Main meeting
1. – welcome and introductions (7pm) The meeting was chaired by Councillor Melly who welcomed everyone, set out the housekeeping rules and reminded residents that the meeting was non-political.
Every time York's minutes name Councillor Melly, as the council published it.
1. – welcome and introductions (7pm) The meeting was chaired by Councillor Melly who welcomed everyone, set out the housekeeping rules and reminded residents that the meeting was non-political.
Volunteering in Guildhall Ward and helping our communities Cllr Melly introduced the topic as an opportunity to discuss and celebrate volunteering in the community.
Councillor Melly then invited the first speaker, Sadie Harvey, York Centre for Voluntary Service CVS Supported Volunteering Project Coordinator. York CVS is passionate about supporting and championing York’s Voluntary, Community and Social Enterprise (VCSE) Sector. Practical support and guidance is provided to enable charitable organisations in York to thrive.
Cllr Melly added that the potential to create a community café at the park pavilion is being explored and several meetings with various stakeholders have been held. Councillors were advised that no appropriate drainage exists under the pavilion. Appropriate drainage connection would be required for a commercial type of café operation.
Cllr Melly left the meeting during the break.]
For Against Abstain Councillor Ayre 1 Councillor Baxter 1 Councillor Clarke 1 Councillor Coles 1 Councillor Crawshaw 1 Councillor Cullwick 1 Councillor Cuthbertson 1 Councillor Douglas 1 Councillor Fenton 1 Councillor Fisher 1 Councillor Healey 1 Councillor Hollyer 1 Councillor Hook 1 Councillor Kent 1 Councillor Kilbane 1 Councillor Knight 1 Councillor Lomas 1 Councillor Mason 1 Councillor Melly 1 Councillor Merrett 1 Councillor Moroney 1 Councillor Myers 1 Councillor Nelson 1 Councillor Nichols 1 Councillor Orrell 1 Councillor Pavlovic 1 Councillor Perrett 1 Councillor Ravilious 1 Councillor Rose 1 Councillor Rowley 1 Councillor Runciman 1 Councillor Smalley 1 Councillor Steels-Walshaw 1 Councillor Steward 1 Councillor Taylor 1 Councillor Waller 1 Councillor Wann 1 Councillor Watson 1 Councillor Waudby 1 Councillor Webb 1 Councillor Wells 1 Councillor Whitcroft 1 Councillor Widdowson 1 Councillor Wilson 1 Totals:
Cllr Melly moved, and Cllr Cuthbertson seconded the following recommendations contained in the report:
[7.10-7.13 pm, Cllr Whitcroft left the meeting, 7.15–7.17 pm, Cllr B Burton left the meeting, 7.16-7.18 pm, Cllr Melly left the meeting].
Cllr Vassie proposed that Cllr Melly be appointed as Vice-Chair for the duration of the meeting.
This was seconded by Cllr Nelson, and with the agreement of the committee Cllr Melly took over as Vice-Chair for the duration of the meeting.
Several members of the Committee confirmed while not a prejudicial or disclosable pecuniary interest that they were subscribers to the garden waste collections service in relation to minute 41, Cllr Melly also noted that she had a non-prejudicial interest in relation to minute 41 as she was currently a Corporate Director of Yorwaste. Several Committee members also confirmed they were snow wardens in relation to minute 42.
Reason: To ensure allocations to the Combined Authority committees are made.” The Labour Group nominated Cllr Melly and Cllr Crawshaw onto the York and North Yorkshire Combine Authority Audit and Governance Committee and Cllr Merrett and Cllr J Burton onto the York and North Yorkshire Combined Authority Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
This was seconded by Cllr Melly. On being put to the vote with nine voting in favour and one against, it was:
[At 3.12pm Cllr Melly sought legal advice from the Senior Solicitor.
Cllr Melly declared that she was a Ward Councillor for Clifton with Rawcliffe and a Member of Clifton Parish Council and had not taken part in any decision making regarding Limetrees .
Following debate, Cllr Melly proposed the officer recommendation to approve the application.
Cllr Melly outlined her disappointment in both the report on the Acomb Road scheme and the lack of progress in the Active Travel Programme. She raised concern that the Leeman Road closure was going ahead despite work to improve the riverside path not being completed. Finally she enquired as to why Hospital Fields Road was having Active Travel work undertaken when it scored lower other areas that were not being worked on.
Cllr Melly spoke on agenda item 4, Update on Anti-Racism Strategy work. She welcomed the report and thanked everyone that had contributed to it. She agreed that the report poignantly highlighted the need for action to address racism and racial disparity in the city.
