CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cambridge City Council
Planning, Wednesday 17 June 2020 at 10.00am

18/1678/FUL - Station Area Development

Refused Planning 5 papers

Planning refused this item on Wednesday 17 June 2020. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item20/52/Plan

Resolved

Resolved (by 5 votes to 3) to reject the Officer recommendation to approve the application. Adjourned 16:25-16:44 for officer discussion to quantify minded to refuse reasons. i. The proposed development would fail to prioritise the movement and safety of pedestrians and cyclists within the CBI area introducing conflict at Station Square and Station Road and further conflict along the car park access road connecting to Devonshire Road. In addition, the footprint of B2 would reduce the flexibility of development coming forward within this quarter of CBI to adequately respond and provide for high quality cycling (including the Chisholm Trail) and pedestrian routes that should have priority over vehicular traffic. The proposal is therefore contrary to policies 25, 56, 57, 59 and policy 80 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2018) and NPPF (Feb 2019) paragraphs 104 and 109. ii. By virtue of the scale, massing and footprint of building B2 in close proximity to Carter Bridge, the proposed building would appear visually cramped, overly prominent and detract from the character and appearance of the existing area. The proposal is therefore contrary to policies 55, 56 and 57 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2018) and NPPF (Feb 2019) paragraph 124. iii. The proposal would cumulatively exceed the anticipated hotel need for Cambridge contrary to policy 77 and is therefore unjustified. Voted on whether to: i. Accept Reason 1 - agreed by 5 votes to 3 . ii. Accept Reason 2 - agreed by 5 votes to 3 . iii. Accept Reason 3 - lost by 2 votes to 6 . The Delivery Manager recommended using the Adjourned Decision Making Protocol as the reasons councilors proposed went against Highways Authority advise. Resolved (by 4 votes to 4 and on the Chair’s casting vote) not to accept the officer recommendation of approval, as the committee were minded to refuse the application, a decision on whether to approve or refuse the application was subsequently deferred under the Adjourned Decision Protocol Under the Council’s agreed Adjourned Decisions Protocol this application will be brought back to a future meeting of the Committee to allow further discussion of reasons for refusal. The following matters may form the basis for detailed reasons for refusal: i. The proposed development would fail to prioritise the movement and safety of pedestrians and cyclists within the CBI area introducing conflict at Station Square and Station Road and further conflict along the car park access road connecting to Devonshire Road. In addition, the footprint of B2 would reduce the flexibility of development coming forward within this quarter of CBI to adequately respond and provide for high quality cycling (including the Chisholm Trail) and pedestrian routes that should have priority over vehicular traffic. The proposal is therefore contrary to policies 25, 56, 57, 59 and policy 80 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2018) and NPPF (Feb 2019) paragraphs 104 and 109. ii. By virtue of the scale, massing and footprint of building B2 in close proximity to Carter Bridge, the proposed building would appear visually cramped, overly prominent and detract from the character and appearance of the existing area. The proposal is therefore contrary to policies 55, 56 and 57 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2018) and NPPF (Feb 2019) paragraph 124.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting. Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cambridge's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning

PLANNING COMMITTEE 17th June 2020

Application 18/1678/FUL Agenda Number Item Date Received 23rd November 2018 Officer Toby Williams Target Date 22nd February 2019 Ward Petersfield Site Station Area Redevelopment Blocks B2 And F2 Devonshire Road Proposal The proposed erection of two new buildings comprising 5,351sqm (GEA) of Class B1(a)/ Class B1(b) floorspace including ancillary accommodation/ facilities with associated plant, 162 cycle parking spaces, and 8 off-gauge cycle spaces for Block F2 and an Aparthotel (Class C1) comprising 125suites, terrace, ancillary accommodation and facilities with multi-storey car park for Network Rail (total GEA 12,153sqm) comprising 206 car parking spaces and 34 cycle parking spaces for Block B2 with associated plant, hard and soft landscaping, new alignment of access from Station Road into Station Square and permanent access from Devonshire Road to the Cambridge Station Car Park, utilising the existing pedestrian and cycle access, restricted to emergency access to the railway only. Applicant c/o Agent

SUMMARY The proposal accords with the Development Plan for the following reasons:

-The principle of the proposed office, aparthotel and car park uses are acceptable.

-The scale, footprint and proximity of the F2 office building to its boundaries and its impact on residential amenity is acceptable.

