AI summaryBroxtowe Cabinet defers decision on £50,000 budget for a Community Governance Review in South Broxtowe, pending clarity on the government's pause to Local Government Reorganisation.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDeferredBudget allocation not approved at this meeting
Money£50,000 proposed, not approvedFrom General Fund Reserves, deferred
What happens nextAwait central government clarificationOn Local Government Reorganisation plans
Who it affectsUnparished areas of South BroxtowePotential creation of new parish councils
What was decided
Cabinet deferred a decision on allocating £50,000 from General Fund Reserves towards a Community Governance Review for the unparished areas of South Broxtowe. Report P2
The deferral was agreed so the Council can seek clarification from central government on the pause to Local Government Reorganisation before committing funds. Report P12
Why
The Government has announced a pause to Local Government Reorganisation, creating uncertainty about the timeframe and scope available to the Council. Report P12, P34
Under the current LGR timetable, there is unlikely to be enough time to complete and implement a Community Governance Review before responsibility transfers to the successor authority. Report P12, P36
Once the LGR transitional period begins, existing principal councils can no longer make Reorganisation of Community Governance Orders, with the power transferring to the successor authority. Report P15, P34
What happens next
Wait for clarification from central government on Local Government Reorganisation plans before reconsidering the £50,000 budget allocation.
The Community Governance Review Task and Finish Group will continue to consider and make recommendations on the scope of any review to the Governance, Audit and Standards Committee and Council. Report P19
The money
£50,000 Proposed budget from General Fund Reserves for a Community Governance Review in South Broxtowe; deferred Report P2, P31
Options considered
Rejected: Approve £50,000 budget for a Community Governance Review focused on creating new parish councils in unparished South Broxtowe. Deferred pending clarity on Local Government Reorganisation pause Report P2
Rejected: Wider review of existing parish boundaries, warding and governance arrangements. Considered too complex and unlikely to be completed before LGR transitional period Report P17, P35
Implications
Financial: No current budget provision for a Community Governance Review; £50,000 would have to come from General Fund Reserves, and total costs may exceed this. Report P4, P31
Legal: The statutory framework for Community Governance Reviews is in Part 4 of the Local Government and Public Involvement in Health Act 2007. Report P6, P33
Risk: Once the LGR transitional period starts, the power to make Reorganisation of Community Governance Orders transfers to the successor authority, limiting what Broxtowe can complete. Report P15, P34
Staffing: The Council lacks sufficient internal capacity or specialist expertise to run a review of this scale while maintaining existing governance, legal and electoral functions. Report P22
Who and where
Residents of the unparished areas of South Broxtowe Report P14, P16
Existing parish councils and stakeholders who may participate in any future consultation Report P18
The Community Governance Review Task and Finish Group Report P13, P19
Timeline
October 2021: First Community Governance Review commenced; did not agree parish arrangements for the north of the Borough Report P11
December 2023: Second Community Governance Review commenced; also did not agree northern parish arrangements Report P11
December 2024: Council agreed to commence a further Community Governance Review after May 2025 to resolve outstanding boundary issues; not yet begun Report P11
20 July 2026: Governance, Audit and Standards Committee re-established the Task and Finish Group and agreed to consider creating new parish councils in unparished South Broxtowe Report P13
Late 2026 or early 2027: Structural Changes Order expected, followed by LGR transitional arrangements and elections to successor authorities Report P12, P34
Approximately eight weeks: Anticipated single consultation period for a review focused on new parish councils in unparished South Broxtowe Report P16, P37
Plain English for the jargon
Community Governance Review (CGR): Legal process under the Local Government and Public Involvement in Health Act 2007 used to consider parish arrangements such as creating, merging, altering or abolishing parishes.
Local Government Reorganisation (LGR): Government programme to reorganise local authority structures, including in Nottinghamshire, with a Structural Changes Order expected in late 2026 or early 2027.
Structural Changes Order: The order that gives effect to Local Government Reorganisation, after which transitional arrangements begin and some powers transfer to successor authorities.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item41
Resolved
RESOLVED that a decision on the allocation of a budget of £50,000 towards the costs of undertaking a to consider the creation of new parish/town councils within the unparished areas of South Broxtowe be deferred until there was more clarity following the government’s announcement to pause Local Government Reorganisation. Reason The deferral would allow for clarification to be submitted from central government on plans for Local Government Reorganisation.
Word for word from the decision Broxtowe published for this meeting.Source: democracy.broxtowe.gov.uk
1. A budget of £50,000 be allocated from General Fund Reserves towards the anticipated costs of undertaking a Community Governance Review to consider the creation of new town and/or parish councils within the unparished areas of South Broxtowe.
2. Authority be delegated to the Monitoring Officer, in consultation with the Resources and Personnel Policy Portfolio Holder, to procure and appoint suitably qualified external consultants, within the approved budget, to provide specialist advice and undertake the work required to progress the Community Governance Review.
Cabinet is also asked to NOTE that the full scope and associated cost of the Community Governance Review will not be known until the initial scoping exercise has been completed and, should additional funding be required, a further report will be presented to Cabinet for consideration.
3. Detail
A Community Governance Review (CGR) is the legal process used to consider parish arrangements, as outlined in the Local Government and Public Involvement in Health Act 2007.
The Council has a duty to keep parish arrangements within its area under review to ensure that their boundaries and electoral arrangements remain appropriate.
CGRs are instigated either at the discretion of the principal council (Broxtowe Borough Council), or in response to a valid Community Governance Petition or Community Governance Application and can consider one or more of the following:
• the creation, merger, alteration or abolition of parishes; • the naming of parishes and the style of new parishes; Cabinet 8 September 2026
• the electoral arrangements for parishes (i.e. the ordinary year of election, council size, number of councillors to be elected to the council, and parish warding); and • the grouping or de-grouping of parishes.
The Council commenced CGRs in both October 2021 and December 2023 but neither review was able to satisfactorily agree the parish arrangements for the north of the Borough. In December 2024, Council agreed to commence a further CGR after May 2025 to resolve the outstanding boundary issues, although this has not yet begun.
Since that decision, the Government's Local Government Reorganisation (LGR) programme has progressed significantly. Based on the current LGR timetable, there will not be sufficient time for the Council to undertake, conclude and implement a review of existing parish boundaries and governance arrangements before the anticipated Structural Changes Order, expected in late 2026 or early 2027, and the commencement of transitional arrangements.
At a meeting of the Governance, Audit and Standards Committee on 20 July 2026, it was agreed to re-establish the Community Governance Review Task and Finish Group and agreed consideration should be given to the creation of new parish councils within the unparished areas in the south of Broxtowe. The Committee also agreed that the Task and Finish Group should consider and make recommendations regarding the scope of any wider CGR work.
The purpose of this report is to seek funding in relation to a CGR focused on the potential creation of new parish councils within the unparished areas of the south of Broxtowe.
The Council is able to commence a CGR notwithstanding the ongoing programme of LGR. Guidance confirms that existing principal councils may continue to undertake CGRs during the reorganisation period. However, once the LGR transitional period commences, existing principal councils are unable to make Reorganisation of Community Governance Orders. The power to make such an order transfers to the successor authority.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.