Petitions
f) Councillor Steward presented a petition which called upon City of York Council to put up signage about the risk of loose deer covering the area of Tadcaster Road new houses to the junction by Askham Bog.
Every time York's minutes name Councillor Steward, as the council published it.
f) Councillor Steward presented a petition which called upon City of York Council to put up signage about the risk of loose deer covering the area of Tadcaster Road new houses to the junction by Askham Bog.
Parish Councillor Geoghegan-Breen was nominated as Vice-Chair by Councillor Kent, this was seconded by Councillor Steward.
Cllr Steward noted that he had attended St Peter’s School and Cllr Burton noted that she had attended Queen Anne Grammar School. There were no further declarations of interest.
[Cllr Burton joined the meeting and Cllr Steward gave apologies and left the meeting].
Cllr Steward noted that he had attended St Peter’s School and Cllr Burton noted that she had attended Queen Anne Grammar School. There were no further declarations of interest.
He also thanked opposition leaders Councillor Nigel Ayre and Councillor Chris Steward for their constructive working relationships, including work on the Community Stadium project.
For Against Abstain Councillor Ayre 1 Councillor Baxter 1 Councillor Clarke 1 Councillor Coles 1 Councillor Crawshaw 1 Councillor Cullwick 1 Councillor Cuthbertson 1 Councillor Douglas 1 Councillor Fenton 1 Councillor Fisher 1 Councillor Healey 1 Councillor Hollyer 1 Councillor Hook 1 Councillor Kent 1 Councillor Kilbane 1 Councillor Knight 1 Councillor Lomas 1 Councillor Mason 1 Councillor Melly 1 Councillor Merrett 1 Councillor Moroney 1 Councillor Myers 1 Councillor Nelson 1 Councillor Nichols 1 Councillor Orrell 1 Councillor Pavlovic 1 Councillor Perrett 1 Councillor Ravilious 1 Councillor Rose 1 Councillor Rowley 1 Councillor Runciman 1 Councillor Smalley 1 Councillor Steels-Walshaw 1 Councillor Steward 1 Councillor Taylor 1 Councillor Waller 1 Councillor Wann 1 Councillor Watson 1 Councillor Waudby 1 Councillor Webb 1 Councillor Wells 1 Councillor Whitcroft 1 Councillor Widdowson 1 Councillor Wilson 1 Totals:
Cllr Steward declared his membership of the Campaign for Real Ale, as a personal interest.
He also highlighted support for the Conservative Group amendment proposed by Councillor Steward in relation to locally driven action on pollution in rivers. That it was right to listen to partners and officers ... view the full minutes text for item 53.
The Leader of the Conservative Group, Councillor Steward, thanked the outgoing Chief Executive, Ian Floyd, who he had always considered a pleasure to work with. He was fair and balanced in his approach and undertaken a great job. He welcomed the appointment of the incoming Chief Executive, Richard Webb, who had demonstrated all the necessary skills to be a great Chief Executive at City of York Council.
Following debate, Cllr Widdowson moved, and Cllr Steward seconded, that the question be now put. On being put to the vote this motion was declared LOST.
Cllr Steward noted that he was a member of York Environment Forum and had not taken part in any discussions regarding the outer ring road. There were no further declarations of interest.
· Officers had looked at the balance and did not think that the very special circumstances outweighed the harm Cllr Steward moved the officer recommendation for refusal for the reasons outlined in the additional information.
Cllr Pearson chaired the meeting from this point and Cllr Steward was elected vice chair.
· Councillor Steward – Deputy Leader’s achievements over this period Supplementary Cllr Steward – Ward Committees and Economic Growth Cllr N Barnes – Ward Committee funding Cllr Pavolvic – Ward funding delays · Councillor D Taylor – new jobs/low paid jobs in the City Supplementary Cllr D Taylor – Inward investment Cllr Aspden responded directly to all the questions put to him, including supplementaries but advised that he would forward the required information to Hull Road Ward councillors and the statistics to Councillor Dave Taylor.
Cllr Steward, Rural West York Ward Councillor, spoke in objection to the application.
Cllr Steward to be appointed as Vice-Chair.
Health, Housing and Adult Social Care Policy and Scrutiny Committee Cllr Steward to replace Cllr Richardson on this committee.
Steve Mills (Local resident in objection), Rachel Martin (Local resident in objection), Anthea Tate ( Agent for applicant in support), Mark Barratt ( Chair of Hessay Parish Council in objection) and Cllr Steward (Ward Councillor) had registered to speak on the application at the meeting. All were asked and confirmed that they did not wish to speak on the application.
Councillor Steward declared a personal non prejudicial interest in agenda item 6 (School Improvement and Ofsted Update on Schools Performance) as a Governor of Rufforth Primary School.
