Resolved
Decision To agree the Council’s proposed response to the Consultation Document “Vale of Leven Hospital” as follows:- In response to Consultation Document "Vision for the Vale of Leven" Argyll and Bute Council would like to thank NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde (NHS GG&C) for the opportunity to participate in the consultation exercise on this particularly important issue relating to the future of the Vale of Leven Hospital. The Council's specific comments are as follows: 1. General The Council welcomes the extensive consultation undertaken, inclusive of local residents on the future of the hospital in an integrated and strategic manner that encompasses all the existing services and potential future services within a single process. The previous planning and consultation processes focused on individual services rather than an integrated approach, which in turn did not allow for the development of a strategic plan for the hospital. The result historically was clearly one which left the community with no option other than to support the continuation of the component services within the hospital in an attempt to force NHS GG&C to take a long term strategic view of the hospital. 2. NHS GG&C Commitment The Council welcomes the intention of NHS GG&C to commit itself to a future of providing services at the Vale of Leven on the basis of serving the local community including the Helensburgh & Lomond area which lies within the Argyll & Bute Council area. 3. The Vision for Unscheduled Care The Council, whilst being aware of the public expectation and support for the retention of anaesthetics and a consultant led service, acknowledges the conclusions of the two independent reviews on this matter and reluctantly accepts, on the basis of the detail supplied that, in the long term, anaesthetic services cannot be sustained to support emergency/unscheduled care, 24/7, at the Vale of Leven Hospital but regrets that it appears to the Council that NHS GG&C have failed to convince a not insignificant number of service users and carers of the clinical effectiveness of the GP led model presented by Professor Dodds and believes that further work is required to consider a north of the river solution. The Council welcomes the progress on Unscheduled Care following on from Professor MacKay's recommendation that further work be undertaken on the feasibility of learning from the work of the Lomond Integrated Care model and is encouraged by the view of Professor Dodds that it is possible to develop a model that allows a proportion of unscheduled care to be maintained by GPs and supported by Consultants at the Vale of Leven. However, the Council would ask for greater detail on how this will be organised , how sustainable the proposal is and an analysis on the possible impact on general GP services; if GPs are to supplement their existing roles with this task. The Council notes the view of NHS GG&C that by refining the existing protocols and clinical assessment scoring systems, that a model of care can be introduced which will allow between 70-80% of the 6,300 patient episodes to be provided at the Hospital. This figure is very encouraging; however, the Council would wish to see evidence of the targets being met and that a follow up report is provided on the progress the first year of the implementation. The Council further notes that within the vision for unscheduled medical care at the Vale of Leven Hospital the service in future will be similar to that proposed by the group of independent experts, that will be a consultant supported GP-led unit. The Council is encouraged by the commitment to provide the necessary extra funding to the Scottish Ambulance Service and welcomes the assurances that there will be extra paramedic staffed accident and emergency ambulance resources introduced to serve the Vale of Leven catchment area. The Council also acknowledges the conclusion of the Independent Review Team and the Scottish Ambulance Service that there are no significant issues around transporting patients from the Vale of Leven to the Royal Alexandra Hospital in Paisley. The Council would however appreciate further detail on the capacity of the Scottish Ambulance Service and how the operational arrangements will be applied to support the proposed redesign of services. The Council, given some of the issues around the current service, would welcome being involved in further discussions around the development of this service and to be involved in monitoring this service in future years. 4. The Vision for Planned Care Services The Council welcomes the advice within the consultation document by NHS GG&C and their commitment to maintaining and enhancing planned care services at The Vale of Leven Hospital across a wide range of services. The proposals for Dental Services, Surgical Services, General Medical Services, Regional Specialist Services and Diagnostic Services which would see an additional 18,350 episodes of care being delivered locally, rather than patients travelling to Glasgow and Paisley, is welcomed in terms of providing local outpatient care and assisting in the strategic plan to sustain the Vale of Leven site. The Council would however encourage further work to investigate the provision of additional services. It is noted that the development of a 20 surgery dental complex at the Vale of Leven will provide specialist care and also provide a suitable environment for the teaching of undergraduate students. However, it is unclear from the consultation document whether clients from the Helensburgh & Lomond area will be able to access this facility or whether it is specific to those patients resident within the NHS GG&C catchments area. The Council would ask that NHS GG&C and NHS Highland provide clarity on this matter. ... view the full minutes text for item 5.