Recommendations from Executive Board
Executive Board Member for Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation, Councillor D Birch, noted the need for improvements and explained that Wychavon Leisure have been calling for them for a long time.
Every time Wychavon's minutes name Councillor Birch, as the council published it.
Executive Board Member for Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation, Councillor D Birch, noted the need for improvements and explained that Wychavon Leisure have been calling for them for a long time.
The improvements to all three Wychavon Leisure sites were noted by Councillor Birch.
Councillor Birch noted that despite the investments, customer prices have only gone up in line with inflation.
Councillor Birch seconded the recommendations.
Councillor J Arnold expressed her view that investing in leisure facilities for residents is very important, and money well spent, and encouraged all members to work with Councillor Birch to ensure that the facilities remain affordable for all residents.
Councillor Birch agreed with Councillor Arnold and stated that he raises the cost of memberships in his meetings with the Managing Director of Wychavon Leisure. It was noted that a programme of free swimming has been rolled out and improvements to the environmental stability of the sites will bring a reduction in running costs.
Executive Board Member for Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation, Councillor D Birch, explained that he had met with the MD of Wychavon Leisure and confirmed that this upgrade had been wanted for some time.
Councillor D Birch responded that it is not simply a modernisation project, it is a significant building undertaking and it has to be done in order to maintain membership levels and improve the whole leisure centre. It will be for Wychavon Leisure to publicise the Health Suite.
Councillor J Arnold queried whether the costs would be passed on to members via membership fees and Councillor D Birch responded that membership fees are not linked to investment and have only risen due inflation.
The Chairman read a further statement from the Local Member, Councillor D Birch.
Councillor Birch asked that the Committee recognise the significant changes to the area since the outline application had been granted. His primary concern was for connectivity. He was worried ... view the full minutes text for item 28.
(Councillor R C Adams did not sit on the Committee for this item and spoke only as Local Member.) (Councillor D Birch was not present for all of the debate and did not vote on this item.) (Councillors R C Adams, A I Hardman, L Robinson, A M Rowley, C G J Tucker and M K Ward had declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item and were present for its consideration and determination.) (Councillor M Grisdale, Drakes Broughton and Wadborough with Pirton Parish Council, spoke against approval of this application.) ([name removed] spoke against approval of this application.) ([name removed] spoke for approval of this application.) A site visit had taken place.
Executive Board Member for Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation, Councillor D Birch, disclosed a pecuniary interest in the recommendation from Executive Board concerning Evesham and Pershore Leisure Centres as a trustee of Wychavon Leisure.
Councillor Birch will not take part in the vote.
Councillor D Birch explained that Pershore was the least economically sustainable of the leisure centres and so this aspect was the priority to safeguard its future.
Councillor D Birch expressed the need for planning enforcement and appreciated the frustration of the local people but stated that we had to be realistic with regards to refusing the application and tearing down the building. However he did agree with the arguments around the roof tiles and that they were not in keeping with the surrounding area.
Councillor NJ Wright read a statement prepared by Councillor D Birch.
Councillor Wright added his own feeling that having gotten to know Greg over the last two or three years he appreciates his enthusiasm for Wychavon and added to the formal proposal from Councillor Birch.
Executive Board Member for Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation, Councillor D Birch, declared an interest in the recommendation from the Executive Board concerning the Droitwich Spa Lido as he is a trustee of Wychavon Leisure.
It was confirmed that Councillor Birch could take part in any debate but could not vote on the item.
The Executive Board Member for Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation, Councillor D Birch, declared a conflict of interest in agenda item 18 as he is a Trustee of Wychavon Leisure.
Councillor Birch confirmed he will take part in the discussion, but not the vote.
Councillor D Birch gave an overview of the history of the lido and the people who have helped save it. He expressed pride in being part of the Council that are putting investment into this.
Councillor D Birch expressed his support for the project.
Councillor P J Knight substituted for Councillor Robson and Councillor R Deller substituted for Councillor Birch.
Councillor D Birch confirmed that the Administration and the Conservative Group support this Motion. He explained whilst the principle of a private management company and associated charges is sound it is the reality experienced by residents that is the problem, especially when compared to areas managed by Wychavon directly.
