CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Argyll and Bute Council

SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT CONSULTATION – A FAIRER LOCAL TAX FOR SCOTLAND

Agreed Committee 2 papers

Organisational Development Policy and Performance Group agreed this item on Thursday 29 May 2008. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item1

Resolved

Decision The Group agreed that the draft response be amended as follows and that this be submitted to the Executive for further consideration:- Paragraph 2.4 - Amend second sentence to state that a system would have to be devised to ensure that the deductions for a Local Income Tax could be shown separately on payslips from other income tax, and the amounts separately identified in remittances from employers to HMRC. Paragraph 2.10 – Add final sentence “It would be preferential to take into account ability to pay”. Paragraph 2.15 – Amend last sentence to read “Central Government would need to be able to manage all of the risk from this for Local Authorities and would need to put transitional arrangements in place to cover the anticipated time lag in cash flow”. Paragraph 2.17 – Add final sentence “ Central Government would need to compensate local government for any potential loss of income from contributions in lieu of council tax” Paragraph 2.18 – To facilitate discussion at the Executive it was agreed to express the view that nothing contained within the proposals gave an indication that the tax would be “local” if it were to be set, raised and collected centrally, and the suggestion was that this word be removed throughout the response. Paragraph 2.19 – There were two conflicting views expressed here, one that if the tax were to be income based then owners of second homes should not be penalised twice by collecting tax on lettings income as well as through Non-Domestic Rates – this was moving away from the principle of taxing income and was illogical. The second view was that this was already the case in that second homes owners pay council tax twice and therefore it was only right to continue the practice. The Group noted that the inclusion of Schedule A (rentals and lettings) income in the base for a local income tax would be more beneficial to the Council and would also not penalise owners of second homes who choose not to rent out their property(ies). Question 4 – Last sentence to be amended to read “However, it believes that the practical difficulties need to be addressed and resolved before details are agreed”. Question 11 – the Federation of Small Businesses should be added to the list of bodies to provide seminars in conjunction with HMRC. Question 17 – Last sentence to be deleted. Question 18 – Agreed to insert after the first sentence “The difference between this actual yield and a notional yield based on a “standard” LIT rate across all of Scotland and total income from the local authority area would then be a financial risk for each local authority “ Amend last sentence to start “If the standard LIT rate is ….” Question 19 – Agreed to add final sentence that “The issue of whether Scotland will continue to receive an amount equivalent to Council Tax Benefit in the Scottish Block needs to be determined before proceeding to implement a local income tax”. Question 20 – Two views were again expressed, the first that you can either tax income or property but not both, and the second that this was the current position and there was no reason not to continue along the same lines. Question 22 – Two options were put forward for discussion by the Executive, the first being Council Tax and the second being Local Income Tax. Question 24 – There was a minority view that the fairer system would be Local Income Tax and the Group therefore agreed to put forward both views for discussion. General – It was agreed that the draft response should be revised to reflect the need for more detail on the precise proposals for a local income tax prior to any decisions being taken. (Ref: Report by Head of ICT and Financial Services dated 22 May 2008, submitted)
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting. Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Argyll and Bute's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Organisational Development Policy and Performance Group

Summary

1.1The purpose of this report is enable consideration of the Council’s draft response to the Scottish Government Consultation entitled “A Fairer Local Tax for Scotland”. The consultation was issued on 11 March 2008 and closes on 18 July 2008.

2. DETAIL

2.1The key principles against which any replacement for the council tax should be assessed are as follows:

• Accountability • Fairness • Stability and Predictability • Buoyancy of tax base • Easily understood • Transparency • Ease and cost of assessment/collection

2.2There are also a number of technical factors which should be considered including the following:

• Effect on cash flow for local authorities • Arrangements for billing and collection of water and sewerage • Effect on contribution in lieu of council tax paid by Ministry of Defence • Distribution between local authorities • Second homes • Loss of jobs to the local economy

2.3The consultation document issued by the Scottish Government poses 24 questions. Draft responses to these questions are set out in Appendix 1 to this report. However these questions do not cover many of the principles and factors set out at paragraphs 2.1 and 2.2 above. Comments against each of these are set out below and should also be included in the response to the consultation which the Council sends.

