DECISION That consideration of this item be deferred and a special meeting of Council be arranged to take place in early September 2010 to debate and consider this item in greater detail. Reasons: 1. Members raised concerns over the housing figures quoted in recommendation 2.1 of the report of the Planning Policy Manager, and were also unhappy that the level of consultation undertaken with the local community regarding the figures proposed was not sufficient. 2. To allow for Officers to undertake research and consultation on this issue and bring forward to the special meeting the results of this process to help in developing new housing figures for the District.
Word for word from the decision Blaby published for this meeting.Source: democracy.blaby.gov.uk
Appendix 1 – Potential options for the Housing Requirement for the District of Blaby.
Requirement Requirement Source Evidence base Comments per annum 2006 - 2026 (1) 290 5800 RSS Options The ‘Options for change’ The housing figure of 290 per year for the District of Blaby for Change paper was based on was identified as one of nine options for growth within the paper October interim 2002 based early drafts of the Regional Plan (option 2B). Option 2B 2005 (option household projections was seen as providing a ‘trend based’ level of growth (i.e 2B) and 2003 based that which reflected Central Government (ODPM) population with the household projections at the time with a locational policy distribution of houses approach of ‘Urban concentration’. It is important to note being informed by 3 that those Government population and household locational choices: 1) A projections have since been superseded (by the revised trend based approach 2004 & 2006 based population and household projections with more housing in and 2008 based population projections). rural areas / medium size towns and less in Advantages large urban areas; 2) Urban concentration • 290 is a figure that BDC has previously supported. and regeneration – • Nearer providing a 5 year land supply (but still not growth in the main cities there – 3.4 – 3.8 years). and sub-regional centres and; 3) Strong Disadvantages urban concentration – focussed growth around • Based on out of date household projections so likely the big cities with to underestimate the housing need for the District. reductions elsewhere. • Would not allow sufficient affordable housing to meet need.
(2) 340 6800 Section 4(4) In September 2006 The housing figure of 340 per year was promoted by Authority’s Leicestershire County Leicestershire County Council (in its role as section 4(4) advice Council, in their role as Authority) as part of its submission to the Regional Plan. (Leicestershire section 4(4) Authority The number of houses proposed by Leicestershire County County supported a level of Council was reduced from 350 to 340 by the County Council) that housing growth of 340 Council’s Cabinet). was submitted units per year. The to the justification for 340 units The justification for 340 units was based on the “proposal Regional was based on the to locate an urban extension to the PUA” and “the need to Planning body “proposal to locate an provide for more local needs in the large villages to the in preparing urban extension to the south of Leicester”. the RSS. PUA” and “the need to provide for more local The ‘Housing Policy justification paper’ that accompanied needs in the large the draft RSS indicated that whilst the ‘draft ‘requirements villages to the south of of 340 per year “were above the current build rate” they Leicester”. were “below the DCLG trend projection for Blaby” (which according to the draft RSS were 391 units per year between 2001 and 2026). Notwithstanding this, EMRA identified this as a suitable level of growth for Blaby in its Draft Regional Plan.
It is worth noting that Leicestershire County Council subsequently reduced its preferred housing number for Blaby to 310 per annum as part of a submission to the Regional Plan examination – this was given little weight by the Inspector who subsequently recommended 380 per year for Blaby District. Advantages
• 340 houses per year would result in a greater number of houses provided from option 1, but would not meet needs identified in household projections.
Disadvantages
• The figures are based on out of date household projections so still likely to underestimate the housing need for the District. • No clear justification (other than policy driven) • Land supply figure of 2.7 – 3.2 years
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Croft Conservation Area DesignationDECISION That the designation of a Conservation Area, as identified on the Croft Conservation Area, as identified on ...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.