Councillor Birch confirmed that the Planning Department will be asked to respond to the ongoing consultations, alongside responses from Councillors. There was a public meeting held recently with Nigel Huddlestone MP to discuss and address these issues. A letter has subsequently been sent to the Minister in charge of these consultations.
Councillor D Birch seconded the recommendations.
Councillor D Birch seconded the recommendations and explained that at Pershore leisure centre the current heating system is very complex, and the largest cost at the leisure centre is related to energy which impacts their profits and future sustainability.
Councillor D Birch agreed that Financial Inclusion officers in principle are a good thing.
Councillor Birch identified that the Council works with partners who can support residents such as Citizens Advice, and utilising these partners would save money.
Councillor Birch confirmed that he opposed the amendment, but not the ideas within.
Councillor D Birch seconded the recommendation and thanked the team for their hard work.
Councillor Birch praised the leisure centres within Wychavon and the work done by Wychavon Leisure and their investment into high quality facilities.
Councillor Birch lamented the loss of the UKSPF as it is a significant amount of money which enables greater investment, Wychavon is fortunate to be economically led and able to absorb this loss of funding. All councillors were advised to talk to the Wychavon officers if they have events that require support.
Consideration was given to the recommendations from the Communities and Funding Advisory Panel meetings held on 17 November 2025, which were proposed by Councillor R C Adams, Executive Board Member for Strong Communities, Culture and Sport, seconded by Councillor D Birch, Executive Board Member for Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation:- Section 106 funding request – Littleton Football Club Resolved That up to £17,688.00 is allocated from the Section 106 contributions reserve towards the installation of a water irrigation system and UPVC windows at the Football Ground.
Councillor D B Birch did not feel from his point of view that the fire risks had been adequately addressed. ... view the full minutes text for item 58.
Councillor P Middlebrough substituted for Councillor Birch and Councillor L Turier substituted for Councillor Sims.
Universities are also aware of this and actively seek to put mitigation in place.” Response from Councillor D Birch “How Wychavon is increasing opportunities:- We are very lucky at Wychavon to have Leonie Silk, our Social Mobility Officer who does an incredibly good job of engaging with the schools in providing the levels of support the schools need and the pupils need, not what we as Wychavon believe they need which are two very different things often.
Councillor Birch added that whereas the majority of councillors had come and gone over the last 50 years, there was a number of officers who had been involved in the Council for many years. He felt that it was important, when the new unitary was formed, the staffing and make up of the new unitary authority looked to preserve as many of those people who had an understanding and knowledge of the district as possible.
Councillor R Deller substituted for Councillor Birch and Councillor P Middlebrough substituted for Councillor Adams.
Councillor Birch asked the applicant details regarding the location of the hydrogen and water supplies. Questions were also raised regarding the flood zones, the construction of a headwall and the discharging of water into the brook.
Councillor D B Birch could not support the application and stated that there was no such thing as a safe site for storage batteries and referenced the comments from the fire service regarding an application for a recent and similar application in the district.
Councillor D Birch highlighted that the legislation in planning was not strong enough to enforce new developments to have solar panels on nearly every single roof and there was the manufacturing capacity to make that happen. He explained how Councils were being forced to increase their housing numbers and also build solar farms on agricultural land and felt that it would be far better to encourage developers to install solar panels on roofs.
Councillor E J Kearsey stated that everything about the scheme was to be commended and she had been able to visit the scheme and see the work that was being undertaken and was very happy to propose the application in line with the officer’s recommendation which was seconded by Councillor D B Birch.
It was therefore proposed by Councillor Stokes, seconded by Councillor D Birch, and unanimously Resolved That the Treasury Management Outturn report for 2024/25 be noted.
Councillor D B Birch sympathised with the parish’s position, but reminded the members of the committee that a similar application had been refused on the same grounds in his ward, the decision had been overturned at appeal even though the inspector had strengthened the level of harm to the rural exception site in that case. He added that finding a housing provider for a small development would be difficult. He suggested that safety concerns could be addressed.
Councillor D B Birch agreed that the applicant appeared to have done a good job of developing the site and was happy to support the application.
Councillor D B Birch asked Councillor Boatright-Greene, if approved, what conditions could improve the application sufficiently.
Councillor D B Birch noted that there was a considerable enlargement on the current application opposed to the technical details consent. He expressed that the addition of a two-storey garage with a staircase, WC and full storage facilities updates represented a significant departure from a garage for a car to what could be considered a second property. The property was much larger than the original application and the additional garage would considerably and demonstrably harm the landscape.
Councillor M S Goodge substituted for Councillor Kearsey and Councillor P Middlebrough substituted for Councillor Birch.
Councillor D Birch disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in agenda item 9 – Droitwich Leisure Centre Extension and Refurbishment as he was trustee of Wychavon Leisure.
Councillor D Birch, having disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in this item took part in the discussion thereon but abstained from voting.
Councillor D Birch, Executive Board member for Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation, introduced the report and explained what the works would entail.
Councillor R Deller proposed and Councillor D Birch seconded that Councillor M S Goodge be elected Chairman of the Council.
It was proposed by Councillor A I Hardman, seconded by Councillor D Birch, and with no other nominations, it was Resolved That Councillor G Wilkins be elected Vice-Chairman of the Council to hold office until immediately after the election of the Chairman at the next Annual meeting of the Council.
That the members appointed to each of the portfolios by the Leader be noted as follows:- · Councillor E J Kearsey – Deputy Council Leader and Executive Board member for Planning, Infrastructure and Urban Design · Councillor E K Stokes – Executive Board member for Resources, Investment and Innovation · Councillor D Birch – Executive Board member for Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation · Councillor R Deller – Executive Board member for Housing, Regulatory and Customer Services · Councillor B Hardman – Executive Board member for Environment · Councillor R C Adams – Executive Board member for Strong Communities, Culture and Sport · Councillor P Middlebrough – Executive Board member for Local Government Reorganisation
It was then proposed by Councillor R J Morris, seconded by Councillor D Birch, and Resolved 1. That the appointments to Committees are as per the sheet attached to these Minutes.
The Chairman advised that for item 8 Councillor D B Birch would be speaking outside the Committee and that although he (Chairman) was a ward member he would not speak on this item as ward member.
Wychavon District Council Councillor D B Birch declared an interest that he is a trustee of Wychavon Leisure and would not take part in the debate or vote.
(Councillor D B Birch had declared an interest in this item and was not present for the debate or vote.) A committee update report had been provided.
(Councillor D B Birch spoke outside of the committee as local member.) (The Chairman did not speak as local member for this item.) (Councillor E A Sims had declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item and was present for its consideration and determination.) ([name removed] and [name removed] spoke in support of this application.) A site visit had taken place.
The Local Member, Councillor D B Birch, advised that the Parish Council were unable to attend and read out a short statement from them in which they asked that the application be refused.
Councillor Birch stated that his main concerns with this site were primarily around the green belt, traffic and the loss of good agricultural land. The green belt should be kept to protect Wychavon’s identify from Worcester’s. He worried that to take away the green belt now could later mean that it would become grey belt once the 40 year temporary scheme ended.
Councillor N Morris agreed with the comments of Councillor Birch and did not like to see farmland used in this way and stated that we should have an enforced roofs first policy.
Councillor D B Birch raised a question regarding the traffic and the access. The County Highways representative stated that they recognised that the A38 was a very busy route. The base modelling showed certain challenges getting onto the main road from side roads and advised further on the traffic management plan and the modelling and surveys provided by the applicant.
Councillor D Birch arrived during this item but did not take part in the discussion or voting thereon.
Wychavon District Council Councillor D B Birch, non-pecuniary, Councillor Birch is a trustee of Wychavon Leisure. (2) Planning Application Ref W/24/02384/FUL. Droitwich Sports And Leisure Centre, Briar Mill, Droitwich Spa, WR9 0RZ.
[name removed] District Council Councillor D B Birch, non-pecuniary, Councillor Birch is a trustee of Wychavon Leisure. (3) Planning Application Ref W/24/00632/FUL. Land At (OS 0835 4940), Evesham Road, Cleeve Prior.
Councillor D B Birch, non-pecuniary, the speaker Peter Ormorod is a named partner for Ormorod Rutter where Councillor Birch was once employed.
