Resolved unanimously to accept the officer recommendation to note that: i. The LGO has upheld a complaint relating to the determination of a planning application. ii. In these circumstances the Head of Legal Services as the Council’s Monitoring Officer has an obligation to report the findings to Council and that Committee is satisfied with the action that has been taken (set out in Section 4 of the Officer’s report).
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
2.1To note that the LGO has upheld a complaint relating to the determination of a planning application.
2.2To note that in these circumstances the Head of Legal Services as the Council’s Monitoring Officer has an obligation to report the findings to Council and that Committee is satisfied with the action that has been taken (set out in Section 4 of the report).
Report Page No: 1 Agenda Page No: 3. THE COMPLAINT AND THE LGO INVESTIGATION
3.1The complainants complained about the way in which the Council’s Planning Committee considered whether or not to revoke their neighbours’ planning application and that the extension would have a detrimental effect on their residential amenity in the form of loss of daylight and sunlight to their kitchen diner. The LGO investigated these issues under the following headings:
o The Independent Complaints Investigator’s report
o The Planning Committee’s consideration of the proposed revocation
o The Council’s comments
o Was there fault and, if so, was there injustice requiring a remedy?
I have used these headings to set out details of the complaint and the LGO decision below.
The Independent Complaints Investigator’s (ICI) report
3.2The LGO noted that the ICI had identified a number of errors in the delegated report by the Case Officer which was signed off by a Principal Planner. There were errors in relation to the relationship between the two properties, measurements and the decision not to require a daylight/sunlight analysis was founded on an inaccurate assumption that all 3 kitchen windows were already compromised in terms of daylight. The ICI noted that the rearmost window was not already shadowed and this window compensated for the reduced light to the other two windows. In the absence of a daylight/sunlight analysis officers did not properly assess the impact of loss of light and the decision was unsound.
3.3The LGO also acknowledged that the ICI found that when the neighbour’s complaint was dealt with under stage 2 of the Council’s complaints policy officers made the wrong judgment in terms of whether or on a kitchen should be regarded as a habitable room. At this stage officers also commented that an extension constructed under ‘permitted development rights’ would have had a similar impact on the neighbours but there were no calculations to back this up. The ICI concluded that the stage 2 response was fundamentally
Report Page No: 2 Agenda Page No: flawed and that on the balance of probabilities the decision to approve the application was unsound.
3.4The LGO also refers to the ICI’s view that the neighbours had set aside a significant amount of time in arguing that the planning decision was unsound; their relationship with their neighbour had broken down; and they felt their quality of life had suffered, and they were seriously thinking of moving home.
The Planning Committee’s consideration of the proposed revocation
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.