Resolved
I. To consider the draft Local Transport Plan 3 (LTP3) and agree any proposed changes. II. To agree that officers draft a statement of support on the basis of the principles set out in paragraphs 7 to 7.3, and for this to be agreed by the Executive Councillor in consultation with Chair & Spokes prior to submission to the County Council. Decision of Exec Cllr for Climate Change and Growth I. Noted the draft Local Transport Plan 3 II. Agreed that officers would draft a qualified statement of support on the basis of the principles set out in paragraphs 7 to 7.3 of the report and subject to changes outlined by Members being made, and for this to be agreed by the Executive Councillor in consultation with Chair & Spokes prior to submission to the County Council. Reason for the I. The County Council is required by the Transport Act 2000 and the Local Transport Act 2008 to produce a third Local Transport Plan for the period from April 2011. The coalition Government has confirmed the continued role of LTPs as a key tool in delivering transport investment and services at the local level. II. LTP3 is made up of two documents, the Policy and Strategy Document (Appendix A) and the Implementation Plan (Appendix B). The LTP sets out existing and future transport issues for Cambridgeshire and includes a strategy to address those issues. III. The plan must state how the County Council intends to spend the transport funding received from the government, and other sources, in order to overcome specific issues. IV. The County Council had asked the City Council and District Councils to consider the plan and put forward any comments prior to their Cabinet meeting of 22 nd February and Full Council on 29 th March. LTP3 will be submitted to the Government on 31 st March 2011. Any alternative options considered and rejected: N/A Scrutiny Considerations: The committee received a report from the Transport Planner regarding the LTP 3. He also tabled an update to take in to account the £3m cut to the bus subsidy announced by the County Council. In response to member’s questions the officer stated that the previous plan had not been a massive success. Air quality had recently begun to move in the right direction and there had been moderate progress on public transport. The committee made the following comments in response to the report. I. Is money being spent in the right way? II. The guided bus is an on-going drain on resources III. LTP3 had no resources to deliver improvements IV. Withdrawal of funding for safety measures was a mistake and this would be feed back to the County Council as a concern. Councillor Blair shared many of the concerns raised. However, LTP3 did not cover the aspirations of a bid to the Local Sustainable Transport Fund. This bid would be submitted in April and much would depend on the outcome of that bid. Councillor Hipkin joined the committee to consider this item and made the following comments: I. There is an inherent tension in the document between the aspiration for growth and the lack of funding for an infrastructure to support this. II. He was pleased to see that the report highlighted the link between transport and land use but suggested it offered no solutions. III. It is time for a radical rethink of growth targets that were unrealistic in the current economic climate. IV. Seeking to reduce commuter journeys at a time of bus cuts is unrealistic. V. Improvements to the A14 are vital and until an alternative plan is agreed air pollution cannot be addressed. Children attending Orchard Park school are expose to pollution and this is not being addressed. VI. Parts of Fenland are amongst the most deprived areas in Europe and Cambridge, as an affluent hubs, should share its advantages. VII. Housing growth could be moved to Wisbech or March with a light rail network to support it. VIII. Joint Leader meetings that had agreed to push ahead with growth plans and this lacked public input and was not in line with the Localism agenda. The Head of Planning reminded members that the previous Regional Spatial Strategy as discussed on October had lead to a joint statement on target numbers. The delivery phase of that process was now underway. A joint position statement on the A14 was also agreed in October when the LTP3 was not available. She suggested taking a pragmatic view and not revisiting previous decisions. The Planning Policy Manager suggested that the report did no accurately reflect the current position regarding the A14 and this would be reflected back to the County Council. A group would be set up to consider the A14 and interim measure would be needed to allow planned development to continue. Peter Studdert was working with developer on both the University and the NIAB schemes to ensure that the A14 does not delay developments. It was agreed that a response from the City to the County was needed. Members expressed the view that they could support the guiding principles of the document but were unable to agree some aspect of the strategy. Members were reminded that previously they had responded negatively to plans for the A14 and the scheme had been rejected. The Planning Policy Manager would circulate a copy of the response letter sent to the County on that occasion. Action In response to member’s questions, officers confirmed that the County did not need a positive response from the City in order to continue with plans. Members agreed that it would be better to engage with the process but to highlight pertinent issues in order to have some influence. Other District Council had taken this approach. Pipeline bids, such as Chesterton Railway Station were dependent on support of the document. Members felt able to support the general principles set out in paragraphs 7 to 7.3 but felt unable to fully sign up to the plan until their concerns with certain aspects of the plan had been allayed. The Scrutiny Committee considered and endorsed the amended recommendations in the report by 4 votes to 1. The Executive Councillor for Climate Change and Growth agreed the decision. Conflicts of interest declared by the Executive Councillor (and any dispensations granted) N/A