Planning Application Ref W/26/00695/RM.
A proposal from Councillor C G J Tucker was put forward to defer the application for further consideration which was seconded by Councillor A I Hardman.
Every time Wychavon's minutes name Councillor Hardman, as the council published it.
A proposal from Councillor C G J Tucker was put forward to defer the application for further consideration which was seconded by Councillor A I Hardman.
Councillor A Hardman queried when the Committee will be reduced to thirteen members. Meesha Patel confirmed this was intended to come to Council in September, ahead of the deadline of October 31 2026.
Chairman of the Audit Committee, Councillor A Hardman, informed Council that there has been one meeting of the Committee since the last Council. The Committee reviewed the annual Internal Audit Report and Chris Green was thanked for producing it. The Treasury Management report was also reviewed and found to be satisfactory.
Councillor A I Hardman asked a question of the County Highways Manager regarding Stonebow Road as their comments seemed to infer that there was an issue with capacity at the junction with the B4084. The County Highways Manager responded explaining the position and also regarding the cumulative impact that they can only consider sites in the SWDP and that have planning permission.
Councillor A Hardman referenced Neighbourhood Development Plans (NDPs).
Councillor Adrian Hardman asked a couple of questions regarding Wychavon’s involvement in public health, particularly in relation to suicide prevention. Jen Taylor confirmed that Hayley Corbett, Health and Wellbeing Officer, works closely with public health colleagues and linked this to the development of the wellbeing hub in Honeybourne and Whittington.
Mr & [name removed] A I Hardman, non-pecuniary, the applicant was known to him when she was on the Parish Council.
(Councillor A I Hardman had declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item and was present for its consideration and determination.) (Councillor J Protherough, Eckington Parish Council, spoke against approval of this application.) ([name removed] spoke against approval of this application.) ([name removed] and [name removed] spoke for approval of this application.) A site visit had taken place.
Councillor A I Hardman shared his concern that the Cotswold National Conservation Board was maintaining its objection as it believed that the development would cause harm to the natural landscape setting.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, gave the following update:- “We met on the 26 September and we did have a thrilling meeting because before that we had an informal meeting where we did an in-depth investigation into cyber security. The bit that I took away is their motto not if but when and I’d remind all members to ensure that their cyber security training is up to date.
This was seconded by Councillor A I Hardman who could not see any harm in the extension which could ... view the full minutes text for item 39a
It was proposed by Councillor E J Kearsey and seconded by Councillor A I Hardman and Resolved To delegate authority to the Director of Planning and Infrastructure to grant Listed Building Consent with an appropriate set of conditions attached.
The Chairman particularly welcomed Councillor Adrian Hardman to his first meeting since becoming a member of the planning committee.
E McQueen referred to an event Melton Borough Council had held which offered free health screening checks for farmers; more details on the link - Health checks for farmers – Melton Borough Council Councillor A Hardman raised the topic of biodiversity landbanks and whether they are having any impact on the rural areas, D Manning said he would take this up with Liz Etheridge, Wychavon’s Senior Environment Officer for Heritage.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, advised:
Councillor Emma Kearsey will be taking over from Councillor Paul Middlebrough as Executive Board representative and Councillor Adrian Hardman will be taking over from Councillor Tony Hartley as a Panel Member. She thanked both members for their time on the Panel. Apologies for absence were received from Councillors A Hardman and E Sims and officer D Manning.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, gave the following update:
It was proposed by Councillor A I Hardman, seconded by Councillor D Birch, and with no other nominations, it was Resolved That Councillor G Wilkins be elected Vice-Chairman of the Council to hold office until immediately after the election of the Chairman at the next Annual meeting of the Council.
That the following be elected as Chairmen/Vice-Chairmen of Committees for 2025/26:- Committee Chairman Vice-Chairman Audit Councillor A I Hardman Councillor N Dawkes Licensing Councillor C Day Councillor J Grady Member Conduct Councillor R Raphael Councillor A I Hardman Overview & Scrutiny Councillor C Homer Councillor M Ward Planning Councillor N Wright Councillor A Dyke and Councillor N Dawkes
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, gave the following update:- “The Audit Committee met on 22 November. It considered the Budget that has been recommended by Council tonight. It also considered the Treasury Management and discussed how well the team are doing in managing the assets that the Council has.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Adrian Hardman, commented that the inability of EY to complete its work was deeply regrettable, especially highlighting how EY had failed to conclude the 2020/21 accounts despite all of the Council’s work being completed on time, and stated that it was unsatisfactory that EY had provided no work of significance for the 2022/23 accounts.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, gave the following update:- “The Committee met at the end of September and we reviewed the Risk Register which had been revised at the suggestion of the Committee to ensure that the impact and mitigation measures on risk were correctly shown.
It was then proposed by Councillor A I Hardman, seconded by Councillor D Boatright-Greene, and Resolved That the amendments as proposed above be added into the procedure document and circulated to Members of the Committee for their approval prior to publication.
