Decision The officers recommendation of approval was rejected by 0 votes to 7 (unanimous) The application was REFUSED by 7 votes to 0 (unanimously). The Committee discussed the following reasons for refusal and the related policies: 1) In the absence of an appropriate scheme for the redevelopment of the site of the building to be demolished the demolition of the building cannot be justified. 2) By reason of its location and scale the present building makes a modest, but positive, contribution to the character and appearance of the City of Cambridge Conservation Area No.1 (Central). Since the proposed replacement development is considered to be in conflict with development plan policy and would not bring substantial benefits to the community, demolition of the building is not justified. The proposal is therefore contrary to policy 4/11 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2006), and guidance provided by PPS5 Planning and the Historic Environment.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
Application 10/0105/CAC Agenda Number Item Date Received 15th February 2010 Officer [name removed] Date 12th April 2010 Ward Market Site Garden House Hotel Granta Place Cambridge Cambridgeshire CB2 1RT Proposal Conservation area consent to demolish an existing single storey leisure club. Applicant C/o Unex House 132-134 Hills Road Cambridge Cambridgeshire CB2 8PA
1.0SITE DESCRIPTION/AREA CONTEXT
1.1Accessed from Mill Lane into Granta Place the site, approximately 1.47hectares, is located on the eastern bank of the River Cam to the south of the City Centre. It is a particularly prominent and visible site within the Central Conservation Area (Area No.1) largely due to its elongated shape, which is surrounded by open green belt land affording long uninterrupted views across to the site.
1.2The application site accommodates the Doubletree Hilton Hotel, formerly known as the Garden House Hotel. The hotel was reconstructed in the mid 1960’s and then altered and extended following major fire damage in 1972. Further extensions were carried out in the 1980’s and 1990’s when a leisure club and swimming pool were incorporated. The current hotel is a bulky building of two phases; the majority of the building constructed in 1972 and the remaining of the pre-1972 hotel that was not destroyed in the fire. These sit uncomfortably with one another with different architectural approaches, further disjointed by the leisure centre to the far south of the building on the site. 1.3 The site’s linear nature, on a north to south axis, presents a significant frontage along the River Cam to the West. The building is in close proximity to the listed Peterhouse College and the Fitzwilliam Museum. The linear nature also presents issues for access, entrances and the servicing of the Hotel with the car park located to the south, approximately 125 metres from the main entrance on Granta Place. Most visitors arriving by car use a secondary entrance adjacent to the car park.
1.4Beyond the large car park, and lying along the length of the southern boundary of the hotel, is Coe Fen, which is classified as part of the city’s Green Belt. There is little in the way of screening onto this fen area. Additionally, there is a wall that belongs to Peterhouse College and is listed.
1.5To summarise, the site is allocated as part of the City Centre in the Cambridge Local Plan (2006); the site falls within Conservation Area No.1 (Central); the building is not listed or a Building of Local Interest; there is a Tree Preservation Order (1988) on the site protecting 4 trees; the site falls within the controlled parking zone; and while the site is not located within the Green Belt, designated green belt surrounds the site immediately adjacent to the east, south and west
2.0THE PROPOSAL
2.1This application seeks Conservation Area Consent for demolition of the existing leisure club, a single storey element at the south-eastern end of the existing hotel building. This application for consent is submitted in conjunction with an application for full planning permission, planning reference 10/0103/FUL which proposed the construction an extension to the existing hotel which will comprise 56 additional bedrooms to the 122 which currently exist to result in a total of 178 guest bedrooms.
2.1The application is accompanied by the following supporting information:
1. Design and Access Statement 2. Planning Statement 3. Heritage Assessment and Conservation Area Assessment; 4. Arboriculture Survey 3.0 SITE HISTORY
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.