Planning - National Scheme of Delegations
Councillor L Robinson spoke and confirmed that the Local Government Association is planning to lobby against this and that it may not be confirmed, depending on the number of LGA groups that protest.
Every time Wychavon's minutes name Councillor Robinson, as the council published it.
Councillor L Robinson spoke and confirmed that the Local Government Association is planning to lobby against this and that it may not be confirmed, depending on the number of LGA groups that protest.
Councillor Robinson agreed that this gives local Members little or no say in the implications of planning applications and it is disappointing that no formal discussions or training sessions have been held on what is a significant change to the planning system.
Councillor Robinson is the vice-chair of the Planning Committee at Worcestershire County Council and that committee has recently had several hours of training in relation to this issue. Following this a letter was sent to the Minister for Housing and Planning setting out concerns.
Councillor Robinson noted that this was a request for better communication, support and training on issues such as this, and not a blanket criticism.
Councillor L Robinson asked if the shape of the site was appropriate given its surroundings and questioned the historic boundary lines for the houses in the locality.
The proposal was seconded by Councillor L Robinson.
Councillor L Robinson expressed her delight with the attention to detail within the report.
Councillor L Robinson, non-pecuniary, in her role as County Councillor, Councillor Janet Butterworth is known to her.
Councillor L Robinson asked about the timescale for completion of stage 1 and 2 of the development which the applicant responded that it would be as soon as possible dependent on the Decision Notice and finalising the Section 106 Agreement and discharging of relevant conditions.
Councillor L Robinson expressed her delight that rural areas will continue to be supported.
The Chairman announced that Councillor Hannah Robson would sit outside the Committee for item 8 and that Councillor Linda Robinson would sit outside the Committee for item 9. Neither would take part in the debate nor vote on the respective items.
Sandpiper TKL Ltd c/o Lockley Homes Councillor L Robinson would speak as ward member only and sit outside the committee for this item. Councillors R C Adams, L Robinson, [name removed], the speaker Neil Pearce is known to them as a former planning officer at the council.
(Councillor L Robinson had declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item, but spoke as the Local Member only and did not take part in the debate nor vote on this item.) (Councillors R C Adams and A M Rowley had declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item and were present for its consideration and determination.) (Mark Broughton-Taylor, clerk to Flyford Flavell, Grafton Flyford and North Piddle Parish Council, spoke against approval of this application.) (A Short spoke against approval of this application.) ( Neil Pearce spoke for approval of this application.) A site visit had taken place.
Councillor L Robinson questioned the applicant on the number of dwellings applied for, in particular the number of bungalows. The applicant was unable to confirm.
Councillor Robinson further questioned the grading of the agricultural land. The applicant was unable to confirm the source of the report submitted. The applicant confirmed that all biodiversity net gain was onsite.
Councillor L Robinson mentioned the homes at Norton which she visited quite often with Councillor Adams and what is poignant for them is that the name of the close where they live relates to the regiment and association with places where they served. She therefore asked if this application were to be approved could the street naming team look at something similar here and the roads named accordingly.
On that basis Councillor Robinson seconded the recommendation for approval.
He introduced himself as Chairman and Councillor Nick Dawkes as Vice-Chairmen and all the other committee members in particular Councillor L Robinson whose birthday it was today. Other Officers present were Mandy Ladds, Committee Administrator, Heather Peachey, Head of Legal Services, Carl Brace, Development Manager and Planning Officer, Karen Wightman, would be presenting both items. Also present was Andrew Fell, Assistant Manager South Worcestershire Land Drainage Partnership.
The Local Member, Councillor L Robinson thanked the Conservation Officer for the excellent report and expressed the gratitude of the local residents who also embraced the report.
Councillor L Robinson questioned whether the downgrading of the B4884 from an A Road had been a mistake given that more restraints regarding access were afforded to an A road.
Councillor L Robinson, non-pecuniary, the speakers are Alastair and Natasha Dent are known to her.
Carl Brace, Development Manager confirmed that disruption to services within the Leisure Centre would be kept to a minimum during construction and Councillor L Robinson encouraged swimmers to use the Droitwich Lido during this phase of construction.
(Councillor L Robinson had declared a non pecuniary interest in this item and spoke as local member for the item and did not take part in the debate or vote.) ([name removed], on behalf of Upton Snodsbury Parish Council, spoke against approval of this application.) ([name removed] spoke against approval of this application.) ([name removed] spoke for approval of this application.) A site visit had taken place.
The Local Member, Councillor L Robinson, did not support the application. She had come onto Wychavon in 2007 to represent Upton Snodsbury. Apart from the chicken farm this was the largest application which had come forward in the whole of her rural ward and this application was quite significant and would increase the village by 31% and increase the population by a third.
Councillor Robinson also stated that there would be some impact on the Listed Buildings and the church and the designated heritage assets and she also had highway safety concerns regarding access and that there was no proposal for a crossing. It did not comply with SWDP25 and the site erodes into open countryside and threatens the gap between Upton Snodsbury and Naunton Beauchamp. It was not in SWDPR63 and we need to remember this is only outline but once passed the principle is established and urged members to consider refusal.
Councillor E Sims welcomed everyone to the meeting, especially Cllr L Robinson and the Rural Panel who were invited to the meeting for the Rural Transport item as it’s also on their workplan.
Councillor Robinson highlighted the various topics and speakers that had been discussed at Panel meetings, including:- · John Campion, Police and Crime Commissioner who spoke on rural crime;
Councillor Robinson then explained about the Wychavon Rural Fund and how the Panel had distributed capital grants from both the Rural England Prosperity Fund (REPF) and the UK Shared Prosperity Fund (UKSPF) totalling over £819k to 54 businesses and community groups, which together with match funding, meant a total investment in Wychavon rural areas of £1.7million.
· Rural youth facilities · Rural health and wellbeing hubs · Community-led rural transport · Broadband and grid infrastructure · Water management The Leader thanked Councillor Robinson ... view the full minutes text for item 33.
Councillor L Robinson has also given apologies but may attend later in the meeting.
Councillor L Robinson was concerned with the strategic gap which was there at present but after the SWDP was reviewed it might be gone. She advised that 3 other applications on this site (2 of which went to appeal) had been turned down because of the location and the principle of the site. She stated that 4 trees were planted after the 1 st World War as a memorial and sadly only 2 trees now remained and she could not see if this went ahead that these 2 remaining trees would not be affected.
Councillor Robinson thought that if the trees were felled that they had to be replaced as part of the Tree Preservation Order. The site was also in a conservation area and a gateway to the village and we should not ignore the TPO and what the planning inspector had said in the past. The Development Manager would follow up if there had been a breach of a Tree Preservation Order.
Councillor L Robinson focused on the location and felt that Walcot Lane was a narrow single track, had a shared use and no footpath and led to the ford.
Cllr Robinson worried they were creating a situation where an accident would happen. She stated that big tankers travelled to the dairy farm and that no buses run from the bus stop.
Councillor Robinson also stated that if it did go to technical detail stage she would like to see wires across the lane to see how ... view the full minutes text for item 60.
Councillor L Robinson remarked that the elevations appeared too high and that blank gable ends were uninspiring.
The Local Member, Councillor L Robinson, stated that the design was exemplary but was concerned that the road was busy and had dangerous bends. Highways were happy with it but felt that if there were further applications that could change.
Councillor Robinson was surprised that we were ignoring the highways comments.
Councillor L Robinson raised a concern over the ethos of self builds. The Head of Development Management clarified that the person who buys one has all the input and control over the development and the legal agreement would tie them to a self build .
Councillor L Robinson expressed concern for the personal care of the horses Ciaran Power, Head of Development Management clarified the criteria regarding the development boundary in the context of travellers.
Councillor L Robinson, non-pecuniary, Councillor J Butterworth is known to her as she is Chairman of Drakes Broughton and Wadborough with Pirton Parish Council which she represents as a County Councillor.