Page 1 of 15 Accountability 2.4 It is very unlikely that a tax set nationally at the same rate and collected by HMRC along with income tax is identifiable as a local tax. It is unlikely that deductions for this tax would be identified in a separate line on payslips and so most people would only be aware that their tax payments had increased, not necessarily that an amount was being deducted as a local income tax.

2.5HMRC would be responsible for identifying the total amount collected as local income tax and for remitting this to local authorities. It is highly unlikely that HMRC would record in which local authority any particular person was resident as they have only set up a single Scottish Variable Rate (SVR) indicator. Use of this indicator would mean that the total collected as local income tax would have to be remitted to central government, much as Non Domestic Rates (NDR) receipts are pooled and then distributed to local government. Local authorities would have no accountability for the percentage collected – relying solely on the effectiveness of HMRC at maximising collections.

2.6If local authorities do not set their own rates of local income tax, that and these other factors reduce accountability. Many years ago the Royal Commission on Local Government in Scotland recognised that a healthy national democracy requires a vigorous and vibrant local democracy as a counterbalance to the inherently centralising power of the central state. The Royal Commission on Local Government in Scotland said many years ago - “If local government is to form a genuine part of the system of democracy it must have the characteristics of democracy in substance as well as in appearance” …………”popular election and power to raise finance go together” …..”if an authority has one but not the other, it is not truly accountable”. Similarly the Layfield Report on Local Government Finance argued for “local authorities … to be accountable they should be responsible to their electorate for both the expenditure they incur and the revenues they raise to finance it.”

2.7Another key issue would be what would happen if the total raised were to be less than predicted. At present that is a matter for each local council to cover any shortfall or to make subsequent spending plans for any surplus. With a nationally set tax, it would no longer be appropriate to make the local council accountable for such variances which would be outwith their control – there would need to be some sort of pooling mechanism.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Abolition of council tax appendix 29 May 2008Appendix 164 KB Download
PDF
SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT CONSULTATION: A FAIRER LOCAL TAX FOR SCOTLANDReport 125 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
1SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT CONSULTATION – A FAIRER LOCAL TAX FOR SCOTLANDThis decision

Who was there

6 of 10 attended
DB
Donald BrownOfficer, apologies
DH
Douglas HendryOfficer, present
DK
Councillor Donald KellyMember, apologies
DM
Councillor Donald MacdonaldMember, present
NM
Councillor Neil MackayMember, present
RM
Councillor Roderick McCuishMember, present
AM
Councillor Alex McNaughtonMember, apologies
GM
Councillor Gary MulvaneyMember, present
AN
Councillor Andrew NisbetMember, present
DP
Councillor Dougie PhilandChair, expected

On this subject at Argyll and Bute

Search all
  1. SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT CONSULTATION – A FAIRER LOCAL TAX FOR SCOTLANDThis decision
  2. National Islands Plan and Scottish Government Population PoliciesNoted
  3. Scottish power renewables/machair wind limited: scottish government's marine directorate section 36 consultation on proposed machair offshore wind farm: site 15 km north west of isle of islay and 12.4 km west of isle of colonsay (ref: 26/01100/s36)Agreed
  4. Esb asset development (uk) ltd: scottish government section 36 consultation for west torrisdale wind farm comprising of up to 9 wind turbines with a tip height of up to 149.9 metres with a predicted output of up to 6 mw per wind turbine, inAgreed
  5. Scottish government consultation response - draft national climate change plan 2026-2040Approved
  6. Voltalia uk ltd (scottish government consultation): section 36 consultation to construct and operate 6 wind turbines with a ground to blade tip height of 200 metres, and associated infrastructure including battery energy storage system andAgreed

More from Argyll and Bute Organisational Development Policy and Performance Group

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
28 Mar 2012 Councillors training and developmentDecision Noted the report. (Reference: Report by Head of Governance and Law dated 19 March 2012, submitted) Noted Open
28 Mar 2012 Implementation of performance management frameworkDecision Noted the report. (Reference: Report by Head of Improvement and HR dated March 2012, submitted) Noted Open
28 Mar 2012 Community engagement strategy/ action planDecision Noted the report. (Reference: Report by Community Development Manager dated 22 March 2012, submitted) Noted Open
28 Mar 2012 Work programmeDecision Noted that discussions were taking place on the Political Management Arrangements through a Short Life Worki... Noted Open
23 Mar 2011 Asset management progress reportDecision The PPG noted:- 1. the progress that has been achieved over the past year; 2. the key elements of the forwar... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies