CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Bridgend County Borough Council
Development Control Committee, Thursday 23 July 2015

P/15/213/FUL - Land Rear of Dale View, Cefn Cribwr - Proposed Detached 1 1/2 Storey Dwelling with Integral Garage

Decided Planning 1 paper

Development Control Committee decided this item on Thursday 23 July 2015. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item598

Resolved

That the planning application be granted subject to the conditions contained in the report of the Corporate Director – Communities.
Word for word from the decision Bridgend published for this meeting. Source: democratic.bridgend.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Bridgend's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Control Committee

RECOMMENDATION : GRANT WITH CONDITIONS

REFERENCE: P/15/213/FUL APPLICANT: MR G DOWER 11 BEACH ROAD PORTHCAWL

LOCATION: LAND REAR OF DALE VIEW CEFN CRIBWR

PROPOSAL: PROPOSED DETACHED 1 1/2 STOREY DWELLING WITH INTEGRAL GARAGE

RECEIVED: 31st March 2015

SITE INSPECTED: 14th April 2015

APPLICATION/SITE DESCRIPTION

The application is referred to the Development Control Committee for determination at the request of the Local Member and in view of the number of objections from local residents and the Community Council.

The application seeks consent to erect a dormer bungalow to the rear of 1-10 Dale View.

The application site originally formed part of the overall site for 40 dwellings on Dale View granted planning permission in 1978. A condition was attached to the 1978 consent requiring the implementation of a scheme of landscaping for the open areas within the development and for their maintenance together with the provision of a footpath along the Cwm Ffoes frontage of the site and to erect a boundary fence.

In 1983, in his decision letter, the Welsh Office Inspector appointed to determine an appeal against the refusal of planning permission for residential development on this land commented that this condition had not been complied with and in view of the condition of the site, it had not been used by the residents in the way it was intended. A considerable period of time has elapsed since the 1978 grant of planning permission and the appeal decision referred to above during which time provision of landscaping and maintenance of the area has not been pursued. It is not considered that it would be practicable to pursue the non-provision of the facility at this stage.

More recently, an outline application for a dwelling was refused on the site (P/05/287/OUT refers) for highway safety reasons. A further outline application (P/06/133/OUT refers) was submitted for a single dwelling on this site, the highway concerns were overcome in this instance, however, the application was refused due to the loss of public open space and the adverse effect it would have on the residents of Dale View, the refusal was upheld at a subsequent appeal (APP/F6915/A/06/1198806 refers), where first hand evidence was heard that the site had been used by local children as an informal play area. In 2007 a full application for a single dwelling was submitted (P/07/1477/FUL refers) but was withdrawn prior to determination.

In the appeal decision (APP/F6915/A/06/1198806 refers) the Inspector in his report stated "In terms of Policy RC3 (of the Bridgend Unitary Development Plan), and despite the lack of positive provision and maintenance for amenity purposes, I consider that the site can be regarded as 'an existing or proposed recreational facility'. That being the case, I am in no doubt that the proposed development would adversely affect it. In the previous appeal decision the development then proposed was found to cause a serious and unacceptable loss of amenity for adjoining residents and although this was some time ago there are no changed circumstances sufficient to lead me to a different conclusion in respect of the proposal before me. I do not find that any of the three criteria in the Policy are met, and the Appellant has not argued otherwise. Therefore I conclude that the appeal scheme is also contrary to Policy RC3".

A further application was submitted in 2009 for a detached bungalow on the site (P/09/268/FUL refers). This application was also refused on grounds that the site was previously used as open space in association with Dale View and its loss would be detrimental to the general amenities of the area.

RELEVANT HISTORY

P/05/287/OUT REFUSED 29-04-2005 ERECTION OF DETACHED DWELLING

P/06/133/OUT REFUSED 18-04-2006 ERECTION OF SINGLE DETACHED DWELLING (RE-SUBMISSION OF PREVIOUS REFUSAL P/05/287/OUT - 29/04/05)

P/09/268/FUL REFUSED 28-08-2009 PROPOSED DETACHED BUNGALOW

PUBLICITY

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
P/15/213/FUL: Land Rear of Dale View, Cefn Cribwr: Proposed Detached 1 1/2 Storey Dwelling with Integral GarageReport 642 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
588Site VisitsDecided 589Approval of MinutesApproved 592Amendment SheetOn the agenda 593P/15/60/FUL - Land at the Rhiw Multi Storey Car Park Walkway Bridge & Entrance, Bridgend - Demolish & Rebuild Car Park: Erect 5 Storeys Residential / Commercial Block (Class A1/A2/A3 & 28 Dwellings with Parking)On the agenda 594P/14/711/FUL - Former Bryncethin Nurseries & S Wales Wood Recycling Pant Hirwaun Heol Y Cyw - C/U Former Nursery & Dwelling to Vehicle Storage New Buildings Access Wood Fuelled Boilers & Wood Drying FacilityDeferred 595P/15/110/OUT - Bayswater Tubes Site Heol-Y-Geifr Pencoed - Construct 47 Dwellings & Associated Works (Outline)Deferred 596P/15/185/FUL - Land off Church Street, Pontycymmer - Development of 5 Detached Houses with Associated GaragesDecided 597P/15/196/OUT - Rear Garden of the Cottage, Coychurch - 2 No. Dormer Bungalows (Outline Application)Decided
598P/15/213/FUL - Land Rear of Dale View, Cefn Cribwr - Proposed Detached 1 1/2 Storey Dwelling with Integral GarageThis decision
599P/15/342/FUL - South West Field at Island Farm, Bridgend - Use of Existing Agricultural Access on a Temporary Basis to Facilitate P/14/823/RESApproved 600P/15/48/FUL - Sandford, Bryneglwys Avenue, Porthcawl - Demolish Existing Dwelling & Replace with New 3 Bed DwellingApproved 601P/15/25/FUL - Playing Field at Ysgol Bryn Castell, Llangewydd Road, Bryntirion - Erection of 67 Dwellings, New Access, Car Parking, Open Space, Landscaping & Associated WorksAgreed 602P/15/194/FUL - Ael Y Don, Ty Fry Road, Cefn Cribwr - Single Storey Rear Extension & Double Two Storey Domestic Garage, Store, Study & Gym in Rear Garden (Amended Desc)Decided 603P/15/364/FUL - 9 Caldy Close, Porthcawl - Amendments to Planning Consent P/14/74/FUL to Include Ground Floor ExtensionAgreed 604P/15/179/RLX - Land Adj 13 Heol Tre Dwr, Waterton - Extend Consent P/10/836/FUL (4 Bed Detached Property & Childrens Play Area) for a further Five YearsDecided 605AppealsNoted 606Training LogNoted

Who was there

13 of 29 attended
NC
Councillor Norah ClarkeCommittee Member, present
SD
Sarah DanielOfficer, in attendance
PD
Councillor Pam DaviesCommittee Member, apologies
WD
Councillor Wyn Davies MBECommittee Member, present
JD
Jane DessentOfficer, in attendance
SE
Stephen EdwardsOfficer, in attendance
CF
Craig FlowerOfficer, in attendance
NG
Nicola GandyOfficer, in attendance
CG
Councillor Cheryl GreenCommittee Member, present
JJ
Julie JenkinsOfficer, in attendance
CJ
Councillor Cherie JonesCommittee Member, present
RJ
Rod JonesOfficer, in attendance

All 29 on the meeting page

On this subject at Bridgend

Search all
  1. P/15/213/FUL - Land Rear of Dale View, Cefn Cribwr - Proposed Detached 1 1/2 Storey Dwelling with Integral GarageThis decision
  2. P/22/716/FUL - Land to the South of Felindre Road, Pencoed, CF35 5HUApproved
  3. P/23/92/FUL - Land South of Former St. Johns School, (North of 22 Bryneglwys Gardens,) Newton, Porthcawl, CF36 5PRApproved
  4. P/23/218/FUL - Land at Brynmenyn and Bryncethin, BridgendAgreed
  5. P/22/756/FUL - Land at Bridgend Police Station & former Cheapside multi- storey car park, Bridgend, CF31 1BZRefused
  6. P/22/484/FUL - Land at Primrose Stables, Old Coachman’s Lane Court Colman, Bridgend, CF31 4NGAgreed

More from Bridgend Development Control Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
19 Oct 2023 Site VisitsThat a date for any site visits agreed by the Committee or identified in advance of the next meeting by the Chairpers... Agreed Open
19 Oct 2023 Approval of MinutesThat the Minutes of a meeting of the Development Control Committee dated 7 September 2023, be approved as a true and ... Approved Open
19 Oct 2023 Amendment SheetThe was accepted by the Chairperson as an urgent item under Part 4, paragraph 4 of the Council Procedure Rules. Decided Open
19 Oct 2023 Development Control Committee GuidanceThat the report of the Corporate Director – Communities, outlining the be noted. Noted Open
19 Oct 2023 P/23/147/FUL - Rear of 82 Merthyr Mawr Road, Bridgend, CF31 3NSThat the above application be granted, subject to the Conditions contained in the report of the Corporate Director – ... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies