Resolved
Resolved (by 4 votes to 3) to reject the Officer recommendation to approve the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommendation. The Committee Adjourned 11:40am to 12 noon so Officers could draft ‘minded to refuse’ reasons for Committee to discuss and vote upon. The Delivery Manager outlined five minded to refuse reasons: 1. The proposed development would fail to provide an adaptable and high quality building for future occupants by virtue of the poor and constrained storey heights and the reliance on the basement area that would not have sufficient natural daylight, contrary to Policy 57 of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018 [and NPPF 2023]. Reason 1 was lost by 2 votes to 3 with 2 abstentions. 2. By virtue of the inappropriate location of the proposed cycle parking facilities within the basement, the proposal would fail to provide accessible cycle parking for all users, contrary to policies 57(d), 80 and 82(a,c) of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018. Reason 2 was lost by 3 votes to 3 with 1 abstention – and on the Chair’s casting vote) . 3. By reason of insufficient information provided with the application relevant to emergency access and egress, the proposal would fail to demonstrate safe access/egress for all users in the event of fire, contrary to Policy 57(b) of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018. Reason 3 was lost by 0 votes to 3 with 4 abstentions. 4. By virtue of the loss of garden space associated with the public house, the proposed development would detrimentally affect the future viability of the public house, contrary to Policy 76 of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018 [and NPPF 2023]. Reason 4 was lost by 1 vote to 5 with 1 abstention. 5. The proposed development would result in less than substantial harm upon the character and appearance of the conservation area, contrary to Policy 61 of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018 and Paragraph 208 of the NPPF 2023. The public benefits arising from the scheme in this instance are not considered to outweigh the harm resulting from the development on the Conservation Area. Reason 5 was lost by 1 vote to 5 with 1 abstention. The Committee: Resolved ( 3 votes to 1 with 3 abstentions ) to grant the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommendation, for the reasons set out in the Officer’s report, and subject to the conditions recommended by the Officer (with delegated authority to Officers to make minor amendments to the conditions as drafted).