Cllr Melly stated that she considered the LCWIP to be five years late and was now being rushed through with the Council having delivered substandard transport infrastructure during the current administration.
In relation to item 4a (Morrell House, 388 Burton Stone Lane, YO32 6EZ), Cllr Melly declared a prejudicial interest, she therefore left the meeting prior to consideration of that item and took no part in the debate or decision thereon.
[Cllr Melly left the meeting for the duration of item 4a.
[4.50 pm Cllr Melly re-joined the meeting.] Members considered a full application at the Lord Nelson, 9 Main Street, Nether Poppleton, York ,YO26 6HS for the erection of 1no. dwelling.
Public Speakers Cllr Melly lived in the neighbourhood of the application site and spoke in objection to the application. She supported student accommodation on the site, but explained that the scheme needed to be well designed. She explained that residents felt that the scheme was overdevelopment and she added that it removed existing parking which would have further impacts on car parking in the area.
In answer to questions from Members, Cllr Melly explained that:
· Regarding engagement from the university, Cllr Melly had organised a meeting with residents.
[ Supplementary from Cllr Melly : All the improvements to Riverside Park are necessary and are now more urgent in the light of plans to close Leeman Road. We are told they will cost over £1m but only £0.5m has been allocated. You said in your report that the plans would be funded through the capital programme.
Public Speakers Cllr Melly, spoke in objection to the application. She highlighted the negative impact the existing short term let had on the local residents noting increased noise and vehicle movements. She noted the requirements of the NPPF and explained that the objectives had been undermined with no economic benefit to the area.
Public Speakers Both Cllr Melly and Cllr Fitzpatrick requested that their comments relating to item 4a (1 Ascot Mews) be taken into consideration for this application.
Cllr Melly spoke on Items 7 and 8. On the former she supported the proposals; on the latter she highlighted a lack of progress on schemes previously prioritised in the programme, including Acomb Road in her ward of Holgate, and suggested the reasons were political.
This was seconded by Cllr Melly . Following a vote with six in favour and one abstention it was;
(i) A petition presented by Cllr Hook, on behalf of residents of Skelton calling for the installation of a pedestrian crossing to allow safe crossing to all between Fairfield Croft and Fairfield Drive. 1 (ii) A petition presented by Cllr Fisher, on behalf of residents of Moor Lane and Princess Road in Strensall , seeking to have these roads fully resurfaced. 2 (iii) A petition presented by Cllr Melly, on behalf of residents and visitors supporting Reverse the Ban in calling for a reversal of the ban on Blue Badge Holders from entering the city centre. 3
(i) Protecting and Improving Local Bus Services Cllr Fenton sought consent to alter his motion to incorporate the amendment submitted by Cllr Melly.
Cllr Cuthbertson, as Chair of the Licensing & Regulatory Committee, moved, and Cllr Melly seconded, the following recommendation from the meeting of the committee held on 4 October 2022.
Following debate, Cllr Melly moved the Officer recommendation to approve the application.
Cllr Fenton moved to approve the officer recommendation, this was seconded by Cllr Melly. Members voted unanimously in favour and it was;
Cllr Melly, Ward Member for Holgate, highlighted costs and accessibility issues and urged that the scheme be reconsidered to keep the public safe while not excluding disabled people.
Cllr Melly moved option 2 to r enew the licence with modified/additional conditions imposed by the committee. The modification related to references to him and her being changed to they or them in the conditions.
He explained that he had informed the Chair on Monday that week that he would only be available as substitute for Cllr Melly in order to conclude the business of the previously deferred National Railway Museum item. He stated that due to the reordering of the agenda he would almost certainly now be precluded from taking part in the decision on the NRM application and expressed deep unhappiness at the way this had been handled.
Councillor Melly noted that she felt the size of the agenda at over 500 pages was not accessible to residents. She also enquired why there were no updates on the Acomb Road Active Travel scheme and why feasibility reports were not included for the Bootham Active Travel scheme or Heslington to Wheldrake . She also asked how many active travel schemes had been delivered.
Cllr Melly raised concerns that certain Council vehicles would continue to use the footstreets while blue badge holders would be barred from entering. She questioned proposals for parking charges to be introduced on Knavesmire Road after it was confirmed this would not happen. Regarding the last mile delivery service she asked that the trail look at including wider benefits, such as smaller businesses being able to access the delivery site and whether the delivery site could be used as a drop off as well as a pick up site.
Cllr Melly declared an interest in agenda item 4 Licensing Act 2003 – Statement of Licensing Policy and Cumulative Impact Assessment and undertook to withdraw from the meeting for that item. There were no further declarations of interest.