(Councillor D B Birch had declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item and was not present for the debate or vote.) The Planning Officer outlined the application.
(Councillor D B Birch had declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item and was not present for the debate or vote.) A committee update report had been provided.
Councillor D B Birch asked the parish councillor to share his thoughts on how the development would complement or detract from the Neighbourhood Plan. He asked the agent if he was happy with the affordable housing mix. The agent answered a number of questions.
Councillor D B Birch was in favour of extra business in Droitwich, but was particularly concerned about the loss of 77 parking spaces in the town centre. He stated that the car park serviced the majority of the town centre including key services like the doctor’s surgery and he was disturbed that traffic may hinder the movement of fire engines.
(The Chairman had declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item and did not take part in the debate or vote.) (Councillor D B Birch had declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item and was present for its consideration and determination.) (Councillor P Speechley, Hampton & Lovett Parish Council, spoke to defer this application.) ([name removed] spoke against approval of this application.) ([name removed] spoke for approval of this application.) A site visit had taken place.
Councillor Birch thought more clarity was needed on where this sits with the best and most versatile land and how that works for the rest of the site and the need to ensure that we do not destroy the land for food production in the future.
Councillor D Birch stated that it was a difficult application and that the traffic issues were severe and was surprised that Highways deemed it suitable. He was also concerned with the density and that the look of the village should be reflected.
Councillor D Birch stated the Local Member had made some good points but that these could be addressed ... view the full minutes text for item 96.
The first Notice of Motion in relation to “Support for the creation of a banking hub in Droitwich” was proposed by Councillor D Birch and seconded by Councillor R J Morris.
Councillor Birch explained that the Motion came on the back of the work being done by Droitwich Town Council in association with Droitwich Place Board which had been gaining momentum since it was first discussed in 2023. He added that this was on the back of an assessment carried out by Cash Access UK and Link that decided that Droitwich did not need a banking hub.
Councillor Birch gave some background information insofar as 10 years ago there had been six banks in Droitwich and now there was only one. He added that there were not enough banking facilities in Droitwich to support businesses and residents and therefore the work was being carried out with the aim of asking Cash Access UK and Link to review the decision they made last year.
He thanked all of the staff within Planning for their hard work and then proposed the recommendations which were seconded by Councillor D Birch and Resolved 1. That publication of the South Worcestershire Local Development Scheme 2024-2026, as set out in Appendix 1, to come into effect from February 2025, be approved.
Capital Parks Budget It was proposed by Councillor B A Hardman and then seconded by Councillor D Birch.
Councillor Powell then proposed the recommendation which was seconded by Councillor D Birch and unanimously Resolved That the progress to date be noted and the recommendations to the changes in the programme of works be approved.
Councillor D Birch now declared a non-prejudicial interest in this item as a Trustee of Wychavon Leisure.
Lido Park, Droitwich Spa – Water Play replacement It was proposed by Councillor B Hardman, seconded by Councillor D Birch, and unanimously Resolved That an increase to the capital programme of £550,000 to deliver the project be approved.
Councillor Birch reminded Members that we were in a climate crisis and therefore needed to be looking at ways to address that. He highlighted the recent flooding in Tenbury and the catastrophic damage caused to businesses. He added that the Council needed to be able to take proactive steps to help people and it was noted that there were some great businesses in the district, such as Floodtec in Hampton Lovett that could help protect both business and residential properties.
Councillor D Birch would also speak as a ward member and not vote on the application.
The Local Member, Councillor D B Birch, confirmed that Highways are to take responsibility for the completion of the footway in January 2025 and that the developer will be charged.
Councillor D B Birch addressed the Planning Committee as one of the local members for this ward.
Councillor Birch acknowledged that the ward members, parish council and residents respected the developer and were keen to work with them. He accepted that the site had been deemed suitable for development ... view the full minutes text for item 76.
Councillor D B Birch agreed that the road is fast and pavements narrow and not suitable for active travel. He was concerned by the implications of changing the shape of the village and was worried that it Badsey may become a suburb of Evesham.
Councillor D Birch, Executive Board member for Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation, introduced the report and explained that this was the first performance report in its new form following on from feedback from the Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
Following further discussion, it was proposed by Councillor D Birch, seconded by Councillor R Deller, and Resolved That the We are Wychavon six monthly performance report be noted.
Councillor Hardman then proposed the recommendations which were seconded by Councillor D Birch and unanimously Resolved 1. That the replacement of the Water Play Area at Lido Park, Droitwich Spa be approved.
Councillor Adams then proposed the recommendations which were seconded by Councillor D Birch and unanimously Resolved 1. That up to £8,500 be allocated from the Section 106 contributions reserve to enable the Parish Council to install changing facilities at Sands Lane Recreation Ground, Sands Lane, Badsey .
Councillor Birch welcomed Councillor Reeves to his first Planning Committee meeting. He did feel that this would be a suitable live work unit and we needed to encourage this type of business although he did have some concern with the hours.
Councillor D Birch stated that it was difficult as best and most versatile land should be protected for agricultural use and for growing crops but the applicant had confirmed that the solar panels would not be cemented in and in 42 years the land could be returned to its original state. This was the least suitable area for farming within the vicinity. Ideally it would be good to see panels on properties but this was not always possible.
Councillor Birch stated that we are exchanging green spaces for green energy. The developer had done quite a bit of work to reduce the impact on the agricultural area.
Councillor D Birch had major concerns with the access and building on the green belt and proposed refusal which was seconded by Councillor Dawkes.
It was proposed by Councillor D Birch, seconded by Councillor A Powell, and Resolved That the minutes of the meeting of the Executive Board held on 10 July 2024 be confirmed as a correct record of the proceedings and signed by the Chairman.
He then proposed the recommendations which were seconded by Councillor D Birch and unanimously Resolved Offenham Parish Council a) That up to £2,028.00 be allocated from the Section 106 contributions reserve to enable the Village Hall to have a comprehensive budget prepared by a Quantity Surveyor and Project Manager.
Councillor D B Birch would also be speaking as a ward member for item 11 and would not vote on that item.
Councillor Birch asked the developer why construction had never ceased in spite of enforcement officers visiting the site on several occasions. The developer re-iterated that development had continued on the basis that it was believed the level was within the tolerance noted on the engineering drawings.
The Local Member, Councillor D B Birch thanked the enforcement officers. He was concerned for the detrimental effect the development was having on the local community.
Councillor Birch noted that while the bungalows on plots 1 and 2 had been built higher than agreed, he conceded that the impact was ... view the full minutes text for item 51.
Councillor D B Birch appreciated Councillor Rowley’s concerns and suggested that the increase in the site be monitored, he could offer no material reason for refusal.
Councillor D B Birch questioned if the agent had read the Wychavon Design Code. He suggested that the design could be better and other councillors shared his opinion.
Following the site visit, Councillor D B Birch stated that he could not see a problem with the application and Councillor P Middlebrough agreed.
Councillor D Birch then addressed the Council to propose an amendment, which was circulated to Members as he spoke. The amendment read:
“This Council rejects all forms of racism and condemns any type of anti-Semitic or Islamophobic abuse in the United Kingdom.” Councillor Birch advised that Wychavon would support any resident impacted directly by global conflict by providing appropriate support and advice.
Councillor A Powell then seconded the amendment and added a few words in support of what had been said by Councillor Birch.
Home Improvement Agency Recommissioning Councillor R Deller proposed the recommendations which were seconded by Councillor D Birch and unanimously Resolved 1. That approval be given to recommission the Home Improvement Agency service.
Councillor Deller then proposed the recommendations which were seconded by Councillor D Birch and it was unanimously RECOMMENDED to COUNCIL on 17 July 2024 1. That approval be given to recommission the Home Improvement Agency service.
Councillor D Birch, non-pecuniary, all the speakers, Councillor M Farmer, [name removed] and [name removed] , are known to him.
Councillor D Birch, local member, advised that the housing allocation was out of date but that the Neighbourhood Plan would stand until 2030. He stated that we were at risk here of losing hamlets as the gap between Porters Mill and Fernhill Heath was getting ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Councillor D Birch, Local Member, advised that this house stands right out in the middle of Hindlip and looks brilliant to what it originally did. The applicant is a victim of time and if the applicant had left the building for an additional four years could have done so under permitted development rights.
However the applicant chose to revitalise the site and Councillor Birch did not feel it would impact the green belt and was concerned that if the application was refused today it would fall back into the original condition and have a detrimental impact on Hindlip.
Councillor Birch proposed approval of the application which was seconded by Councillor A M Rowley.
The new portfolios would be as follows:- Councillor C Day – Council Leader Councillor A Powell – Deputy Council Leader, Resources, Investment and Innovation Councillor D Birch – Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation Councillor P Middlebrough – Planning, Infrastructure and Urban Design Councillor R Morris – Economic Growth and Tourism Councillor R Deller – Housing, Regulatory and Customer Services Councillor B Hardman – Boosting Natural Capital Councillor R Adams – Strong Communities, Culture and Sport The Leader then thanked Councillor E K Stokes for the work done over the past 10 years during which time the Council had gained a strong reputation for its parks, toilets and waste collection.
Councillor D Birch highlighted that although there were 19 letters of support for this application when the Neighbourhood Plan had gone to a Referendum 90% of the community had voted in favour of the Neighbourhood plan and there had been a 71% turnout and he therefore seconded the proposal for refusal.
Councillor D Birch disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in agenda item 9 – Evesham and Pershore Leisure Centres – Public Sector Decarbonisation Scheme as he was a trustee of Wychavon Leisure.
It was then proposed by Councillor Powell, seconded by Councillor D Birch and unanimously Resolved That the , as attached, be approved.
Councillor D Birch ... view the full minutes text for item 126.
The Local Ward Member, Councillor D B Birch asked [name removed] his opinion on the local infrastructure. He also questioned [name removed] on the reasoning for William Davis Limited’s refusal to provide on-site play equipment or land allocation.
Local Ward Member, Councillor D B Birch was disappointed it had been necessary to bring the application to the committee. He explained that both ward members had tried in vain to get the developer to change the layout and design to better meet the design code. Whilst he acknowledged that the developers had addressed certain concerns, he maintained that they were still not making the best and most efficient use of versatile agricultural land.
Councillor D B Birch noted that Pinvin does not have a Neighbourhood Plan. It was Resolved That Permission in Principle be granted.
Councillor D B Birch believed that although not yet adopted, the Committee should be giving consideration to the new design code. He was disappointed that the developer was not present to answer questions.
Councillor D Birch, Executive Board member for Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation, having disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in the Enhancements to Leisure Provision in Droitwich item, abstained from voting on Minute 95.
The relevant portfolio holders gave more background to the promises that covered their portfolios and then Councillor D Birch seconded the recommendations.
Councillor D Birch seconded the recommendations. A named vote was taken in accordance with the Council’s Constitution and voting was recorded as follows:
Councillor D Birch, Executive Board member for Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation, disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in agenda item 12 – Enhancements to Leisure Provision in Droitwich – as he was the Executive Board member for Wychavon Leisure.
Councillor D Birch then seconded the recommendations and highlighted that a number of promises had come from the community e.g. the anti-vaping campaign, together with the health corridor which had come from the work being done by the Droitwich Place Board.
Councillor D Birch, Executive Board member for Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation, having disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in this item, advised that he would abstain from voting.
Councillor D Birch explained that when he first became the Executive Board member with responsibility for Wychavon Leisure he met with their trustees to find out what they wanted and what they needed and he believed that this package of works would fully meet those needs.
It was then proposed by Councillor Powell, seconded by Councillor D Birch, and unanimously Resolved That the draft Wychavon Design Code Supplementary Planning Documents be approved for public consultation from 8 January to 5 February 2024.
Councillor Deller proposed the recommendations and they were seconded by Councillor D Birch, Executive Board member for Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation.
Councillor D Birch, Executive Board member for Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation, introduced the Quarter 2 Signals of Success report for 2023/24 and highlighted a number of points therein.
Councillor Birch explained that as he was now on the Executive Board, he would no longer be able to chair the Panel and therefore he felt it prudent to wait until the new Chair was in place before committing to a work plan for the year. He added that an email would be sent out to members to see what they would like to discuss moving forward.
The Panel thanked Councillor Birch for the work he had done with the Panel so far.
That the members appointed to each of the portfolios by the Leader be noted as follows:- · Councillor A Powell, Deputy Leader and Executive Board member for Resources, Investment and Innovation · Councillor D Birch, Executive Board member for Wellbeing, Social Mobility and Transformation · Councillor E J Kearsey, Executive Board member for Planning, Infrastructure and Urban Design · Councillor R J Morris, Executive Board member for Economic Growth and Tourism · Councillor P Middlebrough, Executive Board member for Town and Rural Vitality · Councillor R Deller, Executive Board member for Housing and Regulatory Services · Councillor B Hardman, Executive Board member for Boosting Natural Capital · Councillor R C Adams, Executive Board member for Strong Communities, Culture and Sport · Councillor E K Stokes, Executive Board member for Resident and Customer Services
Councillor M S Goodge substituted for Councillor Birch and Councillor J Clatworthy substituted for Councillor Robinson.
Resolved That this application be refused, contrary to Officer recommendation, for the reasons but forward by Councillor Kearsey and seconded by Councillor Birch, being:
Councillor Birch welcomed everyone to the meeting and introductions were duly made.
The Local Member, Councillor D Birch, gave apologies from the Parish Council who were not able to be here. He stated that this was an important application as it had the potential to set a precedent for development in residential estates. He did not feel that grey units complemented the area, the units were still too high, would be difficult to screen, overbearing and detrimental to local views.
Councillor Birch proposed that the application be rejected as it was contrary to SWDP 21 the design does not complement the character of the area and the scale and height was not appropriate for the setting; contrary to SWDP25 the design does not integrate with the character of the landscape setting; contrary to SWDP8 the site is not proven to provide the right land and buildings for jobs and contrary to SWDP1 the level of harm imposed outweighs the ecological impact.
Councillor Birch proposed that the application be refused against the officer recommendation.
The Planning Officer was invited to address the points made by Councillor Birch. The Planning Officer stressed that the site had not come forward for 10 years. He also covered the other concerns including height of the buildings, density and issues with the local centre.
Councillor Birch then proposed to approve the application in line with the officer recommendation but with the revised suggested condition.
Communities and Funding Advisory Panel Councillor Rick Deller (Chair) Councillor Andrew Dyke Councillor Robbie Raphael Councillor Emma Sims Councillor Nick Wright Lead Executive Board Member: Councillor Rob Adams Rural Matters Advisory Panel Councillor Linda Robinson (Chair) Councillor Tony Hartley Councillor Ben Hardman Councillor Emma Sims Councillor Nick Wright Lead Executive Board Member: Councillor Chris Day Town Centres Advisory Panel Councillor Richard Morris (Chair) Councillor George Duffy Councillor Andrew Dyke Councillor Mark Goodge Councillor Robbie Raphael Councillor John Clatworthy (substitute) Lead Executive Board Member: Councillor Bradley Thomas Carbon Reduction Panel Councillor Daniel Birch (Chair) Councillor Mark Goodge Lead Executive Board Member: Councillor Beverley Hardman The Leader then went on to advise that following an open call for volunteers, seven new co-optees have been selected to serve from 22 June 2023 until 31 May 2025 on three of the Advisory Panels as follows:- Communities and Funding Advisory Panel Alex Sinton Sarah Lawlor With a previous co-optee, Rob Whittaker, to continue for a further two years Rural Matters Advisory Panel Emma Hamer Michael Simpson With a previous co-optee, Vicki Colwill to continue for a further two years Town Centres Advisory Panel Mick Hurst Jez Hanson Cassie Harris Councillor D Boatright-Greene, Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group, thanked the Leader for confirming that any member was welcome to attend Panel meet
It was then proposed by Councillor B A Thomas, seconded by Councillor C Day, and Resolved That the allocation of places on its four Advisory Panels be confirmed, including the allocation of the vacant places for co-opted members on three of the Advisory Panels:- Community Funding Advisory Panel Councillor Rick Deller (Chair) Councillor Andrew Dyke Councillor Robbie Raphael Councillor Emma Sims Councillor Nick Wright Councillor Margaret Rowley Alex Sinton Sarah Lawlor Rob Whittaker Lead Executive Board Member: Councillor Rob Adams Rural Matters Advisory Panel Councillor Linda Robinson (Chair) Councillor Tony Hartley Councillor Ben Hardman Councillor Emma Sims Councillor Nick Wright Councillor Liz Tucker Emma Hamer Michael Simpson Vicki Colwill Lead Executive Board Member: Councillor Chris Day Town Centres Advisory Panel Councillor Richard Morris (Chair) Councillor George Duffy Councillor Andrew Dyke Councillor Mark Goodge Councillor Robbie Raphael Green Party representative Councillor Charles Tucker Mick Hurst Jez Hanson Cassie Harris Councillor John Clatworthy (substitute) Lead Executive Board Member: Councillor Bradley Thomas Carbon Reduction Panel Councillor Daniel Birch (Chair) Councillor Mark Goodge Green Party representative Councillor Charles Tucker Lead Executive Board Member: Councillor Beverley Hardman