To appoint Councillor Steward to replace Councillor Dew as a council representative on the North Yorkshire Police and Crime Panel
· To appoint Cllr Steward as a conservative substitute on the Children, Education and Communities Policy and Scrutiny Committee;
The Chair (Councillor Steward – Vice Chair), Councillor Lisle and ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Members received the final report of the Scrutiny Task Group set up to review the planning of an overall strategy for the council’s activities to commemorate WW1, chaired by Cllr Steward. Approval was sought for the recommendations arising from the review.
( i ) Non-recyclable Materials (Proposed by Cllr Richardson, seconded by Cllr Steward) “Council notes:
Cllr Steward declared a personal interest as a shareholder in Capita.
Councillor Steward declared a personal interest due to his ownership of one share in Sirius Minerals.
Customer and Corporate Services Scrutiny Management Committee To appoint Cllr K Myers to replace Cllr Steward.
Members were asked to declare any personal interests not included on the Register of Interests, any prejudicial interests or any disclosable pecuniary interests which they might have in respect of business on the agenda. · Councillor Steward declared a personal interest, that he owns one share in Sirius Minerals.
As a Committee of the Executive, Members were asked to consider the appointment of Councillor Gillies to replace Councillor Steward as one of the representatives on the Council’s new Shareholder Committee.
Members requested that they also received information on the breaches that were identified. 1 Councillor Steward proposed and Councillor Kramm seconded a proposal that the Corporate and Scrutiny Management Committee be asked to consider how Members could be involved in the monitoring of procurement processes. On being put to the vote the motion was declared carried.
Cllr Steward also declared a personal non prejudicial interest in relation to this item as a Governor of Rufforth School and he also withdrew from the meeting for the discussion and took no part in the voting thereon.
· Cllr Gunnell – monitoring, inspection and action taken following pavement excavation works by utility companies (iv) To Cllr Steward, Executive Member for Finance and Performance:
Cllr Rawlings moved, and Cllr Steward seconded receipt of the report.
Councillor Steward declared a personal interest in relation to agenda item 11 (Minerals and Waste Joint Plan- Publication Draft – minute 62 refers) as he had previously owned shares in Sirius Minerals and may hold shares in the future.
Councillor Steward declared a personal interest, as he had once owned shares in Sirius Minerals and may hold them again in the future.
Councillor Steward stated that the total ward budget was £33,830, which included £7,000 carried forward from the previous year. He stated that applications for grants had been made by Poppleton Youth Club and the Bowls Club and that an additional application was expected from Skelton Parish Council.
There is an additional £19,780 pot for highway schemes, which Councillor Steward stated can be rolled into one big scheme for the ward over four years. Examples might include updating zebra crossings, additional street lighting, etc. He stated that forms were available for anyone who wished to make an application for Ward funding.
Councillor Steward stated that the officer who deals with the ward had changed two weeks ago and that this had complicated the situation, but agreed that acknowledgements should have been sent to any recent applications.
Councillor Steward stated that if applications were put in, this would likely be looked favourably upon.
Councillor Steward went through the key issues which had been outlined in his written report.
This had been from Councillor Steward, who wished to remain on the Committee but not as Vice Chair.
Executive Leaders Report A written report was received from the Executive Leader, Cllr Chris Steward, on the work of the Executive.
Members were then invited to question Cllr Steward on his report and questions were received from the floor from the following Members in relation to the subjects listed:
· Cllr Gunnell – regular flood updates to Communities & Environment Scrutiny Committee · Cllr Reid – how can York ensure that it benefits from HS2 and HS3 · Cllr Funnell – recent announcements regarding the lesser role of school parent governors · Cllr Levene – concerns regarding the removal of parent governors from schools · Cllr Levene – April meeting of Local Plan Working Group or miss Government deadline · Cllr Levene – consultation on significant changes to Local Plan and effect on deadline · Cllr N Barnes – exploration of Devolution options and consultation · Cllr N Barnes – meeting end of March devolution deadline Cllr Steward responded directly to all the questions put to him.
[At this point in the proceedings the Lord Mayor vacated the Chair and the Deputy Chair took the meeting for the following item] B Executive Recommendations Community Stadium and Leisure Facilities Cllr Steward moved, and Cllr Aspden seconded the following recommendation contained in Minute 83 of the Executive meeting held on 17 March 2016, circulated at the meeting:
As the guillotine had fallen earlier in the meeting Members were unable to question Cllr Steward and/or the Executive Members in respect of any matters within their portfolio responsibility.
Councillor Steward as Chair of the Staffing Matters and Urgency Committee, moved the following recommendation, from the Committee’s meeting held on 1 February 2016, as set out at Minute 68, relating to the remuneration for Chief Officer appointments.
Councillor Steward moved a motion to approve the Pay Policy Statement, which was seconded by Councillor Aspden .
Councillor Steward moved and Councillor Aspden seconded the following recommendations in relation to the report: Recommended: ( i ) That Members confirm their consideration of the Public Interest Report published by the Auditor.
Councillor Steward moved and Councillor Aspden seconded the recommendation made by Executive at their meeting held on 11 February 2016, following consideration of the third monitor report on the Capital Programme (minute 118 refers) as follows:
Councillor Steward requested the consent of Council to the alteration of the original Executive motions to incorporate the amendment previously circulated with the Council agenda papers.
Following receipt of Council’s consent Cllr Steward moved and Councillor Aspden seconded, the motions relating to the following proposals, as set out at pages 1 to 4 of the papers circulated at the meeting (now included in the republished agenda), in relation to:
Councillor Steward apologised that the Trade Unions had not been briefed about the proposal before they were made public. He added that transformation and change needed to be embedded at the heart of every service. In regards to advertising the two posts it was agreed that these would be advertised as widely as possible.
Councillor Steward moved and Councillor Aspden seconded the recommendations and it was
A Executive Leaders Report A written report was received from the Executive Leader, Cllr Chris Steward, on the work of the Executive.
Members were then invited to question Cllr Steward on his report and questions were received from the floor from the following Members in relation to the subjects listed:
· Cllr S Barnes – Letter from Cuadrilla regarding the exploration of fracking in the area and reference to the greater protection of communities as requested by the Local Plan Working Group · Cllr Kramm – minimum distance to drill sites from human settlements not being specified in the Council’s Joint Minerals and Waste Plan · Cllr Levene – changes in Council Tax benefits · Cllr Kramm – the allocation of sites in the Green Belt as starter homes for young families and whether this was possible in York · Cllr Lisle – development of small scale sites in the Green Belt · Cllr Levene – changes to Universal Credit · Cllr S Barnes – inclusion of Whinthorpe site in Local Plan Cllr Steward responded directly to all the questions put to him.
B Executive Recommendations Capital Programme – Monitor 2 2015/16 Cllr Steward moved, and Cllr Aspden seconded the following recommendation contained in Minute 83 of the Executive meeting held on 26 November 2015:
Members were then invited to question Cllr Steward and/or the Executive Members in respect of any matters within their portfolio responsibility. Questions were received from the floor from the following Members in relation to the subjects listed:
Councillor Steward confirmed the recent Government announcement that the York Central site had been given Enterprise Zone status.
Ward Committtees - New Arrangements - Cllr Steward outlined the new arrangements around neighbourhood working, including the Ward committee, Ward team and Ward budgets. Such arrangements have been designed to empower local residents and to support Ward members in identifying, developing and delivering on local priorities. There is also budgetary devolvement to Wards for allocation to local priorities.
Devolution – Cllr Steward gave an overview of York’s current position in relation to the government’s devolution of powers.
Cllr Steward emphasised that this is a great opportunity for York.
Local Plan – Cllr Steward reported that it was hoped to submit the revised Local Plan early next year following the six week consultation period. Whilst the plan did contain a limited amount of green belt development, much of the development was to take place on brown field sites.
In response to a query, Cllr Steward confirmed that in the planning process, ‘safeguarded’ land meant land that had been reserved for future development needs. He confirmed that new housing would not be built on flood plains.
It was then moved by Cllr Steward and seconded by Cllr Williams:
A Executive Leaders Report A written report was received from the Executive Leader, Cllr Chris Steward, on the work of the Executive.
Members were then invited to question Cllr Steward on his report and questions were received from the floor from the following Members in relation to the subjects listed:
· Cllr Gunnell – request for a more proactive stance in relation to the Syrian Refugees and highlighting inconsistencies between the Leader and Executive Members reports in relation to progress on the Community Stadium · Cllr Cannon – public concern regarding the Care Quality Commission’s (CQC) closure of Bootham Park Hospital and a request for support for an independent inquiry · Cllr S Barnes – current funding of Yearsley Pool to 2022 and the funding gap to 2028 · Cllr Cuthbertson – request for an update on York’s devolution bid, following Sheffield’s recent successful bid · Cllr Kramm – in relation to the new Ward funding model Cllr Steward responded directly to all the questions put to him.
B Executive Recommendations Older Persons’ Accommodation Programme: The Business Case Cllr Steward moved, and Cllr Aspden seconded the following recommendation contained in Minute 34 of the Executive meeting held on 30 July 2015:
Members were then invited to question Cllr Steward and/or the Executive Members in respect of any matters within their portfolio responsibility. Questions were received from the floor from the following Members in relation to the subjects listed:
Councillor Steward as Chair of the Staffing Matters and Urgency Committee, moved the following recommendation, from the Committee meeting on 20 July 2015, as set out at Minute 25, relating to the remuneration for the appointment of an Acting Director of Public Health.
A Executive Leaders Report A written report was received from the Executive Leader, Cllr Chris Steward, on the work of the Executive.
