Item11/5/DPSSC
Resolved
An Options Report on Foodstore Provision in North West Cambridge produced jointly with South Cambridgeshire District Council (SCDC) was approved for public consultation following the City Council’s Development Plan Scrutiny Sub Committee and South Cambridgeshire’s Portfolio Holder’s Committee both in July 2010. Public consultation took place for six weeks between 6 th September and 18 th October 2010. Officers had analysed consultation responses. Taking these into account, as well as the evidence base used to develop the Options Report a proposed approach had been put forward to developing Informal Planning Policy Guidance (IPPG) on foodstore provision in NW Cambridge. The analysis and recommendations are provided in the report at Appendix A of this Committee Report. The proposed approach is to take forward Option B, two medium sized supermarkets of 2,000 sq m net floorspace, one in the Local Centre at the University site and one in the Local Centre at the NIAB site, and the small pipeline supermarket at the Orchard Park Local Centre. Decision of Exec Cllr for Climate Change and Growth: I. Considered and approved the content of the report attached at Appendix A of the report, ‘Foodstore Provision in North West Cambridge - Analysis of Public Consultation Responses and Proposed Approach for Developing Informal Planning Policy Guidance’ and approved the approach suggested in the conclusions for developing the Informal Planning Policy Guidance. II. Agreed that any changes in approach that may arise from SCDC’s Portfolio Holder’s Meeting on 25 th January be considered and agreed by the Executive Councillor in consultation with Chair and Spokes. Reason for the Large scale development is proposed in the North West (NW) quadrant of Cambridge at the University Site (covered by the North West Area Action Plan NW AAP, 2008), NIAB sites and Orchard Park. The amount of housing now proposed is nearly 2,000 greater than was originally envisaged when Cambridge City Council and South Cambridgeshire District Council were preparing their formal planning policy documents. In addition proposals for foodstore provision have emerged from discussions with the developers of the three sites. The Councils considered that they needed to jointly investigate the food retailing needs of this part of Cambridge further to ensure that both new and existing residents have adequate food retailing facilities available. The County Council have provided input with regards to transport matters. Any alternative options considered and rejected: An Options Report was presented to the City Council’s Development Plan Steering Group Committee on 13 th July 2010, and South Cambridgeshire’s Portfolio Holder’s Committee Meeting also on 13 th July. This set out four possible options for foodstore development in North West Cambridge: · Option A - Planned Development Only i.e. local foodstores in each of the three Local Centres (this is the policy baseline situation, with the committed and pipeline floorspace and no further foodstore provision) · Option B – Two supermarkets of 2,000 sq m net floorspace (1,500 sq m net convenience), one at the University site and one at NIAB and the committed floorspace at Orchard Park. · Option C – One superstore of 3,500 sq m net floorspace (2,500 sq m net convenience), at the University site and the committed / pipeline floorspace at NIAB and Orchard Park · Option D – One superstore of 3,500 sq m net floorspace (2,500 sq m net convenience), at the NIAB site and the committed / pipeline floorspace at the University Site and Orchard Park. Scrutiny Considerations: The Committee received a report from the Senior Planning Officer regarding the ‘Foodstore Provision in North West Cambridge’. She outlined the consultation process. Members raised the following matters: I. Cllr Pogonowski questioned the results of the consultation exercise as some of the responses appeared to have been wrongly classified resulting in an incorrect count. The officer explained that the Consultees selected the classification themselves. Cllr Pogonowski argued in favour of Option A, small local shops, and suggested this option had been rejected unfairly. He argued that the City Council had an opportunity to set a new trend, to increase their green credentials and to reduce car use. II. Members had sympathy with this point of view. However, this part of the City lacked supermarket provision and those who responded to the consultation had asked for this to be provided. Councillors felt balance was needed and an underused local centre with residents driving to supermarkets further away for their weekly shop would not serve the community. Using the supermarket as a community anchor point with smaller shops around it was agreed to be the best approach. III. Members asked for clarity on the size of the proposed store and how 2,000 sq m net floorspace compared to existing supermarkets. The officer clarified that this would be larger that the City Centre Sainsbury’s but smaller than the Tesco at Milton. The building will be completed to a high standard in terms of sustainable design and construction and should be viewed as the finished design, as extension may compromise some of these measures such as maximising natural day lighting. IV. Integrating smaller stores and outlets with the design of the main store was discussed. Permeability for bicycles and pedestrians would be given high priority. Arbury Court was cited as a good example of a local centre that has mixed outlets and is not dominated by the supermarket. Lessons had also been learnt from Orchard Park about the desirability of leaving flexible space for markets or events. V. Clarity was requested about the visual aspect of the designs. The stores would be a ‘wrap and cap’ design to avoid blank walls and to encourage active frontages on three sides. VI. Using the planning process to ensure a variety of outlets in the Local Centres was discussed. The supermarkets could be restricted from providing a pharmacy or a coffee shop. However, such an approach might result in no provision at all. This would need to be discussed in more detail at the planning application stage. The developer would have a plan in mind for the desired tenants of the smaller shops however, this would be largely market led. A vibrant mixed use centre was envisaged. VII. Members agreed that early delivery of the local centres and the foodstores was important for the early settlers of these developments as a focus for the new communities. The Scrutiny Committee considered and endorsed the recommendations in the report by 5 votes to 1. The Executive Councillor for Climate Change and Growth agreed the recommendations. Conflicts of interest declared by the Executive Councillor (and any dispensations granted) N/A
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.
Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk