Council Debate
Councillor C Tucker introduced the Council Debate and began by suggesting that reducing the consumption of energy should always be at the forefront of the Council’s work to provide assistance to residents.
Every time Wychavon's minutes name Councillor Tucker, as the council published it.
Councillor C Tucker introduced the Council Debate and began by suggesting that reducing the consumption of energy should always be at the forefront of the Council’s work to provide assistance to residents.
Councillor C Tucker noted that it will be a significant upgrade, although it is a lot of money, and asked how it will be marketed.
Councillor C Tucker raised a query about local Parish Councils not being liaised with on this matter as they have been previously and Councillor Kearsey explained that the procedure is that Parish Councils views will not be sought until Wychavon Town Council has been created and taken over the process.
Councillor C Tucker noted that he has been an advocate of a plan for this land for over a year and expressed his hope that the Board see the potential for both residents and nature.
Councillor C Tucker stated that he had been wanting this to be progressed for a long time, and highlighted the location of the land and what surrounds it.
Councillor C Tucker expressed his view that Pershore Leisure Centre was not being made as environmentally sustainable and he would welcome the creation of a future scheme to carry this out.
Councillor C Tucker expressed disappointment that more was not being done at Pershore, but acknowledged the need for action at Evesham which has higher carbon emissions.
1) Councillor C Tucker 2) Councillor J Chaudry
Councillor C Tucker asked that a legal viewpoint on charging for drainage be provided as the law was changed in 2012 to make any foul sewer a public sewer, thus maintenance charges should not be put on these.
Councillor Charles Tucker queried the status of budget proposals, as mentioned in the mintues of the previous meeting. It was confirmed that £100,000 has been made available to support environmental schems as per the allocation in the Budget Report.
Councillor C Tucker asked for further clarification in relation to Pershore Leisure Centre outside of the meeting.
It was also proposed to include an action to support and encourage the development of community energy projects.” Under Low Carbon transport – add “liaise and work with bus operators, Worcestershire County Council and community transport groups to improve public transport service provision.” Councillor C Tucker stated that there was a huge disparity between actions on energy and actions on biodiversity which were not being reported on or not challenging enough and he asked why there was nothing in the plan about achieving 30% of nature recovery by 2030 which was a national target.
Lastly, we’ve welcomed new committee members while bidding farewell to some seasoned veterans embarking on new challenges and it would be remiss of me not to thank Councillor Charles Tucker, who has given 15 years of service to the Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
The Local Members, Councillor C Tucker, D Boatright-Greene and J Arnold addressed the Members. Concern was raised by Councillor C G J Tucker for the Hunter’s Rise and Conninsgby Drive communities and the traffic misery for the residents of Holloway. He considered the access unsuitable on the steepest part of the hill and thought that the traffic mitigations would not sufficiently address the traffic problems.
From the Overview and Scrutiny Committee · Councillor John Clatworthy · Councillor Charles Tucker · Councillor Julie Tucker · Councillor Emma Sims From outside Overview and Scrutiny Committee · Councillor Mary Tasker · Councillor Mark Ward Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee Members of the Committee were asked to note the published Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee (HOSC) update, which had been provided by Councillor Antony Hartley, Wychavon’s representative with the HOSC.
Councillor Charles Tucker requested that as the original funding had been earmarked for Pershore, that the funding remain available for Pershore projects.
As the Chair of the Planning Enforcement Scrutiny Panel (PESP), Councillor Charles Tucker then provided a brief summary of the update that had been shared with Committee members prior to the meeting.
The Local Member, Councillor C Tucker expressed concerns shared by his colleagues. These were the access route, housing mix and type of housing, and density.
The Committee noted the error in Minute 32 from the meeting held on 29 November 2023, which had detailed Councillor Julie Tucker as being the Chair of the Planning Enforcement Scrutiny Panel, when in fact it should have read Councillor Charles Tucker.
The Ward Member, Councillor C Tucker gave some background to the proposed site. He was concerned that there would be a significant increase in traffic along a narrow road to the site and that there would be a greater impact on the existing village and the visibility of the site from further afield. He was against building on grade 1 agricultural ground.
Responding to a question from Councillor C Tucker relating to King George’s Playing Field and access routes at this location, Ian Edwards, Director of Economy and Environment, confirmed that he would make arrangements to inspect the location.
From the Overview and Scrutiny Committee · Councillor Charlie Homer · Councillor Charles Tucker · Councillor Julie Tucker · Councillor Gregory Wilkins From outside Overview and Scrutiny Committee · Councillor Nicola Morris · Councillor Mary Tasker
From Overview and Scrutiny Committee · Councillor Charlie Homer · Councillor Charles Tucker · Councillor Julie Tucker From Planning Committee · Councillor Andrew Dyke · Councillor Nicolas Wright
I am grateful to Councillor Charles Tucker for the following information:- Malcolm started his working life at Evesham High School. He left teaching to set up his woodturning business behind the Jennie Hill Gallery in Pershore before expanding into commercial woodturning at Craycombe Farm.