-The scheme would deliver public realm improvements and the design of the buildings is high quality.

-The proposed new access into Station Square does not arise as a requirement of the development of buildings B2 and F2. The officer recommendation in respect of this aspect of the proposal is neutral. The proposal is recommended for approval with or without the proposed new access.

RECOMMENDATION APPROVAL

1.0SITE DESCRIPTION/AREA CONTEXT

1.1The site comprises an irregular shaped parcel of land, which is mainly the existing surface level station car park and its access road. This is located to the north of the main station and immediately north and west of the six storey IBIS hotel and Cycle Point building and includes a section of land which extends to connect to the bend in Devonshire Road where pedestrians and cyclists are currently able to cut through to the station underneath Carter Bridge. The application site also incorporates a separate area of land that lies in-between Station Road and Station Square on its SW corner in front of Café Nero and is the proposed location of the new access.

1.2The northern boundary of the site is defined by Devonshire Road and station car parking to the north of Carter Bridge. The eastern boundary of the site is defined by the railway line. The southern boundary of the main site is defined by the mini roundabout at the eastern end of Great Northern Road. The western boundary is defined by the gardens and properties of Ravensworth Gardens, a 2.5 storey red brick pitched terrace whose gardens face east towards the site and which are terminated by a close boarded fence onto the station car parking area. Immediately to the south of Ravensworth Gardens properties is an ‘L’ shaped 4 storey residential block known as F1 which fronts onto Great Northern Road. This block forms part of the CB1 development and includes apartments which have rooms which face onto a private rear courtyard space defined by a brick wall which abuts the station car parking area. 1.3 The site is 0.7 hectares (ha) in size. The main part of the site lies outside any defined conservation area, but immediately to the north is the Mill Road Conservation Area, the boundary of which is defined by Devonshire Road. To the south is the New Town and Glisson Road Conservation Area which extends to include the grade II listed Station and Station Square in front.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
18/1678/FUL: Appendix 1: Conditions /52/PlanAppendix 253 KB Download
PDF
18/1678/FUL: Appendix 2: Great North Road Appeal /52/PlanAppendix 123 KB Download
PDF
18/1678/FUL: Appendix 3: DC Panel Minutes /52/PlanMinutes 31 KB Download
PDF
18/1678/FUL: Appendix 4: Dev Control Forum /52/PlanAppendix 344 KB Download
PDF
18/1678/FUL: Station Area DevelopmentReport 714 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

8 of 9 attended
MS
Councillor Martin SmartChair, present
DB
Councillor Dave BaigentVice-Chair, present
KG
Councillor Kelley GreenCommittee Member, present
PL
Councillor Peter LordCommittee Member, present
CM
Councillor Carla McQueenCommittee Member, present
KP
Councillor Katie PorrerCommittee Member, present
KT
Councillor Katie ThornburrowCommittee Member, present
DT
Councillor Damien Tunnacliffe Lib Dem SpokesCommittee Member, present
PM
Phil McIntoshOfficer, expected

On this subject at Cambridge

Search all
  1. 18/1678/FUL - Station Area DevelopmentThis decision
  2. 24/01787/FUL CBC SubstationDecided
  3. 18/1678/FUL - Station Area DevelopmentRefused
  4. 15/1759/FUL - Murdoch House, 40-44 Station RoadApproved
  5. 15/2271/FUL - Jupiter House, 10 Station RoadDecided
  6. 15/0906/FUL - 32-38 Station RoadDecided

More from Cambridge Planning

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
4 Nov 2026 26/02186/FUL Coldham's Common, Pool Way, Whitehill RoadResolved (by 7 votes to 0) to grant the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommenda... Decided Open
24 Jun 2026 25/04187/FUL Hanover Court and Princess CourtResolved (by 4 votes to 3) to grant the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommenda... Agreed Open
24 Jun 2026 25/03323/FUL 73 Newmarket RoadResolved (4 votes to 4 – and on the Chair’s casting vote) to grant the application for planning permission in accorda... Agreed Open
24 Jun 2026 26/01081/FUL 9, 11, 15 and 17 Ashfield RoadResolved (by 6 votes to 0) to grant the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommenda... Decided Open
24 Jun 2026 26/01400/FUL 1, 2, 3, 4, 11, 12 The GreenResolved (by 5 votes to 0) to grant the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommenda... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies