DECISIONS 1. That the recommendations of the Review of Distribution of Section 106 Monies Scrutiny Working Group be approved. 2. That the Development, Growth & Assets Portfolio Holder provides a written response to the recommendations of the Working Group to the Scrutiny Commission within two months of this meeting. Reason: To meet the requirements of the L ocal Government and Public Involvement in Health Act 2007, ensure transparency in the decision making process and assist monitoring of Cabinet Executive responses to scrutiny recommendations.
Word for word from the decision Blaby published for this meeting.Source: democracy.blaby.gov.uk
SCRUTINY REVIEW OF THE ACQUISITION AND DISTRIBUTION OF S106 MONIES
APRIL 2009
1.0INTRODUCTION - WHAT IS A SECTION 106 AGREEMENT?
1.1The granting of planning permission often increases the value of land dramatically but the local community doesn’t always see benefit from the disruption or loss of amenity resulting from development. Also, the local authority may find itself liable for increased infrastructure spending as a result of planning permission.
1.2One way of dealing with this is to secure planning obligations. Section 106 of the Town and Country Act 1990 allows local authorities to secure obligations with developers requiring some form of commitment if planning permission is obtained. (known as a Section 106 agreement – a delivery mechanism for matters necessary to make a development acceptable in planning terms).
1.3Agreements setting out the obligations are often drawn up as a result of negotiation. They must only be sought if they meet the Secretary of State’s policy tests. A planning obligation must be:
a) Necessary to make the proposed development acceptable in planning terms. b) Relevant to planning. c) Directly related to the proposed development. d) Fair and reasonably related in scale and kind to the proposed development. e) Reasonable in all other aspects.
1.4Within these areas there are no hard and fast rules, so long as they are related to a particular need. It can involve the provision of facility, service or sum of money for use by the Council as specified in the Section 106 agreement.
1.5Research by Sheffield University of the Department of Communities and Local Government (‘Valuing Planning Obligations in England, May 2006) found that Section 106 agreements are used to secure:
• Affordable housing, (on or off-site provision or commuted payments). • Open space provision or environmental improvements. • Transport and highway improvements or travel schemes. • Community works and leisure (arts, recreation, public toilets, security, etc) • Education developments (schools, employment and training measures).
1 1.6 The Audit Commission report (‘Securing Community Benefits through the Planning Process, Improving performance on Section 106 agreements, August 2006) stated that some councils are missing opportunities to achieve more for their communities simply because they are not using planning obligations as effectively as they could.
2.0RATIONALE
2.1Several Parish Councils had raised concerns with Scrutiny members about the Section 106 processes. The main issues of concern were: • Perceived lack of openness and transparency. • Inadequate involvement of Parish Councils in the S106 process. • Inability to access details of past and current S106 agreements. • Lack of knowledge of how to get involved at an early stage. • Lack of facility to raise community needs prior to developments in the area. • Perception that decisions on S106 spend were made without consultation.
The complete list of Parish Council concerns is at Appendix 1
2.2Elected Members shared some of these concerns and the Scrutiny Commission decided to set up a working group to review the S106 process, comprising:
Councillors: P. Fox (Chair), A. Tanner, R. Dixon, J. Kenney, R. Ward, J. Dilks, J. Dolby, J. Weatherstone and the late Cllr N. Gilson.
2.3The working group invited all Parish Councils to attend the first meeting. This would enable them to introduce the review and ensure Parish Councils were assured their concerns were to be addressed as part of the review. Nine Parish Councils expressed intention to be represented:
The complete list of representatives is at Appendix 2.
2.5At its first meeting the working group received a presentation from Blaby District Council Head of Planning, Phil Clarke, and Development and Conservation manager, Andrew Senior, which provided foundation information covering:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.