Councillor C Tucker informed the Council that he had called for this debate to explore the report from the Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF) entitled ‘Not heating, eating or meeting bills: managing a cost of living crisis on a low income’, and what it meant for the Council and Wychavon’s residents.
In summing up, Councillor C Tucker stated that there was a need for the Council to be more inventive in its approach to helping those families most in need and that more ways ... view the full minutes text for item 34.
Responding to concerns raised by Councillor C Tucker that there were no Pershore based parks or open space projects included in the report, Councillor King provided assurances that future park improvements for Pershore, such as water play provision, were on the Council’s workplan.
Councillor Charles Tucker praised the Abbey Park barrier and wildflower planting in Pershore, but asked what could be done to prevent traveller incursion onto the park.
Councillor Charles Tucker asked Karen where the cycle shelter in Pershore would be. She explained that this would be in Pershore in the main car park by the market.
Councillor Charles Tucker also asked Karen about the Brompton Bike scheme. Karen advised that this was with the legal team at the moment making sure all parties were in agreement and explained what the scheme was to those that had not heard of it. There would be a locker at the Droitwich and Pershore train stations where there would be eight foldable bicycles available to hire.
Councillor Charles Tucker asked when they were going to see the town centre prospectuses and also if it would be possible to have a copy of John Till’s presentation.
Councillor Charles Tucker made a suggestion for links to the Vale and Spa website to be put on the Wychavon District Council website. He felt it would attract residents as well as visitors. It was agreed this was a good idea.
Councillor Charles Tucker asked how the new Active Travel Officer would be able to help drive the priorities forward for Pershore . He talked about the route from Pershore Railway Station in to the Town Centre. The Keytech bridge.
Councillor Charles Tucker thought gift vouchers could work very well.
Following further comments from members, Councillor C Tucker summed up advising that he was disappointed in the comments received as a lot of what was in the Motion was what was happening at the moment.
Pershore – Cllr C Tucker talked about a link from Wyre road to the new car park on the northern side of the railway line.
Cllr C Tucker agreed that Pavement Licences are a good idea.
Cllr G Duffy agreed with Cllr C Tucker and felt that the annual renewable fee should be easy to do, checks would still need to be done but likely to be fewer and less work therefore the cost should be altered accordingly. He also highlighted that Droitwich streets did not have the width for on street trading.
Cllr C Tucker advised that the Pershore Christmas Tree Light Switch-on would not be happening.
He also added that a number of years ago Pershore members, including himself and Councillor C Tucker, met businesses on the Keytec Business Park, as part of the Meet your Council programme. He explained that a number of the new businesses had produced work travel plans and had provided cycle facilities to encourage staff to use alternatives to car travel. Unfortunately routes to their site, particularly Wyre Road, were not safe to staff using alternative active travel options.
Cllr C Tucker had said with so much uncertainty ahead are we in a position get clarification from anyone else as to what is required going forward.
Cllr C Tucker said he is cautious about spending a substantial amount of money on consultants when it is so uncertain and asked if anything reasonable would be gained from it. He felt it would be better to spend on what is known already and where a benefit could be seen.
Cllr C Tucker asked if a schedule of who has been given licences and those who have applied could be provided.
Cllr C Tucker stressed the importance of the need for better security. He also talked about encouraging the use of electric bicycles and providing electrical points for charging.
Droitwich - Cllr G Duffy and Cllr A Sinton Evesham - Cllr P Griffiths and R Walker Pershore - Cllr M Ward, Cllr C Tucker and M Amies Cllr M King said he would feedback to Worcestershire County Council.
Cllr C Tucker expressed his thanks and gratitude to Chris and Steve for the work they did in Pershore, particularly towards the Pershore market traders who have been able to benefit from the discretionary grant.
Cllr C J Tucker said we should be ready to capitalise this year. S Knight said adequate resources will be in place
It was agreed that Cllr C J Tucker, Cllr A Dyke and Cllr G Duffy would go on the group.
It was agreed that Cllr A Sinton, Cllr G Duffy and Cllr C J Tucker would go on the panel.
Councillor C Tucker then came back with an supplementary question asking whether the Council saw there being any role outside of the main Planning Committee for the scrutiny of planning enforcement.
Councillor Charles Tucker, Ward Member, questioned [name removed] about the proposed location of the ventilation flue, which was referenced in the application papers.
