmed that the financial corrections would be made in the current financial ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Councillor Oades stated that it would be important to have a fallback position in case of any further delays.
Councillor Oades noted that the £145 million shown under debtors for Victoria Square Woking Limited was the impaired value, not the total outstanding debt which was circa £700 million (note 16, page 138). He also stated that the accounts reflected a reduced receivable amount due to default of the loan to Greenfield School, with the actual debt remaining at £13 million. Brendan Bradley confirmed that no write-off had occurred and that the Council was working on a revised loan structure.
Councillor Oades proposed that an explanatory note be included in the accounts to also include an updated revaluation of the ThamesWey properties provided by Mike Stevens. Brendan Bradley confirmed this update would be incorporated.
Councillor Oades, Vice-Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee, spoke against the proposal.
The Leader of the Council, Councillor Barker, expressed that this Councillor Oades asked that his disagreement with the decision for the change to the terms of the loan to be reviewed by the Executive as opposed to full Council be noted. He explained that this was on the grounds that previous decisions related to the loans, specifically the first and second, had been made by full Council, and that this should have meant the third, and any future decisions regarding the loans, were also made in this way. He expressed a belief that this was a process error which should not be used as a precedent for how these loans were handled.
As Vice-Chair, Councillor Oades stated that the Committee had traditionally been chaired by an Independent Co-Opted Member.
Councillor Oades proposed and Councillor Pearce seconded that Puneet Jasuja be appointed Chairman for the meeting. The proposal was agreed by the Committee.
Councillor Oades then proposed and Councillor Pearce seconded that a recommendation be submitted to Full Council for Puneet Jasuja to be appointed Chairman of the Audit and Governance Committee for the remainder of the Municipal Year. The proposal unanimously agreed by the Committee.
Councillor Oades stated that the Strategy appeared too narrowly focused on housing and benefits, highlighting Woking’s exposure to commercial risks. Stephen Fitzgerald, Strategic Director of Finance, stated these were addressed through the Improvement and Recovery Plan (IRP) under the oversight of the Commissioners. The Strategy was stated to target areas known as being high risk for fraud, and that expanding its scope would require additional resources.
Councillor Oades expressed concern over replacing the large document at a late stage and asked the reason for differences in asset valuations in the accounts, which had been due to impairment following assessment by Interpath. Following a question as to whether the Council debt to the Public Works Loan Board remained in light of the loan impairments and debt standstill arrangements, the debt was confirmed as remaining with the asset value being amended to reflect the expected recoverable value under current market conditions. Following a question regarding the depreciation calculations related to Hale End Court properties, it was stated that the budget for the year had been set prior to final valuations being available, and fluctuations in asset values would affect the depreciation calculations.
Councillor Oades also asked about the long-term implications of a Private Finance Initiative (PFI) agreement with Kier Partnership Homes, which extended beyond the expected unitarisation in 2027, and it was noted that that the Borough’s contractual obligations would be expected to be inherited by any new unitary authority.
Councillor Oades gave the example of the past year’s Council Tax increase generating £1.1 million in revenue and not considered material under the current threshold. Paul Jacklin stated that the audit team would make use of a lower performance materiality threshold, around £1 million for Woking.
Councillor Oades stated that the delays in the completion of the audit were frustrating. It was noted that there which was a final piece of information was still being prepared by the Council that BDO would need to review this before concluding the audit. Stephen Fitzgerald added that the delays were also symptomatic of broader issues in the local government audit system.
Councillor Oades stated that the insurance audit had generated a number of high-priority recommendations and it was noted the insurance function had been identified as an area requiring improvement with further detail in the progress report.
Councillor Oades asked who was providing assurance on the IRP if it was no longer being audited and how the Committee could maintain oversight of lessons learned. Stephen Fitzgerald advised that Sir Tony Redmond had expressed willingness to engage with members of the Committee, either formally or informally, to provide updates. If required, a separate session could be set up with the Commissioners to facilitate this.
Finance Working Group : Cllr Greentree, Cllr Howes, Cllr Morley, Cllr Mukherjee, Cllr Oades and Cllr Pearce.
Councillor Cosnahan moved and Councillor Pearce seconded the election of Councillor Oades as Vice-Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee.
Resolved That Councillor Oades be elected Vice-Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee for the ensuing year.
Councillor Stephen Oades, Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee, introduced the recommendation from the Committee to approved amended terms of reference covering the responsibilities of the Committee. The terms of reference had been carefully drafted to ensure that they were consistent with CIPFA guidelines.
At the request of Councillor Oades and in accordance with the decision taken earlier in the meeting under Item 11, the Mayor announced that the meeting would move into Part II – Press and Public Excluded – to enable questions to be raised in respect of the confidential supporting paper (the Strategic Options Appraisal) for the Joint Waste Collection Services Contract. Following a short discussion in Part II, the meeting returned to considerations in public and the Mayor referred the Councillors to the recommendation before them, namely to note the Strategic Options Appraisal.
The Vice-Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee, Councillor Oades, spoke to the recommendations of the Committee, explaining that the Committee had added caveats amidst the concerns over the financial position of the Council. The advice of the KC had been sought to assure Councillors that they would not face litigation.
In response to a question from Councillor Oades, the Chief Executive, Richard Carr, stated that the legal advice had confirmed that the Authority had a duty to approve the accounts by the backstop date set by the Government for all local authorities. Once approved, the accounts would be submitted to the external auditors for their opinion, which was expected to be in the form of a disclaimer. An abdication of the responsibility by the Council to approve accounts would bring it into disrepute and would be unhelpful when the Council was again seeking Exceptional Financial Support.
The Chairman thanked Councillor Stephen Oades for calling in the decision to the Committee and invited him to speak on the item.
Councillor Stephen Oades expressed his dissatisfaction with the report, stating that it did not fully capture the background and seemed disingenuous. He argued that claiming a building from the 1980s was obsolete was inaccurate. He highlighted that Brockhill had 48 flats and operated at full or near-full occupancy for over three decades, generating millions for the HRA account.
Councillor S Oades criticized the neglect of both the building and its residents. He mentioned that residents were promised compensation for heating failures in January 2023, but by October 2024, no one had received any compensation.
Louise Strongitharm responded, also addressing a point raised by Councillor Oades on the payback period and rents. She explained that paragraph 5.5 of the report detailed this. At the point of closure, if was fully occupied, the total rent and service charge for Brockhill was £540,000.
Councillor Oades asked when the consolidated accounts would be available if required for an audit opinion to be issued by BDO. Stephen Fitzgerald stated that they would not be available by the backstop date, noting the initial focus had been on producing sole entity accounts.
Following a question by Councillor Oades as to how long it would take BDO to issue opinions after the production of consolidated accounts and the receipt of MCHLG advice, Steve Bladen reiterated that an exact timeline could not be provided due to the complexity of the issues and the need to consider the advice.
Councillor Oades reiterated an error in the audit deliverables section of the report, which he had highlighted at the previous meeting, noting that the planned date for the audit findings report was incorrectly listed as February 2028 instead of February 2025.
Councillor Oades added that further context should be included to enable Members to interpret the data provided in the tables in the report. It was added that the finalised Internal Audit summary reports were available for Members in their reference area within Teams.
Councillor Oades suggested adding the relevant areas of the Improvement and Recovery Plan as an appendix to the Statement. Adesuwa Omoregie stated that the governance aspects of the Improvement and Recovery Plan could be created as a living document to keep the Committee informed of progress.
In the absence of the Chairman, the meeting was chaired by the Vice-Chairman, Councillor Stephen Oades. Apologies from Joanne Brown, Partner at Grant Thornton, Kevin Foster, Strategic Director – Corporate Resources, and Stephen Fitzgerald, Strategic Director for Finance (S151 Officer), were also received. The Council’s new Interim Director of Legal and Democratic Services (Monitoring Officer), Suki Binjal, the Deputy S151 Officer, Brendan Bradley who would be commencing employment in the coming weeks, and the Principal Financial Advisor, Yusuf Erol, were introduced to the Committee.
Councillor Oades added that the report did not include any figures and as such the progress could not be demonstrated. Section 5 referred to asset rationalisation and debt reduction and it was felt that the report should have included details of the assets sold, their target price and the value realised, together with any next steps. Officers advised that the report was intended to provide a general overview of progress achieved aimed at the Government appointed Commissioners, set around the success measures identified by the Commissioners to judge the performance of the Council.
Councillor Oades commented that the level of borrowing taken by the Council was clearly not sustainable or prudent and the loans were also taken from the PWLB for revenue purposes.
Councillor Oades also challenged the statement in paragraph 10.1 that the Council’s overall financial performance in 2019/20 was good. Stephen Fitzgerald highlighted that the 2019/20 accounts are as they were presented to the auditors and the issuing of the section 114 notice has led to a significant re-assessment of both the revenue account and balance sheet of the Council. The adjustments associated with the section 114 notice would be made in the 2023/24 accounts, rather than re-stating prior years.
Councillor Oades moved and Councillor Cosnahan seconded the election of Claire Storey, Independent Co-Opted Member, as Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee.