Councillor P Middlebrough advised that the Local Member, Councillor A Hardman, had a longstanding appointment and was not able to be present at the meeting.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, gave the following update:
The Chairman advised that the Chairs and Vice-Chairs appointed to the following Committees would remain the same as for 2023/24, as follows:- Audit Committee · Councillor A I Hardman - Chair · Councillor N Dawkes – Vice-Chair Licensing Committee · Councillor M S Goodge – Chair · Councillor E J Bowden – Vice-Chair Member Conduct Committee · Councillor A Hartley – Chair · Councillor P Middlebrough – Vice-Chair Overview and Scrutiny Committee · Councillor C D Homer · Councillor B Hurdman Planning Committee · Councillor N Wright – Chair · Councillor A L Dyke – Vice-Chair
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee gave the following update:- “The Audit Committee has not met since the last Council meeting but is meeting at 2pm this Friday and of course all members will be welcome.
The Local Member, Councillor A Hardman was concerned that the replacement dwelling was more than 30% larger than the original dwelling. He acknowledged the use of materials were in-keeping with the village, but was of the opinion that the design was brutalist and not in-keeping with the village design statement.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, gave the following update:- “The Committee have met once since the last Council meeting and I am delighted to be able to inform Council that we have met our new External Auditors, Azets. That meeting they attended in person and created a very positive impression on the Audit Committee and I look forward to them being able to build a positive and constructive relationship with our finance team. The challenge will be, and for the Council as well, to establish a base line when means Ernst and Young have to finish the two years of audits that they still have to do so they can commence their work from a strong and robust position.
The Chair, Councillor Adrian Hardman, welcomed Karen Jones and Michael Butler of Azets to the meeting.
Councillor A Hardman gave an update on the Member Conduct Committee and advised that the Monitoring Officer was continuing to deal with ongoing complaints but that the Committee had not met since the last council meeting but was next due to meet in February 2024.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, gave the following update:
Sara Stojanovic, Corporate Database Manager said upon reading the Parish Council and local member Councillor Adrian Hardman comments the application does meet the essential criteria set out in 3.5 of the report.
Following the discussions, Councillor Adrian Hardman, the Chair of the Audit Committee, proposed to amend the recommendations set out at 2.1 and 2.2 as follows:
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, updated the Council as follows:
It was proposed by Councillor A I Hardman, seconded by Councillor P Middlebrough, and Resolved That in accordance with the provisions of Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, the public and press be excluded from the meeting during the consideration of the following business on the grounds that they involve the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in paragraph 1 of Part 1 of Schedule 12A to the Act.
Councillor A I Hardman seconded the proposal and it was Resolved That the proposal to appoint David Brotheridge and Chris Jewkes as Independent Members to the Member Conduct Committee be endorsed.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, advised that the Audit Committee had not yet met since the last Council meeting but was due to meet on Friday 21 July at 2.00pm and anyone was welcome to attend.
Councillor Adrian Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, advised that there had been no meetings since the last Council meeting, however it was meeting on Friday 21 April, and he encouraged all Members, particularly those that weren’t standing again, to attend.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee advised that at the meeting on 3 February Members considered the budget, Capital Strategy and Treasury Management Strategy. The Committee also reviewed the progress that the Internal Auditors were making and found that to be sound as well.
Councillor Hardman also gave an update on the position regarding the External Auditors. He advised that unfortunately the Committee still had not seen the audited accounts for 2020 and 2021 but have been assured that this would be presented to the meeting on 21 April and should be signed off before the end of the Council term.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Adrian Hardman, highlighted a number of local authorities that had invested poorly and were struggling financially, and asked the Council to remain vigilant when it came to lending to other UK local authorities.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, gave the following update:- “ Since the last Council meeting on 20 July there have been two meetings of the Audit Committee:
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Adrian Hardman, raised the importance of changes to staff working practices as a risk factor, citing his experience of being aware of local authorities losing staff who were finding alternative ... view the full minutes text for item 12.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Adrian Hardman, expressed his disappointment with the ongoing delay, adding that he hoped the situation would be resolved in time for the Audit Committee’s next meeting.
Councillor A Hardman, Chair of the Audit Committee, advised that the Committee had not met since the Council’s last special meeting.
Councillor Hardman updated Council regarding the delay on the side of the Council’s external auditors in relation to the Council’s Statement of Accounts for 2020/21, and added that many other councils around the UK were in a similar position.
The Leader advised that the Chairman and Vice-Chairman appointed to the following committees would remain the same as for 2021/22, as follows:- Audit Committee · Councillor A I Hardman – Chairman · Councillor P Griffiths – Vice-Chairman Licensing Committee · Councillor A P Miller – Chairman · Councillor R W Raphael – Vice-Chairman Member Conduct Committee · Councillor Mrs E A Eyre – Chairman · Councillor A I Hardman – Vice-Chairman Overview and Scrutiny Committee · Councillor Mrs F S Smith – Chairman · Councillor A P Miller – Vice-Chairman Planning Committee · Councillor D Wilkinson – Chairman · Councillor Mrs E A Eyre – Vice-Chairman
The Local Member Councillor A Hardman did not support the application. He thanked officers for hosting the site visit which he hoped members found helpful. He pointed out that where the bus was parked had previously been flooded.
Councillor Hardman stated that if we believed in the planning process we have to support Bredon’s local plan which has been approved by the inspector and should be given most weight. He urged the committee to refuse the application because the only way he felt that all the issues that this application raises could be discussed to the satisfaction of Tewkesbury Borough, Mitton and Bredon residents, was for the application to come in front of the inspector. The County Highways Officers advised members on the highways issues including the traffic assessments.
The Local Member Councillor A Hardman did not support the application. He informed the committee that the land had not been a considered site within the Bredon Neighbourhood Plan which had been agreed and adopted by a large % of the Bredon Ward. He stressed that there was major opposition from the residents of Bredon regarding the application and said they had a democratic right to have their views considered and, that weight should be given to the adopted Neighbourhood Plan.
Councillor Hardman stated that the site had not been allocated in the SWDP so was contrary to policy and said that although a ‘Duty to co-operate’ document had been signed it was not the same as a ‘Duty to agree’. He also felt that the consultation had been poor. He raised concerns over highways issues, particularly at junction 8 M5, as well as environmental issues, and detriment to the AONB.
Councillor Hardman then dre the committees attention to a garden town initiative that Tewksbury Town Council were part of.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, advised that the Committee had met once on 17 September 2021 and he gave the following update:- “We considered 2 main items – one was satisfactory and one less than satisfactory.
This unfortunately means that Wychavon will join a growing list of Councils who have not had their audits completed and therefore their accounts signed off by the due date.” A question was asked as to whether there was likely to be any financial penalty to the Council for not having the accounts signed off by the due date and Councillor Hardman responded that he was not aware of any penalty given the growing number of other Councils in a similar situation.
The Leader advised that the Chairman and Vice-Chairman appointed to the following committees would remain the same as for 2020/21, as follows:- Audit Committee Chairman – Councillor A I Hardman Vice-Chairman – Councillor P Griffiths Licensing Committee Chairman – Councillor A P Miller Vice-Chairman – Councillor R Raphael Member Conduct Committee Chairman – Councillor Mrs E A Eyre Vice-Chairman – Councillor A I Hardman Overview and Scrutiny Committee Chairman – Councillor Mrs F S Smith Vice-Chairman – Councillor A P Miller Planning Committee Chairman – Councillor D Wilkinson Vice-Chairman – Councillor Mrs E A Eyre
In the absence of Councillor Mrs E A Eyre, Chairman of the Member Conduct Committee, the Vice-Chairman, Councillor A I Hardman, updated the Council and confirmed that the Member Conduction Committee had met once since the last Council meeting.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, confirmed that the Audit Committee had met once since the last Council meeting.
Councillor Hardman reassured Members that the Council was performing well.
Councillor Hardman further informed Members that sound assurance had also been received regarding Internal Audit and that the Internal Audit Plan for 2021/22 had been approved and had highlighted the key risk areas for the Council to be aware of.
Councillor Hardman concluded his update by informing Members that the Audit Committee had discussed the Council’s Corporate Risk Register in order to ensure that it was a true reflection of the challenges the Council would face.
The Local Member Councillor A Hardman did not support the application, he said that the application fell outside of the residential boundary. He referred to the Bredon Neighbourhood Plan and advised the committee that the application conflicted with NP2, the local gap in the plan and P13, greenspace allocation.
In addition Councillor Hardman had concerns about the impact on the AONB and said that the parish council opposed the application.
Councillor Adrian Hardman raised concerns relating to flooding, in particular the issue of flooding to domestic properties in the south of the district. He added he was aware of at least five properties that had been recently flooded.
Councillor Hardman suggested that the Council may wish to re-visit the issue in terms of some form of scrutiny.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, advised that the Audit Committee had met once and the main focus was a review of the Budget, Treasury Management, both of which had been agreed earlier in the meeting. He added that the Committee had also reviewed the Internal Audit progress and it was noted that the plan was now closer to track.
Finally, Councillor Hardman advised that the Committee approved the Audit Letter from Ernst and Young for the year 2019/20.
Councillor Hardman did not think enough consideration had been given to this sensitive site. He felt that it was against SWDP 2 and NP1 in the Bredon Neighbourhood Plan and also contrary to the Bredon Visual Design Statement which was agreed by Council in 2011. In his view it would have an amenity impact on neighbours It was a single track road leading to this development and he did not think this a suitable site even for a self build especially as there was only a shortfall of three self build dwellings in the District now.
The Chairman of the Audit Committee, Councillor A I Hardman, gave the following update:- “The Audit Committee has met twice since the last Council meeting and the main focus of our work has been the signing off of the accounts and I am pleased to be able to reassure Council that it had been done satisfactorily and the deadlines have been met. There are no items that I would draw to the attention of the Council in those accounts that have now been signed off. I think that is an excellent recommendation for the Council that we’ve managed to make the deadline this year as a number of councils are going to struggle even with the deadline having been put back.
That the decision to approve the recommendations and additional narrative relating to the Council’s Going Concern Disclosure be delegated to Jayne Pickering, Deputy Chief Executive, in consultation with the Chairman of the Committee, Councillor Adrian Hardman.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, advised that there had been just one meeting of the Audit Committee since the last ordinary meeting of the Council in July.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, advised that the Committee had met virtually on one occasion since the last meeting of the Council. He added that this was in the relatively early days of Zoom on 22 May 2020.
The Local Member, Councillor Hardman, advised that the question of the site’s development for gypsies/travellers had been going on for 16 years and gave a brief history of it. He maintained that the proposal is over-development in the open countryside. He was concerned that if this application was turned down it would be lost at appeal because the Council does not currently have a 5 year supply of gypsy/traveller plots or a gypsy/traveller strategy plan in place.
Councillor Hardman stated the proposal is against the Bredon Neighbourhood Plan and Policy NP1 but thought it was probably time to move on with this after 16 years. He agreed with Bredon’s Norton Parish Council’s suggestion that the impact on the AONB should be mitigated by means of a 25m deep landscape buffer at the front of the site.
Councillor A I Hardman, Vice-Chairman of the Member Conduct Committee, advised that since the last Council meeting, the Member Conduct Committee had not met. The planned February meeting was postponed to 9 March 2020 at the request of a Parish Councillor who had asked for a hearing of the complaint against him as he did not accept the findings of the investigation.
Councillor Hardman explained that the Monitoring Officer had resolved a number of parish council issues through informal discussion and that the Chairman of the Member Conduct Committee, along with the independent member had considered one formal complaint which was not progressed.
Councillor Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, advised that the Committee had met once since the last Council meeting, on 7 February 2020.
It was proposed by Councillor A Hardman and seconded by Councillor S Bateman and Resolved That the minutes of the meeting of the Audit Committee held on Thursday 21 November, be approved as a correct record of the proceedings and signed by the Chairman.
Resolved That it be agreed that the decision to appoint an auditor for the Housing Benefit Assurance Process for 2019/20, will again be delegated to Vic Allison, Deputy Managing Director, in consultation with the Chairman of the Committee, Councillor Adrian Hardman.
It was suggested that the Parish Council contact County Councillor Adrian Hardman to see if he is willing to contribute towards the project using his Divisional Fund.
Councillor A I Hardman highlighted his concerns regarding his ward, however the acknowledged that this process needed to be started. He did ask officers to reconsider their decision not to hold a consultation even in Bredon area.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, advised that there had been two meetings of the Audit Committee since the last Council meeting.
Councillor Hardman thanked the Committee’s Vice-Chairman, Councillor P Griffiths, who chaired the September meeting in his absence.
The Panel agreed that the pub itself meets the criteria for an Asset of Community Value as it appears to be well used, however, the application also requests that the skittle building and the car par at the rear listed and have therefore asked the Local Member, Councillor Adrian Hardman to obtain further evidence, within 21 days, that the skittle alley is used by the community. RECOMMENDED 1. The Panel considered the evidence and agreed to recommend designation of The Royal Oak, Main Road, Bredon as an Asset of Community Value.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, advised that, very unusually, the Audit Committee had not yet met. However that would soon be resolved as the first meeting of the Committee would take place that Friday.
Councillor Eyre advised the Committee that she and Councillor Hardman sat on the Cotswold Conservation Board (CCB). She added that the CCB had recently been asked to respond to a consultation to the Joint Advisory Panel concerning the South Worcestershire Development Plan (SWDP).
Councillor B A Thomas proposed the appointments which were seconded by Councillor R J Morris and it was Resolved That the following be elected as Chairmen/Vice-Chairmen of Committees for 2019/20:- Committee Chairman Vice-Chairman Audit Councillor A I Hardman Councillor P Griffiths Licensing Councillor A P Miller Councillor R Raphael Member Conduct Councillor Mrs E Eyre Councillor A I Hardman Overview & Scrutiny Councillor G S Bearcroft Councillor A P Miller Planning Councillor D Wilkinson Councillor Mrs E Eyre
He invited Councillor A I Hardman to introduce the video clip showing Midlands Connect A46.
Councillor Hardman explained that the A46 was a key route from Lincolnshire right through to Gloucestershire which spanned 155 miles and 9% of the country’s economic activity was driven along it. He added that Midlands Connect had picked it up as one of the 3 key routes to be improved.
Following the film Councillor Hardman advised that the next stage of the project was for Highways England to make a bid for Regional Strategic Infrastructure Fund monies to focus on the Ashchurch /Evesham and Newark ends of the A46.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, advised that the Committee had a very busy meeting the previous week signing off a number of matters including:- · Accounting policies for use in the preparation of the 2018/19 statement of accounts;
She read out a statement from local member, Councillor Adrian Hardman, who fully supports the proposal.
Councillor A Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee gave the following update:- “The Audit Committee met on 8 February and spent some time going through the Council’s budget proposals for 2019/20 as well as the longer term financial position. We then moved on to the Council’s capital and treasury management strategies for 2019/20 and found both strategies to be sound.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, gave the following key messages from the Audit Committee meeting held on 22 November 2018:- · The main item of discussion was the Council’s budget and promises for 2019/20. The Committee discussed progress on the Grow Save Charge business plan and importantly considered the risks around future financial projections, particularly in the medium term, including the key assumptions that have been made. Whilst there was uncertainty for the period beyond the next financial year, members could be sure that the Council was in the best possible position and able to withstand most foreseeable shocks.
Councillor Hardman then reminded members that the next meeting of the Committee would take place on 8 February and any members that wished to attend would be more than welcome.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, advised that the Committee had met once, on 21 September and had received the Annual Audit Letter, reviewed the Internal Audit process and also looked at Treasury Management.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee advised that t here had been 2 meetings of the Audit Committee since the Council last met. On the 23 May the Committee considered the Council’s Annual Governance Statement for inclusion in the Statement of Accounts for 2017/18 along with the Financial Outturn position for 2017/18.
Councillor Hardman added that it was pleasing to note that savings during the year had exceeded officer expectations. The Committee also agreed to appoint Ernst and Young LLP as the Council’s auditors for Housing Benefit work next year.
Councillor Hardman explained that on 19 July the Committee considered and approved the Council’s Statement of Accounts for 2017/18 having received a clean bill of health from the external auditors. The Committee went on to consider the Internal Audit report for 2017/18, the revised Corporate Risk Register and the Treasury Management Outturn for 2017/18.
