Resolved (by 5 votes to 2) to reject the Officer recommendation to approve the application. Members proposed draft ‘minded to’ reasons for refusal which were re-worded by Officers into a format for the minutes. Members resolved (by 5 votes to 0 with 2 abstentions) to accept both reasons for ‘minded to’ refusal and the wording therein. Resolved (by 5 votes to 2) to refuse the application contrary to the Officer recommendation for the following reasons: i. The proposed development fails to provide high quality cycling infrastructure commensurate with Cambridge as the leading cycling city in the UK and fails to demonstrate it is compatible with the objectives of and safeguards the safety and prioritisation of pedestrians and cycling in the area including the Chisholm Trail. This is because the movement, safety and promotion of cycling as an active transport mode for all users both travelling through the site and for those accessing the Cambridge Railway Station / Cycle Point and utilising the strategic cycle network in the CB1 area, is not prioritised through the provision of a physically segregated and protected cycle route. The proposal is therefore contrary to policies 25, 56, 57, 59 and 80 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2018), the NPPF (Feb 2019) paragraphs 104 and 109 and Local Transport Note 1/20, Cycle Infrastructure Design ( DfT ). ii. By virtue of the scale, massing and footprint of building B2 in close proximity to Carter Bridge and in regard of views from Devonshire Road, the proposed building would appear visually cramped, overly prominent and detract from the character and appearance of the existing area and setting of the adjacent Mill Road Conservation Area. The proposal is therefore contrary to policies 55, 56, 57 and 61 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2018) and NPPF (Feb 2019) paragraphs 124 and 196 .
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
Application 18/1678/FUL Agenda Number Item Date Received 23rd November 2018 Officer Toby Williams Target Date 22nd February 2019 Ward Petersfield Site Station Area Redevelopment Blocks B2 And F2 Devonshire Road
Proposal The proposed erection of two new buildings comprising 5,351sqm (GEA) of Class B1(a)/ Class B1(b) floorspace including ancillary accommodation/ facilities with associated plant, 162 cycle parking spaces, and 8 off-gauge cycle spaces for Block F2 and an Aparthotel (Class C1) comprising 125 suites, terrace, ancillary accommodation and facilities with multi-storey car park for Network Rail (total GEA 12,153sqm) comprising 206 car parking spaces and 34 cycle parking spaces for Block B2 with associated plant, hard and soft landscaping, and permanent access from Devonshire Road to the Cambridge Station Car Park, utilising the existing pedestrian and cycle access, restricted to emergency access to the railway only
Applicant c/o Agent
Addendum Report
0.0This application was reported to the 17 June 2020 Planning Committee with an officer recommendation of approval.
0.1During the consideration of the application, Members of the Planning Committee raised numerous concerns with the proposal and voted not to accept the officer recommendation. A decision on whether to approve or refuse the application was subsequently deferred following the implementation of the Adjourned Decision Protocol (ADP). 0.2 During the debate, the Planning Committee agreed a motion that they were minded to refuse the application for two reasons. These were as follows:
0.31: The proposed development would fail to prioritise the movement and safety of pedestrians and cyclists within the CB1 area introducing conflict at Station Square and Station Road and further conflict along the car park access road connecting to Devonshire Road. In addition, the footprint of B2 would reduce the flexibility of development coming forward within this quarter of CB1 to adequately respond and provide for high quality cycling (including the Chisholm Trail) and pedestrian routes that should have priority over vehicular traffic. The proposal is therefore contrary to policies 25, 56, 57, 59 and policy 80 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2018) and NPPF (Feb 2019) paragraphs 104 and 109.
0.42: By virtue of the scale, massing and footprint of building B2 in close proximity to Carter Bridge, the proposed building would appear visually cramped, overly prominent and detract from the character and appearance of the existing area. The proposal is therefore contrary to policies 55, 56 and 57 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2018) and NPPF (Feb 2019) paragraph 124.
0.5The Committee agreed, through the ADP process, that a further officer report should be brought back to the Planning Committee in relation to the minded to refusal reasons to inform its decision.
0.6This report summarises officer advice regarding the merits of the minded to refusal reasons. It is given following further discussions with the applicants who, after the June Committee, sought to address the draft reasons for refusal through the submission of amendments and further supporting information. These amendments and further information have been subject to additional consultation with third parties and consultees over the summer period and comprise:
a) A revised site location plan and description of development removing the proposed access from Station Road to Station Square. Members will recall that the Planning Committee expressed a clear preference to support option B (removal of the new access from Station Road) as set out in the initial officer recommendation.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.