Apologies for Absence
Notification had been received that Councillor Fenton was to substitute for Councillor Ayre.
Every time York's minutes name Councillor Ayre, as the council published it.
Notification had been received that Councillor Fenton was to substitute for Councillor Ayre.
Councillor Widdowson, Opposition Deputy Group Leader, substituted for Councillor Ayre.
Cllr Ayre (Heworth Without Ward Cllr), spoke in objection to the application.
[The meeting adjourned from 5.08pm until 5.12pm] In response to questions from Members, Cllr Ayre explained:
The Lead Call-in Member, Cllr Ayre, addressed the committee, expanding on their reasons for the call-in. He then responded to questions from Members.
Finally, Cllr Ayre summed up and the Executive Member for Housing, Planning and Safter Communities summed up their position.
He also thanked opposition leaders Councillor Nigel Ayre and Councillor Chris Steward for their constructive working relationships, including work on the Community Stadium project.
For Against Abstain Councillor Ayre 1 Councillor Baxter 1 Councillor Clarke 1 Councillor Coles 1 Councillor Crawshaw 1 Councillor Cullwick 1 Councillor Cuthbertson 1 Councillor Douglas 1 Councillor Fenton 1 Councillor Fisher 1 Councillor Healey 1 Councillor Hollyer 1 Councillor Hook 1 Councillor Kent 1 Councillor Kilbane 1 Councillor Knight 1 Councillor Lomas 1 Councillor Mason 1 Councillor Melly 1 Councillor Merrett 1 Councillor Moroney 1 Councillor Myers 1 Councillor Nelson 1 Councillor Nichols 1 Councillor Orrell 1 Councillor Pavlovic 1 Councillor Perrett 1 Councillor Ravilious 1 Councillor Rose 1 Councillor Rowley 1 Councillor Runciman 1 Councillor Smalley 1 Councillor Steels-Walshaw 1 Councillor Steward 1 Councillor Taylor 1 Councillor Waller 1 Councillor Wann 1 Councillor Watson 1 Councillor Waudby 1 Councillor Webb 1 Councillor Wells 1 Councillor Whitcroft 1 Councillor Widdowson 1 Councillor Wilson 1 Totals:
The Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group, Councillor Ayre, wished to place on record his thanks to the outgoing Chief Executive, Ian Floyd, particularly highlighting his work in relation to development of York Community Stadium, one of the largest capital schemes in the city’s history. He also thanked all those involved with contributing their time and expertise to assist the panel, which included, members of the public, young people and partners. The incoming Chief Executive, Richard Webb, had demonstrated enthusiasm, passion and knowledge and would be a huge asset to the city.
Concerning agenda item 5b Spark York, Piccadilly, York [25/01151/FUL], Cllr Ayre noted that he had been Executive Member responsible for the lease of Spark at the time.
Councillor Ayre spoke on the Heworth Without Multi Use Games Area (MUGA) and noted that City of York Council should represent the views of all and has made no attempt to engage with local public or to represent the wishes of the community. He highlighted that many residents were in favour of the scheme progressing.
Supplementary from Councillor Ayre: The government and the York Outer MP have said unequivocally that they have funded the full dualling, and you’re saying there isn’t. How can that not be a failure in communication, when you’re saying completely the opposite?
Councillor Ayre called for a separate vote on the CYC-nominated Director appointment to Explore York Libraries and Archives Mutual Limited.
Councillor Ayre moved, under section 9.3, that members take the extra 30 mins and remove the guillotine, the Chair advised that the deadline had passed to do this.
Councillor Ayre then moved to suspend the Standing Order that referred to the time period within which the guillotine could be suspended, this was seconded by Cllr Healey.
Councillor Nigel Ayre sent a written submission on item 5; this arrived after the deadline for Public Participation but at the Executive Member’s discretion this was taken into consideration in making her decision on the item.
Public Speakers Cllr Ayre, Heworth Without Ward Cllr, spoke in objection to the application. He explained that the site was strategically important for housing and the applicant had made no attempt to strategically masterplan the site. He noted his concerns regarding education with the two schools put forward not suitable due to distance meaning primary school provision was needed on the site.
Cllr Lomas and Cllr Ayre who was substituted by Cllr Widdowson.
Cllr Ayre declared an interest as a member of the Shareholder Committee and could not take part in the consideration of the application for Yorwaste, Harewood Whin, Tinker Lane, Rufforth, York [23/01732/FULM]. There were no further declarations of interest.
[Cllr Ayre left the meeting at 4.34pm]
Cllr Ayre sent his apologies for the meeting and was substituted by Cllr Widdowson.
It was noted that the current Health and Wellbeing Board membership should include Councillor Mason and not Councillor Ayre as noted in the agenda supplement pack and that this modification would not affect the proposed changes to the Terms of Reference.
Response: No Supplementary from Cllr Ayre: I am aware that some councils in West Yorkshire have agreed to uplift all their third sector contracts to offset the national insurance, will that be something that York will do?
Supplementary from Cllr Ayre: How much precisely would that 5% increase raise and how much of that would be offset against increased in contract costs as a result of the National Insurance increases?
Supplementary from Cllr Ayre: Do you agree with my assertion that probably about 2.5% of the council tax increase will go directly on the national insurance cost of contracts?
Supplementary from Cllr Ayre: Isn’t it the case that elsewhere in your report you claim to dislike a nasty brand of politics, yet your response demonstrates that this is in fact the way you like to do business?
Cllr Ayre: The Deputy Leader is accusing people in this chamber of lying. That is not true, and is defamatory.
Members considered the minutes of the Committees previous meeting and agreed to clarify within the minutes that Cllr Ayre currently worked for a for a Healthwatch contract provider in Bradford.
From Cllr Ayre : Why didn’t you bring a constitutional change to yesterday’s Audit and Governance Committee to have it taken out.
[7.51 pm, Cllr Ayre left the meeting; 7.53 pm, Cllr Widdowson left the meeting.] The Finance Manager, the Head of Business Intelligence and the responded to questions on housing benefit, coroner related pressures and the number of full time equivalents.
Cllr Ayre declared that he had a personal interest in relation to agenda item 5 Procurement of Healthwatch York, as he works for a Healthwatch contract provider in Bradford.
[Cllr Ayre left the meeting for this item] The Director of Customer & Communities introduced the report and outlined the recommendations to reprocure the City of York Council’s Healthwatch York contract for a maximum 4 year value of £462,440. It was highlighted that a 4 year contract would offer stability for the contract holder and assist in staff recruitment.
Supplementary from Cllr Ayre: Does your group believe that it is democratic to remove members rights to ask questions to the Executive about important issues that do not arise from reports to council?
Response: Cllr Ayre you are very welcome to ask me any questions at any time and we will answer them. It’s about making meetings business like and less of a staged performance.
Supplementary from Cllr Ayre: On your pledge, where on the leaflet are the words mobilise the city?
Supplementary from Cllr Ayre : Will you commit to maintaining this level of spending and rule out cuts to the road maintenance budget?
Public Speakers Cllr Nigel Ayre, spoke as Ward Councillor and recommended that improvements should be made to the parking arrangements by amendment of the traffic conditions. He raised concerns regarding the future proofing of the proposed school buildings and noted that approximately an additional 250 places would be required within the next five years. Finally, he requested that Members gave consideration to the management of construction traffic.
On the same item, Cllr Ayre noted that his partner was a blue badge holder.
Cllr Ayre moved the officer recommendation to approve the application, subject to the conditions in the report, the s106 recommendations, the amendments and additional conditions contained within the update, the additional monitoring fee of £14,000, and the additional highway works condition and the revision of the management fee for the affordable housing as discussed during the meeting.
Following debate, Cllr Steward proposed the officer recommendation to refuse the application, this was seconded by Cllr Ayre. Following a vote, with eight Members in favour and one against, it was;
In relation to minute 24, Cllr Ayre requested that the resolution be amended to make reference to Annex A, as referred to and discussed at the meeting, as follows:
Supplementary from Cllr Ayre: Can you not articulate now what you think the impact will be in winter.
Cllr Ayre also declared a personal interest in these items, as a parent of a child attending a primary school that might be affected by the proposals.
Supplementary from Cllr Ayre : Would ask that you answer the question which was put.
Supplementary 2 from Cllr Ayre:
Reason: In order to alter the council’s existing approved budget to reflect the priorities of the council’s new administration.” Cllr Ayre then moved, and Cllr Healey seconded, an amendment to the proposal, as follows:
Cllr Ayre noted that he was a member of the enterprise car club. No further interests were declared.
Councillor Cullwick as Lord Mayor moved, Councillor Ayre seconded, and Council unanimously
A written report was received from Cllr Ayre, the Executive Member for Finance and Major Projects. No questions were put on the report, as the guillotine had fallen.
You could ask Cllr Ayre later, as he will be more sighted on the Local Plan.
Cllr Fisher declared a non prejudicial interest in that item as he knew the surgeon at the hospital and Cllr Ayre also declared an non prejudicial interest in that item following a consultancy at the hospital. No further interests were declared.
a) In respect of Agenda Item 7 (Minute 80 refers), Cllr Ayre stated he was employed by Healthwatch Bradford, but had had no involvement with developments in Humber Coast & Vale.
This was seconded by Cllr Ayre. During debate a number of views were expressed, during which the Chair clarified that the Neighbourhood Plan was part of the development plan for the area. A vote was taken with 8 Members in favour, 5 against and 2 abstentions.
Question to Cllr Ayre, Executive Member for Finance & Performance From Cllr Hollyer:
Changes to the directors of Veritau Limited were reported: Debbie Mitchell had replaced Ian Floyd as a director and Cllr Waller had replaced Cllr Ayre.
Question to Cllr Ayre, Executive Member for Finance & Performance From Cllr Fenton: With regard to recent press reports about significant changes to the Coney Street area, including a riverside walkway and bridge, can you share more information about this?
Cllr Ayre proposed an amended condition that if the building was removed from education/agricultural use for 18 months it would be demolished.
Cllr Ayre proposed approval with the above amended condition seconded by Cllr Doughty. A vote was taken with 13 for and one against.
On conclusion of the question and answer session, the Lord Mayor moved, and Cllr Ayre seconded, the following recommendations contained in paragraph 4 of the report of the COO:
Cllr Ayre noted that this had been addressed at previous meetings.
It is proposed that Council delegate implementation of the scheme to the Chief Operating Officer, in consultation with the Leader.” Cllr Ayre then moved, and Cllr D’Agorne seconded, an amendment to the motion, as follows:
Shareholders Committee Cllr Widdowson to replace Cllr Ayre as the chair of the Shareholders Committee.
Noting the link between the arrangements between the sale of the land and the Community Stadium, Cllr Ayre in his capacity as Executive Member for Finance and Performance declared an interest as did Cllr D’Agorne , as Executive Member for Transport declared an interest and both undertook to not take part in debate on the application.
Cllr Ayre and Cllr D’Agorne withdrew from the meeting for the consideration of this application.
Cllr Ayre and Cllr D’Agorne returned to the meeting for the consideration of this application.
After debate, which centred around the loss of staff parking and traffic congestion issues, Cllr Kilbane moved, and Cllr Ayre seconded, that the application be approved, subject to the amendments reported by Officers and the re-wording of Condition 9. In accordance with revised Standing Orders, a named vote was taken, with the following result:
Local Plan · From Cllr Warters - did the Leader share the pride expressed by Cllr Ayre in the Plan, in view of the effect of inward immigration on the green belt and infrastructure of the city?
The Leader replied that he endorsed the comments of Cllr Ayre , and that the Plan provided the right balance between protecting the city and the green belt and providing economic opportunities and housing.
· From Cllr Ayre (supplementary) – would it not have been remiss of him to exclude mention of the Hub, since it was part of York Explore libraries and thus within his portfolio?
Cllr Ayre declared a prejudicial interest in Agenda Item 11 (Yorkshire Purchasing Organisation), as a member of YPO Procurement Holdings Ltd. He left the room during consideration of that item and took no part in the discussion or decision thereon.
(i) To Cllr Ayre , Executive Member for Finance & Performance:
No additional interests were declared at this stage; however Cllr Ayre , during consideration of Agenda Item 7 (Future Libraries Investment Programme) declared a personal interest in that item as the company he worked for was a tenant of Burnholme Library.
Cllr Ayre spoke on matters within the Committee’s remit, and with reference to Agenda Item 4 (Monitoring Report on Complaints Received). He detailed the impact on himself and his family of the delay in resolving a standards complaint made against him and urged Members to take steps to ensure this situation did not arise again.
Cllr Ayre declared a personal, and possibly prejudicial, interest in Agenda Item 9 (The Provision of School Place and Allocation of School Capital Budgets 2019-2023 to Address Secondary School Place Pressures), as his daughter attended one of the schools receiving funding. He left the room during consideration of that item and took no part in the debate or decision thereon.
To Cllr Ayre , Executive Member for Finance & Performance · From Cllr Waudby – Bootham Park Hospital Update · From Cllr Warters – Community Stadium delays · From Cllr Orrell - £10 parking charge at Community Stadium car park ii.
Council received a written report from Councillor Ayre , Executive Member for Finance and Performance.
Cllr Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest as a member of the Civil Service Sports Club. No further interests were declared.
Cllr Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest in agenda item 4b [Pilcher Homes Tower House, Askham Fields Lane, Askham Bryan, York [19/00454/FUL] through his employment with Healthwatch York.
Shareholder Committee To appoint Councillor Ayre as the Liberal Democrat member and Chair.
Councillor Ayre moved and Councillor Barnes seconded and the Council unanimously
He also noted the written representations received from Cllr Ayre, Ward Member for Heworth Without, welcoming the proposals to trial vehicle activated speed indicator devices in the city and particularly his ward, and from residents of Wetherby Road expressing their concerns regarding speeding on Wetherby Road.
Cllr Ayre declared a personal interest in Agenda Item 6 (Delivering Improved Sport and Active Leisure Facilities at Burnholme ), as his son played for one of the football clubs that regularly used the current facilities. He took no part in the discussions or decision on the item.
Councillor Ayre declared an interest in Item 4a (Minute Item 11) as the current Executive Member for Culture, Leisure and Tourism. He also left the meeting for this item.
Cllr Ayre declared an interest as the head of a charity. No further interests were declared.
(Councillor Ayre left the meeting prior to the vote on this motion) There being no appointment made to the position of Executive Leader at the meeting, the Deputy Leader, Councillor Waller, immediately assumed the position of Acting Leader and thereby presented the Executive’s budget proposals.
Cllr Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest in item 4g as he works for Healthwatch York.
Members were advised that page 4 or the agenda papers ( Para 3 (ii) Outside Bodies, third paragraph) should read “Councillor Reid to replace Councillor Ayre” and not “....to replace Cllr Aspden” as stated in agenda papers, and that York and District Citizens Advice Bureau should not be included in this list of outside bodies as this appointment was not related to the Executive portfolio area therefore Cllr Ayre would remain in this appointment. The committee then considered the following requests with regard to committees and outside bodies:
· Customer and Corporate Services Scrutiny Management Committee To appoint Cllr Ayre to replace Cllr Reid · Economy & Place Scrutiny Committee To appoint Cllr Aspden to replace Cllr Reid · Main Planning Committee To appoint Cllr Ayre as Chair of the committee;
· York BID · Leeds City Region LEP Leaders Board · West Yorkshire Combined Authority · Local Government North Yorkshire and York (as a substitute) · York, North Yorkshire and East Riding LEP Board (as a substitute) · Councillor Reid to replace Councillor Ayre on the following outside bodies:
Councillor Ayre , Ward Member, spoke in objection to the application due to loss of amenity. He also stated that there needed to be significant landscaping to the area, should Members be minded to approve the application.
In response to concerns as to the recommendations put forward by the LPWG, Councillor Ayre, Chair of the LPWG, clarified that the Group had not amended any recommendations, they had been asked to consider and put forward their own recommendations.
In conclusion, Councillor Ayre referred to York’s population, housing and affordability challenges and stated that ... view the full minutes text for item 24.
Councillor Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest in plans item 3a (Site of 17-21 Picadilly , York) as he had a professional relationship with one of the registered speakers through his work with Healthwatch North Yorkshire.
Councillor Ayre then moved and Councillor Cuthbertson seconded refusal of the application on the grounds set out in the Officers report and on being put to the vote, the motion was lost.
Councillor Galvin moved, and Councillor Ayre seconded, a motion to defer the application in order that the applicant be given additional time to put together stronger financial reasons to support very special circumstances.
(iii) The removal of Councillor Ayre as the substitute representative on the Mental Health and Learning Disabilities Partnership Board, as substitute Members are no longer required.
· Cllr D Myers – examples of improved standards and better outcomes across the city following receipt of lower funding · Cllr D Myers – request for specifics which resulted in the same or better outcomes as reported by the Executive Member (v) To Cllr Ayre , Executive Member for Culture, Leisure and Tourism:
Cllr Ayre declared a personal interest in relation to agenda item 6a ( Burnholme Health and Wellbeing Campus: Key Decisions) as his daughter attended the on site Nursery.
Cllr Ayre declared a personal pecuniary interest in relation to agenda item 6 ( Bootham Park Hospital Scrutiny Review Final Report) owing to his employment as an NHS Manager for North Yorkshire County Council and he left the meeting during the discussion and voting thereon.
· Cllr Williams – York Civic Trust and litter in the city · Cllr Williams – Cllr Waller’s comments in relation to the Civic Trust’s Annual report and litter · Cllr D’Agorne – Civic Trust discussions and recycling facilities in the city · Cllr N Barnes –cuts to front line street cleaning services and Ward Committee funding · Cllr Ayre – improvements in street cleaning in the Heworth Ward following devolved ward budgets · Cllr N Barnes –wards with low community participation and engagement leading to a two tier system · Cllr D Myers – waste budget overspending and future controls · Cllr Levene – structure of waste budget and devolved Ward budgets · Cllr D Myers – Pride in York fund and cuts to ground maintenance budget (Cllr Ayre’s portfolio) (ii) To Cllr Ayre, Executive Member for Leisure, Culture and Tourism:
Councillor Ayre declared an interest in plans item 4b (Oliver House, Bishophill Junior) as he had been a member of the Executive when the sale of land was agreed and was still a member of the Executive. He stated that he did not feel comfortable taking part in the decision and left the table and took no part in the discussion or vote on this item.
· Cllr Ayre , on behalf of 34 local residents in the Ashley Park Road area, calling on the Council to have the lamp post outside 19 Ashley Park Road moved from its current position due to safety concerns.
(i) To Cllr Ayre, Executive Member for Culture, Leisure and Tourism:
Copies of the draft minutes and recommendations of the Local Plan Working Group (LPWG) from their meeting held on 27 June were circulated and the Chair, Cllr Ayre confirmed the Plan as robust and meeting the housing and employment needs of the city.
