Resolved
Since the Cambridge Sub-Regional Retail Study was completed in October 2008, there have been a number of changes to the level of housing development proposed in the North West (NW) quadrant of Cambridge at the University Site, NIAB sites and Orchard Park, and proposals for larger scale foodstore provision have emerged from discussions with the developers of the three sites. The sites in NW Cambridge fall within both Cambridge City Council and South Cambridgeshire District Council (SCDC) and both Councils considered that they needed to jointly investigate further the food retailing needs of this part of Cambridge along with associated transport and other planning implications to ensure that both new and existing residents have adequate food retailing facilities available. The aim is to produce joint informal planning policy guidance (IPPG) on foodstore provision in NW Cambridge in order to provide an up to date supplement to retail policies in existing plans and help to guide the future planning of the three sites. The first step in developing the Informal Planning Policy Guidance is to prepare an Options Report (Appendix A) for public consultation prior to taking a view on the preferred policy approach. The Options Report sets out the advantages and disadvantages of each option, using information from the evidence base. Decision of Exec Cllr for Climate Change and Growth: Agreed: a) To approve the draft Options Report on Foodstore Provision in North West Cambridge (Appendix A of the report) for public consultation. b) To approve the consultation arrangements as set out in Paragraphs 3.14 to 3.15 including the Schedule of Consultees in Appendix D of the report. An additional recommendation was tabled at the meeting and this was also agreed. c) To agree that any editing changes arising from South Cambridgeshire’s New Communities Portfolio Holder meeting on 13th July, be considered and endorsed by the Executive Councillor, in consultation with the Chair and Spokes prior to public participation. Reason for the Large scale development is proposed in the North West (NW) quadrant of Cambridge at the University Site (covered by the North West Area Action Plan NW AAP, 2008), NIAB sites and Orchard Park. This will result in an additional 7,000 dwellings and 2,000 student units by 2021. Since the Cambridge Sub-Regional Retail Study was completed in October 2008, there have been a number of changes to the level of housing development proposed in the NW of Cambridge. The amount of housing now proposed is nearly 2,000 greater than was originally envisaged when the Councils were preparing the formal planning policy documents. In addition proposals for larger scale foodstore provision have emerged from discussions with the developers of the three sites. Any alternative options considered and rejected: The aim is to produce joint informal planning policy guidance (IPPG) on foodstore provision in NW Cambridge in order to provide an up to date supplement to retail policies in existing plans and help to guide the future planning of the three sites. The plan led system would normally require a revised statutory planning policy to be prepared where a new approach to development is proposed. However, in the context of current developer aspirations and the need to increase the overall supply of market and affordable housing in Cambridge, it is not practicable to follow this route because of the timeframe involved in preparing a DPD. Nor is it possible to prepare a Supplementary Planning Document because there are no statutory policies with which the proposed approach would be entirely consistent and which it could therefore supplement. Scrutiny Considerations: The Senior Planning Policy Officer introduced the report and explained some proposed minor amendments and some additional diagrams illustrating the design concept of ‘wrapping and capping’ foodstores. In response to questions about these diagrams the Head of the Joint Urban Design Team explained that the definition of the public square was loose and this could include parking. Cllr Pogonowski suggested a very different approach could be taken with a range of local shops instead of a large supermarket. Cllr Blair responded that such centres had been in the original plans. However, developers can put forward any proposals they like. The existing provision is not meeting local need and the public consultation is designed to give an evidence base for future decisions that can be defended. As part of agreeing the preferred approach, a balance will need to be struck between the views received through consultation and the evidence base. Members were reminded that this is not intended to be a debate about which brand of supermarket is desirable. Cllr Znajek felt that the report was difficult to understand as there appeared to be very little to choose between the various options and the traffic consultations appeared inconclusive. He also recommended that the terms quantitative and qualitative need are defined in the glossary. Some members felt that consultation was unhelpful because the decision would be made by who ever decided to build a supermarket regardless of the result of the consultations. Cllr Blair reminded the committee that both Councils had made a commitment to consult the public. Debate followed on which option offered the greater choice to customers, one superstore, two supermarkets or the current policy baseline position of smaller supermakets. Members suggested the report could give more weight to the advantages of smaller supermarkets in the policy baseline position and could highlight the advantages of balance and vibrancy in the local centres of the developments. The Officer explained that this could be done, but that the Supplementary Retail Study had shown that staying with the current policy baseline position would not meet quantitative and qualitative retail need and there would still be a high proportion of people travelling outside the area to do their main food shopping. Evidence shows that currently approximately 84% of people in the NW of Cambridge are travelling elsewhere to locations such as the Tesco stores at Milton and Bar Hill. The Head of Policy & Projects reminded members that they cannot control who buys the site. The public are not expected to give expert or technical responses. Instead the consultation is looking for the human response. All responses will be noted and reported back to members. A tour of the sites was agreed to be unhelpful as they are currently green fields. However, detailed plans are available. Members agreed that a 3rd bullet point at paragraph 6.3 of the draft Options Report (in Appendix A) relating to Option A, planned development only, should be strengthened with regards to the potential advantage of small shops in providing more of a balance and vibrancy to the local centres with the wording agreed by the Executive Councillor in consultation with the Chair and Spokes. As this is a joint City and South Cambs DC document any changes will need to be agreed by both authorities. The Scrutiny Committee considered and endorsed the recommendations. The Executive Councillor for Climate Change and Growth agreed the proposal subject to the amendments detailed above. Conflicts of interest declared by the Executive Councillor (and any dispensations granted) N/A