Resolved (unanimously 7 votes to 0) to refuse the application contrary to the Officer recommendation for the following reasons: 1. The site is located within the Station Areas West and Clifton Road Area of Major Change which seeks to support the continued and complete regeneration of mixed-use areas of the city. Site M44 is allocated for mixed use development including residential use. The proposed development fails to provide residential dwellings and therefore, does not provide an appropriate mix of uses within this Area of Major Change contrary to policy 21 of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018. 2. The proposed development by virtue of its siting, massing, height, scale and design would appear as an incongruous addition to the streetscene and cause an undue sense of enclosure significantly reducing the openness of the Botanic Garden, to the detriment of the character of the area. Furthermore, it fails to preserve or enhance the character and appearance of the New Town and Glisson Road Conservation Area or preserve the setting of the Botanic Garden. The harm caused by the proposed development amounts to less than substantial harm however, the public benefits do not outweigh this harm. The proposed development is therefore contrary to the National Planning Policy Framework and policies 55, 56, 57, 61 and 67 of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018. 3. Insufficient information has been provided to demonstrate that the proposed development would not adversely affect the viability of the Flying Pig public house contrary to the National Planning Policy Framework and parts (d) and (e) of policy 76 of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
Application 20/03429/FUL Agenda 1M Number Item Date Received 10th August 2020 Officer Phil Mcintosh Target Date 9th November 2020 Ward Trumpington Site 104 - 112 Hills Road Cambridge Cambridgeshire Proposal 1) The demolition of Betjeman House, Broadcasting House, Ortona House, Francis House, and the rear multi-storey carpark to Francis House, together with existing refuse and cycle stores; to allow for construction of two new commercial buildings of five and seven storeys respectively, providing flexible B1(a), B1(b), A1, A2, A3 uses on the ground floor and Class B1(a) and B1(b) on the upper floors. 2) The construction of basement with mezzanine level to provide for building services, cycle parking and car parking for the proposed commercial buildings, cycle and car parking spaces for Botanic House and services for Flying Pig Public House. 3) The refurbishment of the Flying Pig Public House at 106 Hills Road, including demolition of part single/part two storey outrigger and single storey store, alterations to elevations, construction of extension to enable level access and layout pub garden. 4) Creation of new public realm and landscaping, incorporating segregated vehicular and cycle access from Hills Road, a new access to service areas and substations, and taxi drop off for both the development proposed and existing Botanic House. Applicant C/o Agent
SUMMARY The development accords with the Development Plan for the following reasons: - The proposed development provides additional employment floorspace in a location where there is strong demand and which results in a significant benefit to jobs in Cambridgeshire - The design and scale of the proposed development responds positively to the surrounding built form and removes existing buildings which detract from the Conservation Area - The proposed development will not adversely impact upon the character and quality of the Cambridge skyline - The proposed development retains the Flying Pig public house as its own entity and will not adversely affect its viability - The proposed development would not have a significant adverse impact on the setting of the Botanic Gardens - The proposed development is acceptable in highways terms in the context of mitigations secured - The proposed development would provide BREEAM Outstanding rated office buildings which exceed Development Plan requirements - The proposed development will deliver an increase in biodiversity net gain (570%)
RECOMMENDATION GRANT PLANNING PERMISSION subject to planning conditions and completion of a Section 106 Agreement
2.0SITE DESCRIPTION/AREA CONTEXT
2.1The application site currently consists of 5 buildings; Betjeman House, Francis House, Ortona House, the Flying Pig public house and a multi-storey car park. There is also some car parking at ground level at the northern end of the site. Betjeman House is a 3 storey buff brick building which is set back from the road frontage bordering the western boundary. In contrast, the Flying Pig public house, Orotona House and Francis House all front Hills Road with minimal setback from the street. Francis House is a 3 storey ‘U’ shaped red brick office building with grey profiled metal mansard roof. The multi-storey car park sits to the rear of Francis House and is constructed of similar materials. Adjoining Francis House to the north is Ortona House which is 4 storeys. The first and second floor consist of a yellow brick mix whilst the upper and lower ground floor are clad in stone. There is also a lead porch roof along the ground floor. The Flying Pig is a modest 2 storey Victorian pub built in circa 1840 with slate roof, blue rendered frontage and walled beer garden to the rear.
1.2There are 3 vehicle access points into the application site, one along the southern boundary serving the multi-storey car park, one for the Flying Pig and one to the ground level car park which is shared by Botanic House and Betjeman House.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.