The Executive Member took into consideration a written representation, submitted by Councillor Ayre prior to the meeting. This was a petition which called for the removal of a lamp post from its current location due to safety concerns. Officers stated that they would bring a report back to a future meeting regarding the petition.
Councillor Ayre declared an interest in Plans list item 3a (Huntington Stadium, Jockey Lane, Huntington) as Executive Member for Culture, Leisure and Tourism with responsibility for delivering the project. He took no part in the debate or vote on this application.
Councillor Ayre declared a personal interest in relation to agenda item 5 – Delivery of Community Facilities at the Burnholme Health and Wellbeing Campus (minute 149 refers) as his daughter attended Burnholme School.
· Cllr Kramm – steps to become the Greenest City in the North · Cllr Galvin – whether any unspent ward funding would be clawed back if unused at the end of the financial year · Cllr Galvin – purpose of the Deputy Leader’s report · Cllr Gates – additional information on work undertaken to increase apprenticeships · Cllr Kramm – Ward budgets for the city centre wards and their use for the upkeep of bowling greens, flower displays at the railway station/West Offices, war memorials etc · Cllr Ayre – possible partnership assistance/BID funding for upkeep of above ward areas Cllr Aspden responded directly to all the questions put to him.
Councillor Nigel Ayre welcomes the group and the schedule for the meeting is outlined.
(ii) Cllr Ayre on behalf of 49 residents in the Langdale Avenue and Rydal Avenue area regarding the state of nearby roads and calling on the Council to work with residents to improve the roads.
Council received a written report from Councillor Ayre , Executive Member for Culture, Leisure and Tourism, as set out in the agenda papers at pages 33 to 38.
Members were then invited to question Cllr Ayre on his report and questions were received from the floor from the following Members in relation to the subjects listed:
· Cllr Gunnell – assurances regarding the budgetary commitment for the Community Stadium · Cllr Warters –when the changes in the retail/leisure offer at the Community Stadium would be brought back to Members · Cllr Taylor – reputational damage to CYC/York Museums Trust regarding resident access to the Art Gallery · Cllr S Barnes – omission of Yearsley Pool and the Pool’s funding from the Executive Member’s report · Cllr Kramm – Plans to celebrate the Diamond Anniversary of York’s twinning with Münster Cllr Ayre responded directly to all the questions put to him
Councillor Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest in respect of Agenda item 6 – Castlegate - Update, as the organisation he worked for were in ongoing discussions with Castlegate staff . He left the room and took no part in the discussion and voting thereon.
Councillor Ayre declared a personal interest in agenda item 4b as his family use one of the surgeries in the Heslington area which could be affected by the opening of a new surgery at the University.
As Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee, Councillor Ayre firstly moved, and Cllr Brooks seconded, the following recommendation, in respect of proposed changes to the Council’s Contract Procedure Rules contained in Minute 74 of the Audit and Governance Committee meeting held on 11 February 2015:
It became conclusive that the council could not proceed with the procurement process when officers brought a report to cabinet in March, which clearly set out the affordability gap (of £1.5 million year on year) between the funding that was allocated to the project and the best offer on the table from any of the potential bidders.” (iv) To the Cabinet Leader (including Finance & Performance) from Cllr Ayre :
· Councillor Ayre declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in respect of agenda item 9 (LGA Peer Review) by virtue of his employment. He stated that he would withdraw from the meeting for this item.
[Councillor Ayre withdrew from the meeting for this item.
(ii) From Cllr Ayre “What percentage of those in work are in part-time employment and how does this compare to the national average?” The Leader replied:
(ii) From Cllr Ayre “Does the Cabinet Member agree with the conclusions drawn by external auditors that her predecessor's EPH project saw £600,000 of planned savings not delivered because "assumptions were flawed", "savings were double counted", "there was no effective challenge of assumptions" and the project suffered as "members made changes"?” Reply:
a. immediately end the trial closure of Lendal Bridge b. publicly admit that the trial has been botched and to apologise for this c. immediately publish the raw data on the trial ahead of their detailed evaluation report d. commit to consulting with residents and local businesses before bringing forward any future plans for Lendal Bridge.” The first amendment was proposed by Councillor Aspden and seconded by Councillor Ayre as follows:
Councillor Ayre also addressed the meeting, on behalf of the Calling-In members, reiterating that any consultation would be uninformed without the additional information requested.
Aspden will know from his membership of the YEP Board, the business community have expressed their support for the city of York being represented at MIPIM and are firmly behind this initiative.” (iii) To the Cabinet Leader from Cllr Ayre :
The representations made by at the hearing by Councillor Ayre, Councillor Boyce and [name removed] and by local residents. Issues raised included:
Councillor Ayre declared two personal interests in the remit of the committee. He was an employee of York MIND and sat on the Mental Health and Learning Disabilities Board (which sits under the Health and Wellbeing Board).
(i) From Cllr Ayre “Can the Cabinet Leader please provide evidence of the following: how many residents have been brought out of poverty as a result of City of York Council “investing in infrastructure and bringing developments forward” and how many residents have been brought off benefits and into well-paid work as a result of City of York Council “investing in infrastructure and bringing developments forward”? Could he break these down by the number of residents attributed to each scheme since 2011.” The Leader replied:
Councillor Ayre proposed and Councillor Brooks seconded that the draft scheme be amended to remove paragraph (c) under the section on petitions not covered by the scheme (i.e. respond to a public consultation organised by the Council). On being put to the vote the motion was lost.
Councillor Ayre then proposed and Councillor Brooks seconded that the draft scheme be amended to reinstate the provision to petition to call officers to account. On being put to the vote the motion was lost.
These figures were released by the ONS in early September.” (iv) From Cllr Ayre “Has the council made compliance with the living wage a requirement of all services currently being outsourced?” The Leader replied:
(i) From Cllr Ayre “What business case was produced to avoid duplicating ICT provision already provided by private operators?” Cabinet Member replied:
(i) To the Cabinet Leader from Cllr Ayre:
Councillor Ayre addressed the meeting on behalf of the Calling-In members confirming the main reason for call in were concerns that the requirements of the Single Equality Act had not been incorporated in to this report. Although in agreement with much of the footstreets proposals, it was the lack of an Equality Impact Assessment and consultation.
Representations were received from the Ward Member, Councillor Ayre . He felt that he could not support the proposals detailed in the Officer’s report because he felt that there had not been a necessary amount of consultation with local residents.
Further representations were received from Councillor Ayre . He felt that the proposals for Davygate were particularly controversial given that there would be a significant reduction in disabled car parking spaces. He requested information regarding whether and what consultation had taken place with disability groups, and if feedback had been received.
ii) From Cllr Ayre :
Councillor Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest in relation to Plans item 4g (Creepy Crawlies, The Arena, Clifton Gate Business Park, Wigginton Road, York 12/02459/FUL) as his son and daughter were occasional users of the site.
Member Support Steering Group (Substitute) Replace Cllr Jeffries with Cllr Boyce Outside Bodies Association for Public Service Excellence (APSE) Replace Cllr Williams with Cllr Levene Foxwood Community Centre Replace Cllr Jeffries with Cllr Burton North Yorkshire Fire & Rescue Authority Replace Cllr Jeffries with Councillor Barnes SNAPPY Replace Cllr Jeffries with Cllr Fitzpatrick Yorkshire Museums Trust Replace Cllr Ayre with Cllr Cuthbertson
Councillor Ayre declared a personal interest as the Chair of Derwenthorpe Transport Sub Committee.
Councillor Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest in item 4a ( Derwenthorpe ) as the Chair of Transport on Derwenthorpe Partnership Forum.
At meetings of the internationalisation group I have set up, your Group Leader Councillor Gillies has agreed with me on this.” (ii) From Cllr Ayre “How much money does he believe taxpayers should be paying for gifts?” The Leader replied:
I do not agree with the Liberal Democrats calling for council taxpayers’ money to fund these redundant posts.” (v) From Cllr Ayre “Can the Leader state whether he believes the shift from FTR to ... view the full minutes text for item 69.
Councillor Ayre confirmed that there were a number of good ideas in the new approach however this appeared to be a flawed policy which would damage the city and its residents. He questioned how the Council for Voluntary Service could undertake additional work with reduced funding and similarly with staffing reductions how would any proposals be delivered. Reductions in the number of ward meetings however would not assist residents in attending meetings and he pointed out that the report failed ... view the full minutes text for item 48.
Councillor Ayre made representations to the Cabinet Member and made comments about the consultation on the Council budget and proposed funding cuts.
Cllr Nigel Ayre welcomed everyone to the meeting.
Cllr Nigel Ayre reported on the progress of Local Improvement Schemes.
Cllr Ayre addressed the meeting on behalf of the Calling-In Members. He expanded on the reasons given for the call-in pointing out that the procurement criteria was crucial in helping shape the facilitates provided at the stadium by the successful bidder. He expressed concern that this was a community stadium but with no input from the public and requested the provision of a more detailed report to include details of the weighting given to the points listed at paragraph 4 of the report.
Councillor Ayre also spoke and stated that he felt that he could not support the recommendations in the Officer’s report because the specific award criteria for successful operators had not been clarified, in particular, there had no been no indication of the weightings used in the assessment of bids. He felt that there needed to be a further report to Cabinet detailing how bids would be assessed. He also mentioned that if a private gym was successful at bidding for a specific leisure facility that there was a possibility that usage fees might rise and could be unaffordable to most users.
Councillor Ayre spoke in respect of agenda item 4 – “Refresh of the Council’s Events Protocol”. He stated that there had been a failure to consult with residents on this issue and that significant issues had arisen since the previous protocol had been implemented. He raised particular concerns regarding the reclassification of Rawcliffe Country Park and at the decision to remove the buffer zone.
Councillor Ayre urged that meaningful consultation take place with residents.
Councillor Ayre also spoke in respect of agenda item 6 – “Developing the Explore Vision in the Library Service”. He stated that he welcomed the planned consultation but regretted the delays that had occurred in the consultation and the costs incurred because of this.
I suspect in the coming weeks.” (iii) From Cllr Ayre “Has the Cabinet Leader considered the impact that the proposed budget changes will have on next year’s budget?” The Leader replied:
(iii) To the Cabinet Leader, from Cllr Ayre “Does the Leader believe the workload he inherited from his predecessor was more than he could manage?” Reply Not at all, but I think my predecessor did not handle his workload well. If he had done so, he may not have lost his seat at the local elections.
I believe what Councillor Ayre is alluding to is that by sticking to a Labour manifesto pledge of creating a new Cabinet Member for Crime and Anti-Social Behaviour, that this reduces the remit of the Council Leader.
Representations were heard from Councillor Ayre, as Ward Member. He considered the application contravened policies GP1 and GP10 of the Local Plan, and a number of other policies, because he felt that the quality of life for the residents was not being protected. This was because the boundary treatment between the site and the adjacent properties would not protect the neighbouring properties from noise and disturbance.
Councillor Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest in relation to Plans Item 4a (6-18 Hull Road, York 11/00050/OUTM) as a member of the Civil Service Cricket Club at the Outgang, Heslington.
Councillor Ayre made representations, as the Ward member, in relation to a residents survey undertaken in the Stockton Lane area in relation to potholes and speed enforcement on this road. He understood that engineering works could not take place until capital funding was available however as work was in progress on Stockton Lane he requested that these issues could be addressed at the same time.
Name Description of Interest Cllr Alexander - Member of the GMB - Holder of a free parking pass Cllr Aspden Member of York Credit Union Cllr Ayre - Council-appointed nominee on Board of York CVS - Council-appointed nominee on Board of York CAB Cllr Boyce - Employee of health-related charity in receipt of grant - Trustee of anther health-related charity in receipt of grant - Mother receives paid for home care from CYC Cllr Crisp - Make regular donations to Oxfam, British Red Cross, MacMillan Cancer Research, Salvation Army - Trustee of RLS-UK / Ekbom Support Group - Director of York Tourism Partnership ‘Visit York’ Cllr D’Agorne Employed as Careers Adviser at York College Cllr Fraser - Member of retired sections of UNISON and Unite (TGWU / Acts sections) - Non-voting participating observer (CYC appointed) on York CVS Trustees - CYC appointed Governor of York Teaching Hospitals Foundation Trust - Resident in an area covered by a Respark Scheme Cllr Funnell - Chair of Friends of St Nicholas Fields Management Committee - Trustee of York CVS - Member of Older People’s Assembly - Governor of Burnholme Community College - Member of Scarcroft Allotments Committee - Holder of a Residents’ Parking permit - Holder of a Senior Citizens’ bus pass Cllr Gunnell - Trustee of York Playspace -
Cllr Ayre – matters relating to the CAB, as a Trustee of York CAB Cllr Galloway – matters relating to benefits for the over-60s, as a person over the age of 60 Cllr Morley - matters relating to benefits for the over-60s, as a person over the age of 60, matters relating to allotments, as an allotment holder and matters relating to fostering allowances Cllr Reid – matters relating to schools, as a school governor Cllr Runciman - matters relating to schools, as a school governor Cllr Waller - matters relating to schools, as a school governor, and matters relating to allotments, as an allotment holder.
Cllr Brooks and Cllr Ayre explained that it would benefit young people of the ward.
Councillor Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest in relation to Plans items 4a (6-18 Hull Road, York) and 4b (32 Lawrence Street, York) as Executive Member for Leisure, Culture and Social Inclusion.
The Executive Member reported receipt of late representations from Councillor Ayre in which he raised strong objections, on behalf of Heworth Without residents, to proposed changes to the No. 13 bus route. He asked First to reconsider their decision or to work with the authority towards finding an alternative solution.
A written report was received from Cllr Nigel Ayre, the Executive Member for Leisure, Culture & Social Inclusion.
Consultations will take place following approval in principle of the scheme. 6.6 Cllr Ayre was asked if he will take into account the feedback from Heworth Without Parish Council about the feasibility study into providing a cycle lane on Stockton Lane (scheme ref. DHO-10-11). He replied in the affirmative. 6.7 There being no further questions, Cllrs.
“Can the Executive Leader please tell Council how many meetings he has had with the Council's Information Management and E-Government Champion to specifically discuss Information Management and E-Government since being in the position?” Reply “It will come as no surprise to say that I see Cllr Ayre frequently and have had a number of meetings throughout the time that Cllr Ayre has been the Council’s Information Management and E-Government Champion to discuss issues relating to the council’s electronic communication, data security, and implications of government legislation.
2.1 Chair, Cllr Nigel Ayre, welcomed residents to the meeting and the minutes of the previous meeting were agreed and signed.
Councillor Ayre and Councillor Crisp were welcomed to their first meeting as Chair and Vice-Chair respectively.
The Group were informed that Councillor Ayre and Councillor Crisp would be taking over from Councillor Vassie and Councillor Looker as Chair and Vice-Chair respectively, subject to full Council approval expected the following week.
1.1 Local residents had an opportunity to speak with Cllr Jonathan Morley, Cllr Jenny Brooks, Cllr Nigel Ayre, Angus Young (Street Environment), Rachel Smith (Children and Young People’s Services), the Safer Neighbourhoods Team, Graham Titchener (Cycling City), Russ Broadbent (Parking Services) and Zoe Burns, Ginnie Shaw & Toby Knight from the Neighbourhood Management Unit.
(i) A petition presented by Cllr King, on behalf of residents of Rowntree Avenue, asking the Council to consider installing lay-by parking in their street. 1 (ii) A petition presented by Cllr Ayre, on behalf of local residents asking for safer crossing measures at Stockton Lane, Hempland Lane and Woodlands Grove. 2 (iii) A petition presented by Cllr Fraser, on behalf of traders in Micklegate, calling for a review of the Council’s policies on A-boards. 3 (iv) A petition presented by Cllr Simpson-Laing, on behalf of local residents, asking the Council to ensure that open space and tennis courts at the old Manor School be made available for public use pending development of the site. 4 (v) A petition presented by Cllr Potter, on behalf of York residents, calling on the Council to introduce a 20 mph speed limit throughout the City in residential areas. 5 (vi) A petition presented by Cllr Bowgett, on behalf of residents of Acomb and Holgate, calling on the Council to ensure that the streets in their areas were repaired so they were safe.
RESOLVED That Councillor Ayre be elected as of the meeting.
1.1 Local Residents had the opportunity to speak to Cllr Nigel Ayre, Cllr Jonathan Morley, Cllr Jenny Brooks, Angus Young (Street Environment Officer), The Safer Neighbourhoods Policing Team and David Slater (Neighbourhood Management Officer) 1.2 Residents had the opportunity to find out more about Without Walls – York’s Sustainable Community Strategy, the Young People’s Plan, Health Walks in York and becoming a member of the NHS Foundation Trust.
2.1 Cllr Nigel Ayre welcomed residents to the meeting.
Councillor Ayre to advise the resident how to do this.
Response was that Councillor Nigel Ayre has received a petition from Friends of Hempland School which will be put forward at the relevant council meeting.
The Chair confirmed that Cllr Ayre and himself had met Amanda Brown from the NYYPCT regarding the information she had produced on dentists and waiting lists at the Committee’s last meeting. He stated that she was examining the PCT’s reporting systems, which produced the information with a view to reporting back to the Committee.
On average there is a 1 week difference between those homes relet following the award and those that did not qualify.” (ii) From Councillor Ayre “Would the Executive Member outline progress on the choice based lettings scheme?” Reply “There have been 124 choice based lettings on hard to let properties since the scheme started.
Councillor Ayre introduced the meeting. The minutes of the last meeting were approved by the ward committee. There were no questions regarding the minutes.
Councillor Ayre announced that the provisional priority local improvement scheme list published in Your Ward was the decision of the ward committee. All schemes included are subject to feasibility, legality and budget availability. ii.
Councillor Ayre asked if there were any questions regarding the schemes list.
There is a problem with Yorkshire Water that is being looked into by Councillor Ayre.
At the start of the meeting the Chair clarified that all parties would be happy for Councillor Ayre to stay for the duration of the proceedings for training purposes. It was noted that he would not take part in any discussions. All parties were in agreement that he could stay.
At the start of the meeting the Chair clarified that all parties would be happy for Councillor Ayre to stay for the duration of the proceedings for training purposes. It was noted that he would not take part in any discussions. All parties were in agreement that he could stay.
· The Chair asked if all parties were happy for Councillor Ayre to remain in the room during the decision making process (for training purposes). All parties agreed that they were happy with this.
It was explained that Councillor Bill Bennett passed away in July and Councillor Nigel Ayre was elected as ward councillor for Heworth Without in the September by-elections.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Ayre attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 21 May 2026 | Council | Committee Arrangements, Allocation of Seats and Appointments to the Council Structure and Other Bodies for 2026/27, and Allocation of Council Motions | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Mar 2026 | Council | Motions on Notice (8.51pm) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Jan 2026 | Corporate Scrutiny Committee | Draft Report of the Budget and Medium-Term Financial Strategy Task and Finish Group (5.33 pm) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Feb 2025 | Council | Adoption of the City of York Local Plan (9:21 pm) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Feb 2017 | Council | Civic Announcements and Announcement of Lord Mayor and Sheriff Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Dec 2015 | Council | Civic Announcements | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Mar 2015 | Council | Freedom of the City | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Feb 2015 | Council | Civic Announcements and Announcement of Lord Mayor and Sheriff Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Dec 2014 | Council | Honorary Freeman | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 Dec 2013 | Council | Civic Announcements and Lord Mayor Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Dec 2012 | Council | Civic Announcements and Lord Mayor Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 May 2012 | Council | Formal Business of Council - Allocation to Seats and Appointments to the Council Structure and Outside Bodies 2012/13 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Dec 2011 | Council | Civic Announcements and Lord Mayor Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 6 Oct 2011 | Council | Freedom of the City | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 May 2011 | Council | Formal Business of Council - Allocation to Seats and Appointments to the Executive, Committees and Other Bodies 2011/2012 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 7 Apr 2011 | Council | Urgent Motion - World Heritage Site Bid | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 9 Dec 2010 | Council | Honorary Freeman | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 9 Dec 2010 | Council | Civic Announcements and Lord Mayor Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Apr 2010 | Council | Urgent Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 4 Feb 2010 | Council | Civic Announcements and Lord Mayor Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 Dec 2009 | Council | Honorary Freeman | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 Dec 2009 | Council | Freedom of Entry to the City | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Apr 2009 | Council | Urgent Motion - Job Losses at Norwich Union | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Apr 2009 | Council | Urgent Motion - Job Losses at Norwich Union | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jan 2009 | Council | Honorary Freemen | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jan 2009 | Council | Civic Announcements and Lord Mayor Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jan 2009 | Council | Scrutiny - Report of the Chair of the Scrutiny Management Committee | Lost | 21 for, 24 against, 1 abstained | |
| 22 Jan 2009 | Council | Scrutiny - Report of the Chair of the Scrutiny Management Committee | Carried | 24 for, 21 against | |
| 10 Apr 2008 | Council | Report of Executive Leader and Executive Recommendations | Lost | 20 for, 20 against | |
| 24 Jan 2008 | Council | Civic Announcements, Lord Mayor Elect and Honorary Recorder of York | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jan 2008 | Council | Civic Announcements, Lord Mayor Elect and Honorary Recorder of York | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Nov 2007 | Council | Honorary Alderman and Honorary Freeman | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Ayre was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 17 of 30 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Ayre declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 Mar 2025 | Planning Committee A, item 154 | Cllr Ayre declared an interest as a member of the Shareholder Committee and could not take part in the consideration of the application for Yorwaste, Harewood Whin, Tinker Lane, Rufforth, York [23/01732/FULM]. There were no further declarations of interest. | Took no part |
| 14 Mar 2024 | Executive, item 102 | Cllr Ayre declared that he had a personal interest in relation to agenda item 5 Procurement of Healthwatch York, as he works for a Healthwatch contract provider in Bradford. | |
| 20 Jul 2023 | Council, item 15 | Cllr Ayre also declared a personal interest in these items, as a parent of a child attending a primary school that might be affected by the proposals. | |
| 9 Jun 2022 | Planning Committee A, item 1 | Cllr Fisher declared a non prejudicial interest in that item as he knew the surgeon at the hospital and Cllr Ayre also declared an non prejudicial interest in that item following a consultancy at the hospital. No further interests were declared. | |
| 28 Nov 2019 | Executive, item 62 | Cllr Ayre declared a prejudicial interest in Agenda Item 11 (Yorkshire Purchasing Organisation), as a member of YPO Procurement Holdings Ltd. He left the room during consideration of that item and took no part in the discussion or decision thereon. | Left the room |
| 18 Jul 2019 | Executive, item 10 | Cllr Ayre declared a personal, and possibly prejudicial, interest in Agenda Item 9 (The Provision of School Place and Allocation of School Capital Budgets 2019-2023 to Address Secondary School Place Pressures), as his daughter attended one of the schools receiving funding. He left the room during consideration of that item and took no part in the debate or decision thereon. | Left the room |
| 2 Jul 2019 | Planning Main, item 9 | Cllr Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest as a member of the Civil Service Sports Club. No further interests were declared. | |
| 13 Jun 2019 | Planning Main, item 1 | Cllr Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest in agenda item 4b [Pilcher Homes Tower House, Askham Fields Lane, Askham Bryan, York [19/00454/FUL] through his employment with Healthwatch York. | |
| 12 Jul 2018 | Executive, item 12 | Cllr Ayre declared a personal interest in Agenda Item 6 (Delivering Improved Sport and Active Leisure Facilities at Burnholme ), as his son played for one of the football clubs that regularly used the current facilities. He took no part in the discussions or decision on the item. | Took no part |
| 11 Jul 2018 | Planning Main, item 7 | Councillor Ayre declared an interest in Item 4a (Minute Item 11) as the current Executive Member for Culture, Leisure and Tourism. He also left the meeting for this item. | Left the room |
| 27 Mar 2018 | Shareholder Committee, item 1 | Cllr Ayre declared an interest as the head of a charity. No further interests were declared. | |
| 13 Dec 2017 | Planning Main, item 10 | Cllr Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest in item 4g as he works for Healthwatch York. | |
| 11 May 2017 | Planning Main, item 103 | Councillor Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest in plans item 3a (Site of 17-21 Picadilly , York) as he had a professional relationship with one of the registered speakers through his work with Healthwatch North Yorkshire. | |
| 7 Dec 2016 | Executive, item 80 | Cllr Ayre declared a personal interest in relation to agenda item 6a ( Burnholme Health and Wellbeing Campus: Key Decisions) as his daughter attended the on site Nursery. | |
| 24 Nov 2016 | Executive, item 64 | Cllr Ayre declared a personal pecuniary interest in relation to agenda item 6 ( Bootham Park Hospital Scrutiny Review Final Report) owing to his employment as an NHS Manager for North Yorkshire County Council and he left the meeting during the discussion and voting thereon. | Left the room |
| 15 Sep 2016 | Planning Main, item 28 | Councillor Ayre declared an interest in plans item 4b (Oliver House, Bishophill Junior) as he had been a member of the Executive when the sale of land was agreed and was still a member of the Executive. He stated that he did not feel comfortable taking part in the decision and left the table and took no part in the discussion or vote on this item. | Took no part |
| 8 Jun 2016 | Planning Main, item 2 | Councillor Ayre declared an interest in Plans list item 3a (Huntington Stadium, Jockey Lane, Huntington) as Executive Member for Culture, Leisure and Tourism with responsibility for delivering the project. He took no part in the debate or vote on this application. | Took no part |
| 19 May 2016 | Executive, item 145 | Councillor Ayre declared a personal interest in relation to agenda item 5 – Delivery of Community Facilities at the Burnholme Health and Wellbeing Campus (minute 149 refers) as his daughter attended Burnholme School. | |
| 30 Jul 2015 | Executive, item 17 | Councillor Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest in respect of Agenda item 6 – Castlegate - Update, as the organisation he worked for were in ongoing discussions with Castlegate staff . He left the room and took no part in the discussion and voting thereon. | Left the room |
| 4 Jun 2015 | Planning Main, item 1 | Councillor Ayre declared a personal interest in agenda item 4b as his family use one of the surgeries in the Heslington area which could be affected by the opening of a new surgery at the University. | |
| 11 Feb 2015 | Audit and Governance Committee, item 56 | · Councillor Ayre declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in respect of agenda item 9 (LGA Peer Review) by virtue of his employment. He stated that he would withdraw from the meeting for this item. | |
| 15 Jan 2014 | Health, Housing and Adult Social Care Policy and Scrutiny Committee, item 62 | Councillor Ayre declared two personal interests in the remit of the committee. He was an employee of York MIND and sat on the Mental Health and Learning Disabilities Board (which sits under the Health and Wellbeing Board). | |
| 20 Sep 2012 | Planning Main, item 12 | Councillor Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest in relation to Plans item 4g (Creepy Crawlies, The Arena, Clifton Gate Business Park, Wigginton Road, York 12/02459/FUL) as his son and daughter were occasional users of the site. | |
| 26 Jul 2012 | Planning Main, item 1 | Councillor Ayre declared a personal interest as the Chair of Derwenthorpe Transport Sub Committee. | |
| 26 Apr 2012 | Planning Main, item 46 | Councillor Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest in item 4a ( Derwenthorpe ) as the Chair of Transport on Derwenthorpe Partnership Forum. | |
| 24 Mar 2011 | Planning Main, item 40 | Councillor Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest in relation to Plans Item 4a (6-18 Hull Road, York 11/00050/OUTM) as a member of the Civil Service Cricket Club at the Outgang, Heslington. | |
| 23 Sep 2010 | Planning Main, item 11 | Councillor Ayre declared a personal non prejudicial interest in relation to Plans items 4a (6-18 Hull Road, York) and 4b (32 Lawrence Street, York) as Executive Member for Leisure, Culture and Social Inclusion. |
Where Councillor Ayre sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Oct 2007 | 96 | |
| Corporate Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2025 | 9 | |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2025 | 9 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Staffing Matters and Urgency Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2024 | 5 | 23 Nov 2026 |
| Corporate Scrutiny Committee (Calling In) | Committee Member | Apr 2026 | 2 | 23 Nov 2026 |
| Planning Policy and Local Plan Advisory Group | Vice-Chair | Jun 2026 | 2 | 17 Dec 2026 |
| Planning Main | Committee Member | Mar 2010 | 92 | |
| Local Plan Working Group | Chair | Nov 2007 | 45 | |
| Licensing/Gambling Hearing | Attendee | Dec 2007 | 44 | |
| Executive - for meetings from 03/06/00 to 26/04/11 | Committee Member | May 2009 | 43 | |
| Executive (Calling-In) - for meetings from 17/04/07 to 04/05/11 | Committee Member | Jun 2009 | 38 | |
| Executive | Committee Member | Aug 2011 | 30 | |
| Osbaldwick and Derwent Ward Committee (Please contact the Communities Team for further information) | Committee Member | Oct 2007 | 22 | |
| Decision Session - Executive Member for Leisure Culture and Social Inclusion | Cabinet Member | Jun 2009 | 21 | |
| Decision Session - Executive Member for Culture, Leisure and Communities | Committee Member | Sep 2011 | 19 | |
| Young People's Working Group | Vice-Chair | Oct 2007 | 16 | |
| Licensing and Regulatory Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2007 | 15 | |
| Corporate Services, Climate Change and Scrutiny Management Committee (Calling In) | Committee Member | Jan 2012 | 14 | |
| Audit and Governance Committee | Chair | Jul 2013 | 14 | |
| Neighbourhood Services and Advisory Panel | Vice-Chair | Oct 2007 | 12 | |
| Health Scrutiny Committee | Vice-Chair | Jun 2008 | 11 | |
| Equality Advisory Group | Substitute | Jul 2009 | 10 | |
| Planning Committee A | Committee Member | Feb 2023 | 8 | |
| Decision Session - Executive Member for Finance and Major Projects | Committee Member | Jan 2020 | 7 | |
| Corporate Services, Climate Change and Scrutiny Management Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2024 | 4 | |
| Children, Education and Communities Policy and Scrutiny Committee | Attendee | Jan 2010 | 3 | |
| Customer and Corporate Services Scrutiny Management Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2014 | 3 | |
| Heworth Without Ward Committee (Please contact the Communities Team for further information) | Committee Member | Oct 2015 | 3 | |
| Decision Session - Executive Member for City Strategy | Attendee | Oct 2010 | 2 | |
| Shareholder Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2017 | 2 | |
| Decision Session - Executive Leader (incorporating Policy, Strategy and Partnerships) | Committee Member | Jan 2020 | 2 | |
| Hungate Ad Hoc Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Oct 2008 | 1 | |
| West & City Centre Area Planning Sub-Committee | Attendee | Sep 2009 | 1 | |
| Decision Session - Executive Member for Children and Young People's Services | Attendee | Jan 2010 | 1 | |
| East Area Planning Sub-Committee | Substitute | Jun 2012 | 1 | |
| Health, Housing and Adult Social Care Policy and Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Jan 2014 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny Work Planning Event | Attendee | May 2014 | 1 | |
| Area Planning Sub-Committee | Substitute | Feb 2015 | 1 | |
| Decision Session - Executive Member for Economy and Strategic Planning | Attendee | May 2016 | 1 | |
| Children, Education and Communities Policy and Scrutiny Committee (Pre Decision Calling In) | Attendee | Jun 2016 | 1 | |
| Executive (Calling-In) | Committee Member | Mar 2018 | 1 | |
| Health and Wellbeing Board | Committee Member | Jan 2024 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.