Overview & Scrutiny Committee Annual Report
Chairman of the Overview & Scrutiny Committee, Councillor C Homer, introduced the report and explained that the content covers the work of the Committee between May 2025 and April 2026.
Every time Wychavon's minutes name Councillor Homer, as the council published it.
Chairman of the Overview & Scrutiny Committee, Councillor C Homer, introduced the report and explained that the content covers the work of the Committee between May 2025 and April 2026.
Councillor Homer thanked the Vice-Chairman of the Committee, the Member Champions, all Members of the Committee and Spencer Winnett for ensuring administrative tasks are completed.
Councillor R Morris began by thanking Councillor Homer and the whole Overview and Scrutiny team for producing the annual report and noted the importance of scrutiny to Wychavon District Council.
Councillor C Homer gave the following update from Overview and Scrutiny Committee:
Councillor C Homer queried the impact that the Council could have on this issue, and noted the previous debates held by Council on the Cost of Living crisis and affordability and homes and ... view the full minutes text for item 57.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer, welcomed Martyn Cross (Head of Engineering and Parking Services) and Andrew Fell (Assistant Manager SWLDP) to the meeting and thanked them for attending.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer, introduced the item and it was noted that a number of questions had been submitted in advance of the meeting, with responses being gained and shared with all members of the Committee.
Budget Scrutiny Review Group Councillor Homer introduced the item, and it was agreed by the Committee that the following councillors would be members of the Budget Scrutiny Review Group for the 2027/28 Financial Year.
The Local Member, Councillor C Homer spoke in support of the application and was excited that the application represented the beginning of a scheme that everyone in the town wanted to see; a scheme that would be sympathetic to existing assets and that would bring forward hospitality, leisure and homes into the heart of the town. He commended the work of the Officers, who had responded well to comments made since the successful consultation meetings.
Councillor C Homer provided the following update from the Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer, introduced the item and confirmed that he had submitted a number of questions prior to the meeting and that the majority of them had received responses that had subsequently been shared with Committee members.
The Chair, Councillor Charlie Homer, welcomed Mark McEgan (Executive Director for Operations) from Rooftop Housing Group, and thanked him for attending the meeting.
The update concluded with the Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer, thanking Tim Lewis for attending the meeting and for the information provided.
The Committee noted that the Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer, had submitted a number of questions prior to the meeting and that detailed responses had been received. It was confirmed these would be shared with the Committee following the meeting.
Councillor Homer highlighted a number of questions and areas that required some additional clarification and detail, and it was agreed that these could be dealt with after the meeting.
Councillor Homer emphasised the importance of projects and ... view the full minutes text for item 62.
Councillor C Homer noted that the Overview and Scrutiny has met twice since the last full Council meeting, on 14 January and 18 February.
Councillor Homer confirmed that Councillor J Tucker had presented the Budget Scrutiny report to the committee and placed on record his thanks to members of that committee and the officers who support it whom give a significant amount of time to ensure this work is done diligently, evidenced by the fact that the recommendations have been approved by the Executive Board.
Councillor Homer explained that at each meeting Councillor M Ward, who sits on the Countywide Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee, provides a detailed update on local health services and recommended that all Members take the opportunity to view this report.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer, thanked Suzanne and Dave for the update.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer, introduced the item and confirmed that some late questions from the Member Champions had been submitted in advance of the meeting.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer, reiterated the request that the Overview and Scrutiny Committee be kept informed regarding how the Council’s replacement budget for the UK SPF funding was allocated.
The Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, Councillor Homer, commented that because the recommended funding outlined in recommendations 2.3 and 2.4 would be coming from the Council’s budget from 2026/27, there should be a greater level of scrutiny of the spending and accountability for outcomes.
Councillor Homer thanked Councillor Julie Tucker and all those involved for delivering such a comprehensive budget scrutiny.
It was agreed that these matters should be put to the Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer, upon his return, and that the workplan would be updated where necessary.
Councillor C D Homer, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, gave the following update:- “Since the last council meeting, the Overview and Scrutiny Committee have met once.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer, introduced the item and briefly explained that the reason for the absence of a 2024/25 Quarter 4 report being brought to the Committee was due to the high demands on officers in dealing with the Local Government Reorganisation (LGR) workload.
Referring to the LGR, Councillor Homer asked the Committee to consider what the reorganisation would mean for the Council’s priorities and promises detailed in the ‘We Are Wychavon’ report, and whether the Council’s plans should focus on those priorities and promises that could realistically be delivered in the time that remained for Wychavon.
Budget Scrutiny Review Group Councillor Homer introduced the item and reminded those present of the excellent work carried out by the previous year’s Budget Scrutiny Group.
Councillor Homer also outlined the format for the work that would be undertaken and reminded everyone that one more councillor from outside the Committee was required.
Councillor Homer stated he was grateful to the members of the Committee for getting away from the meeting and into the community, and for contributing to building a stronger relationship with two of the Council’s key stakeholders.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer, introduced the item and commented that there did not appear to be anything on the Executive Boards’s Forward Plan relating to the Local Government Reorganisation (LGR).
Councillor Homer commented that the Committee was seeking assurance that it would play a role in the Council’s ongoing LGR discussions and have the opportunity to scrutinise the technical aspects of the Council’s response.
The Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, Councillor C D Homer, explained that it had been an interesting year for the Committee and highlighted some of the work undertaken and organisations that had attended meetings.
Notwithstanding the work of the Council and the dedication of officers, Councillor Homer highlighted the work of charity, communities and volunteers across the district that do amazing work to support Wychavon e.g. litter picking etc.
I know there is a lot of publicity at the moment with Riverside and some of the maintenance and I thank officers and Councillor Homer for trying to get a solution on that.
Councillor C D Homer, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, gave the following update:
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Charlie Homer, informed the Committee that a question had been received from Laura Van Toller of Anti-Litter Evesham Volunteer Group, as follows:
“Why haven't our Parks/Open Spaces across Wychavon been made secure since last July (2024)?” Cllr Homer read out the following response, which had been provided by Tim Lewis, Head of Client Services:
Councillor Homer proposed the Annual Report for approval, it was seconded by Councillor Crump and unanimously Resolved That the Overview and Scrutiny Committee Annual Report for 2024/25 be approved, and that it be sent to Council for noting at its meeting on 23 July 2025.
He then proposed the recommendations which were seconded by Councillor C D Homer and with 37 votes for and 1 against, it was Resolved That the following be approved:- 1. A basic allowance for 2025/26 of £5,826, representing a 5.58% increase.
The Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, Councillor C D Homer, gave the following update:- “ Since the last council meeting , the Overview and Scrutiny Committee has met once on the 9th of April. At this meeting, the agenda focused predominantly on Rooftop Housing. I am grateful to the committee for the extensive preparation they did ahead of the meeting and for ensuring we had a robust conversation about Rooftops' performance, especially considering they are the largest social housing provider in Wychavon.
The Chair, Councillor Charlie Homer, welcomed Mark McEgan (Executive Director for Operations) from Rooftop Housing Group, and thanked him for attending the meeting.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer, confirmed he had received an update from Tim Lewis, Head of Client Services, as a follow-up to the littering and fly-tipping agenda item form the meeting held on 4 December 2024.
The Chair, Councillor Charlie Homer, welcomed Stephen Potter (Stakeholder Engagement Manager) and Gareth Mead (River Rangers Manager) from Severn Trent and thanked them for attending the meeting.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer, introduced the item and invited the Member Champions to put forward any questions they had.
The Chair, Councillor Homer, introduced the item by reminding the Committee that the update to the We Are Wychavon Plan related to bringing at least 30 long-term properties back into use by 31 March 2028.
Councillor Homer asked if, having had a number of recent successes in this area during the last quarter, the Council could be more ambitious with its target.
The Chair, Councillor Homer, introduced the item and there was a brief discussion regarding the Executive Board’s financial amendments to three of recommendations within the Budget Scrutiny Review Group’s report, which had been to the Committee’s previous meeting.
The Chair, Councillor Charlie Homer, welcomed Lisa Fairlie (Director of Housing Operations), Steve Eaves (Director of Regeneration), Marc Mayall (Director of Operations for Property Care), and Clare Greensall (Head of Localities) from Platform Housing Group (PHG), and thanked them for attending the meeting.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer, praised the active a collaborative cross-party way in which the budget scrutiny had been carried out.
This was seconded by the Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer and it was Resolved That the report, and the recommendations detailed below, be accepted and approved by the Committee, and included in the agenda of the next Executive Board meeting for consideration:
The Chair, Councillor Homer, advised the Committee that a change to the workplan meant that an update regarding the Council’s Revenues and Benefits service would come to a future meeting. In addition, the Committee was reminded that Severn Trent would be attending the meeting on 19 February 2025.
Councillor C D Homer, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, gave the following update:- “Since the last Council the Overview and Scrutiny Committee have met once. At that meeting we had a lengthy and detailed discussion on litter and it’s blight in our district. Concerns were also raised regarding FCC street cleansing activities and the Committee was assured officers had taken on board our comments and would meet with FCC to relay them.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Charlie Homer, welcomed Tim Lewis, Head of Client Services, to the meeting for the discussion on littering and fly-tipping in Wychavon.
Councillor C D Homer, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, commended the report to the Council and thanked the members and officers who attended regularly and presented to the Committee. He highlighted a recent presentation from Avon Vale River Action Group detailing the work they were doing on tracking the water quality and conditions of the River Avon and how the Committee had assisted in securing further funding for them to purchase further test kits to enable them to continue the good work.
Councillor C D Homer, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, gave the following update:- “There have been two meetings since the last council meeting.
Question from Councillor C D Homer “The Riverside Shopping Centre in Evesham has become a serious problem. The landlords have shown blatant disregard for the property, allowing it to fall into disrepair. The centre is visibly unsafe, dirty and neglected both inside and out.
The Chair, Councillor Charlie Homer, welcomed Rob Dufty, Nigel Grundy, Sharon Keen and Kay McBride from Wychavon Leisure (Rivers Fitness), and thanked them for attending the meeting at short notice.
Councillor Homer, the Chair of the Committee, thanked the representatives from Wychavon Leisure and praised the facilities and the important role they played for the community.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Charlie Homer, informed the Committee that a number of questions had been received on the subject of littering from [name removed] of Evesham.
[name removed] was not present at the meeting and so Councillor Homer confirmed that the responses to the questions would be sent to [name removed] after the meeting, and also shared with Committee members.
Councillor Homer added that the subject of littering would be an agenda item at the meeting to be held on Wednesday 2 October 2024.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer, confirmed that the background information relating to the South Worcestershire Community Safety Partnership was for noting only, and that a full update would be provided at the February 2025 meeting.
Councillor C D Homer, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, advised that there hadn’t been another meeting of the Committee since the last Council as unfortunately the meeting due to be held on 3 July 2024 was cancelled.
Councillor Homer explained that there had been a piece of work undertaken since the last Overview and Scrutiny Committee and Council meetings which was to review the Signals of Success report and to try and make it more approachable and fit for purpose going forward. He added that he hoped the first report for 2024/25 would put some of that into context.
Councillor C D Homer, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, felt that the report was a light touch compared to the amount of money that was involved and suggested that the report goes to Overview and Scrutiny for further investigation.
The Chairman advised that the Chairs and Vice-Chairs appointed to the following Committees would remain the same as for 2023/24, as follows:- Audit Committee · Councillor A I Hardman - Chair · Councillor N Dawkes – Vice-Chair Licensing Committee · Councillor M S Goodge – Chair · Councillor E J Bowden – Vice-Chair Member Conduct Committee · Councillor A Hartley – Chair · Councillor P Middlebrough – Vice-Chair Overview and Scrutiny Committee · Councillor C D Homer · Councillor B Hurdman Planning Committee · Councillor N Wright – Chair · Councillor A L Dyke – Vice-Chair
In the absence of the Councillor C Homer, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, Councillor B Hurdman, Vice-Chairman, gave the following update:
Councillor C D Homer, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, gave the following update:- “Since the last Council meeting the Overview and Scrutiny Committee has met twice. At our previous meeting on 10 January we received updates and reports from Worcestershire Regulatory Services and the final report and recommendations from the Budget Scrutiny Group. On the latter, it was agreed to review the budget scrutiny process as it was neither officers nor councillors benefitted from its current format.
Councillor C D Homer, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, gave the following update:
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Charlie Homer, welcomed Louise Bugg from the Avonvale River Action Group and introductions were made.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Homer, nominated Councillor Angie Crump to be the new Signals of Success Member Champion for the ‘Supporting People’ element of the report.
Councillor C D Homer then seconded the proposal and with no further nominations, the vote was taken which was clearly carried.
Councillor C D Homer, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, gave the following update:- “The Overview and Scrutiny Committee have met twice since the last Council meeting.
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Charlie Homer, then confirmed that a number of questions had been submitted by members of the Committee in advance of the meeting and that the responses to those questions had been shared.
From the Overview and Scrutiny Committee · Councillor Charlie Homer · Councillor Charles Tucker · Councillor Julie Tucker · Councillor Gregory Wilkins From outside Overview and Scrutiny Committee · Councillor Nicola Morris · Councillor Mary Tasker
The Chair of the Committee, Councillor Charlie Homer, informed the Committee that Councillor Julie Tucker would continue as the Member Champion for Sustainable Environment.
From Overview and Scrutiny Committee · Councillor Charlie Homer · Councillor Charles Tucker · Councillor Julie Tucker From Planning Committee · Councillor Andrew Dyke · Councillor Nicolas Wright
The Chairman, Councillor C Homer had given his apologies so Vice-Chairman R Raphael would be chairing the meeting. Apologies for absence were received from Councillors B Brookes, C Homer, [name removed] and Co-optees A Gilmour and N Pierce.
Making reference to recommendation 10, Councillor Homer wanted assurances that enough time and energy would be given to new councillors on planning matters.
Councillor Homer expressed his frustration that not enough was done to highlight to residents that Wychavon District Council had once again frozen its portion of Council Tax.
The Chairman, Councillor C Homer welcomed everyone to the meeting. Apologies for absence were received from Councillors [name removed].
Councillor C D Homer commented that the performance targets showed a fantastic result and thanked the officers as this was a real success story.
Many Members will know that Councillor C D Homer would be getting married on Saturday, the same day as the Royal wedding and on behalf of the Council, she wished him and his fiancée many congratulations and all the very best for the big day. Members gave them a round of applause.
In response to a query from Councillor C Homer, the Committee discussed affordable housing need and the limitations of assessment methods and figures in detail.
The Chairman noted that, as Councillor Homer had commented, there was a need to understand the numbers of younger residents living with parents or relatives while trying to buy a property, instead of registering for social housing, and stressed the importance of starter homes, key worker accommodation, and self-building alongside social housing and affordable housing.
In response to a query from Councillor C Homer, members and officers discussed confusion over the homelessness prevention measure, and what it targeted and reported. Elaine Salter, Housing Services Manager, informed members that the target was based on the previous year and on a slightly incorrect procedure, but that the team was very stringently ensuring that the categorisation of prevention work and advice was being completed properly. It was confirmed that more than half of presentations were successfully prevented from becoming homeless, with the remaining number being classed as intentionally homeless or otherwise ineligible for assistance.
The Chairman, Councillor C Homer welcomed everyone to the meeting. Apologies for absence were received from Councillors [name removed].
Councillor C Homer commented that all members could be very proud of the fact that Wychavon was freezing its Council Tax, protecting services and doing more for its residents as well.
Councillor C Homer suggested that a question around apprenticeship awareness could be formulated.
Councillor C Homer left the meeting .
The Chairman, Councillor C Homer welcomed everyone to the meeting. As Fiona Narburgh has now left Wychavon District Council, Phil Merrick will be taking over as the SMT lead. Apologies for absence were received from Councillors [name removed] and R Morris.
In response to comments from Councillor C Homer, Vic explained that Wychavon had only limited obligations under Universal Credit, and that the intention behind the related promise was to ensure that Wychavon committed to going above and beyond these for its residents. Members agreed that this was the right thing to do.
Councillor Homer further commented on the need for additional detail and specific actions surrounding the green infrastructure promise, and that he was pleased to see a littering promise; on the need for detail on the practicalities of what Wychavon planned to do regarding the delivery of affordable housing; on the potential for greater impact from additional funding for initiatives to assist businesses with accessing European funding; and on the need to ensure that the Council’s apprenticeships promise provided not just for school leavers and young people, but also for people contemplating a career change.
Councillor Homer had strong objections and did feel this would be a destination site and was saddened that Highways England had not recognised that this junction becomes congested at peak hours. It will create more congestion and there was also no condition seeking contributions for a footway and cycle way. He mentioned many young people don’t all drive and would have to cross the A46 and that we should be doing more to assist customers and employees to get there.
Councillor Charlie Homer queried the duration of the works programme and noted a seasonal site at Evesham could be improved during its ‘off’ period. Tim noted that it was a phased closure to ensure as much capacity remained available as possible, but that the order and timing could be looked at.
Councillor Charlie Homer commended both the previously-considered research proposal and the recommendations being moved.
The Chairman, Councillor C Homer welcomed everyone to the meeting especially the new co-optees and round the table introductions were made.
The Team discussed the data presented by the crime heat maps, and Councillor C Homer queried the respective costs of upgrading a camera compared to relocating one entirely.
Councillor C D Homer, Chairman of the Town Regeneration and Economy Advisory Panel, advised that the Panel had the most co- optee applications and as a result had 3 new co- optees .
Councillor Homer explained that Pershore’s report had just been completed and a stakeholders event was held on 5 September 2017. The overall report would be used as evidence for the town plan and the Town Council were fully in support. The key findings focussed on the fact that Pershore was a friendly town and had a high number of independent businesses.
Councillor Homer went on to explain that Evesham’s report had been completed but not yet publicised. Evesham had a vibrant night economy and the new Waitrose development was creating a ribbon of economic development up to the market place.
Councillor Homer highlighted the work being done by the Economic Development team to support the retailers during the High Street enhancements.
In relation to regeneration, Councillor Homer advised that one of the first things the Panel did was to do on a tour of the key sites – both retail and industrial.
Councillor Homer highlighted Brexit and the importance of supporting businesses and reminding them to apply for funding from the various European funding streams to ensure that as much of that money was spent in Wychavon before the closing date of March 2019.
Councillor Homer concluded by mentioning the Council’s new Skills Officer, [name removed], who had done some fantastic work in the first 6 months of her being with Wychavon and was well known within the business world. He added that the Panel had made 9 grants to support apprenticeships across Wychavon out of a target of 20 and he hoped that more could be made in due course. Wychavon was also the first district to set up Network Enterprise Advisors and that was currently doing very well.
Councillor C D Homer introduced the Council debate entitled:- “The recent viewpoint survey suggests that 71% of residents feel safer as a result of clearly visible CCTV cameras and 76% think that CCTV cameras help to reduce crime. Only 13% of residents surveyed felt that CCTV cameras in public places are an invasion of privacy and only 4% think there are too many CCTV cameras in Wychavon.
Given these statistics and the strong support for CCTV in Wychavon, is it a realistic option to reduce or cease the service that the Council provides?” Councillor Homer started by reminding Members that CCTV provision was currently being reviewed by a scrutiny team and added that the Town Regeneration and Economy Advisory Panel had also looked at CCTV. He explained that the latest figures (2016) showed that 846 crimes or incidents were picked up by our CCTV operators, of which 1/3 were directly picked up by our operators and 118 discs were requested by the police to aid further investigations.
Councillor Homer reminded the Council that these cameras were not just used to monitor crimes and antisocial behaviour but on 63 occasions in 2016 the cameras were used for missing people.
In respect of this, it was highlighted that the public did think that cameras were there just to stop the criminal element however national security was also very important as terrorism could strike anywhere at any time and, as Councillor Homer had already alluded to, could be used for more diverse cases such as lost children, people with mental health issues and to help with safeguarding.
In response to a comment from Councillor C Homer regarding ways by which Wychavon could act to diversify the scope of the apprenticeships promise, Phil Merrick, Joint Head of Economy and Communities, agreed that this was a valid concern and noted that Evesham College had recently become involved, and that Wychavon’s new skills officer, Sue Owen, was working closely with other local engineering companies and promoting apprenticeship opportunities.
The Chairman, Councillor Charlie Homer welcomed everyone to the meeting, apologies for absence were received from Councillor R Raphael, [name removed], D Eden and C Brooks.
Resolved That the following members host a member debate on the dates as given below:- 26 July 2017 – Councillor C G J Tucker 11 October 2017 – Councillor C D Homer 13 December 2017 – Councillor R C Adams 21 or 28 February 2018 – [name removed] 18 April 2018 – Councillor P Middlebrough 1 st reserve – Councillor Mrs E B Tucker 2 nd reserve – Councillor M T King
The Chairman, Councillor Charlie Homer welcomed everyone to the meeting, no apologies for absence were received.
The Chairman, Councillor Charlie Homer welcomed everyone to the meeting and introduced Chris Wade and Mike Ostick who would be doing a presentation later on.
In response to a series of queries from Councillor C Homer, Councillor Mrs Duffy made the following comments:
The Chairman noted that New Homes Bonus protocol could be considered in the future; Councillor C Homer agreed and noted that in light of the recent Housing White Paper, and several Neighbourhood Plans approaching public referenda, it would be useful for members to have a better understanding of where the District stood in regards to these.
The Chairman, Councillor Charlie Homer welcomed everyone to the meeting and round the table introductions were made. He thanked META for agreeing to host the meeting and to show us round the building.
In response to a question from Councillor C Homer, Councillor Mrs Robinson noted that she felt that Wychavon stood at the forefront of innovative and effective local government, and noted that while the Worcestershire Leaders’ Board’s detailed devolution bid, submitted in 2016, had been rejected, it would not come off the table.
In response to questions from Councillor C Homer, Jem explained that the Community Infrastructure Levy Regulations ... view the full minutes text for item 53.
The Chairman, Councillor Charlie Homer welcomed everyone to the meeting, particularly Councillor Mrs K Tomalin as it was her first Town Panel meeting and Ian Edwards from the LEP who would be giving a presentation later.
It was proposed by Councillor C Homer, seconded by Councillor Val Wood and agreed that Councillor Robert Raphael be elected Vice-Chairman of the Town Regeneration and Economy Advisory Panel.
Cllr Mrs E Eyre Cllr C Homer; Cllr M Goodge attended the meeting as his substitute.
Councillor Mrs E Eyre; Councillor H Hamilton; Councillor C Homer; Councillor M King; Councillor R Raphael; and That the Budget Scrutiny Team meet on the following dates in a location to be confirmed Thursday December 8th, 4pm Tuesday January 10th, 4pm Tuesday January 17th, 4pm Final Budget Report – O&S Committee, Wednesday January 25th That Terms of Reference for the Budget Scrutiny Team be drafted for adoption at the first meeting of the Budget Scrutiny Team.
The Chairman, Councillor Charlie Homer welcomed everyone to the meeting.
In summary Cllr Homer, the parish council and residents had expressed concerns about this development because of the increased traffic flow to and from the site onto the A46 roundabout. The A46 and A44 are often congested and dangerous for traffic. A drive thru by nature means a quick rotation of business, more vehicles at higher volumes and frequencies which increases the danger and congestion from this site.
Councillor R C Adams proposed and Councillor C D Homer seconded that Councillor Mrs F S Smith be elected Chairman of the Council.
The Chairman, Councillor Charlie Homer welcomed everyone to the meeting particularly the Rural Panel members who were attending for Item 4 - workshop. Round the table introductions were made.
In answer to a question raised by Councillor Homer, Jack Hegarty, Managing Director, confirmed that the Council had committed to run the scholarship programme initially for 3 years. This was to help local students to access third tier learning locally. The hope was to look at continuing this under the new New Homes Bonus scheme for all tiers of education.
Councillor Homer asked about statistics regarding the visits to the contact centres and the partner organisations there. He felt that there would always be a need for face to face contact where a resident had an issue that needed to be resolved quickly.
Councillor C D Homer, Chairman of the Panel, advised that the report set out what the Panel had done so far to show that it was acting within its remit set by the Executive Board. He added that the Panel was willing to look at anything else that the Board would like them to.
The Chairman, Councillor C Homer, welcomed everyone to the meeting. He also welcomed the new co- optee , Michael Howard, to his first meeting of the Panel. He was taking the place of Angela Fitch who had stepped down.
In answer to a question raised by Councillor Homer about the possibility of balancing the budget by issuing Fixed Penalty Notices Councillor Mrs Duffy advised that she would need to ask questions about how the mechanisms of this would work in the Council.
Councillor Homer asked to what degree Fixed Penalty Notices could be used to affect the bottom line of the budget and at what point it could be said the resource involved in dealing with issues was costing the Council money. Jack Hegarty, Managing Director advised that the Council would not invest in Fixed Penalty Notices to raise money. He was not aware of excessive issues from the community and no issues had been bought to his attention.
In response to a question raised by Councillor Homer in respect of the provision of new open spaces, Phil Merrick, Head of Economy and Community Services, confirmed that S106 monies would be used to maintain these spaces.
Councillor Homer asked for feedback on the promise that up to £5milliion would be invested in sport and leisure facilities by 2020 and Phil confirmed that he would check on this and advise members accordingly.
Councillor Homer added that the proposed guide of the industrial estate could create a means of providing a better local supply chain. This was about being smarter about what we have got and would help in increasing the ‘Wychavon pound’. The Chairman thanked Chris for his very informative presentation.
