Decision 1. Agreed in principle to removing the clause relating to ensuring that no teachers will be made compulsorily redundant; 2. Noted the failure to agree with the trade unions at the Employee Joint Negotiating Committee and agreed to remit Officers to refer the matter to the National Joint Secretaries; and 3. Agreed that a further report be submitted to the Executive following feedback from the National Joint Secretaries. (Reference: Report by Head of Improvement and Strategic HR, submitted) *
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting.Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk
1.1Argyll and Bute Council inherited and adopted an employment guarantee for Teachers contained in Standard Circular no 2.18 Absence Cover Arrangements from Strathclyde Regional Council following local government reorganisation. The arrangement dates back to the early 1980’s and states that “The Council agrees to maintain its teaching staff standards and to ensure that no teachers will be made compulsorily redundant during the period of the agreement.”
1.2The agreement was noted by the Strategic Policy Committee (Education) on 25th January 2007.
1.3It was recommended that the agreement be monitored/reviewed every 2 years. This has not happened to date.
1.4The matter was raised at the Education Joint Negotiating Committee held on 25th November 2009 and it was agreed that a further report would be submitted.
1.5The matter was raised at a JSC meeting on 28th January 2010 by the Head of Secondary & Pupil Support but no agreement was reached on how to progress the matter. At a subsequent meeting of the JSC on 29 April 2010 the Trade Unions were advised that given the current position the Council could not continue to guarantee no compulsory redundancies.
1.6The national position is that, although it is not customary for teachers to be made compulsorily redundant, there is no specific prohibition. Councils have tended to utilise the same mechanisms as Argyll & Bute Council, in terms of granting premature retirement and maintaining surplus teachers. However all Local Authorities are experiencing similar difficulties as ourselves in maintaining this in the current economic climate.
1.7The council agreed a redundancy policy on 25 November 2010. This policy states its intention to apply to all council employees. The policy states that in the first instance the Council will seek to reduce employee numbers on a voluntary basis. However, where, voluntary redundancy has not produced suitable volunteers, the Council, shall seek to agree with Trades Unions Representatives the criteria to be used when making compulsory redundancies.
1.8A paper was presented to the Education Joint Negotiating Committee on 15th December 2010 recommending the removal of the clause. This would allow the council to manage employees and budgets more effectively in the education service and bring teaching staff in line with other council employees who are covered by the redundancy policy. Following discussion with the Trades Unions minor amendments were made to the body of the report in relation to the origin of the agreement.
1.9Notwithstanding the amendments the Trades Unions are opposed to the removal of the clause regarding no compulsory redundancies for teachers and have advised that they may seek to ballot members regarding industrial action should the Council impose.
1.10As there was a “failure to agree” at the EJNC, the Head of Improvement & HR advised that the matter should be referred to the National Joint Secretaries for arbitration. Further to that this may result in an imposition.
Recommendations
2.1That the Executive agree to the principle of removing of the clause relating to ensuring that no teachers will be made compulsorily redundant.
2.2That the Executive note the failure to agree with the trade unions at the EJNC and remit officers to refer the matter to the National Joint Secretaries.
2.3That the Executive agrees to a further report being submitted following feedback from the National Joint Secretaries.
3. Detail
3.1The Council is currently facing significant budget challenges. As part of the process of tackling these challenges, all services in the council are being reviewed. This includes the education service which is looking to make savings in the region of £10.4 million.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.