RESOLVED that i) the feedback submitted by schools which identified their preferred options for the future Reactive Maintenance SLA be noted. ii) The current insurance based SLA (Option 1) was not viable, and that a ‘Pay As You Go’ (Option 2) and a service contract SLA was to be offered to all schools be noted.
Word for word from the decision Bracknell Forest published for this meeting.Source: democratic.bracknell-forest.gov.uk
1.1To report back to Schools’ Forum on the consultation with schools to change the current Service Level Agreement (SLA) for schools reactive maintenance.
Recommendations
2.1That the Schools’ Forum notes the feedback submitted by schools identifying their preferred options for the future Reactive Maintenance SLA (see Appendix 1 for details).
2.2The Schools Forum notes that the current insurance based SLA (Option 1) is not viable and a ‘Pay As You Go’ (Option 2) and service contract SLA is to be offered to all schools.
Reasons for recommendations
3.1The LA has a duty to consult Schools Forum on significant issues for schools. Reactive maintenance is a significant concern for schools to ensure the continuing safe and effective operation of school buildings.
4 ALTERNATIVE OPTIONS TO BE CONSIDERED
4.1The options offered to schools are set out in the body of the report.
5 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
Background
5.1At the last Schools’ Forum meeting (9 December 2010) a paper was presented reporting problems with the current reactive maintenance ‘insurance’ SLA and requesting the School Forum’s approval to offer the schools a ‘Pay As You Go’ SLA. At that time the consultation with schools was at an early stage and no information was available regarding what options the schools would prefer. As a result, the Schools’ Forum deferred its decision until the 3 February 2011 so that the feedback could be made available and taken into account.
Options Offered
5.2The options offered to schools were:
Option 1 - Retain and improve the current “insurance” SLA.
Option 2 - Adopt individual SLAs with each school on a ‘Pay As You Go’ basis. Option 3 - Bracknell Forest Council cease to provide a SLA and schools make their own arrangements.
5.3Schools which decide not to buy into this ‘Pay As You Go’ SLA will still be able to subscribe to the service contracts element under a separate SLA.
Feedback from School Consultation
5.437 Bracknell Council schools were consulted and the feedback on their preferred options are:
Option 1 – 0 (0%)
Option 2 – 24 (65%)
Option 3 – 4 (11%)
Service contract only – 7 (19%)
Still to reply - 2 (5%)
Due to the number of schools that have opted for a ‘Pay As You Go’ SLA (Option 2) Option 1 is no longer viable and as a result the service provided for this option will no longer be provided by the Council. If Schools that have still to reply indicate Option 1 as their preferred option they will be offered Option 2.
Should the schools that decide not to subscibe to the the Reactive Maintenance or Service Contract SLA encounter any major problems that could potentially close the school, surveyor support will still be available and the time taken dealing with the problem will be charged on a hourly basis. The cost of providing this service will be £40 per hour.
Some of the comments made by the schools on the feedback form about Option 2 are:
“Retains in-house expertise, ensures we comply with all regulations, removes area from school, gives us more control over our budget and gives us flexibility to get some jobs done elsewhere if we deem that to be better. The cuurent insurance scheme does not appear to have worked very well and has become less viable as schools pull out of the SLA, especially the secondary schools.”
“This option appears to give the best value for money and utilises the procurement/management skills and experience of Bracknell Forest LA”
“This should be the most economical option”
“Seems to be the most efficient and cost-effective option both for the school and the LA”
“Feel it would be better value for money for us – would like the option to review after one year.” “we have chosen this option as we feel that Option 1 is no longer viable and there is not enough time for us to opt out all together and get relevant contracts/cover in place. Option 2 will buy us some time when an informed choice can be made...”
“Seems the fairest way given that we prefer not to have to coordinate it all in school”
Building Group’s Performance
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.