Councillor Homer reported on the survey that had been completed by 27 members and confirmed that the responses had been hugely positive. The Government were currently consulting on the future of New Homes Bonus with a closing date in March.
The Chairman, Councillor Charlie Homer welcomed everyone to the meeting.
c) New Homes Bonus review Councillor C Homer advised that 27 replies had been received to the survey sent out. The responses would be collated and he would be attending a meeting with officers to look at the data in due course.
Cherrie Mansfield shared a summary of the findings of the NHB survey for councillors that has been conducted by Councillor Charlie Homer. There were 27 responses and they showed that the majority of councillors feel well informed about NHB. Cherrie took the Panel through her paper providing an overview and analysis of our New Homes Bonus (NHB) allocations to parish and town councils.
c) New Homes Bonus Review Councillor Homer informed the Committee that a meeting had taken place where the contents of a proposed questionnaire to all members was discussed. This was being composed with a view to being issued to members early in November for feedback from members with their views on New Homes Bonus.
Prior to any discussion on this item, Councillor C D Homer disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in this item as his father was the developer. He advised that he would leave the room and take no part in the discussion thereon.
The Chairman, Councillor Charlie Homer warmly welcomed the new co- optees , Angela Fitch, Darren Eden and Amy Draper. They had been getting to know Wychavon and the work of the Panel in an earlier session.
It was proposed by Councillor C Homer, seconded by Councillor Mrs Val Wood and agreed that Councillor Mrs C Powell be elected Vice-Chairman of the Town Regeneration and Economy Advisory Panel.
He advised that he would like to establish a review team headed by Councillor C Homer.
He added that if anyone was interested in joining the team to let Councillor Homer know. It was hoped that the team would gather information from members about their views, successes, what has been achieved in their ward. Members raised their concerns about this team as it was the Localism and Community Funding Advisory Panel that dealt with New Homes Bonus monies.
The Chairman, Councillor Charlie Homer welcomed everyone to the first meeting of the Town Regeneration and Economy Advisory Panel.
Councillor C D Homer then said a few words in support of Councillor Mrs Duffy and added that she had conducted her year in her own inimitable style and was well respected by all who had met her. He added it had been a year well done.
The new panels and chairmen would be:- Localism and Communities Funding Advisory Panel Councillor Mrs A Steel Town Regeneration and Economy Advisory Panel Councillor C D Homer Rural Communities and Economy Advisory Panel Councillor Mrs E A Eyre
Councillor C Homer, introduced the Council debate entitled “ As we approach the formation of a new government in May, what should the Council’s response be to any proposals, for the devolution of powers coming from shire counties and in particular if this was to happen in Worcestershire.
What would that mean for the current way services are delivered across the tiers here in Wychavon and what benefits would their be?” Councillor Homer, highlighted the number of uncontested parish seats at the forthcoming election and questioned whether the public had a clear understanding of the tiers within local government and services each delivered.
Councillor Homer commented that the matter of waste was an important issue for the Council and that it should always set challenging aspirational goals as the issue would always be recurring. He felt the Council should put a greater emphasis on educating residents of the importance of recycling as a means of achieving a higher recycling rate.
([name removed] spoke with a reservation regarding this application.) ([name removed] spoke for approval of this application.) The Local Member Councillor C Homer supported the application but asked the Committee to consider adding additional conditions to limit work to weekdays only, also restrict the use of pile drills and also that any construction traffic use the south entrance only.
The Local Member Councillor C Homer supported development of the site but said it shouldn’t be at the safety of residents. He queried the impact it would have on safety by reducing the visibility splay from 90 to 47 and he asked the committee to consider putting a condition on to increase the visibility display back up to 90 before the first dwelling is occupied.
Councillor C Homer did not feel that the way the Council communicated was an issue, but rather the level of engagement from residents and how this could be improved.
Councillor C Homer sought clarification on the reasons why the Council undertook on-street and off-street parking enforcement, querying whether on-street or off-street was ... view the full minutes text for item 52.
Councillor C D Homer also disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in the New Homes Bonus application from Evesham Town Council (agenda item 8) as a member of the Town Council.
Councillor C D Homer now disclosed a pecuniary interest in this item as a director of the Community Interest Company that had been set up to deliver the event.
The Chairman read out comments on behalf of the Local Member Councillor C Homer who was unable to attend the meeting.
Councillor Homer supported the application but requested that additional conditions to be added in relation to restricting working hours and cleaning any mud from the road.
The Local Member Councillor Charlie Homer did not support the application and stated that such development on the site would exacerbate the flood risk problem.
Councillor C D Homer disclosed an interest in agenda item 8 – References from the Localism and Communities Advisory Panel in relation to the application by Evesham Town Council for the Evesham Abbey Bell Tower Appeal as a patron of the Bell Tower and Mayor of Evesham.
Councillor C D Homer disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in agenda item 5 – Evesham Abbey Bell Tower Appeal and agenda item 7a – Application for funding for photographic exhibition in Evesham as patron and Mayor of Evesham.
Councillor C D Homer advised that he was happy with the proposal from Norton and Lenchwick Parish Council for the request for additional funding towards the refurbishment of the playing fields in between Lenchwick and Norton.
Councillor Homer outlined a number of actions Evesham Town Council had taken to make residents aware of its plans to use New Homes Bonus for the Bell Tower.
Councillor C D Homer introduced the report requesting funding from Section 106 contributions for the project which would be exhibited on the windows under the Town Hall in the market place, Evesham. The photographs exhibited would depict life in Evesham and the Vale over the past 100 years. He added that Evesham Town Council were funding part of the project but that due to increasing costs it was necessary to secure funding from elsewhere.
He also informed Members that Councillor Charlie Homer had been appointed as the new Mayor of Evesham and Tony Rowley as the new Mayor of Pershore and wished them both well in their new roles.
Resolved That the following Councillors host a Member Debate on the dates as given below:- 29 July 2014 – Councillor R G Brookes 23 September 2014 – Councillor Mrs E B Tucker 16 December 2014 – Councillor C G J Tucker 17 or 24 February 2015 – Councillor Mrs A M Rowley 21 April 2015 – Councillor C D Homer Reserve – Councillor A P Miller.
Councillor Homer sought clarification as to whether any budget had been made available to lobby on behalf of the objectives of the LEP. It was confirmed that no professional lobbying had undertaken by the LEP as it was not thought beneficial.
It was proposed by Councillor Mrs A Steel, seconded by Councillor C D Homer and Resolved That Councillor Mrs F S Smith be appointed as Vice-Chairman of the Localism and Communities Advisory Panel for the 2013/14 municipal year.
Councillor C D Homer also declared an interest in Minute number 153 of the Planning Committee minutes of the 5 January 2012.
Councillor Homer felt that an opportunity had been missed to implement new technologies such as telephone parking and that the Team’s recommendations had not taken full consideration of ‘younger generations’.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Homer attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15 Jul 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Jul 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Licensing Committee | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Apr 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Apr 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Notices of Motion from Members of the Council | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Pay Policy Statement 2026/27 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Oct 2025 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Homer was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 8 of 14 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Homer declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14 Oct 2015 | Executive Board, item 48 | Prior to any discussion on this item, Councillor C D Homer disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in this item as his father was the developer. He advised that he would leave the room and take no part in the discussion thereon. | |
| 19 Jan 2015 | Localism and Communities Advisory Panel, item 36 | Councillor C D Homer also disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in the New Homes Bonus application from Evesham Town Council (agenda item 8) as a member of the Town Council. | |
| 1 Jul 2014 | Executive Board, item 14 | Councillor C D Homer disclosed an interest in agenda item 8 – References from the Localism and Communities Advisory Panel in relation to the application by Evesham Town Council for the Evesham Abbey Bell Tower Appeal as a patron of the Bell Tower and Mayor of Evesham. | |
| 23 Jun 2014 | Localism and Communities Advisory Panel, item 2 | Councillor C D Homer disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in agenda item 5 – Evesham Abbey Bell Tower Appeal and agenda item 7a – Application for funding for photographic exhibition in Evesham as patron and Mayor of Evesham. | |
| 21 Feb 2012 | Council, item 59 | Councillor C D Homer also declared an interest in Minute number 153 of the Planning Committee minutes of the 5 January 2012. |
Where Councillor Homer sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Member | Oct 2025 | 9 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Chairman | Oct 2025 | 6 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Annual Council | Member | May 2026 | 1 | |
| Planning Committee | Local Member | Aug 2026 | 1 | 10 Dec 2026 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.