Councillor Robinson also expressed her disappointment that neither the applicant nor Highways were present to answer questions.
Councillor A M Rowley proposed that the application be deferred for a site visit and this was seconded by Councillor L Robinson.
Councillor L Robinson non-pecuniary, Councillor J Butterworth is known to her as she is Chairman of Drakes Broughton and Wadborough with Pirton Parish Council which she represents.
Councillor L Robinson declared a non-pecuniary interest as the speakers Janet Butterworth and Kenneth Skillern were known to her.
Andrew Fell and Councillor L Robinson confirmed that public sewer cannot be connected to the County Highways drain. Resolved To refuse the application in accordance with the officer recommendation to include the officer verbal update suggested for refusal:
This was also confirmed by Councillor L Robinson in seconding the recommendation.
Councillor M S Goodge substituted for Councillor Robinson.
Councillor J Clatworthy substituted for Councillor Robinson.
Councillor M S Goodge substituted for Councillor Birch and Councillor J Clatworthy substituted for Councillor Robinson.
Councillor L Robinson, non-pecuniary, all the speakers are known to her.
Councillor L Robinson supported the application. She understood the sentiment in the room and mentioned that she was actually Chairman when the ... view the full minutes text for item 29.
Councillor Robinson then proposed deferral of the application and this was seconded by Councillor Bowden.
Councillor Linda Robinson seconded deferral.
· Vicki Colwill · Emma Hamer · Michael Simpson · Councillor Linda Robinson · Councillor Nick Wright · Councillor Ben Hurdman
Communities and Funding Advisory Panel Councillor Rick Deller (Chair) Councillor Andrew Dyke Councillor Robbie Raphael Councillor Emma Sims Councillor Nick Wright Lead Executive Board Member: Councillor Rob Adams Rural Matters Advisory Panel Councillor Linda Robinson (Chair) Councillor Tony Hartley Councillor Ben Hardman Councillor Emma Sims Councillor Nick Wright Lead Executive Board Member: Councillor Chris Day Town Centres Advisory Panel Councillor Richard Morris (Chair) Councillor George Duffy Councillor Andrew Dyke Councillor Mark Goodge Councillor Robbie Raphael Councillor John Clatworthy (substitute) Lead Executive Board Member: Councillor Bradley Thomas Carbon Reduction Panel Councillor Daniel Birch (Chair) Councillor Mark Goodge Lead Executive Board Member: Councillor Beverley Hardman The Leader then went on to advise that following an open call for volunteers, seven new co-optees have been selected to serve from 22 June 2023 until 31 May 2025 on three of the Advisory Panels as follows:- Communities and Funding Advisory Panel Alex Sinton Sarah Lawlor With a previous co-optee, Rob Whittaker, to continue for a further two years Rural Matters Advisory Panel Emma Hamer Michael Simpson With a previous co-optee, Vicki Colwill to continue for a further two years Town Centres Advisory Panel Mick Hurst Jez Hanson Cassie Harris Councillor D Boatright-Greene, Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group, thanked the Leader for confirming that any member was welcome to attend Panel meet
It was then proposed by Councillor B A Thomas, seconded by Councillor C Day, and Resolved That the allocation of places on its four Advisory Panels be confirmed, including the allocation of the vacant places for co-opted members on three of the Advisory Panels:- Community Funding Advisory Panel Councillor Rick Deller (Chair) Councillor Andrew Dyke Councillor Robbie Raphael Councillor Emma Sims Councillor Nick Wright Councillor Margaret Rowley Alex Sinton Sarah Lawlor Rob Whittaker Lead Executive Board Member: Councillor Rob Adams Rural Matters Advisory Panel Councillor Linda Robinson (Chair) Councillor Tony Hartley Councillor Ben Hardman Councillor Emma Sims Councillor Nick Wright Councillor Liz Tucker Emma Hamer Michael Simpson Vicki Colwill Lead Executive Board Member: Councillor Chris Day Town Centres Advisory Panel Councillor Richard Morris (Chair) Councillor George Duffy Councillor Andrew Dyke Councillor Mark Goodge Councillor Robbie Raphael Green Party representative Councillor Charles Tucker Mick Hurst Jez Hanson Cassie Harris Councillor John Clatworthy (substitute) Lead Executive Board Member: Councillor Bradley Thomas Carbon Reduction Panel Councillor Daniel Birch (Chair) Councillor Mark Goodge Green Party representative Councillor Charles Tucker Lead Executive Board Member: Councillor Beverley Hardman
Councillor A L Dyke proposed and Councillor L Robinson seconded that Councillor R Raphael be elected Chairman of the Council.
Councillor Robinson drew the committee’s attention to NPPF11, SWDP 21.9, NPPF48 and stated that the application was contradictory to them.
Councillor Robinson went to inform the committee that the application contravenes the Worcestershire Street Scene Design Guide, clauses 3.14 and 3.15.
She did agree with Councillor Robinson that the standard of the design is less than desirable although screened. You have to look at the reasonableness and degree of harm. Finally she ... view the full minutes text for item 114.
Councillor Robinson advised that although the Case Officer would have preferred post and rail fencing he was willing to accept the retrospective construction of a panel fence as long as native hedging was planted on the outside of the fence. However, the spokesperson for the adjacent landowner has advised the District Council that they have not been consulted and will remove the hedging. The applicant cannot now screen the panel fencing so how can planning permission be granted as it would be illegal to carry out work on ... view the full minutes text for item 51.
· Councillor Linda Robinson – agenda item 4 – Stoulton Parish Council’s NHB proposal as local member.
Councillor L Robinson agreed and added that she is keen for the Panels to make recommendations to the Executive Board that will give a steer.
He reminded the Panel that Councillor Linda Robinson, Leader of Wychavon District Council is a Board Member on the WLEP.
The local member Councillor Linda Robinson highlighted that Wychavon District Council now have a 5 year land supply and that the development conflicted with the SWDP but said the land is a possible development site.
Cllr Robinson had concerns with the increased numbers of dwellings as well as the access proposed, which she felt, would be a danger for pedestrians and children.
Councillor Robinson highlighted that the development would be conflicting with the SWDP and raised concerns over the sizes of the proposed dwellings aswell as the sustainability due to lack of buses and local amenities. Resolved That this application be refused for the following reasons:- (1) The dwellings would be located outside of the development boundary of Flyford Flavell as defined by Policy SWDP2 of the South Worcestershire Development Plan. New development in the open countryside will be strictly controlled to specific uses (SWDP2 C), none of which apply in this case.
Councillor Robinson informed Members of the technical details of the process, which required the Council to allow a free re-submission of an application even if it had been previously approved. It was confirmed that this was an issue that the Council should lobby the future Government on following the May elections.
Councillor Robinson thanked all Committee Members for their hard work, especially the Vice-Chairman and portfolio holder for their help and guidance. Thanks were also paid to all officers who had supported the Committee and its work.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Robinson attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15 Jul 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Jul 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Licensing Committee | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Mar 2026 | Council | South Worcestershire Development Plan Review approval to adopt | Carried | 29 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Notices of Motion from Members of the Council | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Pay Policy Statement 2026/27 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Oct 2025 | Council | Recommendations from Executive Board | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Sep 2025 | Executive Board | Wychavon District Council Empty Homes Strategy 2025 - 2030 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Sep 2025 | Executive Board | 2026/27 Budget Process | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Sep 2025 | Executive Board | Write-off of debts | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Robinson was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 9 of 17 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Robinson declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7 Dec 2023 | Planning Committee, item 73 | Councillor L Robinson declared a non-pecuniary interest as the speakers Janet Butterworth and Kenneth Skillern were known to her. |
Where Councillor Robinson sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Member | Oct 2025 | 9 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Member | Sep 2025 | 8 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Rural Matters Advisory Panel | Chairman | Sep 2025 | 6 | |
| Annual Council | Member | May 2026 | 1 | |
| Executive Board | Member | Sep 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.