No concerns were raised at either meeting which Councillor Hardman needed to draw attention to – and the Council’s systems of control were working well.
Councillor Hardman concluded by reminding Members that there would be training taking place on Capital Strategy and Treasury Management at the next meeting on 21 September 2018 at 2.00pm and all were invited.
In response to a query from the Chairman, Councillor A Hardman, Vic agreed that officers would look at incorporating mention of the wholly-owned housing company that was intended to be created.
The Chairman, Councillor A Hardman, commented that the update indicated a continuing sound and prudent spread of investment, and invited comments or questions from the Committee.
It was proposed by Councillor A I Hardman, seconded by Councillor N J Dowty and Resolved That the Joint Anti-Fraud, Corruption and Money Laundering Policy be adopted.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, advised that there had been one meeting since Council last met and Members considered and recommended approval to the Council of a new combined Anti-Fraud & Corruption and Money Laundering Policy. Previously the policies were separate. He added that It was important that all members familiarise themselves with this new policy.
Councillor Hardman added that external and internal audit plans for 2018/19 were given a final sign off and, as part of the final accounts process for 2017/18, Members agreed the Council’s accounting policies which included one change from previous years in respect of depreciation.
In response to a query from the Chairman, Councillor A Hardman, Wychavon’s preparedness for adoption of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) was discussed in detail. Vic Allison, Deputy Managing Director, noted that it was expected for Wychavon to be fully compliant by the enforcement date of May 25 2018.
In response to a query from the Chairman, Councillor A Hardman, Hassan confirmed that a pension surplus would be described as an asset rather than a liability.
In response to a query from the Chairman, Councillor A Hardman, members and officers discussed the ongoing need for greater efficiency and communication regarding the Home Improvement Agency and Disabled Facilities Grants. Vic Allison, Deputy Managing Director, informed the Committee of a review of current arrangements, which would be commissioned shortly.
In response to a query from the Chairman, Councillor A Hardman, Andy noted that the core financial systems were not considered to be an area of major risk, due to embedded and robust processes and controls, although a watching brief would be maintained, and that it was considered that Internal Audit resource could be better used in other areas where greater risk could be identified.
In response to a query from the Chairman, Councillor A Hardman, Natalie explained the process by which the pension scheme was audited by a different external auditor, and noted that Ernst & Young received and reviewed the results of this audit.
In response to a query from the Chairman, Councillor A Hardman, regarding inconsistencies in connecting payments made for licenses to the licenses that had been issued, Andy noted that a recommendation for more robust processes to be put in place had been made, and that a working group had been formed to address a number of issues.
The Chairman, Councillor A Hardman, commented that the proposals seemed to cover actions already being taken by Wychavon, and the Committee briefly discussed this.
The Leader updated the Council on a number of changes to the membership of Committees:- · Joint Consultative Committee – Councillor Mrs F S Smith replacing Councillor A P Miller · Overview and Scrutiny Committee – Councillor M J Snape replacing Councillor A I Hardman
Councillor A I Hardman then commented that he was in agreement with giving authority to sign the document, however he would like to see that consultation with the 2 local ward members be included. He also detailed issues regarding no consultation with local residents. With the majority of members voting in support of the recommendations and 4 abstentions from Councillors A P Miller, C G J Tucker, [name removed] and K N Wright, it was Resolved That delegated authority be given to the Managing Director, in consultation with the Leader, to progress and sign a Joint Planning Statement with Tewkesbury Borough Council (on behalf of the Joint Core Strategy Councils) to inform the preparation of a Memorandum of Agreement for the possible release of land at Mitton to meet unmet housing needs associated with Tewkesbury Borough’s housing requirement subject to the Joint Core Strategy Inspector’s further recommendation with respect to the latest modifications to the emerging plan.
Councillor A I Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee, informed the Council that the last meeting of the Committee had been very successful and had brought out some of the skills that members bring to the meetings.
Councillor A I Hardman, the local ward member added his gratitude to the tremendous amount of work undertaken by the community and the excellent result at the referendum.
In response to a question from the Chairman, Councillor A Hardman, Nigel reassured members that Wychavon had not been affected by the ransomware attack, but informed the Committee that IT staff had spent the weekend in question ensuring that the council was not susceptible to the system weakness that it had been designed to exploit.
Councillor A I Hardman proposed and Councillor Mrs L R Duffy seconded that Councillor Mrs E A Eyre be elected Chairman of the Council.
Natalie noted that the Chairman, Councillor A Hardman, had drafted a satisfactory response.
Councillor A Hardman thanked officers for a very interesting visit and presentation, and commented that the Review Team could consider contacting District Councils who had chosen to operate a part-time monitoring scheme in order to gain a measure of comparable information.
Councillor A I Hardman advised Members that the Audit Committee, at its meeting on 10 February, considered the budget from a risk perspective and he was pleased to announce that the key financial risks were identified and were being managed. He added that the Committee also signed off the Audit Plan for 2017/18. He informed Members of the update from the External Auditors which had reported on the housing benefit subsidy claim (£28million) and advised that it was a statutory regulation that had to be audited.
Two overpayments had been identified totalling less than £1700 and in light of the subsidy claim Councillor Hardman and the Committee regarded this to be a very good result.
In response to a query from the Chairman, Councillor A Hardman, Natalie explained the guidelines that specified sample size, and the process by which additional testing is mandated by the previous certification letter.
Councillor A I Hardman introduced the following recommendation from the Audit Committee meeting held on 24 November 2016 which was seconded by Councillor M S Goodge:- Confirmation of Auditor Appointment 2017/18 Resolved That Wychavon District Council opts in to the appointing person arrangements made by Public Sector Audit Appointments (PSAA) for the appointment of external auditors.
Councillor A I Hardman advised Members that the Audit Committee, at its meeting on 24 November 2016, considered as its principal business the External Auditor appointment and the process going forward and he thanked Members for their unanimous approval earlier in the meeting.
In response to a query from Councillor A Hardman, Fiona agreed that if all promises and targets were being delivered and met, it could indicate that the bar had been set too low and that this would be taken into account for the future. Fiona also noted that members were asked to suggest new promises and targets in order to ensure that Wychavon continued to challenge itself.
In response to a query from Councillor A Hardman, Councillor O’Donnell discussed the many areas of research and monitoring from which health statistics had been drawn, and noted that the overall aim of his efforts was tied into the national strategy of assisting the public to live well and to look after themselves better, with the associated reduction in NHS pressure being viewed as a side benefit.
The Chairman, Councillor A Hardman, thanked Andy and reiterated that the report was a chance to have input into shaping the plan.
The Chairman, Councillor A Hardman, stated that he felt in no doubt that the ‘People, Place, Prosperity’ approach has worked very well and noted that the key achievement was stability and resilience, backed up by a longer-term perspective.
Councillor Hardman complimented the wisdom and ambition of Wychavon’s approach and noted that the right decision was being taken by the Council in the removal of New Homes Bonus sums from the Council’s baseline in order to reduce or avoid risks presented by potential future changes or reductions.
Councillor Hardman noted that business rates income had performed very well over recent years, but queried how sustainable this was in light of potential changes to rates retention levels. The Chairman agreed that Wychavon’s position was very good against a backdrop of substantial risk, and noted that its robust plan should allow the Council to successfully absorb hits even if they prove to be heavier than anticipated.
Councillor Hardman could always be nominated to the panel later.
The minute should be reworded, therefore, to note that "… Councillor Hardman volunteered to be a panel member." It was RESOLVED That the minutes be amended accordingly for approval at the next meeting of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
Councillor A Hardman also noted concerns over primary care and GPs, and suggested that South Worcestershire CCG could be initially questioned.
Councillor A Hardman explained that while there was Government interest in more smaller-scale building, i.e. individuals having their own properties built, the way the legislative framework has developed has meant that this can be very difficult, for example in terms of acquiring land, with very little self-building happening anywhere in the country. It was suggested that some 25% of properties were self-built 10 to 15 years ago, and that there had been a request from Government to look at ways to generate self-build property interest on Council-owned land.
Councillor A Hardman queried if public expectation had been checked at all, and noted that it had been his experience that there was little public understanding of what Enforcement is, and why it exists.
She also advised that Councillor A Hardman had recently been appointed as Wychavon’s representative on the A46 Member Partnership which was a multi agency group established to work with Highways England to promote manor investment in the A46 trunk road.
Councillor A Hardman, Chairman of the Audit Committee highlighted 3 key points coming out of the meeting of the Committee held on 2 June 2016:- · The Committee considered the annual governance statement and accounting policies which were included in the 2015/16 accounts. He added that these were available on the website and could be inspected by members of the public up to 11 August 2016;
The Leader advised that Councillor A I Hardman had agreed to be Wychavon’s representative.
Cllr Hardman also mentioned flooding issues, the site was not in a sustainable location, there were no footways, it impacted on the AONB and were policy reasons to refuse it.
In answer to a question raised by the Chairman, Councillor Hardman, Helen confirmed that there was a follow up procedure to ensure that recommendations made were followed through. There was a check done after 6 months and then after a further 3 months. If it was found that recommendations were not being followed, then the issue would be bought to the Committee.
The Chairman, Councillor Hardman, commented on the risk identified in respect of the failure to let contracts. Vic advised that, in respect of the waste contract, any work undertaken so far could still be utilised.
The Chairman, Councillor Hardman, thanked Avtar for his update.
The Chairman, Councillor Hardman, pointed members to the key questions posed for the Audit Committee shown on page 65 of the papers.
In answer to a question raised by the Chairman, Councillor Hardman, Vic Allison, Deputy Managing Director, advised that the slippage in capital programme spend was due to valid reasons. In some cases the work had been done but the money had not yet been requested by the relevant parties.
The Chairman, Councillor Hardman, asked what the Council’s policy was on the revaluation of assets. Alison advised this was undertaken at least every 5 years on a rolling basis but some assets were valued every year such as investment properties.
It was proposed by Councillor A I Hardman, seconded by Councillor G O’Donnell and Resolved That Councillor Mrs E A Eyre be elected Vice-Chairman of the Council to hold office until immediately after the election of the Chairman at the next Annual meeting of the Council.
She added that Councillor A I Hardman, Leader of Worcestershire County Council and the local Members of Parliament had written to Greg Clark, the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government, about this as other Councils were also burdened with the implications of the revaluation.
It was proposed by Councillor A P Miller, seconded by Councillor A I Hardman, and Resolved That, in accordance with the provisions of Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, the public and the press be excluded from the meeting during the consideration of confidential information given in relation to consideration of the following application on the grounds that they involve the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in paragraph 2 of Part 1 of Schedule 12A to the Act and the public interest in withholding the information outweighs the public interest in disclosing the information to the public.
The Local Member was not present at the meeting and had asked Councillor A I Hardman to represent him. In his view he did not think the proposed extension was subservient to the existing building but that the fall back position would be worse. He had concerns with development rights, landscaping, the mobile home on the site and wanted the site to be used for residential use only.
Councillor J H Smith spoke on behalf of the ward member, Councillor A I Hardman who was unable to attend the meeting, and stated that he was grateful and supportive of the recommendations.
Councillor A I Hardman – personal and prejudicial interest in agenda item 38 – Bredon and associated maps.
It was proposed by Councillor M C J Barratt, seconded by Councillor A I Hardman, and Resolved That the Minutes of the meeting of the Committee held on 19 January 2011 be approved as a correct record of the proceedings and signed by the Chairman.
(b) Worcestershire Shared Services Joint Committee (Regulatory Services) Councillor P Middlebrough proposed and Councillor A I Hardman seconded and it was Resolved That Councillors K J Jennings and [name removed] be appointed to the Worcestershire Shared Services Joint Committee (Regulatory Services).
The Planning Officer updated the Committee and advised of positive comments made by Councillor A I Hardman.
It was proposed by Councillor M C J Barratt, seconded by Councillor A I Hardman, and Recommended to Council on 22 February 2011 That the proposed increase in fees relating to vehicle and operator licenses as detailed in Appendix 1 to these minutes be approved and adopted.
The Chairman congratulated Councillor A Hardman who had recently been appointed as Leader of Worcestershire County Council.
In Councillor Mrs Eyre’s absence, Councillor Hardman proposed the motion and commented that it was good that Councillors set an example in recognition of the considerable amount of savings that were required to be made in the forthcoming years. He added that by using the HMRC rates it would also simplify the administration of tax matters.
Councillor P Middlebrough proposed, Councillor A I Hardman seconded and it was Resolved That the following be elected as Chairmen and Vice-Chairmen of Committees for 2010/11:
Gypsy and Travellers Issues Scrutiny Team Councillor A I Hardman, Team Leader and Kath Smith, Housing Services Manager introduced the review of the 2007 Gypsy and Travellers Issues Scrutiny Team’s recommendations.
Councillor A I Hardman praised Kath Smith, stating that she had given clarity and purpose to the work done.
Councillor A I Hardman informed the Committee that since the review had taken place Officer interaction with the Travelling community had improved and that Police enforcement was now more effective and proportionate. It was also noted that the number of Gypsies and Travellers now coming forward for pre-application advice had been one of the most successful outcomes of the report.
Councillor A I Hardman – non-prejudicial interest in agenda item 9 – Worcestershire Enhanced Two Tier Working as Worcestershire County Council Cabinet Member.
It was proposed by Councillor A L Dyke , seconded by Councillor A I Hardman and Resolved That, in accordance with the provisions of Section 100A (4) of the Local Government Act 1972, the public and the press be excluded from the meeting during the consideration of confidential information given in relation to consideration of the following applications on the grounds that they involve the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in paragraph 2 of Part 1 of Schedule 12A to the Act and the public interest in withholding the information outweighs the public interest in disclosing the information to the public.
It was proposed by Councillor P Middlebrough, seconded by Councillor Mrs J C Dowty and Resolved That Councillor A I Hardman be appointed to the Board of the Cotswold Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty to serve until the elections in May 2011.
Former Councillor Brian Lewis – Councillor A Hardman spoke about former Councillor B Lewis. He was well-known in Bredon and was dedicated to the community he served.
Councillor Hardman referred to his career prior to becoming a councillor and the polite way in which he conducted business.
It was proposed by Councillor R Banks, seconded by Councillor A Hardman and Resolved That in accordance with the provisions of the Local Authorities (Access to Information) Regulations and associated Amendment Regulations 2002, and Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, the public and press be excluded form the meeting for the following item of business on the grounds that it involves the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in paragraph 3 of Part 1 of Schedule 12A to the Act and the public interest in withholding the information outweighs the public interest in disclosing the information to the public.
Cllr A M G Darby, Cllr A Hardman, Cllr P J Haycock and Cllr R Morris.
Councillor A I Hardman, having not been present at the start of meeting, now disclosed a prejudicial interest in this item as a member of Worcestershire County Council and left the room during the discussion and voting thereon.
Councillor P Middlebrough proposed, Councillor A I Hardman seconded and it was Resolved That Councillors [name removed], [name removed] and [name removed] be appointed to the Joint Advisory Planning Committee for South Worcestershire - Core Strategy.
It was proposed by Councillor P Middlebrough, seconded by Councillor A I Hardman and Resolved That Councillors A L Dyke, [name removed] and R A Jakeman be appointed to the Evesham Market Towns Partnership and that Councillor Dyke take the leadership role.
The Committee discussed the written update provided by Councillor A I Hardman. The Committee noted that progress would be monitored and it would continue to receive additional updates on progress.
The Board considered the report of the Gypsy and Traveller Issues Scrutiny Team, as presented by Councillor A I Hardman, Team Leader, advising the Board of the Team’s final recommendations, in particular, those which would have a direct impact on Wychavon District Council.