Cllr Melly declared a pecuniary interest in Agenda Item 12 (Recommendations of the Licensing & Regulatory Committee). She left the room during consideration of that item and took no part in the debate or decision thereon.
Cllr Melly spoke on Agenda Items 8 and 11 (Minutes 117 and 120 refer). On Item 8 she objected to the proposal to delegate the sign-off of the stopping-up order to officers. On Item 11 she also raised concerns at the proposal to delegate to officers rather than to the Executive Member for Transport.
Cllr Melly declared an interest in agenda item 4 Licensing Act 2003 – Statement of Licensing Policy and Cumulative Impact Assessment and undertook to withdraw from the meeting for that item. There were no further declarations of interest.
[Cllr Melly left the meeting at 5.32pm]
Cllr Melly then moved and Cllr Looker seconded approval Option 2, to renew the licence with modified/additional conditions imposed by the licensing committee, that being that the references to male and female in the conditions be changed to any gender or sex. On being put to the vote it was unanimously;
Cllr Melly proposed a third option; for the Committee to form a Sub-Committee/Working Group to review the policy. The Senior Solicitor advised that she would need to consult the Monitoring Officer on the setting up of this constitutionally and it would probably be a working group rather than a sub-committee. The Licensing Manager added that the Committee had had working groups to look at non statutory policies.
Cllr Melly expressed concern about the reduction in the Acomb Road Active Travel Scheme. She noted that when meetings with Ward Councillors had taken place they had not included the reduction of the scheme and raised concerns that the remainder of the scheme was being outlined for a different program which had no budget or timeline for when work would begin.
Cllr Melly abstained. It was therefore:
Cllr Melly noted the Irwin Avenue petition and requested a wider review of traffic as she felt there were additional traffic issues in the area which should be reviewed. She also enquired as to why blue badge holders were unable to access the city centre through staffed road barriers. She also asked about the progress of the removal of inaccessible barriers on cycle routes across the city.
Cllr Melly noted the benefits of excluding traffic from the city centre but stressed this did not require excluding blue badge holders.
Cllr Melly noted that she felt that the Council needed to be more ambitious with its York Bus Service Improvement Plan. She highlighted issues of inequality raised by disability groups in the city and why the plan saw buses three times less frequent in the evening. She also raised concerns that the plans lack of ambitious as she saw it would mean the Council would miss out on some funding.
After debate, it was moved by Cllr Melly and seconded by Cllr Daubeney to approve the application.
Cllr Melly spoke on Item 8, stating that the scheme had not been properly undertaken as part of a city-wide action plan and that rather than providing an ‘upgrade’ to the transport route it would lead to increased traffic, pollution and vehicle speeds.
Cllr Melly raised concerns that projects to improve cycle provisions lacking progress. She noted that schemes from two years prior had yet to receive preliminary work. She asked whether feasibility work had been completed on a city centre cycling travel route and an update on the use of funding to remove barriers to cycling.
Councillor Melly also spoke in relation to the changes to blue badge parking. She noted that the footstreet extension had many benefits for those that could access to the city centre including being a benefit to businesses, however, she highlighted that this was only ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Cllr Melly declared a non-prejudicial interest as she had joined Heworth Tennis Club which would potentially benefit from S106 funding.
Councillor Barker moved, Councillor Melly seconded, and Council unanimously
Cllr Melly noted that although she worked in hospitality this was not a conflict of interest.
The Chair welcomed Cllr Melly as Vice Chair of the Committee and thanked the outgoing Vice Chair, Cllr Wells. He also suggested that agenda item 5 [Update on interpretation of the law – ‘Out of town’ private hire licences] be deferred i n order that a request be made to North Yorkshire Police to provide their legal advice in respect of out of town private hire licences.
Cllr Warters then moved and Cllr Melly seconded approval of option 1. Following a unanimous vote it was
Cllr Crawshaw and Cllr Melly declared a personal non-prejudicial interest in Agenda Item 3a) The Jubilee, they had signed a petition against a previous planning application for this site. It was noted that this was a substantially different application, and that advisement had been sought from the Monitoring Officer.
Cllr Melly declared a pecuniary interest in Motion (iv) at Agenda Item 8 (Fair Funding Deal for Police and Fire Services). She left the meeting during consideration of that motion and took no part in the debate or decision thereon.
Cllr Melly then moved and Cllr Warters seconded approval of the renewal (option 1). In accordance with the revised Standing Orders, a named vote was taken with the following result:
Cllr R Melly highlighted the positive impact the E-Scooter trial had had so far, but requested that further work be undertaken to allow E-Scooters and E-Bikes to be used beyond the outer ring road to support residents living further away from the city centre from benefiting from their use. In relation to item 10 she noted that Government had supported the schemes but did not award full funding and enquired as to ... view the full minutes text for item 48.
Cllr Melly addressed the committee on behalf of the Calling-In Members, explaining in more detail the reasons for the calling-in, and responding to questions put by Members. The Executive Member for Finance & Performance then outlined the reasons for the original decisions, and responded to Members’ questions. A short break followed, after which questions were put to officers responsible for the report at Annex 2.
Cllr Melly then moved and Cllr Barker seconded approval of the renewal (option 1). In accordance with the revised Standing Orders, a named vote was taken with the following result:
Cllr Barker then moved and Cllr Melly seconded approval of the renewal (option 1).
Cllr Warters then moved option 1 and Cllr Melly seconded this. In accordance with the revised Standing Orders, a named vote was taken with the following result:
( Supplementaries from Cllr Melly and Cllr Crawshaw: What lessons have been learned from the grant going to Homes England instead of the council? How will delivery of the 6,500 jobs promised for the site be ensured?) Response: The fact that the grant was secured, as part of an infrastructure package totalling £175m, demonstrates that our partnership approach was the right one. Development is proceeding in line with the Masterplan and outline planning permission, and there will be further opportunities to work with public bodies on housing.
Cllr Melly, Member for Holgate Ward, spoke on Agenda Item 6 (Urgent Business: E-scooter and E-bike Trial). She welcomed the trial but expressed concerns about a lack of information on mitigating the effects on people with visual impairments, the suitability of the hospital site, data protection and insurance issues, and how visitors to the city could access the scheme.
Cllr Melly, Ward Member for Holgate, also spoke on Item 7. While supporting the extension of the footstreet zone in the city centre, she expressed concern that Blue Badge holders had not been consulted at an earlier stage, and funding built into the original budget to mitigate the impact the changes may have on them.
Cllr Melly , Labour Groups spokesperson for transport, welcomed the Councils progress towards our carbon neutral commitment, encouraging active travel whilst also keeping pedestrianised areas safe. She addressed the changes made to accessing the city centre and although she hoped there would be some long term positive benefits from these changes, she felt some plans put in place had led to people who already had the least access to outdoor spaces and the city centre being further marginalised. She questioned why blue badge holders were not consulted and if the additional seating located on the foot streets was impacting on people with visual impairments or mobility difficulties.
Cllr Melly also spoke on Item 5 as a Ward Member for Holgate. Referring to calls from residents of the Leeman Road area for more community space, she suggested that Network Rail transfer the Gatehouse building to the council for that purpose in return for the proposed disposal of land to NR.
Councillor Melly declared a personal non prejudicial interest in agenda item 5 (Multiple Complex Needs Network Update) in that she was involved in Food not Bombs.
· From Cllr Melly (supplementary) – why was there no re-assessment of the 2017 commitment to look at all policy through the prism of the Human Rights Act?
Councillor Melly d eclared a prejudicial interest in item 5 of the agenda the CCG - Mental Health GP Services Closure report in that she had knowledge of this service.
Councillor Melly did not take part in the discussion on that item. There were no further declarations of interest.
Cllr Melly left the meeting area for consideration of this item. Members received a report which provided an explanation of the circumstances regarding the set up and eventual closure of the Primary Care Mental Health team service.
Cllr Melly declared a non-prejudicial interest in the business of the Committee generally and not in relation to an agenda item in particular, in that she had previously held a post which had involved lobbying on Health policy areas discussed in the Quality Assurance Report.
Councillor Melly declared a personal non-prejudicial interest in item 5 of the agenda the Substance Misuse Review, having previously worked for the Life Live Project.
(i) Carbon Neutral City Moved by Cllr Crawshaw and seconded by Cllr Melly .
Customer and Corporate Services Scrutiny Management Committee To appoint Cllr Musson to replace Cllr Melly on this committee.
Health & Adult Social Care Policy & Scrutiny Committee To appoint Cllr Melly to replace Cllr Musson on this committee.
To appoint Cllr Barnes, Cllr Melly and Cllr Heaton as Labour substitutes.
Planning Committee Cllr Crawshaw, Cllr Lomas, Cllr Melly and Cllr Webb to be appointed as Labour substitutes.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Melly attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 21 May 2026 | Council | Committee Arrangements, Allocation of Seats and Appointments to the Council Structure and Other Bodies for 2026/27, and Allocation of Council Motions | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Mar 2026 | Council | Motions on Notice (8.51pm) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Feb 2025 | Council | Adoption of the City of York Local Plan (9:21 pm) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 31 Jan 2024 | Audit and Governance Committee | Statement of Accounts 2022/23 (6:18 pm) | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Melly was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 18 of 75 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Melly declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8 Feb 2024 | Planning Committee A, item 84 | Cllr Melly declared that she was a Ward Councillor for Clifton with Rawcliffe and a Member of Clifton Parish Council and had not taken part in any decision making regarding Limetrees . | |
| 9 Mar 2023 | Planning Committee B, item 67 | In relation to item 4a (Morrell House, 388 Burton Stone Lane, YO32 6EZ), Cllr Melly declared a prejudicial interest, she therefore left the meeting prior to consideration of that item and took no part in the debate or decision thereon. | Left the room |
| 7 Jun 2022 | Licensing and Regulatory Committee, item 1 | Cllr Melly declared an interest in agenda item 4 Licensing Act 2003 – Statement of Licensing Policy and Cumulative Impact Assessment and undertook to withdraw from the meeting for that item. There were no further declarations of interest. | |
| 27 Apr 2022 | Council, item 64 | Cllr Melly declared a pecuniary interest in Agenda Item 12 (Recommendations of the Licensing & Regulatory Committee). She left the room during consideration of that item and took no part in the debate or decision thereon. | Left the room |
| 2 Mar 2022 | Licensing and Regulatory Committee, item 80 | Cllr Melly declared an interest in agenda item 4 Licensing Act 2003 – Statement of Licensing Policy and Cumulative Impact Assessment and undertook to withdraw from the meeting for that item. There were no further declarations of interest. | |
| 17 Jun 2021 | Planning Main, item 27 | Cllr Melly declared a non-prejudicial interest as she had joined Heworth Tennis Club which would potentially benefit from S106 funding. | |
| 15 Apr 2021 | Area Planning Sub-Committee, item 46 | Cllr Crawshaw and Cllr Melly declared a personal non-prejudicial interest in Agenda Item 3a) The Jubilee, they had signed a petition against a previous planning application for this site. It was noted that this was a substantially different application, and that advisement had been sought from the Monitoring Officer. | |
| 22 Mar 2021 | Council, item 94 | Cllr Melly declared a pecuniary interest in Motion (iv) at Agenda Item 8 (Fair Funding Deal for Police and Fire Services). She left the meeting during consideration of that motion and took no part in the debate or decision thereon. | Left the room |
| 21 Jan 2020 | Health and Adult Social Care Policy and Scrutiny Committee, item 52 | Councillor Melly declared a personal non prejudicial interest in agenda item 5 (Multiple Complex Needs Network Update) in that she was involved in Food not Bombs. | |
| 11 Nov 2019 | Health and Adult Social Care Policy and Scrutiny Committee, item 35 | Cllr Melly declared a non-prejudicial interest in the business of the Committee generally and not in relation to an agenda item in particular, in that she had previously held a post which had involved lobbying on Health policy areas discussed in the Quality Assurance Report. | |
| 23 Oct 2019 | Health and Adult Social Care Policy and Scrutiny Committee, item 26 | Councillor Melly declared a personal non-prejudicial interest in item 5 of the agenda the Substance Misuse Review, having previously worked for the Life Live Project. |
Where Councillor Melly sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Licensing/Gambling Hearing | Committee Member | Jan 2021 | 58 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | Feb 2024 | 15 | |
| Licensing and Regulatory Committee | Chair | Jan 2020 | 9 | |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2025 | 9 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Guildhall Ward Committee (Please contact the Communities Team for further information) | Committee Member | Nov 2025 | 4 | |
| Place Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 2 | 12 Jan 2027 |
| Licensing and Regulatory Committee Sub-Committee | Chair | Jul 2026 | 1 | |
| Planning Committee B | Committee Member | Jan 2023 | 8 | |
| Planning Committee A | Committee Member | Feb 2023 | 6 | |
| Area Planning Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2020 | 4 | |
| Planning Main | Committee Member | Feb 2020 | 3 | |
| Corporate Services, Climate Change and Scrutiny Management Committee (Calling In) | Committee Member | Feb 2022 | 2 | |
| Joint Committee, Corporate Services, Climate Change and Scrutiny Management Committee and Audit and Governance Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2024 | 2 | |
| Audit and Governance Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2024 | 2 | |
| Children, Culture and Communities Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Mar 2024 | 2 | |
| Corporate Services, Climate Change and Scrutiny Management Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2025 | 2 | |
| Health and Adult Social Care Policy and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2020 | 1 | |
| Climate Emergency Policy and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2022 | 1 | |
| Economy, Place, Access and Transport Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Jan 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.