Resolved
Agreed there was a need for affordable and sustainable homes, but on suitable sites which this was not. Councillor Collis ( King's Hedge s Ward Councillor) addressed the Committee about the application: i. Quoted from David Attenborough speech: How do we fit into the natural world? ii. This was an important consideration when looking at the impact of the application on the local area eg biodiversity and loss of open space. iii. Cambridge Colleges were rich and had alternative sites they could turn to, biodiversity did not have these alternatives. iv. Paradise Nature Reserve was a special area and could not be replaced if lost. It was an important habitat for bats, particularly red listed (rare) ones. v. The Ecology Officer based comments on information supplied by the Applicant. If there was any doubt about details, they should be reviewed. vi. Proposed accommodation blocks were too near the Paradise Nature Reserve. vii. Referred to City Council policies to protect the natural world. These should be followed. Requested the application be refused. Councillor Nethsingha (Newnham Ward Councillor) addressed the Committee about the application: i. Expressed concern about: a. Impact of application of nearby school and children’s’ health. b. Construction. c. Relationship between Paradise Nature Reserve and development site. Specifically impact on biodiversity. It was not possible to over emphasise the benefit of Paradise Nature Reserve to the area, and the Applicant appeared to downplay this. d. Light pollution from site. ii. There was cross-party objections to the application from different political groups. iii. This was the wrong application for the site. Costs outweighed benefits. The Committee Manager read out the following points on behalf of Councillor Gilderdale ( Market Ward Councillor): i. Owlstone Croft was part of the green river corridor which stretched from the city centre to Grantchester Meadows. It adjoined Newnham Croft Primary School playing field, a protected open space, and Paradise Nature Reserve, a city and county wildlife site and local nature reserve (LNR). ii. The committee report gave little weight to this wider site context. iii. The Conservation Officer’s assessment focussed on the existing built form and street pattern and impact on the original Owlstone Croft buildings. The assessment paid no regard to the garden’s place in the river corridor, and its significance in the urban/rural interface which was recognised as a key characteristic in the conservation area appraisal. iv. The only mention of the LNR was the reference to the ‘good landscape linkages back to the Paradise Nature Reserve’. This sees the LNR only as a visual backdrop to the proposed development, diminishing its significance. v. The Planning Officer’s opinion that large blocks a few metres away would enhance the view from the LNR boundary was not shared by the hundreds of people who had objected. The proximity of the buildings to this boundary was one of the most opposed elements of the proposal. vi. Cambridge Past Present and Future sum up the harm that would be caused, stating: ‘The development of 3 storey high buildings in close proximity to the local nature reserve would had an adverse impact on the character and amenity of the reserve.’ vii. It would affect the experience of people visiting the Reserve, especially when using the boardwalk next to the boundary. This was installed by the City Council and provides one of the few places it was possible for people with disabilities to access and enjoy unspoilt green space. The adverse impact of this development would be greatest for people with disabilities as they cannot use the alternative path by the river. viii. They would also be at particular risk on the access track to Owlstone Croft, which was not a highway as claimed by the applicant and has no segregated footpath. Construction traffic using this narrow lane over a likely 2 year period raises serious concerns about the safety of the many pedestrians visiting the LNR. In the event of fire this lane would be the evacuation route for people and access route for fire engines. ix. The committee report noted in points 243 and 244 that, ‘Following discussion with Cambridgeshire Fire and Rescue Department, the presence of parked cars on the double yellows along Owlstone Road was currently presenting difficulties for the turning of fire vehicles into the application site’. x. The applicant asserts that, ‘the City Council had a responsibility to ensure Short Lane was adequate for fire tender access’. However, ownership of this lane was unknown, parking controls cannot be enforced and the Council’s legal liability was unclear. xi. These issues of legal responsibilities and liability were complex and could not be left to conditions. They needed to be decided before planning permission was granted as it may not be possible to resolve them afterwards. Councillor Baigent proposed an amendment to the Officer’s recommendation that fire safety provision should be adequate i.e. ensure fire engines could use the access road and access the buildings. This amendment was carried by 6 votes to 0 . Councillor Gawthrope Wood proposed an amendment to the Officer’s recommendation regarding electric vehicles accessing the site during construction. This amendment was carried by 6 votes to 0 . Councillor Porrer proposed an amendment to the Officer’s recommendation that the Applicant should have a single point of contact for residents and nearby school regarding general/construction management. This amendment was carried by 6 votes to 0 . The Committee: Resolved (by 5 votes to 1) to reject the Officer recommendation to approve the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommendation, for the reasons set out in the Officer’s report, (as amended in debate). Resolved (by 6 votes to 0) to refuse the application contrary to the Officer recommendation (as amended in debate) for the following reasons: i. By virtue of the proposed development’s excessive height, scale, massing and lack of subservience, and siting in close proximity to the Paradise Local Nature Reserve, it would result in a cramped and imposing form of development and loss of openness experienced by users from the local nature reserve. As such, the proposal would be out of context with its immediate surroundings. The proposal would result in harm upon the recreational and amenity value of Paradise Local Nature Reserve, which is a protected open space within the local plan set within the wider River Cam corridor. Consequently, the proposal would be contrary to policies 8, 55, 56, 57, 59 and 67 of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018 and paragraph 174 of the NPPF 2021. ii. Incomplete bat survey information has been provided to demonstrate that protected species would not be unduly harmed, contrary to Policies 69 and 70 of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018 and paragraph 180 of the NPPF 2021. iii. By virtue of the layout of the site for future students, the associated seasonal on-site wetland habitat would be adversely affected and the ecological relationship with the local nature reserve would be diminished. Furthermore, there is insufficient evidence to demonstrate that the scheme would not result in harm upon the biodiversity within Paradise Local Nature Reserve, contrary to policies 55, 56, 59, 69 and 70 of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018.