Councillor Stephen Bateman Councillor Elizabeth Eyre Councillor Peter Griffiths Councillor Alex Sinton Councillor Charles Tucker
Councillor Charles Tucker commented that the Council had been unwise to agree the decision not to increase Council Tax.
Councillor Charles Tucker raised a question about purdah.
Jem Teal reminded the Panel about the Council motion raised by Councillor C Tucker and he also let the Panel know that a draft promise is being considered to deliver a three year programme of funding, mentoring and advice to strengthen and improve a range of community-led rural transport options costing £50,000 per year for three years.
Councillor C Tucker said the decline in buses would have a major impact on rural areas and suggested a vision targeting the following three areas:
Councillor C Tucker stated that a four month contract looks hugely ambitious; [name removed] responded that the timescale was taken from similar projects but if the tenders say a different time this would be taken on board Phil Merrick said he was keen that the proposal will influence the South Worcestershire Development Plan review. The Panel agreed to support the report with an amendment to 2.1 The contract shall be for “around” 4 months.
Councillor C Tucker agreed it’s what Councillors should be doing but said he found the visits to the businesses that his ward did very successful.
In response to a query from Councillor C Tucker, the Committee discussed the fixed-term nature of externally funded positions.
In response to a query from Councillor C Tucker, Gary Williams, Joint Head of Housing and Planning Services, acknowledged the downward trend in the time taken to process householder applications and noted that performance was very sensitive to staff turnover. Gary noted that Q4 performance was, however, improved, and that the downward trend should not continue further.
The Committee discussed the recommendations; in response to a query from Councillor C Tucker it was noted that the use of OPCC funding was conditional on using the technical specification that would be laid out. It was agreed that a further visit should be made to the monitoring room, once investment in hardware had been carried out, so that the impact of upgrades could be seen.
The Committee discussed the information provided with the Council Tax bill, and Councillor C Tucker commented on his concern that the freeze could result in a loss of resilience over the longer term and noted that he felt Wychavon could have been more innovative and adventurous for the benefit of its residents.
Councillor C Tucker suggested that aspects of the Council’s new promises could be informed through the survey, and social and/or affordable housing.
Councillor C Tucker left the meeting.
Following a query from Councillor C Tucker regarding an item that was to be circulated, the minutes of the previous meeting, held on Wednesday 21 June 2017 were approved.
She agreed with Councillor C Tucker that it was not for Councillors to complain about other people but to work out how Members could provide constructive input. Whilst she acknowledged that there was a representative from the County Council’s committee on the STP, but that did not help the feedback and understanding for ordinary Members which was very hard to achieve.
Councillor C G Tucker asked a question relating to affordable housing which, whilst there were more affordable houses being delivered, this was no where near the 30% target set. He added that he felt that a % target was better than the number of houses provided.
The Local Member, Councillor C G Tucker, did not support the application. He had concerns regarding the protection of the wildlife corridor and its maintenance and the arrangements for parking. He was fully in agreement with the proposal for bungalows and not 4 bedroom houses and that they should be in keeping with the rest of Conningsby Drive.
In response to a query from Councillor C Tucker, Ian informed the Committee that Ringway had known flood spots built into their cyclical maintenance system, and noted that this resulted in more frequent clearing work and street cleaning in these areas. Ian commented that this was an area of continuous improvement, particularly with new-generation data now becoming available from the Environment Agency.
In response to a query from Councillor C Tucker, Councillor Mrs Duffy noted that any scrutiny exercise that could look into the existing processes and controls used by partners such as Civica with a view to potential improvements would be welcomed.
In response to a question from Councillor C Tucker, Councillor Mrs Robinson explained that it was important to put a solid plan in place to try and deal with the social mobility issues previously discussed, and noted that officers were involved in ongoing discussions, both internally and with partners, to facilitate this.
In response to a query from Councillor C Tucker, heather drew members’ attention to the trigger points shown on the report, which indicate the key stages at which agreements had specified when funds should be paid. Heather noted that while developers were meant to serve notice to Wychavon of this, in practice they often do not. Heather informed members that Wychavon periodically contacted all developers, and particularly those that were known to have begun development, or otherwise have discharged their conditions.
In response to a query from Councillor C Tucker, Fiona informed members that the full annual report from the Director of Public Health could be circulated to provide more context and additional information on life expectancy trends.
Councillor C Tucker joined the meeting The Chairman thanked Jim for his presentation and asked that Members please visit Jim at Wychavon if they had any further questions or wished to find out more.
In response to queries from Councillor C Tucker and the Chairman, David explained that the figures detailed all complaints received, and that only a handful of complaints per year were escalated due to most situations being resolved before expensive legal action was required to be anything more than a threat. David also explained that his staff were rotated as demand requires, but that they would commonly spend approximately two months working within the district of Wychavon.
