Resolved
The City Council has consulted the public and key stakeholders on the recently prepared guidance in respect of tall buildings and their impact on the City skyline. In recent years, the Council has received a number of planning applications for buildings taller than their surroundings. Such applications have been subject to considerable debate before being determined. To help improve the review and decision making process, the Council has prepared draft ‘Cambridge Skyline Guidance’. The document, when approved, would represent informal City Council guidance and would be a material consideration in the review of planning applications submitted to the Council. The Officer’s report set out the representations received during the six-week period of public consultation from Monday 31st October to Monday 12th December 2011. Decision of Executive Councillor for Planning and Sustainable Transport : Agreed the proposed responses to the key issues set out in Table 3.1 of the Officer’s report and resultant amendments to the Skyline Guidance prior to adoption at Environment Scrutiny Committee in March 2012. Reason for the As set out in the Officer’s report. Any Alternative Options Considered and Rejected: Not applicable. Scrutiny Considerations: The committee received a report from the Head of Joint Urban Design Team regarding Cambridge Skyline Guidance. This summarised key issues from the consultation. The Officer also verbally reported representations were received from the following: · Client name: Cambridge South Consortium. Report prepared by Helen Thompson (Bidwells). · Client name: Commercial Estates Group. Report prepared by Helen Thompson (Bidwells). The committee were invited to comment on the Officer’s report. In response to Member’s questions the Head of Joint Urban Design Team and Head of Planning Services confirmed the following: Key Issue 1 (i) Height triggers were a minimum benchmark for greater officer scrutiny. Building heights above or below these benchmarks could be triggers. (ii) Officers, Councillors in their capacity as Ward or Committee Members, and pre-application discussions could activate the triggers. A s indeed could members of the public. Key Issue 2 (iii) Local Plan Policy 3/4 (responding to context) was the principal guidance for tall building locations. The Skyline Guidance provided supporting guidance. (iv) The Skyline Guidance criteria provided a supporting framework to further satisfy the Council that applications were appropriate, as triggers would require developers/applicants to provide further information through the planning application process. (v) Acknowledged Councillors welcomed new tall buildings that responded to context and improved the character of the area. Key Issue 4 (vi) ‘Cones of view’ had been discounted as a term in the report. ‘Cones of view’ suggested a set viewpoint, whereas the landscape in and around Cambridge had multiple viewpoints. Key Issue 6 (vii) Local Plan Policy 3/12 was the principle guidance for the design of new buildings, but the Skyline Guidance provided supporting guidance. (viii) The Skyline Guidance feeds into the Local Plan Review to help develop future policy. As new policies emerge, officers would take them on board during the pre-application determination process. The committee resolved unanimously to adopt the recommendation. The Executive Councillor approved the recommendation. Conflicts of interest declared by the Executive Councillor (and any dispensations granted) Not applicable .