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Birch attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16 Sep 2026 | Executive Board | Budget 2027/28 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Sep 2026 | Executive Board | Health Suite Pershore Leisure Centre | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Sep 2026 | Executive Board | Street Naming and Numbering | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Sep 2026 | Executive Board | Street Naming and Numbering for Wychavon Town | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Sep 2026 | Executive Board | Capital Parks Budget | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Sep 2026 | Executive Board | Holloway Land Improvement & Biodiversity Proposal | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Sep 2026 | Executive Board | Write Offs | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Sep 2026 | Executive Board | References from Committees | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Sep 2026 | Executive Board | Loans for Improvement to Leisure Facilities | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Sep 2026 | Executive Board | Purchase of Abbey Park, Evesham | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Jul 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Jul 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Licensing Committee | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Apr 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Apr 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Council | South Worcestershire Development Plan Review approval to adopt | Carried | 29 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Executive Board | 2026/27 We are Wychavon Plan - Update | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Executive Board | Homelessness and Rough Sleeping Strategy: Approval for Public Consultation | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Executive Board | Intelligently Green Review | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Executive Board | Affordable Housing SPD approval to consult | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Executive Board | Air Quality SPD approval to consult | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Executive Board | Developer Contributions SPD approval to consult | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Executive Board | Sustainable Buildings SPD approval to consult | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Executive Board | Wychavon Design Code SPD approval to consult | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Executive Board | Stoulton Conservation Area Appraisal and Management Plan | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Executive Board | References from Committees | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Executive Board | Droitwich Spa Lido Redevelopment | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Executive Board | Droitwich Spa Pump Track and Skatepark | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Executive Board | Future Delivery of Waste Services | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Executive Board | Write Off of Debts | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Notices of Motion from Members of the Council | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Pay Policy Statement 2026/27 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Feb 2026 | Executive Board | Willow Court Additional Funds | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Feb 2026 | Executive Board | Economic Development Investment Proposal | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Feb 2026 | Executive Board | LGA Corporate Peer Challenge Progress Review Report | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Feb 2026 | Executive Board | Community Infrastructure Levy - Project Identification and Spend | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Feb 2026 | Executive Board | Wychavon District Council response to the Proposed reforms to the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) and other changes to the planning system | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Feb 2026 | Executive Board | References from Committees | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Oct 2025 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Birch was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 9 of 17 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Birch declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14 May 2025 | Council, item 96 | Councillor D Birch disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in agenda item 9 – Droitwich Leisure Centre Extension and Refurbishment as he was trustee of Wychavon Leisure. | |
| 27 Mar 2025 | Planning Committee, item 100 | Wychavon District Council Councillor D B Birch declared an interest that he is a trustee of Wychavon Leisure and would not take part in the debate or vote. | Took no part |
| 17 Apr 2024 | Council, item 109 | Councillor D Birch disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in agenda item 9 – Evesham and Pershore Leisure Centres – Public Sector Decarbonisation Scheme as he was a trustee of Wychavon Leisure. |
Where Councillor Birch sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Member | Oct 2025 | 9 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Member | Sep 2025 | 8 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Executive Board | Member | Sep 2025 | 6 | 18 Nov 2026 |
| Annual Council | Member | May 2026 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.