RESOLVED that permission be refused, the precise wording to be delegated to the Head of Neighbourhoods and Prosperity in conjunction with the Vice Chair and that enforcement action be authorised. Reason The proposed development by virtue of its massing, scale and siting close to the northeast boundary would have an overbearing and oppressive impact on the neighbouring property at No.67 Newdigate Road resulting in an unacceptable loss of amenity for the occupiers of this neighbouring property, contrary to Policy H11 of the Broxtowe Local plan (2004) and Policy 10 of the Aligned Core Strategy (2014). (Councillor M Radulovic MBE, having declared a non-pecuniary interest, left the meeting before debate or voting.)
Word for word from the decision Broxtowe published for this meeting.Source: democracy.broxtowe.gov.uk
Councillor Jill Owen requested this application be determined by the Planning Committee.
1 Details of the Application
1.1The application seeks retrospective planning permission to retain extensions to an existing outbuilding, positioned to the rear of the dwelling, and to retain a single storey summerhouse, positioned in the north west corner of the application site.
1.2The original outbuilding structure forms the eastern section of the current building to be retained and is 11.94m in length with a width of 4.295m and ridge height of 3.35m. The works requiring planning permission extend the building by 7.0m to the north west with the extension having a width of 5.15m. The total size of the outbuilding, including the extensions is 80.683 sq.m.
1.3The summerhouse has already been erected in the north corner of the rear garden and has a width of 4.15m with a total length of 6.4m, ridge height of 2.8m and eaves height of 2.0m.
2 Site and Surroundings
2.1The application property is a two storey detached residential dwelling, occupying a large plot on the corner of Newdigate Road and Cloverlands Drive.
2.2The application property has one immediate neighbour to the north with this boundary made up of a wooden panel fence, circa 1.8m high, and a hedge, circa 2m high. The boundary to the rear is a 1.9m high wooden fence with residential flats occupying the land adjoining the site. The south boundary adjoins Cloverlands Drive with the boundary made up of a 2m high wooden fence with a hedge on the road side of the boundary. There is an existing access to the rear garden from this road.
35 Planning Committee 20 June 2018
North West elevation of extensions. Relationship between outbuilding Also shows relationship with and boundary adjoining 67 protected tree. Newdigate Road.
Relationship between outbuilding Front elevation of original dwelling. and boundary adjoining 67 Newdigate Road.
36 Planning Committee 20 June 2018
View from rear window of neighbouring Summerhouse in north corner of rear property (67 Newdigate Road). garden.
View of development from Cloverlands Drive.
3 Relevant Planning History
3.165 Newdigate Road has been subject to four previous planning applications for the construction of a new residential dwelling to the rear of the original dwelling, all of which have been refused planning permission.
3.2In 2007, an outline planning application (ref: 07/00861/OUT) was submitted applying for the construction of a two storey dwelling to the far end of the rear garden. The application was refused on the grounds that the site could not accommodate an additional dwelling that would not cause unacceptable harm to the roots of the trees on the site, especially the tree protected by a TPO. A second reason cited was that it would cause an unacceptable loss of privacy and amenity to the occupiers of the new dwelling and neighbouring properties.
3.3In 2011, an application was submitted (ref: 11/00250/FUL) for a two storey detached dwelling to be erected on the same site. The application was refused planning permission on the grounds of design by virtue that the scale and massing would be out of keeping with and have an unacceptable impact on the character and appearance of the immediate area. It was also considered that due to the proximity of the proposed dwelling to the northern boundaries on the site it would result in a cramped and overbearing form of development which would have an adverse impact on the amenity of the occupiers of the adjacent property. A further reason given for refusal was that the occupants of the proposed dwelling would have a poor standard of amenity due to the extent of overshadowing on the site caused by existing protected trees, which would likely result in pressure to cut back or remove the trees in the future.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.