Resolved (by 7 votes to 0) to reject the Officer recommendation to approve the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommendation, for the reasons set out in the Officer’s report (as amended in debate) . Resolved (by 7 votes to 0) to refuse the application contrary to the Officer recommendation (as amended in debate) for the following reasons: i. By virtue of the scale and massing of the proposal, the confined nature of the site and the building’s close proximity to Portugal Place properties which have small and confined rear amenity spaces and windows in close proximity to the boundary of the site, the proposal would result in additional significant harm as a result of enclosure to the outlook from the rear of Portugal Place properties. The proposal would therefore not have a positive impact on its neighbours and is therefore contrary to Cambridge Local Plan 2018 policies 55 and 57 and the NPPF 2021 para. 130. ii. The proposed design of the building would fail to assimilate itself successfully into its surroundings and therefore fail to respond successfully to its historical context. As such it would harm the character and appearance of the Conservation Area and be contrary to policy 61 of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018 and the NPPF paras. 200 and 202 amounting to less than substantial harm. The public benefits would not outweigh the harm that would arise to the Conservation Area. iii. The proposal has failed to demonstrate that the scheme could be delivered without harm and or the loss of trees on or adjacent to the site. The potential harm and loss trees of high amenity value would result in wider harm to the setting of the Conservation Area that is not outweighed by the public benefits arising from the scheme. Thereby the proposal is contrary to policies 55, 56, 61 and 71 of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018 and para 131 of the NPPF 2021 which seeks for existing trees to be retained wherever possible.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
Planning Committee Date 11 January 2023 Report to Cambridge City Council Planning Committee Lead Officer Joint Director of Planning and Economic Development Reference 20/04261/FUL Site Jewish Synagogue 3 Thompsons Lane Cambridge CB5 8AQ Ward / Parish Market Proposal Demolition of existing Synagogue and Jewish Community facility and erection of a new Synagogue and Jewish Community facility including replacement parking spaces and new cycle storage and associated works.
Applicant Trustees of the Cambridge University Students' Union Presenting Officer Mary Collins Reason Reported to Third party representations Committee Member Site Visit Date To be confirmed
Key Issues 1. Context of site, design and external spaces (and impact on heritage assets) 2. Residential amenity
Recommendation APPROVE subject to conditions 1.0 Executive Summary
1.1The application seeks planning permission for the demolition of the existing Synagogue and Jewish Community facility and erection of a new Synagogue and Jewish Community facility including replacement parking spaces and new cycle storage and associated works.
1.2The principle of a replacement Synagogue and community facility is acceptable. However, the site is highly constrained, adjacent residential gardens are small and on a lower level and therefore any additional impacts arising from the proposal on the occupiers of these properties will be magnified. These impacts will require very careful consideration, particularly for the occupants of Portugal Place properties.
1.3Officers recommend that the Planning Committee APPROVE the proposal.
2.0Site Description and Context
None-relevant Tree Preservation Order
Conservation Area x Local Nature Reserve
Listed Building – setting of x Flood Zone 1 x
Building of Local Interest – x Green Belt setting of
Historic Park and Garden Protected Open Space Scheduled Ancient Monument Controlled Parking Zone Local Neighbourhood and Article 4 Direction District Centre
2.1The application site is situated on the eastern side of Thompsons Lane, in close proximity to Bridge Street which lies to the southwest.
2.2The site comprises the existing Cambridge Jewish Student Centre, which is set back from the Thompsons Lane frontage.
2.3Adjoining the application site is the Old Vicarage in Thompson’s Lane, which is Grade II and is sited to the southwest.
2.4St Clement’s Church, which is Grade II* listed and its churchyard adjoin the application site to the south.
2.5To the east is the terrace comprising nos. 23-29 Portugal Place, which are Grade II listed residential properties.
2.6The Cambridge School of Visual and Performing Arts (CSVPA) is adjacent to the application site and is situated to the northwest. The existing Synagogue building wraps around the southern and eastern sides of this building. The garden of 22 Portugal Place adjoins the site to the north.
2.7On the opposite side of Thompsons Lane, nos. 32-35 are identified as Buildings of Local Interest.
2.8The site falls within the Cambridge Historic Core Conservation Area.
2.9There is a tree preservation order on the site, however the protected tree appears to have been removed.
2.10The site falls within the controlled parking zone. The proposed development is located within the Air Quality Management Area.
3.0The Proposal
3.1Planning permission is sought for the demolition of the existing Synagogue and Jewish Community facility and erection of a new Synagogue and Jewish Community facility including replacement parking spaces and new cycle storage and associated works.
3.2The proposed replacement building would wrap around the rear of the CSVPA and would be on a similar footprint to the existing building but would be increased and extended forwards. To the northern elevation is a fire escape.
3.3A detached bike store for a vertically staggered bicycle rack for 18no. bike spaces is along the southern boundary. This would be sited directly behind The Old Vicarage. Sheffield hoops for 10 spaces are laid out on the front of the site.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.