( i ) that the three options (not mutually exclusive) for delivering efficiency savings in the street cleansing operation be noted and approved; (ii) that officers’ response to the independent review of the street cleansing service undertaken by consultants, Gordon Mackie Associates be noted.
Word for word from the decision Brent published for this meeting.Source: democracy.brent.gov.uk
1.1This report presents options for efficiency savings in the council’s street cleansing operation.
1.2This work represents part of the outcome of the One Council Waste and Street Cleansing Review.
Recommendations
2.1That the Executive note and approve three options (not mutually exclusive) for delivering efficiency savings in the street cleansing operation.
2.2That the Executive note the officers’ response to the independent review of the street cleansing service undertaken by consultants, Gordon Mackie Associates.
3.0Detail
3.1The purpose of the Waste and Street Cleansing Review is twofold – to seek to deliver an enhanced waste service and to identify and implement options for generating efficiency savings. It is intended the Review should deliver £1.2million savings and that these should be notionally split as follows;
Street Cleansing - £700K Waste Collection - £500K
3.2Proposals for waste collection were considered by the August Executive Committee and these are currently the subject of public consultation. If these are eventually approved for implementation they will deliver £1million annual savings, just short of satisfying the combined annual target.
4.0Street Cleansing Options
Street Cleansing Efficiency Savings – Executive 15th November 2010 V2.0 4.1 Options for street cleansing have now been developed through discussion with the council’s waste services contractor, Veolia. These offer a combined saving of £545K and are not mutually exclusive.
4.2There is a risk that any change to the operation could lead to deterioration in cleansing standards, particularly at the interface of cleansing zones or in areas of high footfall. This may manifest itself in more noticeable accumulations of litter, particularly during busy periods. There would be an onus on StreetCare Officers to monitor this to ensure Veolia still complied with remediation times set out in the contract.
1- Decrease of sweeping frequency on Zone 5’s (from 3 to 2/weeks) £ 465k PA 2- Rebalancing of the PM shift service £ 40k PA 3- Further integration of special collections and cleansing £ 40k PA
4.3Option 1 Decrease of sweeping frequency on Zone 5’s. ANNUAL SAVING £465K.
This is the main proposal, with the principle being a decrease in Zone 5 (residential) sweeping frequency from three times to twice per week.
Whilst this option was allowed for in the Invitation to Tender document that was drafted by the council in 2006 there remains some doubt as to whether the council can swap options during the life of the contract. This issue is addressed in more detail in paragraph 7.0 Legal Implications. In effect, bidders were asked to price for cleansing of all Zone 5s three times a week as well as cleansing of all Zone 5's twice per week, the difference between the two options being £444,100 in 2007 which would be the equivalent of £465,692.51 in 2009-10 prices (with a 0.51% 2009 uplift).
This change would necessitate making around 30-35 operatives’ positions redundant on the Veolia contract. In the current economic climate it may be difficult for Veolia to re-deploy these personnel elsewhere. The redundancy consultation period would be 90 days. The one-off cost of these redundancies is likely to be up to £80K. However, with a 4 month period for implementing the changes, Veolia may have opportunity for natural wastage and other redeployment options to mitigate this impact.
In addition, the change needed would require a major contract variation. The contract has been organised around the delivery of a number of services, and some recent investment decisions (fleet renewal, satellite depot refurbishment) have been made with the view that the cleansing service would continue as it currently is.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Minutes of the previous meeting- that the minutes of the previous meeting held on 22 April 2014 be approved as an accurate record of the meeting. - ...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.