Resolved
Decision The Group agreed that the draft response be amended as follows and that this be submitted to the Executive for further consideration:- Paragraph 2.4 - Amend second sentence to state that a system would have to be devised to ensure that the deductions for a Local Income Tax could be shown separately on payslips from other income tax, and the amounts separately identified in remittances from employers to HMRC. Paragraph 2.10 – Add final sentence “It would be preferential to take into account ability to pay”. Paragraph 2.15 – Amend last sentence to read “Central Government would need to be able to manage all of the risk from this for Local Authorities and would need to put transitional arrangements in place to cover the anticipated time lag in cash flow”. Paragraph 2.17 – Add final sentence “ Central Government would need to compensate local government for any potential loss of income from contributions in lieu of council tax” Paragraph 2.18 – To facilitate discussion at the Executive it was agreed to express the view that nothing contained within the proposals gave an indication that the tax would be “local” if it were to be set, raised and collected centrally, and the suggestion was that this word be removed throughout the response. Paragraph 2.19 – There were two conflicting views expressed here, one that if the tax were to be income based then owners of second homes should not be penalised twice by collecting tax on lettings income as well as through Non-Domestic Rates – this was moving away from the principle of taxing income and was illogical. The second view was that this was already the case in that second homes owners pay council tax twice and therefore it was only right to continue the practice. The Group noted that the inclusion of Schedule A (rentals and lettings) income in the base for a local income tax would be more beneficial to the Council and would also not penalise owners of second homes who choose not to rent out their property(ies). Question 4 – Last sentence to be amended to read “However, it believes that the practical difficulties need to be addressed and resolved before details are agreed”. Question 11 – the Federation of Small Businesses should be added to the list of bodies to provide seminars in conjunction with HMRC. Question 17 – Last sentence to be deleted. Question 18 – Agreed to insert after the first sentence “The difference between this actual yield and a notional yield based on a “standard” LIT rate across all of Scotland and total income from the local authority area would then be a financial risk for each local authority “ Amend last sentence to start “If the standard LIT rate is ….” Question 19 – Agreed to add final sentence that “The issue of whether Scotland will continue to receive an amount equivalent to Council Tax Benefit in the Scottish Block needs to be determined before proceeding to implement a local income tax”. Question 20 – Two views were again expressed, the first that you can either tax income or property but not both, and the second that this was the current position and there was no reason not to continue along the same lines. Question 22 – Two options were put forward for discussion by the Executive, the first being Council Tax and the second being Local Income Tax. Question 24 – There was a minority view that the fairer system would be Local Income Tax and the Group therefore agreed to put forward both views for discussion. General – It was agreed that the draft response should be revised to reflect the need for more detail on the precise proposals for a local income tax prior to any decisions being taken. (Ref: Report by Head of ICT and Financial Services dated 22 May 2008, submitted)