Members were then invited to question Cllr Steward on his report and questions were received from the floor from the following Members in relation to the subjects listed:
· Cllr Craghill – progress on agreement to work with Yorspace · Cllr N Barnes – reduction in Council budget reliant on underspend and New Homes Bonus · Cllr Cuthbertson – to look back at 2014/15 performance · Cllr S Barnes – reference to £688k underspend and previous administration · Cllr Galvin – with decisions required on a range of issues over the forthcoming months who would the city be linking up with in relation to devolution · Cllr Boyce – would the new administration be taking residents with them in relation to the Local Plan · Cllr Doughty – affect on finance of the delays in the sale of Oliver House · Cllr Williams – how different was the delay to consult residents in respect of the Newbury Avenue housing development · Cllr Gunnell – in respect of the length and content of th Leaders report · Cllr Cannon- whether Council would formally receive and consider the administrations 12 point plan · Cllr Orrell – in respect of correspondence with neighbouring authorities either prior to or following the local government election in relation to the Local Plan Cllr Steward responded directly to all the questions put to him.
B Executive Recommendation New Council Housing and approval for development at Ordnance Lane Cllr Steward moved, and Cllr Aspden seconded the following recommendation contained in Minute 16 of the Executive meeting held on 25 June 2015:
Councillor Steward as Chair of the Staffing Matters and Urgency Committee, moved the following recommendations, firstly from the Staffing Matters and Urgency Committee meeting on 8 June 2015, as set out at Minute 6, relating to the appointment of the Acting Chief Executive, including the recommended salary package.
Councillor Steward moved and Councillor Aspden seconded the changes to the Procedure Rules and the Council’s Constitution.
Cllr Steward followed the officer’s recommendation to dismiss the ACV application on just one ground, the previous usage of the building. The report to the leader states:
Councillor Steward, as Executive Leader, Finance and Performance and Councillor Aspden , as Deputy Leader and Executive Member for Economic Development and Community Engagement, attended the meeting to report on their priorities and challenges for 2015/16. They drew attention to the draft Council Plan for 2015-19, which set out their 12 point list of priorities, which included the Council’s statutory responsibilities, all built around the 3 key priorities of A Prosperous City for All, A Focus on Frontline Services and A Council That Listens to Residents.
Councillor Sonja Crisp as Lord Mayor moved, Councillor Chris Steward seconded and the Council unanimously
Councillor Chris Steward moved, Councillor Carol Runciman seconded and Council unanimously
Councillor Steward spoke in relation to Agenda Item 3 (Make it York Commissioning Agreement). He informed the Committee that he was the Chair of the Make it York Shareholder Committee and that they had met four times and alongside himself the membership currently comprised of Councillors Gunnell and Taylor. He then detailed which Members and Cabinet Members had previously been on the Committee.
The Chair invited Councillor Steward to stay at the meeting to answer any questions in relation to the Make it York Shareholders Committee.
Councillor Steward agreed to this request.
Discussion took place in response to points raised by Councillor Steward under Public Participation. It was clarified that Cabinet would set the priorities for Make it York and the Shareholder Committee would scrutinise the delivery of these.
Councillor Steward raised concerns at the rushed delivery date of the SLA and pointed out to the Committee that the Shareholders Committee could only make suggestions to the Cabinet Member. He highlighted the lack of transparency in the process and explained to Members why some of the Labour Group appointees had changed.
Councillor Steward responded that as the Chair as the Shareholders Committee he felt happy to take on the scrutiny of Make it York, but felt there would be a significant overlap with the work of scrutiny committees. He also agreed with the Member’s comment that the inclusion of three Cabinet Members on the Board was too many.
(i) From Cllr Steward “Do you accept that the reason the Conservative Group initiated the Local Government Association’s review of City of York Council’s political culture was not because there was an objection to the ‘Strong Leader’ model of cabinet government, but included because the Labour administration and in particular certain members of the Labour cabinet operated in a deliberately opaque and punitively aggressive manner towards opposition councillors and officers when they did not agree with the administration’s policies?” The Leader replied:
“I believe Cllr Steward to be an honourable man so if he says those were the motivations for the Conservative Group I entirely accept him at his word.
( i ) To the Cabinet Leader (including Finance & Performance) from Cllr Steward:
“Could the Cabinet Leader detail the results of the 2015/16 public budget consultation process?” “Please see Annex 8 of Financial Strategy, February Budget Cabinet.” (v) To the Cabinet Leader (including Finance & Performance) from Cllr Steward:
It was then moved by Cllr Williams and seconded by Cllr Steward:
Cllr Aspden then moved, and Cllr Steward seconded, an amendment to the above motion, as follows:
Councillor Steward moved and Councillor Aspden seconded a motion to suspend Standing Orders in order to allow five Notices of Motion to be considered at the meeting.
She expressed significant concern at one of the recommendations in the report which requested that Members replace her position as Chair of NewCo Shareholders Group with that of Councillor Steward. She highlighted that the Committee had previously voted for her to Chair the NewCo Shareholders Group at their last meeting on 10 November 2014. She questioned why the decision had been put forward for reconsideration and a new proposal recommended without justification for alteration of the original appointment.
She requested that Members uphold the original decision reached to elect her, as the Cabinet Member for Leisure, Culture and Tourism, to Chair the NewCo Shareholders Group and reject the appointment of Councillor Steward as Chair.
Councillor Steward had registered to speak as Ward Member. He supported the views of the residents that opposed the development but acknowledged that it was a tough decision as there are no other suitable sites for such a facility. He stated that it was inappropriate development in the Green Belt for which no Very ... view the full minutes text for item 27.
( i ) From Cllr Steward “Does the leader share my view that zero hours contracts are a problem when people are restricted to one employer and welcome the Prime Minister clamping down on that, or does he oppose all zero hours contracts per se?” The Leader replied:
(iv) From Cllr Steward “ With the leader’s report objecting to two further call-ins as inappropriate in his eyes can he detail any call-ins this term he has not felt were wrong to be done or does he genuinely believe no decision of his administration has been worth further scrutiny ?” The Leader replied:
A Motion submitted for consideration directly by Council, in accordance with Standing Order 12.1(b) (i) Organisational Development Plan (proposed by Cllr Steward) “Council notes with concern the results of the Organisational Development Action Plan, in particular the Leadership section and the current position re ‘Concern about the Behaviour of some Members’. This follows last year’s Peer Challenge review which also expressed concern regarding members’ understanding of council priorities and the lack of clarity within the council.
(i) To the Cabinet Leader from Cllr Steward:
(ii) To the Cabinet Leader from Cllr Steward:
(iii) To the Cabinet Leader from Cllr Steward:
Cllr Steward expressed his support for the proposals outlined in the draft business plan for Newco which would provide a good opportunity for the city. He confirmed that his only concerns related to the financial aspects of the plan.
Cllr Steward spoke on behalf of Helen Butterworth from Rufforth with Knapton Parish Council in relation to Site RE3:772 allocated for a Solar Farm at Knapton Moor. The Parish Council felt that this was an inappropriate use in the Green Belt and in the green corridor in to York mentioned by the earlier speaker. They requested the removal of this site from the Local Plan.
Councillor Steward spoke on behalf of the second group of calling in members reiterating their reasons for ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
Lendal Bridge and Coppergate Traffic Regulation Orders Cllr Steward, spoke to raise his concerns at the current situation in relation to the Penalty Charge Notice’s (PCN’s) arising from the Lendal Bridge trial, which he felt was damaging the city’s reputation. He also expressed concern at the proposal to refund PCN’s only to motorists who made application and spoke of the need for equal treatment for all which included the refund of all fines.
The first four questions were put and answered as follows and Cllr Alexander undertook to provide Members with written answers to the remaining questions ( i ) From Cllr Steward “When the leader refers to good growth can he give examples of companies in York he believes are currently delivering bad growth?” The Leader replied:
(i) To the Cabinet Leader from Cllr Steward:
Minutes from the Local Plan Working Group, 31 March and 30 June 2014 Councillor Steward acknowledged the work which had gone into producing the Village Design Statements and welcoming those recently produced for Wheldrake and Strensall with Towthorpe .
Community Conversations – Next Steps Councillor Steward made reference to the attendance levels at the Community Conversation meetings which did not appear to be as effective as suggested. He made reference to the Copmanthorpe meeting, full details of which had not been included in the report.
Councillor Steward thanked Officers for their report and briefing on the programme. He referred to problems in the area of Adult Social Care and to subsequent delays. Support was expressed for the rationale of the project and focus on good outcomes for service users with the continuation of member input into the proposals.
Councillor Chris Steward moved, Councillor Janet Looker seconded and Council unanimously
Cllr Steward referred to the lack of cross party discussion in relation to the Lendal Bridge closure and reopening and his concerns at the length of time prior to the decision taken to reopen the bridge. He highlighted the lack of tangible metrics and how success would have been measured.
Final Report of the Corporate and Scrutiny Management Committee on the Night Time Economy Scrutiny Review Cllr Steward referred to the final report on the night time economy as a good example of cross party work which had resulted in a good balance of recommendations.
Councillor Steward, spoke to reiterate the views of the Liberal Democrat Conservative Group, in particular that although not against development the scale of the proposals were not felt appropriate for the city or its affect on green belt land. He raised concerns regarding the proposed public consultation document and lack of detail and to the recently circulated traveller’s sites addendum. He asked for distribution of leaflets in areas where a large site was likely to have a major impact on residents.
Councillor Steward also spoke to question the urgency of the city centre competitiveness decision and highlighted the need for cross party discussions in the interests of the city centre.
Without a local plan which takes into account planned growth, there is no protection of our green spaces.” (ii) From Cllr Steward “ With the leader wanting to know whether others are ‘in favour of rent capping’ can he outline the system he is proposing so others could at least have a chance of knowing what he is seeking their agreement to?” The Leader replied:
(i) To the Cabinet Leader from Cllr Steward:
Cllr Steward informed the meeting that the Local Plan Working Group had not yet discussed sites or houses, and was currently behind schedule.
Councillor Steward, as Chair of the Task Group, presented the final report and recommendations of the Group, which comprised of Officer instructions and templates to ensure consistency and monitoring of any future grants or loans made by the authority. He thanked Members of the Task Group for their work over a number of months and asked Cabinet to approve implementation of the following recommendations:
The Leader confirmed that Cllr Steward would be kept informed on the Financial Regulation work and that a report would be brought back to a future Cabinet meeting in respect of the recommendations.
The Lord Mayor firstly welcomed Cllr Steward to the Council meeting in his new role as Leader of the Conservative Group and wished him a happy tenure in the role.
Cllr Steward, as Chair of the Task Group, presented the final report pointing out that the Group had suggested a more common approach, the standardising of applications, with new thresholds and Officer guidance in an effort to provide a clearer, more transparent process for all.
Councillor Steward spoke in respect of agenda item 8 (Public Participation Scheme). He stated that the introduction of the proposed changes would suppress free speech. He expressed concern that the restriction on criticising officers or Members would lead to a weakening in accountability.
Get York Building Phase 3 – Infrastructure Investment Plan for Growth Cllr Steward expressed slight concerns at the ‘ring fencing’ of £10m for infrastructure for the York Central site, questioning if this would be matched by developers. Support was expressed for the efforts to kick-start development of the site but it was questioned if the development would involve cross party discussions.
Consultation Response regarding Combined Authority Cllr Steward confirmed that, whilst welcoming the Government’s devolving of power and funding, he had concerns about the extent of the authority’s links with West Yorkshire and about voting powers on the new Combined Authority. He also questioned how ‘wide local support’, as referred to in paragraph 6.2 of the report, would be defined.
Cabinet Members made reference to the importance of this report to accelerate development of the York Central site and confirmed that the suggestion of cross party working by Cllr Steward earlier in the meeting would be taken up.
External Funding Scrutiny Review Final Report (Minute 57) Cllr Steward raised concerns at the size of today’s Cabinet agenda which he felt would be difficult to discuss in any meaningful detail. He also made reference to the final report of the External Funding Scrutiny Review which he considered to have been too broad in scope.
Travellers Site Provision – Extension of Osbaldwick Site (Minute 69) Cllr Steward made reference to the chairing of the Planning Committee meeting which had recently considered this planning application.
Welcome and Introductions Cllr Chris Steward welcomed everyone to the meeting and introduced himself and Cllr Paul Healey.
Cllr C Steward thanked Laura for coming.
Have Your Say – Local Plan proposals Cllr Steward explained that this was a meeting of the Residents Forum (previously Ward Committee) on the Local Plan proposals.
Cllr Steward explained that whilst his party supported York having a Local Plan the scale of the proposals was not achievable.
Cllr Steward then summarised the proposals which affect Knapton , regarding a show people field bounded by the ring road with 20 pitches.
Cllr Steward invited questions from residents:
Quasi-Judicial/Regulatory Function · Audit and Governance Committee- to add Councillor Brooks as the Conservative member and Vice Chair of the Committee in place of Councillor Steward.
Councillor Steward to be listed as the first Conservative substitute in place of Councillor Brooks.
Council Plan Review and Forward Look Cllr Steward spoke to refer to the list of positive comments and excellent progress made in delivering the Council Plan. He questioned if there were any instances when things could have been done better?
Cllr Steward (CS)welcomed everyone to the meeting and explained that it was a ward committee meeting. As the majority of residents had come to the meeting regarding the proposals in the Local Plan it was agreed to take this as the first item on the agenda under Have Your Say.
Councillor Steward was in attendance to present the report as a member of the Task Group. He advised that the review had been long running and many issues with staff sickness data had been resolved with the introduction of iTrent .
Cllr Steward, as a Task Group member, outlined the background to the review and information received together with the review findings to date which were set out in the report at paragraphs 2 to 17.
Council Response to Consultation on Police and Crime Plan Cllr Steward confirmed his wholehearted support for the proposed CYC response to consultation on the Police and Crime Plan. His only concern related to Questions 2 and 3 which provided six priorities/options and requested rankings which had not been fully listed but which, if ranked would provide a better response.
The report asked Members to add Councillor Richardson as a substitute to the Conservative place on NYFRA, currently occupied by Councillor Steward.
The report asked Members to agree to the change in view of the timing of the forthcoming meeting of NYFRA on 13 February 2013 which Councillor Steward could not attend, but which he wished to send a substitute to. It was noted that the substitute needed to be first formally approved by Members, and that NYFRA were happy with the arrangement.
Councillor Runciman then moved and Cllr Steward seconded acceptance of the report and it was
“I thank you for your stating your belief that this council's aspiration is the right one, especially so considering Councillor Steward said at the recent Cabinet meeting, and I quote, the Living Wage is the "wrong thing for the council to be doing".
Cllr Steward also made representations in respect of Agenda item 10 (Implementing the Living Wage) highlighting the vague criteria set out in the report for the use of Economic Infrastructure Funding to support the Living Wage. He expressed support for the protection and valuing of staff however he felt that this was not the right time to implement this policy.
Councillor Steward also spoke on Agenda item 9 (Economic Infrastructure Fund – Proposals) particularly the Arts Barge project expressing concern at the proposed funding when budgets were being cut and salt bins left unfilled.
Councillor Steward also spoke in relation to Agenda item 12 (Future Credit Union Arrangements in York) questioning the difficulties encountered as it appeared there had been issues at every level leading to the current situation.
Councillor Steward also spoke in relation to Agenda item 16 (CYC Financial Inclusion Policy and Action Plan) confirming that whilst welcoming the policy and plan he expressed concerns at the large number of initiatives and requested some tangible measurable outcomes. Education was put forward as one of the most useful tools and stress as a major result which required management.
Councillor Runciman then moved and Cllr Steward seconded acceptance of the report and it was
Councillor Steward gave a verbal update on the work of the CCTV Task Group. He explained that the group had met with officers to find out more about the proposed changes to CCTV monitoring when the move took place to West Offices. The task group had noted:
Details of a further five questions received from Cllr Steward also in relation to the Leader’s report were circulated at the meeting.
Details of a further seven questions received for the Cabinet Member from Cllr Steward were also circulated at the meeting.
· Community Safety Overview and Scrutiny Committee-Councillor Healey to be appointed as Vice Chair in place of Councillor Steward.
· Yorkshire Purchasing Organisation (YPO)-replace Councillor Steward with Councillor Barton In addition to the above changes, Officers informed the Committee about an additional request for a change to membership of the East Area Planning Sub-Committee from the Conservative group.
In accordance with Standing Order 7, an e-petition was presented by Cllr Steward on behalf of local residents, calling for the council to commit to freezing York’s council tax when setting the budget for the next financial year.
Residents had the opportunity to talk to Cllr Healey; Cllr Gillies ; Cllr Steward; Stuart Stamper, Halcrow Design Consultants; Tony Clarke, Transport Programme Manager; Richard Wood, Assistant Director for Strategic Planning and Transport : Barry Otley , Treemendous ; Julie Hood, Neighbourhood Management Officer in an informal setting.
Residents had the opportunity to talk to Cllr Gillies ; Cllr Steward; Cllr Healey; Mora Scaife , Neighbourhood Manager, Rachel Stewart, Street Environment Officer, Sue Houghton, Major Development Projects & Initiatives; Tony Clarke, City Strategy Capital Programme Manager, Ricky Watson, Street Lighting Officer and Julie Hood, Neighbourhood Management Officer.
After a full debate, Cllr Galvin moved and Cllr Steward seconded that Option B be approved and the matter referred back to Cabinet for reconsideration, with a recommendation that the decision be deferred for the following reasons:
“I apologise if this was not explained clearly enough but the homeless figure has been affected by the compound nature of a number of changes in housing legislation since the general election in conjunction with the downturn in the economy.” (iii) From Cllr Steward “ The Council Leader criticises changes to housing benefit. Does he believe there should be no changes to housing benefit and/or does he believe all current charges for York council houses are fair?” The Leader replied:
This will affect economic growth.” (iv) From Cllr Steward “The Council Leader declares that free Wi-Fi supports his pledge ... view the full minutes text for item 48.
(ii) From Cllr Steward “ The Cabinet Member refers to the need to save £21 million this year. Is this a saving she views as consultants helping or hindering with and can she say what has been spent on consultants in the current and preceding two years?” The Cabinet Member replied:
( i ) To the Cabinet Leader from Cllr Steward:
Residents had the opportunity to talk to Cllr Steward; Cllr Gillies ; Mora Scaife , Neighbourhood Manager; Julie Hood, Neighbourhood Management Officer; Linda Tester, Older Peoples Advocacy York; John Kennedy, Fairness Commissioner; Nigel Colley, Safer Neighbourhood Team and Rachel Stewart, Street Environment Officer.
Cllr Steward expressed the view that the proposals did not match up with the priorities set out in the draft Council Plan and suggested that Members should be considering three consultation options: to sell the site, to sell part of the site or to do nothing.
Cllr Steward introduced himself to the meeting. The minutes from the last meeting were agreed as the true record.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Steward attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 21 May 2026 | Council | Committee Arrangements, Allocation of Seats and Appointments to the Council Structure and Other Bodies for 2026/27, and Allocation of Council Motions | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Mar 2026 | Council | Motions on Notice (8.51pm) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Feb 2025 | Council | Adoption of the City of York Local Plan (9:21 pm) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Dec 2017 | Council | Civic Announcements and Announcement of Lord Mayor and Sheriff Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Feb 2017 | Council | Civic Announcements and Announcement of Lord Mayor and Sheriff Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Dec 2015 | Council | Civic Announcements | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Mar 2015 | Council | Freedom of the City | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Feb 2015 | Council | Civic Announcements and Announcement of Lord Mayor and Sheriff Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Dec 2014 | Council | Honorary Freeman | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 Dec 2013 | Council | Civic Announcements and Lord Mayor Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Dec 2012 | Council | Civic Announcements and Lord Mayor Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Dec 2011 | Council | Civic Announcements and Lord Mayor Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 6 Oct 2011 | Council | Freedom of the City | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 May 2011 | Council | Formal Business of Council - Allocation to Seats and Appointments to the Executive, Committees and Other Bodies 2011/2012 | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Steward was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 21 of 30 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Steward declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 28 Jan 2026 | Joint Standards Committee - Assessments Sub-Committee, item 23 | Cllr Steward declared his membership of the Campaign for Real Ale, as a personal interest. | |
| 7 Nov 2018 | Children, Education and Communities Policy and Scrutiny Committee, item 25 | Councillor Steward declared a personal non prejudicial interest in agenda item 6 (School Improvement and Ofsted Update on Schools Performance) as a Governor of Rufforth Primary School. | |
| 6 Dec 2017 | Audit and Governance Committee, item 33 | Cllr Steward declared a personal interest as a shareholder in Capita. | |
| 12 Oct 2017 | Local Plan Working Group, item 9 | Councillor Steward declared a personal interest due to his ownership of one share in Sirius Minerals. | |
| 27 Jun 2017 | Local Plan Working Group, item 1 | Members were asked to declare any personal interests not included on the Register of Interests, any prejudicial interests or any disclosable pecuniary interests which they might have in respect of business on the agenda. · Councillor Steward declared a personal interest, that he owns one share in Sirius Minerals. | |
| 26 Jan 2017 | Executive, item 95 | Cllr Steward also declared a personal non prejudicial interest in relation to this item as a Governor of Rufforth School and he also withdrew from the meeting for the discussion and took no part in the voting thereon. | Left the room |
| 13 Oct 2016 | Executive, item 52 | Councillor Steward declared a personal interest in relation to agenda item 11 (Minerals and Waste Joint Plan- Publication Draft – minute 62 refers) as he had previously owned shares in Sirius Minerals and may hold shares in the future. | |
| 10 Oct 2016 | Local Plan Working Group, item 5 | Councillor Steward declared a personal interest, as he had once owned shares in Sirius Minerals and may hold them again in the future. |
Where Councillor Steward sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2011 | 65 | |
| Joint Standards Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2015 | 7 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| People Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Apr 2026 | 6 | |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2025 | 5 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Joint Standards Committee - Assessments Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2026 | 3 | |
| Planning Policy and Local Plan Advisory Group | Committee Member | Jun 2026 | 2 | 17 Dec 2026 |
| Copmanthorpe Ward Committee (Please contact the Communities Team for further information) | Committee Member | Aug 2026 | 1 | |
| Staffing Matters and Urgency Committee | Chair | Mar 2014 | 37 | |
| Executive | Committee Member | Aug 2011 | 35 | |
| Customer and Corporate Services Scrutiny Management Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2011 | 33 | |
| Audit and Governance Committee | Vice-Chair | Jun 2011 | 26 | |
| Corporate Services, Climate Change and Scrutiny Management Committee (Calling In) | Committee Member | Nov 2011 | 26 | |
| Local Plan Working Group | Vice-Chair | Feb 2013 | 17 | |
| Rural West York Ward Committee (Please contact the Communities Team for further information) | Committee Member | Jul 2011 | 12 | |
| Decision Session- Executive Member for Finance and Performance | Committee Member | Dec 2014 | 12 | |
| Communities and Environment Policy and Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Mar 2012 | 10 | |
| Effective Organisation Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Chair | Jun 2011 | 7 | |
| Economic Development and Transport Policy and Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Sep 2011 | 7 | |
| Sickness Absence Management Task Group | Committee Member | Nov 2011 | 7 | |
| Planning Committee A | Committee Member | Jan 2024 | 7 | |
| Children, Education and Communities Policy and Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Aug 2011 | 6 | |
| Community Engagement Task Group | Committee Member | Nov 2012 | 6 | |
| Loans and Grants Scrutiny Review Task Group | Chair | Mar 2013 | 5 | |
| Economy, Place, Access and Transport Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2024 | 5 | |
| Health, Housing and Adult Social Care Policy and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2017 | 4 | |
| Corporate Appeals Panel | Committee Member | Dec 2014 | 2 | |
| Equality Advisory Group | Substitute | Feb 2012 | 1 | |
| Planning Main | Attendee | Oct 2013 | 1 | |
| Health and Wellbeing Board | Attendee | Jan 2014 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny Work Planning Event | Attendee | May 2014 | 1 | |
| Member Support Steering Group | Committee Member | Sep 2014 | 1 | |
| Decision Session - Executive Member for Transport - Expired | Attendee | Dec 2014 | 1 | |
| Executive (Calling-In) | Committee Member | Aug 2017 | 1 | |
| Economy and Place Policy Development Residents Parking Task Group | Committee Member | Jan 2019 | 1 | |
| Economy and Place Policy and Scrutiny Committee | Vice-Chair | Jan 2019 | 1 | |
| Economy and Place Policy Development Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2019 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.