Councillor Cosnahan moved and Councillor Greentree seconded the election of Councillor Oades as Vice-Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee.
RESOLVED That Councillor Oades be elected Vice-Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee for the ensuing year.
In receiving the report on the proposed membership of the Standards Panel, the Council noted that Councillor Oades, rather than Councillor Rice, was to be appointed a substitute member.
Councillor Oades moved and Councillor Cosnahan seconded the election of Councillor Boote as Chair of the Committee.
Councillor Oades asked for a work plan for the outstanding items alongside timelines for their completion and Steve advised that BDO would consider whether anything further could be provided. Eugene Walker, Interim Section 151 Officer, advised that there was no outstanding work for the Council to carry out in relation to the 2019/20 Audit and the finance team was working on closing the 2022/23 accounts.
RESOLVED That (i) Councillor Leach be appointed to Licensing Sub-Committee A in place of Councillor Oades for 2023/24; and (ii) Councillor Sullivan be appointed to Licensing Sub-Committee B in place of Councillor Leach for 2023/24.
Councillor S Oades commented that the Committee had received an email that day, that stated that the land inside of the fence belonged to the property owner. Following some clarification the Planning Officer commented that he had seen this letter, but clarified that land ownership was irrelevant and that the lawful use of this land was as amenity space, not as part of the private garden.
TOTAL: 6 Against: Cllr S Oades.
Councillor Morales moved and Councillor Oades seconded the election of the Councillor Aziz as Vice Chairman of the Planning Committee.
TOTAL: 9 Against: Cllr S Oades.
Councillor Oades moved and Councillor Akberali seconded the election of Councillor Morley as Chairman of the Committee.
Councillor Morley moved and Councillor Akberali seconded the election of Councillor Oades as Vice-Chairman of the Committee.
RESOLVED That Councillor S Oades be elected Vice-Chairman of the Appeals Committee for the ensuing year.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Oades attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 Mar 2026 | Council | 2026-27 Fees and Charges EXE26-018 | Carried | 20 for, 2 against | |
| 12 Feb 2026 | Council | Statement of Accounts 2023-24 and 2024-25. AUD26-001 | Carried | 25 for, 1 against | |
| 24 Jul 2025 | Council | Appointment of the Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee. | Carried | 17 for, 1 against | |
| 19 Jun 2025 | Audit and Governance Committee | Chairing the Meeting | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Feb 2025 | Council | Fees and Charges 2025-26 EXE24-060 | Carried | 24 for, 2 against | |
| 10 Feb 2025 | Resource and Finance Scrutiny Committee | Resolution | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Dec 2024 | Communities and Housing Scrutiny Committee | Overview of Brockhill Decisions CHSC24-015 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Nov 2024 | Council | Public Interest Report from Grant Thornton WBC24-048. | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 4 Mar 2024 | Council | Capital, Investment and Treasury Management Strategies and MRP Statement WBC24-001 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 4 Mar 2024 | Council | Councillor Saj Hussain - Funding for Non-Statutory Services. | Lost | 8 for, 14 against | |
| 8 Feb 2024 | Council | Appointment of Director of Finance and Section 151 Officer WBC24-004. | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 30 Nov 2023 | Council | Amendments to Constitution - Media Protocol STA23-025 | Carried | 20 for, 1 against | |
| 30 Nov 2023 | Council | Notice of Motion - Councillor Hassan Akberali - Single Use Vapes. | Carried | 19 for, 2 against | |
| 12 Oct 2023 | Council | Appointment of New Officer Director to Victoria Square Woking Group Companies WBC23-039. | Carried | 20 for, 3 against | |
| 23 Feb 2023 | Council | Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS), General Fund, Service Plans, Budgets and Prudential Indicators 2023-24 WBC23-002. | Carried | 17 for, 6 against | |
| 23 Feb 2023 | Council | Council Tax 2023/24. | Carried | 15 for, 7 against | |
| 1 Dec 2022 | Council | Woking Strategic Partnerships EXE22-059 | Lost | 6 for, 18 against | |
| 1 Dec 2022 | Council | Review of Fees and Charges 2023-24 EXE22-062 | Carried | 14 for, 7 against |
Meetings Councillor Oades was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 16 of 19 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Oades declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Oades in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Oades sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2022 | 40 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Audit and Governance Committee | Committee Member | May 2023 | 21 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| Resource and Finance Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | May 2024 | 16 | |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | May 2022 | 24 | |
| Appeals Committee | Deputy Chair | May 2022 | 1 | |
| Communities and Housing Scrutiny Committee | Guest | Dec 2024 | 1 | |
| Executive | Guest | Sep 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.