Resolved
Agreed with the Officer there was harm to the area ie important views: a. Was most concerned about the impact on the view from Jesus Green. b. Took issue with the opinion the retractable roof would mitigate the impact of the design. c. The Trafalgar Hotel roof example referenced in the Officer’s report was not the same as the one in the application. iv. Significant public benefit was needed to outweigh the additional height to the building from this application. Suggested there was not enough benefit to justify approval. v. If the application was complementary to the skyline, it would be acceptable, it was not. vi. Planning balance considerations: a. The Varsity Hotel was a business. The application would help it. b. The application would do harm to the character of the Conservation Area. The Committee Manager read out the following points on behalf of Councillor Martinelli (Ward Councillor): i. Overall, would agree with the Officer's recommendation to approve the application. The economic benefits were important and likely to outweigh any visual harm, which would not be particularly more pronounced than the current situation with the unfinished building already a part of the skyline. ii. There had now been sufficient time for the Committee to consider this application so would be grateful if a decision could be made this week. The Committee: Resolved (by 4 votes to 3 with 1 abstention) to reject the Officer recommendation to approve the application. Resolved (by 5 votes to 3) to refuse the application contrary to the Officer recommendation for the following reasons: 1. Policy 60 of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018 requires that any proposals for a structure that breaks the existing skyline and/or is significantly taller than the surrounding built form must demonstrate that the proposal would result in a high-quality addition to the Cambridge skyline, that complements the character of the surrounding area. The proposed development is considered to result in a permanent incongruous addition to the Cambridge skyline that would fail to positively respond to the existing delicate and historic features through its height, scale, bulk, appearance and lighting. As such, the proposed development fails to contribute positively to its surroundings and the Cambridge skyline and is therefore contrary to the National Planning Policy Framework (2023) and Cambridge Local Plan (2018) policies 55, 56, 58, 60. 2. The National Planning Policy Framework and policies 61 and 62 of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018 aim to ensure that heritage assets of the City are conserved in a manner appropriate to their significance, including their setting. By virtue of the proposed height, scale, bulk, appearance and lighting, the proposal would result in less than substantial harm to character and appearance of the Central Conservation Area and the setting of listed buildings and would adversely impact the unique, historic landscape of the River Cam. Furthermore, it would also harm the setting of buildings of local interest, which make a positive contribution to the character of the Central Conservation Area. The harm to heritage assets is not outweighed by the public benefits. As such, the proposal fails to preserve or enhance the character and appearance of the Central Conservation Area and the setting of listed and buildings of local interest, contrary to the provisions of the Planning (LBCA) Act 1990, the National Planning Policy Framework (2023) and Cambridge Local Plan (2018) policies 7, 10, 61 and 62.