Resolved
Officers last reported on this matter at the January 18 2011 meeting of the Development Plan Scrutiny Sub Committee. The purpose of the last report was to seek direction on the content and approach in preparing what was then referred to as a “Cambridge Skyline Strategy”. The purpose of guidance in the Officer’s report was to set out in more detail how Policy 3/13 could be applied in the event a tall building was proposed in the city. The guidance was for the benefit of developers, landowners, the community, plus the City Council in exercising its decision making powers on planning applications. The guidance does not create new policy as only the Cambridge Local Plan (2006), and future Local Plans, can set out formal planning policy. Instead the guidance would help interpret and assist in the application of Policy 3/13 and other relevant policies that govern the consideration of proposals for buildings, which could impact on the city skyline. Decision of Executive Councillor for Planning and Sustainable Transport: Approved : (i) The Draft for the purposes of consultation (set out in Appendix A of the Officer’s report). (ii) The proposed draft Consultee List for the Draft (set out in Appendix B of the Officer’s report). Reason for the As set out in the Officer’s report. Any alternative options considered and rejected: Not applicable. Scrutiny Considerations: The committee received a report from the Head of Joint Urban Design regarding the draft . The committee made the following comments in response to the report: (i) Recognised that tall buildings are an emotive issue. (ii) Developers wanted to maximise the density of sites and queried if the guidance would encourage more tall buildings as a way to get more density from a site by building upwards as well as sideways. (iii) A precedent had been set for the Council to accept payments in lieu of open spaces. Councillors wished to see a greater provision of public realm on developments. In response to Member’s questions the Head of Joint Urban Design and Head of Planning Services confirmed the following: (i) Planning policy formed the basis for guidance in the . For example, tall buildings cannot negatively impact on the amenity/character of an area, particularly in historic/conservation areas. Policy is geared to preserve and enhance the historic Cambridge City Centre. It does not promote or discourage tall buildings, but sets out criteria to be met and judged against. (ii) A subordinate document cannot be used to rewrite the 2006 Cambridge Local Plan. Members’ comments concerning tall buildings were noted and would be borne in mind for the next iteration of the Local Plan. Criteria 5 on P62 of the Officer’s report set out criteria for public realm and mixed land use. (iii) The design message from the Draft National Planning Policy Framework remains unchanged ie high quality designs were still desired. There is no anticipated conflict with the draft Skyline guidance. Any challenges by developers would have to be tested through the appeals process. (iv) Paragraph 4.12 of the Officer’s report set out that 3 – 5 storeys were the expected core height for tall buildings. Something significantly taller (eg 7 storeys) would be scrutinised in greater detail by officers who may request amendments to the design. Applications would be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, sensitivity concerning an application would trigger greater scrutiny, even if the proposal was for a building with less than 7 storeys. (v) Noted Members’ comments that different areas had different sensitivities regarding building scale and massing. Paragraphs 3.1 and 3.2 of the Officer’s report set out criteria concerning scale and massing requiring tall buildings not to adversely impact on neighbours. The guidance tried to quantify the impact of building scale/mass on close plus distant skyline views to judge/challenge the buildings cumulative impact. (vi) Members were invited to contact the Head of Joint Urban Design with suggestions for buildings to be included in the list of local landmark maps. Suggestions would also be invited through the November to December consultation period, details were set out in Appendix B of the Officer’s report. The draft would be updated and amended to reflect comments, plus correct typographical errors on map images (set out in the Officer’s introduction to his report). The Head of Joint Urban Design noted the following suggestions for landmark buildings: · St George’s Tower. · Napp Pharmaceuticals Limited building. · Gt Saint Mary’s Tower (vii) The Head of Joint Urban Design undertook to bring back a report to DPSSC 17 January 2012 and Environment Scrutiny Committee 13 March 2012 post consultation on the draft Skyline guidance. The committee resolved unanimously to adopt the recommendations subject to amendments to draft Skyline guidance text to reflect comments by Member’s regarding typographical errors and additional proposals for landmark buildings to be included. The Executive Councillor approved the recommendation. Conflicts of interest declared by the Executive Councillor (and any dispensations granted) Not applicable .