Resolved (by 6 votes to 2) to reject the officer recommendation to approve the application. Resolved (by 6 votes to 2) to refuse the application contrary to the officer recommendation for the following reason: Notwithstanding the material considerations of the case, the proposed student accommodation would result in the loss of two existing dwellings. This would conflict with Local Plan (2006) policy 7/7 which seeks to support windfall student hostel development subject to it not resulting in the loss of family residential accommodation. The proposal would also conflict with policy 5/4 which does not permit the loss of existing dwellings to other uses unless it can be demonstrated it complies with the criteria in this policy. The proposal would not comply with any part of the criteria as set out in policy 5/4. Therefore, the principle of the proposed development is unacceptable and the loss of the existing housing would be contrary to policies 5/4 and 7/7 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2006).
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
Application 16/1529/FUL Agenda Number Item Date Received 18th August 2016 Officer Sav Patel Target Date 13th October 2016 Ward Newnham Site 115-117 Grantchester Meadows Cambridge CB3 9JN Proposal Works and change of use to 115 & 117 Grantchester Meadows including partial demolition of outbuildings, refurbishment, internal and external works and extensions to create 22 rooms and 1 apartment for post-graduate student House of Multiple Occupation. Applicant St Catharine's College
SUMMARY The development accords with the Development Plan for the following reasons:
- The proposed loss of two family dwellings is acceptable in this instance due to the lack of suitable alternative provision and in view of the college’s fall-back position which would result in the potential loss of a total five family dwellings;
- The proposed student housing site is located within an suitable location in terms of its proximity to the college building in the City Centre, will have on site supervision, be close to other student housing site and playing field owned by the college.
- The proposed extensions to the properties are now acceptable following alterations to the west wing and would not have a detrimental impact on the character and appearance of the Conservation Area. - The proposed student housing development is set away from existing dwellings and would not have an adverse impact on residential amenity.
RECOMMENDATION APPROVAL
1.0SITE DESCRIPTION/AREA CONTEXT
1.1The application site is located on the west corner of Grantchester Meadows and South Green Road. The site consists of a pair of Victorian semi-detached dwellings (no.115 and no.117) which are set back from the unadopted track and opposite Skaters Meadow (south). There is a row of tennis courts to the west and a playing field to the north of the site which are part of St Catherine’s College [Herein referred to as the ‘College’]. Both dwellings are in the College’s ownership.
1.2115 Grantchester Meadows is the dwelling closest to South Green Road and is a three storey with a double height baywindow and pitched roof dormer in the front roofslope. There is also a single storey pitched roof outbuilding which abuts the eastern boundary. No.117 Grantchester Meadows is two storey, double fronted and has double height baywindows. Both properties have been extended and altered. Both dwellings have generous rear gardens and currently only 115 Grantchester Meadows is occupied as a dwelling. No.117 is currently vacant.
1.3The site is located within the Newnham Croft Conservation Area and there is a Walnut tree in the eastern corner of the site which has a Tree Preservation Order. The site is also surrounded; to the south, west and north, by Green Belt. Skaters Meadow is designated as a Site of Local Nature Conservation Importance.
2.0THE PROPOSAL
2.1The proposal is for a change of use of the existing dwellings to student accommodation consisting of 22 rooms and 1 apartment for St Catherine’s College. The apartment will be occupied by either a junior fellow or a graduate couple and they will act as site warden. The proposal is to combine the dwellings to create one student accommodation site. The proposal also includes extending the dwellings and other external and internal alterations.
115 Grantchester Meadows
2.2The proposal is to retain the front part of the existing outbuilding and extend it with a new element which includes a first floor. The proposed section of the outbuilding would be 11.5 metres in depth and 6.8 metres wide (5.5 metres at first) and 6.2 metres in height. The proposal would include the demolition of the existing two storey rear extension.
2.3The proposal includes permeable paving to provide a driveway for two cars and York stone paving around the driveway to the main entrance. The front boundary wall between the dwellings is to be retained as is an area of lawn between the boundary and driveway.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.