In response to a query from Councillor C Tucker, Councillor Mrs Stokes confirmed that the new contractor would be responsible for providing collection vehicles.
Empty shops – Councillor C J Tucker to produce a note for the next meeting.
Councillor C Tucker suggested that the provision of surgeries and GP coverage, in light of proposed new housing developments, was an important scrutiny area – asking how the NHS will be planning for the provision of new facilities.
In response to a query from Councillor C Tucker, Fiona Narburgh, Joint Head of Strategy, Democratic & Customer Services, noted that the numbers of people completing the surveys meant that there was not a downward trend in people’s perceptions of their own health, however their concerns should be noted and Wychavon had plenty of roles to play. She noted that it was difficult to explain the results without further clarification from the public; the Chairman commented that it was perhaps due to an ageing population.
The Local Member, Councillor C G Tucker, felt this was a difficult application to judge. If approved a pub would be lost and if refused the owner would have problems in doing it up. He felt it was an asset of community value.
Councillor C Tucker expressed his fears with regard to retail outlets moving on to the Pershore business parks. Chris said whilst he believes there are sites that could be under this sort of threat, he didn’t see this as an issue in Pershore and particularly not on the new Keytech expansion site. (Please see footnote below that Chris has added since the meeting) The issue of a Wychavon Guide to business parks was discussed.
Local member Councillor C Tucker supported the application.
The Local Member, Councillor C G Tucker, had drainage concerns with this application. He felt the drainage pond was on the lowest part of the site and was concerned that the area was within the area subject to surface water flooding in extreme conditions. He thought there should be further investigations into that to ensure floor levels are above that.
Councillor C Tucker sought further information about the proposed saving from letting out of the surplus space at the Civic Centre and whether this was linked to the local Police Station.
In introducing the debate Councillor C G Tucker referred to the need to make substantial savings and suggested that the proposal could achieve this without affecting services to residents. Wychavon and Malvern Hills had similar rural perspectives and a basic similarity in Council structure.
It has no bearing whatsoever on the proposed scrutiny review suggested by Councillor Charles Tucker and myself.
Councillor C Tucker proposed, seconded by Councillor Mrs A M Rowley, that a small Member led Scrutiny Team ... view the full minutes text for item 92.
Councillor C Tucker raised concerns over how the issues raised in the report regarding public access to officers would be taken up and used to inform the on going WETT initiative . The Managing Director confirmed that the lessons learnt in the report had already been taken on board and included in the business case for Regulatory Services .
Councillor Charles Tucker informed the Committee that the Draft Flood and Water Bill was likely to be published in early 2010 and that it was previously agreed that it would be considered by the Committee.
The following questions had been received in accordance with the Council’s Constitution:- Question from [name removed] “With my thanks to Councillor Charles Tucker, I received my copy of the Abbey Park Management Plan 2007-2012 on Saturday morning. However, having studied its contents and several of the books on Pershore , I see that I am correct with regards to the Monastic fishing pond which I have marked below roughly:- Monastic Fishing Pond Pool on the Orchards The proposed wetland/pond Local historians vouch that top soil was taken from areas of the park when the Bowling Club was built which greatly altered original ground levels.
The following Notice of Motion had been received:- Proposed by Councillor Mrs A M Rowley, seconded by Councillor C G Tucker:- “This Council believes that individuals and businesses in Wychavon would benefit from revisions to taxation that would reduce the burden on income while increasing taxation on pollution and the use of finite environmental resources.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Tucker attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15 Jul 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Jul 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Licensing Committee | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jun 2026 | Council | IRP Recommendations | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jun 2026 | Council | SPDs | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jun 2026 | Council | Wychavon Town Supplementary Planning Document approval to adopt | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Apr 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Apr 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Council | South Worcestershire Development Plan Review approval to adopt | Carried | 29 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Notices of Motion from Members of the Council | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Pay Policy Statement 2026/27 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Nov 2025 | Executive Board | Budget 2026/27 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Nov 2025 | Executive Board | Mid Year Treasury Management Review | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Oct 2025 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 5 Jul 2005 | Council | Telephony | Carried | 17 for, 13 against | |
| 5 Jul 2005 | Council | Telephony | Carried | 17 for, 13 against |
Meetings Councillor Tucker was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 13 of 21 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Tucker declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Tucker in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Tucker sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Member | Jul 2005 | 10 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Member | Sep 2025 | 8 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Town Centres Advisory Panel | Member | Nov 2025 | 6 | |
| Climate and Nature Panel (Formerly Carbon Reduction Panel) | Guest | Oct 2025 | 4 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Executive Board | Member | Nov 2025 | 1 | 6 Jan 2027 |
| Annual Council | Member | May 2026 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.