Following on from PC Adams presentation, updates were received from Councillor R G Seabourne on the PACT meetings held at Westlands , Droitwich, Councillors D W Folkes and D S Noyes on the PACT meetings held in Broadway and Councillor A I Hardman on the PACT meetings held in Bredon .
It was further proposed by Councillor A I Hardman and seconded by Councillor Mrs E B Tucker (2) That, subject to Executive Board agreeing recommendations 1 to 5 in the report, any decision by Council be deferred until ... view the full minutes text for item 65.
Councillor A Hardman, Team Leader and [name removed] , Head of Strategy and Communications presented the Team’s report. The presentation included powerpoint slides and outlined the work undertaken and the Team’s recommendations, not only to Wychavon, but to Parish and Town Councils, Worcestershire County Council, the Police, the Government and also to the Gypsies and Travellers themselves.
Councillor Hardman advised Members that the main aims of the review were to encourage better relationships with Gypsies and Travellers who make up the largest ethnic group in Wychavon and to get a better understanding of their culture, as reflected in the Council’s priorities and promises. The Team had also looked at how to achieve a fair but firm approach to recognise the rights of both Gypsies and Travellers and settled residents.
Councillor Seabourne also advised the Committee that discussions had taken place on the potential scrutiny of capital projects as it was felt that it may be better for a separate task and finish group to be established to scrutinise projects rather than Performance and Monitoring Team. b) Provision for Gypsy and Travellers in Wychavon Councillor A I Hardman, Team Leader advised the Committee that the draft recommendations had been formulated and circulated to the team prior to it’s final meeting. Members were advised that the final report would be presented to the Committee on the 17 th October 2006.
(b) Gypsies and Travellers – Councillor A I Hardman, Team Leader, reported that the Team had hosted a very successful consultation event for Parish Councils.
Gypsy and Travellers Councillor Adams passed on his thanks to Councillor Hardman, Team Leader and the rest of the team. He also thanked the other Members for keeping their distance and allowing overview and scrutiny to “get on with it”. He advised that an awareness session had been held Members in December 2005 which had been well attended and that, more recently, a session had been held for Parish Councillors and Clerks.
(a) Gypsy and Traveller Issues – Councillor A I Hardman reported that the Team had held 2 meetings since his last report. These had included discussions with representatives of the Police and Rooftop Housing Association. The Team was also considering the impact of the new Gypsy and Planning Circular.
The Leader of the Gypsies and Travellers Scrutiny Team, Councillor A Hardman, introduced the update report. The Team had held monthly meetings and was aiming to focus its efforts as the topic was so large.
During discussion of the item, Councillor Hardman confirmed that the Team would be making efforts to communicate directly with gypsies and travellers, in spite of advice received that this would not be of interest to the communities involved. Links were being set up with the West Mercia ’s Gypsy and Traveller Liaison Group, for example.
Gypsies and Travellers Councillor A I Hardman, Team Leader, confirmed that the Team had already met on two occasions and the next meeting was scheduled for 27 th February 2006. A Work Plan had been drawn up and he would keep the Committee advised of progress. The Committee noted that practices in similar, as well as neighbouring authorities would be looked at, Fenland District Council being one.
Councillor A Hardman and Councillor J Wrenn suggested it might be a wasted opportunity not to submit questions to Severn Trent. The Chairman reminded members that if they had any questions for Severn Trent Water to submit them in written format to himself or Lin Powell as soon as possible.
It was proposed by Councillor M C J Barratt , seconded by Councillor A I Hardman, and Resolved (1) That the Minutes of the meeting of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee held on 20 th September 2005 be approved as a correct record of the proceedings and signed by the Chairman;
It was proposed by Councillor R G Seabourne seconded by Councillor A I Hardman and Resolved That the Minutes of the Meeting of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee held on 19 July 2005 be approved as a correct record of the proceedings and signed by the Chairman.
(a) Affordable Housing Councillor A Hardman, Team Leader, and Councillor R G Seabourne reported on Team’s recent review of the Affordable Housing Strategy:
It was proposed by Councillor A I Hardman, seconded by Councillor Mrs J C Dowty , and Resolved That the Minutes of the Meeting of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee held on 19 th April 2005 be approved as a correct record of the proceedings and signed by the Chairman.
Councillor Hardman advised that the South Worcestershire Primary Care Trust was currently the ‘lead player’ in these negotiations.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Hardman attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15 Jul 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Jul 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Licensing Committee | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jun 2026 | Council | IRP Recommendations | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jun 2026 | Council | SPDs | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jun 2026 | Council | Wychavon Town Supplementary Planning Document approval to adopt | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Apr 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Apr 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Council | South Worcestershire Development Plan Review approval to adopt | Carried | 29 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Notices of Motion from Members of the Council | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Pay Policy Statement 2026/27 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Oct 2025 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 5 Jul 2005 | Council | Telephony | Carried | 17 for, 13 against | |
| 5 Jul 2005 | Council | Telephony | Carried | 17 for, 13 against |
Meetings Councillor Hardman was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 16 of 24 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Hardman declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Hardman in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Hardman sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Member | Jul 2005 | 10 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Member | Nov 2004 | 9 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Member | Sep 2025 | 8 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Rural Matters Advisory Panel | Member | Sep 2025 | 6 | |
| Audit Committee | Chairman | Sep 2025 | 6 | 20 Nov 2026 |
| Annual Council | Member | May 2026 | 1 | |
| Member Conduct Committee | Vice-Chairman | Jun 2026 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.